My opinions, which are often just me playing somewhat of a devil's advocate, are getting me slammed hard in the karma department these days. I find that a respectful and honest approach provided with reasonable arguments will no longer earn you upvotes. Reddiquette is dead. Say hello to what digg is all about people because we're here.
Ad hominid after ad hominid, and little to no reasonable arguments to backup what is increasingly becoming a portfolio of reddit talking points. The majority consists of the dogmatic left-wing point of view, and the minority consists of the redditors and those who have dogmatic right-wing views. Those who fall under the dogmatic views are becoming more and more narrow-minded.
Increasingly they downvote and provide no reasons for doing so. A person who keeps tossing ad hominid and other logical fallacy attacks at me in a discussion is now getting upvotes, because s/he holds the safe and sound reddit-sanctioned point of view.
I'll admit I hold a lot of "wrong" views, most of us do, but I'm afraid that reddit is becoming a place where it's no longer the norm for people to concede to, or respect, another poster. Instead, it's about being right, and negatively labeling, slandering, or insulting, anyone who expresses the slightest hint of a conflicting view. Forget about facts, these guys want sources for every fact you mention, and then neglect to acknowledge them when confronted.
Yes, it has been a bad day for me, but it was the last straw! I will embark onwards in this 4chan dogmatic troll infested website and bask in the sunshine that shines from what remains of reddiquette! Honestly, we all knew this was inevitable once the website became more mainstream.
Now the the suggestions for the reddit community:
Implement a logical fallacy (ad hominem abuser) meter. Ban those who reach a certain threshold.
Implement some sort of way to give demerits to those who downvote a comment that would be upvoted under rediquette rules.
Both ideas are relatively straight forward and I feel that both ideas can function constructively and appropriately on this website.