r/shoujo • • May 08 '25

Discussion Shoujo hot take: The Underage/Adult Age gap romance genre needs to die.

0 Upvotes

When looking at this subreddit, there have been way too many manga/anime presented where the main couple has an age gap that is incredibly concerning. For example, a girl and her guard dog were talked about all over Twitter for how creepy it is with the main couple and the age gap involved. For context, the main girl is 15 and the love interest, Yakuza guy, is 26. He raised her ever since she was a child, and it's basically grooming the anime. I know that before 2023, the age of consent in Japan was 13, but it wasn't exactly black and white in terms of the law. Even though it is 16 now, a legal adult and a minor are still very creepy.

More recently, a new anime was launched that was posted here on the subreddit and then deleted, called Do Over Damsel. Where the main protagonist is 10 years old but has the mind of a 16 y/o and the ML is 19. IDC what age she is mentally, this kid is young enough to be in 4th grade and shouldn't be in love with a college student.

And don't get me started on Usagi Drop. It was the prime definition of creepy and a p3dophile's wet dream.
So in my mind, age gaps like that need to die off in the Shoujo genre. Your thoughts?


r/shoujo • • Aug 05 '25

Discussion Unpopular opinion about Takumi from Nana: Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

Takumi is far from perfect—he’s emotionally distant, often self-centered, and clearly prioritizes work over connection. But even with all that, I think he was ultimately the right outcome for Hachi given where she was in her life.

Nobu is sweet, romantic, and easy to love—but when Hachi got pregnant, he completely froze. He didn’t step up. He couldn’t take responsibility or make adult decisions. That’s because he was still a kid, living in a fantasy. Hachi needed stability, maturity, and someone who wouldn’t crumble under pressure. That wasn’t Nobu.

Takumi, on the other hand, immediately offered security—for her and the baby. He handled it like a man who knew the stakes. He might not have been warm, but he was present, financially and practically. And in a world like Hachi’s, where security is everything, that matters.

Takumi isn’t a romantic ending. But he’s a realistic one. And sometimes, especially for someone like Hachi, that’s the most fitting choice… it’s definitely not romantic. But for Hachi, who was lost and searching for safety, it made sense. Sometimes the best outcome isn’t the most emotionally satisfying one—it’s the one that offers stability when everything else is chaos.


r/shoujo • • May 03 '26

Discussion Do they belong here or not? (Rant)

0 Upvotes

I mean stories like witch hat atelier, apothecary diaries, fragrant flower blooms with dignity, horimiya, love is war, and other complex or a bit more well written romance or female lead manga, I feel like they could have published it as shoujo really.

I know it's probably a marketing strategy but it feels like they are limiting shoujo versatility when it actually feels like it would belong here. Mainly because most men would read seinen or shounen but not josei or shoujo meanwhile women read almost all genre.

It probably shouldn't matter much but it was just bothering me a bit so I put it out here. I normally love shoujo and I was disappointed they did not end up here, we could have had so much more.

If I am lacking more information please do tell me, but it just looked little disappointing to me that as soon as the story got a little more than dramatic romance or damsel in distress stories it got marketed as non shoujo.

Like I know people read everything nowadays regardless of demographics, but it's like screaming young girls aren't a fit demographics for complex thoughts.

In short I'm just disappointed

Edit: I have made a mistake, I MEANT SKIP AND LOAFER NOT FRAGRANT FLOWER THINGY, I mixed it up coz I was just commenting on something related to both of them ༎ຶ⁠‿⁠༎ຶ

Regardless of the publishing, and no I AM NOT LOOKING DOWN ON ALREADY EXISTING GREAT SHOUJO MANGA, like I already told I love shoujo but I feel nowadays the topics appealing to younger females have changed from what it was generations ago, so it should reflect on the topics used for current generation shoujo.

Also I'm not saying shoujo doesn't have complex characters (kanoko sama from koi dano/warao kanoko sama, skip beat, etc DO have similar complex characters to the manga I have mentioned above)

I'm figuring out how to attach images so I could put in some search results after searching online because of my confusion, I'll add it to another edit or comment as soon as I figure out how to do that.

I know this post is pissing off a lot of hardcore shoujo lovers but I just wanted to put it out, many shoujos do have the damsel in distress part where the male counterparts come to save them, not all but MANY shoujo exist and it's not a bad thing but it projects something when it's used that often.

Edit 2: my intention probably didn't get out well. I mean I don't like how it is marketed and it is getting more reach because of that. Skip beat or ouran or many great shoujo don't even get official english translation or a second season or good quality adaptation. Meanwhile I keep wondering if it would have gotten all that if it had been marketed for a different demographic. The ones I mentioned except few debatable ones could really be marketed as shoujo but would it have gotten this reach?

End: Is shoujo still at this age looked down upon ? That is my frustration. Im just mad how it is marketed and not how it actually is. The popular shoujo or how it is marketed is the one with damsel in distress storyline or clumsy female. I KNOW a lot of great shoujo leads exist but they are not making it into mainstream and that is disappointing


r/shoujo • • Apr 22 '24

am i the only one who think she is kinda annoying?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/shoujo • • Dec 27 '23

Discussion Why do so many shojo and other female-targeted works incorporate problematic elements such as weak (as in character, not physically) female leads and fetishized harassment/abuse?

0 Upvotes

TL;DR version: I notice works that target women/girls share problematic elements from shonen/seinen such as romanticized harassment, abuse, undermined agency, etc. Long answer if you're interested, keep reading (or just skip to the last paragraph)

Many have been talking about how shonen and seinen works poorly write their female characters (be it from shallow behaviors, not having much to do, etc.) and/or put them in problematic positions such as unwanted touching or be in relationships that are problematic (sheer age gaps, a perverted partner, etc.). Now, a common defense for this is that they are written for guys, so it stands to reason that they'd appeal to the target demographic. Besides the fact that I find this to be a sexist notion against guys like me that imply that we instinctively have shallow and disgusting tastes (I prefer women who written as dignified humans. I'm also repulsed by disproportionate bodies that would be painful for a women to have. If I wanted to sate schlocky fantasies, I'd turn to non-mainstream stuff that isn't pretending to be quality art), this also implies that works that target ladies don't have this issue with female characters. Now, I personally find myself enjoying shojo and Josei works more as many try to have balanced character development, with even the pretty boys that appeal to a girl's fantasy having agency. However, this does not mean that stories that target girls/women do not share the same issues as shonen. In fact, several are outright frustrating and disturbing.

I'm going to start of somewhat light with a rather popular work called Maid Sama. While it does feature a hard-working female lead named Misaki and the story deals with topics such as sexism, the male romantic lead, Usui, just rubs me the wrong way. For one thing, he constantly undermines Misaki's agency by going against her wishes and having to constantly save her (I know that many women like to have a guy who looks after them, and that's fine. But when it's so constant to the point of needing to be babysat and not getting things done yourself, it feels demeaning). Another thing is that he's rather possessive, such as one time where he placed a hickey on the heroine so he'd be the only one seeing her in a swimsuit. Worst of all, IMO, he's also perverted as he harasses Misaki, such as early on when he lifts up her maid uniform in an alleyway (it's one thing for a couple to screw around each other if they've known each other for some time and thus are playing with each other in private. But these two just met and Misaki is clearly embarrassed). These are traits that have been criticized in shonen/seinen leads, and yet they are present in a work that targets girls and is written by a female author. But again, this is a rather light example as at least the heroine does call him out and is hardworking. Unfortunately, there is an even worse example.

A more infamous one, IMO, is Vampire Knight. For one thing, the main female lead, Yuki, barely does anything. Maybe early on, she had some autonomy, but once she (SPOILERS, but who cares) gets her vampire powers, it drops significantly. She obsessively thinks about her two love interests, mostly sits around, and is just plain dull. She doesn't even choose who to be with, as her love interests do that for her. Perhaps most disgustingly, one of said love interests, Kaname, is an ancient ancestor or something, making it !nce$tuous.

Another is Wolf-girl and Black Prince. I don't want to get too much into the manga/anime as I've written too much, but basically, it involves romanticized abuse by a boyfriend (who at one point body shames the female lead for overeating), the heroine just putting up with him, and god knows how many other problematic elements. For more information, here's this review by Best Girl's Basement that co-stars Mother's Basement. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qfk-9PHQUpc

Even works that I like that have strong female characters and likeable romantic chemistry incorporate questionable elements. For instance, I like Kamisama Kiss and Fruits Basket, the first for having a likable heroine, Nanami, who goes through many struggles despite vulnerability and doubt, the other for having a cast of characters who have to sort out their trauma. And yet, the first one has our MC be a victim of being nearly assaulted by two of the main male leads, Mizuki (in his introductory chapters) and Tomoe (in the past arc), who are supposed to be likable leads. Sure, their actions aren't presented as good, no attributes are shown, and the intercourse doesn't commence, but the story seems to sweep these harrowing incidences under the rug. Worse, apparently, this was done as fanservice according to some viewers/readers). Meanwhile, the latter story has some adolescent girls get together with grown men (it's one thing to have a crush on an older person as long as one grows out of it. It's another to actually be in a relationship).

Perhaps there are other shojo/seinen works that are also guilty of the same sins of shonen/seinen, but I've written enough, if not too much. Many claim that works targeting boys/men are like that because thats what they want. And yet works that target the other sex are also not exempt from poorly-written female characters, downplayed harassment, and other problematic elements. Just, why would women want such demeaning stories about their own sex? I mean, maybe I can get there being fetishes or fantasies that one wants to sate, but why put them in sincere stories about women's struggles or the human condition (or at the very least, have them be justifiable. Maid Sama could have had the couple knowing each other for a while and both giving consent, so they play and flirt with each other in private, not have one violate the other's modesty without permission)? And keep in mind, I have a similar issue with male-targeted works that also seem to tell sincere stories about the human condition yet throw in fetishized elements that take me out of it (such as Death Note with Misa Amane clashing with the more grounded and serious characters and tone).

I'm sorry for my long and messy post.


r/shoujo • • Feb 09 '26

Discussion Tamon’s B side is giving this to me this right now

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I’ve been listening to the new album with the music video that dropped and I’ve been keeping up with the weekly episode :3. I think Tamon and usage are the fate of Ophelia as she never came for him he would’ve drowned I melancholy. Also neither one want to ruin their friendship.🥹🙏. I’m lowkey stealing this idea from an earlier thread and putting my own spin on it?

I’m excited to see more of the boys animated🕺🏻🕺🏻anyone have any thoughts or songs they’re listening to for Ramon’s b side. I saw a girl so confusing edit that was so good


r/shoujo • • Apr 18 '25

Discussion Why are so many people fixated labelling stuff as male gaze

34 Upvotes

Maybe I'm no better than a man but I need my thick, chubby, cute fl like why are big boobs now classified as male gaze? Be so for real. (I asked something similar before, and I ended up binge-reading most of the recs.) But back to the discussion, I really, really hate how US women sexualize thick, chubby women and then act shocked when men do the same. Like to be more clear, if you were to see a skinny, flat chested girl no one would really think of anything in fact people believe that you can't sexualize them but let say you get a bigger boob, curvy women in the same clothing everyone would be like "ehh it looks a bit male gaze". Like, it is only the male gaze if it is unrealistic, and everyone has their preferences. 

It feels like thick girls are viewed as something sex related.


r/shoujo • • May 12 '23

Discussion LGBTQ+ exclusion in the shoujo community? :(

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I stumbled across a bunch of shoujo Facebook groups (they work the same way as subreddits) that strictly exclude queer content. Didn't know this was a thing, but it made me really uncomfortable.

Shoujo has historically included LGBTQ+ characters, and have made attempts to represent them in an accurate, positive light—arguably more so than any other genre/demographic of manga. The first ever yuri manga was made by a sapphic woman. Sailor Moon, Fruits Basket, Gakuen Alice, Lovely Complex, and Itazura na Kiss are well-known shoujo that include queer ad trans side-characters. There’s also lots of shoujo with canonically LGBTQ+ protagonists, like Ouran High School Host Club, Banana Fish, Kase-san, Sasaki to Miyano, and Kieta Hatsukoi.

You’d actually be hard-pressed to find a good shoujo manga without queer characters—and these depictions are no more sexually explicit than any other shoujo depictions of romance.

But it seems to only be a problem when queer people are the main characters who fall in love? I don’t understand. Are these exclusionary groups just plain old homophobic/transphobic? Shoujo spaces would be the last place I would expect to see such blatant bigotry. :(


r/shoujo • • Mar 29 '26

Discussion Why isn't Yuri put in shojo magazines

0 Upvotes

I mean it's made for women and most Yuri mangas revolve around romance


r/shoujo • • Oct 05 '25

Recommendation Killing time between customers by reading "Red River" NSFW

Post image
2 Upvotes

It's been pretty compelling I really like the historical backdrop and all. There's def been a wave of outside of Japan historical fiction lately but most of them are set in China, feels refreshing that this one takes place in the Ancient Near East.

Uhh I might be irony poisoned but the SubaHibi meme is pretty helpful for describing a compelling character that's got that one funny little quirk that's hard to explain to people.


r/shoujo • • Mar 12 '24

Discussion itsuomi should just date oushi

0 Upvotes

this is my conclusion after latest ep.

they have more chemistry than itsu x yuki..

do you guys not agree?


r/shoujo • • Sep 29 '26

Discussion Is this normal for shoujo?

0 Upvotes

The FL always has child-like features; big eyes, small face, fringe. And the ML is always drawn as the cool one, sharp eyes and sometimes rarely smiles.

In most stories, the FL always is the emotional one or the first to fall in love, and she's the one who always seems to be pursuing the ML. Somehow the ML just seems to be in the agreeing position. The stories just focuses more on the romance part rather than backstories and emotional aspects of the characters.

Is this just because shoujo is written from the FL's perspective? I feel shoujo has good stories, but I would love the FL's look to be less child-like. I wish they'd include emotional aspects and backstories. I like romance, but I appreciate the emotional backstories just as much. But not too dark.

So far, I've really liked: 'May this snow field keep you smiling all the time', 'Firefly Wedding', 'Wake up, sleeping beauty', 'A condition called love'.
BL: 'Kimi no Yoru ni fureru', 'Bride of Ignat'.
Non romance: 'My Broken Mariko', 'A little room for happiness.'

Edit: Hello. I wanted to say that I misunderstood the demographic of manga to it's genre. I am a beginner manga reader. I apologize for keeping the misunderstanding in mind while posting this initially. Thank you for your recommendations so far.


r/shoujo • • Feb 23 '26

Nana is the bad person

12 Upvotes

In my opinion I said MY opinion

Hachi was not a helpless victim. She was opportunistic.

Everyone babies her because she cries a lot. But crying doesn’t erase accountability.

She knew Shoji was drifting and still clung to him.

She knew Nobu loved her but couldn’t offer stability.

She knew exactly what kind of man Takumi was.

And she chose him anyway.

Not because she was brainwashed.

Because he was rich. Famous. Powerful. Certain.

Takumi didn’t trick her into loving him. He solved her problem.

Pregnant. No career. No direction.

Takumi = security.

And deep down? That mattered more to her than romance.

The fandom calls it manipulation.

But if Takumi was ugly and broke, would she have stayed?

Be honest.

Hachi didn’t “fall” into toxicity. She gravitates toward men who validate her and elevate her status.

She wanted to be chosen by someone important.

Takumi is important.

And that’s the truth nobody wants to say.

Nana O chased passion.

Hachi chased comfort.

And comfort won.


r/shoujo • • Dec 10 '25

Recommendation shoujo mangas that doesn't center around heterosexual romance?

1 Upvotes

bonus if it's yuri


r/shoujo • • Nov 17 '24

Discussion Are there any openly Polyandrous Shoujo?

1 Upvotes

We've had a trend lately of openly Polygamous LN/Manga/Anime for dudes. But I genuinely wanna see the reverse as well. Especially since I generally trust Shoujo to handle Emotions better.


r/shoujo • • Mar 03 '26

Discussion One of the worst love triangle ever [nina the starry bride]

0 Upvotes

This post is only for those who also didn't find ‘nina the starry bride' to their liking or who have neutral feelings (like dunno what to say type) cause i want to hear thoughts about what they didn't liked too (if someone really didn't liked it) and I'm also fed up with sett fans all over the internet (i know that he got some character development later on and he had some sad backstory but it was difficult for me to follow this all) i don't have problems with sett fans cause everyone have their own personal taste but it was too much and sett was everywhere. I heard about nina the starry bride that how good it is and kind of similar to yona of the dawn with Princess setting so i thought to give it a try but i dropped it three times cause it was really not what I'm into (according to me it got appreciation more than it deserved) beside Sett was kinda like a red flag and many readers found him to their liking infact I'm also in red flag but sett was not the type I'm into rather if i had to ship nina then i would choose azure more (not both the mls are perfect but azure is kind of better than sett)

I really don't hate love triangle but i hate it when we are not clear to whom fl is going to end up with and when she develops love for both the mls at the same time and it's difficult for me to understand that how can a person develop romantic feelings for two characters at the same time and when it showed the romantic/physical connection with both the male characters, One time she is kissing azure then the other time she's kissing sett then again azure and the cycle goes on....both male characters were getting the equal treatment which made it difficult to find out who actually is the ml and I'm not into second male character too (not that i hate them as long as their personality is good) i feel bad about them when they don't get the fl but i never ship them with fl as long as male lead's personality is not really bad or not treating the fls like shit cause I'm the type who instantly consider the male character who shows up first in the series as the main male character (when they are literally giving the main male character's vibe and when authors intention were also same to show them as ml and most of the time it also came true where fl ends up with them)

I also don't like love triangle when fl already had a lover then she met another character and started to develop love for him too but i don't mind when that other side character betray her and then she finds love from somewhere else. example- yona of the dawn, yona had feelings for su-won but when he betrayed her then she found that love from hak sure it took time but her feelings towards su-won completely changed after this.

Examples of manga where i didn't mind love triangle- my little monster, mizutama honey boy, kamisama kiss, fruits basket (in the initial part where we weren't confirm that how yuki sees tohru), yona of the dawn (initial part, i was secretly rooting for hak even when we got know that she has feelings for su-won but i also didn't got annoyed by him until he betrayed her and i was glad about how the story took the turn) anitomo etc

Another example like “nina the starry bride" -- “the requiem of the blooming princess”. In this manga fl was a Princess who had her childhood lover (secretly loves him) but she send off to marry second prince of another kingdom to form alliance and that prince really killed her childhood lover who came to save her and when she came back to past (time travel) she decided to take revenge on him then after some time we get to see that he's a pity character (these are not spoilers, these all are mentioned in the earlier chapters) she even got ready to sleep with second prince so that she will get the opportunity/opening to kill him, i mean really? and according to how the story is going on I'm kinda sure that she'll develop love for this second prince too!

There are 2-3 more princess setting stories in my read list i hope i wouldn't get disappointed by them like I'm from these two!

Btw Don't take this all seriously to all the nina fans, i don't intend to hurt your feelings i just want to discuss this with someone here if they also didn't liked it when this all happen!


r/shoujo • • Jan 21 '25

Any guys interested in a male-focused shoujo/otome manga discord chat group?

0 Upvotes

Wondering if theres any interest for a group like this. I've been in some shoujo communities and discords before but never really found ones where I could fit in.

I've noticed that my tastes in shoujo manga rarely aligns with others and struggle to find people who read the same stuff. Also the way people enjoy and communicate about shoujo manga in these spaces tend to be a bit inapproachable to me.

Just want to see if this is a personal issue or if guys really enjoy shoujo in a different way from women. In case anyone prefers to just chat 1 on 1 instead of joining an entire group, I'm down for that too.


r/shoujo • • May 24 '24

Shojo with no romance

1 Upvotes

I am new to shojo and need recommendations without romance. As a guy, I like shojo, but only when there is no romance. I am okay with a male or female protagonist.


r/shoujo • • Oct 09 '24

Discussion Why is Ranma not a Shoujo?

4 Upvotes

I'm genuinely quite curious about this. As a child, I was attracted to the show because of the really cute character design and romantic comedy aspects.

I get that people say that it's a Shonen because of the martial arts, but I think that the relationship between Ranma and Akane was always the highlight of the series.

When the remake came out, I was a little bummed out that I didn't see any discussion about it here, since I always thought it was part of the genre because of what I mentioned before.

If it isn't of the topic of the subreddit it can't be helped, but I was wondering if somebody could help me understand.


r/shoujo • • Feb 25 '26

Discussion Nana - extremely disappointed after reading nana Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I’m incredibly sad right now. I’ve been reading several spoilers, especially those regarding Takumi’s love for Reira, and it just makes me furious at the author. Yazawa put someone in the story who only took things away from my favorite character.

I can’t find a single reason why Hachi had to have a child with Takumi, or why they had to get married. I wouldn’t have minded a 'one-night stand'—I would’ve suffered a bit at first, and then the story would move on. She could have eventually found a man who didn't abuse, betray, or trap her. Why? For what reason?

I don’t want it to be Nobu either; I have zero sympathy for him in any aspect, including his appearance. Nothing about him attracts me. I realize I’m being self-centered thinking the story should go my way, but how can I avoid it? Only I know what I like and what I want... so why shouldn't I think about how I wished the story would be?

I wish there had been a tall, black-haired man, someone who wore suits, who was responsible, a provider, and caring toward Hachi. Someone she could have better moments of 'normalcy' with, like the domestic scenes she had with Takumi. Instead, the author chose to give her a marriage and a child with a man who already had another woman in his heart—someone who eventually chooses that other woman and realizes his true feelings for his 'real' love.

Why waste so much of Hachi’s life on a man who leads her nowhere? She just becomes a sad woman, separated from a husband who doesn't love her. He is a disgusting, loathsome man. Clearly, the author doesn't want us to like him, given the detestable scenes she wrote, so why do this to Hachi? I don’t understand. I can’t spend another second reading this story; it feels empty now. The band scenes mean nothing to me anymore. I’m exhausted. I hope I can go back to reading it soon... just a rant hoping someone else has felt this way.


r/shoujo • • Nov 22 '25

Recommendation Recommendations featuring a trans woman?

15 Upvotes

I wondered if anyone has any recommendations featuring trans women or characters who hide that they were born male


r/shoujo • • Jun 13 '26

As some one who doesn't watch a lot of anime, I am confused why Romantic Killer isn't a shoujo

5 Upvotes

My understanding was that what makes something a shounen vs shoujo was its target audience. Romantic Killer feels like it has women more in mind than men. So what makes it a shounen instead of a shoujo?


r/shoujo • • Jan 18 '26

Discussion Does the Honey Lemon Soda anime feel way too childish for a high school story?

4 Upvotes

Is it just me or does the Honey Lemon Soda anime look way too childish? The animation makes it feel like elementary school instead of high school 😭


r/shoujo • • Apr 18 '25

Review My Happy Marriage

16 Upvotes

I watched the first season cuz I heard it was good and also netflix kept on putting it on my face sooo ya. I didn't like it. There was no buildup, no major personality and I felt like it was patriarchal. I didn't like the FL at all. She was so also submissive and even when she stood up it was for "danna-sama". I had to watch it at 1.5x (i wish netflix had a 2x option). I couldn't continue watching S2. So that's what I wanted to share, it's been long since I saw something i didn't like. I hope no one gets offended. Sorry.

Edit: I get that this is based on a historical setting and that's why it is patriarchal but it doesn't undo the fact that it is. The way she was being traded from here to there was something I felt bad seeing. And the age gap between the leads???? Also about her being submissive... I know she was traumatic about her childhood and it will take some to heal that but i didn't like how she was so fixated on the ML. Even when she stood up for herself it was because of her 'husband to be'.

I didn't know people could be this rude.