I will be covering a few topics today:
Napoli is at an inflection point, what does that mean and what does that look like
Napoli’s Financial situation
Guintoli & Spalletti and the De Laurentiss cancer
My predictions on what’s next based on where we are today and what we know
A warning to everyone before reading, I have never been a supporter of De Laurentiis, however I do respect him, I do acknowledge what he has accomplished, and despite my opinion on him being that he is not a good owner for Napoli and is to be blamed for what is about to happen over the next few months, I also give him credit & praise for not only putting us in a position to win a Scudetto but more importantly how he did so.
First I would like to get out of the way three points which I am sure will be thought and made by someone. 1. We just won our first scudetto in 33 years let’s just enjoy this and worry about next season in the offseason- yup got it, I have been celebrating for weeks, but I like to look into the future too. 2. DeLa is our guarantee, no matter who leaves, he will ensure we will be good – sure, but as the title of this post says, we are at an inflection point, we have won something now, being “good” isn’t “good enough” 3. We don’t know anything yet, it’s just speculation – eh I live, breath and eat Napoli, there are rarely surprises with this club, we are being told what is happening indirectly through Dela’s & Spalletti’s words and by looking back at the history of DeLa’s reign, the situations keep repeating themselves.
This will like likely be an unpopular opinion but while I respect DeLa, deep down I don’t think he cares much about winning, he is a business man more than an owner. Now, with that said, he is one of the best businessmen we have in the sport. The fact that a team of Napoli’s caliber and with the players that have passed through this club and are on this club, have their image rights owned by the team and not to themselves is remarkable. His innovative deal with EA7 was a stroke of genius, from a margin’s perspective Napoli is the team that makes the most profit from a kit sponsor over any other team in the league. From a business perspective, Dela is a genius and head and shoulders one of the best in the sport.
However, he is not one that is “obsessed” with winning. He is obsessed with generating revenue, which is why a top 4 finish has been and will always be his central goal. The biggest challenge Napoli the soccer team, and Napoli the organization have is, in my very unpopular opinion, is DeLa.
I can make a much longer post about this, but the bridges this guy burns from Mazzarri, Higuain, Mertens, Maggio to Allan and now with Spalletti is our biggest Achilles heel.
Napoli are at an Inflection Point:
The team has finally won, and it is in this very moment that the club can write it’s future. Do they take the leap up and build upon this very rich foundation that they have right now or do they remain who they are, a provincial club who always tries to win, but focuses more on the balance sheet, which naturally puts them in this perpetual cycle of selling top players, pissing off coaches, and making low risk “bets”.
I admire DeLa for how he has gotten us to this point in regard to financial management, but operating the same way will not bring us ahead, it can only set us back.
I am not saying that he needs to go out and buy €100 million euro players, or have the highest pay role of the league. However, what I do believe is that at this inflection point, if you want to make a leap up and not take a step down, you need to replace (some) of the pieces you loose with pieces that have proven they are better, not with ones that you are taking a “bet” that they could be. Last year we took this bet, with Kim, Kvara, Raspa and Simone. And it worked, but when we are also losing the guy who made those “bets” Giuntoli and who upskilled those “bets” Spaletti. It is difficult to have fate that we will catch lightening in a bottle twice.
The inflection point has two paths forward, and this is what they look like.
Operating Napoli as DeLa always has; this would look like losing Giuntoli, Spalletti, Kim, Osi, selling Lozano and Zielu. Replacing these pieces how we did in the past…
We lost Bigon we bring in someone who was a good Sporting Director in the lower level, who was Giuntoli. This worked out for us
We lost Ancelotti, we bring in Gattuso someone with no proven success and won nothing.
We lost Allan we bring in Tiemoue Bakayoko
We lost Inler we bring in Mirko Valdifiori
We lose Lavezzi we bring in Omar El kaddouri
We lose Ospina we bring in Sirigu
We lost Jorginho and Hamsik in the same season we bring in Ruiz and Diego Demme
We lost Higuain we bring in Milik & Pavoletti
Yes, we also brought players like Higuain to replace Cavani, we brought in Koulibaly to replace Paolo Cannavaro, Zielinski to replace David Lopez, Albiol to replace Dossena, Pepe Reina to replace De Sanctis, Callejon & mertens to replace Edu vargas.
Those players turned out to be studs for us, but aside from Higuain & maybe Reina, everyone else was a “bet”. A bet that worked out very well, but to be honest, it was only in that summer of 2013 when Benitez came that we actually went out to get household names. Normally, this is not how Napoli operates. HOWEVER, when they went outside of the norm of how they operated, brining in a coach who maybe wasn’t tactically great, but could attract names… They made a leap.
The other side of the inflection point could sort of look like that summer of 2013.
And not I don’t mean brining in Rafa again, Rafa was brought in for clout and reputation, to make us more international, and to try and convince the likes of Higuain, Abiol and Reina that if someone of Rafa’s stature is choosing Napoli, maybe they are worth giving a shot to.
10 years later, this would look different…. But if Napoli want to make a leap up at this inflection point they need to make moves that look like … *note I am not suggestion these actual people I am giving an illustrative example of the caliber
Replace Guintoli with the likes of: Leonardo, Sebastian Kehl (of Borussia) or Roberto Olabe (of Real Sociedad)
Replace Spalletti with Zidane, Conte, Nagelsmann, Diego Simone … Someone that players would want to come to Napoli to play for
Replace (some) of the players like Osi, Kim, Lozanom zeilu with the likes of Marco Asensio (out of contract) or go out and bring in someone like Fati who is struggling on barca on loan. Replace these players with players who have proven to be good, to be able to contribute on big team, instead of paying €40 million for Fratessi who has not proven himself on any stage yet, and is yet another “bet”. I know Napoli can’t do this with everyone, but if you are losing Stars, you need to bring Stars in. Last year was an anomaly, we lost proven players who some would call stars and brought in bets that developed into stars quickly. But now that we won, we need to operate differently.
And Napoli Can afford to do this, Let’s start with the financials:
Revenue: These are relatively accurate estimates but Napoli this season has needed about €78m from champions league and will net about €24 for winning the league. This is not accounting TV rights income from the league (last year it was 90 million), Revenue from sponsors, commercial & royalties, and remember Napoli owners players image rights. (last year this was 37 million) and then other revenue such as ticket sales / merch (last year this was about 14 million). I think it is safe to say that TV rights, commercial rights, and ticket sales and mech will all be higher, but for the purposes of this exercise lets keep last years numbers.
Competition Revenue: €102 Million
Tv rights: €90 million
Sponsors /Commercial rights: €37 million
Tickets/mech: €14 million
Estimated total income: About €243 million ( and this is with last years numbers and with sale of players)
Expenditures
2023 Players’ & Coach salaries (without bonuses) is about €80 million
Now a look at the transfer market transactions that already already agreed upon.
Napoli Owe
Napoli will receive
So let’s just say from a financial state point, Napoli isn’t just in a “healthy” position, they are probably in the best financial position they have ever been in the history of the club.
Even if they didn’t sell anyone, having brought in and estimated €243 million this season and having about €80 million in salary obligations for next year, €28 million owed out for the purchases of Simone & Raspadori…. Napoli have a cool €100 million they can spend in transfers and still be in the green.
However we know this isn’t happening, but let say BEING VERY VERY CONVERVATIVE they only sell Kim, Zielu and one between Lozano and Politano… those three players alone could bring in €100 million.
I am giving this financial picture because the club has the resources to operate differently than they have in the past, which has traditionally been: formulating a budget based on the earnings from sales in that season and going after players who are “bets” low cost because they have established themselves as top players yet, who are young and often not coming from Top clubs.
I have always respected DeLa for how he balances the books, *remember he is a business man not an owner* and he has been applauded worldwide in the world of football for how he has steered this club financially up until this year. While other teams, especially in Italy, have been in perpetual financial trouble ( i.e. Inter, Milan, Roma) or complete cheaters (Juventus), Napoli has been able to operate like a provincial club (i.e. Atalanta, Sassuolo, Fiorentina) but out preform like a big club.
However this year it needs to change, it must. Napoli find themselves in a financial situation that is drastically different than years past, they can’t operate entirely like a provincial club. Most of the bets they have made in the past 2-3 years have paid off in droves: Kvara, Elmas, Di Lorenzo, Frank, Rrahmani. However some have not, just to put something in perspective, Diego Demme & Politano are the 6th & 7th highest paid players on Napoli respectively.
This year we need to shell out the money.
Giuntoli and Spalletti:
Giuntoli:
They are both out, to me (my opinion) Giuntoli is the bigger loss here, by a long shot. Working for DeLa is not easy, taking a look at his track record almost every coach or D.S. ( what Giuntoli is and basically equates to a GM in American sports), have left Napoli in bad terms. In addition to the a pleatora of players: Milik, Higuain, Allan, Mertens, etc.
Working for DeLa is hard, he has a lot of rules In place, he owns your image rights, and at the end of the day, he wants & needs to be star of the show.
To that end, Giuntoli was perfect for Napoli in this regard because he actually doesn’t want to be in the spotlight and prefers to operate in the background. Add to that he knew exactly how to execute Napoli’s strategy (buy low & young, try and sell high). He will be a big loss for the club, but I will say he was not perfect.
He knew how to buy low & young, how to scout well. but when it actually came to selling players and getting a little bit above market value ( like a good D.S. does) he wasn’t able to execute. Ruiz for €23 million ( when he was in the prime of his career at 26 years old we probably could have gotten more), Milik at 27 years old for €8 million the same, Manolas who we paid €40 million for and then selling him for €2.5 and he wasn’t even 30 years old yet.
He could have done better with those sales, and I know what many of you will say, these players were on expiring contracts and yes you are right, but we could have still gotten more.
You know what the problem was? All of them had issues with DeLa and DeLa had issues with them, so they became cancerous in he locker room and had to get out.
So losing Giuntoli will be tough, but what we can’t do is replace him with someone else who has only had experience in lower leagues such as the guy who is in the front running now Ciro Polito the D.S. for Bari, who has only been at Bari, Ascoli and Juve Stabia.
I know what you are thinking… why not? It worked with Giuntoli, we trust DeLa!
But this is the problem, if Napoli is going to make a jump to be an elite organization they need graduate from compiling a roster and management team that are all “bets”. That strategy was amazing, and it worked, we won! But it’s time to take that leap.
However, I have very little fate that Giuntoli will be replaced with anyone notable, the person in that role needs to be someone who is ok not only riding in the backseat of the car the DeLa is driving, they need to be ok with being in a completely different car. DeLa is the boss here, he needs to be the star of the show at all times.
Spalletti
Here is what I will say, Spalletti leaving is the perfect manifestation of Napoli’s problem. He is in love with the city, he has a roster that is extremely strong, he is at a club that is very healthy financially, yet he still wants to leave and will.
Why? Some will say, “He want’s to leave a winner” but the way Napoli is currently constructed the have one of the best foundations for sustained success. Even if we lose Kim, we net €60 million + all the cash we have from this years winnings, and you are telling me that if we take the revenue from Kim, allocate another €60 million from our winnings (about 25% of the total). That is an €120 million transfer budget to go out an get a Kim replacement and strengthen a few other parts of the team. (and this is not taking into consideration the revenue generated from the players we sell in said positions we are upgrading).
You are telling me that if DeLa went to Spalletti and said: I won’t sell any key pieces you don’t want to lose (Osi, Kvara, Lobo, whoeverelse), I have to sell Kim, but will giving you this team + a transfer budget of €120 million, plus and 3 year contract so you can continue to build upon this team…. You are telling me A) This team couldn’t be very competitive in Italy and Europe AND B) Spalletti would still want to leave?
No, please guys don’t be fooled. It is very clear why Spalletti is leaving, firstly DeLa is DeLa and has made everything about him again, has disrespected Spalletti and just like every other coach… ruined the relationship.
In addition; the handwriting is on the wall… he is going to cash in. He will sell anyone he can, and replace them with other “bets” the difference is this time he can tell the fan base, hey I did it before and we won, I am doing it again, and you will regret questioning me.
All this is heartbreaking as a die-hard fan. Don’t get me wrong, while I am upset and worried about losing Giuntoli, and much less so upset about having a new coach. I am not upset about Spalletti leaving, I am infuriated about what this actually means for the club.
There has been only one time, that DeLa has brought in a manager or coach that you could categorize as “Proven” was Carlo Ancelotti and we saw how that worked out, so of course he going to go with another “bet”.
Before you guys come for my head saying Rafa was also proven, I say that is questionable aside from the Liverpool spell and maybe Valencia early in his career…. He has been kind of a mess and a stop gap coach at best. Yes he won the European league with Chelsea in 2012 but that was a squad that should have been competing for something more, and even they understood that Rafa was medicore at best… he won the European league as an interm coach and they still replaced him – tells you everything you need to know.
So now what? What’s next based on what we know today?
Guintoli and Spalletti are 100% out, if one or both go to Juventus that will be the biggest F* you to DeLa, and while I do think it’s petty and completely disagree with the notion of keeping them both out work for a year because of contractual obligations. If I were DeLa I would only let them go and release them of the clauses to teams outside of Italy. This is just good business, especially Guintoli, there is too much knowledge on Napoli’s transfer strategies that he could bring to Juventus or any other Italian club and really set us back seeing that we are likely going to sell big pieces and don’t have a Sport Director yet.
With that’s said, my prediction is that Guintoli will be at Juventus next season, and to be honest I wouldn’t be surprised if Spalletti could follow, although I could also see him going to the EPL or taking a year off.
We will bring in the sporting director from Empoli or Bari and be sold the same bullsh*t, that it worked before bringing in a sporting director from a provincial side and it will work again.
In regards to the coach: I see someone like Vincenzo Italiano from Fiorentina or a Thiago Motta from Bologna maybe even a Pallidino from Monza. Basically another “bet”
This will inevitably set the team back, not because these guys are bad sporting directors or coaches, but because Napoli are at an inflection point. If they really wanted to keep their top players, attract other top players, and challenge for the champions league like DeLa keeps saying…
Who do you think current and future players are going to want to play for more? A pairing of Ciro Polito and Thiago Motta? Or a pairing of Leonardo and Diego Simone ? (not saying it should be these two it’s just an example of a pairing that holds esteem around Europe)
It’s a damn shame, Napoli are at such an inflection point, a point where they could really make a leap, where they can set a foundation for a winning culture after having finally won.
However I have zero fate in this, Spalletti leaving tells us everything we need to know, this team will be dismantled, a week ago when I was sure that Spalletti was going to stay even though Giuntoli was out, I was very convinced that Osi was going to stay another year, and the only significant player we were going to lose was Kim.
However now, Osi will be out, Kim will be out, Zeilu and Lozano too, and I wouldn’t be surprised if someone like an Elmas left.
These guys will be replaced by players we never heard of, coached by someone who is past his prime (Rafa) or someone who only coached in the lower ranks (italiano).
We will revert back to hoping for a top 4 finish, and be told by DeLa that he is our Osi, our Spalletti, our Kim.
Before anyone comes for my head about how great DeLa has been for Napoli and there are much worse owners out there, let me say again. I recognize what he has accomplished for us, and once again what was remarkable was how we did it.... But he is the problem.
Every player that leaves has a problem with him, every coach that leaves has a problem with him. It is such a shame