r/selfhosted • u/AhmedBarayez • 32m ago
Need Help Sophos Firewall VM is it worth it to use it bare metal and change my setup??
So i have my setup like this
ISP router → MikroTik ac lite used as a VLAN-aware switch.
The ISP router goes to MikroTik port 1, The WAN travels over a single trunk (port 2), and all VLANs to a Proxmox server.
Sophos Firewall runs as a VM on that server, with all other VMs. It’s the gateway and DHCP server for all VLANs (5 = Wi-Fi, 10 = wired LAN, 30 = servers).
Mikrotik handles DHCP requests and sending them to Sophos using relays
Tiny network: about 2 wired PCs and 4 to 5 phones.
The VM already starts first on boot, and the BIOS powers on after a power loss.
Everything works perfectly but i'm annoyed (just to play a little more) and i want to separate the Sophos into a device on its own, to make the firewall independent of the main server, so that after a power cut devices don’t wait for Proxmox and then the VM to get IPs, and so the internet survives server failure or maintenance, etc
So i was thinking about two options
A) A small mini PC with one NIC running Proxmox, Sophos stays a VM with virtual NICs for WAN, LAN, and a trunk to the MikroTik.
B) A small SFF PC with one extra PCIe slot for NIC, and use it as bare metal port for WAN and port for LAN
Both options will allow me to use the firewall right after the ISP router and use the Mikrotik as switch only to handle ports traffic
BUT, does it worth it or i'm too paranoid? like i said everything actually works great i don't have any issues but i prefer sophos on its own and most likely bare metal, what do you recommend?


