r/sharditkeepit • • Oct 13 '19

BreakDown So you think you have a god roll?

1.3k Upvotes

Hello Guardian, my name us u/pandapaxxy. So you got a weapon, whether it be from the end of a crucible match to just lying on the ground. You want to know if it’s good, right? How it performs compared to all the other weapons within the world of Destiny. Well I have you covered. I have made breakdowns on all the weapons starting way back to Forsaken (and even beforehand), all the way through the seasons to now. You can either browse the recommendations in one place here without my ramblings, or look further below to see why I recommend each perk.

First things first: What constitutes a god roll?

This is always a tough question to answer, but I’ll do my best. It is a weapon or set of weapons / armor that best fits what you need it to do. Whether that is a build for endgame content, something to min / max for power fantasy, or just the way you like to play. It is the perfect set of weapons for you.

The community at large likes to talk about the best of the best, and sometimes it’s really as simple as “has damage boosting perk” and “speedy fast reload” that makes it great. Other times it’s the nitty gritty that people seem to like. Every weapon roll tells a story, some are meant for a build, others meant for materials. But you’ll figure that out a bit later.

Spare Rations and Mindbender's Ambition

Forsaken

Black Armory / Season of the Forge

Joker’s Wild / Season of the Drifter

Curated Weapons Breakdown

Penumbra / Season of Opulence

Shadowkeep / Season of undying

Garden of Salvation weapons

Armor 2.0

Season of Dawn

Season of the Worthy

This is a living document of sorts. It will be updated with more and more weapons as they get released. But will be made constantly as reddit archives posts older than 6 months.

I hope you enjoy! And happy hunting!

Edit: added current season


r/sharditkeepit • • Sep 14 '18

BreakDown Let's talk Forsaken God Rolls

994 Upvotes

Hello Guardians, my name is u/pandapaxxy with r/sharditkeepit. Today I will be discussing "God Rolled" weapons that were introduced with the Forsaken DLC. I know you're itching to read the rest and find out which weapons are top tier, but in this post will be a table leading to each individual weapon class, because reddit puts a limit on posts at 40,000 characters. The topic of discussion are PvE and PvP God Rolls. Many will overlap from PvE to PvP, and some might be far from what you think. However, that's the great thing about random rolls!

Spreadsheet, same information as below, just with 100% less Panda ramblings.

NOTE: These, again, are my ideas of tried and tested God Rolls. Are they 100% perfect? No. Are they going to mesh with your play style? I cannot say for certain.

The weapons below are broken down by weapon archetype and then RPM within an archetype. Hopefully it all makes sense. Energy / Kinetic for “primary” or “special” weapons does not matter their frames and perks are all that matter.



Auto Rifles

Bows

Hand Cannons

Pulse Rilfes

Scout Rifles

Sidearms

Submachine Guns

Shotguns

Sniper Rifles

Fusion Rifles

Linear Fusion Rifles

Rocket Launchers

Grenade Launchers

Swords



See something you want to discuss down below? Let’s talk God Rolls! Now that you know them try and find one that tailors to you. Maybe your roll isn’t here, still could be good. Don’t be too worried about getting “the perfect roll”.


r/sharditkeepit • • May 28 '21

BreakDown I've created a Vault Analyzer for Destiny Item Manager search that analyzes my armor and tells me what isn't a good roll or worth keeping, among many other useful functions to help keep my vault cleaner!

813 Upvotes

How do I use this?

Instructions are inside the link on the "Vault Analyzer" page with illustrated steps.

Link to the Vault Analyzer with Instructions:

Google Sheets Link

Plain Text Instructions. For those who can't use google sheets. This link is just text, the google sheets link above has much better presentation and illustrations.

What this “Vault Analyzer” is:

This Vault Analyzer is a very long search for Destiny Item Manager that highlights what you can dismantle without worrying about it being useful. The main goal is to make the process of checking random stat armor simpler by reducing the need to look at every piece and decide in the moment "is this good?" This is done by performing mathematical analysis and checks on every armor piece in your vault to check if they reach any of the set conditions. These conditions are listed in the "Items to be Kept" section of the google doc on the Vault Analyzer page. The Analyzer also helps prevent mistakes like deleting that pinnacle you just got from running a dungeon and making sure you have raid armor in each slot to utilize Raid Mods without accidentally deleting those pieces.

What this “Vault Analyzer” is not:

My Vault Analyzer is not telling you how to play or limiting your builds for a specific meta, you are in control. First, the Analyzer cannot dismantle anything, you dismantle items in game. The Analyzer will keep any armor that could be useful to any player. I don't have to agree with your play style, but the Analyzer will keep armor that will help you make your builds. Also, the Analyzer is not saying the highlighted items are the only things you can trash since it does not filter things like weapons based on perks. Also, there may be armor rolls you don't want that are considered interesting by the Analyzer. If you want to delete more, tag items with the junk tag and the next time you use the Analyzer, those items will be included.

Who should use this Vault Analyzer?

Anyone. From weekend warriors to daily hardcore grinders, this is designed for everyone.

For you weekend warriors who only play when the kids are asleep, this should help reduce the chaos and pressure that is "I don't understand armor," while making sure you have armor to abuse things like Hunter invisibility for Nightfalls. No more checking armor but still knowing you can make an effective build for PvE or a casually competitive build for PvP. While also knowing you won't accidentally dismantle any useful items for light leveling or utilizing raid mods. Just follow the analyzer's recommendations and go have fun. Tip: Recovery is the most important stat for PvE. Resilience shines brighter in PvP.

For you daily grinders, this can help make sure you're keeping armor for your late game builds for PvE and PvP without having to consider every drop that you earn. The analyzer looks for any combination of stats that can theoretically contribute to any kind of build from a no-mods build with T10 Recovery, T7 Discipline, T7 Intellect on Warlock for PvE to a fully modded 10/10/10/5 Hunter build for PvP. These aren't the only builds nor are they the meta I'm pushing, the Analyzer is very open ended and looks for all combinations of stats.

My Breakdown of Armor & How this Works

Link

Thanks

Huge thanks to the DIM Development team for all of their work on Destiny Item Manager and for their support.

Edit: Formatting.


r/sharditkeepit • • Apr 12 '21

Vendor God Roll Khvostov 7G-02

812 Upvotes

Roles are: Adaptive Frame,


r/sharditkeepit • • Feb 20 '21

BreakDown Season of Chosen Massive Breakdown

683 Upvotes

Hello guardians u/pandapaxxy here with another breakdown, this time for Season of the Chosen. Zavala started another war with the Cabal on Mars. While I started another season off with a breakdown. Jokes aside let’s get into this. If you’ve never seen any of my breakdowns you can find last season’s breakdown here. The way I do this is simple. I organize weapons based on slot (not ammo type) and alphabetically.

If you’re more interested in the meat and potatoes of the breakdown without explanations you can find my full spreadsheet here

Every single legendary weapon in Destiny 2 is here, updated as of Update 3.0.0.2 (and this current season has the most recent balancing taken into account.)

NEW!!! Thanks to @Rusty Na1l on discord for helping me sort this out. But you can now search for any weapon you’d like from Season 10 (Season of the Worthy) to today. Any non-sunset weapon will be available to you. What you have to do is make a copy of my spreadsheet to use for yourself, scroll over to the search tab and use the drop down to pull any weapon instead of having to know what season it came out in and finding it.

Note: Any adept weapon introduced this season is the same as the non-adept version as far as I can tell. The only difference is being able to slot the adept mods. The base stats and perk pools are the same. So you can take the regular recommendations as the same for the adept variants.

If you so decide to view both MnK and Controller recommendations you’re going to find a lot of the same information, this is because the perk pools aren’t super varying to make the recommendations black and white like in seasons past, but also because the gap between the two input methods is feeling a lot smaller. I’m comfortable saying both recommendations could be taken either way (with a proper pinch of salt).

New Perks

Returning Weapons MnK

Ordeal, Ritual, Season Pass MnK

Battleground, Faction MnK

Iron Banner, Trials of Osiris MnK

Returning Weapons Controller

Ordeal, Ritual, Season Pass Controller

Battleground, Faction Controller

Iron Banner, Trials of Osiris Controller

That is all for the new season! I’m sorry I couldn’t get this out before the Messenger Weekend™ finished so you could know what to grind for. New perks always make my job just a little harder. I want to test them myself and that’s not always possible in a quick fashion.

I also want to thank you for reading and sharing these, it’s all I ever asked for when making these breakdowns. This will be the last official breakdown I am going to do. I will be stepping down as a moderator and taking a break. This is long overdue and I am just so appreciative of all that has happened since my first Destiny 2 breakdown all those years ago.

We can even go further back in time to Destiny 1 when I made some Vendor Reset posts back in Age of Triumph (Bungie please add rotating vendor weapons).

It has certainly been a journey and one I never thought would happen when I first started a reddit account asking about weapon rolls myself.

Thank you for helping me hone this craft throughout my time and encouraging me through talking and sharing my posts. I could have never done it without you. I don’t know if I will come back, and if I do it will take some time to catch up to the latest sandbox changes and start making breakdowns again. I will always hold Destiny close to my heart as the memories and stories and weapons have all served to create experiences I hope I never forget. You all made this community feel like home and I cannot thank you enough. Even though I will be leaving the weapons will never stop, so think critically. Know how you play and how weapons can leverage that, and always always be willing to explore other weapons.

Eyes up, and as always: Happy hunting Guardians.


r/sharditkeepit • • Oct 20 '21

PvP PC This sub is growing into a weird showboat fest

660 Upvotes

If you are willing to invest a significant amount of time grinding for a God Roll pvp Palindrome I am assuming that you have the competence to know that a Hammer forged, High cal/Ricochet, Killing wind, Rangefinder, Range MW Palindrome is a God Roll. Especially when the posts states that you "grinded tirelessly for it". Thats like finding a $100 bill and going into your bank and asking the teller if the newly found $100 bill is valuable. FFS of course it is. Mods go ahead and delete this post, or downvote it to infinity. It's just annoying. This sub should be about people actually asking questions about their rolls inquiring about perks in combination with one another, and others genuinely giving advice about it. What is the point of posting a perfect roll. And everyone and their mother shouting "WOW GOD ROLL SO JEALOUS". For some kind of weird sense of self assurance? Bye.

Don't want to be this dude, but I appreciate the awards. Happy to hear that people seem to agree as well.


r/sharditkeepit • • Jan 18 '22

BreakDown So you think you have a god roll

566 Upvotes

Hello Guardians, my name is u/PandaPaxxy.

So you got a weapon, whether it be from the end of a crucible match, strike, gambit all the way to just lying on the ground. You want to know if it’s good, right? How it performs compared to all the other weapons within the world of Destiny 2. Well I have you covered. I have made breakdowns on every weapon starting from vanilla Destiny 2 (and even beforehand) to current day. Here is my last breakdown from the 30th anniversary weapons.

First things first: What constitutes a god roll?

This is always a tough question to answer, but I’ll do my best. It is a weapon that best fits what you need it to do or compliments your build. Whether that is a build for endgame content, something to min / max for power fantasy, or just the way you like to play. It is the perfect set of weapons for you.

Another way to look at a "god roll" is a 5/5. The barrel, magazine, first and second trait, and masterwork are all what you'd desire. 5/5 rolls can be heavily tailored to you, so your 5/5 might be different from your friends 5/5 or even mine.

The community at large likes to talk about the best of the best, and sometimes it’s really as simple as “has damage boosting perk” and “speedy fast reload” that makes it great. Other times it’s the nitty gritty that people seem to like. Every weapon roll tells a story, some are meant for a build, others meant for materials. But you’ll figure that out a bit later.

Here is my updated list of all non-sunset weapons for you to grind out before the end of Season of the Lost.

Big thanks to u/sirstallion, u/_lady_y and my Patrons for their support. If you'd like to become a Patron you can find the updated intro here.

Let me know your thoughts below! Some of the weapons have been updated from the last breakdown to now, so keep that in mind.

Happy hunting Guardians!


r/sharditkeepit • • Dec 13 '21

BreakDown 30th Anniversary Weapons Breakdown

539 Upvotes

Intro! Explosions! Woooo! We back at breakdowns y'all

Definitely remove that and rewrite it.

Hello Guardians, my name is u/PandaPaxxy. I am back!.. sort of. Did you miss me? I have a lot of work to do if I want to truly say I'm back, but who knows if I'll catch up on my backlog. But this is a small breakdown for the 30th anniversary update and I do miss making these for you.

If you haven’t seen my breakdowns before I do things a little differently. I will be organizing the new weapons by activity, weapon slot, and then alphabetically. That means the new 6 man activity, kinetic and then alphanumeric. Then comes energy for the same activity and so on.

Included in this one breakdown are MnK recommendations, Controller recommendations, and my own personal roll for the weapon I'm chasing.

I will not be linking my older breakdowns because my last one was Season of the Chosen...yikes.

Without further ado, let's start with the new seasonal content's perks. I hope you're as excited for this as I am. The Dares are so much fun, and the dungeon should be giving out incredible loot. (PS it's the first dungeon I've solo flawlessed).


New Perks:

Legacy PR-55 Frame - Customized frame with dramatically increased accuracy, stability, and targeting while hip firing. (Only on the BxR-55 Battler)

Blunt Execution Rounds - Damaging nearby combatants with melee abilities dramatically increases handling and damage. Expires after a short duration or the next shot.

Rolls on the BxR-55 Battler

Cold Steel - Powered Sword hits slow targets.

Rolls on Zephyr

Duelist’s Trance - Sword final blows grant increased charge rate, efficiency, and defense until this weapon is stowed.

Rolls on Half-Truths, Hero of Ages, The Other Half

Eager Edge - Gain increased Sword lunge distance immediately after switching to this weapon.

Rolls on Half-Truths, The Other Half

Golden Tricorn - Final blows with this weapon grant bonus damage. While this buff is active, grenade or melee kills of the same damage type greatly increase its damage and duration.

Rolls on 1000 Yard Stare, Matador 64, Retraced Path

Light Battery - Lightweight, agile battery.

  • Increases handling speed

  • Increases reload speed

Rolls on Retraced Path

Perpetual Motion - This weapon gains bonus stability, handling, and reload speed while the wielder is in motion.

Rolls on Cold Front, Eyasluna, Pardon Our Dust, Wastelander M5, 1000 Yard Stare, BxR-55 Battler, Matador 64, Retraced Path

Tactical Battery - This weapon has multiple small improvements.

  • Slightly increases stability

  • Increases reload speed

  • Slightly increases range

Rolls on Retraced Path




Dare’s of Eternity

Pardon Our Dust - Kinetic Grenade Launcher

Source: Xûr's Treasure Hoard in Eternity

  • Rate of Fire: 90

  • Impact: 55

  • Range: 76

  • Stability: 35

  • Handling: 71

  • Reload Speed: 72

  • Mag size: 1

  • Aim Assist: 75

  • Recoil Direction: 77

Curated Roll:

Lightweight Frame / Quick Launch / Spike Grenades / Pulse Monitor / Rampage

Recommended Controller PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Quick Launch, Smart Drift Control, Linear Compensator

  • Magazine: Spike Grenades, Blinding Grenades

  • Perk 1: Auto-Loading Holster, Ambitious Assassin

  • Perk 2: Vorpal Weapon, Demolitionist, Adrenaline Junkie

  • Masterwork: Reload or Velocity

Recommended Controller PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Volatile Launch, Confined Launch, Quick Launch

  • Magazine: Proximity Grenades

  • Perk 1: Auto-Loading Holster

  • Perk 2: Demolitionist, Vorpal Weapon

  • Masterwork: Blast Radius or Velocity

Recommended MnK PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Quick Launch, Smart Drift Control, Linear Compensator

  • Magazine: Spike Grenades, Blinding Grenades

  • Perk 1: Auto-Loading Holster, Ambitious Assassin

  • Perk 2: Vorpal Weapon, Demolitionist, Adrenaline Junkie

  • Masterwork: Reload or Velocity

Recommended MnK PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Volatile Launch, Confined Launch, Quick Launch

  • Magazine: Proximity Grenades

  • Perk 1: Auto-Loading Holster

  • Perk 2: Demolitionist, Vorpal Weapon

  • Masterwork: Blast Radius or Velocity

Panda's personal roll:

Quick Launch / Blinding or Spike / Auto-Loading Holster / Vorpal Weapon / Velocity MW

The first weapon is Pardon Our Dust, a kinetic grenade launcher. The downside to this is it is worse than last season’s Ignition Code. Both in farming and rolls you can get. If you already have a good Ignition code there is very little reason to get another one of these. If you don’t have a good roll yet, then this will be a very easy farm to get one without having to go back into last season’s content.


Wastelander M5 - Kinetic Shotgun

Source: Xûr's Treasure Hoard in Eternity

  • Rate of Fire: 80

  • Impact: 65

  • Range: 50

  • Stability: 46

  • Handling: 69

  • Reload Speed: 63

  • Mag size: 6

  • Aim Assist: 49

  • Recoil Direction: 51

Curated Roll:

Lightweight Frame / Smallbore / Assault Mag / Perpetual Motion / Killing Wind

Recommended Controller PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Barrel Shroud, Corkscrew Rifling, Smallbore

  • Magazine: Assault Mag, Tactical Mag, Appended Mag

  • Perk 1: Subsistence, Lead from Gold, Slideshot

  • Perk 2: One-Two Punch, Trench Barrel, Adagio

  • Masterwork: Reload

Recommended Controller PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Full Choke

  • Magazine: Assault Mag, Accurized Rounds

  • Perk 1: Perpetual Motion, Slideshot

  • Perk 2: Opening Shot, Killing Wind

  • Masterwork: Range or Handling

Recommended MnK PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Barrel Shroud, Corkscrew Rifling, Smallbore

  • Magazine: Assault Mag, Tactical Mag, Appended Mag

  • Perk 1: Subsistence, Lead from Gold, Slideshot

  • Perk 2: One-Two Punch, Trench Barrel, Adagio

  • Masterwork: Reload

Recommended MnK PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Full Choke

  • Magazine: Assault Mag, Accurized Rounds

  • Perk 1: Perpetual Motion, Slideshot

  • Perk 2: Opening Shot, Killing Wind

  • Masterwork: Range or Handling

Panda's personal roll:

Barrel Shroud / Assault Mag or Tactical Mag / Subsistence / One-Two Punch / Handling MW

The Wastelander M5 is arguably the best gun to come out of the Dare's. It is the only second shotgun to roll subsistence which is just bonkers on it. As a plus, it's easier to get than the Comedian. Seriously give it a try. I prefer One-Two Punch on my shotguns but if you’re rocking subsistence then Trench Barrel could be incredible for getting the most damage per shot.

Crucible is no exception for this shotgun. Riiswalker has some fierce competition. The Wastelander M5 feels great in PvP too. Full Choke is the only option you really want to look for. It feels like the Wastelander has a tighter hip-fire spread but that could be anecdotal and my testing revealed it isn’t that much different from my Riiswalker. The exception being Opening Shot. When Opening Shot is active this is the best feeling pellet shotgun I think I have ever used. It feels so consistent.


BxR-55 Battler - Energy Solar Pulse Rifle

Source: Xûr's Treasure Hoard in Eternity

  • Rate of Fire: 450

  • Impact: 23

  • Range: 55

  • Stability: 63

  • Handling: 74

  • Reload Speed: 67

  • Mag size: 36

  • Aim Assist: 85

  • Recoil Direction: 70

  • Zoom: 20

Curated Roll:

Legacy PR-55 Frame / Polygonal Rifling / Flared Magwell / Snapshot Sights / Blunt Execution Rounds

Recommended Controller PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Arrowhead Brake

  • Magazine: Flared Magwell, Ricochet Rounds, Light Mag

  • Perk 1: Outlaw, Demolitionist

  • Perk 2: Kill Clip, Adrenaline Junkie, Blunt Execution Rounds

  • Masterwork: Reload

Recommended Controller PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Arrowhead Brake

  • Magazine: Ricochet Rounds, Accurized Rounds, Flared Magwell

  • Perk 1: Snapshot Sights, Demolitionist, Killing Wind

  • Perk 2: Rangefinder, Kill Clip, Eye of the Storm

  • Masterwork: Stability

Recommended MnK PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Arrowhead Brake, Extended Barrel

  • Magazine: Light Mag, Flared Magwell

  • Perk 1: Outlaw, Demolitionist

  • Perk 2: Kill Clip, Adrenaline Junkie, Blunt Execution Rounds

  • Masterwork: Range

Recommended MnK PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Arrowhead Brake, Extended Barrel

  • Magazine: Accurized Rounds, Ricochet Rounds

  • Perk 1: Snapshot Sights, Demolitionist, Killing Wind

  • Perk 2: Rangefinder, Kill Clip, Eye of the Storm

  • Masterwork: Range

Panda's personal roll:

Arrowhead Brake / Ricochet Rounds / Demolitionist / Kill Clip / Stability MW

The BxR-55 Battler, much like all the 30th Anniversary Dares of Eternity weapons, are a call back to Bungie’s history. This is no different. If you played Halo you know this gun from the model to the scope to the hip fire. Unfortunately I never played Halo, so the nostalgia is missed on me. Hopefully the same cannot be said for you. Regardless of the history the BxR-55 Battler is the best feeling 450 pulse in the entirety of Destiny, the shortcomings come from being a 450 frame. A push one way or the other could easily tip the scale into a dominant adaptive or rapid-fire frame meta with how this frame slips right between them. Does it feel fantastic? For sure. Is it meta breaking or a complete game changer? Not at all.

To ensure it does feel good, you’re going to want to get Arrowhead Brake to get that sweet 100 recoil direction. Then slot the new full auto retrofit mod and go to town.


Retraced Path - Energy Solar Trace Rifle

Source: Xûr's Treasure Hoard in Eternity

  • Rate of Fire: 1000

  • Impact: 6

  • Range: 68

  • Stability: 78

  • Handling: 51

  • Reload Speed: 50

  • Mag size: 94

  • Aim Assist: 100

  • Recoil Direction: 94

  • Zoom: 16

Curated Roll:

Adaptive Frame / Chambered Compensator / Tactical Battery / Subsistence / Frenzy

Recommended Controller PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Fluted Barrel, Smallbore, Corkscrew Rifling

  • Magazine: Tactical Battery, Light Battery

  • Perk 1: Subsistence, Feeding Frenzy

  • Perk 2: Frenzy, Golden Tricorn, Demolitionist, One for All

  • Masterwork: Reload

Recommended Controller PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Smallbore, Fluted Barrel, Hammer-Forged Rifling

  • Magazine: Projection Fuse, Particle Repeater, Tactical Battery

  • Perk 1: Perpetual Motion, Killing Wind

  • Perk 2: Demolitionist, Disruption Break, Harmony

  • Masterwork: Stability or Range

Recommended MnK PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Fluted Barrel, Smallbore, Corkscrew Rifling

  • Magazine: Tactical Battery, Light Battery

  • Perk 1: Subsistence, Feeding Frenzy

  • Perk 2: Frenzy, Golden Tricorn, Demolitionist, One for All

  • Masterwork: Reload

Recommended MnK PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Hammer-Forged Rifling, Fluted Barrel, Smallbore

  • Magazine: Projection Fuse, Tactical Battery

  • Perk 1: Perpetual Motion, Killing Wind

  • Perk 2: Demolitionist, Disruption Break, Harmony

  • Masterwork: Range

Panda's personal roll:

Fluted Barrel / Tactical Battery or Enhanced Battery / Subsistence / Golden Tricorn / Handing MW

Oh am I so glad to see a legendary trace rifle. Now we have an exotic and legendary version of every weapon. The new mag options are interesting, I think Tactical Battery is the best option for most use cases as it adds range, stability, and reload speed. Subsistence makes it a mini-Prometheus Lens without the AoE damage. But with a perk like Frenzy or Golden Tricorn you can easily get better damage numbers. This is a welcome addition to anyone’s arsenal.

For PvP I am not sure this will really shake up the sandbox. But it's for sure an interesting play and will allow some loadout diversity as you can pair a trace rifle with an exotic.


Half-Truths - Power Arc Sword

Source: Xûr's Treasure Hoard in Eternity

  • Swing Speed: 46

  • Impact: 60

  • Range: 40

  • Charge Rate: 32

  • Ammo Capacity: 61

Curated Roll:

Adaptive Frame / Honed Edge / Balanced Guard / Thresh / Eager Edge

Recommended Controller PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Jagged Edge, Honed Edge, Tempered Edge

  • Magazine: Swordmaster’s Guard, Enduring Guard, Heavy Guard

  • Perk 1: Duelist’s Trance, Relentless Strikes, Tireless Blade, Thresh

  • Perk 2: Harmony, Eager Edge

  • Masterwork: Impact

Recommended Controller PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Jagged Edge, Honed Edge

  • Magazine: Swordmaster’s Guard, Burst Guard

  • Perk 1: Tireless Blade, Duelist Trance

  • Perk 2: Assassin’s Blade, Eager Edge

  • Masterwork: Impact

Recommended MnK PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Jagged Edge, Honed Edge, Tempered Edge

  • Magazine: Swordmaster’s Guard, Enduring Guard, Heavy Guard

  • Perk 1: Duelist’s Trance, Relentless Strikes, Tireless Blade, Thresh

  • Perk 2: Harmony, Eager Edge

  • Masterwork: Impact

Recommended MnK PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Jagged Edge, Honed Edge

  • Magazine: Swordmaster’s Guard, Burst Guard

  • Perk 1: Tireless Blade, Duelist Trance

  • Perk 2: Eager Edge, Assassin’s Blade

  • Masterwork: Impact

Panda's personal roll:

Jagged Edge / Swordmaster's Guard / Duelist Edge / Eager Edge / Impact MW

Oh this is a fun sword. It’s an adaptive frame, which isn’t the best at the moment but it is unique which gives it a +1 in my book. The key to this sword is Eager Edge. Using this perk makes you go incredibly fast after taking this sword out (does go away pretty quick), but is a legendary way of Worldline Zero skating. It is incredibly fun; which is half of what video games are for, right?

For PvP I can see Eager edge becoming the new “cheese” for sneaking up and killing people that aren’t accustomed to seeing swords in PvP. Try it out in all game modes.


The Other Half - Power Void Sword

Source: Xûr's Treasure Hoard in Eternity

  • Swing Speed: 46

  • Impact: 60

  • Range: 40

  • Charge Rate: 32

  • Ammo Capacity: 61

Curated Roll:

Adaptive Frame / Jagged Edge / Balanced Guard / Eager Edge / Frenzy

Recommended Controller PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Jagged Edge, Honed Edge, Tempered Edge

  • Magazine: Swordmaster’s Guard, Enduring Guard, Heavy Guard

  • Perk 1: Relentless Strikes, Duelist’s Trance, Eager Edge

  • Perk 2: Whirlwind Blade, Vorpal Weapon, Frenzy, Surrounded

  • Masterwork: Impact

Recommended Controller PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Jagged Edge, Honed Edge

  • Magazine: Swordmaster’s Guard, Burst Guard

  • Perk 1: Eager Edge

  • Perk 2: Frenzy, Vorpal Weapon

  • Masterwork: Impact

Recommended MnK PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Jagged Edge, Honed Edge, Tempered Edge

  • Magazine: Swordmaster’s Guard, Enduring Guard, Heavy Guard

  • Perk 1: Relentless Strikes, Duelist’s Trance, Eager Edge

  • Perk 2: Whirlwind Blade, Vorpal Weapon, Frenzy, Surrounded

  • Masterwork: Impact

Recommended MnK PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Jagged Edge, Honed Edge

  • Magazine: Swordmaster’s Guard, Burst Guard

  • Perk 1: Eager Edge

  • Perk 2: Frenzy, Vorpal Weapon

  • Masterwork: Impact

Panda's personal roll:

Jagged Edge / Swordmaster's Guard / Eager Edge / Vorpal Weapon / Impact MW

While the Half Truths might be the best in PvE and PvP for zooming around the map. The Other Half will be the best for straight up damage. Pick your poison and enjoy.



Grasp of Avarice

Eyasluna - Kinetic Stasis Hand Cannon

Source: “Grasp of Avarice” Dungeon.

  • Rate of Fire: 140

  • Impact: 84

  • Range: 56

  • Stability: 68

  • Handling: 54

  • Reload Speed: 50

  • Mag size: 11

  • Aim Assist: 80

  • Recoil Direction: 96

Curated Roll:

Adaptive Frame / Truesight HCS / Ricochet Rounds / Rangefinder / Moving Target

Recommended Controller PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Fastdraw HCS, Steadyhand HCS, Truesight HCS

  • Magazine: Appended Mag, Extended Mag, High-Caliber Rounds

  • Perk 1: Rapid Hit, Outlaw, Perpetual Motion

  • Perk 2: Kill Clip, Demolitionist, Headstone, Harmony

  • Masterwork: Reload

Recommended Controller PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Steadyhand HCS, Fastdraw HCS

  • Magazine: Ricochet Rounds, High-Caliber Rounds

  • Perk 1: Perpetual Motion, Rangefinder, Rapid Hit

  • Perk 2: Moving Target, Snapshot Sights, Demolitionist

  • Masterwork: Handling

Recommended MnK PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Fastdraw HCS, Truesight HCS

  • Magazine: Appended Mag, Extended Mag, High-Caliber Rounds

  • Perk 1: Rapid Hit, Outlaw, Perpetual Motion

  • Perk 2: Kill Clip, Demolitionist, Headstone, Harmony

  • Masterwork: Reload

Recommended MnK PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Truesight HCS, Fastdraw HCS

  • Magazine: High-Caliber Rounds, Ricochet Rounds

  • Perk 1: Perpetual Motion, Rangefinder, Rapid Hit

  • Perk 2: Snapshot Sights, Demolitionist, Moving Target

  • Masterwork: Range or Handling

Panda's personal roll:

Fastdraw HCS / Ricochet Rounds / Rapid Hit / Moving Target / Handling MW

The “King” from Destiny 1 has returned. Is it better than Fatebringer (Adept) and Palindrome (Adept)? I don’t think so. But it can definitely hang and seeing one isn’t a direct handicap. Eyasluna has an ease of use that the other two just simply don’t have. It feels so smooth to shoot and has an easier entry (other than being paid) compared to the two adept versions. When comparing normal base models it becomes even better as there’s no adept mods to socket and the farmability of this (come Tuesday Dec 14th) will make it a very easy choice for a lot of the more casual community.

For PvE the tried and true pairing of a reload perk and a damage perk will be your bread and butter. If you want to get saucy something like Headstone or Harmony could be good for specific builds.

For PvP Perpetual Motion from my very limited testing seems to be the best choice. I don’t have exact numbers on the bonuses (feels like +10 per stack). You should almost always be moving in 6s and in 3’s you should be moving but maybe a little less distance. A perk that helps you when doing what you normally do is incredibly easy to choose. Rangefinder allows Eyasluna to compete with Palindrome but being in different slots means you can have an A to B loadout using different weapons. More loadout diversity is not a bad thing.


Matador-64 - Energy Arc Shotgun

Source:

  • Rate of Fire: 65

  • Impact: 80

  • Range: 68

  • Stability: 53

  • Handling: 49

  • Reload Speed: 53

  • Mag size: 5

  • Aim Assist: 65

  • Recoil Direction: 77

Curated Roll:

Precision Frame / Corkscrew Rifling / Tactical Mag / Perpetual Motion / Harmony

Recommended Controller PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Barrel Shroud, Corkscrew Rifling, Smallbore

  • Magazine: Assault Mag, Tactical Mag, Appended Mag

  • Perk 1: Lead from Gold, Full Auto Trigger System, Pulse Monitor

  • Perk 2: One-Two Punch, Swashbuckler, Golden Tricorn, Harmony

  • Masterwork: Reload

Recommended Controller PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Full Choke

  • Magazine: Accurized Rounds, Assault Mag

  • Perk 1: Perpetual Motion, Threat Detector

  • Perk 2: Opening Shot, Killing Wind

  • Masterwork: Handling or Range

Recommended MnK PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Barrel Shroud, Corkscrew Rifling, Smallbore

  • Magazine: Assault Mag, Tactical Mag, Appended Mag

  • Perk 1: Lead from Gold, Full Auto Trigger System, Pulse Monitor

  • Perk 2: One-Two Punch, Swashbuckler, Golden Tricorn, Harmony

  • Masterwork: Reload

Recommended MnK PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Full Choke

  • Magazine: Accurized Rounds, Assault Mag

  • Perk 1: Perpetual Motion, Threat Detector

  • Perk 2: Opening Shot, Killing Wind

  • Masterwork: Handling or Range

Panda's personal roll:

Full Choke / Assault Mag / Perpetual Motion / Opening Shot / Handling MW

Now. Let me preface this by saying precision shotguns are not the best choice for any content. That being said, Matador 64 might be your best option depending on your roll. For PvE One-Two Punch is still my favorite choice for the sheer damage you can get with your melees.

Crucible is where this shotgun will shine. It’s not as consistent as Felwinter’s Lie, nor is it as fast as A Sudden Death. So why use it? Well, the same reason Eyasluna will be strong. Perpetual Motion. The handling from that coupled with opening shot will mean you can use your abilities and still have a fast handling shotgun. You can be on any subclass and still reap the benefits. It might not be the best in slot, but it will be consistent across any subclass across any build and any gamemode.


1000 Yard Stare - Energy Void Sniper Rifle

Source:

  • Rate of Fire: 90

  • Impact: 70

  • Range: 57

  • Stability: 60

  • Handling: 48

  • Reload Speed: 47

  • Mag size: 4

  • Aim Assist: 66

  • Recoil Direction: 76

  • Zoom: 44

Curated Roll:

Adaptive Frame / Fluted Barrel / Tactical Mag / No Distractions / Golden Tricorn

Recommended Controller PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Arrowhead Brake, Fluted Barrel, Corkscrew Rifling

  • Magazine: Tactical Mag, Appended Mag, Extended Mag

  • Perk 1: Triple Tap, Quickdraw

  • Perk 2: Demolitionist, Golden Tricorn, Dragonfly

  • Masterwork: Reload

Recommended Controller PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Fluted Barrel, Arrowhead Brake

  • Magazine: Accurized Rounds, Tactical Mag

  • Perk 1: Firmly Planted, Perpetual Motion, Quickdraw

  • Perk 2: Snapshot Sights, Moving Target

  • Masterwork: Handling

Recommended MnK PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Arrowhead Brake, Fluted Barrel, Corkscrew Rifling

  • Magazine: Tactical Mag, Appended Mag, Extended Mag

  • Perk 1: Triple Tap, Quickdraw

  • Perk 2: Demolitionist, Golden Tricorn, Dragonfly

  • Masterwork: Reload

Recommended MnK PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Fluted Barrel, Arrowhead Brake

  • Magazine: Accurized Rounds, Tactical Mag

  • Perk 1: Firmly Planted, Perpetual Motion, Quickdraw

  • Perk 2: Snapshot Sights, Moving Target

  • Masterwork: Handling

Panda's personal roll:

Fluted Barrel / Accurized Rounds / Firmly Planted / Snapshot Sights / Handling MW

Unfortunately this sniper does not compete in PvE compared to other snipers. I wouldn’t be using a sniper to clear rank-and-file enemies. And I wouldn’t use this sniper for boss damage. It does have Triple Tap and Demolitionist for faster mag dumps, but being an adaptive frame means it sits in the middle of burst damage and sustained damage.

I do not know why everyone is so hyped by Quickdraw and Snapshot Sights on the 1kys. Quickdraw only works when you swap to the weapon with it, and goes away when you aim down sights or 1 second (whatever happens first). Unless you’re going for style points hot swapping to this sniper for montages the better choice is Firmly Planted. Firmly Planted increases accuracy and handling when crouched and activates on a slide. You do not have to stay crouched for it to be activated and could even crouch mid-gunfight for all the bonuses.


Hero of Ages - Power Arc Sword

Source:

  • Swing Speed: 46

  • Impact: 60

  • Defense: 60

  • Charge Rate: 33

  • Ammo Capacity: 57

  • Aim Assist: 0

  • Zoom: 0

  • Recoil Direction: 0

  • Bounce Intensity: 100

Curated Roll:

Vortex Frame / Honed Edge / Balanced Guard / Demolitionist / One for All

Recommended Controller PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Jagged Edge, Honed Edge, Tempered Edge

  • Magazine: Swordmaster’s Guard, Enduring Guard, Heavy Guard

  • Perk 1: Relentless Strikes, Duelist Trance, Demolitionist, Tireless Blade

  • Perk 2: One for All, Chain Reaction

  • Masterwork: Impact

Recommended Controller PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Jagged Edge, Honed Edge, Tempered Edge

  • Magazine: Swordmaster’s Guard, Burst Guard

  • Perk 1: Tireless Blade, Demolitionist

  • Perk 2: Assassin’s Blade, En Garde

  • Masterwork: Impact

Recommended MnK PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Jagged Edge, Honed Edge, Tempered Edge

  • Magazine: Swordmaster’s Guard, Enduring Guard, Heavy Guard

  • Perk 1: Relentless Strikes, Duelist Trance, Demolitionist, Tireless Blade

  • Perk 2: One for All, Chain Reaction

  • Masterwork: Impact

Recommended MnK PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Jagged Edge, Honed Edge, Tempered Edge

  • Magazine: Swordmaster’s Guard, Burst Guard

  • Perk 1: Tireless Blade, Demolitionist

  • Perk 2: Assassin’s Blade, En Garde

  • Masterwork: Impact

Panda's personal roll:

Jagged Edge / Swordmaster's Guard / Demolitionist / Chain Reaction / Impact MW

This is probably the best thing to come this season. It’s an incredible design. A second spin-to-win sword and comes with Chain Reaction? Heck yeah! Arguably One for All is going to be better on this sword as you can spin in a group and instantly get full stacks. BUT sword go boom? Sword go boom. I’m excited.

For PvP it’s clearly outclassed by the energy swords Half Truths and The Other Half.




Exotics

Forerunner - Exotic Kinetic Special Sidearm

Source: “Magnum Opus” quest.

  • Rate of Fire: 200

  • Impact: 25

  • Range: 100

  • Stability: 73

  • Handling: 64

  • Reload Speed: 82

  • Mag size: 15

  • Aim Assist: 60

  • Recoil Direction: 96

Perks:

  • Full Stop - Oversized Sidearm with extended-range, heavy caliber rounds. Fires full auto with increased rate of fire. Deals increased precision damage to unshielded targets.

  • Pace Yourself - Tapping the trigger gives this weapon less recoil and improves accuracy.

Roll:

Full Stop / Smallbore / Flared Magwell / Pace Yourself / Smooth Grip

Catalyst: The Rock

For several seconds after a final blow, [Alternate Weapon Activation] to consume part of your ammo reserves, converting your next thrown grenade into a fragmentation grenade.

  • Defeat 700 targets

  • Found through achieving rank 16 with Xur


Gjallarhorn - Exotic Solar Rocket Launcher

Source: “And Out Fly the Wolves” quest

  • Rate of Fire: 15

  • Blast Radius: 95

  • Velocity: 50

  • Stability: 68

  • Handling: 69

  • Reload Speed: 43

  • Mag size: 1

  • Aim Assist: 76

  • Recoil Direction: 49

Perks:

  • Wolfpack Rounds - Rounds fired split into tracking cluster missiles upon detonation.

  • Pack Hunter - Gain increased handling and reload speed when standing near allies. Firing this weapon also grants Wolfpack Rounds to nearby allies wielding non-Exotic Rocket Launchers.

Curated Roll:

Wolfpack Rounds / Volatile Launch / Alloy Casing / Pack Hunter / Short-Action Stock

Catalyst: More Wolves

Increases magazine size. Final blows with Wolfpack Rounds spawn a faster, more powerful missile at the target’s location.

  • Defeat 400 targets.

  • Found within the Grasp of Avarice Dungeon.



Small edits :) and thank you all for the awards!


r/sharditkeepit • • Oct 03 '19

Armor 2.0 Breakdown

483 Upvotes

Hello Guardians! My name is u/pandapaxxy and I have compiled all the mods for Armor 2.0 in an easy to read format you can look at and save as you familiarize yourself with the new system!

Link

The basic premise is that your armor has an element; Arc, Solar or Void. As well as 10 energy points. Each mod has a specific element that your specific armor piece has to have in order to use that mod.

For instance an Auto Rifle Loader mod for your gauntlet costs 1 Solar energy to equip, therefore cannot be used on Arc or Void armor pieces.

Another note is that while you can use different mods for your gauntlets (so long as you have the energy for it) you cannot double down on the same or enhanced versions of mods.

Ex. You can use Auto Rifle Loader (1 Solar Energy) and Fusion Rifle Loader (2 Solar Energy) but you cannot use Hand Cannon Loader and Enhanced Hand Cannon Loader on the same piece of armor.

If you have any questions I will be more than happy to answer any and all questions to the best of my ability. And don't worry, my weapons breakdown for all the new shadowkeep weapons will be going out tomorrow; it just needs a bit more work.

Edit: Armor stats can go to 100, but are on a per armor / mod basis

EDIT 2: As far as I know, all old mods (Super Mods, Ordinance Mods, Impact Mods, Paragon Mods) work the same as before.

EDIT 3: No, I do not know what the max stat package to look out for is. T12 is the max across all of your armor pieces. I just looked at mods, not stats


r/sharditkeepit • • Sep 19 '19

PvE Console The Huckleberry roll

457 Upvotes

I know it’s an exotic I just want to know. I got ricochet rounds, rampage and short action stock

Edit: Ok so all exotics roll the same idk how I didn’t know that lol


r/sharditkeepit • • Nov 16 '20

BreakDown Season of the Hunt (Beyond Light) Weapon Breakdown

432 Upvotes

Season of the Hunt breakdown!

Hello guardians, u/pandapaxxy here with the newest seasonal breakdown. This time we head right into Beyond Light and Season of the Hunt. I have jokingly called this season: Season of Killing Wind because so many weapons have that perk available with no other good perks in slot. So be prepared to see that perk pop up quite a lot.

As with any new breakdown you can find the spreadsheet without all the text here

If you’re new to these breakdowns let me explain how this works. I have broken up the recommended lists into MnK and Controller based off of feedback from the community and the different inputs requiring different recommendations. Within each breakdown I have the weapons listed alphabetically based off of weapon type. To explain this further; all of the kinetic weapons are sorted alphabetically, then the energy weapons, then finally your heavy weapons. It is not sorted by ammo type but where the weapons fall in your character slots.

These recommendations are my own based off of the perk pools from Bungie, and you are free to disagree or agree with these recommendations, feel free to let me know what you think in the comments but please keep it civil. With that out of the way let’s get into this!

New Perks

Europa Weapons MnK

Faction / Season Pas MnK

Trials and Iron Banner MnK

Deep Stone Crypt MnK

Dawning and Hawkmoon MnK

Europa Weapons Controller

Faction / Season Pass Controller

Trials and Iron Banner

Deep Stone Crypt Controller

Dawning and Hawkmoon Controller

As of the publishing of the breakdown a lot of perks I have not had a lot of hands-on time with and the raid weapons aren’t even available within the API. When those weapons are released they will be added in, and more perks will be tested. Please note that the wishlists that are made following my breakdowns are subject to change as perks are understood more and the season progresses. I am doing my best.


r/sharditkeepit • • Oct 08 '19

PvP Console Scorch Cannon

408 Upvotes

Not sure if this is a good roll?

Flaming balls of fire

Extended Mag

Hipfire Grip

Will probably use an Icarus mod on it.

And has Shaxx lost his mind?


r/sharditkeepit • • Jun 17 '20

BreakDown Season of Arrivals Breakdown and Spreadsheet

401 Upvotes

Hello Guardians! My name is u/pandapaxxy and I am here with Season of Arrivals newest weapon breakdown. Not a lot has changed but there were a handful of new perks and weapon types that had me distracted trying to figure them out before posting this.

Of course if you’re interested in just the spreadsheet you can find the updated version here.

Unfortunately the loot pools are a bit more confusing than typical loot tables so I have put the entire breakdown onto one page per input versus previous breakdowns where they were broken down by loot tables. Within each breakdown they are organized by loot tables and alphabetically in Kinetic, Energy, and Power. Hopefully this new format works a little better, but ultimately I am trying my best with the weapons introduced.

New Perks

Season of Arrivals - Controller

Season of Arrivals - MnK

Let me know if you’d like the format changed for future breakdowns or if you have any suggestions. I am not sure how to do this but having two separate docs for each input is beneficial. It makes the process of making this take a lot longer each time. I don’t want to combine the two but having an easier format or something similar would definitely have to be created at some point soon. As always be safe and Happy Hunting Guardians.

So you think you have a god roll

Edit: changed sword guards on the two new frames


r/sharditkeepit • • Feb 15 '21

BreakDown People, IF IT HAS DESPERADO IT'S GOD TIER

392 Upvotes

It gets very annoying seeing so many posts about outlaw desperado Messengers so for anyone who's about to make a post asking if their god roll messenger is good, if it has desperado it definitely is.


r/sharditkeepit • • May 10 '20

BreakDown New breakdown of every weapon

380 Upvotes

How has your quarantine going guardians? Mine has been productive. I have compiled a full breakdown of every single weapon* within Destiny 2 to date, and made them sandbox relevant.

If you'd be interested you can use the link here.

This took a LONG time to make and I am very proud of how it came out. Let me know if you have any suggestions as to how to make this better.

Links to:

As always I appreciate this community so much, and you're more than welcome to join our Discord!

Happy hunting Guardians, u/pandapaxxy signing off

* Legendary weapons only


r/sharditkeepit • • Mar 18 '23

Destiny 1 R.I.P. Lance Reddick.

372 Upvotes

Off-topic but a memorial should be in every Destiny sub.

May the Light bless the loot of the afterlife, Commander. You will be missed.


r/sharditkeepit • • Sep 14 '18

Hand Cannon God Rolls

370 Upvotes

Hand Cannons

Precision Frame

Trust

  • Rate of Fire: 180

  • Impact: 78

  • Range: 37

  • Stability: 56

  • Reload Speed: 50

  • Handling: 35

  • Mag size: 9

  • Recoil Direction: 96

  • Aim Assist: 78

Recommended PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Full Bore, Extended Barrel, Polygonal Rifling

  • Magazine: Extended Mag, Alloy Magazine, Flared Magwell

  • Tier 1: Outlaw, Dragonfly, Genesis, Triple Tap

  • Tier 2: Rampage, Zen Moment, Explosive Payload

Recommended PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Hammer Forged Barrel, Extended Barrel, Full Bore

  • Magazine: Accurized Rounds, Drop Mag, Extended Mag, Flared Magwell

  • Tier 1: Opening Shot, Outlaw

  • Tier 2: Rapid Hit, Zen Moment, Explosive Rounds

For PvE this is an interesting weapon. I, personally, love it. The recoil is fun, the weapon handles like a dream. Mine has Outlaw / Zen Moment, and on beefier majors it trucks their shields, crit kill, outlaw for fast reload. What’s interesting is the reload feels slower on Trust compared to other Precision Frame hand cannons despite having the best reload speed by 10 points! Anything to increase the mag, minimize downtime, and capitalize on add clearing is a boon in my book. Unfortunately Outlaw and Dragonfly are in the same tier, and I have yet to try Genesis. But from what I hear it is strong on a weapon that only has 9 bullets in the magazine. I also would strongly recommend not using this weapon for end-game activities. The low mag size, low range, coupled with the abysmally small damage means you’ll pelt them from a close range, reload, then kill them. While a shotgun can do that with one or two bullets, a fusion has further range, and a sniper has even more range and requires even less bullets. Is it fun? Yes. Is it practical and useful for end-game? I’d say no.

For PvP this has a very nice 2 crit 2 body, with a very forgiving body TtK. You need Range, with ghost bullets and the accuracy cone hand cannons face with bloom. The more range; the better. For that Rifled Barrel / Accurized Rounds / Opening Shot will give the best range on a hand cannon PERIOD. But more specifically for this particular weapon. The tier 2 perk is a toss up. Rapid Hit increases stability and reload, two perks to help Trust, Zen Moment is my pick, because I have yet to test out Rapid Hit. Explosive Rounds also pushes out the damage drop off, but I wouldn’t use this at sniper rifle ranges.

Lightweight Frame

Waking Vigil

  • Impact: 78

  • Range: 31

  • Stability: 38

  • Reload Speed: 56

  • Handling: 63

  • Mag size: 12

  • Recoil Direction: 98

  • Aim Assist: 85

Recommended PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Sureshot HCS, Crossfire HCS

  • Magazine: Extended Mag, Alloy Magazine, Flared Magwell

  • Tier 1: Outlaw, Dragonfly, Genesis, Triple Tap

  • Tier 2: Zen Moment, Explosive Payload

Recommended PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Hitmark HCS, Crossfire HCS, Sureshot HCS

  • Magazine: Accurized Rounds, Ricochet Rounds, Drop Mag, Extended Mag, Flared Magwell

  • Tier 1: Opening Shot, Outlaw

  • Tier 2: Slideshot, Explosive Rounds

A member of the Lightweight Frame, and being the only member of said frame to have random rolls. The Waking Vigil is an interesting weapon. It does not have better stats than the static Midnight Coup, nor the slaying potential of Dire Promise. So what makes this weapon so good? For one it allows a mixture of great perks, which can put it above the rest. In PvE Outlaw and Dragonfly offer the most utility. Triple Tap increases the already decent magazine, and any of the tier 2 perks are just icing. Snapshot Sights make the weapon feel faster, and Slideshot can make the weapon reload and feel more stable.

For PvP it’s the same story as Destiny 1 and Trust. Range is King on hand cannons. For now until Bungie removes the bloom mechanic hand cannons will be bound to “Range or Bust”. There are no barrel mods making it similar to the hand cannons of old. So go for whatever makes you feel comfortable.

Adaptive Frame

Better Devils

  • Rate of Fire: 140

  • Impact: 84

  • Range: 46

  • Stability: 48

  • Reload Speed: 46

  • Handling: 46

  • Mag size: 10

  • Recoil Direction: 88

  • Aim Assist: 75

Recommended PvE Perks:

  • Sights: Sureshot HCS, Crossfire HCS

  • Magazine: Extended Mag, Alloy Magazine, Flared Magwell

  • Tier 1: Outlaw, Triple Tap

  • Tier 2: Kill Clip, Rampage, Zen Moment, Explosive Payload

Recommended PvP Perks:

  • Sights: Hitmark HCS, Crossfire HCS, Sureshot HCS

  • Magazine: Accurized Rounds, Ricochet Rounds, Drop Mag, Extended Mag, Flared Magwell

  • Tier 1: Rangefinder, Moving Target, Outlaw

  • Tier 2: Opening Shot, Explosive Rounds

So this was difficult. The Better Devils is a weapon most are familiar with, and Ten Paces is new. But Ten Paces only beats Better Devils by 5 stability. Tying in range, reload speed, and magazine. Losing in handling (by 2), aim assist (by 4), and recoil direction (by 1). It was really close. So what makes this better? Well for one the stats, but just barely. The range is the same so either will work in PvE. The “God Roll” Outlaw / Kill Clip is still applicable to these and many other weapons, but don’t sleep on other perks. It cannot roll Dragonfly or Genesis, but the true value in this gun is the sheer workhorse nature of it. In year 1 it served well in Guardian’s hands in every level of PvE. This will do the same with even better perks,

For PvP, the boon of hand cannons continues. Rangefinder / Opening Shot is truly a thing of beauty. But one thing to note. My Better Devils with TrueSight HCS / Accurized Rounds / Rangefinder caps at 58 range. While my Ten Paces with Crossfire HCS / Accurized Rounds / Moving Target has 63 range. Is Ten Paces a better Better Devils in disguise? Further testing needs to be done and a spreadsheet of all the perks and their functionality is in the works.

Aggressive Frame

Warden's Law

  • Rate of Fire: 110

  • Impact: 92

  • Range: 56

  • Stability: 29

  • Reload Speed: 27

  • Handling: 24

  • Mag size:

  • Recoil Direction: 97

  • Aim Assist: 68

Recommended PvE Perks:

  • Sights: HitMark HCS, Crossfire HCS, Sureshot HCS

  • Magazine: Tactical Mag, Flared Magwell, Steady Rounds, Drop Mag

  • Tier 1: Rampage, Kill Clip, Zen Moment

  • Tier 2: Outlaw, Fourth Time’s the Charm, Triple Tap

Recommended PvP Perks:

  • Sights: HitMark HCS, Crossfire HCS, Sureshot HCS

  • Magazine: Ricochet Rounds, Accurized Rounds, Drop Mag

  • Tier 1: Opening Shot, Kill Clip, Rampage

  • Tier 2: Rangefinder, Moving Target, Fourth Time’s the Charm

Warden’s Law is an interesting weapon, it fires two bullets at the same time. Kind of like a shotgun where all the pellets exit at the same time, versus Crimson where the bullets leave one after the other. Interesting in concept, sub-par in performance. The two bullets aren’t directly on top of one another, thereby making it possible to miss a bullet. In PvE it’s much less of an issue. The crit box on most enemies is big enough to snag one if not two hits. Triple Tap should work, but I don’t know how it fairs on this weapon. YMMV. The thing to boost on the Warden’s Law is stability, reload, or handling. The most important, in my opinion, is reload. Recoil and the stability can be mitigated through different armor perks, and learned through play. But reload in general practice is something everyone has to do. Outlaw is by far the best perk for this. Drop Mag also helps, but makes you burn through ammo. Either is preferable over the Zaouli’s Bane level of slow reload.

In PvP the prior statement of missing a bullet is present here. As with all hand cannons range is prioritized. Opening Shot and Rangefinder will give the best benefit. Drop Mag really isn’t a bad perk because it allows faster reloads and ammo isn’t as big of a deal. I wouldn’t personally grind to get a good roll until the accuracy issue is addressed. The Aggressive Burst sidearms are much more forgiving and always go where you point them.

Aggressive Frame

Duke Mk. 44

  • Rate of Fire: 110

  • Impact: 92

  • Range: 68

  • Stability: 36

  • Reload Speed: 37

  • Handling: 37

  • Mag size: 9

  • Recoil Direction: 90

  • Aim Assist: 64

Recommended PvE Perks:

  • Sights: HitMark HCS, Crossfire HCS, Sureshot HCS

  • Tier 1: Outlaw, Triple Tap, Rapid Hit,

  • Magazine: Alloy Magazine, Light Mag, Flared Magwell

  • Tier 2: Kill Clip, Rampage, Field Prep

Recommended PvP Perks:

  • Sights: HitMark HCS, Crossfire HCS, Sureshot HCS

  • Tier 1: Rangefinder, Opening Shot, Outlaw

  • Magazine: Ricochet Rounds, High Caliber Rounds, Alloy Magazine

  • Tier 2: Rampage, Moving Target, Kill Clip

Remember the choice in Destiny 1 where you could choose your first primary after the OG Khvostov? The Duke was one choice. A hand cannon most forgot, brought back with everything included. Even the old perk layout. Can the Duke compete in a new sandbox with new perks? Yes and no. In PvE the thing you’re trying to shoot, if it doesn’t have a shield or is a major or ultra? It’s gonna die. One bullet, every time. The Duke Has so much impact that most adds are gonna die. That being said we can capitalize on that. Outlaw, Triple Tap, and even Rapid hit all extend the magazine or speed up reload time. Even something like Field Prep on a hand cannon is a benefit. Much like Warden’s Law the Aggressive Frame hand cannons suffer from poor reload speed. Field Prep allows faster reload, it also increases your reserves. Something all hand cannons lack in PvE content. Win Win? I would almost argue Field Prep is as amazing as Kill Clip or Rampage, due to the sheer nature of better reload for another perk like Triple Tap or Zen Moment, then the increased reserves mean you can use something else on your armor.

For PvP it’s a 2 crit 1 body kill. It takes some getting used to, the rate of fire, the accuracy issues with bloom. The Duke comes with the highest base range of any hand cannon. Meaning more range will make this hand cannon map. Would you want to compete against pulse rifles and scouts? Not with a hand cannon. But you could! I don’t personally like this archetype of hand cannon, never did. But it is the best of the Aggressive Frame hand cannons.


r/sharditkeepit • • Jul 05 '21

BreakDown I've simulated all 352,275,361 possible armor rolls and analyzed all of them, here's the results!

359 Upvotes

First, if there are any Bungie employees reading this, I have a question: Could anyone disclose the rules for how armor from activities like raids and dungeons or biased rolls from umbrals are rolled? Just knowing what influencing factors and rules are for armor from the various sources would be a game changer.

The Results

Notes:

  1. You may want to look at the results on a computer for the smoothest experience.

  2. This data shows how armor is rolled in a randomized void with no outside influencing factors. Most armor in D2 has some form of bias when rolled based on the source and many other factors. Essentially, this data shows what armor exists and the data can be used to rank individual armor pieces.

  3. This is all the possible base rolls. Certain Year 1 exotics have intrinsic bonuses that can allow exotics to have values that contradict the results.

Check out my Vault Analyzer for automated armor analysis and vault cleaning in Destiny Item Manager.

How to Get Better Armor

Huge thanks to Zeta for his assistance in this project. Without his help, this project would have taken a few months rather than a few weeks.


r/sharditkeepit • • Jan 06 '20

BreakDown Top 3 Legendary weapons of each archetype

353 Upvotes

I originally made this spreadsheet for myself and my clanmates, but decided to post it here as I've seen a lot of posts from people requesting some form of breakdown like this in recent weeks (and there hasn't been a list like this that I've been able to find). The sheet goes through the top 3 PvP and top 3 PvE legendaries of every single archetype of every weapon type in the game (doing my best to exclude rituals and pinnacles), with an associated "god roll". For source material, I tried to keep it objective, and heavily referenced ratings and comparisons on light.gg and destinytracker, as well as the god rolls lists compiled by u/pandapaxxy, though my own personal opinions do influence some god rolls here and there. I hope this is found useful for some of y'all out there. Enjoy!

Edit: Added some notes at the bottom going over all the pinnacles and rituals and how they relate to other legendaries. In general, most pinnacles and rituals will be better than their normal legendary counterparts, but there are some exceptions.

Top 3 Legendaries per archetype

Disclaimer: Since I only included 1 roll for each weapon, and I only play on PC, these rolls and weapons are based with mouse and keyboard in mind.

Disclaimer 2: This is by no means meant to be a de-facto list of the undisputed best weapons and rolls in the game. It is merely meant to be a guide as to some of the best weapons per archetype with rolls that are often viewed as a "god roll", that I personally think are the best roll for that gun. Use it as a starting point if you don't know or are new, then build off of it from there as you develop your own preferences and tastes for certain weapons. If a different roll than the listed one works better for you, by all means, use it. I highly encourage you to check pandapaxxy's work on this sub if you are interested in alternative perk selections that could still qualify as "god rolls".

Edit 2: Holy shit, thank you whoever that was for the gold! You definitely didn't have to do that.


r/sharditkeepit • • Mar 16 '22

BreakDown Season of the Risen Breakdown

346 Upvotes

Hello Guardians. Welcome to MY throne world Season of the Risen. Whether we wanted it or not, we've stepped into a war with the Savathun on Mars. So let's get to taking out their command, one by one. Immaru. From what I can gather he commands Lucent Hive from an Imperial Tombship outside of Quagmire. He's well protected, but with the right team, we can punch through those defenses, take this beast out, and break their grip on Quahog.

This is going to be a long breakdown, so open up a couple tabs. Grab some warm vex milk and some burnt edge transits, and let’s get down to business.

Similar to my last breakdowns I will continue to follow the same format. Weapons will be organized by kinetic, energy, power, and then alphanumeric from there. Both MnK (mouse and keyboard) and controller recommendations will be within the same document. Since this will be split up into multiple different smaller breakdowns you can find and digest the information you’d like when you get there.

This has taken a LOT of testing and planning so I do hope you enjoy each of them. If you have any questions myself or u/SirStallion_ will be happy to answer them.

Some final bits? If a weapon is craftable and enhanced perks are an option, assume the enhanced option is also a recommended perk. I will only note the regular version for consistency’s sake, but the enhanced version is just a better version of the older perk.

I am also testing out some new formats and wordings. Rate of Fire is now Rounds Per Minute to follow a similar language to in game. I would also like to ask if you are interested in me adding in the zoom stat on weapons. On certain weapons like snipers it can be make or break, less so on other weapons but it does impact how a weapon feels. I am more than willing to add it to all weapons, just let me know if that would be too much or if you simply do not care.

Here is the full spreadsheet. Thank you to whomever decided to reformat for me. I appreciate that a ton! Now don’t do it again.

Origin Perks / New Perks

Exotic Weapons

Faction Weapons (Iron banner and Trials will be here too)

PsiOps / World Drops

Enclave / Wellspring (all craftable weapons are here)

Raid Weapons


If you have any comments, suggestions, or feedback please do let me know. This took a lot of time to set up and make. It will be in your third party apps soon, no ETA. Please do not bug them on transcribing all of this.

If you'd like to support me further, I do have a Patreon. You do not need to subscribe, but patrons do get access to the breakdowns early, some extra goodies from me, and you get to see the process of these breakdowns live. Kind of cool right? As always these breakdowns will always be free, but if you'd like more you are free to subscribe.

Thank you all for viewing. Best of luck grinding and crafting your weapons and most of all, Happy Hunting Guardians.


r/sharditkeepit • • Dec 15 '19

BreakDown Season of the Dawn Breakdown

345 Upvotes

Hello Guardians! My name is u/pandapaxxy, and we have with us a brand new season, so that means brand new breakdown. This one took me far longer to do because of a couple small changes I continue to make more changes that are requested from the community. If you like these changes please let me know, but the more things I have to do, the longer it takes.

As always the spreadsheet without any ramblings: Here

So what are the changes? I have split up most of the recommendations into MnK and Controller. Ritual weapons and the Altar / Pit Recommendations were kept platform universal. I decided to do this for a number of reasons, but mainly because the two input devices play differently. Some recommendations are the same regardless of platform, and for some it’s just a difference of one barrel or one mag, but instead of astericking every single time it’s different I just made multiple breakdowns. So without any further delay here they are!

Pit of Heresy / Altar of Sorrow weapons

New perks

Ritual weapons

Returning Weapons MnK

Returning weapons controller

Sundial weapons MnK

Sundial weapons controller

Dawning / Season Pass MnK

Dawning / Season Pass Controller

One final point, these breakdowns take exceptionally long to make. I would feel uncomfortable setting up a patreon simply for these breakdowns. I will not stop doing these until the community asks me to, but I am not sure how to fuel these and future updates, as well as potentially more breakdowns in between content releases. But I am open for discussion if you’d be willing to support outside of sharing and upvoting.


r/sharditkeepit • • Oct 05 '19

All PC God roll Kinetic Auto Rifle

336 Upvotes

Khvostov 7G-02

-Adaptive frame

-Cracked sight


r/sharditkeepit • • Dec 11 '19

BreakDown Hawthorne Field Forged Shotgun is back! What is a god roll?

332 Upvotes

When I first started playing Destiny 2 as a free to play player during the free giveaway, Hawthorne's field forged shotgun was one of my favorite weapons. I loved the way it looked, sounded, and most importantly the way it played! It also helps that the base roll of the shotgun is already great, and also the fact that nowadays, lightweight frames do the job of rapid fire frame shotguns similarly, or even better in PvP. Now it's back with random rolls, what are the best rolls? Here are my answers.

PvP Rolls

Barrel Perks: Full Choke, Rifled Barrel, Smallbore

No surprises here. Full Choke Tightens your pellet spread when you ads, making your pellet spread more consistent. Rifled barrel straight up ads +10 range, but also decreases your handing, which might cause you to loose out on some shotgun duels if you pull your shotgun out too slow. Small bore gives only 3 less range than rifled barrel (+7), but comes with no handling decrease, which is a good middle ground.

Mag Perks

Assault Mag, Accurized Rounds, Light mag

No surprises here either. Accurized rounds gives +10 range, while Light mag gives +5 range. Always shoot for Accurized Rounds, but light mag ain't bad either. Assault Mag slightly increases rate of fire on shotguns, and is great on lightweight shotguns, because a high rate of fire is already one of their strengths. Hell, if it already shoots pretty fast, how bout bump it up some more!

Here is where the fun starts...

Perk column 1

Full Auto, Firmly Planted

Full Auto is always great on shotguns, because it boosts your rate of fire by 10% (Someone check me on this). As I already mentioned, rate of fire is one of the greatest strengths of lightweight shotguns. By further boosting the rate of fire, this thing can really send lead down range. Not to mention, the year one roll of this shotgun also has full auto, so if you get this perk, you can really get some of that classic feel. Stacked with assault mag, you can shoot even faster.

Firmly planted is a NEW perk on shotguns (I think) the description of Firmly Planted states:

Increased accuracy, stability, and handling when firing while crouched.

Accuracy (although still a vague stat) on a shotgun, can potentially decrease pellet spread, allowing for more consistent damage on opponents. The handling bonus can also allow you to pull out, and aim down sights quicker with your shotgun. The best thing of all, firmly planted can proc when you are sliding. Getting any ideas? Slide, aim down sights, and fire.

Last column. Damn this post is getting pretty long. Sorry, I just love this shotgun too much.

Opening shot, One Two Punch, Demolitionist, eye of the storm

Opening shot is one of the best perks for a shotgun. Max range and increase accuracy on the your opening shot of attack? Nuff said. One two punch can shut down supers in the crucible, but honestly, it isn't a perk for me. While some people can do some absolutely bonkers stuff with it, the fast speed of supers, and the rng of pellet spread just makes this perk a novelty for me. You do you though: https://www.youtube.com/watch?reload=9&v=q_3KiTTHjkE. Demolitionist is always useful for grenade builds, as you can quickly recharge your grenades with each kill. Eye of the storm, in my opinion, is also a great perk, because in shotgun duels, when you are wounded by your enemy but still alive, often times you will be right in that critical health zone. High risk, high reward.

Yep. That's it. I'm more of a PvP guy, but here is a rapid-fire list for PvE perks.

Barrels: Anything but full choke or Smoothbore

Mag: Tactical Mag, Appended Mag (Extended increases the same number of rounds), Assault Mag

Perk 1: Full Auto, Field Prep, Grave robber

Perk 2: Demolitionist, Surrounded, One Two Punch


r/sharditkeepit • • Sep 07 '22

BreakDown Season of the Plunder Breakdown

303 Upvotes

Hello Guardians, my name is u/PandaPaxxy, back again with another Destiny 2 weapons breakdown. If you’re new to this, check out my past breakdown here.

Here’s how this all works. I take the new weapons, tell you what’s good on them. You give me your undying support and I take over the world. Does that work for you? Cool, glad we’re on the same page.

These breakdowns take a lot of time to make, so if you’re interested in supporting me directly my patreon page and information can be found here.

Weapons are categorized by drop location (world drop, vendor weapon, etc), then into their respective slots of Kinetic / Stasis, Energy, Power and alphanumerically organized in there. PvE, controller and MnK recommendations all exist for every weapon.

For those of you who dislike reading and just want weapon perks right in your face-hole, take a look here. (I think this is still being updated, hold please)

Vendor - Includes ritual weapon, iron banner, and trials of osiris.

Seasonal Content / Season Pass

World Drops

Kings Fall

New Perks / Exotics

If you have any questions please let me know. I appreciate you reading this all. Happy hunting Guardians.