r/streamentry • • Aug 04 '19

practice [practice] Good sleep, eating healthy, working out, and antidepressants are all far more effective at improving one's mental health than meditation

8 Upvotes

I was once like you. I bought into the all of the hype, I practiced for over an hour everyday and read every thing I could about meditation. I went on several retreats, and even sat 14 hours a day at an intense sesshin. I spent thousands with a well known teacher.

I now think that was all a waste of time. Meditation is fantastically overhyped bullshit that at best results in mild benefits. If you're trying to improve yourself, there are far more straight forward methods that actually work. Get outside, eat healthy, volunteer at an animal shelter. If you're depressed, take antidepressants. Go to therapy. Just don't waste your time with meditation thinking you're going to get somewhere.

I'm posting this for people who wonder why meditation isn't living up to the hype for them. It's not because there is anything wrong with you, it's because it doesn't work for anyone else either. It's all just hype and people one-upping each other with their peak experiences. Yes, interesting things can happen but they don't last and they don't make you a better person.


r/streamentry • • Dec 01 '25

Energy I’m aware of people’s subconscious in real time via microexpressions, projections, feeling but pretend as if I’m talking with them on their surface level. Isolating experience. Anyone else?

0 Upvotes

Always been hypersensitive, was heavily “autistic” growing up. Got into meditation in my teens. Got into psychedelics and empathogens a bit later as well. Stopped the drugs. Never stopped the meditation. All that ramped up my already high awareness and sensitivity into silly levels.

At this point I regularly intuit information which isn’t available in consensus reality. I probably process anywhere between 10x-100x more information in real time than the average person.

Interactions with people are weird. I have to pretend that we’re on the same wavelength when we’re barely inhabiting the same universe. I stick to the expected and accepted scripts in most conversations and meetings and just say nothing more often than not.

I’m routinely aware of what goes on in people’s minds, emotions, what their fears, judgements, fantasies, secret wishes, complexes are. I lost jobs because of this before. My superiors felt unexplainably uncomfortable around me simply because my vessel was mirroring their bullshit back to them. I would then get fired for wishy washy reasons even though I was fully aware of the real motivations.

I often see weird expressions on people’s faces when they’re talking to me. Mixes of confusion, fear, uncertainty, bewilderment. It’s like they keep trying to mentally put me into a familiar model of what a human being is and they consistently fail because I have no idea what a human being is or what I am.

Some people open up to me with deep stuff. Because I feel them and listen to them I guess. Don’t know how not to pay attention to someone. Attention is all I am.

If I’m channeling energy into a specific chakra or focusing on something a lot, people tend to start talking to me about those topics. And I know in real time why it’s happening but it’s pointless to even try to mention it to someone.

I guess people think I’m engaged in their idea of a conversation. The verbal conceptual conversation is like 2% of what’s happening for me. I’m socializing with their unconscious material and projections the entire time while the words are just filler I say so that the person doesn’t trip out in the interaction.

I had a period where I thought that we’re all doing this pretendsies thing. Boy what a disappointment it was to learn that not everybody is cosplaying as a human being. I guess I take all our ideas about how reality works, what we are, what our culture and society is as mere suggestions that I’m free to fuck around with to my heart’s content. And the more you fuck around, the more you find out.

I can keep doing this indefinitely, consensus reality isn’t that difficult, conversations generally follow neat scripts and the universe has plenty of built in safety mechanisms which prevent me from going off the rails (trust me, I tried). But it’s such an isolating experience. I am yet to find people who are surfing reality on this level. I only had a brief encounter with one monk who was able to get me.

I’m posting this fully aware that most readers will pass judgement, saying that this is DPDR, prepsychotic state or some other shit. Yeah, no. But thanks for trying. Anybody here who gets it though?


r/streamentry • • Dec 17 '25

Practice Okay so apparently I'm a stream enterer, now what?

0 Upvotes

My understanding of this stuff is still pretty limited, and I haven't really formally meditated for any extended period, but I have skimmed through Mastering Core Teachings of Buddha which helped me understand my first spontaneous Arising and Passing Away experience which happened around 5-6 years ago. I temporarily lost the Self View fetter and it felt like I had taken off a heavy ass backpack that I didn't even know I was carrying, and I generally just felt really good for about a week or so. Then the Self View illusion slowly returned in the following weeks, but never to the level it was before the A&P.

Since then I had a pretty cool Non Duality Awareness experience 2-3 years later which pretty much entirely removed the rest of the Self View fetter/chain. Having one permanent self doesn't even make sense anymore, especially after checking out Internal Family Systems therapy, which has a part-approach to the human system.

So that chain is pretty much gone. And together with it the Doubt chain is also pretty much gone.

The third, Attachments to Traditions/Rituals has never really been a thing for me, I think I lost this one during childhood when I moved from a country with Slavic culture to a Western one, which made it really clear that all of the societal "truths" and norms I at one point though were reality are just made up bullshit.

So the first three chains/fetters are pretty much gone, but where do I go from here? I'm not interested in doing any retreats because I kinda feel like a lot of people at those are taking this shit entirely too seriously and make their whole identity revolve around meditation and "enlightenment".

I'm also not too keen on spending countless hours meditating because I have a pretty ADHD-like personality structure which makes focusing on something that isn't immediately rewarding really hard.

The fourth fetter, Craving Sense Objects/Sensual Desire is still pretty strong.

So is the Aversion of Sense Objects/Ill will one. This one is probably stronger than the fourth.

6th and 7th fetters are also there, but they don't seem to be doing much? They don't exactly affect my daily life, at least not that I notice.

Conceit is still pretty present, lol. Since being more aware of these things clearly makes one BETTER than people who are less aware, right?? RIGHT??

Restlessness fetter is also pretty strong and I'd say fairly dominant.

Last one, Ignorance is pretty hard to judge because I don't know what I don't know. I've probably had hundreds of insights between the "bigger" experiences, which has allowed me to peek "further" than my current level of awareness but the most accurate way for me to sum up my knowledge about the "true nature of reality" is "Fuck if I know, dude".

My current "practice" isn't really any form of structured practice, but rather done through spontaneous curiosity, contemplation and just "looking" at my inner world and trying to see why things are the way they are. I really don't know how to explain it, because it's pretty much been happening on it's own since my first A&P experience, and especially after the Non Duality Awareness one.

Looking at how the progression from Stream Enterer to Arhat is layed out, I'm assuming that I should be focusing on the 4th and 5th fetter going forward? If you guys have some advice on how one does that, that would be pretty cool!


r/streamentry • • Jun 18 '19

practice [practice][conduct] I’m enlightened. AMA

3 Upvotes

Hiya, folks. After seeing /u/siftingtothetruth’s AMA, I thought maybe I should do one. I think you’ll find this offers a nice contrast.

To give you some backstory on my own transition: I dabbled in various Buddhist teachings and meditation in my early twenties, and the idea that there's something inherently unsatisfactory about how life is usually experienced really resonated with me. The meditation part, however, did not. I did and still do find a lot of traditional meditation boring. So, suffice it to say, I never developed a consistent practice. But that sense of "seeking" stuck and led to a lot of self-reflection and personal work over the years mainly in the realm of Western psychology--I got a lot from the works of Albert Ellis and, later, Carl Rogers.

The real seminal development that directly led to my transition, though, was reading the Sam Harris book Waking Up. I came across it after one of Sam's talks about the book was suggested on YouTube while I watching Jill Bolte Taylor's "My Stroke of Insight" TED talk. She's the neurologist that had a stroke that led to an awakening type experience. I remembered seeing her talk when it first came out and was revisiting it because I was really feeling that unsatisfactoriness of normal living and her talk was a breadcrumb along my path of trying to "figure it all out".

Anyway, Waking Up really opened my eyes to the wider non-Buddhist world of awakening. As I said, my prior investigations into what I'd now call awakening (and previously would have probably called enlightenment), were very much centered in the world of Buddhism, so I really didn't know about things like Ramana Maharshi and direct inquiry or more recent things like The Headless Way. How my search could have been so siloed, I'm not sure, but Sam's book really opened my eyes.

More than that, though, I think the book made me realize awakening/enlightenment was a real thing that happened to real people in the modern world. As I'm sure.you know, it's pretty taboo in most Buddhist traditions to talk about your attainments, as they're called, so having previously only been exposed to the Buddhist world, I wasn't unsure if enlightenment was real. And, even if it was, it seemed to be the sort of thing that happened after decades of practice in a cave in Nepal (interesting to think that now, having read Jeffery's research re: locations 4 and beyond, that it might be the enlightenment/awakening that leads to living in a cave and not the other way around).

So, emboldened that something might be achievable on the "end of suffering" front, I started doing some direct inquiry practices. Examining the sense of self, playing with some perceptual stuff around that sense of being "riding in one's head, behind one's eyes", stuff like. I did that for about a day and it seemed like I got some insight but nothing mind blowing.

The next evening, though, at a Starbucks, I was reading a Kindle book about "direct pointing" (another thing mentioned in the Sam Harris book), and for some reason found myself trying to imagine myself in the most foreign environmental conceivable. I imagined being on Mars (admittedly, maybe not exactly the most foreign environment conceivable...) and I had the realization that that experience, while literally alien, would still be, well, an experience. It would still have that quality of experience-ness, whatever that is. Moreover, that quality had always been present and would always be present in any experience. I'm inseparable from the quality of experience-ness and, in some important way, I am that quality.

With that realization, the scales fell from my eyes, so to speak. I felt great joy and an even greater sense of homecoming. I felt completely at home in the universe and existence, a feeling I now remembered from early childhood. That sense of dissatisfaction, that nagging feeling the something must be missing, disappeared and has not, to this day, returned :-)


r/streamentry • • Nov 26 '25

Science Can we finally talk about the elephant in the room? There are no arahants in our monasteries

16 Upvotes

Over the last several months I have been shadow banned, censored and officially banned from multiple buddhist subreddits for my opinions and interpretations of the dhamma with comments like 'that’s not what the Buddha taught', 'that’s wrong view', 'you’re misinterpreting the suttas' etc. But let's be brutally honest for a second.

there are no arahants, or sakadagamis, or anagamis in our monasteries today. the monastic sangha, as an institution, has not produced a single publicly verifiable fully awakened being in at least 50 years.

according to the texts, the understanding of undiluted pure dhamma leads to arahantship and can be attained in this lifetime. so shouldn’t we see at least one or two unmistakable cases in present time? Why cannot anyone today accomplish what angulimala could?

The essence of the eightfold path has been lost. So maybe it is time to discard blind belief in commentaries from all the schools of buddhism and re-evaluate them, by first learning pali, and then going back to the original teaching of the buddha and reading them for ourselves.

But first we have to be open to unconventional ideas and interpretations. Thoughts?


r/streamentry • • Apr 08 '25

Practice Using AI to support advanced practice

0 Upvotes

As soon as ChatGPT came out I started experimenting with it in all aspects of my life, and I got quite surprised by how much it knew about spiritual practice.

One day we were chatting about the concept of luminosity of awareness in Tibetan Buddhism, and instead of theorizing about it I asked it: "wait, why don't you guide me to explore this experientially?". I sat in meditation, eyes closed, and kept interacting with ChatGPT using voice mode.

This experience made me even more fascinated by the potentials.

Sure, sometimes it gets things wrong, particularly with some of the more niche practices where it doesn't have much knowledge. Once it suggested I visualize the colors of the chakras, in the context of Rob Burbea's Soulmaking practice... 🙈

But when used in the right way, it can be incredibly accurate. For instance, I had an AI create three progressive guided meditations, this time providing exhaustive reference by attaching the PDF of "With Each And Every Breath" by Thanissaro Bhikkhu. The results are impressively accurate, progressive, and appropriate.

Being a tech guy, I've cobbled together a few existing tools to simplify these explorations. Not just to chat about theory, but to create experiences, such as guided meditations.

I've been experimenting with combining AI chatbots with these tools that synthesize them in audio format, and I'm blown away by the creative potential.

I'll give you an example of something very creative I've tried today. Various traditions, including Vajrayana deity practice, incorporate meditation with sacred images. Christopher Titmuss discussed this in his Substack, applying it to different artworks. Inspired by this, I found a contemporary enso painting and used AI to create guidance that encourages both sensory experience and inner resonance with the artwork.

Another fascinating example: do you ever happen to discover, in your practice, new techniques you've never heard before? The other day I used an AI to create a guided meditation to practice a particular way of tuning into the in-between awareness (no self, no non-self, not here, not there).

In all these examples AI is not so much the teacher or source of wisdom, but a tool, a source of inspiration, a co-creator. This is a more considerate and conscious way to relate to it.

If you are intrigued, I'd like to invite you to join the new subreddit I've just created, to collectively explore, discover, discuss and share. The good and the bad, the concerns (both technical and ethical) and the new potential.

I've also published these tools on a website I've created. I've called it AIM Lab (as in AI Meditation Lab). It's free, free from advertising, community-driven and open-source.

It's still a work in progress, but I've already published a tool that everyone can use to easily create and share guided meditations, starting from an AI generated script.

I've published this a few of days ago, and we already have some new meditations generated by the community, including a traditional Golden Light Compassion Meditation, a No self short meditation, and a more original self-inquiry meditation called The Detective Of You.

Come and explore if you like. Listen to others' meditations, create your own.
You are warmly welcomed.

LINKS
-----
The new subreddit about AI and meditation: https://www.reddit.com/r/AIMeditationLab/

Website for AIM Lab where you can generate your own meditations: https://aimlab.soundglade.com/

An article I wrote with some more creative examples: https://aimlab.soundglade.com/articles/creative-examples


r/streamentry • • Apr 20 '26

The Place for AI in Practice

1 Upvotes

TLDR practice advice:
Can use AI for exploring specific threads/methods and finding patterns, but rely on the triple gem (the Buddha, the dharma, and the sangha) for the wider perspective and course correcting. Developing sati for reification is invaluable when using AI. The human is the only thing in that dyad that can slow the conversation down and create the space for more skillful navigation.

I'll throw it out there. I think AI can be helpful for practice, but like with any domain, it's only when you have familiarity that you can identify when the AI is wrong or playing into confirmation bias. The danger here is that AI is acting as a narrowing accelerator. It removes doubt and encourages you to barrel down a hole with blinders on. As a beginner how can you know if it's pointing you the right way? As a beginner it's likely that you can't even articulate your goal in the context of the dharma. Heck even advanced practitioners seem to have endless debates on the endpoints as well.

There's a second tension I'd like to point out. I've noticed fewer questions and posts as of late and wonder if it's due to the tension between embarrassment and asking questions. AI has completely reduced the embarrassment factor by allowing you to ask any type of practice or spirituality question without random strangers telling you you're wrong in some way. The funny thing is people challenging and helping you understand stuff is THE feature and an incredibly valuable thing.

AI as a Narrowing Accelerator

Earlier I dropped this term and it's how I've started to think about how AI drives towards a conclusion in an efficient manner, even making stuff up and hallucinating things along the way. It will make up your "goal" if not clearly defined and give you advice and instruction on how to get there. The progress will feel easy and fast too. This isn't a raft, it's a freaking spaceship! What happens when you hit a road block or find yourself in a destination that isn't what you wanted?

The deeper the hole that this narrowing accelerator digs for you, the harder it is to reel things back and find a footing. Walking back all that "progress" is painful and often people may even double down on the route the AI suggests vs coming to terms and asking for help.

External Broadeners

This brings me to the counteracting force, the external broadener. An external broadener is something that has broad perspective of the dharma and can help course correct. AI cannot do this without threshold expertise. Other broadeners can be teachers, text, and the most impactful for myself, this sangha /r/streamentry. Each one of these can act like a brake and slow you down. They can point areas that are relevant to your personal goals and point out any personal assumptions that you may want to spend some more time investigating.

For most of my journey I never had a direct teacher and actually relied on this sub as my own external broadener. They say the best way to get advice isn't to ask a question, but to post a wrong answer. Right away I started replying to questions on this sub from the perspective of my own practice. I was very careful to not speak about anything I haven't validated myself, speaking about generalities, or clearly specifying that any personally experimental views were works-in-progress. I really can't express much gratitude I have for countless deep exchanges, comments, and even upvotes as indirect feedback.

The feedback from this community comboed with the massive amounts of free material out there ensured that I was always path finding towards the right clearings and not a cliff or dead-end. Even texts and recorded talks can be approached as a conversation and help you course correct. Bring questions and see if you can infer how the author would answer them.

The point of this story, is please ask questions to external broadeners! Also, ask yourself if the AI, texts, communities, and even teachers who you're interacting with act like an external broadeners. Very often those things can work as narrowing accelerators. Some signs to look out for is people claiming that their path is the only "correct" path. Do they encourage you you to understand other perspectives? Sometimes the detours are helpful to see the pitfalls and traps. Breadth in practice is under appreciated I think. Breadth helps make the integration part easier and to me is the primary goal of my own practice, flexibility through emptiness.

Be a Lamp

One of my favorite sayings from Burbea talks about this:

the only mistake we can make is to be stuck in one way of seeing things, one way of thinking about the self, or relating to the self...

Following from that statement he talks about breadth too:

Whatever that is, it doesn’t have that flexibility, that malleability, the fluidity, the range that is, I think, a result and an expression and embodiment of freedom: range, flexibility in thinking, in acting, in relating, in meditating.

My biggest tip is to keep an eye out for any texts, authors, communities, and teachers that can act like external broadeners. I've found this to be relatively rare and one of the reasons I found Burbea's teachings so appealing. He teaches you how to be your own external broadener. How to freely and critically question your own assumptions and how to create your own hypotheses. When you can be a light upon yourself, you can find the stream yourself and identify when other narrowing accelerators are hurling you towards an irrigation ditch or a sewer line.

As for the paradox of being your own "external" broadener, what happens is you can act like your own brakes and the brakes for AI. Sati helps identify when some brakes are needed. Another term for narrowing is reification and I think it will be one of the most important sensitivities to develop in this new future.

May infinite doors open for you! ✨🙏 🪷

Also, this is another call out for any experienced practitioners to post! The other under appreciated benefit of practice reports is it helps people understand what endpoints may look like and help other orient to similar or adjacent goals. It doesn't have to be your whole history, maybe a just an single arc, a method review, the traps or pitfalls you encountered, etc.

TLDR practice advice:
Can use AI for exploring specific threads/methods and finding patterns, but rely on the triple gem (the Buddha, the dharma, and the sangha) for the wider perspective and course correcting. Developing sati for reification is invaluable when using AI. The human is the only thing in that dyad that can slow the conversation down and create the space for more skillful navigation.


r/streamentry • • Aug 21 '19

community [Community] How to Find a Good Dhamma Teacher

1 Upvotes

Friends, in light of recent news regarding Culadasa, many are encountering the fetter of doubt. Remember: one man is not the dhamma, and there are many out there who know the dhamma.

Students looking for a teacher will be served by knowing what to look for in a dhamma teacher. Here are the main points:

The Dhamma Teacher's Behavior

There are dhamma teachers who are/were known to abuse alcohol.

There are dhamma teachers who charge money (taking what is not freely given).

There are dhamma teachers who are accused of sexual misconduct.

There are dhamma teachers who kick out dhamma teachers for that sexual misconduct rather than finding a way to rehabilitate the offender (kicking out of the club is a kind of killing).

There are dhamma teachers who have inadequate teacher training programs (and they know it). This is a deliberate lie.

In short, there are dhamma teachers in the west whose behaviour disqualifies them. They do not live the dhamma. This is a separate issue to the matter of what knowledge of the dhamma they may or may not have.

——

Who Put the Dhamma Teacher in the Position of Teacher?

Most dhamma teachers in the west were self-appointed or trained under one who appointed themselves. In short, the lineage is broken; there is no direct lineage back to the Buddha.

Many well-known Western dhamma teachers claim to have stayed in Asia to study under one or more famous asian monks, but unless that Asian teacher had the westerner teach dhamma while the senior monks listened, then administered further training before sending the new teacher out to teach, this westerner has no lineage. A claim that this or that asian monk was "my teacher" is no qualification. It is a kind of lie: making claim of a lineage that does not exist.

——

Dhamma Knowledge

It is well known in the sangha that a teacher must have a certain status. One point is 10 years as a monk. After 10 years, a monk can become an Achan and have students of his own, but there is a deeper point: dhamma knowledge. Normally a new teacher has some level of attainment: fruit of the path of sotapanna is normally required.

Bhikkhu Buddhadasa said the requirement is that the new teacher must know paticca samuppada in detail and understand how the mind works. This would mean that the new teacher would have the path of sotapanna, but not yet the fruit. Few of the western teachers have even this level of dhamma knowledge.

An even more basic point that can be of use to a student looking for a worthwhile teacher is that if the teacher teaches any kind of magic then this teacher is not teaching dhamma, rather they are teaching superstition. The Buddhist Religion is full of it (superstition).

The teachings of the Buddha require clear comprehension of dukkha and the avoidance and elimination of it all. Deep understanding of the five aggregates and paticca samuppada shows that there is no self, nothing to be reborn, nothing magical at all about the way the mind functions its way into dukkha.

The dhamma student is 100% responsible for their own skill development. A good teacher can only point to the task to be done.

——

Money

The good dhamma teacher does nothing and so charges no fees. If one pays a fee then one expects something in return. A struggling student may ask a teacher, "why am I getting no results? I paid good money!”

“Well, its your kamma,” the greedy teacher may respond.

Please quit such teachers and seek a noble one who will not keep students in darkness about their own abilities.

Ordinary folks are not expected to uphold the precepts but the noble keeps them naturally due to purity of mind. Any teacher who charges money for dhamma– even on a private basis– is taking what is not freely given. The Buddha did not charge for the dhamma. For anyone else to do so disqualifies them as a teacher.

——

Noble Teachers

Noble teachers can be found. They are out there. One just has to use discernment.

Here on /r/streamentry, scrutiny of anyone posing as a teacher is commonplace.

The Dhammarato YouTube channel is full of delightful conversations with dhamma friends, and both Dhammarato and I are available to speak on Skype, for free.

——

I reiterate: the dhamma is not represented by one individual, especially not one who charges money for what the Buddha gave freely and who also gets themselves into all kinds of worldly trouble.

We share this post so that those who are experiencing doubt in the dhamma can find noble dhamma friends who will help them to come out of suffering.


r/streamentry • • Feb 03 '22

Insight Are Computer Science/Programming Concepts not utilised enough? They aided me to obtain arhat.

1 Upvotes

I feel like looking at the logic of most computer science concepts will give one a clear rational understanding of how awakening and meditation works if one can then apply them back to their own experience. I believe I am an arhat as after observing my experience enough times, I haven't seem to have suffered for a while now, mentally I feel as if there is no where else to go. I have tried my best to seek absolute truth and if I found evidence to refute this, I would immediately accept the alternative since that's the process of how I got here in the first place, to embrace the change. To me full awakening is the simplest possible way of representing to the mind that change is absolute in all circumstances and cannot be refuted. That's it. The simplicity of this surprised me. As soon as one intuitively understands that "simplest" possible way, they are free from suffering permanently. People can make this idea as complex or simple as they want it to be, but the only way to escape an infinitely recurring problem like suffering is to have an infinite solution that can be applied as many times as necessary without conditions, and the only way to obtain that infinite solution is for to be infinitively simple. If the solution to suffering was bound by limits or conditions like age, wisdom or personality then it could not be a solution as it could not be infinitely applied. I've have been meditating for about 5 years, from 16 to 21, started using the mind illuminated in 2018, and I felt I progressed the most from 2020 - 2021 and obtained arhat in Aug-Sept last year. The moment I started getting into programming and understanding the logic of it in the beginning of 2020, I felt like the my practice and level of insight just got better and better. The interludes outlined in the mind illuminated were also a great foundation for putting the computer science logic into perspective in relation to the mind. I think at max I only ever got to about stage 7 or 6, and I never really achieved any jhanas except maybe the whole body jhana. I felt meta awareness was sufficient for insight. I don't recall any cessations either, maybe I could never accurately identify them. I did not do any retreats, and I don't think I ever meditated beyond 1 hour in a single session, or did more than 1 session a day. Mainly because I couldn't conveniently do these things in my household/location. I never really ventured outside of mind illuminated in a significant way, I just occasionally read posts on this subreddit and Mind Illuminated as a reference point for my progress.

I stopped consistently meditating since Sept 2020 due to a lack of a need to, and only became an arhat after continuously reviewing the abstraction that kept coming up in the Computer Science Degree I was studying, and observing it in my own experience enough times. That's where I saw the potential for an infinite solution and an end to suffering from my own understanding. I know of concepts like non-returner and stream enterer, the fetters, the dukkha nanas but I never really stuck to them as guiding principles and just experimented on my own, since I felt the logic of Computer Science and the mind models to be sufficient enough for understanding where to go. I could fit my experience into those terms if I had to, but I did not feel the need to as they felt too rigid to a degree. I don't explicitly know when I became non-returner, or once returner, or when I cycled through the dukkha nanas, if I ever did. I only use the term arhat because I assume it means someone without suffering.

Being an arhat does not mean you lose any freedom or ability to experience emotions or mental states as due to abstraction, all mental states are "always" infinitely accessible and can be retrieved as long as the conditions are in place, from the worst ones to the best ones. An arhat is absolutely free to do whatever they want, good or bad even if that means becoming a psychopath or a saint. They can continue to enjoy tv shows, movies, games, get angry, get sad, contemplate what the point of it all is. After all, they cannot suffer, so there are no true consequences to the actions they can take anymore; They just cannot go about actions in a way which would cause them suffering. Since the mind has limits, we can always exploit these limits to get the mind to produce any known outcome. That's all we do in meditation, exploits the limits to produce joy and tranquillity, even in conditions society would deem it is not possible to feel those things. Exploit is rather negative word and implies we are bending the mind to our will, but it only looks that way from the perspective of self and is instead just the mind doing what it has always done, fabrication. My life through awakening would not really be seen as a happy one by society, as I lived in a household with depressed and mentally ill family members with not much freedom of my own, but it did not seem to impede my progress through the path. From my understanding, achieving a pleasurable existence is a job distinct from awakening, and is skill within of it self. Hence why things like dark nights will always be avoidable to a degree, or that the path doesn't have to be some brutal trial by fire. Awakening makes it significantly easier to achieve that pleasurable existence however.

The main point of this post and ramblings is due to my own results with these ideas, I am curious to see if this is an area that can be further utilised to help the steps needed to awaken to become more clear, or if I have misrepresented something that is still very unclear. From my experience, programming is an excellent grounding in the logic required to awaken. I hope a useful discussion can come from this.


r/streamentry • • Feb 15 '21

conduct I PLEAD THE FIFTH PRECEPT: Addiction to Drugs. Self Sabotage on the Path of Self Realization [conduct]

2 Upvotes

STAY AWAY FROM DRUGS. I DONT CARE HOW ADVANCED YOU ARE. I feel like drugs can be even more addictive to someone who sees dukkha very easily and readily. A person who is sick of constantly expanding and contracting, going in and out of unpleasant and pleasant states and perceptions, etc. Drugs can be even more tempting to this person because substances can almost consistently provide the same experience or deliver a set of experiences that you can become obsessed with. Especially for those of us who have had bouts of excessive drug use or just problems with it in general before taking up meditation seriously. Those old habit patterns are waiting for you...believe me.

ANDDD, the solitary confinement most meditators subject themselves to can create the perfect breeding ground for a relapse into drugs. The isolation and the painful feeling of disconnect from your fellow man can make you even more susceptible to overindulgence because you won't really have a support group of people around you who can find out that you're spiraling into abject peril. Your setting doesn’t really require you to see people or stay in touch so there’s essentially no safety net between you and rock bottom. They might even think that because you're such a talented meditator that you can use drugs from time to time and not suffer from using it and get entangled. Therefore, they won't even take the problem as seriously as they might need to in order to get you help!

Keep in mind that the drugs are just part of the problem. The scenarios and people that are connected to these substances are not your friends (drug dealers, people you use with, the communities you may go into, the horrible intimate relationship choices, problems with the law, issues at work, etc.). They're a shadow of what real community and friendship is. Not to mention you can be putting yourself at great risk when using these substances. You may think you're smoking cannabis, but it has been sprayed with LSD and laced with highly addictive opioids.

Oddly enough...you likely are a pretty good meditator but unfortunately the very trait that enabled you to excel in meditation is now working against you. Meditation requires habitual tendency to a degree. Being able to do something over and over again repeatedly and continuously. An addict is able to do something over and over again, repeatedly and continuously but unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on how you see dukkha) the drugs will zap the power of your mind and body and attenuate your spirit whereas the meditation will do the opposite. Your addiction, that you may have developed in meditation, to altered states of consciousness will be revealed when you dabble with substances and it can become hard to hold back from them because it's so "easy" to attain them through substances as opposed to literally breaking your back walking and sitting all day noting or praying. It’s an easy access.

You may want to quit cold turkey (the abrupt and complete cessation of taking a drug to which one is addicted) or be forced to because you're basically broke from not working consistently and volunteering at meditation centers. This will be like hell. Your conscience will BUUUUURN from the withdrawals...like you wouldn’t believe and make you believe things about yourself and others that aren’t true because your consciousness might get flooded with embarrassing, shameful, repugnant memories of the way you behaved when you were not sober in the form of "flashback style" memory recall. Reason is, is that the sober you is most likely behaves very differently from the intoxicated you and for some reason the mind is incredibly good at producing the arising of memories of past blunders in this phase of withdrawal and even after the withdrawals. You’ll get this notion that you’ve been possessed almost because you wouldn’t have behaved in that shameful way or made those mistakes had you been sober. This can demolish your self esteem and worth and even make you very suicidal. So, you need to have support and ween yourself off instead of just going cold turkey. Some substance dependencies can be fatal if you do this like with alcohol dependency, for instance. This abrupt stopping of use can be so disorienting that it could lead to an admission into a psych division of a hospital until you get through the acute withdrawal phase. Or even lead to you relapsing again onto the substance to rid yourself of the withdrawals. At its worse it could lead to suicide. So please speak to professionals as to how you’ll go about coming off various substances. I’m not a professional.

Some people will not be able to make sense of how a meditator could do drugs, think you're a phony and slowly but surely drift away from your life. Some, and key word is some, people you thought you could consistently rely on will eventually become much more difficult to reach because they've lost faith in you and a part of them is likely remorsefully scared of what has happened to you. It's not their fault. If they've never dealt with drug problems *after* beginning to meditate "seriously" they'll just think you're a fake and your wisdom will have lost its luster. Most meditators anyway are very focused, driven people anyway, so as long as you're not serving their development on "THE PATH" they all of a sudden just can't seem to find the time to connect with you. They only have time for development (BHAVANA) and you now don’t seem to have ANY of that. This is no coincidence. This is likely because at this phase in your life you're bitter, angry and lamenting after a visceral intensified experience of the 8 worldly winds (Pleasure & Pain, Gain & Loss, Praise & Blame, Fame & Disrepute) from the lifestyle that the drugs beckoned you into. These vibrations are unpleasant and therefore very few want to hear this. It's painful and scary that one can plummet from such highs to such depths. No one wants to fall out of heaven. Like an angel’s good karma running out as they fall into a lower, more unpleasant realm.

That's okay and understandable, this world is demanding and if you're not adding value to someone's life you simply aren't worth their time. They're not going to adopt you as a child and give you ALL the love and care you require. These focused meditators have adopted themselves and have become their own caretakers. They know their burden is already quite hard to bear, let alone taking on part of yours. They will likely try to help you as much as they can, but they don't have enough time and maybe even knowledge to help you. This is where you need to get professional help from counsellors and mental health professionals that you can consistently call. This is when you get out into the community in a positive way and feed that desire for connection that ALL humans have. This is where you make the most triumphant comeback where you rid yourself of your addiction and begin to really understand why the 5th precept of abstinence from intoxicants exists within Buddhism. I'm no pro, but you'll likely need to attend some kind of support group like (AA meetings and the like). They'll understand your plight in a way that most others wont. I am no fan of seeing so many pictures or statues of the Buddha sitting alone. I feel like it has given people the false impression that you must be predominantly alone in order to progress. Or the notion that being alone with eyes closed is the best example of mindfulness. Do not go it alone. Not for long at least ;)

You may have turned to drugs in a moment of desperation. You needed to feel better, to have fun, relax, and you achieved that for some time but as I said, it’s not sustainable for most and has grueling downsides. If you failed to moderate it in the past, do not risk it by using again thinking that your meditation will help you moderate it. Your meditation can help you come out of the addiction, go through withdrawal and maybe not go to the extreme with use. But believe me. It’s not worth the risk. Some people can moderate their usage, but this is not an area to be optimistic in. It’s not worth your precious time.

It would be best to reconsider picking up some of the wholesome hobbies that you did before you became obsessed with meditation. Revisit the past times you enjoyed but then dropped as a sacrifice for a clear runway for your meditation take off from. Bring your meditative mind to those wholesome things like playing sports, making art, exercising, cooking, hiking, reading interesting novels that don’t have to do with meditation specifically, being in nature, playing instruments, singing, dancing, etc. You’ll need these things to substitute for your addictive relationship to drugs.

I hope this post serves you well. I admire this community and all the people who make it up so much. I wish you all true happiness free from destructive, self sabotaging tendencies.

I PLEAD THE FIFTH

Sincerely,

cowabhanga


r/streamentry • • Aug 16 '20

conduct On the notion of stream-entry and the title of sotāpanna [conduct]

0 Upvotes

Disclaimer: this is my take on stream-entry and the title of sotāpanna (stream-enterer) picked up from what I've read about Buddhism in historical contexts, what I have learned about monastic life, and what I extrapolate from considering the contexts from which such titles originated.

Traditionally, titles like stream-enterer sotāpanna were bestowed by the Sangha onto a bhikkhu or bhikkhuni (Buddhist monk) with great merit, stable meditative absorption, virtuous conduct and demonstrated adherence to the noble eightfold path during every waking moment of their lives. Monastic Buddhists are fully embedded in the lives of their fellow bhikkhus and bhikkhunis, receiving instruction from teachers more advanced on the path, and interacting in close proximity with peers who are also cultivating a practice in similar ways. In simple terms, there's thousands of close proximity touchpoints with which their behavior and meditative attainments can be assessed each day - this monastic life and context draws a stark contrast to the lives of lay people like ourselves. The monastic environment is extraordinarily conducive to developing meditative absorption, virtuous conduct, and integrating the noble eightfold path as a lifestyle. It's also an environment that is conducive for teachers and peers to assess one another's levels of meditative absorption and virtuous conduct because monastics are surrounded by one another every day and everyone is having highly symmetric interior and exterior experiences of life. Thus, the collective wisdom and observations of the sangha and it's teachers is the ultimate arbiter of one's progress on the path. If a teacher becomes aware that a sangha member has consistently achieved meditative absorption, been impeccable in conduct, has clearly embodied the eightfold noble path, and that belief is communed by sangha members and advanced teachers, they might bestow the honorary title of sotāpanna (stream-enterer) to the meritorious sangha member.

I don't think it's otherwise possible to determine if anyone has actually attained stream entry without being embedded in the aforementioned context. There are those who would say otherwise, but I would maintain a strong degree of skepticism about such claims in lieu of any empirically validated neurophysiological indicators that could be used to determine such things outside of the context mentioned above. I would also question the character of a lay person who claimed such a title for themselves as it seems to suggest a lack of deference for traditions and ways of life which are in all likelihood outside of their comprehension (unless they had previously renounced and been part of the monastic community for a substantial amount of time).

That being said, I think that for all practical purposes among lay practitioners, these titles and attainments are irrelevant. A person's conduct, integrity, clarity of thought as evidenced by their communication and embodiment of the eightfold path should probably speak for itself.

Please engage with Thanissaro Bhikkhu's study guide for stream-entry as a primer to familiarize with what stream-entry actually is such that you can bring a bit more than an opinion to the conversation.


r/streamentry • • Aug 19 '25

Health Mediation and holding your seed

2 Upvotes

Are there practices or rules of thumb for how often a man should spill their seed? Accumulation is helpful up to a point but is detrimental to hold forever according to some science


r/streamentry • • Oct 09 '25

Jhāna The reason some people can easily access the jhanas and it is impossible for others.

14 Upvotes

There are two practitioners with identical mental states. They have no hindrances, no defilement, no psychological disorders, nothing that can get in the way of accessing the jhanas -- their mind is still. They both have access concentration. They both meditate in the same environment. They both feel comfortable and safe in that environment. Yet one has an easy time accessing the jhanas and the other makes no headwind. Why is that?

It's not uncommon in meditation circles to hear of enlightenment and jhana access like a lotto. Sometimes people just get lucky and others get unlucky. For some people it's incredibly easy and for others it is difficult. No one knows why.

Ten years ago there was a neurology study on this lotto. By studying the brain they not only hoped to explain what was going on in the brain, but why experiences can vary from practitioner to practitioner so much. While the brain scans were interesting, it unfortunately didn't answer this question. There had to be something a bit more conclusive.

For 15 years I've wanted to know the answer to this question and I believe I've figured it out. It comes down to inflammation. Not external inflammation like joint inflammation, though that can be a factor, but internal body inflammation so small one may not be able to perceive.

Perception is neat. We notice difference. If we're used to not having a stomach ache and then we have one, we notice having a stomach ache. But if someone has a low lingering stomach ache for years that is consistent, they can't tell they have it. It feels normal. The only tell-tell sign is when there is a change. Maybe they take a medicine and their stomach feels better so they notice, or someone else touches their stomach and they don't like to be touched there. It's possible to feel bad in the present moment from inflammation but have zero awareness of it if that bad feeling does not change.

It's said 90% of our emotions come from our gut biome. While this hasn't been proven yet, an increasing body of evidence is slowly showing this to be the case. Particularly, our emotional baseline comes from a combination of our gut biome and our internal body inflammation. If you've got nothing going on, no negative stressors in life, nothing large, so you've only got your emotional baseline, how you feel after that comes down to your gut.

The difference between the two practitioners is once all of their emotions have died down from a lack of stress, but also enough sensory seclusion that only their emotional baseline is left, one practitioner feels good and the other feels bad. One practitioner enjoys just sitting and chilling. They'd rather sit than go on Reddit. They'd rather sit than watch TV. It's nice. It's pleasant. And from that positive emotions build eventually leading to the jhanas. The other practitioner might have a sore stomach, but they can't tell they have a sore stomach. To them they would rather go and do other things because the present moment doesn't feel good. They'd rather distract themselves with TV to get away from the blah that is the present moment.

Inflammation comes in many shapes and sizes. Allergies cause inflammation. Allergies can prevent someone from getting into the jhanas. Though not all inflammation can prevent one. The inflammation has to make them feel just bad enough it overrides neutral-good baseline feelings. The vast majority of inflammation that makes one feel bad in the present moment is tied to the gut, so e.g. allergies can inflame the muscles around the stomach, or it can cause nasal congestion to leak into the intestines that can cause a very mild stomach ache. There are many medical conditions like this that can prevent one from entering the jhanas. Another example is many people who have depression also have IBS, and IBS can cause gut inflammation.

There is a potential solution.

Maybe it's not a potential solution but a full solution, but because there are a lot of medical issues that can cause pain that can prevent one from entering the jhanas that haven't been mapped out, I can't guarantee a solution for everyone. The landscape is vast and complex. However, given the vast majority of issues stem from the gut, the solution has been recommended in the suttas the whole time: eat a whole foods plant based diet. A WFPB diet for short. Specifically, the suttas suggest avoiding eating animal products that has been slaughtered for you, like buying it in stores. But say you go to a party and there is extra meat that will go to waste if it isn't eaten, then it's better to eat it than to spoil it. So it's not a 100% vegan diet, it's more like a vegetarian diet that allows for meat on special occasion.

In the Buddha's time there wasn't ultra processed foods, so there was no consideration for it. A whole foods diet is a traditional diet, like one Gautama would have eaten. It's minimizing strongly processed foods like tofu and fake meat, and sticking to traditional meals instead.

When one switches to eating whole foods their healthy fiber intake goes up. Foods that feed gut bacteria that cause inflammation go down. Ingredients that cause inflammation go down. It isn't an overnight process, but over a period of months it can help one's emotional baseline improve. Life starts to feel really good. Also, as ones gut shifts WFPB meals start to taste better than meat based meals. It doesn't feel like a punishment but genuinely enjoyable.

Buddha recommended socializing around good people. He said it is not half of the holy life, but the entirety of the holy life, signifying the significance of how important it is to be around good people. Socializing revolves around food, and most restaurants do not have a vegan option, but they do have many really good tasting vegetarian options. They may or may not be whole foods. That's okay. It's better to socialize and eat as healthy as reasonably possible that still tastes good than it is to not socialize and be dogmatic about diet. You don't have to be strict with this diet. It's okay.

This, like many mysterious and subtle things, it was right there in the suttas all along.

If you have access concentration, or even near access concentration, but sitting sucks, consider making your body healthier through exercise, diet, lifestyle, and even prescription drugs if needed.

For me, taking allergy medication combined with 50mg of Pepcid every 12 hours helps a ton, but I have MCAS, a rare medical condition that creates GERD. Before I had MCAS I went from living in the jhanas, but once I got MCAS, they became impossible to access without these medication, so I know first hand both how easy and how difficult it can be from a medical condition. Everyone's situation is different.


r/streamentry • • Jan 11 '26

Insight I realized Nirvana and the Pure Land and how to access them

0 Upvotes

Last night I realized Nirvana and the Pure Land and how to access them, so I will try to explain. (There are probably some parts of this that are wrong, and you are likely to have your own take and disagreements, so don't take my word for it. Check all of this)

First, let's say Nirvana, a state of not suffering, exists. Everyone who wants anything wants Nirvana all the time, so let's just assume it exists and is findable somewhere because otherwise we can't get Nirvana and we will be perpetually unsatisfied. How could we get Nirvana? Well, consider this: Have you ever known clearly a moment where you weren't suffering? For all you know, it may be that by the very construction of what it means to be a lifeform, all life always suffers and the only way to stop suffering is to not be alive and therefore not be conscious, and this is what the 1st Noble Truth says. Under this assumption, if you are alive, not a single condition can cause Nirvana. Likewise, if you are not alive, you are not conscious and therefore you already have Nirvana regardless of conditions. Either way, not a single condition, nothing at all you can do, can cause Nirvana. Therefore, Nirvana is unconditioned. However, we assume Nirvana exists and is findable by us, which means that, since Nirvana is unconditioned, it is also unconditional. It always exists and no conditions can remove it either. All you need to do is know it exists and is already here and train your attention to it. (From my own experience, btw, even while experiencing Nirvana, there is nothing I can point to and say "This is what not suffering feelings like." or even "This is what not suffering is". I can only describe it in terms of what it isn't. Everything I experience still contains suffering, and I still experience suffering, however, at the same, as long as I pay attention to Nirvana, I also experience no suffering and know it)

The Pure Land, a world of maxed out, overflowing positivity, the highest Heaven, is similar. Because we have ideals (since we are reasoning humans), the conditions for the Pure Land to already exist and be everywhere from our perspective as humans is already met. All we need to do to live as present in the Pure Land and to have infinite bliss and goodness and the such is know it exists and is already here and to pay attention to it. There is no experience of the Pure Land or of infinite bliss. They cannot be experiences because, by definition, they are better than all experiences. They are knowledges.

Experiencing Nirvana and the Pure Land is therefore almost entirely effortless. We just need to know they exist and how and to pay attention to them. We can then define the jhanas as states of absorption into paying attention to different aspects of the Pure Land (or seeing reality from the perspective of the Pure Land) so that jhana becomes almost effortless.


r/streamentry • • Jul 27 '26

Practice What forms of meditation can I do to invoke profound changes in conscious experience?

0 Upvotes

Now I know this question invites many people who enjoy putting such curiosities down with the usual dogmas surrounding various forms of praxis and popular philosophy:

“Meditation is about being aware of whatever enters consciousness in the present”

“Meditation is not about escape into intoxicating effects or dream-lands”

“Your desire for these states should be the focus of your attention; obsession with such states is a distraction from the path”

“Everything produces profound changes in consciousness”

“It is unsafe to seek altered states of consciousness”

I know these common objections. Yet I persist. I put them here ahead of time so you know I am not unfamiliar. I know that I am responsible for myself and I know the potential consequences.

So, that all being said, what methods of meditation do you recommend? I do understand that “profound changes” is vague and that’s fine. For this is the beginning of investigating the whole affair at an experiential level. So I do not need to hone in on one specific profound conscious state. Any will do.

Thank y’all!


r/streamentry • • Jun 04 '21

Theravada [theravada] Someone's method for Stream Entry

0 Upvotes

Don't ask me who it is or how it is known, but here is how a lay person attained Stream Entry:

- Read What The Buddha Taught by Walpola Rahula. Would read a chapter of this book and study it for a day or two or a few. Once a conclusion about the contents of the chapter were reached, would move onto the next chapter. Repeat. Started meditating as well. The night the book was completed in this way a rainbow lotus was seen opening up within their mind. Individual says the vision was beautiful, but alarming.

- Spend next few months meditating inconsistently on the breath and thinking about what they learned.

- Read Way to The End of Suffering by Bhikku Bodhi in the same manner as the above first book. Started putting certain behaviors into practice learned in that book. Continued to meditate inconsistently for next few months.

- Broke through into Jhanna sitting in car while meditating during lunch break. Lasted only a few minutes, but felt good. Continued meditating more consistently for next few months.

- Listened to this series of lectures http://buddhanet.net/audio-lectures.htm in a similar manner as with reading the above two listed books. Individual reports that not long after finishing the lectures or sometime during the listening of these lectures, stream entry was achieved.

User reported certain changes:

- Ability to extraordinary memory. Could recall many events with extraordinary detail. One such example is visually and audibly recalling the first few hours of Final Fantasy VII nearly perfectly. User could have kept going. The game was played ten years ago. Similar feats done for other games.

- User had diagnosed OCD and it went away almost completely.

- Verbal mastery. Hard to describe, said their mastery of the language increased to the point where they understood language and it's nuances to a much greater depth.

- Massive decrease in fear and of dying.

- During meditation their body would 'heal'. Their spine would straighten itself.

- This one I had a hard time believing: minor instances of precognition. Not really elaborated on.

I know those with attainment aren't supposed to talk about attainments. They said I could post this out of compassion for research purposes. Consider it anecdotal evidence. Envy and disbelief are obviously two things that can occur, so the only was is to "come and see" as The Buddha said.


r/streamentry • • May 01 '24

Insight Suffering isnt real, so there is no need to fear it.

8 Upvotes

Realization isnt a state of mind or an attainment, it is just seeing through how the mind builds "suffering" from sensation. Our lives are spent running from bad feelings in one way or another, but like in a Scooby doo cartoon, if you pull off the hood of any feeling, you will find plain sensation. It's just old man Miller trying to scare you off your bliss.

The "path" of enlightenment is really a "process" that plays out in human nervous systems. Our brains are designed by evolution to seek solutions which will deliver the least "suffering" to those we care about. If you are raised in a coal mining town, you might really want a job in the mine. If you are raised on Rodeo drive, that wont seem like a good idea. Our preferred route to alleviate suffering is created in our minds by our circumstances. When a person begins meditating, for whatever reason, the mind begins to see that the most direct route to less suffering is to let it go. To see that this suffering or that suffering isnt important and to release it. The nervous system is now pointed towards realization and will progress in that direction unless it gets knocked off course by this or that. Eventually, the mind sees through the entire pageant of suffering - it sees how the sets are made and knows the lead singer is an alcoholic - so it stops being sutured inside fabricated suffering mind states and just sees sensation arise and pass away. This isnt a supernatural event or even that interesting. It seems stupidly obvious, actually, when you realize it.

The issue we face as Yogis is that the mind surfs through landscapes of sensations and stories and enters all kinds of frames of reality as the day goes by. At work , this is what's happening and what's important, on the subway that is and at the strip club it's something else. For Yogis we experience that just sitting doing nothing and a wild river of mind states courses through most folks minds. Imagine what is happening when you are up and about and stressed. The process of realization is first to establish a vanguard understanding and then to slowly but surely allow that understanding to permeate your brain and nervous system, releasing subconscious narrative and tension as you go. The end state being a completely relaxed nervous system on earth doing nothing, being nothing. A buddha.

The traditional buddhist understanding of emptiness is a profoundly deep way to allow your nervous system to enter this state. Seeing how meaning structures are all imagined, accepting the abyss as this. It is hard to hold that view, however, and raise a child or be a good cop. The conditions of your life will push you into mind states so far removed from emptiness that it just is too difficult to really believe in emptiness while doing it. There is a reason why the Tibetans sometimes put people into dark rooms alone for 3 years.

I propose an alterante understanding that permits the same state of zero suffering, but is more portable. I propose accepting that what is happening is just a body on earth and what is occurring in your mind is just sensation from the physical world entering through the sense doors. You dont have to make up any story about who you are or why you are sitting there or what's going to happen next. Just accept that this body is doing stuff in response to stimuli. When you hold the frame that what is entering consciousness is just sensation at the sense doors, the main impediment is the body. It is pretty easy to close your eyes and let go of meaning in what you hear and taste and smell. Feeling is a motherfucker.

Lie down on the ground and let your attention skip around on your body. Try to focus your attention on the contact points between your body and the floor. If your attention drifts or you find your self in fantasy, return to the frame that you are just on the floor feeling your body. Notice that you are not in any control of how your attention skips around. Try to see where your mind misinterprets a physical sensation as emotion or intuition or fear and return to the frame of just a body on the floor, doing nothing.

Whether your team just won the Super Bowl or you were just pushed in front of a train, it is possible to frame what is happening at the moment as a body on earth and data at the sense doors.

This transcendent, but down to earth, frame, allows bliss and satisfaction to flood in to the mind. To shine through muck of emotion and dissatisfaction we are usually lost in. For this, as it is, to become apparent in its perfection. Like a crypto trader on a whale watching cruise, you look up from your phone and see the breach and rainbow.


r/streamentry • • Jun 04 '24

Insight I believe I may have entered a sort of "enlightenment", but what do I do now?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone.
So first off, I'm a philosopher and a mystic, as well as a skeptic who prizes rationality above all else. So I've always been in a rather unique position, being too esoteric/mystical to really fit into the scientific community, but also far too skeptical to fit into the typical occult/esoteric groups. I'm most certainly an odd one.

I'm 26 years old. To elaborate on my experience, and how I found myself facing "enlightenment", I'll give a brief background on my upbringing, as it was extremely atypical.

I grew up in a deeply religious family. My Mother had seemingly dealt with bipolar episodes which manifested via religious zeal. She'd take the unfortunate into our home quite frequently, so I had massive exposure to suffering that people faced from early adolescence. My upbringing until this point was rather privileged, so encountering these worlds people lived in where they frequently suffered and faced drug addiction, well it got me thinking quite deeply about the circumstances we find ourselves in and how we're shaped. It created some rather fertile grounds for extreme levels of compassion. I'm the image of the nerd who does everything right and has a successful future waiting for him. My best friends had been drug addicts (Sadly, many of them are no longer around). So I've walked this line between these worlds people live in, and I've seen massive amounts of suffering. This led me to quite the introspective path.

When I was 14, I had found myself no longer believing in my faith. So I abandoned it. Up until 16, I focused on scientific and atheistic perspectives. Eventually I grew frustrated with the meaningless existence that's implied by the scientific perspective. I desired purpose. But when I searched through all the religions, I found nothing but hypocrisy and absurdity. I needed to know the truth, but I refused to accept someone else's word for it. I needed to know it myself.

First, I began seeking via practical buddhism. Strangely enough, it took very little effort/practice to create states of jhana for myself. Mediation alone was pretty great, but it didn't provide me answers I was seeking. Eventually I disregarded the Jhana. I wanted answers, not pleasure.

So I found myself studying mysticism. I quickly realized that many of our religions may have started in truth, but truth was hard to verbalize in a straightforward manner, so they relied on stories. I realized the people of old weren't literal/factual thinkers like we are, and I began to speculate that the reliance we grown towards rationality and linguistic thinking had essentially bottlenecked our ability to understand. So I spent years attempting to learn how the mystics of old thought, while simultaneously adhering strongly to scientific knowledge and reason. I found myself with a desire to find the answers through whatever means I had to find them. I assured myself that if an answer were true, it would line up with scientific understanding and ultimately be testable.

The mystery of consciousness was my driving motivator, above all else. I didn't believe there's any beings in the sky. I don't care for an explanation of why the earth existed. I just wanted to know how we were possible. It's entirely feasible with our scientific understanding that we could evolve as we have, and behave as we do. In such a scenario though, we're just biological robots. Cause and effect. Even our inner voice can be observed to strongly relate to our vocal cords, speaking to ourselves is just simulating speech with speaking from a neurological perspective.

But how can we be aware? How can any of that be possible? Electromagnetism may easily explain computational and emergent systems, but the nature of awareness, that's most certainly not electromagnetism. It's as though by being aware, we spin up a mini universe to mirror the physical universe.

Science could explain everything from our origins to our behavior, yet it lacks any of the pieces needed to explain our experience. Whatever allows us to experience this life, it appeared to me that this "force" must be something far opposed to the scientific forces we're know of. But I believe in science, and I believe there must be a scientific explanation. I desired strongly to unite science with spirituality, so I spent a decade of persistent thought experiments and seeking to figure this out.

Then, the answer I had sought had became apparent in recent months. I tore apart my mind until I could find this "force". I suspected that the force which enabled awareness must be a fundamental force, it made 0 logical sense that such an absurd phenomena could arise from electromagnetism alone. I realized though reading neurological research that my inner voice was really just my vocal cords, my mind hallucinating them activating when I speak. I assumed that other methods of imagination were likely similar, occurring in the brain and were fundamentally illusive. I suspected that this force most certainly plays other roles in the universe, I just had to figure out what force it was in order to draw the right correlations between the mind and scientific observation.

When I finally tore my mind apart, I was left with just awareness, and I realized the force that enables our experience. That force is time. We aren't anything, besides a moment which is constantly perpetuated. I realized our awareness lies in this strange chasm between the physical universe and time, as though we are each individual strings of time. I realized that time was the fundamental force, and it led me to an understanding of the origins of everything, akin to the holographic principle, but with time as the fundamental dimensions which all else originates from.

I realized how the brain functions. It's much like a neural network (obviously the structure of the brain inspired our design of neural networks), but there's an intriguing factor I had realized that would take place in the "training data" of our minds.

Neurons are activated with a combination of chemical and electrical signals. When our neurons are activated, they emit electromagnetic fields. Ultimately, these electromagnetic fields resemble our brain state. When neurons are activated, they transmit ions. These ions are incredibly small and likely affected by quantum physics. Now, I'm not proposing some strange quantum tunneling phenomena like existing quantum consciousness theories pitch. I'm just pitching a change in circumstances of the Brain.

As our neurons our activated, the electromagnetic field inevitably exhibits patterns that reflect our current brain state. Here's the caveat though, each change in the electromagnetic fields would inevitably affect the results of future quantum interactions in the brain by changing circumstance and probability. The electromagnetic activity of the brain is constantly carving out the next moment in our mind, by shaping probabilities within it.

This isn't speculation, electromagnetic fields will inevitably have some effect on quantum phenomena. So this "interference" our brain faces from its previous moments is a persistent factor in our brains training data, our brains must accomadate for this "interference" from the previous moment to remain functional. So what does the brain do? It gives this interference a purpose, turning it into the thread that ties our moments together.

The changes in probabilities reflect the patterns of the electromagnetic field, so the brain works to integrate this into its experience so that it can function and survive. We aren't necessarily our brains, we're the moments between the brains activity and it's effect on it's own behavior. Tiny quantum phenemena that would typically average out into determinism via other systems, is instead persisted via this electromagnetic loop of the brain.

I've also extended my theory into an explanation of how time can bring all the other forces into existence.. But that's for another time, as this post is already quite long.

Here I am, after a decade of seeking, I seemed to have carved out a modern and potentially scientific/testable route to "enlightenment". I see the nature of the mind now, from a rather rational and scientific perspective as well as a mystical one. My inner voice isn't much different than any other bodily sensation, it's all just one experience, we just form divisions between our inner worlds (and the outer worlds), in an attempt to maintain sanity and ensure we don't chop our own fingers off by forgetting they are our fingers. I'm just a moment in time. The mind is extremely clear to me now.

But this proposition is quite grandiose, and while I feel obligated to share it (Humanity could use a spiritual approach that walks hand in hand with science), I'm not quite sure how to. Trying to share "enlightenment" typically leads to starting cults, and enlightenment also brings quite a bit of myth with it, as people think it's some sort of evolution into something more than human. But seeing it now, it's more like a "How was this not obvious?" feeling than it is a "Messiah" complex.

So what do I do now? I feel as though I am obligated to share what I've learned, I believe it could be the foundation for a truly scientific spirituality, and a truly spiritual science. But at the same time, I feel like I must be rather arrogant. I found a new path, one that may complement science and help us reach a new stage of evolution. But reading the sentence I just wrote? I must be quite arrogant and potentially even insane lol. I feel insane, yet this truth still feels more true than even the fact that I breath air.

So what do I do now? lol


r/streamentry • • Sep 06 '26

Practice Easy technique for very deep rest in a bed.

0 Upvotes

Lie down in your bed in a comfortable sleeping position (It has worked for me on a side) and don't move at all while concentrating by not doing anything at all, even don't think, if you forget bring the mind back to concentration. If you do move again don't in a nice resting position. It worked as the deepest rest I ever have had in my bed.


r/streamentry • • Jan 21 '25

Śamatha Has anyone experimented with clothes and grooming and how they affect your shamatha?

0 Upvotes

This is inspired by a video from YouTube channel "Real Men Real Style": "Why Most Men Don’t Dare to Dress Well". The guy argues that dressing "well" (whatever that means) can significantly boost our confidence, even if no one is watching.

I do not claim to know anything about "style", but I do have clothes that I love and other clothes that I just wear in order not to wear out my favourite clothes too often.

The video made me wonder: Does the way we dress affect our shamatha (ie, our stability of attention and peripheral awareness)? Physical comfort is one obvious factor (I would not want to wear a necktie when meditating), but might there be others? And if so, in which direction? It is conceivable that dressing "cool" or "stylish" might make us more concentrated, but it is also conceivable that this could make us more tied up in unnecessary pride and shame and worry.

Other aspects of grooming (shower frequency, shaving, deodorant, hair) might conceivably also have a psychological effect.

Has anyone experimented with this?

I have been wearing a rather drab hoodie for some weeks. I will try to wear one of my favourite sweaters instead for a while and see if that seems to make any difference.


r/streamentry • • May 28 '26

Practice Go Upstream

0 Upvotes

The parallel architecture of debugging, memory reconsolidation, and meditative insight

A few years ago, a friend was teaching me programming and introduced an unexpected analogy. Code, he said, is like a pinball machine, and data is like the pinball moving through it.

The analogy isn’t perfect, but it clarified a useful mental model: code as a fixed architecture that interprets and processes a fluid, changing variable—data—to produce an output. Change the architecture, the variable, or both, and you change the output.

Code doesn’t always work the way we want; it produces unwanted outputs in the form of errors. The error-generating mechanism is often hidden, because if it were easy to see, we’d have already fixed it.

One way to fix an error is to add more code at the end: an additional operation that takes the unwanted output and transforms it into the desired output. When the error-generating mechanism is hidden, this is often the easiest, most accessible approach.

Patching code this way can work, but it results in messier architecture, especially with multiple downstream patches. A program “fixed” this way will always be more complex and less efficient than necessary.

The cleanest, most effective way to resolve an error is to go upstream to its source: find the hidden root cause of the unwanted output and modify or remove the original error-generating mechanism. The result is more streamlined, legible code that performs only the operations necessary to get the desired output.

Inner Architecture & Personal Experience

We have inner architecture formed through genetics, culture, and past life experience. This architecture interprets and processes new life experience the same way code does for data.

Inner architecture consists of structures, some of which are legible to us (conscious) and some illegible (unconscious). As these structures interpret and process new experience, they sometimes lead to unwanted outputs: cognitive, behavioral, emotional (the “output” can be entirely internal).

Hidden Structures

Persisting, repeated, or seemingly intractable unwanted outputs are caused by structures that are partly or fully illegible. Unhelpful patterns persist because what generates them is hidden in the unconscious. If it were easy to see, we’d have already “fixed” it.

Unconscious structures often form as a response to being hurt. If we get hurt, and lack the capacity to fully metabolize the experience at the time, the memory of the hurt is pushed out of conscious awareness. A protective structure then forms to prevent us from being hurt again in the same way.

In first grade, I was called upon to answer a question in front of the class. I didn’t know the answer, so I didn’t know what to say, so I didn’t say anything. Other kids found this funny, and I got embarrassed. A structure forms to avoid situations where I might get caught “not knowing the answer”, to protect me from feeling that embarrassment again.

Protective structures that form early in life, when we’re most likely to experience hurt we don’t have capacity to fully metabolize, often retain the psychological simplicity of a child. As circumstances change, they continue filtering new experience and pattern-matching it to old.

The filtering is often too broad: highly motivated to avoid pain, a protective structure identifies and reacts to anything that might, sort of, kind of have a similar shape to the original experience of hurt. The more intense the hurt, the more aggressive the filter. Structures that formed with a positive intent end up being counterproductive or dysfunctional.

You may recognize familiar patterns: a structure tries to protect you from heartbreak by never allowing you to open your heart to someone new, or a structure tries to help you avoid being caught unprepared by making you over-prepare until the window to act has closed.

In my example about “not knowing the answer”, the structure naturally leads me to avoid answering questions in class. But to a hypersensitive structure with an aggressive filter, almost any kind of open-ended social interaction can be interpreted as risking “not knowing the answer”. It might also lead to social anxiety, staying quiet in groups or avoiding them altogether, or fear of public speaking (all of which I’ve experienced).

Counteracting

One way to address unhelpful patterns is to try to counteract them. Trying to think different thoughts, keeping your phone in a different room, or forcing yourself to raise your hand in class are all examples of counteractive measures. When the upstream generator of the unwanted pattern is hidden in the unconscious, this is often the easiest, most accessible approach.

Counteractive measures can work, but they have the same disadvantages as patching code. They’re additive, and must be repeated each time the unwanted output emerges. Since psyches aren’t deterministic code, if we’re tired, out of routine, or forgetful, counteractive measures that require effort and willpower often just don’t work.

When unwanted patterns persist for long periods, requiring constant effort to counteract, it’s a sign the upstream generator is still running. New experience is being processed through an old structure, and the problem persists, no matter how much well-intentioned and effortful counteracting has been done.

Fortunately, there is another way.

Dissolving Schemas

Instead of counteracting unwanted cognitive, behavioral, and emotional outputs, we can go upstream and address the hidden root cause directly through the process of memory reconsolidation.

In memory reconsolidation, a protective structure is called a schema: a set of beliefs formed around a particular emotionally salient experience. The process involves identifying the schema, activating it, and then presenting it with contrasting evidence—something that disconfirms its built-in assumptions. When this is done effectively enough or enough times, the schema updates or dissolves and new experiences are no longer processed in the old way.

Memory reconsolidation is a cross-domain, method-agnostic mechanism for transformative change, defined as the elimination of unwanted symptoms without the need for ongoing effort (i.e. counteractive measures).

Continuing my example, perhaps I engage with my fear around speaking in front of groups using a parts framework. (In modalities like IFS or Aletheia, parts are a way of interfacing with schemas.) I notice a tightness in my chest associated with this part, along with a mental image of being caught not knowing what to say.

If I work skillfully with this part from a place of loving presence, the structure naturally begins to soften and melt. It may then reveal to me the original first grade memory that is the source of the schema. Either way, my fear around “not knowing the answer” diminishes, and speaking in front of groups becomes more available.

In the memory reconsolidation process, the schema must be made legible, but the emotional memory that generated it doesn’t need to be. The cause of an unhelpful pattern is the upstream structure that formed around an experience of hurt, not the experience itself. We can dissolve protective structures without knowing when or why they formed; for memory reconsolidation to work, it actually doesn’t matter.

Perceptual Architecture & Sense Data

We have perceptual architecture that interprets and processes sense data (sight, sound, touch, etc.). Sense data is not coherent in and of itself; this architecture compiles it to form what we take to be perceptual primitives like objects, movement, and distance.

This happens at a micro-phenomenological level, so subtle and fast that it precedes our awareness of its output: the output is coherent subjective experience itself. Rapidly and reliably this compiling—agglomeration—creates the sense of ourselves as a subject situated in a three-dimensional world of space, time, and objects.

Example: you see a bird and hear it chirping. It seems like the chirping is coming from the bird, but there is in fact a subtle and rapid “gluing together” of the sight and sound sense data to create this perception.

You can try this yourself: close your eyes and pay close attention—what in your immediate experience actually indicates to you that the sensations of your face are your face?

Try it now.

You may notice, accompanying the sensations, a subtle mental image of your face, or inner dialogue saying something like, “I can feel my cheeks and lips” or, “What do you mean? That’s my face!” But without these other forms of sense data, and the agglomeration between them, there is nothing inherent or coherent about the face sensations in and of themselves.

Something Not Quite Right

Sensations arrive in experience pleasant or unpleasant; perceptual architecture also assigns valence. We don’t get to decide what feels good or bad, just like we don’t get to decide that we want more of one and less of the other.

Since experience is an ever-changing mix of both, there’s an intrinsic push-pull—we want the good to stay (but it goes), and we want the bad to go (but it’s here). The wanting is also micro-phenomenological, a subtle movement away from what is here and toward something else, a grabbing for something somehow better but just out of reach, something that could be there but that is not actually there.

Wanting things to be different than they are means being dissatisfied with the way they actually are. A slight, constant, underlying feeling of something-just-not-quite-right, like having the tiniest of pebbles in your shoe, very fine, almost sub-perceptual, but with reverberations that run all the way up through the stack of perception.

The dissatisfaction is there as soon as we’re aware of any moment of experience, feeling blended with and inseparable from it. Our default system setup is error-generating, and the mechanism is hidden because it’s embedded in upstream perceptual architecture. In practice, it always just feels like there’s something fundamentally not-okay about any moment.

We’ve all experienced this at a gross level: wanting something because we believe it will satisfy us, reaching it, finding it lacking, and still the desire to get to something better, to be ultimately satisfied somehow, is there. This happens moment-to-moment as well.

More of the Same

One way we try to fix this is to change experience into different, better experience. Just as dissatisfaction seems subtly, inherently in actual experience, ultimate satisfaction often seems subtly, inherently in potential experience.

Patching what feels missing in current experience with future experience seems like the only option, making it the easiest, most accessible approach.

It never works, because any experience we can change the current one to is downstream of the same perceptual architecture. Anything the wanting wants contains the same wanting, and therefore the same dissatisfaction. It’s like trying to fill a hole that can never be filled, meet a need that can never be met, reach something that forever remains just out of reach.

Chasing better experience may sometimes feel like it kind of works, but it’s never a robust answer to a perennial problem.

What a Clever Trick

Dharma practice enables us to go upstream and directly address the root cause of the dissatisfaction. One way to think about meditation is as a way of increasing legibility into our perceptual architecture. The deeper we practice, the further back we go.

In coding and inner work, the error-generating mechanism must be found and understood before it can be worked with and resolved. Meditation collapses the distinctions: clear seeing of perceptual architecture is meditative insight. Finding, understanding, working with, and resolving are all one intervention that leads to freedom.

In practice, this usually happens a little at a time.

Example: I’m sitting, after building up some concentration and sensory clarity I begin following the instruction to “look for the center of experience”. The center usually seems to be in the head, so this involves a lot of fine-grained examination of head sensations.

With sufficiently clear seeing, there is no center to be found, and I’m laughing because how could these sensations ever have been a self? What a clever trick, the cosmic joke, pulling the wool over all our eyes. And with this seeing, some sense of that center diminishes, a perma-contraction relinquishing, disappearing, dropping, falling away, and with it a sense of lightness, freedom, openness, liberation. Everything becomes a little “thinner and lighter”, and moment-to-moment experience contains less dissatisfaction.

Insight is variously described as a letting go, a dropping away, a removal. Because there’s no getting outside of perception, what sees the error-generating mechanism is seeing an aspect of itself. When perceptual architecture clearly sees through self-harming delusion, it tends not to go back to performing the self-harm.

What’s so radical about the dharma is that it goes so far upstream as to address the mechanism that makes it even possible for it to seem like there’s a problem with any moment of experience.

A Lot of Trouble

These three information processing architectures share analogous characteristics. Each architecture processes a changing variable, contains hidden error-generating mechanisms, and has lower-friction yet suboptimal methods for patching unwanted outputs. Each has more challenging, yet worthwhile, methods for going upstream to address the hidden generator.

This helps us understand efficacy in two domains: resolving issues at the level of the personality structure (cleaning up), and resolving issues at the level of perception or consciousness itself (waking up).

With memory reconsolidation, you free yourself of the structures that misinterpret new experience, downstream symptoms resolve, and you no longer need to counteract them.

With meditative insight, you free yourself of fundamental delusion, suffer less moment-to-moment, and you no longer try to satisfy dissatisfaction-containing experience with more dissatisfaction-containing experience.

Go upstream. You really save yourself a lot of trouble.

---

Thanks to Daniel Kazandjian, Carmen Lau, Matt Southey, Romeo Stevens, Roger Thisdell, and Daniel Thorson for reading drafts of this.

Originally published on Substack and X.


r/streamentry • • Mar 11 '25

Practice An introduction to the Holy Rosary

5 Upvotes

So... You've been looking for a different practice. Maybe you're looking for something devotional and heard something about this Holy Rosary thing and decided to give it a shot, but you don't know what this thing is or how to get started or even how the mechanics of it work at all.

Fret not, Padawan, I'm here to help you along the Path.

I'll skip over the history of the Holy Rosary, but it's very interesting if you're into this kind of thing.

First things first:

"Alan, do I need to be a Christian to pray the Holy Rosary?"

"No."

"Do I need to believe in God, god, gods, or deities in general?"

"Also no."

"Oh, okay. What do I need, then?"

"Something you can use to count prayers. It can be a prayer rope, rosary beads, or even a japamala. A basic rosary is best because it has the divisions already clear. We'll talk about that in a moment."

What is the Holy Rosary?

Most Christians believe that to pray the Holy Rosary is to repeat the Hail Mary and then the Our Father about fifty times and that's about it. You've done the world a great service. Alas, that's not the case.

The Holy Rosary is a tool to help you develop concentration.

You've tried the breath. You've tried mantras. You've tried Buddho. Nothing worked. And now you think this Awakening thing is not for you. You're wrong. This Awakening thing is for everybody willing to put in the effort.

Preliminaries

The first thing to understand is that "praying" is not a matter of repeating words out loud. Most of you already know this, but it's always worth repeating: true prayer is something that happens inside the mind. The externals - your position, your posture, the movements you make, and whatever is "outside" of you - are completely irrelevant.

What do you need when it comes to the externals? A position that's comfortable enough to stay in for a long time, but not comfortable enough that you can fall sleep. I recommend walking while praying. When you get really into it, you'll need to sit down or kneel. Avoid lying down until you are very advanced, because you will fall asleep and you will have intense dreams/hallucinations/visions. Or maybe you won't, who am I to judge?

"Well, okay, so what are the Hail Marys and Our Fathers for?"

They're a type of "padding" for your mind. A "safety net", if you will. At the beginning, though, they're like a gentle hand guiding your mind into the correct state for prayer/meditation. They're good for transitioning into prayer, for sustaining prayer, and then for coming out of prayer.

Whenever your awareness strays from your topic, as it will inevitably happen in the beginning, the spoken prayers are there to help you along. They're a sort of chant you will keep going in the background to keep the "potencies of the soul" occupied. Whenever you hear or read "potencies of the soul", think of your physical and cognitive faculties - eyes, ears, nose, tongue, skin, and then your mind. For my Buddhists out there, the potencies are the same thing as "Salayatana" (avijja paccaya sankhara, sankhara paccaya viññana, viññana paccaya nama-rupa, nama-rupa paccaya salayatana...)

So, you get your senses busy - you touch the Rosary, you speak the prayers, you hear the sound, you see the beads or whatever you use for visual aid, and you smell nothing, because smell is really hard to come about, unless you start having experiences of divinity, in which case it's common to smell the scent of roses (Rosary) or jasmine. Some people like incense and candles, I never use them.

"Well, what about my mind?"

Great question.

This is where true prayer begins: the mind.

How do I pray the Holy Rosary?

We already know that prayer is not the repetition of words ("And when you pray, do not use vain repetitions as the heathen do" Matthew 6:7-8), so what is it?

It's the engagement of the mind with a topic or object.

I'll say it again: Prayer is the engagement of the mind with a topic or object.

In other words: it's vitaka and viccara.

You direct your mind to a topic or object (you give rise to it, you bring it into existence) and then you examine it and lose yourself into it (you keep it into existence by clinging to it. "Clinging" or Upādāna is suffering. So you should stop clinging, right? Wrong. This is the good kind of clinging, the clinging that takes you to the end of clinging.)

In the case of the Holy Rosary, we traditionally have three groups of "Mysteries" that are used. These mysteries are a summary of the New Testament and the life of the Lord Jesus Christ, may He be forever praised:

The Joyful Mysteries (The Annunciation, The Visitation, The Nativity, The Presentation, The Finding)

The Sorrowful Mysteries (The Agony, The Scourging, The Crowning, The Carrying, The Crucifixion)

The Glorious Mysteries (The Resurrection, The Ascension, The Descent of the Holy Ghost, The Assumption of Mary, Mary being Crowned Queen of Heaven and Earth)

That's how the Rosary is traditionally used: reflecting on the life of Jesus and the events narrated in the New Testament. Hopefully, if you do it right, you'll start gaining powerful insights into the nature of suffering and the human condition, until you become Holy/Awakened yourself.

"Right... So... I just chant the prayers and imagine the scenes?"

That's it.

"Doesn't sound very cool."

It is very cool. And when you do it right, it gets REALLY intense.

"Do I need to use these Mysteries?"

No, you don't.

"Wait, seriously?"

Seriously. You can use anything as your topic of reflection. Imagine you want to understand the link Sankhara paccaya Viññana. You can simply focus on that during your prayer.

Imagine you're trying to understand something from your past - an event, a trauma, an experience, you name it - you can reflect on that while you pray.

Imagine you have a problem you really need to solve: you can think it over while you pray,

Now, the most interesting thing about the Holy Rosary is that it makes you feel safe. When you feel safe like that your mind opens up much more easily. This is the role of jhana, for instance: your mind feels good and safe and suddenly opens up about its nonsense, because it is feeling so good it sees no reason to cling to anything else. It's like a dog busy with a toy. Kinda literally.

The Mechanics

By now you've probably understood that the important part is not the repetitions, the positions, or the topic you choose: it's the way your mind engages with said topic.

In terms of mechanics, or how to operate the beads, it's fairly simple, but a distinction is necessary:

In English-speaking countries, the word "rosary" usually means what is called "terço" in other countries (like Brazil). "Terço" means "a third" of something. Why that name?

Because the "Full Rosary" is actually 150 decades (150 Hail Marys) divided into 3 groups of 50.

What is called "the rosary" in English-speaking countries is usually just 50. I recommend you start with just 50 and build up to 150 - or maybe even more, depending on your dedication, devotion, intensity, and need.

If you're a Catholic (Orthodox or Roman) you can start by doing the Sign of the Cross (a signal to your mind that you're about to do something that requires your full attention and some level of solemnity) and then reciting the Nicene Creed. If you're not a Catholic or a Christian, you should still find something to do to signal to your mind that it's about to get real, at least until contemplation becomes your standard state of mind.

I doubt the Christ and the Buddha would object to you saying "namo tassa bhagavato arahato samma sambuddhassa" a few times before starting your prayer routine, but maybe that's just me.

Then you hold the first bead between two fingers and pray the Our Father.

Next, you'll see three beads together. You hold them one by one, and pray one Hail Mary for each. Hold the first one, Hail Mary. Hold the second one. Hail Mary. Hold the third one. Hail Mary.

And now you pray a Glory Be. (Glory be to the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Spirit, as it was in the beginning is now, and ever shall be world without end. Amen.)

If you know Latin, you can pray everything in Latin. Some people say it works best. (It does work best, but not because Latin is special. It's simply because you're speaking a different language and have to focus more intensely.)

Now you get into the Mysteries proper (or your own topic of meditation)

It goes like this, and you say it out loud:

"Glorious Mysteries

The Resurrection of the Lord Jesus Christ"

Pray the Our Father (holding the big bead)

Pray 10 Hail Marys (holding the smaller beads)

When you reach the end of the 10th Hail Mary, you pray another Glory Be. Then you announce the second mystery, pray another Our Father, and then 10 more Hail Marys. And keep going until you finish the 5 decades you're praying.

Now, the important part here: while you're reciting the prayers, your mind will be focused on your topic. You can use the prayers themselves as your topic until the mind settles down. What does it mean to be "full of grace"? What does it mean that "the Lord is with thee"? What does it mean to be blessed? And so on.

"Alan, can I focus solely on the prayers themselves just to get my mind in the correct state?"

Yes, you can.

What matters here is getting your mind to settle down and feel at ease with what you're doing. Don't try to make your mind settle down, because it will not work. What you're going to do is coax your mind into relaxing and enjoying the experience. This is something that is good in and of itself, since it costs nothing to anyone anywhere, and gives you excellent results.

One technique I always suggest is actually talking to the Holy Mother while you pray - either verbally or mentally. Picture her - or any one of your choice, including the Buddha - and talk. Just like you would talk to a best friend or someone you trust completely.

"Alan, I don't trust anyone completely."

Then this is an even better exercise for you. Allow your mind to open up about all your problems and deficiencies and mistakes and shortcomings. The more honest, open, and sincere you are, the best the results you get. The more defensive you are... You get the idea. There's a reason why "Do not lie" is more important than "Do not kill" in Buddhism.

Also, we always hear talk about metta, right? Well, you should be the first recipient of your metta.

Allow yourself to love yourself and to want the very best for yourself.

This is not selfishness. This is wisdom.

Mystical Stuff and a couple of warnings

Mary Most Holy - aka Our Lady - once told a man I know that simply speaking the prayers out loud "makes them gray" for her. It's not that they're not worth anything, it's just that they're not worth anything. So, whenever you're praying, keep the mind engaged with your object, whatever it is. If you believe such things, consider that every Hail Mary you say out loud is a rose you're offering the Holy Mother, so try to do a good job of it but DO NOT FORCE OR STRAIN YOURSELF. Enjoy the process. Just do your best with what you can and have at the moment. Things will improve over time.

"How do you know it was the Holy Mother and not something from that guy's head?"

You don't know. That's why you should pay careful attention to what you're doing and always examine where this kind of knowledge comes from. Always be mindful while praying and meditating.

"Mindful of what?"

Every time you have an insight/revelation (there's no practical difference between them) ask yourself: is this true? Where does it come from? (what are the values and principles that give rise to that concept? Are they aligned with the True Dhamma?) Where does it lead me? (what would happen to me and to the beings around me if I put that advice into practice?)

This should take care of most visions and locutions.

Never believe your visions and locutions. If something seems to be true and useful, TEST IT.

Also, if you have a teacher or a confessor, only ever talk to THEM about your experiences during prayer. Don't go boasting about it.

If you have a close friend and/or confidant WHO ALSO DOES THE PRACTICE, you can talk to them and share experiences.

If you have no one, you can message me.

Questions?


r/streamentry • • Oct 03 '21

Science [science] Stream entry is possible without meditation through psychedelics

6 Upvotes

I would like to preface this post by saying that everyone’s experience is different and that in general it is probably good practice to tread lightly when it comes to psychedelic drugs. I want to share my personal experience because I was unable to find one similar to mine and maybe it will help someone else in the future make sense of the whole enchilada.

Some background on my life, I had a fairly normal and happy childhood. No childhood trauma or bullying. I was born in India and lived there for 8 years before moving to North America. The suffering started around 16. My mother passed away from cancer, this led to some existential crises. I spent the next 6 years working hard to get into medical school to honor my mom.

I was eventually able to get into medschool but when I got there I realized that there was mass cheating going on and nothing was being done about it. More than half the test questions were sourced from old exams and shared through back channels and google docs. It all came to a head when half the auditorium was empty 30mins into a 5 hour immunology exam. This exam was the hardest thing I had ever taken in my life and just sitting there knowing that half the class cheated and there was a good chance I was going to fail the class led me to question everything.

It bothered me to my core that the people that society trusts with their lives were such low integrity individuals. I knew some of my peers would inevitably kill patients because of what they were doing and nothing would happen because malpractice insurance exists and doctors almost never lose in a court of law. The medical lobby is also extremely powerful in America. This experience led me to drop out of medschool and pursue things I actually liked.

Around the time of me deciding to drop out I had my first psychedelic experience. It was a 5g shroom trip (I know, crazy dosage) where I just dried up the shrooms and made a tea. I went through the regular arcane fractal patterns emerging and some hallucinations into what seemed like endless death loops. Eventually I went through a loop and came in contact with the while light. Non-dual all knowing consciousness of eternal love. That lasted for maybe a few minutes and then I fell asleep.

The first experience didn’t have lasting changes in my life but I did start realizing that there was something more out there. Stream entry happened around 7-8months later when I did my second psychedelic trip. Around this time I had processed all of the emotions that came with dropping out of medschool. The shame of not being able to honor my mom and having to move back in with my parents was the biggest cause of my suffering. Before the trip I would say I had done maybe 6 months of self reflection and had cultivated a true love for myself. I didn’t have a meditation practice at all and spent most of my time playing poker at local casinos.

The second trip was an LSD trip where I did 2 100-150ug tabs. This trip I had the same fractal patterns emerge and had some hallucinations as well. This time, however, as I came into contact with the non-dual everythingness I realized I was it. After that it was like a light went off and all of the worries I had in my life just fell away instantly.

The best was to describe the relief that you get is imagine you are having a terrible nightmare where nothing seems to be going your way. Then, something happens and you remember or realize that you are dreaming, and that you are actually asleep somewhere in Massachusetts. The happiness or satisfaction of making millions of dollars in the dream could never compare to the peace of knowing that this is actually a dream and that you are completely safe and secure somewhere else.

There were some permanent changes after this second trip and I can say pretty confidently that I experienced stream entry. The first big change I saw was that I stopped lying completely. I just didn’t see the point of being someone other than myself, it just wasn’t interesting. I also stopped being an asshole to the world. I stopped littering, stealing, manipulating, etc. I just intuitively knew what the right things to do were and usually just did them even if they were a more cumbersome or expensive option. I stopped objectifying people and interestingly started personifying objects that I owned. I started treating my stuff with respect and maintaining it.

The most fascinating part was that I knew deep down I was never going to go back. I wasn’t interested in going back to lying. Eventually I got into philosophy and found my way to Advaita Vedanta. I still didn’t have a meditation practice at the time but I was fascinated by Dharma talks because now it seemed like I could understand them not only on an intellectual level but also an experiential level. It all just made sense.

I want to conclude this post with my own hypothesis on the conditions that led to my stream entry, I think there are a few, and if some readers have similar traits, then psychedelics may get you over the hurdle of stream entry.

  1. Relatively high intelligence

I’m not the smartest person in the world but I was smart enough to get into medschool with some effort

2. Extremely high suffering followed by self reflection

This is the hardest part to cultivate because part of it involves luck. There is no seminar or two day event where you can wear some lanyards and find out what it’s like to have your mom die and not be able to honor her. It requires an deep experiential understanding of suffering and not an intellectual one.However, if you do carry a lot of Dukkha, and are able to process those emotions you may be primed for psychedelics

3. High openness/perception

We were required to take an MBTI personality test when I first entered medschool and my result was ENTP. The most anomalous score for my test was P or perception. It was the most lopsided result where almost 100% of the questions I answered were on the perception side as opposed to Judgement. Although I would take this last trait with a grain of salt, just my personal experience

In conclusion, I would like to say that it is DEFINITELY possible to attain stream entry without a meditation practice through psychedelics , however deep suffering and introspection also seems to be needed. Good luck.


r/streamentry • • Mar 31 '20

buddhism [Buddhism] "Understanding Buddha's Teachings" YouTube & Discord

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I want to share a YouTube channel that a kalyāṇa-mitta, Vilas from India, is hosting. He explains various aspects of Buddha Dhamma there. This is Nibbāna centric Dhamma that is focused on comprehending the message of the Buddha. I have had many discussions with him personally and he has helped me to understand many basic things. He is very good at explaining the concepts and he can understand and speak Pali well. I also created a Discord server for people to discuss with him. The goal is to comprehend and find, each for oneself, the proper way to go about things - so that practice leads to sustainable and real results (peace of mind and changes in one’s habits/behavior), happiness. Not about who or what is wrong. Dhamma has to be understood by each person themselves. Facilitating this is the goal of this YouTube channel as well as the chat-server. Anyone with the intention to learn and understand is welcome, no matter if he feels he understands Dhamma currently or not. You can have a look at Vilas’ YouTube channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCM0GSLye8Js09qO8ebgEywg/about The link to the Discord server can be found here (I locked it at 25 uses because I am unsure about spam/bots. If you can’t get in then just PM me - I will be happy to facilitate. https://discord.gg/THumYV (link updated) May you attain Nibbāna at the earliest. nibbānam paramam sukham


r/streamentry • • Feb 24 '25

Vipassana The first time I took LSD since I started practicing Vipassana (Goenka) - potential stream entry

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I am new to this sub (read quite a few posts already since I fell down the rabbit whole of stream entry a month ago or so) and would love to hear your thoughts on my experience and my interpretation of it (also, at the end of this post, I added a few questions). I also hope that hearing about my experience will be helpful for some people. To those at the beginning of their journey, please remember that there are many dangers to taking LSD - there is such a thing as a bad trip. I am sure that if I hadn't advanced my equanimity and wisdom through Vipassana meditation, this evening would have had a very different impact on me (I for one do not plan to gamble with LSD another time).

Note: I am aware drug experiences are a dubitable thing. I suspect it might have been stream entry, but I understand this is probably impossible to know at this stage and I will have to see where I am in a year or so. In any case, I will try to speak to a credentialed teacher in person at some point.

My background

Fetters

I cannot remember ever having clung to any rite or ritual, and indeed I arguably never even performed one. Regarding the other fetters, I think I still (have) had them to a good degree, though I dare say that none of the first six fetters has been particularly strong as of late. Supporting this notion, I tend to feel relatively little ill-will these days and am more positively inclined toward others. The last 4 fetters I cannot really relate to at this stage yet.

Meditation practice hard facts

I've been meditating (Goenka) since my first Vipassana 10 day course last year June. I did another 10 days this January. After the first retreat, I started off with around 1.5 hours of meditation per day, which gradually decreased to virtually zero during Christmas. Since the second retreat, I've been meditating around 2 hours a day, sometimes less. I only have practiced the style as taught by Goenka so far.

Meditation practice soft facts

Concentration: My capacity for concentration is pretty low and I can confidently state that I never entered any jhana during my meditations (even if my understanding of what a jhana is is very limited).

Body sensations: On the seventh day of my first course, I achieved free flow on my body surface in a rather abrupt way (seemingly right after an exploration of the sensation I associate with anxiety, located within my body). During the last two days of the second course, I had an "electrical current" experience and could sweep most of my body within a few seconds (except my head, which tends to be dominated by gross sensations). Outside of the courses, the sensations I feel are less subtle and there is much less flow, if any.

Potential chakra experiences: In the first course, I on the 5th day had a piercing sensation within my "third eye chakra" area, and later noticed a horizontal red line where the piercing sensation had occurred. My assistant teacher had no explanation for this Harry Potter style phenomenon, especially since I never practiced any energy-based techniques. Indeed, I hadn't believed in chakras till then - today I believe my third eye had opened a little bit (as silly as it sounds). Subsequently, during the course I had felt pulsing sensations at this area, and I experienced a stark buildup of gross sensations on my forehead (with muscle tensions). During my second course I felt as if the third eye chakra had opened completely (a sensation of some blockage giving way to a heat sensation). Some other chakras seemed to be open as well, including the crown chakra.

Awareness of impermanence: With most sensations I had observed, if not all, I had observed them to pass after some time. In addition, right before the (presumed) initial opening of my third eye chakra, I had realized that I had been ignorant of an important change which had occurred in my life (I had only processed it on a surface level). Perhaps an hour before that realization, I believe during a meditation session, I felt some kind of soft pulse penetrating my mind (very brief, perhaps 0.5 sec), and for a few seconds I was under the impression that I could feel everything around me changing right in this moment.

Psychedelics

I had stopped taking LSD or shrooms since my first Goenka retreat (until the night I am recounting below). I am experienced with psychedelics: I am in my mid-thirties and have been doing LSD/shrooms occasionally since my mid-twenties (no more than once every two months).

Ethics/śīla

I've been living vegan since 2019 and generally would say am typically trying to behave ethically since then (with common weaknesses such as an objectively low level of generosity, and a low capacity commit to relationships, though this was "fixed" after my first vipassana course). Once though in 2022 my ethical integrity broke down - I intentionally lied. This was such a terrifying experience: I felt the lie had so many repercussions that it would lead me into a downward spiral (further lies, further regret, etc). Luckily for me the context of the lie was very local (quite far from my "life center"), which allowed me to escape the downward spiral even without having had the deep integrity to confess my lie. I think there I had a first taster of the "true" dangers of living unethically.

Trip setting (LSD + weed + a unique evening)

Two friends, my wife, and I, went to a concert. The two friends and I took LSD (around 120 mcg) before the concert and enjoyed an amazing high during the concert. The concert was amazing, psychedelic, with a whole range of emotions. We went out of the concert elated, and started vaping weed outside of the building.

We were reflecting on the concert, and our lives more generally. We were notably also talking about how we felt like robots most of the time, and that we would like to "live more".

At some point, my wife lost her consciousness. Luckily, I had her in my arms at that point, so she didn't hurt herself while falling. She "just" fainted, but this happened for the first time (probably she didn't drink enough water at the concert) and thus was a new experience for her and me. For a brief moment I thought I had lost her.

My wife regained her consciousness after 2 seconds or so. I shouted for water etc., and while I was not completely freaking out, I was quite unnerved. Here I just want to give a shout out to my friend who reminded me to "try to not freak out completely", which brought me back into a more stable mindset.

Another pulse, and starting to get into a meditative mindset

My wife and I canceled our afterhour plans and went straight home with a taxi. During this ride, we were mostly silent. At one point, I felt a soft pulse penetrating my mind similar to the pulse I experienced during my first vipassana course (see my background). My concentration rose, and I started to feel the same (gross) sensations I at this stage of my vipassana meditation tend to feel during meditation. I thought that perhaps the universe just gave me a friendly reminder of the impermanence of all things. I started practicing equanimity toward the sensations and the situation as a whole. Everything felt a little unreal (or too real) at this stage.

Once we got home we first got some snacks and chilled on the sofa. I felt more creative then usual, less restrained mentally (though I didn't take any creative actions). But what I experienced once I was in bed probably was more profound:

The part of the night where I believe I might have attained stream entry

The conditioned/the first two noble truths?

As I lay in bed, I started to feel as if I experienced every single moment distinctly. "Life" seemed like a succession of distinct moments. I interpreted this at some point as being reborn at every moment. I seemingly did not get distracted, and I at multiple times found myself realizing that "oh I find myself in this mind state now because of [this particular mental action/succession of actions which just happened a few moments ago]". I felt this was a deeper realization of the nature of samsara (everything being conditioned, including my very thoughts, though this seems to contradict the perception of creativity I had earlier). I realized (or thought) that "I" was really a process, that there was nothing really "me" (i.e. unchanging), though I couldn't quite understand how it was possible that "I" still seemingly traveled "through" time in a monotonous forward fashion, as opposed to simply a random moment or perhaps a moment of "my choice". I then at the same time however understood that this is how it is, every moment is conditioned and not "my choice". Some anxious moments followed, but I managed to regain equanimity quickly, also because I thought to myself that I actually am quite fine with where I am in life right now. I basically accepted my "predicament". I also had the thought that since change is unavoidable (in the conditioned life), there will always be suffering in some sense, if only for the reason that even during the "best" times, if I meet them with due awareness, I will be aware of their impermanent nature. Thus, there will never be a pure sweetness, life will always be bittersweet at the least.

A Taster of the unconditioned/the 3rd and 4th noble truths?

During the time when I experienced distinct moments, I appeared to have the "ability" to fall in between moments, seemingly stretching out time for a much longer time. While "falling" in this way, my capacity for conscious declined, and it was not a bad "feeling" at all (just to clarify, there was no associated body sensation, though perhaps a slight lightness in my upper head). However, I believed that fully letting myself fall might cause me to not be able to come back. Because I wanted to stay in this life, I stopped myself from falling "too far". Side note: Every decision I made during these moments was highly deliberate, eg, snuggling up to my wife (but yet conditioned, eg, if I would have let myself fall I presumably would not have had the ability to snuggle up).

Notes on body sensations and vision

I did some Vipassana meditation while in bed, but I would say nothing out of the ordinary happened in this regard. However, my vision once appeared to "reveal" that everything physical is basically a type of illusion, or alternatively, a cloud of wavelets without true substance. Before things got "too deep" I got spooked however and turned my attention elsewhere. I suppose it is normal to have such "hallucinations" during a psychedelic trip, it is just that now I interpret my "sober" perception as being more deceptive than what I perceived during that LSD trip ;).

Notes on the importance of śīla and samadhi

While I had the perception(s) of being (re-)born every moment, I perceived that all I can do in this very moment is to think in such a way that the "next guy who wakes up" is in a good position (to stay on the path). I also felt some compassion for this "next guy", and thought that it would be a good idea to send some metta toward him, where I later included my wife and then everyone (I am not sure how precise/advanced my metta meditation is, but I tried at least and I felt as in a distinct state while doing it). I thought I had obtained a deeper understanding than before of the importance of śīla and samadhi - i.e., I (still) want to really be aware of every moment, including my thoughts, so that I can at all times make sure that I (as a process) can properly follow śīla (which I already understood to be vital for my wellbeing and integrity, as I already learned the dangers of unethical behavior earlier, see my background above).

After the experience

My capacity for "falling into between moments" gradually subsided, but it was a slow process, and my awareness remained very high for several hours. I was wondering for a while how I could ever fall asleep again (which admittedly is a typical LSD experience). I realized however that by yearning for rest and moving to distract myself (which I started doing after perhaps an hour or so) I could slowly reconstruct "my self" and this would eventually enable me to fall asleep. I believe I fell asleep around 5AM (10 hours after having taken LSD). I woke up at around 9AM and felt fully refreshed - I went for a jog immediately. I had maintained a palpably heightened awareness until approximately 6PM (I went to a vegan outreach and felt more attentive during conversations, though I also got exhausted and was generally humbled that my eloquence certainly had its limits still). I still am less distracted than before the whole experience, though my baseline by now seems rather similar to where I was before (e.g. no more ongoing sensing of the gross sensations I typically feel during vipassana meditation).

Decisions:

  • Already while I was still high in my bed, I resolved to donate money (more than is usual for me). As a side note, upon deciding this, I think I had a feeling of a distinct "state of decision"

  • The next day, my wife and I both wondered why we are taking drugs - it felt unnecessarily unhealthy. Further it seemed like drugs were basically a manner of escaping, and we do not feel the need to escape (anymore). So we now made the intention to reduce drug use to a minimum, i.e., zero (allowing for some wiggle room since we do not want to be dogmatic about it, at least at this stage).

Ideas which were helpful

As I think it might be helpful for others, I here just want to jot down key ideas I remembered from Goenka's recordings which I found really helpful during the journey:

  • The yardstick to measure your progress on the journey is your degree of equanimity

  • Your awareness should match your equanimity and vice versa

  • As long as you take shelter in triple gem/follow the path, you'll be fine: I at some point thought, "am I missing a golden opportunity here by not letting myself fall?" and got anxious briefly, but then stabilized again (I also reminded myself that an attachment to the idea of nibbana also qualifies as an attachment)

Concrete questions

  • Does my "letting myself fall" experience resemble any key concept in terms of the path, a jhana, or perhaps even awakening itself (if followed through upon until "the end")?

  • If so, I am wondering whether one could "let oneself fall all the way" once one senses physical death to be right around the corner. In other words, the idea would be that I would live this life and then not inhabit yet another body but rather stretch out my last moment into infinity, as it were. Actual physical death, or alternatively, the moment(s) where my consciousness would typically seek another body to rest in, would never "catch up" to me, given that I will never arrive in that next moment (I am wondering, is this what the Angulimala story is about?).

  • If I really had understood that "I" am re-?)born in each moment, why am "I" still attached to something (so as to stop myself from falling, out of a fear of not returning)? Maybe I still need to perceive/understand that "I" really is "I" in quotation marks, as in an assemblage of constituents rather than one whole thing? Or is it perhaps a normal thing to not fully awaken until shortly before death (see above point)?

  • What am I to make of the "pulses" I experienced? EDIT: I am not sure whether "pulse" is the best word here. Perhaps it was more like a "jump" to a different (heightened) state of awareness/consciousness.

  • I also wonder whether it might be time for me to move on to Tibetan Buddhism, given the Chakra experiences I had (which seemed to be correlated with great advancements in my practice). Plus, my wife is a yoga teacher, so this would seem to align nicely. Indeed in my city there are some centers, so I will most likely explore this in any case.

Thanks!