r/skulduggerypleasant • • Feb 17 '25

Discussion I think I know the biggest issue with Phase Two

7 Upvotes

Made a post a while back about being an OG fan who's never read Phase Two because he didn't know it existed. I agree with the sentiment they're a step down and I think there's one reason why.

Omen Darkly. Jheeze what a terrible character.

For five books we have to slog through a boring and weak teenager getting endlessly embarrassed at school. He doesn't even have redeeming features. He's not funny, he's not smart and worst of all, he's not endearing. The amount of chapters that end with a random teacher or student (god knows why there's so many introduced) just mocking Omen and Omen just taking it. And the way Derek Landy writes them, it's like we're supposed to side with the people mocking him.

I get the point, he's not the Chosen One. He's not Auger. But oh my word there is never a reason to root for him, besides he tends to end up on Skulduggery and Valkyrie's side. Even after the Sebastian Tau reveal we just have to accept he's got a bizarre belief system on top of it all. And don't even get me started on the ludicrous Darquesse spawning a baby of herself storyline. Wtf is that?


r/skulduggerypleasant • • Jan 14 '20

[LEAKED] Netflix Animation Adaptation of SP confirmed and has finished Pre-production

0 Upvotes

I've come into contact with someone who works as a Show runner at Netflix based in the USA.

Derek Landy has kept is quiet for a while that an Animated Adaption has been greenlit for Netflix. According to sources that's what his recent trips to US have been regarding. Character designs and expression sheets have been finalized, I have 2 in my possession of Nefarian Serpine and Mevolent, the lack of Nefarian's red right hand and Mevolent's character outfit has been indicated of an origin story.

Character #008 and #Character 009

Voice Actors have been chosen, some famous, more new talent, auditions held over the last year and a half. Pre-production has just finished and Production is scheduled to start late 2020.

Artist credited but not legible.


r/skulduggerypleasant • • May 12 '26

Question What are your thoughts on the general world building of SKP setting?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I think it’s really, really abyssal. From power systems to organizations, it is definitely the worst aspect of the setting for me. What is worse is that there are really some cool ideas and fresh takes on creatures and monsters, at least on the first books. They had this gothic charm on them. But newer ones seem to be very generic…

Despite this I still enjoy the books. What are your takes on this?

Edit: My dumb ass accidentally wrote SKP instead of SDP… sorry about that


r/skulduggerypleasant • • May 26 '25

Discussion Erskine Ravel deserved better Spoiler

2 Upvotes

That's it. That's the post. It's my first post here and I'm in the mood to start some fires.


r/skulduggerypleasant • • Nov 26 '24

Discussion Taken names Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So, I've finally got fed up with the taken names, am I the only one starting to just find them dumb?

I finally realised that Alice is called Winter Grevious, I mean Jesus Christ. They've always kind of been like that, and I've posted before about this probably being me changing but it is just stupid. Everyone sounds like a 00s emo band. I get some of these are because teens are coming up with them, but come on.

Is this just the transition from the old books being more aimed at kids so it kind of fit the tone more, and now the YA and older side makes it seem worse? Like Skulduggery is a crazy name, but he is a skeleton so may as well, same with ghastly and the scars, own it. But I feel like too many of them are named like book character, omen, sorrows, Melancholia for the bitter moody villain.

I mean I'd just take a normal name because I want my coffee order to not be embarrassing.


r/skulduggerypleasant • • Feb 24 '25

Question What is skulduggerypleasant?

2 Upvotes

I’ve literally never heard of this show/book/movie/comic/manga/anime, I have no idea what it is or what form of media it is, or what it’s about. I followed this sub for some reason and I don’t know why.

BTW this is a totally genuine question, you can look back at my post and comment history, I’ve never interacted here


r/skulduggerypleasant • • Sep 26 '25

Meta Would this be how you imagine Eliza Scorn ???

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/skulduggerypleasant • • Sep 01 '24

Fan Art How I imagine Tesseract

Post image
0 Upvotes

(I think this is the right flair.)


r/skulduggerypleasant • • Apr 12 '24

Fan Art Just Love AI

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

I think its pretty accurate how the Bedlam Covers could Look colored.


r/skulduggerypleasant • • May 26 '24

Question When does book 8 get good Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Im currently half way through book 8 (they are about to break in to the english sanctuary for the engineers prototype brain) and ngl it feels much more slow and I am having trouble to read it and still remember whats happening. Is it like this the whole book or am I just at a slower part? If so when does it get better? Edit: looks like everyone says the end is the best part so I will keep reading and update when I have finished it

Edit: everyone says it gets better after this so I will update when I have finished it Update: i am half way through book nine and lets just say I didn’t expect what happened );


r/skulduggerypleasant • • Mar 06 '24

Fan Art Skulduggery Pleasant fancast

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Thoughts?


r/skulduggerypleasant • • Dec 12 '23

Discussion Darquese vs Sukuna (jujutsu kaisen). Who would win?

0 Upvotes

Thought Sukuno starts off more powerful, Darquese has endless potential and can catch up to him if the fight goes long enough.


r/skulduggerypleasant • • Sep 14 '22

Question Do you think Derek Landy become too political? Spoiler

24 Upvotes

I love Skulduggery pleasant series.Atleast i love them until dead of the light i think at last books Derek become too political like putting USA president (obviously Trump) to his books I am not even a american and i hate trump and i dont want to see some one like him on a fastasy book.If i want to read a book about politics i would read 1984 or animal farm its a fantasy book not a politics book.Also i think things like sexuallty is gets politicilazed too.I feel little uncomfortable how Derek use sexuallties to get approve of some groups.Dont get me wrong i dont have a problem that seeing different sexuallties in the books i am bisexual myself but the thing that bothers me is i feel like its forced.I would love to see Valkyrie realize that she is bisexual and struggles to understand her feelings towards Militsa Gnosis and then slowly they 2 become a couple.But instead of that in offscreen she realize she is bisexual and starts a relationship with Gnosis.That make me feel like Derek doesnt put different sexuallties in his books beacuse he wants to do it but instead it feels like he just want to get some power or fame by putting LGBTQ+ charcters in his books.What do you think about that?


r/skulduggerypleasant • • Jul 01 '25

Theory The bee gods telling me to drink more lead but im starting to get suspisous is this really lead cos its making me lose my eyesight and feeling to my legs... and the rest of my body. Also the bee doctor refuses to answer my questions? What should i do? NSFW Spoiler

0 Upvotes

ALso do bees have skeletons and magic just wondering on your thoughts. ALSO COKE IS BETTER THAN PEPSI


r/skulduggerypleasant • • Jan 31 '25

Discussion Controversial opinion

5 Upvotes

Personally I believe the series fell off heavily after Mortal Coil. It feels like landy struggled to manage his original more gothic horror inspired tone and it got dragged down into a spiral of endlessly higher stakes with the world mechanics getting more and more skewed until it turned into the mess of phase 2. Just an opinion would love to hear some good counters why you think I'm wrong.


r/skulduggerypleasant • • Mar 10 '25

Question So... Am I supposed to sit here an believe that Dusk just sat on the chair and negotiated with China fucking Sorrows while she bathed?

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/skulduggerypleasant • • Feb 20 '25

Theory Hol’ up..

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/skulduggerypleasant • • Dec 26 '21

Question Am I a micro-celebrity

0 Upvotes

I'm confused as fuck

46 votes, Dec 28 '21
15 Yes
31 No

r/skulduggerypleasant • • Mar 20 '26

Discussion THATS ME

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

IM ON GOOGLE


r/skulduggerypleasant • • Apr 18 '25

Theory My fancast for Skullduggery Pleasant

3 Upvotes

I started rereading the whole series soooooo…. This is my fancast!

Skullduggery- Johnny Depp. I honestly think he would be amazing, he’s played so many different characters with such unique personalities and I know he could pull this off!

Valkyrie/Darquesse/Stephanie- so obviously the actress would have to play so many different characters with so many personalities, considering one is good(and kinda crazy) one is evil and another is completely emotionless for a few movies. So I think an unknown irish actress would be great- and someone between the ages of 12-15 because Val is 12 in book 1.

Tanith- Emily Blunt. She’s immediately who I think of, I feel like she would portray Tanith amazingly, she’s exactly how I imaging her to look and I adore her accent!

Fletcher- I honestly can’t think of anyone who could portray Fletcher perfectly, but there’s two options imo- An unknown, and maybe Walker Scobell? This one I’m not sure of but I think he’d be really good and would be able to portray Fletchers fun, silly side.

China- I think maybe Saoirse Ronan if she dyed her hair, or Lucy Hale , but I’m leaning more towards Lucy.

Mr. Bliss- I think Jason Stantham would be really good! He’s exactly how I picture Mr. Bliss, and he has quite a cold resting face which I think is perfect!

Serpine- Tom Hiddleston. He looks exactly like how I imagine Serpine to. I think he’d be an amazing actor for this role.

Ghastly- Mark Strong. He looks perfect, and he just gives Ghastly vibes to me. He’s a great actor and I think if anyone could pull off Ghastly, it would be him!

Clarabelle- I loved Clarabelle and anytime I was reading her parts out, I kept doing a Luna Lovegood voice. That’s why I think Evanna Lynch would be amazing! She has the looks imo and her voice is just how I imagine Clarabelle’s!

That’s all I can think of atm, lmk if you agree or if there’s anyone else you’d cast!

Edit: I actually just finished a movie called Incoming, and now I'm kinda sorta thinking- maybe Mason Thames for Fletcher? He was really silly and random in the movie and I think he could be like that for Fletcher!


r/skulduggerypleasant • • Apr 06 '24

Question No scene with Militsa after the ending? Spoiler

3 Upvotes

What the heck, Derek Landry. You get the protagonists girlfriend abducted and almost brutally murdered and you don’t put a scene with her after that? That’s just lazy writing.


r/skulduggerypleasant • • May 09 '24

Fan Art using AI to do Skully characters(PART 1: Skul, Val, Tanny)

0 Upvotes

r/skulduggerypleasant • • May 14 '24

Satire idgaf, this is their sexuality

17 Upvotes