r/silenthill • • Oct 28 '23

Fanmade My alternate take on Maria's outfit from SH2

Post image
56 Upvotes

r/silenthill • • Jun 03 '24

Fanmade Let’s get Bloober to see this 🔁 (credits to @raquelcornejo_ on X)

Post image
0 Upvotes

Link to the Tweet by 𝕽𝖆𝖖𝖚𝖊𝖑 𝕮𝖔𝖗𝖓𝖊𝖏𝖔 🦇 (@raquelcornejo_) on X:

https://x.com/raquelcornejo_/status/1797584260104343922?s=46&t=299MlVeueYN4tRlAtN0OHA

I saw this on Twitter and thought that those with a Twitter account who appreciate this improvement of Maria's design could help raise awareness of this post. This way, Bloober Team might actually notice it through the fog of the ongoing polarization.


r/silenthill • • Oct 23 '25

Silent Hill f (2025) I wanted to like silent hill F

1 Upvotes

But for now this is a DNF. Game started pretty good. But it’s just not very good ultimately. The fights are not fun or unique. They are a nuisance. After about the halfway mark the game is just a bother. I was trying to speed through areas and get to cut scenes to try and finish the game but said to myself, this isn’t how silent hill games are meant to be. So I am done for now and will seek greener pastures. Story seemed cool, even the monsters at the start were cool. But it is so damn repetitive and just a chore to progress.


r/silenthill • • Jun 04 '24

Meme Happy now?

Post image
0 Upvotes

This Angela discussion is some of the dumbest shit I've seen lol.


r/silenthill • • Oct 05 '25

Silent Hill f (2025) I just finished Silent Hill f (Major Spoilers) NSFW Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Major spoilers ahead, by the way.

A lot of anger and frustration went into this, so beware of bad language. I use hyperbole in parts to describe how I felt, this game just made me so unbelievably mad and frustrated.

The ending where Hinako screams, "I hate everything about this", "I hate this place", "I want it to stop", and so on..

Yep, that's exactly how I felt at that point in the game, and the only time I found her character relatable. If anything, this game encouraged me to take drugs to get over what a miserable fucking experience this game was.

I don't even know where to begin...

The game has one of the worst combat systems I've seen.
You don't know your weapon reach, so you constantly miss. Enemies act like they're still alive when they die, so you are tricked into hitting a dead enemy to waste stamina. You constantly get stun-locked by enemies, so all you can do is spam dodge.. You have parts of the game where the game throws undodge-able scripted enemies that grab you. The game constantly spawns an enemy right in front of you after picking up a key item or behind a door in an effort to scare you. It'd be fine if they did this once or twice, but it happens probably 50 times.

The combat system doesn't make the game scary, it makes it a slog, it makes it fucking annoying. I felt physically ill towards the last 4 hours of the game, trying to finish it.

The puzzles are uninspired, some are directly ripped off from other SH games and I don't think I found a single puzzle that was fun or interesting to figure out. (Played with hard puzzles on).

The game re-uses so many of its levels, but not in a creative or fun way like in the RE remakes, no. It's just literal padding and backtracking for no reason other than to fill out their shit game.

And half-way through the game, it becomes a beat-em up. Don't worry I'll get to that part when I cover what this game calls its story.

Let's talk about how this game has almost nothing to do with Silent Hill.

The constant dialogue queues, where Hinako has to comment on literally EVERYTHING. "Oh, my weapon needs to be repaired", "oh, is it dead?". JUST SHUT THE FUCK UP. She never stops doing it. It's so typical of modern games, there's no subtlety.

The notes you pick up aren't unique at all like they were in the other Silent Hill games, you pick up about 200 generic notes that convey the story and none of them are unique. Same font, same backdrop, at some point I just stopped giving a shit.

Which brings me to the UI. The game's UI reminds me of shitty open-world Ubisoft games or open-world souls-like games, it's not at all giving off horror. And tutorial messages? Waypoints showing objectives on the map? Stop handholding us. You clearly want to give us an annoying and unfair challenge with the combat, why are you gonna hold our hand with anything else?

You have this journal that supposedly Hinako is writing and drawing images in. But this is supposed to take place in the 60's, why is she drawing people in a 2000's anime style? Why is there a note mentioning mild autism even though that wasn't commonly diagnosed until decades later? (yes I know it was first diagnosed in the 40's, but you're telling me this small little Japanese rural town has revolutionary and progressive psychological care?) The journal does nothing but take you out of the game and the immersion and it would have been better if they left it out of the game.

When people try to say this game has nothing in common with souls-likes, what the hell are you talking about?

I will agree it's not 100% like Dark Souls. But it's definitely qualifies as a souls-like. It takes ideas from every game it can think of, Generic open-world games, modern RPG's, Sekiro, Bloodborne, Dark Souls, SH2 Remake..

Let's talk comparisons.. The save station, the level-up system (RPG elements in fucking Silent Hill.. why?), weapon durability (WHYYYY???), healing items with a 4-slot UI that looks like souls games with literal estus flask animations, the stamina bar, the bullshit combat that straight up does things that aren't fair, bosses that are clearly just setup like souls bosses without a health bar, it goes on and fucking on. At one point you literally siphon SOULS.

Now, the writing. And finally showing me that Ryukishi07 should keep in his lane and write visual novels about schoolgirls.

All the dialogue is clichéd and full of tropes. "MY NAME IS... MY NAME IS.. HINAKO!!!", like she's some fucking shonen badass. Another thing is how these characters are supposed to be kids, but they all look like they're in their 20's, yet they act like they're 13. So when one of the characters says something childish, I just sit there and go "there's no way you're this fucking stupid".

There's so many cutscenes where it just shows how childish the writing really is. All I get from this guy is that he inserts his fetishes into his works.

Fox Mask is an obvious thirst trap for tumblr people, when I first encountered him in the game, it completely took me out of the immersion. White hair, looks like a j-pop star.. god it's so fucking terrible.

And then we turn Silent Hill into a snuff flick for shock value, where her arm gets decapitated and replaced with a fox furry arm. Just.. Why. Why? This was the part where I was previously gonna say this game's 6/10, and changed it to a 4/10. Then she becomes all stoic and turns into a Rei Ayanami archetype, with a dead souless voice. It's just all stuff I've already seen in anime so many times before.

After that it only gets worse, and worse, and worse. I'm not gonna lie, the first 15 minutes of this game was actually a pretty cool setup. But after that title screen with the main theme, it only goes downhill (pun intended).

I could see how this could have been a great game (not a great Silent Hill game), mind you, but the execution and writing is so terrible that it just stumbles and falls flat.

There's also so many things it just randomly throws in, like a call-back to the giant head encounter in Silent Hill 4. This game struggles to come up with its own ideas, and the original ideas they have are just so poorly realized.

We've already seen a female protagonist facing a sexist society in Silent Hill 3, and that game executed it so much better.

Me and my friends were 30 minutes into the game and we called it, that it was all gonna be in her head and that she's running around killing real people.

It was so god damn predictable. Nothing, absolutely NOTHING about this game is subtle. Why even throw in the police report at the end? You think we're too fucking dumb to understand what you were trying to imply?

This game has really nothing to do with Silent Hill, and I'm genuinely upset how westerners will glaze anything just because it's Japanese. I can't see any other reason why the game has gotten such high review scores, it fucking baffles me. Sadly, this is just going to encourage these devs to make more terrible games.

Play the SH2 Remake or the original Silent Hill 2 and have an actual unforgetful experience. Well, I guess this experience is unforgetful too but in a way where I was traumatized by having to endure playing it. At the end of it, I was almost dead inside from exhaustion.

This game was probably being made and during production, they were offered the Silent Hill license and just ran with it. This game would have been, probably a 4, 5 or 6 out of ten if they didn't put Silent Hill in the title.

Anything positive I can throw in? I think the core concept of the story was good but horribly executed. Ryukishi07 clearly doesn't understand what Silent Hill is and how it is supposed to work.

The music was good (Akira Yamaoka still makes great shit), but one of the tracks I swear to god gets used 15 times when you're with Fox Mask in cutscenes. And let's not forget this game uses the fucking VINE BOOM sound effect.

The ambience at the start of the game was genuinely good, but the more you have to deal with the combat system and the more enemies per encounter, it goes from unsettling to fucking annoying.

I knew this game was going to be terrible the moment I saw the announcement for it, and it proved to be even worse than I anticipated. And the audacity they have to ask people to re-play the game to experience the other endings is just foul.

Don't buy it, don't fund these devs. Go back to making Resident Evil multiplayer games and B-titles.

2/10 Silent Hill game, 4/10 game.


r/silenthill • • Oct 01 '25

Silent Hill f (2025) Reporting back on silent hill F later in game

5 Upvotes

Ok I promised in my last post I would report back on the game. My first post was about how I loved it until the point I was at and how the silent hill vibe was there.

I’ve just arrived at that point in the shrine, with the fox arm, yes... Now I understand more about the “this is not a silent hill game” comment. It feels like a separate game tbh from this point.

Jeez, it’s like one morning at the office the team came in and said no no no let’s do something different, f**k the silent hill title, let’s go full on Hinako, wth. And still yes I agree that it’s still a nice game, and I could call it silent hill until this point but not anymore now that’s not what I paid for.

They wanted to take a risk I guess which is good sometimes but that’s a bit too much haha


r/silenthill • • Sep 26 '25

General Discussion Not liking Silent Hill f doesn't mean we are "haters"

186 Upvotes

Can some of y'all stop with the toxic positivity? Not everyone who dislike the game is a "loser, hater, incel". Learn to tell things apart. I don't like the new game, but I played through it all. Does that make me a loser like some of you keep calling out others in the comments? No. There is a third group of people in this whole situation, they're called the trolls. It's them who haven't played SHF yet they jump in the hate bandwagon because that's what the internet is like nowadays. These people got "freedom of speech" confused with "I can say whatever I want with no consequences".


r/silenthill • • Dec 27 '25

General Discussion I don't want famous actors on my Silent Hill games so I'm ok with the cancellation of Silent Hills, also I don't want Kojima near a Silent Hill game despite his creative and innovative ideas.

0 Upvotes

I really don't. Open for discussion.


r/silenthill • • Feb 13 '26

General Discussion I feel Silent Hill lost the plot

0 Upvotes

I liked silent hill F and I am excited to see the new silent hill, kinda pumped me cause I might see a work very close to the Ballad of black Tom by Viktor Lavelle

But here is the thing people, when I played Silent hill....it was actually about Silent hill, it was not just a mysterious fog that covered the town with monsters, it was more of a purgatory that personified human darkness. The monsters in F were scary yes but completely lacked the disturbing factor because it was more inspired by Japanese monsters and Silent hill 2 complete devoid of symbolism compared to Abstract daddy or Valtiel

Even though the story is good, it lacked what made silent hill, that being purgatory aspect which isolates us and force us to encounter horrors and disgust done through symbolism both in monster and level design, like how iconic was the pizzeria/bowling place was in Silent hill 2 with its own unique ost, such is unfortunately not in Silent hill f and it has completely become a unique beast of its own wearing the skin of Silent hill

THE NEW ANNOUNCEMENT:

I am excited, and I really dont want them to follow F design and rulebook, I really dont want a franchise that has its horror born out of the subconscious or fear of the main character be it James or Heather, or like Henry confronting a psychic hell, to turn into a streamer slop game.

No offence meant, you guys rock


r/silenthill • • Sep 28 '25

General Discussion Updated my tier list after beating SHf for the first time.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Also switched Downpour over Shattered Memories as I grew more fondly towards Downpour.


r/silenthill • • Mar 07 '26

General Discussion You know what's sad? Return to Silent Hill is still a better and more faithful adaptation to it's source material, than Castlevania Nocturne and Devil May Cry.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/silenthill • • Sep 23 '25

General Discussion Purists shouldn’t be taken seriously

1 Upvotes

You’re allowed to criticize the newest game but being overly negative and dismissing it just because “it doesn’t take place in Silent Hill, so it’s not a true Silent Hill game” is stupid as shit. Resident Evil 4 is one of the most beloved games of all time yet it was a massive departure from the previous games in the series, not only in the setting and enemies but also the entire way the game is played.

It’s like some fans just want to drown in nostalgia and play the same games over and over again.


r/silenthill • • Aug 01 '25

General Discussion This is the thread for those that watched the new Silent Hill F content and are not enthused.

0 Upvotes

Just finished watching the hands-on preview, and let me start by saying that in NO MEANS do I think this game looks bad. In fact, it looks pretty good, though frustrating.

But it is still not giving me a single "Silent Hill" vibe, at all.

I was okay with the Japanese setting, but making the game combat-focused and more a Souls-Like just completely takes me out of it.

Having no guns makes sense for the time and place, but making the weapons breakable sounds like such an annoying add-on. I feel like that's why so many games stay away from that idea.

Silent Hill is all about the psychological horror, and having to manage inventory/level up(?) at save points/and perform counterstrikes to significantly damage enemies as a teenage girl just seems like it will make it less a Silent Hill and more a new "Souls-Like".

Game still looks fun! Just not getting any Silent Hill vibes from this. Thoughts?


r/silenthill • • Oct 05 '25

Silent Hill f (2025) Silent Hill f isn't a Silent Hill game, and Resident Evil 4/7 are the perfect examples why. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Confusing title, I know. But stick with me as there's a lot of merit in this point of view and when looking at RE4 and RE7 it becomes abundantly clear why SHf has alienated so many fans to the series.

I believe every game series has two identities; the internal identity, and the external identity.

  • The external identity is all the stuff on the outside; the visuals, the art design, the character design, the aesthetics of the 'world' along with the 'look', 'feel', and 'vibe'. It can even extend to things as small as the technology used and how computer screens or clothing looks. It's the cover of the book essentially.

  • The internal identity is everything within; the lore, the backstory, the overall story, the mythos, the characters, the 'rules' of the world, the world's history and chronology, and even the series' gameplay and core mechanics. It's the string in between the pages that holds the book together and even the letters on the page.

The reason I point these out is because Silent Hill f makes fundamental mistakes in these departments that no other Silent Hill game makes, and succeeding in these departments is the exact reason Resident Evil 4 and 7 were so critically acclaimed and were a welcome entries to the RE series which I'll explain later.

First, what is Silent Hill's identity?

*These can be subjective but the things listed below are the most widely accepted*

External

  • The Fog

  • The town of Silent Hill

  • The Otherworld (seen differently by each character but the most visually recognisable is the dirty steel and iron Otherworld seen in Silent Hill 1, 2, and 3, sometimes accompanied by rain)

  • Predominantly Western clothing and culture (cars, stores, etc also)

  • Flashlights

  • Horrific and gory monsters that delve deeply into body horror leaning towards grotesque sexual undertones.

  • The 'siren'

Internal

  • The cult (including mentions of native land, gods, sacrifices etc)

  • The history of the town of Silent Hill

  • Alessa/Cheryl's involvement in Silent Hill as a whole

  • White Claudia

  • Psychological manifestations individual to each person

  • The main character usually being an 'outsider' or someone not familiar with the place of Silent Hill or it's residents

  • The main character's plight being because of, or directly tied, to the town of Silent Hill

  • Side characters seeing and interacting with Silent Hill differently to our protagonist

  • Resource management

  • Infinite inventory

  • Clunky combat with enemies who can be avoided

  • Firearms to balance the combat's clunkiness

  • Notes and letters adding to the world of SH and expanding the lore

  • Puzzles

  • Multiple endings

  • Vagueness or ambiguity when it comes to 'canon' or giving an official answer to what happened (The canon endings to Silent Hill 1 and Silent Hill 2 are still fiercely debated today with the fate of Cybil and James still unclear over two decades later).

These lists are by no means definitive and differ between each person but I tried to make them as widely accepted and broad as possible to include differing thoughts and feelings on what makes Silent Hill.

Now, I'm going to show these lists again, but I'm going to cross out everything that Silent Hill f either doesn't do or fundamentally changes;

External

  • The Fog

  • The town of Silent Hill

  • The Otherworld (seen differently by each character but the most visually recognisable is the dirty steel and iron Otherworld seen in Silent Hill 1, 2, and 3, sometimes accompanied by rain)

  • Predominantly Western clothing and culture (cars, stores, etc also)

  • Flashlights

  • Horrific and gory monsters that delve deeply into body horror leaning towards grotesque sexual undertones.

  • The 'siren'

Internal

  • The cult (including mentions of native land, gods, sacrifices etc)

  • The history of the town of Silent Hill

  • Alessa/Cheryl's involvement in Silent Hill as a whole

  • White Claudia

  • Psychological manifestations individual to each person

  • The main character usually being an 'outsider' or someone not familiar with the place of Silent Hill or it's residents

  • The main character's plight being because of, or directly tied, to the town of Silent Hill

  • Side characters seeing and interacting with Silent Hill differently to our protagonist

  • Resource management

  • Infinite inventory

  • Clunky combat that isn't a focus but is made as easy as possible to keep it serviceable

  • Enemies who can be avoided or run through

  • Firearms to balance the combat's clunkiness

  • Notes and letters adding to the world of SH and expanding the lore

  • Puzzles

  • Multiple endings after your initial playthrough with each ending being equally as valid as the others in terms of an overall satisfying conclusion

  • Vagueness or ambiguity when it comes to 'canon' or giving an official answer to what happened (The canon endings to Silent Hill 1 and Silent Hill 2 are still fiercely debated today with the fate of Cybil and James still unclear over two decades later).

This is where the divisiveness comes from. It's not a 'fear of change' or a rejection of what's new. It's because Silent Hill f removes or fundamentally changes base pillars of Silent Hill's external and internal identity that each game previous has followed in some way or other.

You absolutely can change a lot of the external and internal identity of a game series, but the more you cut away, the less familiarity there is and it's how we get into situations like this. There has to be a balance.

Silent Hill f has the fog, it has to some extent the ability to use flashlights (lanterns), and it has grotesque body horror enemies that lean towards sexual undertones.
However it has no Silent Hill, it has no Otherworld (as the game takes place in Hinako's mind, confirmed by the additional endings, the Otherworld is simply another area in her mental struggle, it is not the Otherworld we know or are familiar with.), the Western aesthetic and stylings are gone along with the siren signaling a change in the world, which is honestly fine and a very minor aspect but I wanted to include them on the list as they have become iconic in their own right.

Regardless, in terms of External Identity, the only real constant is the fog and the body horror enemies, which can absolutely work so long as the Internal Identity balances out these changes.

Unfortunately Silent Hill f removes a large amount from the Internal Identity too.
There is a 'cult' in the game but they are not the cult who's actions have had a ripple effect in every SH game that came before f.

There is no mention or reference to Silent Hill as a town or the previous events of any of the games (I know it's set in the 60s but SH has always been very vague about the exact years that each game takes place so it's possible that this could play a role if they did decide to reference previous events or happenings but they didn't), along with this as mentioned above the game in fact takes place in Hinako's head so the idea of a 'Japanese Silent Hill' also isn't present here as it has no physical presence.

There is no mention or reference to Alessa/Cheryl or any other main player in Silent Hill's lore or history.

There is no confirmed mention of White Claudia. There are white flowers behind Shu's house that have hallucinogenic properties but for some reason the game never outright confirms this so as of right now there can be no definitive connection made.

The main character being an outsider isn't present here as Hinako is an engrained resident of Ebisugaoka and is familiar with the village and it's residents.

The town appearing different psychologically to each person doesn't apply here because no other person in the game is experiencing this alongside Hinako as it's all in her head.
Hinako's plight has nothing to do with the town of Silent Hill nor does Silent Hill have even an indirect influence.

There is resource management, but the infinite inventory system which Silent Hill favored in most games is no longer here.

Combat is now a major focus in the game, adding mechanics such as stamina and sanity bars, a 'Beast Mode' for Hinako's fox form, upgradeable stats, Omamori's that buff Hinako's abilities, and multiple enemy arenas that can only be progressed after defeating every enemy present. Along side intricate and over-the-top boss fights that visually and mechanically look more at home in Elden Ring than in an SH title.
Firearms are not present in Silent Hill f nor are ranged weapons like bows etc.

The game does not have multiple endings on a first playthrough. It has a locked ending with subsequent endings only available in NG+ onwards. These endings are not equally valid as unlike previous SH games, these endings act almost as a continuation of each other so instead of showing a different possible outcome they are actually used as a way to give the player more insight and information on what actually happened during the story.

A player who gets the In Water ending for SH2 and a player who gets the Leave ending will still both know that James murdered Mary after her sickness had developed to a point in which he couldn't cope anymore. None of the major story beats are different or missing for either player- simply the outcome.

A player who puts Silent Hill f down after 1 playthrough will have an objectively different and lesser experience compared to someone who finished 3 playthroughs for the True ending. The player who stopped after their initial playthrough will miss out on major plot points and story beats that fundamentally change the story and the canonicity of the events that happened during the game, imagine having to finish NG++ to get the cutscene where James watches the tape.

Vagueness and ambiguity are not present in Silent Hill f as the journal spells out on paper what each monster means, how it effects Hinako, how Hinako thinks about the people around her and what her desires and wishes are. Alongside this, the game has an agreed upon 'True ending' which settles most debate on the canon ending to the events of the game.

I love Silent Hill f, it's a really fun game that I put 40+ hours and 4 playthroughs into.
And if you enjoyed it and prefer to include it within the Silent Hill series then more power to you.

But to me, even as a spin off, Silent Hill f simply isn't a Silent Hill game.
It discards, ignores, or fundamentally changes so many aspects of Silent Hill's identity and makes no effort to try to balance this out with other aspects that I can't ever recommend it to someone who is interested in Silent Hill as a franchise.

Resident Evil 4 and Resident Evil 7 were two games that fundamentally changed RE as a series and even they had more respect for the source material that came before.

RE4 had an entire opening cinematic explaining the events of the previous games and how they tied into the events of RE4. Along with having Leon return as the protagonist and having the events of RE2 directly effect how he acts. Ada also makes her return here too.
RE7 has numerous references to RE events, organizations and characters; from the Chris Redfield cameo to the Alyssa Ashcroft newspaper article.

Those two games changed the type of series RE was, while keeping almost all of the External and Internal Identity of RE intact. (Umbrella, Raccoon City, Viral outbreaks, previously established characters, resource management, combat, inventory management, gameplay loop, the look and feel of the game etc)

Like I said, Silent Hill f is great and I really enjoy it. I just wanted to sum up why I personally (and maybe others) are so disappointed that this is the game we waited over a decade for.

I would love to hear everyone else's thoughts on this if you've been strong enough to endure my dog water typing skills for so long.


r/silenthill • • Sep 29 '26

Silent Hill: Townfall (2026) SH Townfall has boring environments and abysmal exploration :( Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

I really wanted to like this game, but I can’t get over how disappointing the environments and exploration are.

For the environments:
Outside of the fog and Simon’s otherworld, there are almost no horror elements present anywhere. Every single building/room you explore is just a normal empty room. This is a story about an oil rig disaster, WHY IS EVERYTHING SO CLEAN? Where is the decay and rot and oil sludge? Especially Zoe’s hospital section, there is literally one single spot with a little bit of oil staining that she comments on and the rest of the hospital is perfectly clean and normal (pic above as an example). Where is the viscera and gore?? Disturbing, grotesque environments are a staple of SH and this game has almost none of them.

The exploration:
Because stealth is so forced, the exploration absolutely suffers for it. The only purpose in exploring most rooms is to find a place to hide. 90% of what you explore is an empty room with a closet. Where are the creepy notes???? Strange things within rooms you can interact with? Hell, they could have even added some creepy sound design outside of the background ambience, like in SH2R when you enter a room and hear a gasp or heavy breathing. There is literally just nothing, no signs of the people who lived in the town and suffered from the disaster, and the only notes you really find just repeat the same shit about the medical center being overrun and lack of resources. There is ONE note you find where a resident talks about feeling sick and nothing else. For a game about immense suffering from a catastrophe, it felt extremely sterile and tame.


r/silenthill • • Sep 23 '26

Silent Hill: Townfall (2026) *SPOILERS* Anybody else feel underwhelmed? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Does anybody else feel... underwhelmed?

To be clear I think the game is fine overall

The characters (especially Ordell!?!) felt super underdeveloped and stale. Does Ordell have a personality? Like at all? Same with Zoe. I feel like the only person with personality in this game is Richard lol

The story itself felt very cookie-cutter. We knew almost from the very beginning that there was some kind of big disaster, that a corporation caused it, and that there was social upheaval. And we don't really learn anything that changes this at all. I spent 9 hour trying to uncover something more to the story for the game to just tell me the story exactly as it told it to us in the first 25 minutes lol. Like damn there's really not that much to it huh?

And no tie-ins at all to the cult or town of Silent Hill that's... interesting. At least f paid lip service to SH in a few documents. But I guess maybe I haven't found them and they're out there? I haven't seen anything anyways

I beat the game this morning and just realized that I haven't even thought about it once for like the last 5 hours. Like okay it's over that's about that


r/silenthill • • Feb 08 '26

Silent Hill f (2025) Silent Hill F is fine...

1 Upvotes

I wrote a long thing about the game and then I accidentally refreshed and lost it all, and I don't feel like writing it all again, so I will write the reduced version:

The game is fine, is not a bad game by any means, it has some lack of enemy variety, and very few bosses. But I didn't feel in any moment I was playing a Silent Hill game. At least for me SH is American horror and thriller through a Japanese lens, which makes for a very unique experience. This is not that, this is purely Japanese horrror, which I usually dont' enjoy very much. For that reason I didn't find the game even remotely scary, it has some f-up imagery but that's about it.

So, if you're in doubt if you should buy it, no, this is not the worst game ever made as some claim in this subredit, but if you want the SH experience, this is not it. If you like Japanese horror with some FOG, this is it. I think I'm really done if the future games are going to be like this, I should have known after Short Message and the whole "silent hill phenomenon" thing they invented, that this was their plan. At least I can look forward fot the next Bober's remake.

Anyway, good game, not scary, not Silent Hill (at least for me).


r/silenthill • • Sep 22 '25

Silent Hill f (2025) 🌸 Silent Hill F is Konami's RE:Village

Post image
0 Upvotes

Draw your own conclusions


r/silenthill • • May 27 '24

Discussion Anyone also thinks that SH3 is just not that good as everyone says it is?

1 Upvotes

I’ve been slowly making my way through every SH game, am currently at Homecoming if anyone cares. But before every game i tend to make a small research into the game into what people think about it, and it seems universally agreed that SH3 is the best one.

But after i’ve played it… i dunno man. It just feels like a lesser version of the first game? I never found the cult stuff that interesting, though i think that sh 1 and 4 handle it the best, but with 3 it just…. Not that good? The cult stuff felt kinda shit into it and god damn that start is awful. The starting mall might be the worst level in the franchise, it’s on the same level as the asylum from sh:o and the building world from sh4, it’s just too big for it’s own good, and it’s not that memorable as the mall from sh1. Then you have the station-metro-construction-building section of the game and it’s basically filler… you can’t tell me that there’s some hidden meaning to an ass sticking out from a wall in the construction building. The apartments part is… okay actually. Then the big twist happens and the game finally becomes good? The hospital-church might be the best section of the game! But then the game just ends with the most unfair fucking boss in the entire franchise. The controls don’t help as they are much worse in here than they were in any other SH game (even sh4).

Heather is also just kinda annoying she has her moments but i never found her that compelling. The only part that i’d argue are great is the fleshing out of Harry’s character and the overall theme of the game the focus of unwanted birth and rape are genuinely interesting even if the execution was subar.

The game also never really had a moment that scared me, the monster design was just goofy, a walking sperm cell? A fat guy? Dogs again? That one fly thing was the only thing that somewhat scared me but apart from that it’s just…. Eh

I am genuinely confused about why everyone just seems to praise the game. I know that opinion is subjective but i almost got doxxed because of me not liking SH3.


r/silenthill • • Apr 17 '24

Discussion My Silent Hill games tier list <3

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/silenthill • • Jan 24 '26

General Discussion Thoroughly enjoyed the new movie

Post image
0 Upvotes

Went in with low expectations but still hyped. Film was significantly better than I had thought it would be. It might not be a great adaptation or get the story right but the atmosphere and cinematography were everything I could’ve wanted. Also, the acting from James is great, especially during the emotional bits, even if his thick beard was hilariously fake. Shoutout to the guy I sat next to in the theater who was just as hyped, and was wearing James’ jacket from the game. Just enjoy movies, thats the point.


r/silenthill • • Feb 22 '26

General Discussion New generation vs Original

2 Upvotes

so there's two different kind of people. the ones who liked SH2R and SHF, and those who didn't. I'm the latter. I absolutely love the team silent era games but not the newer ones. why is it that I'm being attacked for having this opinion?

I feel like new silent hill is kinda what the original re4 was compared to the trilogy and code Veronica. games with a completely different feel, genre, and gameplay. I happen to love re4 cause it's a great game.

I just feel that for silent hill this transition from psychological horror to action-horror/ hack and slash doesn't work as well.

To me silent hill is all about the atmosphere and immersion. it's a game that makes you feel stuff in an emotional way. I feel that the heavy combat totally takes you out of that immersion.

what do you guys think? I have to disclaim that I respect everyone who enjoys the new and old games. I'm not trying to diss anyone, just sharing my opinion and I'm open to change it based on the reactions.


r/silenthill • • 25d ago

Silent Hill 2 (2001) SH2 and SH2, Am I A Snob?

0 Upvotes

So I played SH2 on PC years ago, properly experienced it. Fog and everything, you guys will know more but had the details you need for the quintessential SH2.

I recently tried out the remake, and it's weird but it just doesn't feel like SH2? It's a great game yeah, but maybe the nature of it being modern, made properly rather than taped together with the limitations of consoles and actually a full on graphical remake. The original SH2 just has a feeling... the fog, the density, the grittiness. It's grimy but as a juxtaposition it's also quite mellow, flowy, distant. It's strange but beautiful. It's probably just the place and time but it has that something.

Though looking online it seems to be really liked by fans, anyone else?


r/silenthill • • Jan 05 '25

Discussion Why Kojima's Silent Hills would not have fit Silent Hill.

5 Upvotes

Even with Kojima bringing in the talent of other artists like Del Toro and Junji Ito, I really didn't like the implications of what Silent Hills was going to be from what PT implied either.

Yes, people are correct in saying PT wasn't a demo for Silent Hills itself, but it was a slice of the sort of horror that Kojima's team was aiming for in the final game, the sort of horror that he found personally scary. A lot of that horror was very much taken from tropes that Kojima has consistently used his work, like Western movie motifs and 4th wall breaking. As a product by itself, that may have been fine if PT was promoting a standalone IP, but that sort of thing has never been part of Silent Hill's brand of horror.

Silent Hill's best moments of horror come from the disturbing implications of what we don't see, which makes the actual terrors of monsters or violence that reveal themselves all the more disturbing when they show up. Serious themes like unwanted pregnancy and familial abuse are displayed in purposely distorted imagery so it isn't blatant but has us dwelling on it, and the oppressive lonely atmosphere makes a contradicting feeling of claustrophobia in an open space.

Put it this way: Stanley's letters to Heather, messages from a character we never see but appears to be following our every move, are far more disturbing to encounter and read compared to repeatedly having the ghost of a dead lady jumpscare you while a fetus speaks about doppelgangers in a sink.

Would Silent Hills have been better than previous attempts post-Silent Hill 4? Very much so, given the clear technical talent on display in making PT and its subsequent promotions. But that doesn't mean it would've been a good Silent Hill game.


r/silenthill • • Sep 24 '26

General Discussion Playing Townfall rn and it feels like...

4 Upvotes

...every week when you get someone on here posting: "Hey guys, check out my new horror game inspired by Silent Hill".

Townfall feels like Konami saw one of those games, except they actually decided to slap on SH branding half way into development lol. Refunded.