I see a lot of people hate Starfleet Academy. Some critics are very valid, and I understand them, and some are just moronics or just nitpicks. A lot of it is just pure hatred, like you don't see often. A good critic, at least you will find something positive in his review. He will try to remain balanced and unbiased. That is not the case for the toxic part of the fanbase, as you see them hate anything and do not find anything positive about the show.
Even the wardrobe, which has been really good, has been criticized to no end by detractors. The best thing to me about the series was the wardrobe, the jacket, the uniforms have been amazing, Darem's costume on his planet was superb. When I see someone criticize the wardrobe, I just do not listen to the rest of what he says, as I don't think he really is objective. Just an example.
But the thing is, fans hated this show before it even came out. As soon as they heard the premise about an academy, people started to hate and seethe. They hate the academy, the lightning, the cast, everything. However, a lot of fans also like the old cast. They don't like the young ones and would rather focus more on the old cast. They are asking where Lura Thok is when the show is about the cadets, their growth, and their changes to become Starfleet officers.
One common criticism was also how the young cast is incompetent, swallows comm badges, and is not disciplined enough.
They hate how the cast participate in fun behavior, or should I say any youthful behavior like a prank war, or getting drunk in bars and starting fights, or Caleb's rebellious personality.
I find a lot of this behavior similar in the real world to millennials' and boomers' disdain for Gen Z. A lot of the young actors are good, but fans will never see that. And when they see them do things competently, like when Jay' Den saved his whole civilisation, or when the cadets were able to defeat the Venari Ral, they are asking how come the adults didn't figure it out? Why were the cadets the ones to defeat the Venari Ral?
So do those critics want the cadets to be idiots incompetent or competent? Which is it? I feel they get confused in their hatred. That is what happens when you get so much hatred, your criticism doesn't even make sense any longer, with so many emotions, rationality has left the window for just pure hatred salad.
Ignoring, of course, that SAM is an advanced A.I. photonic they took 200 years to build, and the cadets are geniuses in their world, the best among billions and billions of their species, with even the main cast a cut above the rest. I digress.
I feel a lot of the fans grew up on old Trek and are disgruntled that the main cast does not look like them, and they feel abandoned by the writers. They can not relate to the young cast and would rather see middle-aged actors looking like themselves, kicking ass. Am I wrong?