r/sleeptrain • • Dec 10 '20

Too complicated

2.2k Upvotes

Your baby needs 11.33 hours of night sleep every night. Any less and they will be ruined as a person forever. Any more and the next morning they will wake up at 3:30am and do that for the next 2 years.

No sleep associations except for white noise, pacifier, swaddle, lovey. Except they can't use the lovey because they are babies. Get it out of their crib it will suffocate then. And stop using the swaddle when they are exactly 13 weeks old when you can tell that they are thinking about rolling over but spend $600 on transitional products. Then stop using the paci at 4 months. Wait, make that 6 months. No, a year. Whatever just let them keep it forever and put a bunch in their crib. But don't put anything in their crib.

Your baby needs 3 naps per day that are 1.25 hours long. Any more and they will not sleep tonight. Any less and they will not sleep tonight. And they will only sleep that long if you hold them. But make sure not to hold your baby to sleep. That's a sleep association and you don't want to be holding them to sleep even they're 22 years old do you?

Their room has to be 68 degrees fahrenheit. Any colder they will not sleep. Any warmer SIDS. And by their room I mean your room. For 6 months. No, let's make that a year.

Even though you are doing all of this stuff you baby is still sleeping like shit. It's not because they are a baby, it's because you're doing something wrong. Time to hire a pediatric sleep consultant for $150/minute.


r/sleeptrain • • May 06 '21

6 - 12 months Night gathers, and now my watch begins

1.1k Upvotes

It shall not end until the baby is asleep. I shall take no break, have no snacks, watch no netflix. I shall wear no pajamas and drink no tea. I shall live and die by wake windows. I am the blackout curtains in the darkness. I am the watcher on the monitor. I am the shield that guards the realms of bedtime. I pledge my life and honor to the Night’s Watch, for this night and all the nights to come.


r/sleeptrain • • Nov 19 '20

Vent it Out The cost and hype around Taking Cara Babies is really overblown

1.1k Upvotes

EDIT: While TCB is overhyped, it still may be worth it for certain situations. If you're still questioning whether you should buy the ABCs, I've written a different post here to address when it may be appropriate for you situation.

I'm not sure if this is allowed, but I just can't help myself. Please remove if inappropriate!

Disclaimer: if you're a fan of TCB, please don't read this as a dig at you! I was just about implement the program myself before going another route, and I'm sure it would have ultimately worked. I'll never judge a single parent for their sleep training choices, this is just a vent about the hype.

So anyway, here it is.

The cost is gross

The cost of TCB is not just overpriced, its almost exploitative. Selling sleep-products to sleep-deprived people is often not a recipe for ethical business practices, and TCB is no exception. Yes, I've bought other overpriced shit for my baby, but I've rarely done so out of desperation and crumbling mental health.

I won't even get started on the ABCs costing nearly $200, but the "3-4 month" guide is $40 for a PDF... that apparently you only get access to for 6 months?? I was partly spurred to write this rant after reading this post, where OP clarifies that she contacted customer service and they confirmed this policy was intentional. This level of greed is gross. Its a $40 PDF!!

The program is narrow

I've watched the whole ABCs program and read the accompanying guide. We all already know its Ferber. But I'm shocked at just how narrow the program is compared to other resources. Other resources will give you options. They'll talk about extinction, they'll talk about ways you can ease into sleep training, they'll talk about adapting for roomsharing and co-sleeping, they'll talk about continuing to night feed if you want.

Not TCB. The vibe is very much "sure, you can try to make changes, but then we can't guarantee anything will work, so we strongly recommend you follow this plan to the letter." I was already pretty suspicious about "pop-ins" (check-ins), I really didn't think they would work for my baby. I was also fine doing feedings 1-2 times a night, I just wanted LO to stop waking up 5 times a night. Roomsharing is also highly discouraged, but I didn't really want to move into the living room for 2 weeks.

This program would just not have worked for me, and there's not much information at all about what you're getting before you pay full price. I've also seen people asking on here whether they should get TCB for nap training when there is literally one video at the end of the whole thing about naps, which essentially boils down to "now do the same for naps." Obviously people don't know entirely what they're getting when they pay for the program.

I get it, there's a gold standard to the plan. Cara can't have a "99% success rate" of babies sleeping through the night if people are allowed to deviate from the gold standard, but if you're looking for various tips and options this program is not for you.

The format is... kind of dumb

I will try to contain my snarkiness... but what the heck are these acronyms? S.I.T.B.A.C.K.? C.U.T.F.E.E.D.S? I don't think this program represents some fantastic innovation of Ferber or whatever run-of-the-mill sleep programs, if anything its almost more confusing and wordy than needed.

The ABC videos are non-sensical!! The letter "L" is dedicated to copyright piracy for god's sakes! I'm kind of peeved that this "90+ minute" video series has like 5 minutes dedicated to lecturing you about illegally sharing the program!

The hype is overblown

Look, just don't spend your hard earned money on this thing unless you've tried cheaper resources and other methods first. If you've tried and read it all, and TCB is your last hurrah at sleep training sanity - its worth it. Or, if you like Cara, you want to support her, you like videos - go ahead. Again, no judgement!

But the fact that TCB is increasingly treated as the default approach on Reddit is totally disproportional to the quality and value of the program. It might seem like the secret, exclusive, hidden knowledge of sleep training, but its not. That's really what I wanted to say.

Fin


r/sleeptrain • • Sep 13 '20

Discussion what i learned about baby sleep half a year in

1.0k Upvotes

the rules changed for us just about every month. so in the words of that idiot song by rodney atkin: if you're going through hell, keep on going.

you can hold your bub for naps for three months straight and you will think it is an unending tunnel and two weeks into naps in the crib, you will miss the snuggles and revel in your newfound freedom because parenthood is weird.

some of the sleep hack stuff works, some of it doesn't. all of it is baby dependent. get on your local buy nothing group and work through the options because some nights you just need a tiny shred of hope in the form of the zen sleep sack. the miracle blanket and zipadee zip worked for us at various ages respectively, but who knows.

you can change the bedtime routine and bub can deal. just because a bath got you an extra two hours of sleep one night from it does not mean you need to kill yourself bathing him every day for the next four months. save your knees. he's not dirty anyways.

outside is magic. take the fusspot baby outside and enjoy the longer next nap.

if you have a contact napper, know that the libby/overdrive app will get you instant free access to thousands of e-books with just a library card.

if you have a heckuva time breastfeeding, don't sweat the feeding to sleep stuff. heck, don't sweat the feeding to sleep stuff anyways.

when you reach the deranged states of sleep deprivation, make your partners take shifts. 4 hours is evidently the minimum for not being a total zombie. if you're in the total sleep depravity despair, it will end.

your baby that rolled over in the cot is in all probability, very safe. you can check on him five different times and watch him breath, but you might wake him up and then he'll be pissed.

don't talk to parents with those docile, unicorn babies that sleep magically.

your bub might cry way less during ferber than he did during a 'normal' night.

your mom has probably forgotten about the sleep deprivation. don't listen to her when she says bub has too many naps or cries too much at bedtime or whatever. maybe parenting was easier in the 80s, i don't know. don't let it get to your head.

the app stuff helps a bit but you don't really need to be obsessive about it. have a vague idea of how long bub should stay awake at age appropriate times, and then just wear a watch and watch for sleepy cues. that's probably good enough.

huckleberry premium wasn't worth it for us. but the free app is great. helps me keep track of optimal bedtimes and when we're on a 11 day poop strike.

don't be afraid to try things. put him in the cot for a nap, go for a walk when you get the chance. sure, lots of routine is good. but total routine during lockdown can get a bit obsessive. don't forget to live.

one day you'll actually make it back down on the couch to watch tv with your partner. it'll be nice. sometimes you'll miss it. nothing will compare to watching your kid learn to scoot his little baby butt around on the rug.

if you're losing your mind from doing riverdance five times a day with a massively grumpy reflux baby to get him to nap, know that this ends. putting on wireless headphones and having a private rave helps some. ice cream helps some.

some nights sleep will totally and utterly suck, and then your bub will wake up with fifteen new consonants and sit up unassisted.

some nights sleep will just suck for unknown baby reasons, and you make yourself an extra large cup of coffee, put the cranberries on extra loud, and deal with it.

white noise helps, but then you might accidentally sleep train yourself so that you need white noise too. (just me? probably just me.)

people who didn't have babies just as the world locked down during a global pandemic say some of this stuff is easier in Normal Times. hang on to that, today if you need to.

if you're trying, chances are you're doing fine. if all else fails, check out this post of baby gear from the past and realize that if you haven't put your kid in the yard in a wicker cage, you're doing all right today.


r/sleeptrain • • Jan 14 '22

Success cyclemam's baby sleep guide

828 Upvotes

You might have seen my comments around this subreddit (a lot) and a few of you have encouraged me to make a mega post. (Ta-da! here it is!) Just quickly on why I have collected this copy-paste resource: I was really frustrated with how reddit works- lots of people posting the same question, with the upvote/downvote no one sees the same version of reddit, so it was hard for people to learn from other threads. I felt like I was typing out the same answers all the time, so I gathered them together and would copy/paste as needed. (so yes, please share, please steal!) I also was frustrated that there wasn't a good resource on gentle sleep methods.

This is a baby sleep guide, (not a sleep training guide) because even if you don't train, there's so much to learn about baby sleep that can help. This is what drew me to this sub initially- because who knows about sleep? People who sleep train.

Sleep training gets presented as this black and white "cosleep until they are seven, or leave baby to cry alone until their heart breaks" (neither an accurate representation!) and there's no middle ground presented. The middle ground exists! It's big! There are lots of sleep training methods that work, especially if you put in the work to set baby up for success.

General Principles

Before diving in, a common thing is that parents feel that they've "missed the boat" if they haven't started with a newborn, 4 month old, or whatever. It's never to late to get better sleep, you can jump in wherever you're at. You don't have to have followed the newborn bit to succeed at the later bits, and so on. Guide is organised chronologically by age, but skip up to where you're at.

All babies are individuals! The advice might not apply to your baby. Your baby might hit milestones at slightly different times. That said, the general patterns and principles are there because they seem to hold true for a lot of children, so if your child is way off what's 'normal' it might be time to look into that. You know your child best, though.

Be aware of the process: while nightweaning might be the ultimate goal, independent sleep and a good schedule are the steps before that, it doesn't work so well to jump straight to night weaning.

Talk to your child about what's going on. Yes, they might not understand yet, but that's how immersion works. Eventually, they will!

I'm no expert. I only have a sample size of one (new baby joining us in 2022, we'll see how we go!) plus learning lots of stuff about sleep through this sub, getting feedback on whether my advice worked. Precious Little Sleep by Alexis Dubief is an amazing resource. I lean heavily on her website! (Parenting pro-tip- buy the ebook, you can read it on your phone when holding that baby!)

Newborns

Nawww. Welcome to the world, little one.

Here's a comment I made about newborns https://www.reddit.com/r/sleeptrain/comments/k439pn/anyone_willing_to_share_a_newborn_guide/ge7imn1/

Here's Precious Little Sleep's newborn guide https://www.preciouslittlesleep.com/newborn-baby-sleep-survival-guide/

The big comment: a guide to sleep training (gentle focus)

(this is basically what I've been spamming this sub with for the last year. :) )


The first thing to set up to give yourself the best chance of sleep training success is to establish a schedule or rhythm with age appropriate wake windows- (scroll down for the chart, can skip the article if you like) so baby isn't over or under tired at bed time. (For naps, this guide to short naps really helped us. )

Another thing to make sure is that you have a calm and consistent bed time routine where your last feed is ending half an hour before bed time, and ends with baby in bed by themselves with the same conditions for the night. (Baby needs to be biologically ready- really little babies just fall asleep when eating- it's natural.)

This article at Precious Little Sleep explains what's going on with baby sleep. It is a good summary and worth reading!

All sleep training will involve a little fussing, this article helps explain what that looks like: Fussing vs Crying

There are a lot of sleep training methods. Here are some gentle ones, others are Ferber and CIO. I feel it's important to understand the theory of what you're trying to achieve (independent sleep) and find a mix of methods that work for your family.

Gentle Sleep training methods:

  1. Give baby a chance method

  2. Sleep lady shuffle

  3. Pick up put down, camp it out and chair method are others.

I really recommend Precious Little Sleep, the ebook is really reasonably priced. There are a range of options explored.

What we did

DIY Gentle Method - a mix of methods that worked for us.

This is what we did for feed to sleep - we chose to do that before sleep training, some families move right to sleep training. My husband has said that he wouldn't do this again, but I think it worked ok, but not as a sleep training method.


A potential issue with gentle methods

So the goal of sleep training is independent sleep- baby needs to fall asleep alone in order to know it's OK to fall asleep alone, so when they microwake at the end of a sleep cycle, they slip into the next one instead of waking up and going "hey!! where's my sleep help?!" Methods like pick up put down and the chair method don't remove the parent until the end of the process, so you've got to be consistent for a LONG time and might not see results until you remove yourself. You don't have to leave baby a long time, but they need a chance to fall asleep alone.

Tips by age- I guess a bit of a FAQ.

2-4 months ish
This is when things get HARD. Lovely newborn conk out all the time, sleep anywhere is GONE. Baby is starting to really wake up and notice the world. If the first three months are the fourth trimester, this is like labour.

A lot of parents post asking if it's too early to sleep train. And yes, if we're talking traditional cry it out methods, it's too early to sleep train. However, you can start gently practicing independent sleep, knowing that you may need to step in and help baby sleep if it's been too long (max 20 minutes.)

Undertired is a sneaky enemy- for a long time overtired has been your main enemy, and suddenly UNDERTIRED sneaks in and looks exactly like over tired. Finding the balance between them can be tricky! But around now is the time to ask "maybe baby needs to stay awake just a smidge longer".

With little babies, sometimes you go to put baby to bed early, they aren't tired, but they aren't being stimulated, so the nap doesn't work. If it's been 30 minutes of trying for a nap, give up, go do something else for half and hour, and try again.

https://www.preciouslittlesleep.com/what-we-learned-from-the-rock-n-play-recall/ - A really interesting blog post about why it's no longer reccommended to do sleep in swings, and why it's important to encourage independent sleep as soon as possible, before parents curl up from exhaustion.

If your baby doesn't like swaddling, don't worry. It's harder to get rid of later. If your baby hates being unswaddled, stick with it. They do get used to it eventually.

4 months

  • It's normal for naps to be crappy. It's normal to have a lot! We had 5 regularly at one point.

  • If you don't train, the 'regression' (major sleep development) will get better as their sleep cycles lengthen, but independent sleep solves a lot.

  • It is normal to be waking at night to feed, still.

  • Yes, the regression is the sign that baby may be ready to sleep train. You don't have to wait until it ends- it won't.

  • If you haven't ditched the swaddle, do so.

5 months (aka dropping to 3 naps?)
Somewhere in the 4-6 months range, the development for consolidating naps happens. Baby is changing a LOT in a short amount of time, so you thought you'd figured out the wake windows that work? They probably need stretching. Some people really push dropping to three naps already, but make sure baby is getting enough day sleep before you do. We were on four naps at 5 months and had dropped to 3 at the end of the month. It's OK to hold on to a nap if baby needs it.

It's also still really normal to be feeding a few times overnight still.

6 - 7 months (aka dropping to 2 naps?) Six months is tricky because baby is starting to grow out of the three nap schedule, but probably isn't quite ready to drop to two naps. From now on, the secret to dropping naps is: "can baby stay awake long enough?".

My advice is to lock in bed time to a fixed actual clock time, like 7pm, 7:30pm, 8pm, or whatever suits your family. (Think about your desired wake time too- some babies do 12 hour nights, some 11, and some, 10.) This way you can take advantage of the circadian rhythm.

As you gently stretch wake windows and hopefully naps get longer, nap three will get squeezed until it's too short to keep, and you'll drop to two naps.

Here's our nap dropping experience. https://www.reddit.com/r/sleeptrain/comments/ll6gja/dropped_a_nap/

8-10 months
Separation anxiety might be a thing, developments might make things interesting. Things like sitting in the bed, standing in the bed and not being able to lie down, etc. It's OK to leave baby to figure it out. Lots of daytime practice helps, but ultimately they've got to apply those skills.

We really enjoyed being on a clock based schedule (based on 3/3/4) instead of rigidly following wake windows.

11-16 months (aka dropping to one nap??) Like dropping to 2 naps, the criteria is: can baby stay awake long enough? There can be a 'false sign' that baby is ready to drop to one nap around the 10-13 month stage- often this is because of the explosion of development (words, walking) that might be happening about now. You might need to cap naps and max out a two nap schedule. We found that once running was a thing, baby was getting physically tired and went back to taking full advantage of two 90 minute naps during the day.

We found the 12 month regression real, it kicked our butts. But at 12 months we added two small, safe, soft toys for night sleep (sometimes called 'loveys') and this made a big difference for sleep.

Dropping to one nap was one of the harder transitions we've done. (We moved to one nap at 15 months. Like walking, the range of when babies are developmentally ready to drop is very big! Some babies keep two naps until 18 months, some drop around 12.) Suddenly we were back to wake windows and trying to stretch them 10 minutes at a time. If we stretched too far the nap would be too short and the day would be hard. We were stuck on 11:20am naps for a while. (11:30? No way!) Figuring out when to feed her was tricky. But it was worth the pain and we are now back on a one nap clock based schedule. (Up at 7, nap 12-2, bedtime 8pm)

Older kiddos

How to use a toddler alarm clock (PLS)

For older kids, there are four methods that I know of.

  1. chair method- also called sleep lady shuffle. Basically you gradually move a chair out of the room by moving it a little each night.

  2. excuses method. This is like reverse Ferber. Instead of check ins, check out. Do your routine with snuggles etc, but leave with an excuse like "I have to go to the toilet, I'll be right back" etc. Teaching kiddo that you do keep your promise, you will be back, and they are ok to be alone and hopefully fall asleep. Longer and longer "check outs" after a fairly short initial one.

  3. Super Nanny method. There's a process, but basically you just end up plopping kid back into bed until they give up and stay in bed.

  4. baby gate the room, kid proof, they may fall asleep on the floor, that's cool. Then do CIO or other more standard younger kid method. (This is for kids who aren't in a cot/crib anymore.

Other topics

Wake window notation
Often used as a shorthand in this sub, something like 3/3/4 means that baby has a two nap schedule (/ is a nap) with wake windows of three hours, three hours, and four hours.

The over tired spiral
When baby gets overtired, so they don't sleep, so they get overtired, so they don't sleep- this is miserable. We found you need to FIGHT baby to sleep however you can (rocking, etc) to reset.

Distraction Technique
Babies get FOMO. (Fear Of Missing Out). Then they develop the ability to recognise A, then B, means that C is coming up next. (C is sleep! We don't want sleep!) We found that after getting baby ready for bed we would go and do something else for a few minutes (talking to the 'mirror baby' or going outside if really upset) before continuing the routine when baby was calm.

Naps
Naps are mentioned all through the guide, but a quick naps guide https://www.preciouslittlesleep.com/monumental-guide-to-short-naps/

It's really normal for naps to be short and painful (to get) until the development for consolidated naps kicks in around 4-6 months.

I suggest doing nights first, then naps, not all at once. For training naps, do one at a time, not all at once. Try leaving baby for 10-15 minutes and then rescue the nap if needed, the overall rhythm of the day is important to overnight sleep.

If baby is happy in their cot, it's OK to leave them until you want to get them up!

Night weaning
So worth it- our baby is finally sleeping through. For us, there was a lot of talking about how the milkies were getting smaller (I was capping feeds and cutting down minutes per side- the pace that worked for us was about 1 minute a week- too fast and she'd wake up more often.) Then we talked about how the milkies are available when the sun is shining, that the milkies are sleeping at night time now and we can have them in the morning.

For initial training, not feeding before midnight was a really helpful guideline- if we fed before midnight we were in for a bad night.

https://www.preciouslittlesleep.com/what-you-need-to-know-about-sleeping-through-the-night-part-3 - PLS night weaning guide

https://www.drjaygordon.com/blog-detail/sleep-changing-patterns-in-the-family-bed - we also found this article helpful- even though it's from the perspective of a bed sharing advocate, it has a gentle nightweaning approach that I borrowed from.

If your baby is older than 6 months, talk to your doctor if night weaning is appropriate. Some babies still feed overnight until 12 months. (Or longer, but once past 12 months I think parent can choose to night wean.)

Other things we've found useful

Water before bed! Sometimes kids are just thirsty. It's ok to offer a sip of water (we do it after brushing teeth) and it helps with sleeping through.

Before bed time snack- we found we need to time this so it doesn't result in a feed to sleep association, but we offer porridge, banana and yogurt before bed. Apparently the banana can help with muscle aches.


r/sleeptrain • • Jan 07 '21

Caught myself looking at our yawning cat thinking ’better get her to bed before she gets overtired’ 🤦🏻‍♀️

655 Upvotes

r/sleeptrain • • Aug 06 '21

Let's Chat Precious Little Sleep AMA

593 Upvotes

I was asking the author of PLS (Alexis Dubief) questions on Twitter about some sleep training stuff, and mentioned that r/sleeptrain always refers to her book because it’s super helpful. She mentioned she had offered to do an AMA here but the mods never got back to her, but the offer still stands. Just wondering if anyone on here would like for her to do an AMA? I know I sure would!


r/sleeptrain • • Apr 01 '21

Let's Chat Help! Our baby falls asleep in her bassinet every night before we have a chance to apply any of the sleeping training methods. What are we doing wrong?!

590 Upvotes

We have spent dozens of hours reading about baby sleep since the second trimester. However, our three months old falls asleep by herself every night before we have a chance to use any of the techniques we learned. She has been doing this basically since birth. How do we practice CIO or FIO if she doesn’t cry at bedtime? Any idea how to develop this “bedtime routine” we have heard so much about if she is already asleep before we start step one of the routine? Are we supposed to S.I.T.B.A.C.K and drink a glass of wine during her first sleep stretch (six hours)? None of the sleep training scenarios seem to apply to us and we are so lost and confused. Please help!


r/sleeptrain • • Aug 14 '20

Killing myself to get my 8 m.o. to sleep, turns out I was the problem

578 Upvotes

After 54 hours of labor, Ivy was born at home on my living room floor on Nov 22 2019. Sleeping was impossible. I hated to hear her cry, my body instinctively responded to her and I couldn’t imagine stopping it. My mother-in-law warned me not to “let her use my boob as a pacifier”, but I always let her nurse as much as she wanted and it seemed to be her go to comfort as she never took a rubber pacifier or a bottle. When she was tiny, I would swaddle her, nurse her to sleep, and then in super slow motion put her down in the bassinet. 70% of the time she would wake up and I would have to start all over again. It would regularly take me 45 min to and hour or more to get her down, for every nap and every time she woke up throughout the night.

As she got bigger and was rolling as we had to stop swaddling, I started using the Snuggle Me pillow to put her down without waking her up. I would nurse her while she was lying in the pillow on my lap, then after she dozed I would unlatch her and pick the pillow up with her on it and slow motion transfer to crib. She would usually wake 20 min later and I would have to start again. I got no time alone with my husband, I started to resent him as he got to sit downstairs and watch TV as I killed myself to get our girl to sleep.

Around 6 months she got too big for the pillow. I could not put her down without waking her up. I actually started nursing and rocking her to sleep, then climbing into the crib with her still on my boob and lying down with her in her crib until she reached a deep sleep at which time I would unlatch her and do some silent slow motion ninja moves to get out of the crib without waking her. I would do this 3,4 sometimes 6 times between bedtime (7ish) and when my husband and I would go to sleep around midnight. Then the next time she woke up I would just give up and take her in bed with me.

Then she started rolling over and crawling and pulling herself up on the crib. I was at a loss. I would spend hours every day and night rocking her, fighting her as she’s simultaneously breastfeeding and kicking me away with both feet. One night I punched the crib in frustration when she awoke as I was climbing out.

We had to make a change. We decided we were going to try cry it out with my husband in the room, not me. I did the bedtime routine, bath, stories, songs and nursing, then put her in her crib awake and said night night mommy loves you go to sleep. She started crying immediately.

Then my husband went in. I hate to admit I had no confidence in his ability to soothe her. At first he just sat in the chair next to the crib and told her it’s going to be ok. She cried for about 20 minutes that first night. When her crying got bad, he picked her up but he also couldn’t put her down without waking her. So he started just rubbing her back and laying her down when she stood up, saying positive things like I believe in you baby, it’s ok, you can do this your doing great.

2 days later and it takes him 5 minutes to put her to bed, when she awakens at night and for naps. She protests minimally at first, more grumbles than real cries though. Tonight he put her in her crib and she laid right down and put herself to sleep. I watched on the monitor totally dumbfounded.

My recommendation to all you weary moms who feel like your the only one who can get your babe to sleep - is maybe, if you have someone to help, try removing yourself from the equation. Try it first at night when she is really tired. The first night is tough. Hearing her cry when I knew I had what she thought she needed (boobies) was hell. But it’s worth it. I was the mom who said I would never sleep train. And now I say screw all the heated opinions around those words “sleep training.” If where your at isn’t working, make a change. Sleep is important and so is your mental health and alone time/ time for your relationship or marriage. Baby needs sleep for brain development. A rested mom is a happy mom is a good mom 🤍


r/sleeptrain • • Apr 20 '23

1 year + So freaking sick of social media pushing the idea that sleep training is child abuse.

575 Upvotes

My sister in law told me letting your baby fuss or cry for a little bit at night to learn how to self soothe is child abuse. Every Tik Tok video on Cosleeping or sleep training is full of commenters saying shit like “sleep training is lazy. You’re rewiring your infants brain to not trust you just because you need sleep.”

My daughters lack of sleep made me suicidal. When we sleep trained her she never was allowed to cry for more than 15-20 mins. She sleeps through the night now every single night unless she’s sick or teething, which is how I know she WILL wake me up if she needs me.

Someone in my life had the gall to tell me their child must be more attached to them than my daughter is to me because they cosleep with their child.

Social media can just f*ck right off.


r/sleeptrain • • Jan 04 '22

6 - 12 months Middle of the night, just you and I

567 Upvotes

It's 2 AM and I hear you stir. Will you go back to sleep like you often do? Or will this be one of the nights you need a little bit of help?

The crying starts and we start the timer. 1 minute seems like an hour - 10 minutes an eternity. Fleeting moments of anger flit through my mind, but then I wonder - what is going through your mind as you raise your little head up towards us. Are you sleepy? Or is the "mamamam" sound you make while crying a plea for me to come to your side? How can I be angry when you are crying out for help? I try to tune you out - climbing Everest would be easier.

The timer goes off and I spring out of bed to pick you up. You put your little arms around my neck, your breathing slows down, and your body turns to lead. You let out a little sigh and fall asleep in my arms with your head on my shoulder. I'm tired, you are tired. . I place my hand on your back and feel the rhythm of you breathing. You needed me and so I'm here. I'll keep you safe and give you comfort. I don't want to ever let go. Time stands still and in this moment, it is just you and I.

We make it through the night. You seem no worse for wear while we feel like road kill. I drag myself bleary-eyed into my office, barely making it through the morning. As I lay my head on my desk feeling sorry for myself, I remember your little arms around my neck. I remember feeling your breath under my hand, the smell of your hair. And even in the throes of sleep derived desperation I realize that this is just a phase - this won't last forever. And I need to just be in those moments together when it's the middle of the night and it's just you and I.


r/sleeptrain • • May 30 '21

Let's Chat “Unicorn babies” exist. It’s not your fault if yours isn’t one!

549 Upvotes

I’m coming back here as a second time mom with some new perspective.

My oldest son, now 20 months, was a horrible sleeper. He wouldn’t go in his bassinet until he was a few weeks old. He’d pop awake at the slightest movement, despite being wrapped as tightly as a burrito. He’d scream his little lungs out the minute we put him down and he needed to be nursed to sleep. He woke 3-5x/night right up until we sleep trained him at 4 months. I used to get so upset when people would say to put him down drowsy but awake, or use wake windows, or put him to bed earlier to make him sleep later. Nothing worked! I wondered what I was doing wrong.

Turns out, nothing. I wasn’t doing anything wrong. I just had a tough sleeper. I have 3 month old twins. They’re unicorns. I keep waiting for the other shoe to drop and for them to hit a regression, but so far so good. From birth, I could put them down awake and they’d go to sleep without crying. By 10 weeks, they were sleeping 10-11 hours at night. They nap for 1.5-2 hours three times a day.

Seeing how easy these babies are, I’m realizing that I didn’t do anything wrong when it came to my oldest son’s sleep. He just wasn’t a unicorn. So if people tell you that something works great for them and it won’t work for you, don’t blame yourself. Different kids respond to different strategies, and you need to find what works for you!


r/sleeptrain • • Dec 19 '24

Success Story The 2-yawn rule and some other unsolicited advice from a mother of 4

411 Upvotes

I have 4 kids, ranging in age from 6 months to 6 years, so I’ve been living the sleep training life for some time now. The holidays have always been the hardest time of year, between traveling, late night parties, and the inevitable sicknesses, it can feel like your LO will never get back on schedule. So I wanted to share what I call the “2 yawn rule” (or alternatively the “put your money where your mouth is” rule 😆)

If your baby has been missing sleep due to unusual circumstances (not because they’re growing into a new developmentally appropriate sleep range), trying to keep them on their regular schedule the next day can unintentionally lead to an even more overtired baby and land you in that vicious “too tired to sleep” feedback loop. If you’ve had a rough night or if your baby is struggling to make it through their usual wake window, don’t be afraid to just pop them back in bed! My rule of thumb is if baby yawns twice or more within 20 minutes or so, they’re tired enough to at least try a nap. Doesn’t matter when their next nap is supposed to be, just let them try to get some sleep and then re-work the schedule from there. You might try to wake them up in time for their last wake window to be close to normal, or you might just say “fuck it” and let them sleep as much as they want. After one or two of these catch up days it will hopefully be a bit easier to get back onto their usual schedule.

And while we’re on the topic of getting off schedule… during the holidays it can be a real struggle to fit in your kids’ sleep in between all the festivities. Naps and bedtime can be an excellent excuse for getting out of invitations and obligations you don’t want to go to! But, as someone who is a strong believer in the importance of sleep and the sanctity of the schedule… I would gently challenge you to let things slide a little bit this season. Yes, I know that skipping a nap can turn into a meltdown and/or a sleepless night. But there are some things that are worth a sleepless night (or even a sleepless week.) If you don’t want to go to the office Christmas party anyway, absolutely use your kids bedtime as an out! But oftentimes the connections and relationships built between your baby and your village this time of year are far more beneficial than a good night’s sleep.

Christmas of 2019, I had a 2 month old and a 20 month old. The 2 month old only slept while being held, and I had to be very strict with my 20 month old’s schedule, or else she’d turn into a total gremlin by sundown. That wasn’t going to be possible with the Christmas schedule we had planned out, and I was dreading it. But I did it anyway. They barely slept at all spending the night at my parents’ house. The baby cried through the whole Christmas party with my Grandparents. The toddler cried the whole drive home. The next few days were rough to say the least! I didn’t know it at the time, but between Covid and my grandparents getting older, that was the last Christmas we’d ever have at the farm. Now when I look back at the pictures we took of Grandpa with all his great-grandchildren, my 2 month old crying in Grandpa’s lap while my 20 month old sucked her thumb for dear life, I thank my lucky stars that I didn’t let their nap schedule keep us away from that party.

Sleep training and getting my babies on a routine nap schedule has been one of the best parenting moves I’ve ever made. I’m sure a lot of you feel the same! But don’t let the schedule hold you and your babies back from experiencing the holidays! Sometimes you just gotta embrace the suck.


r/sleeptrain • • Apr 02 '21

Let's Chat Spite sleep? I'll take it!

411 Upvotes

My little guy doesn't really do "drowsy but awake."

What he does do is snap his eyes open to glare at me with unadulterated contempt at my obvious abandonment and poor parenting practices the moment his little back touches the crib. He holds eye contact for a good few seconds to make me fully understand the depths of my betrayal and inadequacy as a parent for daring to expect him to sleep by himself(!) before rolling away from me with as much force as a 3.5 month old can roll and looking back once more to make sure I've recieved his stink eye and know that I'm not allowed anywhere near him anymore for having broken his trust. And then falls asleep with a sigh to let the world know that he's not happy with it.

He basically spite sleeps at night and after a day full day of nap fighting meltdowns I'll take it and try not to laugh.

Anyone else have a "gotta laugh (silently!) or else I'll cry" story?


r/sleeptrain • • Jun 03 '22

4 - 6 months unpopular sleep opinion

396 Upvotes

I know this is specifically a sleep training forum but I did just want to let anyone know who needed to hear this that whatever you do to yet your baby to sleep is not a bad thing UNTIL it becomes a problem for you.

I rocked my son to sleep for every nap and bedtime and they learned to link sleep cycles just fine when it was developmentally appropriate for him. (around 5 months) My nieces and nephews were all rocked to sleep and they're great sleepers too. My son literally pushed away from me at 7 months when i tried to rock him and has been putting himself to bed ever since.

Point being: if it is working fine for you to nurse to sleep or rock to sleep, don't feel the need to change just because "experts" say your child needs to fall asleep independently by 4 months.


r/sleeptrain • • Mar 01 '23

Let's Chat Some babies are just bad sleepers, and there's nothing you can do about it.

388 Upvotes

From the time my baby was born I was determined to have a good sleeper. I obsessed over wake windows, schedules, always put her down awake, and rarely allowed contact napping. I read all the books and joined all the groups. I did everything "right." Eventually I hired a sleep consultant and did what she said, down to the letter.

My baby still sucks at sleep. She has never slept through the night, and I can count on one hand the nights where she's only woken up once. She's 14 months old.

Moral of the story? I would tell new parents two things:

  1. Some babies are just bad sleepers no matter how hard you try. It is not your fault.

  2. Having a healthy interest in baby sleep is fine. There's nothing wrong with trying different things and installing good habits (and always practice safe sleep!). But don't let it become an obsession, and for god sake, don't let it get in the way of enjoying your baby. If you miss a wake window by 15 minutes, it's not the end of the world. If your baby has an extra short or long nap, you are not doomed. And if you want to have a snuggly contact nap, DO IT. None of this will change anything in the grand scheme of things.

(I'm not looking for advice by the way .. believe me, I've tried it all.)


r/sleeptrain • • Sep 27 '25

Let's Chat I'm so sick of the anti sleep training trend and shaming

385 Upvotes

I got shamed on Facebook yesterday for mentioning how amazing sleep training was for our family. People accused me of traumatizing my daughter, that I "taught her to not go to me for her needs", that sleep training "causes mental disorders", that my degree in psychology is a "sham" if they didn't teach me emotional development of babies (which they DID, and in fact suggested sleep training), and that I "shouldn't have had kids if I didn't want to deal with wake ups". What the frick? Whenever I brought up the research and asked them what their research was, they stopped responding. I don't understand why people think it's better for both me and my daughter to be waking up every hour because she doesn't know how to sleep, as opposed to letting her cry it out and now getting long stretches of sleep. I'm so sick of the whole "anti sleep training trend". It's not backed by science!


r/sleeptrain • • Aug 26 '24

Let's Chat A year on - the highs and lows of baby sleep

382 Upvotes

1 year ago today I joined reddit out of desperation. I'd been sucked into the concept of wake windows, independent sleep and sleep regressions largely by TikTok. As a first time mother, I didn't know who else to turn to....

My babe was not following the rule book. She was exclusively contact napping, being fed to sleep and had no concept of bedtime. Rather, she'd fall asleep in my arms and then I'd bravely attempt a cot transfer. Looking back, she was a thriving 14 week old baby but I was so consumed by her sleep, that I was in the pits of depression and had self referred myself into therapy.

The following months were brutal and I spent hours (literally, up to 5 whilst she slept on my chest) trawling through forums and trying to improve her sleep situation. Turns out there was nothing to really improve, just my attitude and expectations. She woke only for 1 feed but my perfectionism meant this wasn't good enough. I needed her to sleep through and by herself.

What this did to me was soul destroying. My girl was a project, something to fix. My life revolved around her sleep and my relationship with her suffered. I couldn't bond with her because I saw her sleep as a hindrance to my life. This is despite her sleeping very well (14 hours a day a lot of the time) but I needed more from her. I needed that perfect 12 hour night, her to follow online wake windows and for her to drop naps at an appropriate time. I resented contact naps and felt trapped. I looked at other parents with rage as they were getting so much done, going out for meals and had a baby just 'slot' into their life. Essentially a baby that just slept in the cot.

Now at 15 months post partum, I look back at myself a year ago and feel sad at the joy that was robbed from me because of my sleep obsession. Yes, I had postpartum depression and anxiety, but sleep was the trigger.

If you're still reading this, you are doing a great job and don't let the online world tell you otherwise. Make the changes you need to, but don't be fooled that baby sleep is linear and/or easy to fix. The only thing that can be fixed is one's attitude and approach to it. For me, things that helped were taking risks (travelling, risking naps on the go, letting others handle her sleep), finding hobbies and accepting uncertainty.

In the end, we chose to aim for independent sleep, but set a goal of a few months to achieve this. We essentially replaced feeding to sleep with bouncing to sleep, which was then replaced by crib jiggling and then chest patting. After 6 weeks or so, she found her thumb and the rest is history. There's been lots of hurdles and we still do 1 contact nap a day. But this is something we cherish and have kept out of choice rather than necessity. We're not afraid to tend to her overnight or assist her to sleep if needed. I don't live in fear anymore and can finally feel present with my little one.

If you've bothered to read all of this, thank you. Baby sleep is integral to your mental health but please don't let it consume you xxx


r/sleeptrain • • Apr 26 '22

9 - 16 weeks At first I was afraid, I was sleep deprived

381 Upvotes

Kept thinking I would never sleep for more than 3 hours at a time

But then I spent so many nights letting you cry it out

And I grew strong

And now I can sleep for long


r/sleeptrain • • Jan 04 '22

Let's Chat TCB is a Trump supporter

380 Upvotes

Just to put it out there again… I’m going to leave my opinion for myself, this is just information that some parents - positive or negative - might find helpful in deciding if they want to purchase her products.


r/sleeptrain • • Dec 14 '24

Success Story I’m so sick of the mom martyrs telling me that sleep training my kid is abusive. TW: suicidal ideation + attempt NSFW

373 Upvotes

From the time my daughter was born, I got severe PPD and was in a psych ward when she was 12 days old. What triggered it? The lack of sleep and extreme pain I was in.

My husband and I were doing 3 hour shifts because neither of us could stay awake long enough since in our 3 day stay at the hospital we got maybe a total of 5 hours of sleep (in 3 days). It didn’t help that since I had been torn and stitched standing up was excruciating.

One night we were so dangerously tired that we decided to just put her in the room with us in her crib and sleep while she slept. She wouldn’t fucking sleep. Every 5 minutes she’d wake up wailing.

I went into the bathroom and self harmed and told my husband to take me to the ER. I have pretty severe BPD amongst other things and didn’t know how much sleep deprivation would make these things worse.

We had to go live with his grandparents and they had to help us take care of our daughter because I was literally so suicidal.

Finally at my daughter’s 6 month appointment I asked “should she be able to self soothe and go to sleep on her own?” My pediatrician said “yes” adamantly, and told us to sleep train. This child is and always was in the 93rd percentile for weight and height. So her size wasn’t a problem. She was just so used to us coming at her beck and call for every little thing (not talking about if she’s hungry or her diaper is full. We’d do both of these things and she’d still wake up screaming 5 min later. She also transferred to the crib after we rocked her AWFULLY. No matter what. She’d wake up)

I couldn’t do it anymore. So we sleep trained. She’s a spirited child. The first night was 50 min of crying (we’d check on her and say ‘it’s ok, we’re here’ every now and then so she didn’t think she was abandoned). We did this for about a week. Things improved. But not before my husband’s grandmother essentially kicked us out and told us that we were abusing her by trying to teach her independent fucking sleep.

We go back home and lo and behold, my child sleeps 12 hours without screaming her head off for us to come in the middle of the night. She still wakes up, but instead of screaming now she just plays in her crib. We hear her sometimes.

This is just an anecdotal about how sleep training my bad sleeper saved my fucking life. I’m so glad that some of these mommy martyrs have strong enough mental health to wake up at 2am when their toddler is screaming to play with them and they do it (yes, an actual comment I saw on Tik Tok. I’m sorry but if my toddler wakes up at 2am and wants me to play with her, I’m telling her go back to sleep and we’ll play tomorrow.)

This shit almost killed me. Sleep training is the one thing that saved me. But some of these people would have rather me kill myself than god forbid teach my baby independent sleep.


r/sleeptrain • • Mar 04 '24

Success Story For the parents on the fence about CIO

355 Upvotes

I was you. I was actually more in the "don't believe in it" camp. I live in a country where it is considered cruel and I also saw it as a way to fit my baby into a capitalist way of living that depended on me being sharp at work...which also did not sit right with me. I did not judge my friends who did CIO or Ferber, but I knew it was not for us.

We tried everything. Cosleeping, bedsharing, every schedule tweak imaginable, but nothing was working. Then, after months of my baby waking up every 1 to 1.5 hours, I almost shook him in desperation in the middle of the night. I immediately stepped back and we committed to CIO that following night.

Well, one week later my baby just got placed in the crib and drifted off to sleep without a sound. He wakes up 2x to feed and goes back down easily and wakes at 7:30 with a huge smile. He's happier during the day, eating better, and my partner and I now are infinitely better parents than we were before. If you are on the fence, this is another success story to help get you there if you need it.


r/sleeptrain • • May 11 '25

1 year + I deleted Huckleberry

354 Upvotes

I downloaded huckleberry when I was in the throes of the 4 month sleep regression and it became my lifeline. I used it every day to track every nap to the minute. My nap schedule was militant! It was kind of miserable because it was hard to get out and do anything but also made a huge difference in my sons attitude, so it was worth it. Well, my son is now almost 21 months and we just dropped to 1 nap. His sleep is so consistent and predictable that I deleted the app! I’m so proud of myself and him 😅 just wanted to share some success.

We did the Ferber method around 5/6 months and it saved my life (only slightly exaggerating)


r/sleeptrain • • May 21 '21

Let's Chat Sleep training question

352 Upvotes

Can you sleep train a 34 year old? At 419 months I need some advice on daytime wake windows and what to do about night wakeups and my inability to fall asleep independently. I’d like to aim for 8 total hours of night sleep and one 0.5/1 hour nap per day. Is there a form that can be submitted to my boss to make this happen? I estimate that my wake windows should be 6 hours but can be stretched. Not anticipating the boss to be on board or the baby to let naps happen.

Night wakeups include racing thoughts and difficulty putting self back to sleep. Tried CIO for falling asleep, but very stubborn and I’m not crying but not sleeping. White noise helps!

Advice appreciated!

/s

-signed a wakeful parent who is trying to be funny but also wants to sleep better tomorrow night