r/secretofmana • • May 12 '23

Art & Images Who the fuck thought this was a good puzzle? Who thought this was an okay thing to put in the game? I'm sorry but when a puzzle is so cryptic that a guide is REQUIRED, someone fucked up.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/secretofmana • • Feb 16 '18

[PS4] What an embarrassing, colossal fucking disappointment!

3 Upvotes

Let me preface this by saying I'm a huge fan of Secret of Mana and usually in my eyes Squaresoft can do no wrong. Even when they "remastered" FF9 with built in hacks and same low def backgrounds (let's be real, we wanted HD backgrounds, they were gorgeous back in the day)

That being said, there's a line in the sand right at this abomination. Once you actually play this polished turd by escaping the relentless glitches and crashes, Square takes your nostalgia out behind the bar and blows its fucking brains out all over the alleyway dumpster.

I like the voice acting, the art style, and even the non existent mouth movement, it has a Radiata Stories feel to it.

The music sounds like they pulled a composer out of middle school music class, no not band, I mean a kid that is in music class just because he needs an art credit to make it to the 9th grade. They let him listen to the original score and said "Hey kid, there's a crisp 20 for you if you take a shit all over every single one of these songs, we can't afford a DAW so we'll just set you up with MTV Music maker on the PlayStation 1. Not the full game, the JAMPACK demo version.

The bosses thus far are laughable. I couldn't believe how easy they were. Clicker Heroes had harder bosses. Why they decided to destroy every sense of accomplishment in the game is beyond me. In contrast, your first trip into the haunted forest will skewer you with arrows and serve you up next to a lobster tail.

Square promised menu casting without interrupting gameplay. LIE, same old system.

When this promise was taken back, we were told that we could assign spells to shortcut buttons (L1 and R1) to minimize gameplay interruptions during multiplayer. LIE, you can use shortcuts in single player, but as soon as a second controller is added, the functionality disappears! That makes about as much sense as Taco Bell discontinuing the triple steak stack. Fucking none!

Let us not forget that armor has been changed to some convoluted bullshit with a bunch of different stats for each piece of gear, including some unique stats, all of which you can't even see before you buy it! Funny how this ripoff ships with a blind claw machine system in the armor shops.

Don't get me started on the fact that there is no cannon travel cutscene. All the bullshit polish but they couldn't throw a spinning character across an overworld that ALREADY EXISTS AS AN ASSET ON THE DISC. That's not just lazy, that's 32 year old man with 2 kids and a wife that works 2 jobs but he's still trying to get his band "discovered" by playing open mic night at Buster's Beers n Brats by the gas station near the freeway exit levels of lazy.

Remember how long it took to grind out those magic levels? It took ages! For most of us this was a time period in our lives during which we had just about unlimited free time, and it STILL took forever. Well, BUCKLE UP FUCKERS, you can't chain cast magic anymore, enjoy that grind! However much time you spent getting the timing just right, waiting for a certain part of the animation, or maybe even a part of the sound effect, oh well, it's gone. Out the door and it took the kids with it.

Do I think this is a shameless, predatory cash grab that exploits only their most dedicated fans? No, I don't. Rather, this is just a giant FUCK YOU to us instead. Some strange ego trip by a company whose relevance is fading faster than a Polaroid sitting under a desk lamp, just so they could fuck us in the ass, and have us PAY them to do it!

I give it 1 out of 5 giant fucking turds.


r/secretofmana • • Oct 28 '18

Reasons for liking this game?

0 Upvotes

Id like to preface this by saying I'm not trying to start an argument. I didn't enjoy this game very much and am just genuinely curious to why it seems so beloved.

I played this game to completion a while back, and I have to say, I kind of regret it. The game felt like a chore to get through, and it didn't feel like a rewarding experience when I was done. I LOVE the idea of this game. And I really WANTED to like it. It has a lot of elements that I really love. But in practice, it was an all around frustrating experience. I'll come back to this idea of loving the ideas, but not the excecution a lot.

I love the idea of the action-oriented combat and rpg elements put together. The vast variety of weapons to choose from is great, and I love leveling things up, especially seeing the weapons physically change to more powerful forms, it's a great feeling... Well, it would be, if I used them. I wanted to use the cool weapons, but was stopped by the most infuriating mechanic I've ever seen in any video game.

Missing.

I understand attacks missing is just a fact of life in rpgs. But this is an ACTION rpg. When I actively control my character, and clearly connect with an attack, only for the game to say it missed, its frustrating. Most of the time, I could never tell if I whiffed an enemy, or the game just decided that attack missed. And it happens so often! Why is a literal WALL so evasive? Why am I missing when I clearly did not? This makes the whole charging mechanic utterly useless. I spend what feels like an eternity charging my weapon to max, unleash my attack expecting a devastating blow... And it misses. Rendering all that time charging that I COULD have spent dealing damage, completely usless. I try again. It misses. Over. And over. And over. Its never a good idea to charge your weapon more than a few levels because of how often it misses.

And this isn't even mentioning how infuriating being knocked unconscious is. While you only have one party member, all you can do is just sit there and wait to die. This, along with missing, makes the beginning of the game incredibly difficult for the most asinine reasons.

And then I get magic.

And then I have the opposite problem.

The game became way too easy. Magic is so unbelievably overpowered. It does truckloads more damage than basic attacks, and never misses. The game became "Fill up on MP restore items, demolish everything in your path on the way to the next town, rinse, repeat." It was cool trying out different spells to see how they looked, or what utility spells did, but why use a utility spell when you could just kill your enemies instantly? There's no cooldown. It freezes enemies in place. You can pummel them with spells and they cant lay a finger on you. Not even bosses.

I didn't want to use magic. I wanted to play fair. I wanted a challenge. So I used the buff spells to buff up my party, get their weapons enchanted, and go to fight the boss fair and square. And I miss. And I miss. And I miss again. And finally I land a hit, and it deals absolutely PITIFUL damage compared to any one of my spells. I had to aim, I had to actually hit the boss and chase after them, but even if I didnt whiff I could still miss. If I used a spell, I didnt have to do anything. I just click the spell. Over. And over. And over until they die. Its not fun, its not fair. But playing fair isn't fun either, because it just doesn't work. You cant win when you miss every other attack, and your weapons are little more than toothpicks in terms of damage compared to magic. How polarized the difference was between how brokenly underpowered melee combat it, and how brokenly overpowered magic is, was absolutely unbelieveable.

I made myself get through the game, and I beat it, but it wasn't a good time. The game was either so difficult, in the most frustrating of ways that it wasn't fun, or so pathetically easy it wasn't fun depending on how I decided to play. The game left a very bad taste in my mouth.

There's the awful ai getting stuck on things and generally being stupid, and the ring menus being unintuitive, but those are just minor nitpicks of mine compared to how awfully balanced the game felt to me.

I feel like there was so much potential, but it just didn't deliver. I wanted to like this game, I had heard so many good things about it, but upon playing it I just couldn't find any myself.

So I want to ask: why do you like this game? What makes you look past the flaws? Or maybe, if they aren't flaws to you, why is that? I just genuinely want to know what this game has to offer that I missed out or didn't pick up on.

TL;DR: Didn't like this game at all. The mechanics of using melee combat (mainly missing) made the game nearly unplayable. Using magic on the other hand made the game so easy it felt like there was no point. Why do you like the game despite this/why does it not bother you?


r/secretofmana • • Dec 31 '20

Discussion Trials of Mana [Online Game Code] is 30% off

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/secretofmana • • Jun 12 '20

Videos & Music Trials Of Mana Running On RX570(I3-4130)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/secretofmana • • Feb 26 '26

Question Whatever happened to the top down era Jrpgs?

9 Upvotes

Chrono trigger was one of the last released in 1995 that was considered a top down perspective era game. Most everything else at the time was going for 3d open world stuff like the Zelda games on n64 that I never got into. The late 80s and early 90s was the golden age of RPGs and square was the master. I can’t believe there isn’t some sort of a fan made sequel using the same engine with today’s computing they could do crazy things with rpg makers and open source. Why has square never released a throwback to something similar like Zelda, a link between worlds


r/secretofmana • • Apr 23 '20

Discussion Oh, is chawett's voice actow too gwating to your wittle eawrs?

0 Upvotes

All the people complaining sound like bigger babies than Charlotte herself.


r/secretofmana • • Jul 28 '25

Humor Games cover on backwards lol

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Is this common? Its just the cover glued on backwards lmao


r/secretofmana • • Apr 16 '20

Discussion Secret bosses and remake Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So I know there isbat lesst teo secret bosses on the original seiken densetsu III the black rabite snd the chobin hood.

The black rabite is only accessible by having Duran or Angela as main character, but I can't seen to remember the chobin hood one.

Maybe they are not the same locations ob the remake but I am gonna stick with Angela main to face echo the black rabite *echo *.

Are there any other secret bosses?


r/secretofmana • • Mar 04 '18

Secret of Mana Remake Looks a Little Odd

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/secretofmana • • Aug 29 '24

Discussion Called it!

0 Upvotes

With Visions of Mana being out today, one of the high points I've heard is the combat. Other than it not relying on the perfect dodge/counter mechanic we've been seeing a lot in ARPGs, it's been praised for the customization & varied battle system. I posted this last week about character builds/variety being my biggest takeaway from the demo. Yep, I totally called it!


r/secretofmana • • Jan 08 '24

Discussion How Long Will Visions of Mana Be?

5 Upvotes

Does anyone have a guess on how long Visions of Mana will be? The average Mana game last 20 hours but based on what I've seen, Visions seems like it'll last considerably longer. If the story is more linear like most Square games today, my estimate is 30 1/2 hours. Don't get me wrong, most SE games include plenty of side content. The thing about Mana games is that their stories are more simplistic compared to Final Fantasy or Octopath Traveler and lack distractions. And I'm assuming this game won't have a class system but will be more like Secret of Mana in terms of story structure. But what are your thoughts? How long do you think this game will be?


r/secretofmana • • Sep 10 '25

Discussion I couldnt finish this game after 30 years and im quite sad ☹️

0 Upvotes

So this year ive been on a pretty hard retro streak replaying rpgs i havent played in decades.

Some of the games i beat in the last few months are Final Fantasy 1, 2 (4), 3 (6), Mystic Quest, Legend 1 - 3, Lufia 1 and 2, Breath of Fire 1 and 2, Chrono Trigger, Earthbound Beginnings, Earthbound, Mother 3, Super Mario RPG, and the 7th Saga. I beat all of them and some of them multiple times.

I then moved onto the mana series and beat Adventure and Sword of Mana. Secret of Mana was next and sadly i couldnt finish it.

I loved this game as a kid but i remember getting stuck on the bosses and i couldnt beat them unless i spammed magic on them to stun lock them. And this hasnt changed as an adult.

The 100% recharge system didnt age well and i believe this system was better in Adventure. In that game you didnt need to wait for the bar and that game played just fine.

The hit boxes are also atrocious. Did i miss because the enemy dodged? Or did i miss because of a wonky hitbox? Was that delayed damage number mine or one of my two allies attack? And some enemies are infuriating like the snow wolves who can stun lock you constantly. This game amounts to stun lock or be stun locked.

Want to avoid the enemies and run by them? Nope, you are turned into a moogle, confused, set on fire, turned into a snowman, vined and slowed, etc. Or you get stopped because your ally is stuck behind a rock.

So while the graphics and soundtrack are absolutely beautiful, the rest of this game aged pretty poorly, much more so than Final Fantasy Adventure imo.

As a kid the only Square or Enix game I didnt own was Secret of Evermore. Now as an adult i realized why i never bought it post Mana. ☹️


r/secretofmana • • May 15 '23

Question Am I softlocked? I can't get through without a pickaxe, I am out of pickaxes, and the way back to buy more pickaxes is blocked by more boulders that also require a pickaxe to get through. So I actually cannot leave this area. What am I supposed to do?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/secretofmana • • May 16 '21

Discussion This might've already been discussed, but this game has a serious problem with bosses. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

While I was playing SoM, I kept trying to convince myself, "It's okay! Bosses are an important part of RPGs, so it's normal that there are many!"

My foot. This is laughable. This is the reason this game didn't make it big. It's full of unfair and time-consuming boss monsters that most of the time don't even differ from each other.

I am currently in what I think is called the Pure Land. There was a recolor of the snake that terrorized the mushroom village, a dragon, a recolor of the sring-legged coocoo bird that appeared in the deceased sprite village, and I'm currently fighting a recolor of THAT SAME DRAGON that was the second that I mentioned! That's already 4 bosses in a single area, and only one of them is new material!!!

These bosses are also not fun. They keep spamming magic spells that slow down my team. The spring-legged bird is also hard to target: Randi, the person who I equipped with the sword, has to stand behind the enemy to slash it, and it only works when it's a level 0, uncharged attack, otherwise he flies into the bird and gets hurt.

It's really a shame, because the game has other qualities that are obligated to make up for it: beatiful soundtrack, nice graphics and world design, the ring menu, option for multiplayer. If there wasn't this ONE issue (aside from a slightly bad storyline), then SoM would be considered a legendary game by so many people other than us, fans.

SquareSoft, I expected better.

Edit: It's not the difficulty that bugs me, I beat the enemies when I take an effort. It's the repetitivity that made me angry. Nevertheless, thank you for trying to help me, people in the comments! I'm playing SoM on the Mini SNES.


r/secretofmana • • Mar 13 '21

Question Please help, in PS4 remake of secret of mana

0 Upvotes

In the original secret of mana for SNES you would land on that tiny island, save with the cat, hold R L start and select to reset, and start a new game which continues from the glitch save you off to get the 9th sword orb. How do you get the 9th sword orb in the PS4 remake?


r/secretofmana • • Apr 24 '20

Videos & Music My Trials of Mana Stream.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/secretofmana • • May 08 '20

Question omg please tel me angela gets better. playing on pc trials of mana

0 Upvotes

Im playing on hard first time just hitting people with some crappy staff, wheres my magic c'mon man :(?

also what should I be putting my points into I love AOE attacks and high damage


r/secretofmana • • Jun 22 '23

Discussion Querido diario...Desamor 20/6

0 Upvotes

Un día bello y fresco , un día que me tome para estar con mi familia, quería estar bien , feliz y capaz tener un buen momento con mi pareja abrazados con mi hermosa bb alado, hasta que...

reviso su cel , no buscaba nada , ni esperaba encontrar nada, pero de todas formas lo vi, buscaba a put4s de la zona, porque? cosa que ni me quería, se lo dije y me pego.. hasta acá llegue dije! no vuelvo ni pienso volver con esta persona que cada ves que le reclamo me pega, cada ves que le descubro algo me pega, solamente me miente, estoy feliz de todas formas ,,, porque se que ya no tengo que seguir perdiendo el tiempo con esta persona, podre volver a enamorarme de nuevo de alguien que no me trate de estúpid4, ni me trate mal... 🐇


r/secretofmana • • Oct 04 '23

Question What terms am I supposed to use for the sprite

6 Upvotes

The wiki says they/them the original game says it/it's Wtich one do I use in order to be respectful to fictional sprite


r/secretofmana • • Apr 23 '22

News & Features Why I hated Secret of Mana 2 (Argh!)

Thumbnail
wall-jump.com
1 Upvotes

r/secretofmana • • Oct 21 '20

Humor When your sibling says, "Come on I didn't hit you that hard"

Thumbnail
pbs.twimg.com
0 Upvotes

r/secretofmana • • Dec 04 '21

Discussion Is Secret of Mana a primary source of inspiration for Final Fantasy VII? Spoiler

5 Upvotes

I've been researching Secret of Mana for quite some time now, and the coincidences seem to keep piling up. As far as I know, Final Fantasy VII appears to function as a Secret of Mana Remake, or at least is heavily connected to Final Fantasy VI, which in turn, was impacted by Secret of Mana.

I still can't believe how many people gloss over the connections as well. I've listed a few below.

First of all, Still of the Night resembles Can You Hear the Planet Crying. I've read several comments on YouTube that pick up on the connection, and I don't think it's coincidence. The City of the Ancients/ surrounding Forest area resembles the Pure Land in Secret of Mana- complete with ruins (seashell-themed, but still) and surrounding forest. The area is even situated near a giant crater-type area.

The Ancients are also mentioned in Secret of Mana, although they don't seem to be planet-loving, instead they were people who lived (some of whom built the Mana Fortress) before the Mana Beast attacked the Fortress and the Mana Sword smashed it.

Thanatos I think bares a connection to Sephiroth, as Thanatos (role-wise) functions as one of the heavenly generals (four fiends in FF mythology). The main difference from previous FFs is that he survives until the end, as opposed to the Emperor. A similar thing happens with Kefka in FFVI, and Sephiroth himself is a part of Shinra (military, as Kefka was) and even takes down the President, only to have the President be replaced.


r/secretofmana • • Jul 04 '19

Playing some Seiken Densetsu 3 toady. Starting in 30 mins.

Thumbnail
twitch.tv
13 Upvotes