I know I am not making friends with this post, but what the actual fuck? Ranting, but I am genuinely shocked -
After 20+ years working in tech, including startups and smaller companies, now my own company - I was brought in as a consult at Amazon and Meta. I genuinely thought the people working at these companies would be exceptionally smart, capable, and innovative. That is certainly how they present themselves.
But my God. These are some of the most backward, chaotic, and astonishingly inept workplaces I have ever encountered. How is this even...possible?
I am sitting in meetings wondering: Is this a meeting? Is this person speaking? Are these supposed to be sentences? One woman rattles through the agenda, constantly misspeaks, cannot complete a coherent thought, and appears to have never encountered the concept of presentation skills. Nobody reacts. Apparently this is normal.
Then a Product VP shows up with a Word document masquerading as a presentation. No structure. No formatting. Just words dumped onto a page like evidence recovered from a hard drive. But oh boy - an ego...wow.
The next one, an overly confident dude in his 30s...does not even turn his camera on ? And like a stubborn teenager answers to all questions, not just mine but also the legal reps' comments 'and why would we do that'. Well, cause otherwise we commit fraud? Hello?
They can't think on their own feet anymore? And there are so many roles that do the same - I come from start ups, we do everything. I mean, no wonder, there are so many lay offs. I hate saying but yeah...you don't need all these puppets.
Amazon was another universe of dysfunction: outdated information, broken links, contradictory instructions, and an onboarding process that felt like an escape room that predates the internet - designed by people who had never successfully escaped a room.
Has anyone there heard of workflow optimization? Information architecture? Basic communication? Or are they all too busy using internal acronyms and telling one another that they hire “the best”?
I previously worked with two Product VPs who had come from these major tech companies. Me and coworkers did wonder back then - they were fired within a few months. At the time, I was confused. Now I understand.
Take away the enormous brand, the army of employees, the internal machinery, and the ability to schedule another meeting whenever something goes wrong and some of these people apparently cannot function.
And the confidence! They really seem to believe they are operating on a level the rest of us could never comprehend. True, I really can't comprehend nor do I want to.
I cannot comprehend how a trillion-dollar company can have worse onboarding than my neighborhood Pilates studio. I cannot comprehend how senior product leaders reached that level without learning how to structure information. What ...is going on ? And I cannot comprehend why people who would struggle to survive for six months inside a functioning startup - if they make it that far even - think their paycheck is proof of superior intelligence??
I have always pushed back against the idea that AI can simply replace people. Human judgment, curiosity, context, communication, and creativity matter, especially now. But I sit through these meetings (as I write this actually hahah...) and think: You know what? Replace away.
If the job consists of reading broken documentation, moving incoherent information between teams, regurgitating corporate language, and scheduling five meetings to avoid making one decision, AI may actually be overqualified.
I know this will upset people who are stuck at Meta, Amazon...Are the genuinely capable people hidden somewhere inside these companies? Where are they? I am in the Bay Area, I thought's it's the holy grail here? Feels more like corporate daycare.