After stepping out of my comfort zone following roughly 1900 hours of LRP, and maybe 100 of MRP I finally bit the bullet and tried something I’d never done before: I committed the crime of checking out an NSFW server; Euphoria Station. I was shocked by how much character customization they allow. They have something like 500 different markings and 13+ races. It felt great to finally have more control over my character than just choosing their skin color.
Then I wondered why no LRP server offers a similar level of customization. And it hit me: some LRP players absolutely dismiss that kind of quality as "furry slop." Certain things, especially roleplay related ones get written off as “furry slop” without a second thought. I believe this is one of the reasons only NSFW servers have high pop on r/ss13. People who genuinely wanted that “furry slop” were alienated by the main community and migrated to more accepting places... They just happened to be NSFW. People in LRP SS13 made poor design choices their aesthetic and I can see LRP SS14 going the same way. The shitcode, the constant broken antags, total lack of unique crew content (especially on Trauma which is busy adding 32094729 way antag can explode everybody with their mind and a public hangings) is becoming an aesthetic of failure, of silly coders and incompetent "goida" mods, terrible medical personnel that doesn't want to deal with woundmed and much more things that usually would be considered detrimental.
I remember once saying that Traumastation could use more races, even if they don't have unique gimmicks and somebody told me it's "quantity over quality approach". Then I said that it's both quality and quantity to have more customization options and they didn't even replied to me.
On MRP this is generally not the case. Sure people can be more oversensitive (i got banned after 2 rounds of Euphoria for telling a borg who was trying to kill themselves to "do it" because it's "suicide roleplay and some people have <quoting admin> "trama") but this is exactly what happens if you alienate people who don't want public hangings in the game. MRP players are genuinely the victims of SS13 ERP PTSD. Wizard's Den LRP was the original mainstream entry point for English-speaking SS14, but I don't think upstream did nearly enough to keep the MRP crowd interested in the game. Instead of developing mechanics, content and systems that would naturally encourage roleplay, it increasingly relied on social structures like whitelists and player groups. Those turn into metacliques, where being part of the community becomes more important than the actual roleplay experience.
Consequently, alternative servers that offered more creative freedom, character customisation and dedicated roleplay content became associated with ERP. LRP players don't want features associated with MRP like character customization or the "looks at" emote because they are the true spessman who carry the flame and those bad MRP "chuds" are bad and just wait to turn your favorite server into a liar of carnal pleasure.
Tldr; SS13/SS14 have developed an association between certain types of game design and certain types of players to the point where otherwise cool features become culturally unacceptable.