A threesome has always been on my husband's bucket list. I'm straight so the idea of an FFM was always a reflex nope for me, but after years and years of discussing each others' desires and becoming more adventuresome together, I decided that I wanted to give him an FMF experience. I am also very inherently monogamous so it took me a while to wrap my head around the idea of spending one evening being "monogamish." I had to get my head around the idea that non-monogamy can be ethical at all, as a concept; and then that it could be okay for *me*, as an individual oriented toward fidelity -- but I got there.
And surprise -- it was good! It was a comfortable, positive, ego-stoking experience on my end, and "the best purely sexual experience of his life" on his end. I read about a million old reddit posts about threesomes, how to do them, what goes wrong, yadda yadda. So here's my experience:
1 ) Hired a professional. This was 90% of the success right there. We looked for a higher-end escort, who was experienced working with couples, and whose vibe was: "I would be honored to help guide you through your first threesome encounter." I was very nervous about how I'd feel being with a woman, so I picked. (We browsed together so I knew she was one of the ones he liked too, but I did the deciding and let him know who I was going to approach.) I chose someone with a nurturing vibe, trained in sex coaching as well as escorting, and she was perfect. You definitely want at least two hours (we spent two and a half). Internet paranoia compels me to recommend that you do this in a country or state where it is legal, but sex work is work and it's ridiculous that it's illegal anywhere, so.
1a) We did our research about how to approach this correctly. Followed a few sex workers on twitter to understand their lives and their need for safety and verification. Read lots of the FAQ and "Etiquette" sections of their web pages. In a nutshell: Send a very respectful introduction email with just enough personal information (full name and a facebook or linkedin, something like that) so that they can verify that you're not an axe murderer or a cop. I met her in person for coffee first, to talk things through and get myself comfortable with her. I paid for her time. This is not standard but *I* needed it, because I am a "connection first" kind of sexual being, and it made me feel a thousand times more confident and reassured so it was worth the extra cost.
2) We picked a venue that allowed for lots of options. For me, this meant not a hotel room, which might have made me feel claustrophobic if things felt awkward. YMMV but my ideal location had a pool, hot tub, and an open-ended bedlike situation like an outdoor couch. I was initially picturing a large private poolscape. If I started to feel overwhelmed, I reasoned that I could take a dip under the water, swim a quick length in the pool, or that we could all move back and forth between the bed and the spa if we wanted to ramp the intensity up or down. That was my vision board, if you will. We looked around at airbnbs, private spa facilities, upscale bath houses, cottages, etc., and ended up finding a venue that was perfect for us. Again this required budgeting, but we'd been planning this for years so we prioritized it in a way that worked for our finances. The entire sexcapade cost about $2000, so it was a lifelong fantasy fulfillment (or at least an attempt at it), in exchange for a vacation we didn't take, in our family's budget.
3) I choreographed with her (verbally, over coffee) a few "scenes" beforehand, especially the part where we got started. I had no idea how to get past the awkward say-hi part, and I knew I'd be nervous, so we talked it out. I knew I wanted to give my husband a bit of a girl-on-girl show, but I wasn't sure if I would be comfortable with anything beyond some very light caressing, so we talked about how that might look. We would start things off with the girls slowly undressing each other (I shopped for a sundress with shoulder ties, for example, so that she could unwrap me with maximum visual sensuality), then both of us ushering him into a chair and whispering to sit back and enjoy, then the two of us going over to the outdoor shower, caressing under running water with soap suds and seeing how sexy we could make that look, and seeing how things went. Then eventually we would walk over to him, teasingly undress him together, and let things unfold organically in the hot tub from there.
3a) We also talked about soft signs to slow down -- if it started to feel too intense, for example, I would turn my back to her and lift up my hair, a signal that she should do some light fingernail tracing up and down my back (a sensation that is very soothing and calming for me). Everyone knew that if anything felt uncomfortable enough to slow it down more than that, we'd stop and talk it through, so that wasn't an issue. Then I discussed two "positions" that I was hoping we could treat him to, assuming things were flowing nicely and she was up for them, which were a double blow job (bucket list item for him), and a three-person sex position to finish things off, where I was riding him cowgirl-style and she was sitting in front of me, straddling his face for oral.
4) Wait, back up the horse. I should have made this #1. Our limits were simpatico and we agreed about them very very early. He did not care about PIV with anyone but me, which made me feel hugely more comfortable with the whole idea. I did not want him to kiss anyone else initially, but that one ended up being important enough to him that I let that one go. And there were no expectations about my interaction with her: He was happy with a scenario with two girls focusing on him, and he was happy even if it never got beyond kissing and everybody's hands were roaming. It could be a group foreplay session, at the lighter end of the possibilities, which was within my comfort zone. His anticipation level was set at "kissing, hands and breasts everywhere, and maybe a double bj as a stretch goal." I knew that his own private fantasies involved girl-on-girl play, so I did want to see if I could give him a little bit of that visually, but it would depend on how I felt in the moment.
5) Okay, my girl-on-girl experience -- it was NOT BAD! It was nothing like I had thought. I was afraid that, in the moment, I would feel "icky" about being sexual with another girl, but it was totally fine. It was a completely neutral tactile experience. Shockingly neutral. Bodies are bodies. Kissing a girl felt like a weirdly watered-down version of kissing... a softer version of a boy? There was no sexual energy or zing, but I didn't feel uncomfortable either. (I am actively turned off by girl-on-girl porn, so this was a real fear.) Same with caressing or kissing her breasts - she was small-breasted, so it was like a slightly bumpier version of teasing and kissing my husband's nipples, and in the moment it was well within my comfort zone. Human bodies are surprisingly interchangeable! (I had awkward teenage sex a couple of times and then met my husband so I have pretty much no knowledge of what sex is like with anyone but him. You all probably already know that humans are humans, but I was surprised and relieved that kissing her wasn't icky.) I would say that overall, I was not *turned on* throughout the adventure, but I was having relieved fun, performing for my husband and doing teasing and delicious things to him. It wasn't a horny experience for me, but it was fun, it made me feel wild and beautiful and adored by my beloved, and I loved seeing him feel good and turned on himself.
6) We spent most of the time in the hot tub, making out in bubbling water for a couple of hours. There were different people up and down on the edge of the tub, back into the water, hot and swirly with the jets going, everybody round and round. It was very free-flow. HYDRATE! I did feel some feelings watching my husband kissing someone else (and absolutely zero feelings watching him kissing her breasts or going down on her, or watching her/us give him oral -- so somehow my mind categorizes kissing as romantic, while second and third base are A-OK being categorized as meaningless casual sex for me?), but I was prepared for that. I protected myself by finding something to do during the kiss-switching times so I wasn't sitting there staring at them. The floaty water situation helped with that. He'd kiss me, we'd unlatch and I'd immediately swirl around and find something else to suck on, lol.
6a) Did you know that a "three person kiss" is a thing? She suggested it and I was like o.O but it works. You put everyone's lips together in the middle and it somehow works out. (This was helpful later on, when we were doing the double bj by trading off cock/balls, and she whispered "let's do it like the three-person kiss" so we put his shaft in between our lips and that totally worked also.) Who knew?
7) He spent probably 70% of his touch and focus (from my perspective; maybe he felt like he was receiving more than that) on me. I felt very attended to. My vague idea, going in, was 50/50 but he was very attentive to me. (His entire goal out of this bucket list item was that it be a thing that We Did Together, bringing a third into *our* sex life, as part of exploring life and sex together after two decades of marriage -- he had no interest in having a threesome with my permission with two other women, which was where we stalemated for a really long time, some years ago). There was never ever a single second when I was unattended to by someone, so I never felt left out. I never had the opportunity to pause and watch them do anything. Everything kept flowing round and round. This is also 100000% why my advice is to be with someone professional, because her attention was on facilitating a good experience for both of us. Which she did an amazing job with. They really know what they're doing. Experience with couples, I'm telling you.
8) In retrospect, I should have run the final position (the cowgirl/oral one) by him first, because that was the only moment that felt slightly awkward to him (he wanted to be able to see me more, but my entire body was blocked by her body -- and it turns out that achieving a Legit Three Person Sex Position, which I was congratulating myself on engineering for him, because it felt very extra, wasn't as important to him as not losing contact with me). I chose that one because it was the only three-person line drawing I could find on the internet that included neither a) PIV with the other girl, nor b) genital contact between me and the other girl, which I knew I wasn't down for. (This was correct: I was very comfortable with kissing and caressing above the waist, which was a big surprise to me, and was very happy not to feel pressured to exchange any touches below the waist. Also, that last 1% of "Am I really bi? All girls are bi, right?" doubt is gone.)
8a) And yet, I still feel residual inferiority about this. Bi girls are more highly valued by our culture (at least by the general sex-positive culture in my area; I know I shouldn't generalize) than straight girls. My upbringing and location have socialized me to internalize the idea that bi girls are "better" than straight girls.
8b) I'm really glad I went into it open-minded, because I got to experience "kissing feels neutral, it's an emotionless tactile kissy sensation -- not a sexually uncomfortable twinge, or even worse, an active aversion" and that made me feel SO much better about myself. Yes I live in a part of the country where we all like to think we are allies, but I always felt a little ashamed for being turned off by girl-on-girl porn/erotica. Like, am I secretly homophobic? I'm glad I got to have an experience that was positive yet affirming. And she was very tender and attentive to my body language and my requests. She read the room perfectly and managed to combine my responses in real time with my planned-out requests. My requests had been a duality of "here's what I think I'll be up for in terms of my own comfort zone" and "but I also really want to give my husband a visual treat, so I'm hoping to push my envelope a little bit if things are flowing well." Her touches were an expert blend of probably 80% soothing non-erotic touches that she knew felt shivery and pleasurable to me (tracing fingers, feather touch all over, light massage, playing with my hair, running fingertips along my forehead) and 20% very gentle visually-oriented erotic touches to tantalize my husband (soft-mouthed kisses, nipple sucking and caressing).
What else? Oh 9) I reframed my fears as nerves. Stage fright, basically. This was a scene in a movie that I was nervous about, just like any actress before her first sex scene. We were both super nervous in the week leading up to it. Reminding myself that this was a scene and that stage fright is normal was A+ as a meditation technique. I also asked my doctor for a few Xanax to have on hand in my purse (I made up a story about why, dental-procedure anxiety or something, because yeah I wasn't going there with my GP), just in case I felt like I needed to take the edge off of the adrenaline. Having it there was psychologically reassuring, a safety net. Exactly like a stage actress would do. That mindset worked really well for me.
10) I had an emotional crash the next morning! It was basically a textbook sub drop, where the intensity and emotions and brain chemicals after a big exciting SCENE suddenly fall off a cliff. I had been building up to this day for a solid year logistically, and much longer mentally. Classic sub drop. We talked and I immediately felt normal again. But I didn't see that coming and it confused me. The experience was good, why do I suddenly feel empty and crashy? But as always in marriage, cuddling and communication was the fix. It's possible that if we had de-briefed with each other immediately afterwards, it wouldn't have happened (but it was past midnight and I wanted his good memories to "cement" so that he'd have them forever, before dissecting it together in a big over-analytical postmortem, like we do), so we went home and entwined and went to sleep. And then I woke up the next morning like wow wait what?).
Sooooo to wrap this up, it was good. It was better than I could have hoped, for both of us. Don't do it if you don't want to, but if you find yourself *wanting* to want to, I hope our experience helps someone. Your sexcapade may vary and maybe a wild spontaneous FWB fling is what's best for you, but my advice to the uncertain is: forget unicorns. Remove the extra layer of complication and give yourselves the gift of a professional to attentively guide you through. For us, it was a 10/10 decision, wouldn't go back and change that choice for the world.
Tl;dr: Overcommunicate for years and then hire a professional. Everyone will get what they want. The end.