r/skeptic • • Jun 26 '25

šŸ’© Misinformation The Fascist Cult Behind the Latest "Trump Stole the Election" Claim

Thumbnail
youtu.be
77 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • Nov 08 '24 Polished Gold Turd Sipping Tea Wholesome Seal

šŸ§™ā€ā™‚ļø Magical Thinking & Power Trump Won With Misinformed, Naive, Low-Info Voters

Post image
28.7k Upvotes

r/skeptic • • Feb 16 '26

āš– Ideological Bias Performative virtue-signaling has become a threat to higher ed

Thumbnail
thehill.com
0 Upvotes

Note: I wanted to edit the title, but then I’d have to use the editorialized title flair. Although, I really wanted to use the ideological bias flair and I don’t think there’s a way of attaching two flairs. Honestly, I think reddit should allow us 37 flairs if we want to… ;)

Anyway, I’m hoppin’ mad about the title and even more so the rest of the garbage in the article. I’ve written a shortened ā€˜review’ similar to how I might for a manuscript submitted for peer-review, albeit with a little more tacit snark. I thought you all might enjoy. Here we go…

This Opinion piece has left me with many questions and few pathways for finding answers. I was surprised that there are no links from the article to support assertions.

We asked: Have you ever pretended to hold more progressive views than you truly endorse to succeed socially or academically? An astounding 88 percent said yes.

Astounding indeed.

I would love to see the peer-reviewed paper for this. If anyone has been able to locate it, would you be so kind as to point me in the right direction?

I would be interested in reading the entirety of this survey. Given the authors’ interest in bias it’s surely not lost on them how framing of survey questions and social desirability bias in respondents could skew their results. I’m sure they went to great lengths to minimize these possibilities. Nevertheless I still have a great interest in reading the survey.

https://law.stanford.edu/publications/framing-effects-in-survey-research-consistency-adjusted-estimators/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social-desirability_bias

Our question was clinical, not political: ā€œWhat happens to identity formation when belief is replaced by adherence to orthodoxy?ā€

How to do the authors define ā€œclinical?ā€ What does it mean in this context (as opposed to medicine or psychology)? Analytical? Diagnostic? It’s always interesting to see who the authors are:

Kevin Waldman and Forest Romm are clinical psychology researchers at psychFORM.

They are described as ā€œclinical psychology researchersā€ but this is not actually clinical psychology research… More on that at the end.

Seventy-eight percent of students told us they self-censor on their beliefs surrounding gender identity; 72 percent on politics; 68 percent on family values.

I am curious how this might compare with adults with jobs. Do workers also self-censor on these beliefs at the same percentages. Would it be less? More? Or what about in a religious context? To what extent is there self-censorship there and would it compare to the data from this study?

In public, students echoed expected progressive narratives. In private, however, their views were more complex.

An observation: If you’re listening carefully, you’ll also notice this everywhere you go, but certainly not just for progressive narratives. People in general want to relate to others. People desire to be well-liked. These are long established phenomena in psychology. Moreover, the human brain desires simplicity and stories that ā€œmake sense,ā€ as opposed to messiness and complexity and nuance. These are all very human and nonpartisan tendencies.

As I mentioned above, there are no links in the article to click through to the researchers. There are no degrees listed and no academic affiliations. So I looked it up: https://psychform.com/about-us/

Kevin Waldman’s career spans Ivy League research labs, correctional institutions, Division I athletic programs, and thousands of interviews with college students nationwide.

…

Forest Romm is a clinical researcher, with an emphasis on women’s psychology, whose work is driven by a deep desire to understand the complexities of human behavior and experience

I still can’t find any degree information, curriculum vitae, or what ā€œIvy League research labsā€ this person was trained in.ā€ In my 25+ years of studying psychology, sex differences, reproductive hormones, and mental health, I also don’t think I have ever heard of the subfield of ā€œwomen’s psychology.ā€ Is there also a ā€œmen’s psychology?ā€ I was always of the mind that there wasn’t a ā€œwomen’s psychologyā€ or a ā€œmen’s psychology;ā€ there is only psychology. Perhaps I am mistaken. I will have to look more into that…

I wonder whether the author would be willing to share their dataset and survey so that I might also test some my own hypothesis. These are certainly very important questions to questions to ask and we must leave no stone unturned.

…

For my tastes, I don’t even really like to go to the APA website for a good representation of clinical psych research, because I think it’s too close to pop psych and regrettably doesn’t do enough to showcase researchers who are doing stellar (more complicated and nuanced) work. But here you are anyway: https://www.apa.org/pubs/highlights/spotlight/topic-clinical

In closing, I probably could have expanded here in a lot of places and a lot ways but I’ll just say that as always, if there’s anything you would like more info on or if you’d like links to papers, just say the word (oh!).

I hope you enjoyed the Easter eggs. :)


r/skeptic • • Mar 21 '24

Olympic transgender policy goes against science, say academics

Thumbnail
thetimes.co.uk
2 Upvotes

The majority of the data (which is limited) this far show transwomen have an advantage in sport even after taking testosterone suppressing meds. To make things fair, perhaps sporting orgs need to create an open category.


r/skeptic • • Apr 03 '20

Alex Jones was charged with driving while intoxicated just after midnight Tuesday

Thumbnail
thewrap.com
3 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • Sep 18 '25

Reasonable attempt to debunk Charlie Kirk Assassination conspiracies

Thumbnail
youtube.com
77 Upvotes

Marcus touches on the currently popular theories about how the gun was hidden, the bullet wound questions, the possibility of body armor, why AI can't accurately fix the low-resolution frames of the suspect's face, whether someone else may have shot Kirk, and uses math to debunk the claims of a shot coming from the side (plus more).

We have a long time before every piece of evidence comes out and can be analyzed in detail, but I think he does a fairly good job.


r/skeptic • • Apr 26 '26

šŸ’© Misinformation I am very frightened by the response to the incident at the WHCD.

102 Upvotes

The White House Correspondent's Dinner incident was obviously an intensely condemnable attempt at political violence, and it's very good news that no one was hurt. Actual people, with friends and families and lives, could have been killed. But I have not seen a single post on the matter whose top comment does not voice the opinion that it was a fabricated false flag.

Conflicting reports from while the event was developing, easily explained by the fact that it was an intense and confusing situation around which rumors would swirl like mad, are being described as 'rapidly changing the narrative'. Trump's (distasteful) comments about the ballroom, while opportunistic, are being treated as the 'reason it was orchestrated'. I hear the opinion that the Trump administration is 'not getting the response they were expecting' from a false flag to 'drum up midterm support' or 'get sympathy from the press'.

The opinion is so widespread that I wonder if I am the one taking crazy pills. Do I now live in a country where I cannot be in touch with reality? I thought my fellow leftists scoffed at the right's propensity to invent narratives and misinformation.

I have not seen much outright misinformation, but I have seen intense speculation and disproportionate conclusions. I am afraid to be living in a country with rising political violence. But I am also afraid to be living in a country where meaningful events do not have consensus reality. I shouldn't have to live with such an intense 'I'm frightened I'm wrong' feeling pricking at the back of my neck about something like this.


r/skeptic • • Jul 09 '25

šŸ§™ā€ā™‚ļø Magical Thinking & Power Why I Welcome Elon Musk’s ā€œAmerica Partyā€

Thumbnail
thenation.com
33 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • Jan 23 '24

šŸ‘¾ Invaded Explaining why Richard Dawkins is transphobic and why the skeptic community should be aware of that.

166 Upvotes

Considering that both Richard Dawkins is still a somewhat prominent atheist that was in the center of the skeptic movement and that LGBT people are discussed in this sub because we are often targets of harrassment, I think this post is relevant.

I know I'll be preaching to the choir for most of you, but I've seen many people confused about him. "He's not transphobic, it's just difficult for him to accept certain things as a biologist". "He's just abrasive, but that doesn't mean he is promoting hate". Or even things like "the far-left is coopting the skeptic movement and Dawkins is having none of that". I just want to explain why I disagree with that.

I'll talk about things that he said to prove my point:

1) Tweet #1

Is trans woman a woman? Purely semantic. If you define by chromosomes, no. If by self-identification, yes. I call her "she" out of courtesy.

Many people use this tweet to dismiss the accusations against Dawkins because, see, he even calls trans women by their preferred pronouns.

Here are the problems:

  • It's very reductionist and wrong (not wrong as insensitive, wrong as incorrect biology) to define women as XX, even if your argument is that only cis female people are women. Dawkins as a biologist should know that. He is clearly not well informed on the subject.

  • There is a biological basis as to why trans women can be categorized as women. There are many studies on that. It's not something completely sociological and subjective. Society isn't treating trans women as women "out of courtesy". He completely ignores that.

2) Tweet #2

In 2015, Rachel Dolezal, a white chapter president of NAACP, was vilified for identifying as Black. Some men choose to identify as women, and some women choose to identify as men. You will be vilified if you deny that they literally are what they identify as.

Dawkins compares trans people to Rachel Dolezan, a white person trying to pass as a black person to gain benefits from society. That person didn't even have a mental condition, or anything of the sort. What is he implying here?

And even if that person truly believed to be black: It's obvious that society shouldn't treat her as such. It's obvious that she would be considered delusional. That's not remotely comparable to transgender people at all.

3) Helen Joyce

Dawkins both endorsed her book called "Trans: When Ideology Meets Reality" and invited this person to talk in his YouTube channel where they were friendly and mostly agreed.

Some of Helen's views:

  • In various tweets, she described the provision of gender-affirming care to trans children and youth as "child abuse," "unethical medicine," "mass experimentation," and a "global scandal."

  • As she told the magazine The Radical Notion in a 2021 interview: "It was very straightforward: 'They are sterilizing gay kids. And if I write this book, they might sterilize fewer gay kids.'"

  • "And in the meantime, while we’re trying to get through to the decision-makers, we have to try to limit the harm and that means reducing or keeping down the number of people who transition,ā€ Joyce said. ā€œThat’s for two reasons – one of them is that every one of those people is a person who’s been damaged. But the second one is every one of those people is basically, you know, a huge problem to a sane world.ā€

This is the type of person that Dawkins supports these days. He also defends people that take similar positions such as JK Rowling.

4) Interview with David Pakman

In this interview Dawkins talks about some of his views on the issue.

I am not particularly bothered if somebody wants to present themselves as the opposite of the sex that they are. I do object if they insist that other people recognize that. I support Jordan Peterson in this, if nothing else, in that he objects to the Canadian government making it mandatory that he should call people by a pronoun.

Jordan Peterson lied through his teeth because of this bill. That's how he got famous, for being a "free speech warrior" and painting the trans movement as authoritarian. Nobody was arrested in Canada because of pronouns. Years later Dawkins believe in lies.

I would have a strong objection to doctors injecting minors—children—or performing surgery on them to change their sex.

I understand saying that minors shouldn't undergo surgery, although these cases are rare and anti-trans people conviently forget that minors undergo other similar procedures.

He's completely unfair about hormonal treatment. It's very important for us to not go through the entire puberty to only later start hormones. I started as a 16 years old and that was very nice for me. It's authoritarian to simply deny trans minors these treatments (and kids don't take hormones as he implies, another lie).

But I fear that what we're seeing now is a fashion, a craze, a memetic epidemic which is spreading like an epidemic of measles, or something like that.

More people are going out as gay and bi than ever because we are becoming free to explore sexuality. Would Dawkins call that "an epidemic of measles" as well?

5) Putin, Islam and Trans people

He wrote an open letter to his friend Ayaan Hirsi-Ali. He wrote:

I might agree with you (I actually do) that Putinism, Islamism, and postmodernish wokery pokery are three great enemies of decent civilisation. I might agree with you that Christianity, if only as a lesser of evils, is a powerful weapon against them.

What does mean by "wokery pokery"? Well, mostly he is talking about the trans movement. If you have any doubts he made a video about it:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Q-rKCdvpiV4

In the 45 seconds mark he literally puts an image of trans activists when he mentions "the woke". For Dawkins talking about trans rights is as dangerous as people supporting Putin and Jihadists. For him Christianity is the "lesser evil".

To conclude

Richard Dawkins is doing very real harm with all these positions that he's taking. He is still influential and a public figure. I heard multiple times religious people say "see, even an anti-religious atheist agree with us on this subject". It's important for the skeptic community to separate itself from him and call him out (many skeptics and humanists already did). It's difficult to welcome marginalized LGBT and make excuses for this type of behavior. Of course, don't erase his contributions to biology in the past, but the man is sadly an open bigot these days.


r/skeptic • • Oct 01 '11

Dear /r/skeptic, why do you allow yourselves to get trolled?

2 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • Jul 08 '11

Rebecca Watson's Delusion

21 Upvotes

Has anyone else noticed how common it is for Rebecca Watson to mention how many men desire her? I've heard it from her several times - even before this whole Dawkins kerfuffle. It seems obvious to me that the point she is trying to make is that tons of guys really want her, despite whatever guise she gives for constantly bringing it up.

The point Dawkins was making was that nothing of note happened in the elevator. This reinforces my point. The "creepiness" aspect was the guise she used to mention how much men desire her.

Then it was her and her alone that blew this whole thing up. She could have responded gracefully to Dawkins but instead she has spent all of her time badmouthing him, calling men misogynists, etc. It is clear from her post about it on skepchick that she thinks there are two kinds of men in the world: those who think women are dumb and useless, and those who think women are dumb and useful only for sex. With an attitude like that no wonder she was creeped out in the elevator.

This whole thing is just more attention-whoring on her part. It's almost as if she's screaming "look at how big of a deal I am because I got in a fight with Richard Dawkins!"

Rebecca Watson: Pass.

Edit: This guy has her number: http://integralmath.blogspot.com/2011/07/ceterum-censeo-rebecca-twatson-esse.html


r/skeptic • • Feb 24 '26

Medical Associations Trusted Belief Over Science on Youth Gender Care

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
0 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • Nov 29 '24

OMG: Watch Joe Rogan Realize HE WAS COMPLETELY LIED TO!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • Sep 15 '23

Did Elon Musk Turn Off Starlink Access in Crimea To Disrupt Ukrainian Attack? (No)

Thumbnail
snopes.com
2 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • Jan 21 '25

Currently, 8/10 of the 'Hot' r/skeptic posts are politics. The top headline is untrue, and two other posts are overrun with conspiracy theories. Is this what we want here?

143 Upvotes

So, right now, 8/10 of the "hot" r/skeptic topics are political topics. 7 out of 10 if sorting by "top".
Is this what we want on this sub?

One of them has a clear nexus with science: the executive order pulling the US from the WHO is an interested topic not discussed much yet in politics subs. But the comments on the article are basically content-free; there's a single comment by someone who appears to have read the article, who discusses the actual background to the EO, in a single sentence. The other comments are just outrage.

The top post right now is just false: some random tech blog claiming that everyone was set to follow Trump and Vance on Instagram. At least some (call it roughly a third) of the comments have noticed that this is a misinterpretation of normal activities. Another top post is just a screenshot of Instagram doing political stuff (which at least appears to have been true for a couple of hours, because it was changed/fixed).

The election thread has a ton of people talking about how, actually, Elon hacked the election. It was majority pro-conspiracy theories for most of yesterday. Now it's maybe slightly-more-than-half pro-conspiracy theories. I can't overstate how bad this thread is, so maybe just go read the comments, if you haven't. At least after a whole day of voting and commenting there's some pushback visible.

Pardon the soapboxing here, but it's clear to me that this sub has become overrun with low-effort outrage bait about politics. The carve out that politically-motivated "misinformation" (which isn't that easy to define) and politically-motivated conspiracies are allowed, has turned into anything-goes, as long as it's outrageous. Posts about Elon's Nazi salute, federal hiring and other stories are just outrageous. Trump's going to be outrageous for 4 years, so if that's the standard, that's what's going to be on this sub until the next election.

Most of my involvement in skepticism was way back when James Randi was alive and I understand the community has changed since then. Nobody died and made me any sort of authority figure here; I'm not a mod anywhere, not a gatekeeper of what's scientific skepticism and what isn't. I know moderating is a hard job and most of my interactions with the mods here have been very polite and positive. While I was writing this, I think the mods actually deleted at least one political outrage post, so, uh, good job.

But I think this is bad and rules should be changed. Or else the next 4 years will just be outrage.

EDIT: Well, this wasn't fun. Guessing at some percentages, I'd say about 70% of the replies didn't agree with me, and an overlapping 15% also hate me personally.

EDIT2: Maybe more like 25% hate me personally. So that's a lesson learned, I guess.


r/skeptic • • Mar 02 '11

Proof that r/911truth is completely and utterly dishonest: when someone asked 'Who had the resources to plan and execute 9/11?' - the answer 'AL QAEDA' received 100% downvotes... Hmmm... Not one honest person there. Not one...

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • Jan 12 '25

How can transgender people in sports be presented to your average person?

Thumbnail
forbes.com
114 Upvotes

Context: I am a trans woman and completely amateur runner. I ran a half marathon over a year ago. When I told one of my coworkers about how I was running the half marathon race, they asked if I was worried that I might win the entire women’s race and face public scrutiny. For reference, my best half marathon time ever was 2:05. The woman who won the half marathon race did it in 1:13. I was right around the middle of the pack.

Beyond that, since transitioning, I lost a ton of muscle mass. At that time, I had lost over 40 lbs. despite this, I still couldn’t beat my previous 5k record of 25:13. The closest I ever got was 26:15. It irks me when people insist that trans women have virtually any athletic advantage. Is there some nuance to this? Sure. For instance, it’s not as though the day after I started transitioning, I insisted on running in the women’s category (though I’d still have lost lmao).

Sources such as this say we may even have a disadvantage, but your average person still acts like it’s some highly disputed issue. I’ve even had liberals tell me that it might be something trans people should just give up on. I think the average person is just uninformed and I think if there was actually a chance for trans people to present the nuances behind this issue, justice would prevail. However, there is no such thing as nuance in the media. I feel so hopeless trying to talk about these issues because at the end of the day, I could pour my heart out to people and some pundit would tell them I’m wrong in a series of one to two syllable words.


r/skeptic • • Oct 29 '23

As far as I can tell, it is simply not factually correct to claim that Israel is engaged in genocide against the Palestinians

0 Upvotes

This post is an investigation of factual claims, which is in the spirit of scientific skepticism and of this subreddit. So as I understand it, it is within the rules of the subreddit.

In the wake of the recent war between Israel and Hamas, some critics of Israel have accused it of carrying out a genocide. I don't think however that this is accurate.

Look for example at the Wikipedia page Genocide against Palestinians. The proponents of this idea apparently can't even agree on if this genocide happened in the past or is something that is taking place right now. It os obvious from the article that this is not an agreed-upon topic.

Further, if you look at the population development of Palestine from 1915 to 2021 and compare it with Cambodia, you notice two things:

  1. In the case of Cambodia, you see a clear dip in their population due to the Cambodian genocide.

  2. There is no similar dip in the Palestinian population, which we would expect from a genocide. By contrast, it has a steady growth over time.

(Some, but not all, of these critics also say that Israel is comparable to Nazi Germany in its treatment of Palestinians, which is an absurd claim. Israel is not engaged in the industrial murder of Palestinians (indeed, around 20% of the Israeli population is made up of Palestinians and/or other Arabs, something equivalent of course was never the case in Nazi Germany), there is no Israeli equivalent to Einsatzgruppen, there are no gas chambers for Palestinians in Israel, and in more people died in the Warsaw Ghetto alone during a few years than have died in the entire Israeli-Palestinian conflict (both sides combined) since 1948. Come to think of if, more people have died in the Russo-Ukrainian War since the invasion last year, or in the Syrian civil war, than have died in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict since 1948.)

So while I fully agree that Israel deserves criticism for many things, like being led by Netanyahu who is not particularly inclined to a final peace settlement, or for continuing to expand its settlements on the West Bank, or for collective punishments of Gaza, or for not being cautious enough about preventing the deaths of civilians (it is more so than Hamas is, of course, but that is a really low bar to pass), I also think that at least skeptics should not engage in hyperboles. As far as I can find (but I am prepared to be convinced otherwise), it is simply not accurate to claim that Israel is engaging in a genocide against Palestinians (let alone being like Nazi Germany). So let's dispense with the hyperboles and focus on the actual issues.


r/skeptic • • May 26 '26

Kyle Busch's death cause by a head cold?

0 Upvotes

"The medical evaluation provided to the Busch Family concluded that severe pneumonia progressed into sepsis, resulting in rapid and overwhelming associated complications,"

https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/nascar/2026/05/24/kyle-busch-cause-death-pneumonia-sepsis-what-we-know/90233872007/

Busch was only 41yrs old. The media reporting is that pneumonia progressed in sepsis. Okay, but pneumonia is caused by something. Not an illness to itself. Reports about the actual illness vary from head cold to sinus infection. Seems strange that a healthy 41yr old would die from an out of control head cold.

Kyle Busch wasn't explicitly an antivaxxer but frequently downplayed the severity of COVID-19. Back in 2021 he routinely dismissed the need for precaution. The NASCAR audience is very conservative and in recent years conservatives have become aggressive antivaxx.

Did Busch die from a head cold or did you actually have COVID or some other sort of season flu that is easily protected against with vaccines? Is the media just being polite and trying to avoid political uproar by not being more curious? Healthy 41yrs don't die from head colds.


r/skeptic • • Jan 22 '22

The Vaccine Worked for Me

20 Upvotes

In the past two weeks I was exposed to two people who tested positive for COVID. I developed muscle aches and a low-grade fever and thought "Oh crap." I took a COVID test: NEGATIVE.

I realize I'm a sample size of one but I am thrilled for two reasons. First and most important, I don't have COVID. Second, I can say a big "fuck you" to all those antivax bitches who think the vax doesn't work or will ruin your immune system.


r/skeptic • • Oct 15 '25

The Hasan Piker Dog Collar Controversy Is Worse Than You Think

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • Jul 13 '11

In support of Rebecca

14 Upvotes

I just want to lend my support to Rebecca. I am a skinny white guy, but I can empathize with the plight of vulnerable women. I recently got on an elevator in a sketchy part of town and a big black man got on the elevator with me. He asked me if I could make some change for a large denomination bill. As a skinny white guy, I felt uncomfortable taking my wallet out in front of this guy. Now, it was probably innocuous and safe, but I still felt very uncomfortable. To all the black people out there, when you confront a skinny white guy in a enclosed space, don't do this. I'm not saying all black men are thieves and robbers, but I think they should be more respectful to vulnerable people in enclosed places.


r/skeptic • • May 04 '24

šŸ’‰ Vaccines Thousands Believe Covid Vaccines Harmed Them. Is Anyone Listening? (NYT Gift Article)

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
52 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • Mar 20 '12

6th man to walk on the moon attests that UFO's are real and they have been covered up for 60 years. What does /r/skeptic make of this?

0 Upvotes

I should also point out that his opinions and experience is not unique within the astronaut community. Gordon Cooper also talked openly about his sightings and experience with UFOs.

Buzz Aldrin has been less forthcoming, but none the less has talked about the objects often seen in space.

I believe there are other examples of Astronauts speaking out, but they're not on YouTube.