So I bought my Forester brand new in 2021, and was really excited about it… really wanted to love this car, and most people I know have had only positive experiences with Subaru. But I’ve had several points of failure, a couple serious ones, all under 60k miles. The biggest ones:
• Complete transmission failure at 40k miles requiring replacement of the transmission (it was covered under warranty, but was really disturbing to me that a brand new car required this at 40k miles?)
• Engine coolant valve failed at 54k miles completely bricking the car and leaving it inoperable in the middle of traffic.
Have other’s had these issues? Or did I just get a lemon?
- 2021 Forester Sport, 5 years old, currently at 60k miles, my experience:
Under 1,000 miles:
- Windshield cracked from what I assumed was a minor stone strike. Used my insurance glass benefit to replace it. But I’ve been reading that this appears to be a known weakness of the OEM glass on this generation?
Around 20,000 miles:
- Rear gate LED light failed, replaced under warranty
- Driver side rear passenger door edge guard detached - never replaced. The dealer has never had the part in stock, and I was told it's being discontinued
Around 40,000 miles:
- CVT transmission failure, jerking and stuttering when accelerating from a stop, plus the car abruptly shutting off while driving. Required complete transmission replacement (was under warranty - thank god)
- Note that it seemed the replacement transmission is a remanufactured same-design CVT? Not an updated or redesigned unit? Which doesn’t leave me feeling good about this…
Around 44,000 miles:
- Start/stop system causing the car to shut off completely while stopped at lights, required full battery system replacement including new housing. - Was told there was a hardware software compatibility issue and that I needed a new housing system to hold a larger battery. Told it wasn't covered under warranty and charged $352.49 out of pocket
- Driver side window failure, regulator and motor replaced ($107 extended warranty deductible)
Around 50,000 miles:
- Driver seat sport leather upholstery cracking and ripping. The seat cover replaced by Subaru as a courtesy after I contacted Subaru customer advocacy about the next incident
Around 54,000 miles:
- Engine coolant valve (TCV) failure — car became completely inoperable while driving in traffic, leaving me stranded in the middle of an intersection off a highway off-ramp. Had to get the car towed, etc. Most dangerous incident and what ultimately prompted me to contact Subaru Customer Advocacy. Subaru reimbursed me for the towing, etc
- Supposedly replaced with a redesigned / updated part
Overall… the warranty coverages have prevented financial catastrophe, and Subaru customer advocacy has been somewhat responsive. But I’m just shocked at everything that has gone wrong with a “new” car, after having drove a 2006 Hyundai for 16 years and never had any repairs, just routine maintenance.
I asked Subaru Customer Advocacy if they have any type of “goodwill or loyalty program” if I were to consider giving Subaru another chance, but they do not and said they could offer a coupon towards the purchase of a brand new car. And after my experience, I’m just not feeling confident in the reliability of Subaru - after all this I’m leaning towards looking for a 5th gen 4Runner.