KIRKPATRICK SALE
- «Human Scale» (1980)
- «Rebels Against the Future» (1995)
- «Human Scale Revisited» (2017)
A comment
Interesting ideas about “decentralism” despite Sale’s neo-Luddite framework. We could draw a distinction with a more open concept of “technological decentralism”. Sale’s vision imposes clear limits (comprehensible scale, local control, low dependency, repairability, and non-disruption of existing relationships), and these limits are incompatible with the dependencies of industrial digital infrastructure (digital industrialism/gigantism) and the logic associated with blockchain technology.
I wonder: could a tokenized community or movement that seeks to update the consensus of value in favor of society and the emancipation of people, outside the dominant traditional system, be perceived as a form of “human-scale” technology despite its magnitude and its dependencies?
However, it is not necessary to force Sale’s framework. It may be more useful to distinguish a more open “technological decentralism” (understood as the capacity to coordinate value, information, and cooperation outside traditional intermediaries) and to analyze it on its own terms. The question then shifts: what concrete conditions would a tokenized community need to meet so that its pursuit of a consensus of value outside the dominant system (perceived as broken or rigged) effectively contributes to people’s autonomy and to real forms of cooperation, rather than merely generating new abstractions or speculative dynamics?
There are interesting intersections between these components and other ongoing disruptions (artificial intelligence, automation, transformations of work and value). In the case of the SPX6900 community, what stands out is the emphasis on a shared spirit and the desire to transcend the merely digital through connections and possibilities of cooperation.
For that aspiration to hold with rigor, it is necessary to examine the actual practices closely: the real degree of control exercised by participants, the existence of bonds and activities that do not depend exclusively on the token’s dynamics, the relationship between the agreed-upon value and tangible needs or projects, and the community’s capacity to resist or modulate the logics of concentration and speculation that typically accompany these systems.
Ultimately, the interest does not lie in forcibly fitting these initiatives into Sale’s concept of “human scale”, but in using that concept (and other frameworks) as a critical lens to assess the extent to which a tokenized community succeeds, or fails, in generating more autonomous, comprehensible, and grounded forms of coordination and value.
Everything is questions.
Personally, this resonates with me: being connected by every possible means and combining all possibilities of cooperation around a shared mission/objective: FLIP THE STOCK MARKET (by internet, land, sea and air)
6900>500 💹🧲