So, I started over. Deleted all downloaded mods, erased the .ini files, fresh, clean install. Launched the game, went through the playroom intro, got to the menu, no issues.
And then I started installing mods. SKSEVR, all the basics like VRIK, HIGGS, etc. Didn't go too crazy, just added basic functionality stuff.
But now, whenever I launch the game, regardless of whether I have the playroom turned on or off, I get the bethesda splash screen, then it goes to the dragon logo, I see the fog in a dark room, hear the main menu music, and... nothing. The menu never appears, and i'm just trapped in a foggy void with the dragon logo.
I'm not sure what's caused this. I can post my current mod list in a couple of hours when i'm back at home. But in the meantime, I was hoping maybe someone's run into this issue before and may have some insight. Google was unhelpful, just found solutions for flatrim and suggestions about deleting the .ini files.
EDIT: Solved. I had "bLoadVRPlayroom=0" under the [Archive] header by mistake and I guess that ruined everything somehow!