r/spaceships • • 1h ago

Ship Design Breakdown 🔧 🔧 Ship Design Breakdown | How Much Armour Should a Spaceship Actually Have?

62 Upvotes

What’s cooler than a sci-fi warship that can take a beating and still keep fighting. But how much armour would you actually need on a spaceship?

In most sci-fi, we see ships exchanging fire for minutes at a time, with explosions covering their hulls before someone finally loses their engines or blows up. But would that work if we tried to make these ships realistic? Armour adds mass, and mass affects how much energy you need to accelerate the ship. On the other hand, leaving important systems exposed means that a single lucky hit could leave you drifting in space. So where do you draw the line? Would you armour the entire ship as heavily as possible, or focus on protecting the parts that really matter?

Let's start with Battlestar Galactica. The reboot's Galactica is a great example of a warship that relies on physical armour and point defense weapons rather than energy shields. It can take serious punishment and keep fighting (if Pegasus is there for a suicide mission lol), and its flak batteries create defensive barriers against incoming missiles and fighters. The ship's Command Information Centre is buried deep inside the hull rather than sitting on top of a tower. Why put your command staff in an exposed position when you could protect them behind several layers of structure? Of course, armour isn't magic. A powerful enough hit can still penetrate the hull, damage internal systems or cause structural problems. Galactica eventually suffers cumulative damage that it can no longer properly repair. Would you design a ship like this to absorb as much damage as possible, or would you prioritise avoiding hits in the first place?

Then there's Star Wars, where ships combine physical hulls with deflector shields. An Imperial Star Destroyer is protected by shields and armoured plating, but its bridge tower still sticks out above the main hull. The tower is a distinctive part of the design, and the ship has shield systems to protect it, but that doesn't make the arrangement completely risk free. If the shields fail or a vulnerable system is damaged, an exposed command structure can become a serious weakness. The destruction of the Executor at Endor is a good example of how a capital ship can be lost after a chain of events leaves it vulnerable, although the exact role of its command tower and bridge in that sequence is worth distinguishing from the broader question of armour. Compare that with Galactica's buried CIC. Would you rather have a heavily shielded but exposed bridge, or a command centre hidden deep inside an armoured hull? I think I know the answer most of you will comment. And if your shields are strong enough to stop most incoming fire, how much physical armour do you actually need?

Star Trek takes a different approach again. Federation starships rely heavily on deflector shields, which can protect them against weapons fire and certain environmental hazards. Their hulls still matter, though, especially when shields are weakened or fail. The Enterprise-D, for example, has its bridge on top of the saucer section, which makes it a prominent feature of the ship's silhouette. That's a very different choice from Galactica's internal CIC. You could argue that a shielded ship doesn't need to bury its bridge as deeply, since its defenses should prevent most attacks from reaching the hull in the first place. But what happens when the shields go down? Wouldn't it make sense to have a backup command centre somewhere deeper inside the ship, with redundant controls and communications? And how much armour would you need around the bridge if your shields could fail at the worst possible moment? A shield is only useful while it can absorb or deflect the attacks coming at you.

There's also the question of what kind of armour you actually use. A thick solid plate is one option, but it's not necessarily the most efficient solution. You could use multiple layers separated by gaps, with an outer layer designed to break up incoming projectiles before they reach the main hull. Real spacecraft already use versions of this idea. Whipple shields use a sacrificial bumper spaced away from the pressure hull to break up high speed debris and spread its energy over a larger area. More advanced versions use additional layers of materials such as ceramic fabric and Kevlar. Could a sci-fi warship use something similar against kinetic weapons? Perhaps a sacrificial outer hull could take the first hit, with a tougher inner structure protecting the crew and critical systems. You could also use compartmentalisation to stop one penetration from flooding half the ship with decompressed air or disabling an entire weapons section. Would spaced armour be more useful than simply adding another few metres of solid plating?

And what about radiation shielding? Real spacecraft need protection from solar particle events and cosmic radiation, especially when astronauts travel beyond the protection of Earth's magnetic field. Water and hydrogen rich materials can be useful for radiation protection, and spacecraft can have designated shelter areas where the crew can take cover during a solar storm. But radiation shielding and armour against weapons are not the same thing. A material that's good at reducing radiation exposure of course isn't automatically good at stopping a kinetic projectile or an energy weapon. A realistic warship might need different layers for different threats, with heavier protection around the reactor, ammunition stores and crew compartments. You'd also need to consider the direction of incoming attacks. A ship expecting a frontal engagement might reinforce its forward facing systems, while a vessel likely to be surrounded would need more balanced protection, aka Galactica.

Of course, the best way to survive a hit is to not get hit in the first place. Point-defense cannons (PDCs), interceptor missiles and automated targeting systems can destroy incoming missiles or threaten attacking fighters before they reach the hull. Galactica's point-defense weapons and flak are good examples of this approach. In other universes, fighters and electronic countermeasures can also help prevent an enemy from getting a clean shot. But point defense has its limits. It needs enough coverage to engage threats approaching from different directions, and it can be overwhelmed by a sufficiently large attack. A projectile that's already very close may leave little time to react. Even if you destroy an incoming missile, its fragments could still damage the ship. So would you invest more mass in armour, or spend it on additional point-defense weapons and ammunition? Perhaps the ideal warship would use a combination of both, with active defenses reducing the number of hits and armour giving the ship a chance to survive the ones that get through.

Finally, there's the question of what you're actually trying to protect. A warship doesn't necessarily need every square metre of its hull to be equally resistant to damage. The reactor, propulsion systems, ammunition stores, life support and command facilities are all critical, but losing different systems has different consequences. You could distribute redundant systems throughout the ship, so a single hit can't disable everything at once. You could put ammunition behind armoured bulkheads, isolate damaged compartments and give the crew alternate ways to control the ship. On a carrier, you might prioritise protecting the hangars and launch systems. On a battleship, the main weapons and power systems might deserve more protection. A smaller escort might not have enough mass for heavy armour everywhere, so it could rely more on speed and point defense.

So here's the question: how much armour should a spaceship actually have? And of what type?

Would you go for a heavily armoured hull like Galactica, rely on shields like the ships in Star Wars and Star Trek, or build a ship that tries to avoid incoming fire altogether? Would you bury the bridge deep inside the hull, or trust your shields to protect an exposed command tower? And which sci-fi warship do you think has the smartest approach to surviving a battle?


r/spaceships • • 5d ago

Spaceship Discussion 💬 What’s the best spaceship entrance of all time?

3.8k Upvotes

r/spaceships • • 15h ago

Discussion / Question I'm ressurecting this old thread regarding exposed bridges - can anybody come up with reasons for why they might not be stupid?

Thumbnail gallery
410 Upvotes

r/spaceships • • 11h ago

Screenshot / Photo Surprised I haven't seen any mentions of X4: Foundations on here! Here are some of my personal favorite ships.

Thumbnail
gallery
86 Upvotes

X4 has some of my favorite ship designs ever, but I can't post all of them, too much effort lol


r/spaceships • • 1h ago

3D / Models Starship of the Megachaira in battle - Gondwana [OC]

Post image
5 Upvotes

The itensity of a voidward battle is best measured in the munitions expended. Two starships can antagonize, chase, and out-maneuver one another for days and weeks with scarcely any shots exchanged, building pressure through positioning and exacting their control over space by secondary craft. Or, in a span of mere hours, arsenals with the strength to level continents can be exchanged, the void set alight by fire and interceptions.

High above a barren moon, where deep ruins are said to lie, two vessels have committed to bring their long war to an end. Once the first salvo flies, the first missile fleets cross the distance, there is no stopping the cascade of lightning and thunder between them, not before one of the warring ships is exhausted and forced to retreat, ceding the moon and its secrets to the Clades and their boundless curiosity.


r/spaceships • • 16h ago

Discussion / Question Concept of a piezoelectric spaceship

31 Upvotes

This is a bionic airship that generates a mechanical traveling wave with electrical charges on its surface, which provides adhesion to the atmosphere and space's rarefied plasma. The mechanical wave and charge generation are physically linked by piezoelectric elements or friction between the skin layers. In the atmosphere, the main component of the thrust is aerodynamic, based on the principle of a fish, and in space, charges lead to the formation of a Debye shielding cloud of charged particles within a large radius that are thrown off by the travelling wave It's similar to how a fish throws off vortices, creating jet thrust.


r/spaceships • • 12h ago

Artwork Why won't it stop groping at me?!?!?!

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Flung chapter 15 is out tomorrow on all your favorite webcomic platforms including Webtoons, Tapas, GlobalComix or in widescreen Epic Format at www.stardog.tv!


r/spaceships • • 19h ago

3D / Models I made a tiny USS Resolute in scale to my ST Into the Unknown models

Thumbnail gallery
11 Upvotes

r/spaceships • • 18h ago

Artwork DERELICT TIDE [OC]

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

r/spaceships • • 1d ago

Artwork Oil painting of X-Wing starfighters by Nacicaba

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/spaceships • • 22h ago

Other 🫡Corellian Torpedo Boat DP8. Modded.

Thumbnail gallery
16 Upvotes

Mods: Renegade Specialized Ship Modules, Antares Supra, Mattels Project Fenrir, Tiger Shipyards, ASC Deimos, InquisitorGlow Parts, Avontech Stardust, Barrage Missile Launchers, Matilija Aerospace, Ol’ Big X, Micro Modules.


r/spaceships • • 1d ago

Tabletop Wargaming Homeworld themed Resistance faction from Dropfleet Commander

Thumbnail
gallery
210 Upvotes

This is my hand painted Resistance fleet from the Dropfleet Commander tabletop game. Inspired by Homeworld and TTA.


r/spaceships • • 20h ago

Games BAO - a compact reconnaissance craft from our space sim, Verse Project

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

An earlier look at BAO, the light reconnaissance craft in our space sim, Verse Project. Its brief is to reach an unsurveyed area, scan it, leave a beacon and get home. The priorities for that role are manoeuvrability, low fuel use, a sensitive scanner and a low thermal signature. These two hangar views show its rounded hull, canopy and landing gear.


r/spaceships • • 1d ago

3D / Models Scout Arrival - Babylon 5 Jump Point V2

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

Still a few little tweaks I could do for this, and after upload I immediately changed the lacunarity and got a better texture, but I'm reasonably content with this effect, and very happy I've got it entirely in camera in Blender (bar some slight glow compositing)


r/spaceships • • 17h ago

Games Dust In The Void: WIP 1st video pre alpha

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

This is my new creation, Dust in The Void. Year is 2060. Humans have settlements on the moon. Competing factions want control over the limited real estate near the lunar south pole. You're a mercenary pilot flying everything from bulky nuclear powered transport hoppers to advanced stealth fighters. You have an advanced augmented reality helmet that lets you see through your ship and sync with your advanced avionics and manage 6 Degrees of Freedom flight. This video showcases my first simple combat mission to intercept an OPFOR bomber on its way to Shackleton Crater.

I've got a long way to go to make this playable, but I'd really love to hear your feedback! If you'd like to learn more and follow along with development: https://discord.gg/cfd4RV8k7


r/spaceships • • 20h ago

Custom Build Cool ship design

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/spaceships • • 1d ago

Discussion / Question What spaceship show/film have you watched lately that you would highly recommend?

107 Upvotes

r/spaceships • • 1d ago

Games The Rocinante. Built in Space Engineers.

Thumbnail
gallery
49 Upvotes

Tried to build it as true to the real Roci as I could. 6 PDCs, 2 torpedo launchers, 1 railgun. Its a little larger than the real one just due to the limits of the game, but I think it looks fairly proportional.

Couldnt make the PDCs deployable without making it quite a bit bigger though, which I wanted to do, but just couldnt get it to work. The interior is also simplified and standard layout, rather than like a building, otherwise it would be too heavy.


r/spaceships • • 1d ago

Discussion / Question Neck or No Neck?

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/spaceships • • 1d ago

Artwork Space Fleet

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/spaceships • • 2d ago

Fleet Archives 📼 📼 Fleet Archives | Homeworld series | Have you played it? Which game was your favourite?

170 Upvotes

r/spaceships • • 1d ago

3D / Models Theoretical Horizons - USS Voyager Bridge WIP

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

r/spaceships • • 1d ago

Discussion / Question spaceship, jet, or something else?

Post image
5 Upvotes

i know it’s awful quality it’s a screenshot from a video i took just now in tucson, az. i can’t find any reports online of a space shuttle taking off or anything space x related so im wondering if anyone knows what this is? is it just a jet? it wasn’t moving like a plane or jet just moving straight up until no longer visible.


r/spaceships • • 1d ago

Video / Animation Sovereign vs. Mirror Galaxy X

1 Upvotes