r/shmups • u/Tantra_Charbelcher • Nov 05 '23
Star Fox 64 is the most underrated shmup, and it's not even close
To shut down the first argument, Starfox 64 is absolutely a shmup and is erroneously classified as a rail shooter. In every rail shooter you can only aim and maybe duck in a select few. House of the dead and gal gun are rail shooters where you have no movement options whatsoever, you are quite literally on an invisible rail. In starfox 64 you have complete range of movement across a 2d plain. Yes you can go faster and slower through the level, but you can do that in Eschatos and Raging Blasters as well. The 3D is irrelevant. There is no planet where Starfox 64 is not a shmup but raystorm and ray crisis are.
With that out of the way, Starfox 64 exceeds most shmups in every aspect, starting with full voice acting. Not only is every character fully voice acted, including bosses and side characters like Bill and Kat, but the dialogue is so iconic it's become memed. Especially for the time, a fully voiced acted action game was unheard of. Compare it to Raiden V where you need an option to mute the voice acting.
The graphics and art direction are stellar. There are dozens of different enemy units with different traits and behaviors. With the the 3D version, aliasing is gone. When you destroy a unit, it explodes into fire, often breaks apart and crashes like a real air unit would after taking damage. Each character is extremely distinct and memorable. Each level is completely differentiated from how the other levels look, same goes with bosses.
The music and sound design are superb. The entire game is cinematic with victory music after boss cutscenes, distant shots of the battle you're heading into, little stories at the start of levels. Literally each boss has a different pilot with full voice acting.
The gameplay is stellar. Basing score on units destroyed is wholly unique in shmups. There are strategies for each level. Bosses level to level are vastly different from one another. Some levels have multiple bosses depending on your route. The game is responsive, accessible, and downright fun. You don't need ten kinds of power ups to be good or ten different crafts, just one good one. Razion EX doesn't even have power ups.
The game design is what really elevates it to GOAT status. You start on lush, modern Corneria with a city invasion. Then you can enter a fleet battle or go through an asteroid field depending on your performance. Every level presents unique threats. Asteroids, an enemy mercenary team, gundam units, lava that melts your ship, debris from a destroyed base, underwater wildlife, search lights, missiles aimed at your carrier, in one level you have to fight a fucking train with multiple ways to stop it. If you prove your superior skill, you fight the entire enemy fleet head on in Area 6. There are secret routes that lead clear across the map, and after you 100% the game you unlock an all new harder mode. Each person in your crew does something unique whether highlighting secret routes, analyzing boss hp, or revealing boss weaknesses. Starfox 64 figured out how to make a triple A shmup 25 years ago by giving us several different routes instead of a 10 hour shmup.
Whenever people talk about best shmup ever, Starfox 64 is never in the conversation, but it should be. The level of polish, the personality given to each character, the breadth of enemy units, how each level is wholly unique whereas even the best shmups fail to differentiate levels with more than just a different number (dodonpachi, eschatos, rolling gunner, crimzon clover). Sure it's not as challenging as 2D shmups of the era, and high score chasing might be simpler, but the quality and quantity of content are obvious. This game is simply fun and well made, and that should matter more than how high you can make your high score.
