r/soundtracks • • Apr 13 '24

Discussion Is Hans Zimmer Overrated?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Almost every movie score enthusiast is a fan šŸ˜ of Hans Zimmer. They compliment him for his way around mixing traditional musical instruments šŸŽ¹ with the digital tools šŸ’» available in this day and age. They also praise him on his ability to create up with soundtracks that leave even the average moviegoer hungry šŸ˜‹ for more. He is also considered to be one of the living 1000 geniuses 🧠. However, compared to the likes of John Williams, John Powell, John Debney, Jerry Goldsmith, etc., is Hans Zimmer overrated? šŸ¤”


r/soundtracks • • Jan 09 '26

šŸ“¢ Discussion Unless there is ghost writing involved in John Williams' Disclosure Day score, he will almost certainly be nominated at age 95 (or posthumous) in 2027.

2 Upvotes

Is that crazy or what!


r/soundtracks • • Aug 22 '26

šŸ“¢ Discussion How did Howard Shore just come out of nowhere and do an amazing job on Lord of the Rings?

12 Upvotes

Why was Howard Shore chosen for Lord of the Rings? Had he done any similar films? Seems like he was just perfect for the role and came out of nowhere in a sense.


r/soundtracks • • May 17 '25

Discussion Am I the only person who listens to the sinners soundtrack on repeat?

3 Upvotes

r/soundtracks • • 18d ago

šŸ“¢ Discussion Is this a hot take?

6 Upvotes

Project: Hail Mary has a better score than Interstellar. Just upvote/downvote to vote

Edit: I also love Interstellar's my main reasoning is the diversity, intricacy, and creativity of phm


r/soundtracks • • Mar 12 '24

Discussion Zimmerā€˜s Score for Dune2 is Weak

0 Upvotes

Watching Dune 2 on the big screen I was blown away by the direction, production design and the acting alike. It was a fantastic immersive experience. And the only thing that, every once in a while, distracted me from completely losing myself in the movie was Zimmerā€˜s score. I thought it was lackluster and neutral where it shouldnā€˜t have been. There’s great opportunity for grandiosity, for epic themes. On Giedi Prime, during the final Battle, during the Shai-Hulud surf scene - instead I mostly heard blaring orchestral noise. I was really disappointed with the score. Especially because I adore the Toto/Eno-Score for Lynchā€˜s version of the movie. Anybody else felt similarly? Or do most of you get more from Zimmerā€˜s take?


r/soundtracks • • Jul 30 '25

Discussion The Best Soundtrack of All Time (it's not close)

0 Upvotes

r/soundtracks • • Jul 18 '26

šŸ“ Insight The odyssey

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/soundtracks • • Aug 24 '25

šŸŽ» Original Music šŸŽ» When a 2005 TV movie soundtrack is better than a big-budget Superman soundtrack in 2025

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/soundtracks • • Jan 18 '26 Bravo

šŸ“ Insight J.K. Rowling on Hans Zimmer scoring the Harry Potter series

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/soundtracks • • Oct 12 '25

šŸ“¢ Discussion This was meant to be a follow-up to J. Trapanese and Daft Punk? This soundtrack is ass

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/soundtracks • • Sep 07 '16

Discussion how/why the fuck did "The Hateful Eight" movie win the Oscar for best score?

0 Upvotes

I just watched the movie, hoping to have a nice experience like I had with Interstellar, or The Imitation Game, or The Social Network or How to Train Your Dragon etc etc etc.

It was a huge disappointment, does anyone know ..like what factors came into play to make this movie's score the "best" of the year? Like what do the judges consider? IT was like crap to me


r/soundtracks • • 4d ago Helpful

šŸ“¢ Discussion Top 10 Video Game tracks

Post image
101 Upvotes

In no particular order. Once again, struggled to keep this to 10! What would you add? I know Ocarina of Time missing is a crime, but…


r/soundtracks • • Feb 14 '25

Derivative Music I wish to report "The Creator" (2023)

0 Upvotes

For inappropriate use of Radiohead, and repeated violations of Shostakovich's eighth string quartet (the DSCH motif and the knocking door motif). Also, it is bad.


r/soundtracks • • Dec 24 '25

šŸ“¢ Discussion Can you hum a single theme form Avatar 3 ?

1 Upvotes

apart from the first opus’ voices of despair and destruction which we barely hear in the 3rd btw


r/soundtracks • • Dec 01 '23

Insight WE DONT NEED TO KNOW YOUR SPOTIFY FILM COMPOSERS LISTS... WE ALL KNOW WHO ZIMMER/WILLIAMS/GIACCHINO/ELFMAN ARE...

23 Upvotes

r/soundtracks • • Oct 01 '25

šŸ“¢ Discussion I believe Batman is the franchise with the best overall scores.

13 Upvotes

Star Wars or Lord of the Rings are often the popular choices due to the musical identities John Williams and Howard Shore established for those worlds. However, I would argue Batman is an embarrassment of riches.

In terms of overall variety and quality, I don’t think it gets better than Batman. Elfman’s gothic, Goldenthal’s zany, Zimmer and Junkie XL’s bombastic, Newton Howard’s emotionality, and Giacchino’s atmospheric.

The consistency of Star Wars and Lord of the Rings does matter, but it is impressive how valid arguments could be made for a few of those eras being best for Batman. Burton-Elfman, Nolan-Zimmer, Reeve-Giacchino, etc. I think the diversity throughout Batman films keeps listening fresh and interesting.

On top of the composers I mentioned, Shirley Walker contributed phenomenal work on ā€œBatman: Mask of the Phantasmā€ as well.


r/soundtracks • • Aug 02 '24

Discussion Why Hans Zimmer's minimalism is genius

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/soundtracks • • Sep 02 '26

šŸŽ» Original Music šŸŽ» The Harry Potter 8 Film Franchise Soundtrack Is The Best Of All Time?

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone. I CANNOT help but wonder how some people don’t appreciate the soundtrack enough. For Me, it has EVERYTHING:

melancholy (farewell to dobby, obliviate, hedwig’s theme, a window to the past),

love (harry and ginny, the friends, harry and hermione, when ginny kissed harry),

happiness (buckbeak’s flight, reunión of friends, leaving hogwarts, another year ends, fireworks)

unity (ron’s Speech, neville, neville the hero, loved ones and leaving, dumbledores army)

mystery (the spiders, another story, the goblet of fire,the werewolf scene, double trouble, the chamber of secrets)

darkness (the dementors converge, voldemort, the dark mark, malfoy’s mission, the drink of despair, the killing of dumbledore, death eaters, bathilda bagshot, panic inside hogwarts, procession)

sadness (death of cedric, farewell aragog, snapes demise, severus and lily, farewell to dobby, obliviate, dumbledore’s farewell, death of sirius, the diadem, harry’s sacrifice)

hope (dumbledore’s army, the patronus light, flight of the order of the Phoenix, finale, hogwarts hymn, the room of requirements, the friends, the weasley stomp, neville the hero, voldemort’s end, a new beginning)


r/soundtracks • • Dec 01 '23

Discussion My 2023 Spotify Wrapped

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/soundtracks • • Sep 04 '23

Discussion Without question, Space Jam has the best soundtrack of any film ever made in history.

1 Upvotes

Just listening to this soundtrack makes this without question my favorite movie. 27 years since it’s release and imo most of the lineup could sell out a concert if they weren’t dead, canceled, or animated:

Seal ā€œFly Like An Eagleā€

Coolio ā€œThe Winnerā€

Quad City DJ’s ā€œSpace Jamā€

R. Kelly ā€œI Believe I Can Flyā€

B-Real, Busta Rhymes, Coolio, LL Cool J, & Method Man ā€œHit ā€˜Em High (The Monstars’ Anthem)ā€

D’Angelo ā€œI Found My Smile Againā€

Monica ā€œFor You I Willā€

Salt-N-Pepa ā€œUpside Down (ā€˜Round-N-ā€˜Round)ā€

Robin S. ā€œGivin’ U All That I’ve Gotā€

Barry White & Chris Rock ā€œBasketball Jonesā€

All-4-One ā€œI Turn To Youā€

R. Kelly, Changing Faces, & Jay-Z ā€œAll Of My Daysā€

Spin Doctors Feat. Biz Markie ā€œThat’s The Way (I LIKE IT)ā€

Bugs Bunny ā€œBugginā€™ā€


r/soundtracks • • Sep 05 '26

šŸ“¢ Discussion Spiderman Brand New Day theme almost identical to Inception soundtrack?

0 Upvotes

Is it just me or are the melody from the Inception soundtrack very similar to the theme in the Spiderman Brand New Day soundtrack? I noticed it especially when listening to Old Souls compared to Suite New Day.


r/soundtracks • • 20d ago

šŸ“¢ Discussion How come Justin Hurwitz never matched La La Land

1 Upvotes

I thought La La Land was such a perfect soundtrack. Everything just worked but above all the melodies were amazing. I’m surprised and disappointed that the follow up weren’t even close.

Edit: it’s an opinion but for me I keep going back to certain soundtracks I’m just not drawn repeatedly to his other work. It possible others go back to Babylon and First Man but they don’t come close… again in my opinion.


r/soundtracks • • Apr 17 '25

Discussion Is Hans Zimmer the most overrated composer of the last 30 years?

0 Upvotes

The name is recognisable, but how much of the work does he actually do? Should the other composers get the credit?


r/soundtracks • • Feb 04 '26

šŸ“¢ Discussion What’s the soundtrack that ruined the movie for you?

0 Upvotes

I’ll go first. The female choir in Glory was too much for me to bear and I had to turn it off after about 30 minutes.

EDIT: I’ve been corrected that it is a boys choir. I guess I didn’t listen hard enough as I was reaching for the remote.