r/spacex • u/BEAT_LA • Feb 02 '26
r/spacex • u/Intro24 • Apr 12 '17
[Discussion] ITS Funding Theory: US Military Deployment
I'm starting to think that SpaceX's big play for making ITS a reality might be to get the government to invest in it for military purposes first and science later. A militarized ITS might work like this:
BFR stands at the ready whenever it looks like US intervention might be needed
BFR launches within an hour of getting green-lit (weather permitting)
The booster returns and the spaceship part takes 45 minutes at most to arrive anywhere in the world
Spaceship lands with like 300 troops or 7 Abrams tanks. The tanker variant is supposed to be able to take 380 tonnes to LEO so I'm thinking suborbital could be around 450 tonnes
Spaceship unloads and does a Grasshopper-style hop to an awaiting ship
Ideally, it could land on a Navy ship flight deck but worst-case-scenario, it'd land on a heavy-lift ship or a specialized droneship-like platform that would be pre-deployed and then towed back.
Cost: Based on the price slides from the ITS presentation, this comes out to as little as $5 million or $10 million at most, which is something like the cost of a Predator drone. Even if I'm way off base and this system costed $100 million per use, that's peanuts to the US military (0.01% of discretionary military spending) and a small price to pay for a large deployment of resources to literally anywhere in 1-2 hours. Even if it was only a few dozen special forces and it took 6 hours I think it would still be worth it. This could also be used for humanitarian efforts. The USNS Comfort hospital ship costs something like $40 million per deployment.
Reasons for thinking this:
Elon made jokes ("Steal Underpants") for the funding slide during the ITS presentation. It seems like he doesn't want to straight up say the US government will be paying for it
Elon said "ultimately this is going to be a huge public/private partnership"
The internet satellite constellation would maybe be sufficient for funding but won't be fully operational until ~2030 so I think it's more for long-term funding for actual colonization after getting there initially to drum up support
Elon goes out of his way to mention that there might be a market for really fast transport of stuff around the world. It seems like by far this would be most useful for military purposes. For goods and commercial passengers it'd be prohibitively expensive
I can't find the quote but Robert Zubrin makes a big deal about how infeasible people will think ITS is until SpaceX proves the system and the US government throws money at it
Even if they skip the militarization of ITS, it's reasonable to think it won't be going to Mars without considerable support from the US government. But how might it go from military logistics to an altruistic Mars venture? Note that the Apollo program went to the moon on rockets first developed for the cold war. Imagine something like this:
Elon starts making friends in politics, advising Trump for example
Prove the functionality of the ITS booster in some capacity
Convince the administration to invest in ITS for affordable 1-hour deployment of troops/cargo anywhere in the world
Once the technology is proven and developed using military funds, casually suggest using ITS to send people to Mars
If ITS could get to Mars within 8 years of program start (before the end of an administration) a non-incumbent President would surely want to fund it and be the President that got us to Mars, especially if the booster is proven. That puts people on Mars by 2028, assuming Trump isn't re-elected, which is right around the time people think it'll happen, including Elon if you account for his warped perception of time. By this time the world is hyped, private companies start investing, and the internet satellite constellation is online, giving SpaceX the resources to continue colonizing Mars.
Possible Problems:
It's been brought up that ITS would look like a nuke. This is my biggest concern but one that I think could be surmounted. First off, ITS is too big to be a conventional nuke. It could be a trojan horse but Elon seems to think the same system could work commercially even though it would have the same problem. I think it's as simple as the US saying "we're going to launch a giant thing, trust us that it's not a nuke". Sounds silly but that's the whole philosophy of mutually ensured destruction and we kind of already do this with regular orbital rockets. And most likely, any country this was deployed too wouldn't have nuclear strike capabilities
People think a launch couldn't be organized in time but I think the rocket would be put on standby during times of crisis OR it would be planned well in advanced for things like raids or conventional logistics support. It's still faster than a cargo plane and much faster than a ship and it's direct insertion to exactly where it's needed
There's concern that it's hard to get the stuff out. This is solved if the stuff is people or if the ship landed at a base to be unloaded but in general I don't think it's a big enough problem to make the system infeasible
I think by far the biggest reason this wouldn't be pursued is public perception. All I can say is SpaceX already launches military payloads and that they could frame a military ITS as more of a logistics vehicle than than a weapon of war, much like the cargo ships/planes it might replace
TL;DR: It seems to make sense that SpaceX would pursue a military version of ITS to deliver troops/cargo anywhere in the world in hours. This would not only partially pay for a Mars mission but also get a foot in the door for support from NASA
r/spacex • u/rustybeancake • Mar 26 '25
How Elon Musk’s SpaceX Secretly Allows Investment From China
r/spacex • u/[deleted] • Nov 13 '20
Not really a quandary Elon Musk’s positive and negative tests for coronavirus create a quandary for SpaceX
r/spacex • u/Primathon • Jun 17 '16
Incorrect. Broadcast is live. Evidence that SpaceX is actively filtering the webcast video feed [video analysis]
Edit: Wow, this brought up a lot of discussion. Official word, as confirmed by SpaceX employees as well as the mods of this sub, is that "what you see is what we see" when it comes to landing video. That seems like the best and most reliable source at this point.
I think there's an entirely reasonable case to be made that -- based on the reactions from the crowd, the body language of the announcers, and the timing of the webcast transition into Stage 2 coast -- that SpaceX at least believes the landing had failed as they were delivering the "we'll let you know" speech (they obviously have access to much more data than just the ASDS video link). You can decide for yourself. Original post follows:
Let's just start with the disclaimer: I'm not trying to cast SpaceX in any sort of bad light, and if I were in charge of things, I'd probably be making the same calls they are. It's a total no-brainer of a decision on their end. An unfiltered feed gains them basically nothing, but they stand to immediately lose control of the PR situation. There's also a historic precedent of them having never before shown a landing failure on the live feed. We've had quick confirmation of RUDs, and we've seen video within a few hours, but we've never seen it in real-time. Having the official position of "we don't know yet" is infinitely more valuable to them then "well, 30,000 people just watched our rocket explode live". They are under no obligation to share 100% of everything with us.
So we start from the idea that there are two possibilities:
The feed we're seeing on screen is exactly what they're seeing in Mission Control
The feed we're seeing on screen is NOT exactly what they're seeing in Mission Control
During the relevant portions of the video, there's not really one particular thing that sticks out. However, there are a lot of small things that add together. Play enough poker and you can't help but notice them...
If you loop the webcast, it's much easier to see. Open this up in another tab:
Eutelsat/ABS Mission Hosted Webcast -- Loop from 26:54 to 27:20
The screen that seems to be showing what the crowd is reacting to is in the bottom row, second from the left; directly between announcers 1 and 2. Watch the loop a few times; the reactions from the crowd seem to be in direct response to changes on this screen. And though it's difficult to confirm absolutely, the image on that screen seems to very closely match what's being displayed in the right-hand video box, under the telemetry (our "public feed").
First, let's pay close attention to the crowd.
26:57 – The crowd makes a noise, but the public feed doesn't change at all. Everyone in that room reacted to something, but we didn't get to see what it was. A man in a grey hoodie, directly behind announcer 3, raises his hands on top of his head in a surprised motion.
26:59 - The screen shows a bit of movement, and we hear second noise from the crowd; a rising, inquisitive tone – exactly what you would expect from "ooh we don't know yet!". Again, the public feed does not change at all. Something very obviously happened that everyone saw and reacted to, but it's not what was displayed on our screen.
27:02 – Announcer 1: "We should be able to have some conclusive evidence in a second..."
27:08 – The screen in question briefly flashes a different image, and there is instantly a much louder crowd noise; this time, a significantly different sound. It is a sharper, falling tone, very much in line with what you would hear if a bunch of people saw a booster being destroyed. Again, the public feed doesn't change at all.
27:11 – You can hear someone yelling in an unfriendly tone in the background, and it's definitely not a stretch to say it sounds a lot like "aaah fuck!" (27:13ish)
27:13 - Announcer 1 immediately moves to the "we don't know" speech. He begins with "So we will provide updates…" and ends with the obviously rehearsed sound bite of "if the stage landed, or we collected more experimental data"
In summary, the crowd reacted three times, in distinctly different ways, to what appears to be the "real" feed visible on the bottom left in the control room. For each of the three reactions, which involved maybe a hundred different people each time, the public feed image remained unchanged.
If the feed is unaltered, this behavior would make no sense whatsoever.
If the public feed is being filtered, this makes perfect sense.
Now let's take a look at the announcers.
Announcer 1 does the best job controlling his body language. The only soft tell I can see is going from a slight wringing of hands (generally a more nervous pose) before "the moment" at 27:08, to linking his fingers (generally a more confident pose). He's also the one to deliver the "closeout" speech, where the broadcast moves from "we don't know" to "we'll let you know". Given that this is one of two potential outcomes for this event (landing vs RUD), it's a near certainty that they have rehearsed both these moments and decided ahead of time who would say what – especially the "…or if we just got more experimental data" sound bite in the event of failure.
Announcer 2 gives it away the most. She is giggling constantly, has a huge grin on her face, and playing with her hands and hair. During this moment of tension, she says "at this point, we're unsure of the status of the landing…", and trails off a bit while the crowd reacts. Then there is an immediate shift in her body language: her smile becomes more forced, she purses her lips, presses her hands together in front of her, and looks to her left for her co-announcer to deliver the "we'll let you know" sound bite. If she didn't actually know the status of the landing, stopping mid-sentence like this would be somewhat strange behavior. If she learned the status of the landing, then this point would have been rehearsed, and would have proceeded exactly as we saw it.
Announcer 3 has been very active with his hands the entire time, moving them at chest level while clenching and unclenching his fists. This is a very nervous move. However, as soon as the crowd reacts for the final time, a few things happen in rapid sequence. His hands stop moving, he fully extends his fingers in a stress-release motion, and then drops them to his sides, where they stay mostly still for the rest of the loop. There is no reason for this behavior if the booster was still in an unknown state. If, however, he saw that the booster didn't make it, then again, this behavior makes absolutely perfect sense.
Here's another way to look at it. Mute the sound, and watch the loop a few times. Pay attention to the facial expressions and body language.
Consider the two possibilities: They legitimately do not know, or they are just finding out and moving to the "shit, it blew up" contingency. One of these scenarios makes sense, and one does not.
So yeah, I'd say they're filtering the feed.
Again, in defense of SpaceX and everyone who works there, I love that they're sharing the info they are. At the end of the day, this doesn't change anything, and it's not surprising in the slightest. Analyzing body language is fun for me, I feel like this is a pretty accurate assessment of the situation, it matches with what we've been historically shown, and it's a fairly conclusive answer to the question of "does SpaceX actively filter the landing feed?" – "yes, almost assuredly"
r/spacex • u/reuters • May 13 '24
Musk's SpaceX is quick to build in Texas, slow to pay its bills
r/spacex • u/threezool • Aug 05 '17
What Would a Failed Falcon Heavy Launch Mean for SpaceX?
r/spacex • u/MrCleanMagicReach • Oct 14 '16
Elon Musk and SpaceX Consider Mars a Moore's Law Problem. It Isn't.
r/spacex • u/RaphTheSwissDude • Jan 16 '20
Starlink might face a big problem...
r/spacex • u/nick9000 • Jan 03 '24
SpaceX accused of unlawfully firing workers critical of CEO Elon Musk
r/spacex • u/chalez88 • Jun 03 '19
Astronomers call for action agaisnt starlink
r/spacex • u/MuppetZoo • Oct 02 '20
SpaceX Is Trying to Force Residents Out of a Small Texas Village
r/spacex • u/WhoseNameIsSTARK • Jun 23 '17
Misleading Spacecom hasn't yet recovered its $50M payment to SpaceX
r/spacex • u/Seedfusion • Oct 02 '25
Elon Musk’s SpaceX Took Money Directly From Chinese Investors, Company Insider Testifies
r/spacex • u/Crayz9000 • Jun 30 '15
Misleading PBdS: SpaceX customers' dream: Failure caused by F9/Dragon coupling issue due entirely to Dragon mods, clearing F9, & rocket returns in Sept.
r/spacex • u/dante80 • Jul 10 '23
SpaceX's Starlink internet satellites 'leak' so much radiation that it's hurting radio astronomy, scientists say
r/spacex • u/jedmeyer2 • Sep 10 '18
Misleading Forbes on SpaceX's Plan to not Reuse Crew Dragon
r/spacex • u/Jeramiah_Johnson • Oct 08 '19
Why NASA's Annoyed About Elon Musk's Giant Rocket
r/spacex • u/CProphet • Apr 16 '17
Discussion: Is Military Entanglement Inevitable for ITS
It seems, come whatever, that SpaceX will find a way to build their Interplanetary Transport System. The company was specifically set up to make multiplanetary spacecraft and they’ve come too far and achieved too much to miss their shot.
Come the great day when they haul the first ITS stages up the launch mount at Pad 39A for vertical integration, will the military laugh it off as a stunt – or will they get very serious. SpaceX are due to launch an NRO payload this month (NROL-76) which is pretty hardcore military, so they don’t appear adverse to this kind of work.
OK, assuming the military bite, what sort of missions could we reasonably expect from them? Establishing military bases on the Moon or possibly Mars to preempt Chinese invasion…seems fanciful, so perhaps something a little closer to home.
1. Satellite Servicing Facility
During the Shuttle program the military were particularly interested in using Shuttle to retrieve and deploy satellites. Military satellites are expensive (think billions) and sometimes take the best part of a decade to build. Gaining the ability to retrieve, refurbish and then redeploy these strategically pivotal satellites seems a sound investment. For instance NASA worked with ESA to create Spacelab, an orbital workshop and hardware system, which they used to service Hubble. The ITS should be ideal for this kind of work, the spacecraft is so big that it could effectively be fitted out as a satellite repair workshop. Of course if a satellite can’t be repaired in space it could be returned safely to Earth on the ITS, refurbished, then re-launched on the next service mission.
2. Orbital Debris Mitigation
Inevitably space Junk will become an increasingly fraught problem for space operations; left unchecked it could result in a Kessler syndrome event. The military are particularly exposed, with maybe $100bn+ in satellite investment, plus unimaginable fallout if terrorist groups/rogue nations effectively gain a free pass to do anything they want. Again ITS could launch huge numbers of rendezvous vehicles which could be used to de-orbit objects like used upper stages or defunct satellites, effectively eliminating these potentially large sources of space debris. Conceivably these large items might even be guided back to an ITS spacecraft where they could be recycled into raw materials for orbital manufacturing. A kilo of aluminium has comparatively little value on Earth but in orbit that same mass is worth thousands, if it can be processed into feedstock for microgravity manufacturing. Shredding satellites would also allow the user to retain confidentiality for the design and operation, effectively solving two problems.
3. Paramilitary Police Force
SpaceX are close to achieving their goal of lowered launch cost by a factor of 100, after they successfully demonstrated booster reuse. It’s only a question of time before much of these savings are passed on to launch customers, triggering an unprecedented increase in space activity. Likely private space stations, asteroid miners and satellite recyclers will all ‘spring up’ overnight – not to mention increased foreign military activity in cislunar space and Earth orbit. In an ideal cosmos these space surge groups would play well together, however, if history teaches us anything, this is unlikely to be case. If there is no authority presence in space, there is effectively no law. Some kind of paramilitary police force seems inevitable, in fact the US Air Force are already taking steps to form a Space Corp (similar to the way the Air Force split from the Army after World War 2). To be effective this space military will ideally be independent, with their own space stations and ships. These patrol vessels will need to be big in order to deal with any contingency, ranging from space rescue through to full on conflict. ITS again could easily fit such work, putting them one step in front of the problem.
Of course if any (or all) of these ITS applications appeal to any part of the US military or intelligence community, these groups would be well placed to provide additional funding to speed up ITS development. Recently it was announced military spending should increase by $54bn which is roughly three times NASA’s yearly budget. Overall US military spending stands at $584bn so SpaceX would effectively be tapping into the main power grid for funding. Of course after SpaceX provide ITS to the military, they could use it to colonise Mars or do whatever they want.
So what do people think about these ideas to harness ITS potential, happy times - or pile of poo. Or perhaps there’s some other lucrative ITS moneyspinner ideas you’d like to discuss. Please feel free to add to the discussion.
Edit 1: Effectively, the US Air Force have already begun to fund ITS with their Raptor development contract. So the question remains: what comes next?
r/spacex • u/[deleted] • Sep 22 '13
I made a futuristic concept of a SpaceX cargo ship of the future!
r/spacex • u/pmgoldenretrievers • Mar 16 '21