r/space1io • u/[deleted] • May 23 '17
Discussion flawed points system
The points system is flawed, leading to artificially inflated high scores and arena records.
The points system currently awards points for (1) killing a leader's fleet and (2) for killing individual ships. The points given for killing ships is fine and straightforward. One ship killed equals one point.
However, the points for killing leaders (although proportional the leader's rank prior to being killed) does not take into account the total number of fleets in the arena. If, for example, there were only 10 fleets in the arena, all fleets would be on the leader board. The probability of all these fleets being skilled is low, because an increase in skilled fleets only comes with an increase in the number of fleets (statistically speaking). This means it's easier for the leader to defend the title given that the leader has less competition. If the only other skilled fleets are ranked #2 or #3, then each time the leader kills them off he gets lots of points. This problem is compounded by the fact that in an arena with few fleets, it is harder to build up a successful fleet and find fleets to battle and earn points off of.
What I'm saying is that when I get on in the morning, and see that someone already has an arena record of 3000+ pts, I know they got there because they played in an arena with few fleets and few skilled fleets. They were rewarded with an artifically inflated high score because they had no competition. This is why it is meaningless to see people bragging about having a high score of 5000 or 7000 or more. They simply played in favorable conditions and got more points than they deserved.
It's as if a Formula 1 racing car was on a track with a Ford Fiesta, and the F1 car got 50 points every time it passed the Fiesta in a 2 hour race.
Or it's as if Lebron James was playing against 5 elementary school kids. A final score of 380 points wouldn't mean Lebron James is some sort of basketball god that can beat an NBA team by 300 points too. It would just be stupid.
I suggest a scoring system that accounts for the number of fleets and the rate of turnover on the leader board. If the #1 spot is being taking frequently, that means it is a competitive arena. If the #1 spot is held for 30 mins while some skilled fleets kills the 9 other newbies in the arena, then the #1 fleet should be awarded fewer and fewer points for each kill.
Update: GoldenSnidget suggested a percentage-based scoring system. That could work, too.