r/startrekpicard • • May 01 '22

Some people are trying to say it's not an oversight that Vulcans had transporters in the 20th century. They say, "Emory Erikson only invented it for humans, vulcans already had it, DUH" I wonder if you actually watched the episode Deadalus, because how do you explain what T'pol says?

0 Upvotes

"The Vulcan Science Academy has been studying sub-quantum transporting for some time, with little result."

Seems pretty cut and dry that humans invented transporters for the federation.


r/startrekpicard • • Apr 19 '23

Picard S3 is fun, but is really almost nothing like TNG

0 Upvotes

Picard S3 is really well done, and I'm thoroughly enjoying it for what it is: a reunion mini-series. To people saying "more of this!" ... I think you're getting so caught up in the nostalgia that you're not noticing that Picard S3 is nothing like TNG. TNG followed the famous Star Trek mission statement: explore strange new worlds ... seek out new life and new civilization. TNG discovered new worlds, had entire episodes that ruminated over social, moral, and philosophical questions raised by encountering worlds unlike our own. That's what fans fell in love with in the 90s. Picard S3 has the trappings of TNG (familiar ships and faces) but it does almost none of the kind of storytelling that made you love TNG in the first place. I'm not yuck-ing anyone's yum here. The show is great fun. Just want to put out a reality check about what this season really is and why it's fun. I especially hope we don't get "more of this" because I think another season like this, and it will get really old really fast. If there is a spin-off, I hope they use the SNW playbook and make a true sci-fi show that embraces novel scientific and cultural exploration.


r/startrekpicard • • Feb 16 '23

OPINION: The new characters are a bust

0 Upvotes

I just thought about putting this out there, but the fact that most of the "new" characters from Season 1 were slowly phased out and ultimately eliminated by Season 3 shows that these characters were a bust right? Agnes Jurati, Captain Rios, Soji, Elnor, from what I've read they have left the show and are not coming back for Season 3. This suggests to me that STP recognized that these new characters are not popular and are not working out.


r/startrekpicard • • May 13 '22

What happened to mental health in the 24th century?!

1 Upvotes

I have such a hard time with the JL Mom subplot. His Mom is in such a bad state that Dad Picard locks her in her room, but doesn't call for help? And clearly, this isn't the first time!


r/startrekpicard • • May 08 '22

This is the stuff...

8 Upvotes

This series takes Star Trek in the same direction that Gene took it when he could follow his best instincts. It may not suit everyone in this new "woke paradise," but it's certainly my cup of tea.


r/startrekpicard • • Sep 18 '20

Wouldn't it have been ideal to wrap up the series with this one season?

1 Upvotes

Just finished watching and I can't help feeling that Picard was cheated of death, especially since he'd made his peace with it. His resurrection did not sit well with me. May Sir Patrick Stewart live a long life, but they seriously couldn't have envisaged running multiple seasons with him at the helm?


r/startrekpicard • • Sep 10 '22

Crime?

8 Upvotes

Raffi actress said something about how we get to see the crime underworld of the federation in season 3…..that just sounds so utterly lame and not realistic for the federation. I’m all for no more high stakes saving the universe every season, but crime? Ugh


r/startrekpicard • • Sep 20 '21

The entire crew of the La Sirena including Picard should either be in jail or rehab!

0 Upvotes

The entire crew of the La Sirena including Picard should either be in jail or rehab.! Agnes murdered someone. As did Seven of Nine, who like Raffi and Mr. Han Solo-Pilot-dude seem to have severe substance abuse issues. That leaves Picard as the only one. Oh wait, he should also be in the slammer for getting that Romulan Ex-Senator killed, and as an accessory to murder, when he gave Seven of Nine weapons for her little ultra-violence spree.


r/startrekpicard • • Apr 15 '22

Question So Picard has claustrophobia now?

0 Upvotes

Apparently no one told the Picard who got stuck in the turbolift with those kids. Or the Picard who played flute with his lady friend in the Jefferies tubes. Or the Picard who spent most of Starship Mine crawling around in the Jefferies tubes, Die Hard-style.


r/startrekpicard • • Mar 02 '23

Request - AI remaster of S03 episodes.

0 Upvotes

Would someone, for the love of Trek, run these episodes through an AI to brighten the scenes?

Can you imagine seeing red, blue, and gold uniforms?


r/startrekpicard • • Nov 17 '22

jurati is tired on her day off

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/startrekpicard • • Apr 09 '22

just finished S02 Ep06 - random thoughts

1 Upvotes

Before I start, I'm just a casual viewer. I started watching TNG in the mid-nineties and never looked back but I don't go into great detail, I just always make sure I'm watching anything with Star Trek in the title.

My thoughts so far:

I'm sorry but Picard died at the end of S1and I hated that he did. In my head, all I'm seeing is an android replicating the brain pathways of Picard. I could understand it if they put Picard in a younger body but its still Patrick Stewart (thank goodness) and the android is just imitating Picard's responses. For me, there were two choices the writers had:

  1. Forget/cure Irumodic Syndrome

  2. Have Picard die, make him an android that's replicating the brain pathways and therefore possible thoughts of the original character. The android will be played by Patrick Stewart and therefore have all the limitations that come with an actor of that age but none of true wonders of experiencing life as a human at that age and the experiences he had.

Brent Spiner playing another ancestor in Noonien Soong's history, so lucky they all look the same.. I feel it cheapens Data's story and is just a vehicle for Brent's ego. Its good his daughter also looks like the android from S1 - lucky stuff..

Borg Queen and Jurati - I don't know/care enough about Jurati yet to see how the relationship with the queen goes, I feel the whole invisible queen has also quite cheapened the queen character I saw develop in First Contact and Voyager

Raffi - just annoys me, I liked her in season 1 but in S2 she just frustrates me and I almost want to skip her scenes.

Q - I love him and I always want to see him but why bother messing around with a Picard android?

The series so far - it would be a bit of a pointless TNG episode that gives the actors a chance to change character a little, play someone from their characters past and we, the audience, would just have to accept the characters looked the same as their ancestors or that alternate reality characters luckily all knew each other.

I remember Patrick Stewart saying he had held off on playing Picard in the past because the story had never been that great, after S2 all I cant think is - wow those stories must have been truly terrible to say S2 made the cut.


r/startrekpicard • • Nov 15 '24

What's with all the f*cks in Picard??

0 Upvotes

Every other Star Trek show has been able to go through its entirety without ever using the word "f*ck". But in Picard, it seems like we got one almost every episode. Are they doing this purposefully? Why?

As a quick example, the admiral who told JL to STFU. I understand the scene, and understand that she couldn't get a word in edge wise, and it was deserved. But I would have felt better with a simple "shut up, Picard." Why the over-embellishment?

I have nothing against cussing. Not at all. But I feel it's forced, and seems completely out of place in a Star Trek series. Call me old fashioned, but I enjoyed the idealism in classic trek and the subsequent series. It seems they wanted to make Picard a darker series, and pointlessly filled it with the overuse of the word f*ck.

What do you guys think about this? I know my post is years too late, but on a second rewatch of the series, this quite annoyed me. Every time it was said, it felt out of place to me.


r/startrekpicard • • Apr 11 '23

Janeway is the new borg queen

0 Upvotes
  1. Nobody can get to Janeway

  2. This would have major ramifications for the federation.

  3. She is arranging the fleet to be in one spot

  4. She has the authority to implement that all starships are interconnected , like the borg

5.Vadik's line to 7 on the bridge.....Fitting it is you to stay and witness this

6. Janeway was once assimilated

7. Jack is an anomaly. A human/ borg hybrid. Janeway needs him to know how and why

8. She would have knowledge of what is in Daystrem Station.

9. Why Changlings ? Borgs would be noticed , and changlings share a desire for a colletive link

10. What would freak Troi out , seeing Janeway as the queen.

Thoughts ????


r/startrekpicard • • Apr 21 '22

Mental health in the 24th century

0 Upvotes

The treatment for a woman who is having a psychotic break, who is clearly a danger to herself and others, is to lock her up in a rural chalet? Is psychiatric treatment in a medical facility not a thing in the 24th century? Anyone else deeply disturbed by how mental health was portrayed in the latest episode, Monsters?

Not to mention in the previous episode, Renee's clinical anxiety and depression were alleviated by a 5 minute pep talk from a stranger? Sigh....


r/startrekpicard • • Apr 23 '23

The Borg were only in the story because they couldn't think of a way to defeat just the Changelings

3 Upvotes

Think about it.

The threat to Earth and the Federation could just as easily have been the same without the Borg involved. Changelings could have seized control of the fleet in pretty much the same way, possibly even using the transporters to insert changeling DNA rather than Borg DNA. And, since the ship networking using Borg tech was introduced in season 2, that could have still happened the same way.

The inclusion of the Borg did one thing. It gave them an easy kill switch, unlike a series of changelings scattered among the ships, taking control of various systems.

Because this wasn't a military victory, and that's fine, because Trek usually isn't about military victories. But using the Borg gave them an easy out, because defeating the changelings was too hard a solution to come up with.


r/startrekpicard • • Apr 02 '22

Question Gave up on Discovery and will start Picard, have a few questions?

0 Upvotes

I’m gonna start Picard, how does that fit into the timeline? I’m assuming after nemesis? How does seven of 9 fit into things? What’s the basic plot? Do DS9 characters come into play? I’ve seen more positive responses on here about Picard plus I can’t get into spore drive plot of discovery and other things


r/startrekpicard • • Feb 16 '20

Discussion Anyone else think that the serie is way to slow ? 4 episodes done and 'nothing happening'.

0 Upvotes

.. since episode 1.

I would not mind if the season would be 20episodes but its what 8 or 10?

Ep4 done and we are still gathering the party bf venturing forth.......


r/startrekpicard • • Apr 24 '22

I may be the only one but..

1 Upvotes

OK, so I came to picard late, never had any interest in it until I was persuaded to watch series 1 just after Christmas. I did have to concede I enjoyed it, but series 2? I watched up to episode 6, lost interest and have no intention of returning to it. Anyone else in the same place as me? Finding it difficult to motivate myself to watch it.


r/startrekpicard • • Mar 19 '22

I'm sick of time-travel

1 Upvotes

It's like they are out of ideas for the late 24th/early 25th centuries - when are we going to get a live action series that fully explores the "mainline" post-DS9/Voyager Star Trek universe without making every major event tied to a change in the timeline somewhere? It's like show-runners keep using this excuse to "write freely" without caring about the lore that was already built


r/startrekpicard • • Nov 17 '22

Jurati sketch + smol Aggie

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/startrekpicard • • Nov 04 '21

S01E03 - Does it get better?

5 Upvotes

I admit I've only seen the classic Star Trek show and movies, nothing from TNG or later, and I'm a little late to the party, but does the show get better? Do you need to watch TNG to get it?

Episode 1 was great, episode 2 was hmmm, but episode 3 was hard to watch. Raffi and Rios are very melodramatic and cliche, the brother/sister GOT thing, it's very disappointing but maybe this just the style of TNG and I'm out of the loop? Is it supposed to be kinda campy?


r/startrekpicard • • Mar 26 '23

I have a problem with Starfleet in current Picard. Please help.

36 Upvotes

I really want to like Picard, but I just can’t get past the fact that so few people in Starfleet seem professional. Admirals swear at Picard, people are rude to each other and yell at each other on the bridge, people don’t deal with their internal baggage professionally. I know that Roddenberry had the idea that no one should have internal conflicts on TOS, and I understand how limiting that would be from a writing perspective, but this just seems ridiculous.

Case in point, the moment when Riker says to Picard: “remove yourself from the bridge. You’ve killed us all.” First of all, you’re the captain now. You decided on his advice. Second, why are you declaring that the situation is hopeless in front of younger officers who are trying to do their jobs?

Another instance from the latest episode when Riker congratulates Picard on his use of the word “burgle” during a briefing.

If you go back and watch Next Gen, they are much more professional.

Please help me understand what is going on in terms of the logic of the show instead of just what it feels like to: lazy, badly written characters that are cheaply emotional to add drama.


r/startrekpicard • • Feb 01 '20

Discussion Language

1 Upvotes

I personally was not a big fan of the explicit language used. It's not like I dont enjoy the show so far. I acctually really like it. I was a young kid when TNG was on tv and we really enjoyed watching it as a family. I was excited to watch with my 9 y/o (like we did with the mandalorian) but I'm gonna have to watch this season my self first. Its not like I dont watch shows with bad language at all. To me this is like if luke said "fuck it, I'm out" in the last jedi. Just seems unnecessary to me.