I liked it and already ordered volume 2.
It isnt perfect or anything and at worst I would say it is okay, not great or bad.
Some moments I liked would be the superman talking down a woman from suicide, him helping a boy with his abusive dad and Lois being upset for just being known as the woman who interviews superman.
It also has some strange moments that I would understand people disliking the story for, like when superman set fires to a bunch of drug dealers stashes or when he encountered the aliens and he focused on them being illegal immigrants.
The main part of the aliens story is that people should do good and help others if they have the power to do so, while the aliens tried to keep to themselves and distant with them even immediately saying no to helping a sick security guard that superman brought in before changing their minds. The initial focus on them being illegal immigrants was just strange.
I havent read the new krypton story as of yet but I do know that it sets up supermans depression as well as him feeling disconnected to humanity for this story and why he is acting off, which is something batman calls him out for after he held a man upside down in the air.
This was my first superman comic and my only other experiences with the character was with the justice league animated and unlimited shows as well as the james gunn movie.
As I said before, I ordered volume 2, but I also decided to pick up a more well liked story, so I bought superman for all seasons.