r/sewing • u/[deleted] • May 11 '20
Discussion This is a really grumpy post. Constructive criticism, per rules.
I used to love this sub. I would see so many cool things people are making! It was so neat checking out the creativity and sewn varieties.
But now it’s all “What machine should I buy?” “Help me find a pattern for this shirt on this Instagram model.” “What’s wrong with my machine? (I never read the manual and I didn’t thread it correctly or adjust the tension)”
As an avid sewist, crafter, and fabric store employee, I use to love this sub. But you guys are driving me fucking bananas now. I finally have to unsubscribe.
But don’t worry, I’ll see you all at the local Joanns where you can fondle the non-essential fabric, ignore social distancing, and treat my coworkers and I like shit all in one go. Cheers!
117
u/ForgottenPassword92 May 11 '20 edited May 11 '20
Besides the ending in bold i think this is a common complaint that people need to get over. I have seen this in many subs and it’s always the same, “i’m OG and all you noobs are annoying and repetitive. This place used to be cool, I’m leaving.”
And i say, good riddance.
I’ve seen a lot of super creative posts on here in the couple months I’ve been subbed. And yes, I’ve seen a LOT of posts that could have been handled with a look at a manual or a google search that takes as much effort as asking the reddit world to tell you and guide you. But who cares? Is it so bad to ignore or respond to a few people trying to get into and enjoy and learn and master a hobby that you yourself find worth while?
What do you think Reddit is for? It’s a hodgepodge of people, ages, ideas, activities and STUFF.
So you’re offended that the 15yo kid who broke out his mothers sewing machine so he could make his girlfriend a handkerchief wants to ask some experts for advice on why the thread is bunching up? Or the girl that it’s happening to while she alters her shirt? Or the woman whose husband got her a too complicated machine that is not what she’s used to?
Or you’re upset that the man who started sewing masks because his sister works in a hospital and his coworkers are on construction sites and so went to his house and picked up his wife’s sewing machine (who died a year ago so she can’t teach him to use it) and started making masks and then posted for help because the machine locked up and he doesn’t know why? (That was me).
Oh, how about that 1920s Parisian dress? Or the Victorian era hand-sewn piece? Or the weird puffy owl or bat thing someone made as their first ever project posted this morning?
Go. There is plenty here for others to enjoy. There are plenty of people looking for help, support and guidance and i can offer it or not. My choice. I don’t need to make them feel bad about asking.
11
u/chuchudex May 11 '20
r/sewhelp is real
51
May 11 '20
I’d bet the one’s asking the questions do not know this.
Wouldn’t it be great if in addition to answering their questions we let them know about an additional helpful sub?
Sharing is caring!
16
u/ForgottenPassword92 May 11 '20
Exactly.
I've been redirected to a more appropriate sub before. It's helpful.
6
u/ForgottenPassword92 May 11 '20
A good response to those posting on the most popular and active sewing sub (r/sewing).
4
May 11 '20
And for the record, the sidebar has all of your answers!!!!!!! Machines, tutorials, etc. and r/freepatterns is a great sub to spam your insta model clothing questions!
5
34
u/scrablee May 11 '20
Goodbye. You will be happier elsewhere. I like that this sub has the variety of very talented and experienced stitchers, newbies excited by their first projects, photos of all types of cool sewn items and clothing, and, yes, people who need help, ask questions, and are respectfully answered.
18
u/sewing06 May 11 '20
I think we are getting a super concentrated version of what is usually the annual new people go to college problem that reddit generally suffers from. Loads of people have suddenly picked up our hobby, and they all have the same beginner problems.
It is certainly frustrating when the same basic question turns up for the third time in a few days (or hours), but reddit is not the most searchable of sites and the third person deserves help as much as the first. I think it would be worth having some more faqs in the side bar to handle some of these questions, but that requires someone with the skills to volunteer to write them.
I love that this sub is beginner friendly and that people try to help each other. I have certainly grown in my sewing journey by being in this sub even if I already knew the basics. I can also understand that the influx of newbies is making this a little bit like your job which is not great for you, but many people here will not know anyone in real life who can sew.
Regarding the pattern searches, it is hard for a beginner who doesn't know the terms for various necklines etc to know how to do an effective search. Again, this is the sort of thing where if they had a physical shop they could go to, they would be asking someone like you for help, but right now, this sub is pretty much it.
6
u/chuchudex May 11 '20
Often pattern search requests are from something RTW online, if they'd look at said description it will literally tell them the key words to put in a pattern search, ex " v neck, button down, bishop sleeve blouse" 100 percent rayon viscose. Thru that search they can find what they personally like for themselves, based on their skill set & fabric choices from there. And they gained knowledge for moving forward in their new hobby.
8
u/yeahsewwhat May 11 '20
... for those who don’t know anyone. I don’t know anyone personally who sews. But if you have access to Instagram or reddit you have access to google and if you don’t know what kind of neckline it is you can literally google “chart of neckline styles” or “list of neckline styles” and countless graphics, blog posts,- and videos will detail all of this. In fact - i did a google image search for that very thing and was flooded with info. So much faster than asking Reddit.
12
u/m-m-m-fashion May 11 '20
I think this sub would be a lot tidier if we responded to these questions simply by linking to tutorials. There only are so many ways that one can screw up the thread tension, so I agree with you in that regard.
Another great thing would be a sticky post on top of the sub and more info in the About section. It took me ages to find the community info on mobile when I first started out on Reddit.
However I have no sympathies for people always going on grumpy or offensive rants full of generalisations because this only sparks defense when there are actual problems with this sub that are worthy of a discussion.
7
u/Zesparia May 11 '20
Reddit unfortunately only supports two stickied posts at once. Moving from one to two was a HUGE deal to begin with so getting a third is simply not in the cards. Right now the mod team has completely suspended the usual rotating themed stickies in favor of permanent Machine Monday and Simple Questions threads, so that people who are struggling to understand their grandma's machine after hunting it down where it has lived in a closet for 17 years can try to get it working again.
Other QOL changes were already in the works before lockdowns got instituted but then obviously lockdowns got instituted and we're getting unprecedented traffic increases from people who need help. Those changes are a marathon to complete, vs being quick sprints, so are being worked on in what free time exists for the team.
To give an off the top of my head example of what we're dealing with, December (aka when everyone is making gifts and GETTING sewing machines and thus need to get started) averaged roughly 140 comments (including answers given of course) to each week long simple questions thread. April... April got 300+ in each and every one. Visitor traffic stats are even more staggering.
Every post and comment that goes up here does have lurkers who see it and use it to solve their issues, based on those stats.
4
u/chuchudex May 11 '20
A bot to redirect to r/sewhelp would be awesome for both the users with troubleshooting issues and the saints who are willing to answer their neverending repetitive questions.
9
u/Zesparia May 11 '20
That would require a chunk of a few hours to code the bot, testing back and forth over time to see what key words and phrases would need tweaking, and then further tweaks when the bot actually goes live. Then we'd have to deal with user fallout whenever the bot missteps. This hypothetical bot would be one of a few bots we currently have in the works as we try to condense as much info as we can and get it where it needs to go, in between handling increased moderation duties.
In the end we also plain have no inclination to alienate newbies entirely. In every community there is a balance between sating the needs of newbies and sating the needs of the more experienced members of a niche. Right now it's a phase where newbies are rampant due to events far outside of any of our control. As time passes it will ease. If it gets to be a lot then posts can be hidden in your feed.
2
1
u/m-m-m-fashion May 11 '20 edited May 12 '20
Thank you for your replies!
I'm glad to hear that this is all due to the current situation, hopefully that will get better soon. I do hope that we'll have better measures in place to combat with repetitive questions, although I understand that it all takes some time.
Lastly I'd like to emphasize again the fact that some people just may not know where to look for the FAQs; maybe this could be solved by some addition in the About section, possibly short-term stickies or automatic messages in times where there are many people joining.
I don't know what your possibilities are and I don't want to nag too much in these busy times - those are just the things that come to my mind when I get annoyed about the repetiteveness of the posts but also the helplessness of new posters.
Cheers and thanks again!
Edit: super cool that we have a 3rd tab now :) thanks
9
May 12 '20
Then don't read those posts. It takes like 2 microseconds to scroll by posts you're not interested in.
21
u/Ahollowbullet-yet May 11 '20 edited May 11 '20
You sound like you're having a bad day. Very presumptuous of you to say that we're all rude to retail workers. Overall you could have voiced this issue in a much kinder way.
10
u/moretorquethanyou May 11 '20
If people asking other people for help because they don't know how to Google something or read a manual then I must infer that you don't internet much.
I'm sorry you're grumpy. I hope things get better soon.
5
May 11 '20
Yeah I personally love to ask questions and read questions of others regarding what ideas people have regarding outfit/pattern matching. People often have ideas and insights that I wouldn’t have thought of like how a dress I was looking to recreate had a “total dirndl vibe” which I hadn’t even realized and have since then gone down a total dirndl rabbit hole.
3
u/chuchudex May 11 '20
You will benefit greatly from sewingpattern review.com. Most every pattern out there has been sewn & reviewed by someone. Great for fabric variations & body types w great insights to any alterations they made. # a pattern name on Instagram for more great inspiration.
2
May 11 '20
That sounds pretty cool! Thank you for your insight.
1
9
u/yeahsewwhat May 11 '20
This is all very true. I’m new to sewing myself but taught myself a bunch. This sub like any sub was always a mix of posts for sure. However, in the last few weeks there are SOoOoo many people posting the same questions, the same pictures.
If you have the energy to ask a question on reddit, can’t you ask google? Can’t you help yourself before you ask others to do everything for you?
Things have definitely “gotten worse” here compared to other subs in the last few months because so many people are just starting to sew. Sadly, many people also don’t like self directed learning and need to be spoon fed everything. The combination hasn’t been good for this sub.
6
u/RedRapunzal May 11 '20
I'm new to sewing and have loved the in-depth posts and assistance the community has provided posters. I try to read these engaging posts fully to glean good tips.
I must agree the constant what machine and photos of clothing from the web is annoying. Stop stealing other people's designs. Go look for the pattern or machine for yourself. No one machine is top.
I blame the mask rush for some of this. My questions are, after this pandemic becomes history, will the mask makers keep sewing? What happens to all the masks? Is it worth buying a machine to make masks (my state has them for free)? Did you really need all the cotton fabric at the store (sorry, the shortage is bugging me)?
Maybe we should add something at the top of the sub with and index of basics like names, trouble shooting, machine basics...
3
u/yeahsewwhat May 11 '20
It should be worth noting that a lot of supply / distribution issues with sewing materials and equipment right now are not at the local level even though you may be frustrated that certain stores are out of certain things. Some materials and even machines are in such high demand that their distribution is being carefully administered w many organizations and agencies so that as soon as things land off a cargo ship they’re already spoken for and sent to areas with the greatest need. Right now many of them don’t even have time to go directly to private consumers thru a retailer because companies or non profit organizations are buying larger orders to meet demand directly thru distributors etc.
So people in your area may have access to free things but are buying up supplies anyway - in part to make their own gear, in part maybe because they’re home and finally have time to learn sewing. Either way, it is creating a boom that people in the industry anticipated about as far back as January according to my local singer dealership, which said even then they were warned that global events would cause distribution issues. The same distributor also said that because there are so many people misusing machines right now to male protective gear are bringing them in either because they’re using them incorrectly or overworking them - and that they’re just sort of overwhelmed with repairs at the moment, in addition to not being able to even get machines in at all much of the time.
6
u/chuchudex May 11 '20
YouTube is overflowing with tutorials from the most basic, to more difficult problem solving. Much easier to watch a video for the spoon fed crowd! Sewing is a solitary sport. It takes patience, & experience that you only get by doing. Many Quarentined New hobbyists want their experience to be fast & easy, instant. There are some new phenoms posting amazing FO 's on this sub but they are Exceptions, not typical.
3
u/yeahsewwhat May 11 '20
Re: the solitary sport - yes, sewing is something that many take for granted despite the fact that items sewn by others are essential to our daily lives. Just like cooking, which also takes practice, people often see something online or in the world and try to replicate it. Being caught up in the solitary act, the ego gets attached to the process and product, and even though someone could objectively see flaws in someone else’s work, they may overlook them in their own, even if they compared it to a store bought item and could see differences their perception becomes a bit clouded. Even when craftsmansahip is good, sometimes taste level is not great or materials are bad. People do this with other things too like cooking ... how many think they’re awesome cooks but they’re food doesn’t even LoOk good let alone taste good or hold up to a professional in a blind taste test?
4
u/yeahsewwhat May 11 '20
On the other hand, anecdotal evidence on this sub also shows an abundance of poor craftsmanship and low taste even among experienced sewists ... which gives me confidence as a beginner. 🍵
2
u/chuchudex May 11 '20
Agreed! Said perfectly ! Fit, appropriate drape of fabric for pattern, pre washing, pressing, oh I could go on & on about craftmanship....
12
u/chuchudex May 11 '20
Your 2 ND paragraph, yes! Has become, " someone else do all the research for me" sub. If you Google your issue, adding "and reddit" all the same answers will pop up, rather than asking the same ?s over & over. Google & Pintrest are your friends! I wrote a similar post on r/freepatterns & people were offended cuz I said the sub was "hijacked" by these same " find me a pattern posts" SMH, mods?
12
u/AsideTheCreekWV May 11 '20
They don't even need Google. There is easily 4 posts a day asking "which is the best machine for a beginner?"
Do people not look around a bit when they goto a new sub?
6
u/twowheeledextremist May 11 '20 edited May 11 '20
I don't work in a fabric store so I can't speak to your last paragraph, but know that you are not alone in this sentiment. I have to take a break sometimes because the repetitive questions just get to be too much. Especially the "find me a pattern" questions - I want to respond with, "do you have ANY idea how many pattern companies there are?" - Big 4 and too many indie companies to count, not mention all of the out-of-print patterns you can buy on E Bay and Etsy.
It can be annoying, but I think it's the nature of Reddit. The Bicycle-related subs got this way too with the same questions over and over. The subs get very large and I would imagine that the mods have to pick their battles - focus on the trolls and creepers and let the beginners ask their questions even if they are repetitive.
With all that said, I wonder if there's a way to moderate and direct the more repititive posts to something that can be a little more productive. I've started to see a bot that posts to the "what machine should I get" questions and directs people to the side bar. What about a bot that directs the other questions? I feel like the pattern questions would be more helpful if the posters would talk a bit more about themselves - for example, what is your skill level? I see questions about patterns for kind of complicated garments that might be a little advanced for a beginner. There's few things more discouraging in sewing than picking a difficult pattern and having it not turn out the way you hoped. Also, "show your work." What research did you already do? If you selected a couple patterns that are the style you're looking for, someone on the sub might have some experience with it and can give you some specific pointers.
Anyway, these are just some thoughts. I hate to see anyone leave, but I get it too. These are anxious times and you have to conserve mental energy.
4
u/chuchudex May 11 '20
I vote Yes to more bots that redirect!, Vote No to posts asking the sub to find overly ambitious patterns of Ready To Wear.
2
u/QueenBlanchesHalo May 12 '20
I have to say this sub is really great at finding patterns and it’s the kind of thing that’s harder to google - even reverse image searching would be limited - so I’m kinda ok with those requests.
4
u/itsmynetoo May 11 '20
Alrighty then, go on with yo bad self.
And by the way, fondling nonessential fabric is therapy for many.
2
u/CustomSawdust May 11 '20
This happens on every creative sub.
I am subscribed to most every sub that covers my extensive hobby interests. The advanced participants begin as willing teachers and post quality content and willingly help, then newbie after newbie creep in and ask the same questions over and over.
Some sub mods create a 101 sub to hopefully eliminate the the sophomoric questions, but some usually get through if the mods are off duty.
I was a member of a specific music themed sub and complained aboht this only once, used the term neophyte, and was assaulted with unbelievable language because i was simply tired of 101 questions taking up the bandwith. Unsubbed due to the personal attacks. Their true personalities came out they had no business pretending to be such artists.
Interested crafty people tend to be a little non-technical and wouldn’t read instructions to NOT post their plebe inquiries anyway. This is the mod’s job, or if enough people don’t like it we can downvote the posts and take a chance of exhibiting niche elitism.
3
May 12 '20
So then make “creative subs” private so just the advanced participants can participate.
Or better yet-use discord so you won’t be bothered
3
u/CustomSawdust May 12 '20
We could. I am not as bothered as the OP on this one, just relating my experience with the other sub. If i do not care for a post i keep scrolling.
There will always be willing teachers with seemingly perpetual patience for the newbies.
3
May 12 '20
“There will always be willing teachers with seemingly perpetual patience for newbies”
You sound arrogant
I’m certain there are other platforms that you and others can go -to not have to deal with and be patient with “newbies”.
Especially now, since there happens to be a worldwide something happening, the uptick of inquiries from “newbies” will be increased.
1
2
u/yeahsewwhat May 11 '20
U/mmmWeir thank you for your work and for putting up with people. I try to support Joann as little as possible but when I need to I do because I know the company at least provides jobs for people (even if they could compensate them better and treat them better). For every down vote this post gets, a retail / service industry worker out there finds a nug of weed that had been hiding under something right when they get home after a long shift ends...
18
u/Feeling-Concept May 11 '20
I sew and I lurk this sub and something I really like about this subreddit is the overwhelming kindness and selflessness of the people on this sub. Sometimes people post patterns as replies that I didn’t even think about googling or making and I have ended up making after seeing them posted. I can understand your frustration with the repetitive posts which can be answered with try rethreading your machine or something along those lines, and I think it speaks to the specialness of this sub that people meet posters where they’re at and aim to help. However, I don’t work at a fabric store so I can understand how it may be frustrating to deal with people at work and find similar questions, posts and comments on this sub.