Critical analysis, advice, Or questions are welcome.
So I started the game with a drop in drop out commitment with a west marches style set up
We are playing every two weeks and have had 3 sessions. Lost citadel is our funnel, the Sovereign legion has come across the sea with ships of criminals funneling them into the meat grinder for a chance at claiming the minotaurs horns to grant extended life to the foreign monarch.
Session one
Little was decided about the continent/realm, the party entered the Citadel and searched for treasure, they had 0 random encounters(rng)
But managed to stumble their way into the central courtyard and meet the minotaur, fighting and getting lucky for a round or two, then fleeing the entire citadel, no random encounters or wrong turns took place to stop them. THEY WERE THRILLED they loved the feeling of being totally outmatched and fleeing unsure if they were taking wrong turns because of the pressure(they had forgotten the way in)
In retrospect I think if the minotaur had more the 10ft in a straight line as he ended any double move I should have let him get his charge attack. My party for session one was 2 players so I was afraid of being too punitive.
Session 2,
they stock up gain their third party member, and re enter, they go right into the Ettercaps area.
They fight and the party sage dies in poison webs after saving another from webs(seperare webs attacks) the party gets lucky I allowed the light to amplify into a flashbang type situation, the players were close to the exit to the room and regrouped, while the ettercaps were blinded didnt finish off the part.
Perhaps allowing the crystals to be of use rather than a hazard was too giving, but it played well at the table. I only wish I didnt second guess it verbally, I think it worked okay, but would have been great if I made the ruling more confidently.
After randomly rolling a high stat warrior my third PC returned with his Conan level character(managed to roll 18str and 16con) he was both delighted at his new character and happy to finally lose a character in an rpg after years of gaming(he has even been a professional dm before) the party moves in vengfully wrecking the ettercaps this time even killing the sniveling Eske, they rolled exceedingly well for treasure and looted the scroll.
They bought their freedom for 200g each(they had to cash out the magic items they rolled to afford it) payed to the soldiers occupying the harbour and citadel exterior(alternate way to win freedom without killing the minotaur, they want to return after gaining more gear and levels)
Session 3
I was so excited about sandbox randomness that I rerolled the world map a few hours before the session, ting to eliminate my preconceived ideas about the setting(other than the sovereign foreigner legion) I opted to wong it based on what they gravitate towards.
They were too excited about mechanics to interact deeply with NPCs so I got them some rumors in the abstract
They could seek a real town as the small hamlet formed by the escaped convicts is resource poor, or help the community grow by solving issues for the group for gold, they opt to head west to search for a lost supply gathering expedition the payout is good because of the desperation for rations in a desert harbor.
They roll a encounter first hex and despite, getting the drop on the 4 lizardfolk, even with a crit on one and a sneak attack on the other, the attacks fail to fell the lizards, they demolish the party.
Here I could have done a total wipe, I felt as I had already killed a player last Session I should provide an alternate opportunity. (In retrospect i should have set up a table for this in the spirit of emergent play) ill be using the roll of the dice to determine situations with unconscious characters in the future.
The party wakes up imprisoned(they are lucky the lizardfolk rolled well and managed to stablize them as they need slaves for their ruin escavation project)
Third session only has the thief and the Chad warrior. They try to escape their bonds in the night rather than waiting until morning and suffer for it with the enemies being dark adapted and all.
Somehow the thief escapes and the warrior was unable to overcome the 4 and has been taken back to there camp as a slave(same guy who lost his first character mind you) hes rolling a new character until we can rescue Conan. We are a pretty close group of friends so he seems unbothered by the bad luck that has befallen both his character's.
STATE OF PREP
The hex map is currently mapped out 8 hexes or so in north, east and northeast of the coast(yes I made my westmarch map a mostly crawl east map... the irony is not lost on me.
POIs feel like they are telling a larger story thats informing the flavor of the the setting, perhaps im infering too much and spiderwebbing associations and history into the POIs which is less emergent I suppose.
Im also making random rolls for some things to avoid me having too much control over the different past events and factions. And the pois themselves were randomly rolled but the someway contextualize by region and infering
Ive prepped enough for 3 quests from rumors, a small dungeon close by for one, and a longer overland trek to get the supplies and test supply management. And a third getting to a nearby settlement to set up a trade route. Im hoping their decisions will take over more after this initial push to get them started.
The first main faction the Sovereign Legion will have their first faction turn at the end of session 4.
I havent yet determined goals and movements for other main factions as my players haven't encountered any, and none have emerged from randomness yet. The Lizardfolk thing seems like it might become a larger faction as they are likely too strong for the Party to rescue Bram right away.
Pretty much everything else is being left open enough for emergent play to carve out. Although I did get an extremely rare occurrence of 3 or 4 locations being controlled by a evil sorceror, so maybe that will turn into a big focus of the campaign(evil sorceror rules the land sword and sorcery style)
My main concerns,
Am I being too lenient? Or just right?
I think my players may yet become Shadowdark converts but how do I avoid pitfalls.
Do you see any warning signs.
Will the small group size cripple the campaign(2-3 per session)
Please any advise or thoughts.
Thanks for reading!