r/startalk • • 25d ago

Meme

Post image
0 Upvotes

Just something funny my wife made that I had to share on here for some laughs


r/startalk • • Feb 11 '15

Neil deGrasse Tyson waxes poetic on ‘StarTalk,’ new Nat Geo talk show

Thumbnail
sciencerecorder.com
1 Upvotes

r/startalk • • Jun 20 '26

Please stop the lame drug jokes!

0 Upvotes

Every. Single. Episode. One of the hosts has to rehash a tired joke about weed/acid in response to a questioner or the guests.

I promise I am not clutching my pearls. It's just SO unfunny, and it derails the conversation because the guests never laugh at it.


r/startalk • • Jun 19 '26

AGE: SIX SEVEN

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/startalk • • Jun 27 '26

My thoughts on NDT and StarTalk changed, and I was a Tier-2 Patreon subscriber and I'm absolutely wrecked by it!

0 Upvotes

I loved the show but now I regret it. In fact, I was subscribed to StarTalk Signature.

NDT is literally a source of misinformation, and StarTalk is no longer a science show, they keep making unscientific jokes and it is really annoying. I am embarrassed I subscribed and became a member. I thought I would listen to a science show, now it's more of a comedic show with tons of misinformation.

In fact, he doesn't even understand complex topics. Like he doesn't even know Newton's law of cooling, ! He once even said "We don't use the term 'Law' in physics"; that's 100% false.

NDT is literally an egoist, arrogant person nowadays. He's good for wannabe learners who don't even have a wide-range area of knowledge, but the clown NDT literally acts like he's an expert in every field. He makes statements about artificial intelligence and biology, is that his field?

The rudest part of NDT is how he keeps talking over people!! Let the guests talk, Terence Tao was on the show and with Mercurio they kept talking over him like that's extremely rude to the guests. He did the same to Brian Greene and Charles Liu!

Why did I give $25 every month in a year to this clown who keeps bringing up Michio Kaku. He does a great disservice to physics and education by miscommunicating ideas and making people think "Physics is like a video game" while it's not!

The entire goal of NDT is to make listeners feel empowered that they know science, while in reality he ditches the complex topics like path integrals, wavefunctions, quantum gates, etc. He secretly uses the Dunning-Kruger effect and uses it fraudulently, by feeding individuals up with nonsensical content that tricks them into thinking their curiosity has increased, while in reality all he does is talk about elementary things and simplify huge topics into a small, packaged, neat and delicate format that isn't science, it makes listeners overconfident and falsely believe they are smart.

If you took a real test on the topics he talks about, 99.99% of people would fail it. For example, I'll give everybody on this sub a basic quantum computing problem, apply the Pauli-X gate to 1. Did anybody know the answer? Maybe some of you do, but of the millions of people watching the show, probably 1%. You see, science is very complex, it isn't that simple as he constantly says.

Anyone who is watching or listening to him should wake up and realize how complex and advanced science is. He's doing a great disservice to the field. Science isn't a circus. Don't subscribe or become a Patreon.


r/startalk • • Aug 13 '25

Chuck’s Joe Rogan Impression

0 Upvotes

Is perfect! Best cohost for an educational podcast. I kinda wish all the people in r/JoeRogan would give it a listen.


r/startalk • • 17d ago

Please explain this like I’m 5

Post image
0 Upvotes

How is almost 1 light year from earth, how do radio signals take 24 hours to transmit to earth?

I’m sure I’m missing something obvious, right?


r/startalk • • May 22 '26

Back in the day...

0 Upvotes

..and maybe now, when watching a sporting event, there was the "play-by-play" announcer ("Gain of five yards. First down") and the "color" announcer ("I haven't seen a pass like that since John Smith broke his ankle in the blizzard of '94.") ....I say all this so I won't be misunderstood when I say: I like listening to Tyson, but I can't stand the color guy. As soon as be opens his mouth, I close the tab. Just my 2 cents.


r/startalk • • Jan 11 '25

Did Neil, Chuck or Cara Santa Maria ever address the inappropriate intro in S2:EP15?

0 Upvotes

I was just getting into Star Talk after loving Neil's Cosmos many years ago and this put me so completely off him that it still leaves a bad taste in my mouth years later when I see or hear NGT. Was there ever an apology or anything like that to maybe put my mind more at ease? Or did noone really care or make a big deal about it?

For reference: https://startalkmedia.com/show/are-you-out-of-your-mind/ @ 3-4 minutes in.


r/startalk • • Aug 20 '25

Getting more content with the other co-hosts

3 Upvotes

I like Chuck's radio voice and how knowledgeable he has grown over the years but I'm so sick of the same repeated jokes about mispronouncing names and the accents. We have heard the same thing so many times and it probably eats about 2 mins out of every 48 min episode. It feels like Neil's over the top laughing is only to humor Chuck because there's no way it's genuine.

When Matt Kirshen or Paul Mercurio are the co-hosts it feels like a lot more questions are being answered


r/startalk • • Jun 03 '20

An idea about what could have happened before universe:

0 Upvotes

Hey chuck i know im not a patrion but i have this idea for a while and i need an approval by Neil. I'm from India 🇮🇳and i am literally diehard fan of this show . Please hear me out pleeeaaassee!!. I have an idea about what could have happened before big bang. Its gonna be long.

So we all have heard about that big bang happened from a singularity. A point source. And then it goes kaboom and here we have our univers after some 13 billions afterwards right!! But i think there might have been an universe before ours that have existed. But its been proved that universe is expanding. So how can singularity happen in that universe ! Well if we see experiments in hadron colliders we can recreate a universe tha lasts 10 to the power of negative 13 seconds . And we have seen that in that time temperature is through the roof that physical boddies cant really exist there. And to generate that much energy there must have been lot of things happening. But! If we calculate time like 10bil years as 1 sec as a perspective , and assume in the prev universe already passed its old stage and its stars are dying here and there creating blackholes. Those blackholes consuming other star systems. Then the giant blackholes inside galaxys are colliding with those blackholes. Then this way there would be way more black holes than normal stars and planets( dwarfs, neutron stars etc) And thus when there will be no other stars or plannets there. Only blackholes. Then those all black holes will colllide with each other creating a a super duper whoper giantass black hole😅 that cant hold its mass or energy but trying hard to become a singularity and den goes kaboom with giant explotion creating a new universe. Which is our universe as we know.

And i know this process to be possible it would take bazzilions of years and with all those tiny collision and explosions can also create new astro bodies; and also maybe some black holes or exoplanets and star systems can go missing in this singularity process but we have found a star older than our universe. I know its a very generalised idea but still.. ....we only know about 0.1 percent of univese .so can it be possible that universe is not really steady it's like a repeating process of dying and creating within a time period like a loop. I m looking forward your opinion Neil. U have been always been a good teacher to us with a brilliant view . I am highly looking towards u to enlighten me.. And if someone else interested in this please give it a like. 🙏🙏:-)


r/startalk • • Aug 21 '26

Good Neil! Don’t bagel boil your words like Sagan!!!

0 Upvotes

I read the Sagan on the origin of earth, I guess from the show. But now I’m on another one but it’s not Sagan I want to talk about. I don’t even know that I want to ask anything. But I have tones on my mind Neil. I have; reflective light and the molecules that refract different temperatures but the scale to represent this is, ok black; hot hot but not bright bright, that hot is absorbed, but why are tin foil toasters seems to flip my theory over wrong. Ok so your in black on black on a hot day you are dying in some cases, sand which is light picks up heat good, but if it were black, watch out, only if it’s wet!!! Sad sad there’s tears are cool. Whit jumpsuit on white surface your cooler, but really hard to look at with all the energy dissipating, no sorry Sagan, it’s seems I gotta read past the acknowledgement, but his conscious provoking images as oneself as an important male heir of earth is alienating.


r/startalk • • Sep 30 '26

Anyone else find this show just not funny and corny?

0 Upvotes

I just recently started listening to it and after like 1-2 shows I’m like I can’t do this anymore. For 2 big reasons. 1. They almost try too hard to act funny and cheesy. Like when a guest says a fact they’d be like “waaaaaat??!!” Or try to make a dad joke at every turn. I remember part of a fan question said “short and sweet” and Neil said something like “I’ll answer it long and bitter”. It’s like he’s trying so hard to make everything comedic.

2. It gets annoying when Neil, who’s background is in astrophysics to pretend that he doesn’t know something. Some of the facts that these guests bring up I feel like he probably already know and he acts like he doesn’t and acts all surprised and sometimes make jokes about it. It doesn’t feel like a scientist talking to a scientist but rather an uneducated YouTuber talking to scientists.


r/startalk • • May 26 '26

Paul Mecurio or Chuck Nice?

0 Upvotes

Who do you guys like more?


r/startalk • • 19d ago

The first half of the last AI episode felt like a sales pitch more than an actual informed interview

2 Upvotes

I was listening this: https://startalkmedia.com/show/the-game-theory-of-ai-with-aza-raskin/

and the guest was talking a lot about the dangers of AI and how powerful this technology is. He was literally regurgitating the same narrative these big AI companies have been pushing lately, and with the upcoming Anthropic IPO I find it very curious that they decided to make this episode right now.

I'm not saying the team at ST got paid to push this bs but still it feels like the first half of the episode was more of a marketing stunt.

Let me explain...

Aza was touching on some very true points when he mentioned that AI has got so powerful, and it can be used for lots of malicious attacks. However, there are three VERY VERY BIG elephants in the room here:

  1. Yes, AI breached secure systems. But those agents were given full control over their environment, no monitoring whatsoever. If they _were_ monitored, and people knew what they were doing and still allowed them to proceed, then that's a lawsuit waiting to happen. Aza described the scenarios kind of like a Skynet type of AI, but in reality it was just a tool used to parallelize lots of work, with full access to external software. Not some kind of self-conscious entity that took over the system.

  2. At some point, after all this talk about how extremely powerful and dangerous these AI agents are, Neil asked "but what if you just plug the servers off? Would that stop it?". Notice how Aza started panicing because after all that tough talk, it turns out that, YES. Yes, if you plug the servers off the AI agents are gone. Heck, cut the electricity, or the internet connection to the datacenters. They're gone. He tried to raise an argument about how these models can transfer their weights to other servers. I have never heard of this (I'm a software engineer btw), but even if that's true (and that's a BIG IF; that would happen, again if someone gave them access to a server somewhere that hosts their weights, which is also dumb as fuck), where the hell would they tansfer themselves? Petabytes of data where? Mobile phones? Gtfo. It would take them a shit load of time just to complete the transfer, let alone pass the accumulated context, build the harness to run themselves, etc. That is practically impossible, even if theoretically plausible. Aza was clearly looking for a way out, and since the guys there stopped pushing him immediately he found it. Finally, he mentioned that in about a **FREAKING YEAR** we would have models that are almost comparable to Mythos running in our kindles? Dude, no-fucking-body is taking you seriously here. You need a $5k machine to barely run a lobotomized 4bit quant of Qwen-3.8 27B, with [maybe?] 128K context, and at maybe 20tok/s. That is nowhere near Mythos levels, and that's with a very high-end PC. Your kindle can barely run its own operating system you clown.

  3. Again, he kept mentioning how powerful these models are. That is true. In some cases. Because as Ed Zitron said in an interview with Jon Steward: "If these models are so good, why don't they find a way to actually run their business?". If you look at the economics of AI, and how the landscape looks like, you'll see that AI in terms of profitable business is crealy a bubble. It's a circular economy, and all players in it are losing money so damn fast. Anthropic wants a bail out, and is gonna use retail investors to get it. _This is not financial advice btw, but use your brain when you handle your money folks_.

The rest of the interview was pretty cool tbh, it just felt wrong that Aza was there tryna sell snake oil to a group of people who clearly are not literate in computer science and software engineering, let alone AI engineering. I think Startalk should do better next time.


r/startalk • • Jul 06 '26

Was Hasan Minhaj the worst comedic cohost Startalk ever had?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

His jokes weee mid, Brian seemed to not like him LOL


r/startalk • • Jan 13 '21

Love the show, but...

17 Upvotes

Chuck Nice is very obnoxious.


r/startalk • • Feb 23 '21

RIP Stephen Hawking

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/startalk • • Jan 13 '15

Each episode will feature a short segment by none other than Bill Nye!

Thumbnail
engadget.com
3 Upvotes

r/startalk • • Jun 06 '26

Neil Degrasse Tyson is a source of misinformation.

Post image
0 Upvotes

I've compiled a list of some of Neil's wrong claims Fact checking Neil Degrasse Tyson There is more I could add.

Most of his misinformation is harmless. For example who cares if Neil tells his pseudo nerd fans there are more transcendental numbers than irrationals?

His wrong history is another matter.

When it comes to history Neil brings to the table a strong bias. Combine that with Neil's lively imagination and abysmal scholarship and you have Neil fabricating history to push his religion vs science narrative.

Items 2, 3, 4, 6 and 22 are examples of Neil's false history. I have yet to add Neil's false accusation against St. Augustine.

The three celebrity skeptics in the cartoon attended the 2006 Beyond Belief conference as well the 2010 TAM6 meeting.

In this video you can see Richard Dawkins in the audience seemingly very entertained by Tyson's performance at Beyond Belief. Neil and Richard met at this conference.

At both Beyond Belief and TAM6 Neil fed three steaming piles to the self proclaimed skeptics in attendance:

Neil's Bush and Star Names story.

Neil's story that Newton just stops when he cedes his brilliance to God.

Neil's story that Ghazali ends the Islamic Golden Age he he proclaims math is the work of The Devil

Most "skeptics" in this clique seem to endorse Neil Tyson and his impressive portfolio of misinformation. In 2022 Dawkins gave Neil the Dawkins award for his good work.

An actual skeptic habitually checks claims to see if they are supported by evidence. Any so called skeptic that swallows Neil's fictions have shown themselves to be as credulous AF.

Neil is greatest gift to apologetics in the 21st century. His Nagasaki class bull shit bombs have obliterated the credibility of his clique of pseudo skeptics.


r/startalk • • May 20 '25

Escape velocity question

0 Upvotes

Why do we need an explosion to escape earth gravity, why can we helichop out of orbit? I have an answer in my head, I just need someone to confirm it.


r/startalk • • Apr 07 '25

Pick up line help

0 Upvotes

I'm watching Star Talk TV on Amazon. Can't rewind or record. They title episodes in chunks, not individual episode. He and Chuck were talking about math pick up lines. The first was "Are you the square root of negative one?" Anyone know the other two? TIA


r/startalk • • 15d ago

BLACK OMEGA STAR!!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/startalk • • Jan 08 '15

Neil deGrasse Tyson Gets a Late-Night Nat Geo Talk Show (based off of Star Talk)

Thumbnail
hollywoodreporter.com
4 Upvotes

r/startalk • • May 03 '26

Are We Living in a Simulation?

Thumbnail
projectcredo.com
0 Upvotes

"Simulation Theory" comes up on StarTalk every so often.

It came up recently on S17E12 ("Cosmic Queries: Is the Universe a Math Problem?"), where a listener asks: Do we live in a simulation?

Neil and co. discuss the idea for a few minutes – but as always with these “cosmic queries” discussions, there isn’t much time to go into detail.

So, what exactly is simulation theory and why do so many people seem to believe it? Let’s dig in.

Bostrom’s Paper

The modern form of the simulation hypothesis comes from a 2003 paper by Nick Bostrom.

First, he argues that it should be possible to simulate consciousness.

Bostrom is talking sci-fi more than “real life,” rooted in known science but pushed to the extreme. If we had a computer the size of a planet, he concludes that we could simulate “the entire mental history of mankind.”

In other words, we could simulate every human brain to ever exist.

The Three Possibilities

This leads to three possibilities:

  1. No human-level civilizations reach this technological level. Either large-scale disaster (man-made or not) or technological stagnation could prevent this from happening.

  2. No human-level civilization at this tech level is interested in making such simulations. After developing to this level, human-level civilizations could simply lose interest in making these simulations. Maybe they’re too advanced to benefit, or think it’s cruel to simulate human-like minds.

  3. We are almost certainly living in a simulation. If 1) and 2) aren’t true, then it’s likely there are many simulations. If there are simulations within simulations, the number becomes truly huge (see image below). At this point, a simple count of “real” vs. simulated realities makes it almost certain we’re in a simulation.

Improving the Estimate

Bostrom basically compares numbers (real vs. simulated) to make his famous argument.

But there’s a slightly improved, Bayesian calculation that just puts us at just over 50% odds of living in a true reality. One key difference is assuming some limit to simulations within simulations – eventually, computing power runs out.

So toss a coin. If you call it right, maybe we’re real.

---

If you're keen to delve deeper into the actual source material, check out our post on Project Credo: https://projectcredo.com/posts/424

We're building Project Credo a space for "evidence-grounded" discussion – and StarTalk is our first community. If you have any feedback, we'd love to hear it!