r/starbound • • Apr 12 '14

Starbound development

I bought this game about 7/8 months ago and it showed great promise. I patiently put this game to the side to wait for the big features they were going to add to the game. So just a week ago i went on steam, enabled the unstable branch and started playing again. But to my suprise the game hasnt changed at all so i went to the starbounder website to check the updatelog to find out they mostly added hats and other cosmetic stuff. Where are the big gamechanging features? Where is all the cool stuff you promised to put in? After leaving my homeplanet and going through all the stuff i could craft, i felt extremely underwhelmed. I just went around planets collecting furniture and mining stuff from the surface. I have been very patient but this is not what ive paid for and not what they have promised.

I feel like the Starbound devs are more concerned about their own future than that of this game. To be fair after all this time of development this is all they come out with? I tried to put this as nicely as i could and i hope im not the only one thats not satisfied with some hats. Come on Starbound devs, we waited and waited and now we want some BIG changes and not some small tweaks.

1 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

26

u/Tiyuri Chucklefish Apr 14 '14

We are working as fast as is possible.

We have a finished game planned out and a quality requirement to meet.

Team is literally upending their entire lives to move to new country to speed up development in the long term and finish it faster overall at the cost of a short slow period of transition.

Progression work goes on behind the scenes because releasing it bit by bit will mean people playing through each new part very quickly.

At this point our goal is just to finish our game based on our vision, as long as that takes. And the longer it does take the more time, money and dedication it costs. It'd be great if we could finish it tomorrow but were in it for the long haul to make sure the game ends up the way we wanted.

The alternative to this is another rushed out game release that failed to meet its potential.

11

u/Savergn Apr 15 '14

Game takes long time to release = "Devs abandoned game, ran off with money, GG."

Game gets rushed out of door due to demand = "Shitty devs should have spent more time on game"

Honestly, I understand why the releases have slowed down and I'm perfectly fine with it. I know what I was getting into when I paid for a early access to a game that's being actively developed.

-3

u/Sondberg Apr 15 '14

Thats not really answering any of my concerns. If this is the pacing of development im afraid the game will not change much for the upcoming years. Seems like another game thats suffering the early access curse.

1

u/ragout Apr 16 '14

Team is literally upending their entire lives to move to new country

Did you read?

-6

u/Sondberg Apr 17 '14

This subreddit is a joke. I ask a very sensible question. They havent done shit the past year. Their internal issues/policies or moving offices does not concern me at all. This is just another game that seems to be never finished. This is not a AAA title. Even the modding community pumps out content faster then the people that according to you dedicate their life to this game. I didnt pay for a new office or to move their crew over. If i knew beforehand this was the case i would have never purchased this product. Another company that shits on your trust. Im out. Uninstall cba waiting for years to play an old gimmicky dated game. cya

10

u/starbounder_002 Apr 12 '14

I'm concerned about the way development is going at the least. Many features talked about as being late in progression such has ship development around February of last year, are still being worked on. Seemingly completely different from the near finished product shown then.

It would be nice to at least know what issues prompted the current seeming rework of the ship progression system and what currently remains to be done before the next update. As well hearing what they are doing to speed up development would be nice. Not just in generalities but as in what they have learned and are putting forward towards the continued production of the game in the coming year.

Here is hoping they can get rolling after such a good but somewhat slow start this year and pick up steam. :)

7

u/andreasblixt Apr 12 '14

I agree that the "pay for early access" model sucks. But not because it makes game developers suck. I see nothing wrong with the pace that Chucklefish is developing the game. Developing high quality games takes time. We're talking years for a game that looks good, works well, and has a good storyline.

I think the early access model sucks because the people paying feel entitled to faster progress. I won't argue whether the feeling of entitlement is right or wrong. It may very well be right. But what's important to know is that money does not speed up development. Money is there to ensure that development can go on for as long as it needs to. So in reality, throwing money at a project may make things take longer, but that's because more attention is spent on quality and detail. It's a mistake to expect the money to make it faster, and it's sad to see great games get rushed and lose quality because of this misconception. Even AAA games have suffered from this when publishers have been impatient.

So please, be patient. If you wish to pay for a finished project, maybe you can kindly ask for your money back and pay when the game is done. But have the humanity to respect the developers and encourage them to finish the game. Don't make them feel bad for putting extra effort into it, or taking the time they think they need. Don't be the reason they stop wanting to go in to work in the morning.

15

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '14

I feel like the Starbound devs are more concerned about their own future than that of this game.

Agreed. I gave them money to help get what they promised to us faster. But after 8 months of watching them use the money to buy offices/move workers to a new continent/fund other indies etc i am over Starbound. This game would have never released if we didnt pre-order. Its not the first early access game i have bought that failed to deliver... But it is definitely my last.

3

u/Korelle Apr 12 '14

I agree, this is honestly why I'm growing to hate the early access model. It's not as bad as Dean "Take the money and run" Hall, but it's certainly not filling me with promise.

-2

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '14

Yup. TIY is setting himself and the team up for life with that money, instead of finishing the game we FUNDED and using the PROFIT to fund his publishing business.

I haven't posted in this sub for months because every time this was brought up in the past we had the fanboys in here saying "its only beta" or "They are working as fast as they can" or "chucklefish are best devs ever, they communicate with us so much". Its a shame a dev cant talk a game into existence, or Starbound would have been the game to end all games.

16

u/renadi Apr 12 '14

Do you honestly think we've given the entire team a lifetime supply of money?

It takes a lot more than that to survive.

They are setting themselves up to easily continue creating games, including Starbound, they're far from set for life at this point, and they're being smart, they're investing in the future.

20

u/arcticblue Apr 12 '14 edited Apr 12 '14

Father of 2 small children here. Holy hell, life is expensive!

AFAIK, Chucklefish is a relatively small team and of course they don't work 24/7 so it's no surprise that major features aren't done all that quickly. I've never worked on a game, but I've done plenty of web development and I can say first hand that developing something that looks professional and gives a polished experience is not an easy task. I think their prioritities kind of got shifted around after they saw the huge number of people who paid for early access which they didn't quite expect. Seems like they bumped reworking the save files up to a high priority to keep people from getting pissed with every update and then they started adding content while working on the big features. Sounds like a good way to go in my opinion. I expect we'll get a major update soon-ish that implements lots of new features.

7

u/ZeroChaosXZ Apr 12 '14

Finally, someone with Sense is talking in this thread. thank you for your personal input on the subject.

To everyone else, remember, Just because you don't like it, doesn't mean they aren't trying.

12

u/GrimoireOfAlice Apr 12 '14

I am curious to know how exactly you think a game developer turns money into a game.

Because you seem to be under the illusion that it is some form of conversion process where money magically turns into game code.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '14

I am curious to know how exactly you think a game developer turns money into a game.

The reasoning was that they could quit their fulltime job and focus entirely on Starbound. Which they did, but the pace of development slowed down rapidly due to new offices.

We're financing the game out of our own pocket and a couple of our team members have had to take on second jobs. We're hoping the preorder will allow them to work full time on Starbound and get the game to you quicker!

3

u/GrimoireOfAlice Apr 12 '14

The reasoning was that they could quit their fulltime job and focus entirely on Starbound. Which they did, but the pace of development slowed down rapidly due to new offices.

Ever written code? I assure you it is not a consistent thing.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '14

Yes, I am a software developer (R&D) and know what to expect from my colleagues. And I have been following Bartwe's streams just enough to know his previous pace.

-5

u/GrimoireOfAlice Apr 12 '14 edited Apr 12 '14

And therefore I hope you realize that you only have "What Bartwe tells you" to go by, right?

For all you know they could have made rapid progress or no progress but your perception of this is solely based on what you are told and not what is.

-5

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '14

I am curious to know how exactly you think a game developer turns money into a game.

When they asked for money, They never mentioned they needed new offices and to relocate people to another continent. I supposedly funded a group of indy devs to finish making a game that they were already working on.

Because you seem to be under the illusion that it is some form of conversion process where money magically turns into game code.

Thats what they asked for the money for right? To finish the game. I, along with many others wouldn't have given them a single penny if i would have know they would use it to fund other indys and to buy a new office.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '14

What do you mean by "fund other indies"?

And buying a new office? No, they didn't "buy an office", they're likely renting it, and all game studios have office costs, if you didn't know that then tough luck, try researching into what you're spending your money on in future.

6

u/GrimoireOfAlice Apr 12 '14 edited Apr 12 '14

Thats what they asked for the money for right? To finish the game. I, along with many others wouldn't have given them a single penny if i would have know they would use it to fund other indys and to buy a new office.

No, they asked for money to make the game development a more stable thing. They implied the game would be finished no matter what money they gained. Source: http://playstarbound.com/store/faq.php

What baffles me however is why you think you're allowed to dictate what a company does with its profit. I know it's early to consider an unreleased game profit. But if you factor in how much it'd cost to pay the full teams wages for the rest of the year while also allowing for expenditures. I'd imagine they came out rather impressively in profit. And as a company they have a right to do whatever they want with that.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '14

You seem a bit ignorant over how games are made. Most of the Starbound devs were in multiple geographic locations, and now they're moving to one location in an office. All game studios need an office to make the game efficiently (don't try to sell me telecommuting), so a part of the cost of a game is to rent office, buy licenses, buy hardware, office equipment, legal fees. All of the boring shit that games need in order to be made.

Don't whine that they're improving the studio situation since a bad situation slows development down more than you can imagine. The game is still in development, they're moving the staff around and as such, development has slowed drastically.

If the game is still in this state in one year from now then I'll be pissed off too, but the sort of features that they're planning to add will take a good 5-6 months at least, and that's being optimistic.

To preface any responses, I am a professional game developer myself, so while I can't speak for Chucklefish, from what I can see they're going through a big transition right now and the people in this thread seem to be whining about the fact that games aren't developed as fast as they'd like.

8

u/duckmurderer Apr 12 '14

I would say that's an unfair POV, but I really don't know anything about you to be the judge of that. Are you familiar with the game development process? If you are, how exactly are you familiar with it; have you developed a game; has a friend or family member developed a game?

It's safe to say that, for me, I don't know. I don't know how hard it is or what sort of time/effort combination is required of developing core elements of a game. I know that a lot of games that get pumped out in a year aren't well received by me and many others. I also know that a lot of games that take too long to develop are lost causes. From my perspective, a well polished and well liked game takes an average of 5-6 years to develop. How long has Chucklefish been developing Starbound? At what point exactly in their development did they open up their game to early release sales?

Take Kerbal Space Program for example. For a long time the game was bland and stagnant. The only mode was creative, the only thing we did was build massive rockets with massive delta-v to take us all over the system. There wasn't much to it and that was the way it was for quite some time. But now they're further in the development process. They have a campaign mode. They have a research system. There's even a special mission! The game isn't complete, but the life of the game is starting to blossom.

To be blunt, who are we to judge chucklefish if we don't actually know exactly what they do all day in their office, if we don't see it for ourselves?

-2

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '14

To be blunt, who are we to judge chucklefish if we don't actually know exactly what they do all day in their office, if we don't see it for ourselves?

We are the suckers who paid for everything happening at Chucklefish(including the office you just mentioned). Thats who. Im not going to reply to your other part because it is the usual /r/starbound apologist copy/paste. "but look at castlestory.... and kerbal..They sucked too" is no excuse.

18

u/duckmurderer Apr 12 '14

23rd February

48 days.

That's 48 days since they've been focusing on the progression update. On this day, they spent 5 hours discussing exactly how progression in the game will pan out and how to implement it. Not long before that, they reworked the ship/character files so that you don't lose them with every single update.

This isn't being an apologist, this is being able to stop and think about it. They've shown that they are working on the game. Just because they can't work to your impatient time schedule doesn't mean that they stole your money.

This is why I asked if you knew anything about game development. I don't expect the meat and potatoes of a game to be developed in 1.6 months.

7

u/MagnorCriol Apr 12 '14

Thank you.

2

u/duckmurderer Apr 12 '14

You're welcome.

4

u/DoctorProbesalot Apr 12 '14

You consider yourself a sucker; That's an important distinction. And unless you ponied up several orders of magnitude more than a lousy 15 bucks, you essentially funded doodly squat for CF.

-2

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '14

You consider yourself a sucker; That's an important distinction

No shit sherlock, thats why i said WE. Very observant little fella aren't you? Care to add anything to the discussion or are you on Chucklefish defense mode?

And unless you ponied up several orders of magnitude more than a lousy 15 bucks

Yup, just as i thought, an apologist. I dont care about the amount of money, Its the principle of it. What would happen if we all chargedback our lousy 15 bucks? Thats right, They would be right where they started, except would have a mountain of debt from the new offices and relocation of dev team.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '14

[deleted]

-7

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '14

I'm sorry that you feel you've wasted your money. You should uninstall your copy and not donate another dime. We are all going to have fun with the new releases and continue to support Chucklefish on their path to making a great game with the knowledge that they will be able to put a roof over their heads while they work.

Good for you. Why dont you set up a direct debit for them too so they can have drinks on you?

7

u/ZeroChaosXZ Apr 12 '14 edited Apr 12 '14

"I feel like the Starbound devs are more concerned about their own future than that of this game."

No Shit. did you people forget this game is "Beta" or something?

Regardless there have been plenty of updates, such as Gravitational Pulls, Unique Biome Experiences, a BIG change in the way Worlds are edited so you do not continue to lose Universe Data every build, and a RECENT plan to change the combat system.

They have had great updates, just nothing you took the time to look in to. Or probably cared for honestly.

10

u/Professor_Retro Apr 12 '14

The level of entitlement and ignorance in this thread disgusts me.

1

u/Nolfinkol Apr 15 '14

Did you really think a small indie company is going to release a finished game only four months after the beta release? Be realistic here. According to Wikipedia, "Starbound was formally announced by Tiyuri in February 2012." It took them two years just to reach a stable, playable beta. Do you really believe that four months is all it takes to go from their placeholder beta gameplay to their true vision of the game? It took Minecraft almost a whole year to go from beta to what they considered a full game.

0

u/starbounder_002 Apr 15 '14

I would like to note I looked into this Nolfinkol. Please read: http://www.reddit.com/r/starbound/comments/22kbhn/chucklefishstarbound_a_timeline_showing_several/

Chucklefish not only announced it in 2012. They also announced full release in summer 2012. It has been over two years since.

You are correct it took them far longer to achieve beta, but I question why they where telling the press release was going to be in 2012 if that was the case? Again, this behavior is simply concerning at the end of the day.

While striving for vision is a good thing, perfection is impossible. Right now as it stands your example with minecraft in comparison is not a favorable one towards them.

0

u/Sondberg Apr 15 '14

There is something fishy about all this.

7

u/teisbist Apr 12 '14 edited Apr 12 '14

How do people not understand how businesses work? You sell a product, people buy it, and then you have some money. Some gets reinvested back into the product to make it better, some gets invested into other projects for your company, some gets invested into new employees. This is not a new concept. It's how businesses have worked since businesses have been a thing.

Starbound didn't happen on Kickstarter, where it would be extremely bad form to throw money at things like an office. No one "invested" in Starbound/Chucklefish. You ordered or pre-ordered a product of theirs and gave them money. That money is theirs to spend as they please.

This self-entitlement shit needs to stop. I want Starbound to be finished as much as anyone but it's just insane to expect them not to operate like a business.

9

u/Koomban Apr 12 '14

There is a fundamental disconnect between what Chucklefish has demonstrated wanting (creating a game studio, publishing new games, creating new games) and what we, the investors deserve. On the pre-order page, it's stated that:

Your purchase will go directly towards the development of the game and help us to get it into everyone's hands sooner.

Unfortunately, when people have expressed concerns, Tiy's response is:

Honestly how we spend our money is none of your concern.

We're at the point where Chucklefish is so sensitive that any criticism, even if it's well-reasoned and worded is banned for on the forums or deleted/strawmanned to be the same person here on this subreddit. When the concerns grew too large to be ignored the last week, minor tweaks that Tiy even admitted only took a few hours were pushed to placate people but they didn't do anything but make combat even more broken. The other daily blogposts are just restarting what they said they'd do months ago. People are so desperate for change that the new hire was met with a lot of fanfare, but when you take a step back and look at the statement, it's more of the same: restating old progress/promises, and promising that more is to come "soon."

There's no reason to trust these developers.

2

u/GrimoireOfAlice Apr 12 '14

Fairly sure it is none of your business how a company spends their profits.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '14

Unfortunately, when people have expressed concerns, Tiy's response is:

Unfortunately? No, he's right. It is none of your business how they spend their money. It is actually their money.

We've been promised just one thing, a finished game called "Starbound", not the right to decide how they spend their money, nor the right to dictate the games design, nor the right to be involved in the game making process, just the game.

We're at the point where Chucklefish is so sensitive that any criticism, even if it's well-reasoned and worded is banned for on the forums or deleted/strawmanned to be the same person here on this subreddit

What's more likely is that they're at the point where they can't afford or be bothered to moderate highly controversial topics that are likely to result in low quality discussion.

Have you ever moderated a forum? Everyone acts like an entitled child that screams about freedoms and some foreign constitution whenever they get banned, as if the moderators are held to the standards of some government. Deleting topics that cause that sort of behaviour is the best way of keeping the forum from becoming a cesspit.

PS. We're not investors. We're customers.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '14

[deleted]

5

u/autowikibot Apr 12 '14

Investor:


An investor is a person who allocates capital with the expectation of a financial return. The types of investments include: gambling and speculation, equity, [debt](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bond_(finance)) [securities](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Security_(finance)), real estate, currency, commodity, derivatives such as put and call options, etc. This definition makes no distinction between those in the primary and secondary markets. That is, someone who provides a business with capital and someone who buys a stock are both investors. An investor who owns a stock is known as a shareholder.

====

Image i


Interesting: Angel ^investor | ^Investment | Collective investment ^scheme | Gold as an ^investment

Parent commenter can toggle ^NSFW or ^delete. Will also delete on comment score of -1 or less. | FAQs | ^Mods | Magic ^Words

1

u/chook0 Apr 13 '14

We pre-ordered a game that was supposed to be feature complete by the end of 2013. Toady doesn't need an office to work in. Cactus doesn't need an office to work in. We're not here to support Chucklefish into developing into EA. We're here to make sure they finish the game they said they'd finish.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embezzlement

1

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14

You're acting like they're off buying Ferrari's and Blow to snort off hookers asses with the 15$ you helped fund a Work In Progress game into eventual completion.

Give it a rest. They're using the money to invest in the future of their company. Not that I'm white-knighting them, I want my game, but the difference is I'm not going to sit here and throw out outrageous claims of embezzlement, or other shady goings-on at Chucklefish.

Having said all this, the stance their taking of basically "mind your own business" in regards to money spent, would probably have been a moot point if they didn't advertise what they were spending money on..

"Look at our office!" when the games not done, is basically throwing gas on a fire.

0

u/autowikibot Apr 13 '14

Embezzlement:


Embezzlement is the act of dishonestly withholding assets for the purpose of conversion (theft) of such assets by one or more individuals to whom such assets have been entrusted, to be held and/or used for other purposes.

Embezzlement is a kind of financial fraud. For instance, a lawyer could embezzle funds from clients' trust accounts, a financial advisor could embezzle funds from investors, or a person could embezzle funds from his or her spouse. Embezzlement may range from the very minor in nature, involving only small amounts, to the immense, involving large sums and sophisticated schemes.

More often than not [citation needed], embezzlement is performed in a manner that is premeditated, systematic and/or methodical, with the explicit intent to conceal the activities from other individuals, usually because it is being done (by the perpetrator) without the other individuals' knowledge or consent. Often it involves the trusted individual embezzling only a small proportion or fraction of the total of the funds or resources he/she receives or controls; in an attempt to minimize the risk of the detection of the misallocation of the funds or resources. When successful, embezzlements continue for years (or even decades) without detection. It is often only when a relatively large proportion of the funds are needed at one time; or they are called upon for another use; or, when a major institutional reorganization (the closing or moving of a plant or business office, or a merger/acquisition of a firm) requires the complete and independent accounting of all real and liquid assets; prior to, or concurrent with, the reorganization, that the victims realize the funds, savings, assets or other resources, are missing and that they have been duped by the embezzler.

In America, embezzlement is a statutory offense so the definition of the crime varies from statute to statute. Typical elements are (1) the fraudulent (2) conversion (3) of the property (4) of another (5) by a person who has lawful possession of the property.

  • Fraudulent: The requirement that the conversion be fraudulent means simply that the defendant wilfully and without claim of right or mistake converted the property to his or her own use.

  • Conversion: Embezzlement is a crime against ownership; that is, the owner's right to control the disposition and use of the property. The conversion element requires a substantial interference with the true owner's property rights (unlike larceny, where the slightest movement of the property when accompanied by the intent to deprive one of the possession of the property permanently is sufficient).

  • Property: Embezzlement statutes do not limit the scope of the crime to conversions of personal property. Statutes generally include conversion of tangible personal property, intangible personal property and choses in action. Real property is not typically included.

  • Of another: A person cannot embezzle his own property.

  • Lawful possession: The critical element is that the defendant must have been in lawful possession of the property at the time of the fraudulent conversion and not have mere custody of the property. If the defendant had lawful possession the crime is embezzlement. If the defendant merely had custody, the crime is larceny. Determining whether a particular person had lawful possession or mere custody is sometimes extremely difficult.

====

Image i


Interesting: 2011 Iranian embezzlement ^scandal | Last Will and ^Embezzlement | ^Theft | Political ^corruption

Parent commenter can toggle ^NSFW or ^delete. Will also delete on comment score of -1 or less. | FAQs | ^Mods | Magic ^Words

3

u/Ebkrem Apr 12 '14

I've long decided that the content I am going to enjoy most with Starbound is going to come from community mods. Some parts of Chucklefish's vision of Starbound are not my cup of tea, but it is their game to create. What I don't like, mods exist to alter/supplement.

What I want to see is transparency and inclusion. Sometimes, yes, this is going to be missed deadlines. I know from experience that programming doesn't mesh with deadlines, but communicating this is important. Basically more "this is where we're at, this is where we're going" and less "X feature will be in Y update" with or without a timeframe. A lot of people seem to want the latter, but development just doesn't work that way.

Just, please, please give modders tools to do what they want to do. The mod format is already fantastic in terms of the community.playstarbound.com site & installing & making it easy for the end user. There are simply only so many things modders can do without the coding to hook into what they want to work with.

Having open & relaxed environments for mod devs to provide their works is far better than the inherently slow process of making a mod native.

4

u/Fluury Apr 12 '14

Wait what?

I personally consider monster changes as a big update, it could be worse.

5

u/CrashmanX Apr 12 '14

Claim to wait 7/8 months. Expect entirely new features. It's only been 5 months.

-2

u/starbounder_002 Apr 12 '14 edited Apr 22 '14

You need to reread his post. He said he -bought- the game several months ago and is unsatisfied with progress since his purchase. Then they just checked back in recently.

His statement is true unless you know the gentleman only purchased it five months ago? Edit: To be clear, Chucklefish has posted what they have been doing/gotten done, for well over a year now. His claim is perfectly legitimate to have been waiting that length of time, regardless of when the beta was released.

4

u/Industrialbonecraft Apr 12 '14 edited Apr 12 '14

Oh look, an indie studio trying to pay their bills and ensure they can keep developing a game? HOW DARE THEY! This is just ridiculous entitlement.

Or do you just not have any concept of development? They're not a big team, this project is pretty ambitious, and it's going through multiple revisions. Including some of the major features of the game - like the combat which go overhauled early on, and is currently being overhauled. That's pretty damn big and time consuming. You got this in early access. What did you expect? You're not going to get a finished product in four months. If you didn't want to play an unfinished game, you shouldn't have paid for one.

Stop whining.

3

u/duckmurderer Apr 12 '14

They announced the new progression path, like, two months ago. Be patient, padawan.

If you didn't want to buy an unfinished game then you shouldn't have.

1

u/ZeroChaosXZ Apr 12 '14

This.

2

u/thisthatbot Apr 12 '14

that

Hi! I'm a bot that replies to "this" with a "that". Please message my ^^^^^^^creator if there's a problem.

4

u/ZeroChaosXZ Apr 12 '14

I like this bot.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '14

This again?

1

u/Kinasin Apr 12 '14

Truthfully it seems like the Dev's are off in lala land. It doesn't even seem like they are working on the game.