r/startrek • • Mar 29 '26

Kudos Starfleet Academy

92 Upvotes

I laughed hard. Ive teared up.

The hate for NuTrek is just ridiculous. Its art. It may not be for you. You might not like what they did... but give it a rest.

I liked Discovery. I like SNW (Edit: not Brave New Worlds but Strange New Worlds ). Below Decks is meh, but I can take stuff or leave it.

I liked TOS, TNG was OK, Did not like DS9. Enterprise was awesome. Voyager was awesome. I even liked the animated series.

There's a lot to like, and some stuff not to like. Some of y'all are getting Star Wars fantasy nasty, though.

You remind me of the BSG whiners that cant stand that they made Starbuck a woman.


r/startrek • • Apr 13 '11

Not cool, Captain Picard! NOT COOL!

Thumbnail comixed.memebase.com
117 Upvotes

r/startrek • • Mar 24 '26 Heartwarming Bravo

Starfleet Academy has the best gay representation in 50 years of the franchise.

154 Upvotes

It's really nice to be so very far from the 90s, where the closest we could get is Evil Gay Versions, symbiote technicalities, and Garak acting flamboyant.

Discovery unfortunately loses many points for burying their gays nearly the moment they got them, and no amount of mycelial magic will make me forget. Though how boringly they are written might.

But sweet Starfleet Academy manages to have plenty without it really being a thing. The gay klingon is just a klingon who likes dudes. the other gay guy who seems nice and inquisitive instead of being mostly catty like a certain blonde engineering officer. Also, excellent domestic ideal lesbians, with perfect casting, and plenty to do in the story.

I'm going to miss Academy a lot when it's gone.

Edit: OhMyGodIForgotLowerDecksWhichWasGoodButNeedSomeMaleGays

Edit 2: Is a gay dude not entitled to be happy in the face of seeing good examples of his people?

Can you really say everyone seems gay when we've had zero gay bedroom or romantic kissing scenes, while Cadet Caleb Fuksalot is moving the plot by screwing a princess?


r/startrek • • May 17 '23

Star Trek: Discovery is my favorite of the New Trek

67 Upvotes

I love the queer representation, the time jump, the characters, the story, the mirror universe subplot, section 31, Pike etc. I just love it all and don't really understand where all the hate comes from and will be sad when the final season airs next year.


r/startrek • • May 03 '26

Discovery is actually quite excellent

0 Upvotes

I'm an "old Trek" kind of guy. Finished a Voyager with my kids (first time for them), so I figured it was time for them (and me) to watch Discovery.

Just watched S01x11. To my amazement, I'm loving the series. We witnessed one of the best plot twists I've ever seen on TV. Almost "Sixth Sense" level of epic.

The only criticism I have is that the show feels more like a re-imagination / reboot. Continuity is blatantly poor (e.g. Klingons, 23rd century ship design), but the story telling is good enough for me to suspend my internal criticism.

I've heard S02 is great but S03 and beyond fall off a precipice, but I'm keeping an open mind. I was expecting unwatchable, and so far, got excellent.


r/startrek • • Sep 12 '26

Anyone love Star Trek: Academy?

0 Upvotes

I grew up on Star Trek. My first love was Voyager as it was regularly shown on TV when I was a child. Later on I discovered DS9(its my favorite trek). TNG and Enterprise.

I didn't like the New Trek, Star Trek Discovery. Picard was okay. Then came the travesty Star Trek Academy. I am a fan of Robert Picardo so I gave it a watch and I must say, its hilarious in its own way, especially that caricature of a Klingon that shits on established lore. I basically see it as a parody of Trek, but the show, writers and producers see it as a continuation of Trek and they are actually serious about it lmao. I dont know, but being familiar with TNG, DS9, Voy, this show is just hits funny and I love watching short clips of it just to see the serious ridiculousness of it all. Its like the writers of little Britain tried to make Trek lol.


r/startrek • • Mar 15 '26 Bravo

SFA feels like the first true modern Star Trek because of its setting.

37 Upvotes

Starfleet Academy is the first true modern star trek. Completely able to stand on its own without having to rely on nostalgia. Using "The Burn" as the backdrop was an ingenous move.

To me Star Trek has always been this hyper-progressive show that takes the attitudes of the present day and projects them into a sci-fi future representing the best of humanity. There’s this underlying optimism. That humanity pushes forward, explores new worlds, and boldly goes forward.

As an example:
TOS -Their present day attitude was the exploratory spirit of the space race and the moon landing, helping start the original optimistic tone.
90s era Star Trek - The Federation was this stable, peaceful, and prosperous entity. That laid-back utopian vibe mirrored the optimism of the post–Cold War era. Those shows presented the best of humanity against a backdrop where people felt like they figured shit out.

And thats why Starfleet academy worked so good. it is the first of the newer star treks that really maintains that core Star Trek optimism with present day attitudes. Strange New Worlds is good, but thats because it was just recreating and copying the formula of the past Star Treks. Picard was good, but its best parts were completely powered by nostalgia, again relying on past Star Treks. Discovery actual tried to modernize, but it couldnt bring that important underlying optimism. In losing that, it sucked and at times didnt feel like star trek.

By using "The Burn" as a reset button, the galaxy isnt stable anymore, resources are limited, alien races are now former allies. The setting feels uncertain and fragile. And that mirrors a lot of the present attitudes we have today. The world is burning from climate change, depleting resources, civil and international unrest, global instability, all things that make the future feel uncertain and fragile. It takes Starfleet, the best of us(humanity), right into the middle of all this uncertainty, and then we get to see the next generation rebuild optimism by exploring new worlds and bravely go forward.

And thats what Star Trek always did. Took the concerns and attitudes of its time, and then showed people being awesome in a scifi setting. I really hope the future of Star Trek continues down this path, it actually feels like a show for the next generation, but still distinctly Star Trek. Starfleet Academy's writing was hammy and contrived sometimes, that stakes at times were way too high, but its setting made for a solid story.

tldr: Starfleet Academy kicked ass, and you should recommend it to anyone who's not a boomer. We need more Post Burn star trek.

clarification : not saying sfa didnt have nostalgia. It just didnt rely on nostalgia. Someone who has never seen star trek can enjoy SFA way more then they can enjoy Picard as an example.


r/startrek • • Feb 06 '26 Bravo

SFA, unlike other Modern Trek shows, is The Next Generation (TNG) of the franchise today.

0 Upvotes

I'm a big supporter of Modern Trek but I always felt something hampered and held it back. I wasn't sure what it was until SFA. Now it's so obvious in retrospect.

Modern Trek was under the shadow of previous Trek. That's what held it back. In contrast, SFA is an (almost) clean break from previous Trek. Just like TNG was.

Except for the McCoy cameo, Roddenberry wanted TNG to be a clean slate. It took place a century later and had a bald middle aged captain, no Vulcan characters, Klingons as allies, etc. TNG was also radio silent on TOS specific lore until Unification. This allowed TNG to grow into its own independent identity. And it became a legendary show precisely because of this even if it took two seasons to get it right.

Imagine instead if TNG took place between TOS and TMP or after Star Trek VI. Imagine if it succumbed to pressures and expectations of endless TOS cameos. Hell, they probably would have made a TOS character a character on TNG. They may have replaced Patrick Stewart with Walter Koenig as Captain. Perhaps they would have returned to the Mafia planet. Or maybe Khan survived! TNG would have forever been under the shadow of TOS.

Now let's look at Modern Trek.

  • Discovery - TOS prequel

  • Picard - TNG sequel

  • Lower Decks - right after the events of Voyager and endlessly referencing previous Trek.

  • Prodigy - a quasi-Voyager sequel

  • SNW - another TOS prequel

Holy crap! Let the past be the past!

SFA is truly The Next Generation of our time in terms of it being a clean break. It feels fresh and new. It takes place 800 years later, the Federation is emerging from a Dark Ages, Vulcans and Romulans are one people, Klingons are almost extinct. We have new alien species right off the bat.

Unlike TNG which went scorched earth with not referencing TOS at all for five years, SFA has already referenced previous Trek. It also has a legacy character (the Doctor). This is fine as long as they keep these callbacks to a minimum. My fear is that they won't. Hopefully I'm wrong.

Final note: In terms of quality, it is unfair to compare the totality of TNG (178 episodes of stories and character development) to the five episodes of SFA. The appropriate comparison is the first five episodes of each. In this case, SFA blows TNG out of the water in every category.


r/startrek • • Jun 01 '24 Heart of Silver Take My Silver

The Star Trek franchise is in the best place it’s been since the 90s thanks to Discovery

94 Upvotes

It walked so Strange New Worlds could run and i enjoyed the experience the whole time.

54% upvote rate, the people have spoken.


r/startrek • • Mar 26 '26

Is there an LGBTQ+ safe Star Trek space out there for me after the chaos of Academy?

0 Upvotes

Am I alone? I sure feel like it.

I have had ONE thing in my 45 years that gives me pure childlike joy, and it’s my Star Trek. It wasn’t until my late autism diagnosis that I realized I never let myself tell anyone the truth of that desire nor collect anything because I wasn’t letting myself unmask and made my best attempts at being society’s “idea“ of “normal”. I didn’t even own a mug or a button. I would not let myself.

Suddenly I found a supportive partner and she gifted me a Data and I LOST IT. Not physically, but I just cried my inner child tears for an hour.
I now have revised production scripts and signed figures and old books and magazines and still feverishly collecting. Every box I open I am openly smiling like a 6 year old on Christmas morning. But it took me 45 years to get there.

But here’s the problem. I’ve been let down. And hard.

Very hard.

i joined all these ST groups all over social media, including here. But when Academy aired and suddenly there was “woke” chaos over a gay Klingon…in a skirt.

How is it “woke” if it’s literally in the future when humans have evolved to the point of not giving a flying rat‘s bottom about who you love or what you wear. What is so difficult for people to understand about natural human consciousness and evolution? I mean, yall remember slãvery and burning witches at stakes, right? I mean, unless you think we should still be doing that? If not - then YOU, have evolved. Congrats!

Anyways, due to the hostility in literally every social media ST community, I do not know where to turn.

I’m looking for a queer ST safe space after all the hostility from Academy soaked into social media and made it toxic.

is there a Discord? A website? A hidden gem somewhere here in red state TN?

I don’t know where to go now. The Academy hatred has made me completely rethink my deep love for Star Trek and I can’t let the haters take my joy away again. I know what the show represents, but so many don’t and they are so SO loud. And with that has come so much negativity against the 🏳️‍🌈 community.

Honestly it’s been so intense and toxic I don‘t even feel safe going to GalaxyCon this year in TN (we don’t get a lot of cool options here).

No social media platforms or groups or threads feel safe. If you know of a safe LGBTQ+ Star Trek private Discord group please message me. I’d deeply appreciate it.

Edit: Also, I’m not posting about Academy in itself. I’m posting about all the hatred I’ve seen in reference to how “woke” it is and the clear anger towards there being a gay Klingon. I am not expressing what my opinions are about the show, I’m talking about the onslaught of hate that followed its release.

Also, please stop being mean. You don’t know what you’re doing to some of us…and we don’t deserve it. We aren’t hurting you. Stop.


r/startrek • • Jul 09 '26

Michael Burnham

66 Upvotes

I wanted to make a post to acknowledge Michael’s growth because I feel like all anyone does is complain about her.
Not only is she one of my favorite Star Trek girlbosses (alongside Jadzia, Kira, Janeway, and B’Elana) but she shows SO MUCH GROWTH. In episode one she commits mutiny because of her Vulcan-like belief that she knows best. While I don’t believe she was the main reason for the battle this was still hard to watch. Her supposed crying every episode is caused by the fact that she is human, not Vulcan, and has been told to hide her emotions for her whole life which will of course bubble over. By the end she makes rational choices by asking others for help, she’s calm and knows that she can acknowledge her emotions much like Spock learned. She finally is able to mourn her parents and overall becomes a mature woman who learns to let people in and have a passion for exploring rather than just being in starfleet.
I know this will be controversial but I just love her character especially her friendship with Tilly and Stamets and borderline sibling relationship with Saru. I think by the end she is an empowering woman who deserves a praise post once in a while.


r/startrek • • Mar 22 '26 Bravo

To me a lot of the hatred for Starfleet Academy comes from a hatred of anything that looks youthful. Spoiler

258 Upvotes

I see a lot of people hate Starfleet Academy. Some critics are very valid, and I understand them, and some are just moronics or just nitpicks. A lot of it is just pure hatred, like you don't see often. A good critic, at least you will find something positive in his review. He will try to remain balanced and unbiased. That is not the case for the toxic part of the fanbase, as you see them hate anything and do not find anything positive about the show.

Even the wardrobe, which has been really good, has been criticized to no end by detractors. The best thing to me about the series was the wardrobe, the jacket, the uniforms have been amazing, Darem's costume on his planet was superb. When I see someone criticize the wardrobe, I just do not listen to the rest of what he says, as I don't think he really is objective. Just an example.

But the thing is, fans hated this show before it even came out. As soon as they heard the premise about an academy, people started to hate and seethe. They hate the academy, the lightning, the cast, everything. However, a lot of fans also like the old cast. They don't like the young ones and would rather focus more on the old cast. They are asking where Lura Thok is when the show is about the cadets, their growth, and their changes to become Starfleet officers.

One common criticism was also how the young cast is incompetent, swallows comm badges, and is not disciplined enough.

They hate how the cast participate in fun behavior, or should I say any youthful behavior like a prank war, or getting drunk in bars and starting fights, or Caleb's rebellious personality.

I find a lot of this behavior similar in the real world to millennials' and boomers' disdain for Gen Z. A lot of the young actors are good, but fans will never see that. And when they see them do things competently, like when Jay' Den saved his whole civilisation, or when the cadets were able to defeat the Venari Ral, they are asking how come the adults didn't figure it out? Why were the cadets the ones to defeat the Venari Ral?

So do those critics want the cadets to be idiots incompetent or competent? Which is it? I feel they get confused in their hatred. That is what happens when you get so much hatred, your criticism doesn't even make sense any longer, with so many emotions, rationality has left the window for just pure hatred salad.

Ignoring, of course, that SAM is an advanced A.I. photonic they took 200 years to build, and the cadets are geniuses in their world, the best among billions and billions of their species, with even the main cast a cut above the rest. I digress.

I feel a lot of the fans grew up on old Trek and are disgruntled that the main cast does not look like them, and they feel abandoned by the writers. They can not relate to the young cast and would rather see middle-aged actors looking like themselves, kicking ass. Am I wrong?


r/startrek • • Dec 18 '24

Star Trek 2009

11 Upvotes

Rewatched the reboot today. It’s not only probably the best Trek film, but just an amazing theatrical experience. The opening sequence is easily one of the best lead ins to the title. It’s as mentionable as Saving Private Ryan. The set pieces, wardrobe, camera work…everyone that had a hand in this film is a master of the craft. The JJ Abram’s lens flare is a bit overdone at times, but otherwise fits the style.

The acting and character selection is spot on. The dialogue, delivery, and inflections appear natural and never out of sort. The gratuitous scene with Kirk and Uhura (and friend) were a bit overripe, though still serves the Kirk/Trek trope.

The baddy was fine, the MacGuffin grounded, the threat worthwhile. All in all, it was a great origins story that connected the characters and didn’t make them feel wedged in. The follow up films didn’t do justice in continuing the vibe. But if I had to introduce someone to Trek, the 2009 film would be my go to.


r/startrek • • Sep 07 '25

Watching the Berman era Star Trek for the First Time - Dear Doctor might've turned us off of Enterprise entirely

0 Upvotes

Several months ago me and my boyfriend started watching Star Trek for the first time, in particular the Berman era (TNG - Enterprise)

Prior post on the subject:

https://www.reddit.com/r/startrek/comments/1jib1kq/first_time_watching_star_trek_trois_character/
For the most part we've been watching Voyager episodes, though we'll swing back to DS9 and TNG eventually. The series has a lot of really good episodes!
Unfortunately, our experience with Enterprise hasn't been so fun. We just got to the Dear Doctor (aka the one where Phlox is complicit in genocide and the episode ends with Archer doing a 180 and giddily agreeing with Phlox at the last minute) and it's so bad. I have no idea what the writers and producers were thinking greenlighting this script. Also, it feels like the writers of Star Trek fundamentally don't understand what evolution is.

Anyways - we really wanted to love Enterprise. We did see Regeneration before this (which was really good!), and maybe we'll revisit the show eventually. But man --- what a terrible episode xD

On a positive side --- we're *really* loving Voyager! I plan to write a full review when we're mostly done with the series!


r/startrek • • Jun 22 '26

I miss Discovery.

0 Upvotes

Of all the series I wish the most that they'd continued - Discovery and Enterprise.

Finishing a re-watch of all five seasons. Discovery was outstanding.


r/startrek • • Jan 21 '26

Why are new shows never given a chance?

2 Upvotes

I watched both episodes of Academy and made the mistake of going on YouTube the next morning. The amount of hate is ridiculous I rather enjoyed the show. But as brought up on What we left behind doc DS9 was hated in the beginning. Now I am not saying Academy is going to be the next DS9 but let's give it a chance.


r/startrek • • Aug 03 '25

Star Trek gay awakenings?

61 Upvotes

I was wondering if anybody here has had a lesbian/gay/bi/trans/other queer awakening thanks to a Star Trek character, actor, or maybe even plotline/episode? I'd love to hear your stories if you have any :)

For me, it wasn't so much a bi awakening as an affirmation of what I kind of already knew, but watching DS9 recently I was so enthralled by Jadzia Dax. I thought it was so cool she was a woman but also not, and that she didn't care about her lover's gender, and that she had a wonderfully weird taste in men anyways. I couldn't figure out if I wanted to be her or be with her.


r/startrek • • Jul 28 '24

Discovery Season 4 is a phenomenal example of what modern trek can be

0 Upvotes

Me wife and I have been binging the franchise in release order for... A while now. We're currently in the back half of discovery Season 4.

It's not perfect, idk that any trek is completely, but the improvement over its past seasons is massive. The character growth, better slower pacing, and interesting plotlines, all in a modern styled drama really make me happy.

Lower Decks is ok and earlier Discovery is alright, but it's nice to see a fresh, well done trek.


r/startrek • • Aug 03 '23

Star Trek Strange New Worlds has been great.... until the last 2 episodes Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Cartoons and musicals... no thanks

Until now they've done a great job on both seasons of making an interesting and dynamic show.

What I can't believe is that after stealing a Hitchhiker's guide style situation, an improbability fold, they decide to do a musical. Seriously.. that's all you could come up with?

Hate musicals, always have.

< / 3 Strange new worlds.


r/startrek • • Aug 31 '26

Was Star Trek Academy really all that bad?

0 Upvotes

To begin with, I get that any series revolving around youths is probably not going to work as well for older people, but...

  • I like that the main character has a small, unique skill set, but he's an idiot, wrong, and fumbles most situations at first.

  • I like that the secondary male character is a jerk but also has a point at least most of the time.

  • I like the hologram girl who struggles to adapt to human society-- but like Spoke or Data, it's not even so clear that anyone understands that there is something up with her.

Things I can kind of understand people not being all that up for

  • The main captain is just WAY too casual. Even if she says she is 300 years old, she reads as a normal human who somehow simultaneously resigned over passing an unfair sentence on a criminal and yet also has centuries of wisdom. The actress is fine, but this is a contradictory character.

  • We do have a couple of species show up that shouldn't show up. I don't think it is beyond reason for the remaining Jem Hadar to be cured enough that they could breed on their own and eventually use the same technology that allows humans and Vulcans to cross-breed to do the same. These are things that technically could have happened after the Dominion War. But there is one girl from a species in old Star Trek (the white on one side and black on the other) that we were told wiped each other out, and the sole remaining members were hundreds of years old. This also seems to me like... maybe declaring the whole species dead rather than their initial planet may have been an overstatement.

If I were really going to make any serious critique, I would have preferred this to be an animated series rather than a live-action one.


r/startrek • • Jan 25 '26

I’ve just started watching Enterprise and I’m enjoying it except for

2 Upvotes

That atrocious opening credit song. Skip it every time, what the hell is this crap?


r/startrek • • Nov 24 '16

Wow - so many Star Trek fans just want 3 white, middle aged men exploring space - I'm appalled.

45 Upvotes

I'm mildly shocked to see the veiled, casual prejudice on the forum today against first casting. Totally against the spirit of inclusion which the show itself personifies. I'm delighted with the first casting - screw the backward attitudes. You want three, middle aged white men? Thankfully the world has moved on.


r/startrek • • Jul 08 '25

What are your favorite LGBT+ Star Trek couples? Canon or otherwise

5 Upvotes

I assume there aren’t many but I like myself some Ships


r/startrek • • May 25 '26

I was mistaken about TOS

0 Upvotes

When I started watching the show, I was creeped out of my skin by the lechery, sexual harassment, and patriarchy oozing out of every scene (I thought this was supposed to be the ideal world where everyone was treated equally and with respect). It made me give up on the series and years later, I suffered through only watching the key episodes. I just didn’t get what was so good about TOS when I came from watching TNG and DS9 (and now LD has arguably joined their ranks with the exception of the last season).

Then Paramount+’s shitty recommendation queue finally made me aware that they had made movies with the TOS cast. And ooooh gosh, right from the first movie, I could totally see why it was quintessential Star Trek. ST V was utterly forgettable and had lots of elements more similar to Star Wars, but I’m still glad that I watched all of them. Kirk and Co. have more than redeemed themselves after the show, and after reading on this sub how creepy Gene Roddenberry was, I have more context. What a difficult era that must have been! And then Rick Berman happened 🤢

Edit: To all those protesting that it was woke for its time, I never disputed that. My only point is that it was unnecessarily sleazy. If there is sleaze and lechery that doesn’t even add to the story, I won’t watch it. Period. They got better about it in the movies, so I’m a fan of those.