r/slp • • Mar 29 '22

Dysphagia should not be part of the SLP profession

1 Upvotes

How is this not the domain of a dietitian who deals specifically with food? How is it not the domain of an occupational therapist who deals with quality of life and occupational hazards? How is this not the domain of a physiotherapist who is the master of the body and muscles? How is this not the domain of an ENT whose job literally includes the word "throat" in it? Or a dentist or orthodontist who deal with the mouth? Or even then, how is dysphagia not its own specialised job - its own unique profession - a dysphagiologist, let's call it.

Instead, I, a "speech and language" pathologist of many years, now just spend my days talking about foods, textures, consistencies, drinks, ordering different foods for the bedside trial, looking into mouths and worrying about life/death situations. Am I a nurse? Am I a dietitian? Am I a nutritionist? Am I an ENT? Am I a chef? Why is so much of my profession dedicated to food and swallowing? I've started to think that there is actually no such thing as a "speech pathologist", a name which pretends that over 50% of the caseload is not dysphagia. A better term would be a "swallowing pathologist".

I feel tricked. I went to college and studied something called SPEECH and LANGUAGE pathology, I learnt linguistics and biomedical science, I learnt about communication disorders, and yet over 70% of my caseload is swallowing and dysphagia. For a career seemingly dedicated to communication, it is quite possibly, and very ironically, the most poorly named career when so much of the caseload is to do with swallowing.

It seems there's no escaping it in the adult sector. Whether you're in the acute setting, the community, outpatient, rehab - dysphagia has hijacked this career, akin to telling a physiotherapist that he/she/they has to now incorporate pottery into their profession. Yes, we are larynx protecters, but only insofar as we deal with the communication aspect of the larynx, like voice. And even then, we don't deal with everything larynx-related - we're not opera teachers nor are we pulmonologists.

It is simply a historical accident that dysphagia was only relatively recently tacked onto to our profession by orthodontists and neurologists. They could have added anyone else but they chose a profession dedicated to communication, and, like a virus, it has taken over and now we have this awkward situation where our job is no longer exclusively or even majority about communication.

The career I thought I loved has been hijacked and it would have been nice to have been properly forewarned about this before I invested so much time and so much college debt into it.


r/slp • • May 25 '25

Autism Can some “Neurodiverse affirming” and “Anti-ABA” Speech Therapists please define “behaviorism” and discuss what makes ABA harmful?

0 Upvotes

I am curious to see how we are conceptualizing the theoretical underpinnings of ABA and reflecting on ways to keep this theory out of our own clinical practice.


r/slp • • Jan 18 '25

I’m a (mostly) anti-ABA SLP who works at an ABA clinic. AMA!

11 Upvotes

I wanted to post a whole rant but decided to see what would happen if I took this route.


r/slp • • Apr 12 '23

Speech Retreat owner Hallie Sherman deletes feedback for racist lineup

12 Upvotes

For the past three weeks the four Speech Retreat owners have been receiving feedback that their conference has way too many white people in the lineup.

Up until this morning there was an image on social media showing 20 white business owners faces with comments from SLPs about the lack of diversity.

After sending feedback to Speech Retreat this morning they decided to delete the image and all our comments and feedback.

Our field can't fix its racist roots when nobody in the field can talk about it.

The Speech Retreat owners are most to blame but so is every single one of the business owners in that group who are also saying and doing nothing and agreeing to present for them anyway.


r/slp • • Jan 30 '23

Queer and child free SLPs

29 Upvotes

Rare bird in the schools, I know. Anyone else show up to a staff meeting or informal work gathering and everybody talks about their husband and kids or their pregnancy? It's eh.....not a great feeling.

I like being who I am because it helps me relate to the kids, esp. the queer tweens and teens that all of a sudden think being gay is the next hot thing (lol def wasn't like that in the 90s but I'm glad things have changed). But unfortunately my colleagues don't represent my demographic and the schools in general are like...really not awesome places for spirits like myself.

I don't talk to straight people for fun in my spare time and they don't come into my community anyway but I have to earn a paycheck and have no control over the types of folk I work with and their gender roles and traditions, or their race/class politics either. My friend is a nurse and she has to deal with the same thing. I think for her acute care is much more fast paced so there isn't really time to care about things like that when someone's life is in your hands. Schools are more like, well, remember high school?

That was such fun, huh? Let's do it again as a grown up lol.

How do you deal with it as an outsider?


r/slp • • Jun 30 '23

Seeking Advice Ethical dilemma or am I being nosey? Received a crap eval report

1 Upvotes

I see a 29 month old bilingual for moderate language delays. Child was found ineligible for early intervention services (they almost always deny)

In the report, the SLP stated “children exposed to two languages may experience typical delays in language production” and other statements that alluded because the child is bilingual, delays are present but considered acceptable. SLP also advised the parent that the kid just needs to be around other kids and will recover from the delay.

The SLP put in suggested goals for the child if the parent seeks outside services.

I’m very mad with the line about bilingual children experiencing delays is acceptable. This is a big myth that I do everything I can to tell my parents that research disputes this.

Do I take any steps about this (other than parent discussion that I think the report is garbage and I will keep seeing the child)?

Is this an ethical issue or do I just roll my eyes and mind my business?

Thanks

————— ETA:

Maybe I should have made the severity of the child’s delays more obvious and this is NOT a case of difference vs disorder.

The eval was in the child’s first language. The kid is at approximately 18–20 month receptively and expressively. Child has approximately 20 intelligible words total in both languages. There is absolutely a delay present.

I understand there are differing eligibility requirements. That is not my problem.

My problem is that the evaluation report, performed in the child’s first language, documented that this language delay is expected and acceptable because the child is bilingual. Which in my clinical opinion, is a problem.

I did not tell the parent verbatim that the eval is garbage, I said I don’t agree with it. My strong opinions and casual language are because this Reddit, not an ASHA convention.

I did not publicly doxx the SLP, file a report, or contact the SLP in any way. I got an evaluation I thought was bad and borderline unethical and vented on Reddit. Y’all can stop crucifying me for “trash talking” the SLP because I didn’t. The eval was bad, and WE HAVE ALL THOUGHT THAT.

The fact that I’m getting roasted in the comments but that the vote count hovers at zero says that yes, this may very well be an ethical issue.

Next time I post on r/SLP, I’ll remember I’m talking to ASHA board and people who pretend like they don’t know what a poop knife is. JFC.


r/slp • • Dec 18 '23

DO NOT USE Speechpathology.com

0 Upvotes

Spend your hard-earned money somewhere else. I have never had a good experience with them (automatic renewals every year, poor customer service, etc). Also, they are DEFINITELY just in the business of just making money. They have not been helpful for helping me as an individual SLP or helping me with my CEU needs. Rant over. Thanks for reading :)


r/slp • • Mar 05 '23

Being a "swallow expert" does not sound cool

0 Upvotes

*not a super encouraging post for fellow SLPs. Welcome feedback

I work a SLP at a 1000+ bed hospital floating between acute and rehab. Finishing up my CFY soon. But I started taking pre-reqs at a community college for a career change already.

Is it just me or is this dysphagia thing just not super interesting to me? (I'm not even talking about all the cog orders we get over at rehab on perfectly functional patients and having to "treat" them for an hour because they're somehow "not baseline." Like the pt's like wtf are you doing here? And I'm like I honestly don't know.") Anyway - back to dysphagia. I'm starting to feel dysphagia treatment at hospitals is easily something RNs can do with little training. I mean they already do dysphagia screenings anyway on new stroke patients. What am I doing differently? Commenting on their multiple swallows? Slowed A-P transfer? Like as long as it's functional and they get it down, do we really have to make it appear so complicated? Of course, instrumentals are cool, and they certainly, certainly have their place. I'm not saying acute SLP profession is a scam, but I'm just realizing I don't want to do this for rest of my life. Swallowing management, tbh, just seems not very significant to me that there needs to be a whole different profession. A lot of us don't even realize how big of a role aspiration plays in causing aspiration pneumonia. It's almost as if someone said, "aspiration might cause pneumonia" and suddenly SLPs take aspiration waaaay too seriously. I know I aspirate just as much as some of the patients I see, and I'm fine. But I'm changing my subject.

Critiques/feedback is welcome. One thing working in the hospital taught me is I want to go deeper in medicine, and I'm planning on going to PA school once I have all my pre-reqs while working. I just feel like my job is something so simple but so glorified into being so scientific because professionals have a master's degree (with only 1 dysphagia course!?). Again, just ranting. NOT saying dysphagia doesn't exist or shouldn't be treated. Just my current feelings.


r/slp • • Sep 14 '24

Why did I get downvoted for politely pointing out that a professional SLP shouldn’t be using racial slurs in a social media post?

Thumbnail
gallery
58 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I noticed this post using the term “ji**ed” in a derogatory manner to mean “ripped off.” As someone whose family’s ancestors died in the holocaust, I don’t love the anti-Roma racism. Many Roma were murdered in concentration camps alongside my people. I know no one wants to be “called out,” so I politely told this person with the benefit of the doubt that their post contained a hurtful racial slur. I try to believe people are ignorant rather than hateful.

Instead of editing the post, I was met with downvotes. Why? Is it because I didn’t answer the question? I thought the first commenter’s post was sufficient to answer the question. Are we seriously this hostile about our own blindness to everyday racism?


r/slp • • Dec 16 '23

My beef with neurodiversity self-advocacy: how do we know these people are who they say they are?

113 Upvotes

I did not go through grad school in the era of extreme preoccupation with the neurodiversity community's take on therapy, so I don't know a whole lot about how autism self-advocates came to be such a presence in our field.

What I did experience was the sudden explosion at the outset of the 2010s of parents seeking autism eligibilities for kids with social-emotional difficulties... regardless of their children's language skills or capacities for perspective-taking and central coherence. Because most psychologists and clinicians at the time had little experience diagnosing autism, it wasn't hard for parents to get the label they wanted. It still isn't as hard as it should be to pressure clinicians to make a desired diagnosis.

I am still very much of the opinion that if an individual's symptomatology better fits another disorder, we should not be diagnosing that person with autism. And frankly, a lot of the "neurodiversity" discourse on social media looks to me like what happens when kids who were misdiagnosed in early elementary school become young adults: lots of black-and-white thinking, extreme hostility to differing viewpoints, and unwarranted presumptions of authority.

So when the Informed SLP basically acknowledged that our field embraced Natural Language Processing because the neurodiversity community said we should, my first thought was: who the hell is the "neurodiversity community"? Seriously. Who even are these people? How do we truly know they're autistic? Is someone autistic just because they say they are? How was it decided that extremely high-functioning self-advocates with exceptional language skills, advanced degrees, and careers have special insight into which therapies are most appropriate for minimally verbal individuals who need around-the-clock care?

There are just so many presumptions here that have gone dangerously unexamined.

Edit: I'm not sure a good-faith discussion of this topic is possible. It doesn't seem so. Posts that are at all critical or even questioning of ND orthodoxies are instantly shared to ND cliques, who arrive en mass to downvote even the most respectfully observed comments.

That said, it's not at all hard to find accounts of the harm this discourse's excesses are causing.

Edit update: A perfectly reasonable comment on the importance of distinguishing autism from mere quirkiness was just deleted because it had negative votes.

Second update: I'm seeing comments promoting facilitated communication 🤯🤯🤯


r/slp • • Dec 02 '23

Neurodiversity discourse is a drag

22 Upvotes

I think it’s completely fair to ask someone purporting to speak on behalf of the -entire- autistic community to undergo a rigorous neuro-psych evaluation if they want to tell SLPs how to do their jobs. People with personality disorders declare themselves autistic all. the. time. Parents of children with conduct disorders who don't want their parenting scrutinized seek ASD diagnoses all. the. time. I'm kind of done with discounting interventions because some jag-off with excellent language skills and a flair for online conflict said they were ableist and non-neurodiversity-affirming. I'm kind of done with therapists whose training seems to have emphasized critiquing interventions from a "neurodiversity" standpoint over evaluating their evidence base.


r/slp • • Jul 17 '24

Can an SLP get Botox and/or lip filler?

0 Upvotes

I recently had someone tell me that they couldn’t get Botox or lip fillers because of our job. I was just curious if anyone in this group has Botox or fillers and can speak to their experience? I know a girl in my cohort who had fillers, but that was grad school and not full time work. Does filler and Botox really affect our work that much?


r/slp • • Oct 14 '23

Can someone please help me communicate my concerns properly with my kid's SLP?

0 Upvotes

My son is 3.2 years old. He has been in speech therapy since he was 18 months old. We are a bilingual household but my son exclusively speaks only in English. He was a late walker (not sure if there is any connection). He hasn't shown any other red flags.

His first words were at 19 months. Now he has close to 400 words of spoken words (variety of them like nouns, verbs and adjectives), understands much more. He follows 2 step instructions about 75% of the time. His receptive language gets better everyday so I am not very concerned about that. It's his expressive language that has me worried.

He, on paper, is ticking many of the milestones.

  • He has sentences of 3-4 words. Some are even longer.

  • knows to use atleast 3 location words - on, in, under

  • can use pronouns like I, my, you

  • can sing songs

  • can't really tell full stories but will add sentences in context when I am narrating stories

  • can answer simple questions

  • initiate simple sentences (this has been emerging with me taking back my prompts which he has grown very dependent on)

  • use and form sentences in different contexts meaningfully

  • picks up new words fairly decent

  • has begun to read 3-4 letter words

  • he is also an expert facial cues reader and can realize he has said something incorrectly from my expressions and shut down. He looks at me for affirmation while he forms sentences to make sure he has got it right.

Our biggest goal right now is to get him comfortable to use more sentences.

My major concern is it feels as though he speech should be more organic by now ? There should be questioning.. The Why's and What's atleast ? My SLP says it will come but my son's entire speech feels like me making all the effort and him just saying things to get me off his back so that he can go play. When I show him something unfamiliar I can literally see him trying to throw all possible answers at me in hopes that one will satisfy me enough to let him off the hook.

While I understand he is a toddler and his attention span is less and mine has been extremely cooperative to sit and do activities with me everyday so that we can work on his speech...I am starting to freak out about this.

I am a first time mom and I am fighting my family to get my son the speech therapy as opposed to their wait and let him learn at his own pace approach. They are happy with his single word responses. Only my partner is supportive of this.

Please help me understand if my concerns and valid and how to drive this point home to my SLP. She is wonderful I am not denying her that. But she is either not getting it or maybe I am not explaining this properly to her.


r/slp • • Sep 28 '24

Speech Assistant I made a really bad mistake when recommending PT to someone

0 Upvotes

A long time ago (4 years ago) I was told by a PT that kids needed to sit criss cross or something was wrong with their posture. If they sit in a W shape, they can hurt their posture? I kinda blindly believed it. I looked online and it said it was bad practice to make kids sit criss cross and abusive so I got scared.

I never corrected a kid’s sitting position before, but I felt bad realizing that it can be invasive to make a kid change sitting positions and I told someone that I thought something was off with their posture and they got mad at me. I only did it once. I did recommend PT to the family and he did qualify

I now know that I should not make kids change positions, but is it wrong of me to fix their sitting position if it looks painful or mention something to the family if they have bad posture?

I do not know a lot about PT. Someone told me offhandedly and I probably shouldn’t have said anything.

Any ideas how to handle this situation better?


r/slp • • Feb 06 '25

2025 POLITICS MEGATHREAD

0 Upvotes

SLP is an inherently political field. The policies made surrounding healthcare and education will impact us and our patients directly, and discussion is warranted. Due to an influx of posts regarding the topic, we have decided to make a megathread. Any posts regarding this topic made after this post is pinned will be deleted and redirected. This will be in effect for as long as this post is pinned.

BE RESPECTFUL- Disagreeing and productive discussion is welcome. Personal insults, name calling, and mocking others will not be tolerated. Trolls and bots will be banned.


r/slp • • Jul 21 '25

Why can't myotherapy improve speech

6 Upvotes

I'm not a Speech-Language Pathologist but I notice the hate of Myofunctional therapy in this subreddit, and I don't understand it. Intuitively, it makes sense that if a weak muscle is preventing your lips from articulating a sound clearly, then strengthening it will help improve articulation. Is there a reason why this rationale doesn't work?


r/slp • • Sep 08 '25

SLPs, what are your thoughts on expanding our scope to diagnose autism?

5 Upvotes

Edit:::

Looking at ASHA’s scope of practice, SLPs can already diagnose autism with the right training. So the real question is—if it’s within our scope, shouldn’t we also be able to bill and get reimbursed for it?

###

I’ve been thinking about the fact that as speech-language pathologists, we often work closely with children who show clear signs of autism, yet the formal diagnosis typically falls outside our scope and under other professionals (psychologists, developmental pediatricians, etc.).

I know there are some autism assessments that SLPs can get trained in and use for diagnosis, but reimbursement through insurance or recognition by government entities is often not there.

So, I’m curious:

Would you want ASHA to advocate for SLPs being able to formally diagnose autism?

Do you feel we have the training/background to do so, especially with additional certification?

How do you think this would impact access to services, billing, and collaboration with other professionals?

I’m not looking for legal advice—just your perspectives as fellow SLPs on whether this is a direction our field should explore.


r/slp • • Apr 16 '23

People Pulling Out of the Speech Retreat

2 Upvotes

Question... does anyone think the people pulling out of the Speech Retreat are better than the people who thus far have stayed in? Like either way they agreed to be in this conference that didn't prioritize voices of color. Does pulling out really show any strong vote for diversity or is it just pulling out when the water gets hot? Like the issue could be any other current issue and their reaction would potentially be the same. I almost feel like the way the instagram "I'm not longer associated" posts are going it seems like just another way to not take responsibility and doesn't make any real change. What do others think, because maybe I'm missing something?


r/slp • • Oct 08 '23

What can I do with bachelors SLP, if I probably don’t go into grad school?

1 Upvotes

Definitely feel I fucked up in life…

I picked a dead end bachelors speech pathology now 30k with it

Usually with bachelors in SLP u have to get the masters to follow up. I dint know why it’s set up that way. Like why u can just get bachelors and start working immediately

That’s why should of done nursing would got bachelors start working

all I know is that I could work school or healthcare somewhere that what the degree relates to

Or follow up with another masters like social work, mental health counseling etc

But I’m also interested in other stuff like modeling, arts, acting, business (beauty/fashion), and social media(tik tok/YouTube)


r/slp • • Apr 27 '24

IEP goal says: ...correctly articulate T, S, SH, J, and F correctly... do they mean "J" or /j/?

0 Upvotes

I'm posting this partly because I think it's sort of funny but also because I think it's a little bit annoying. I genuinely don't know if I should work on words like "jump" or words like "yellow." If I was going to write it like they did and I mean /j/ but I want to write it in a way that parents understand, I would write it as T, S, SH, Y, and F. so I genuinely don't know if the SLP before me meant one or the other. Anyway. Let's vote. Yellow or Jump?


r/slp • • Mar 16 '25

Seeking Advice Pragmatic Language Program Resources

0 Upvotes

Hi all! Looking for advice, support, and guidance. I am a BCBA looking to provide some guidance and support to a parent of a client of I am supporting who struggles with pragmatic language. I am out of my wheelhouse here on the full extent of programming she is asking for and we are looking for an SLP with expertise in the area to support him to collaborate with, but mom wants some resources she can complete with him on her own to bridge the gap in the interim. I told her I didn't have much experience or knowledge within the area, but would consult with colleagues on the topic and see if they had any recommendations, but I figured going to a source of SLP's I could talk this through and discuss this with would be helpful as well. Do online programs/resources exist like this? Do you have any personal favorites or recommendations? Should I just hold off until a relationship with an SLP is established and let them take the lead on this? I know I want to assist but I also know I need to stay in my lane and want to find the balance of competency while also supporting this kiddo. Any and all advice and support would be appreciated.


r/slp • • Jul 20 '26

SNF/Hospital Hospital SLPs

0 Upvotes

Dear hospital SLP,
If your hospital does not include your evals and/or instrumentals in discharge paperwork, please go find your rehab director at your earliest convenience and tell them to escalate this issue, ask them to speak with case managers and do an internal audit if they must. Because after getting yet another 200-page discharge without any ST notes, I am submitting a complaint to Inspector General for negligence and naming the DOR (and will start including all SLPs working there too) in there. Enough is enough.


r/slp • • Sep 21 '22

SLP May never take mask off??

0 Upvotes

I have a 2-year-old with Down syndrome who has about 15 words. The SLP we have been assigned by the county is still wearing a mask to every session. I told her I respected that when we first started but now I am seeing comments in the news say ‘The Pandemic is over.’ I’m also part of a religious community who has been very conservative with mask wearing but even we will no longer be required to wear masks to meetings starting October 1. Our IDS is giving me videos of tactile cues for speech but all the SLP does is narrated play with the mask on. She is nice but I am concerned that my son is not getting what he needs from speech therapy. How would you handle this? She thanked me for respecting her choice but now I think she will never take the mask off and I am concerned for my sons progress. Should I ask for a different therapist? There is a huge shortage of SLPs in our area so at first I just felt lucky to have anyone coming but now I am thinking my child’s needs are not being met.


r/slp • • Feb 21 '26

Mamdani to raid the teacher pension fund?

0 Upvotes