r/scrooges • • Nov 28 '10

Matching Algorithm, I am disappoint..

2 Upvotes

Given that the RedditGifts team said they would wait until there were less than 100 unsatisfied matches, the chances of being one of those hundred was something like 0.5%

I guess that makes me incredibly unlucky, since I didn't check the international shipping box and yet ended up with an international match anyway. I could completely understand if I were in some small country with only 2 people participating, but no. I'm in Canada, which has something like 1500 other people signed up. My giftee is in the US, which is slightly cheaper than other countries, but still.. I'm not looking forward to spending twice the suggested gift value just on shipping.

Would it be possible to switch with someone that has a Canadian giftee? Otherwise I'm tempted to send something light and small like.. say, paperclips. Ok, maybe not paperclips, but I could put together a much better gift without the international shipping.

TL;DR - whine, whine, whine.. got screwed by the matching algorithm ignoring my shipping preferences


r/scrooges • • Jun 18 '11

Being given a thoughtless gift irks me more than being shafted.

0 Upvotes

Throwaway because I feel like venting.

I've been participating since the beginning for RG and over time I've noticed that my Santas have gotten more and more careless with their gifts. It honestly looks as though they waited till the last possible second to throw something together. Sure, this may come off as insensitive but I'd rather them not retrieve it at all and show that they don't care instead of getting some gift that was thrown together without any consideration about what my likes and dislikes are. I was blown away during the first and even the second exchange, but lately, it's just looks like something my Santa found on the day of the deadline. Seriously Santas, what the fuck?. Why are you choosing to send something completely useless that I can't use. Especially when everyone of my links, my comments, every possible thing I have outlined says that is not up my alley. Thanks for nothing. This is my last exchange because even when I was unemployed and broke as fuck, I still tried to make sure my giftee got something that they would like and enjoy.


r/scrooges • • Dec 06 '10

Shipping

Thumbnail i.min.us
5 Upvotes

r/scrooges • • Dec 10 '10

I'm pretty sure I'm being shafted. I've decided to bid SS farewell.

0 Upvotes

My info was retrieved exactly once on Dec 1. I've had no contact with my Santa, and obvioulsy no gift has been shipped. I would be astonished if this changes by the 25th.

My giftee, on the other hand, seemed to enjoy what I got him, so at least it hasn't been a complete failure. Of course, for all I know, he could be disappointed as well. It's hard to judge because even rubbish gifts are being praised in the most superlative tones on the gallery. (Edit on reflection: I think that was an unfair statement. I have no business judging what anyone thinks about their gifts. I should have better stated my admittedly feeble point about genuine appreciation being lost in an ocean of superlatives. I did not intend to judge the givers, who have surely put their best effort into selecting their gifts.)

I probably won't participate in another reddit Secret Santa. No disrespect intended to the organizers, but it is just a bit too random. I understand that there is no way they could have prevented scrooges from signing up, but It seems like a fundamental flaw with the secret santa concept. I will be interested to know how many people failed to keep their promises in the final tally.

I've overwritten my profile with fake info since there is no apparent way to delete one's redditgifts.com account. This is not ideal. People should be allowed to leave if they wish. I don't care to be rematched. I'm writing this from a throwaway account for obvious reasons.


r/scrooges • • Dec 24 '19

I should be happy... but I'm still sad (pointless rant)

2 Upvotes

Throwaway account for stupid post by entitled idiot. Please ignore.

Finally got my gift today, I'd say overall, success! I just gotta wait one more day to see what my giftee thinks and that's gonna boost my mood immensely.

But the stupid part of me is still sad. Is it because it's over? Because I have nothing else to anticipate? Who knows.

For context, we don't celebrate christmas, never got to as a kid, and still don't have anyone to celebrate with now (not to mention I haven't really moved out yet anyways.) But I signed up this year because the idea of giving and getting something cool to and from strangers sounded dope. And it is great on paper. Having a list of details- when properly filled out and not demanding- makes shopping for a stranger easier than shopping for actual people. Crafting too! I did a bit of both for my giftee.

By that same logic, I did my best to fill out my interest and notes and made sure to include low budget gift suggestions for the secret santas who have fallen on hard times. I did ask if they could spare my gift expense and send something for my siblings instead- in my head im thinking a stocking type thing for them both to enjoy which wouldve made me happy enough, but include a little about them too in case my ss is a unicorn and decides to send them both something meaningful.

To my ss' credit, they did send a nice pin for my sister (rip my brother didn't get anything but i also had no info for him bc he is in ternage phase and doesnt talk to us like that so I understand) I appreciate the thought, and the gifts were wrapped and pretty!! I have legitimately never received a gift with a bow on it so I have now carefully undone the wrapping and pinned it to my wall because it made me that happy.

Now for the stupidest part. My secret santa, unlike so many of yours here, actually read my profile and interests and didnt shaft me. I got a set of books from one of my favorite series. But I'm still kinda bummed.

The issue is none of them were from the correct series I listed, but rather one of the other numerous spinoff series. I wont pretend I'm reading works of literary genius- these books were serialized and mass produced every few months- the book numbers for the ones I got were late 100s- but this was one of my first series and it means a lot. They arent exactly expensive (one of the books i got even said "Only $1.99" on the front cover lol)

So I know it was easy to accidentally get the books from a different spinoff series... but I said the full name of the correct series and even the issue # I left off on in the notes. They ignored my other suggestions and interests so me thinks they may have been short on cash and opted for the book route- or they had no clue about any of my interests and figured books are easy- which is entirely fair and I'm glad they even bothered to look at my profile. But I made a somewhat exaggerated post to make them feel good about their gifts, knowing im not actually all that excited about the books and may not even read them. And I have to act excited about it to my siblings who probably think I'm an idiot for participating.

On the plus side, I have genuinely been saying I need to read, and this gives me a good excuse, I also went and bought myself a few of the books from the correct series (not that the spinoffs are the worst thing ever. I guess im extra bummed because these spinoffs I find less interesting than even some of the other spinoff series I have read.)

They seem like a genuinely nice person, and it was their first ss like me, so I feel seen, but it's still somewhat disappointing none of them are from the correct series and that they all have some of the lamer plots. When you make as many as hundreds of books, there are bound to be some duds. I just wish I didn't receive all "dud" books.

I still hope they enjoy their christmas. People who actually celebrate should have fun with it. Me? Im just gonna sit in my room and stare at the wrapping I pinned- it's one of maybe 3 gifts in my life that have ever been wrapped so I am a little obsessed with wrapped gifts and I'm just super glad my ss bothered to do that, as most dont.

The time after these holidays is gonna suck because I'm gonna have to do something that will severely strain my relationship with some family members, so I was hoping (don't ever hope for anything specific, that's setting yourself up for disappointment. I am entirely to blame for this.) I might get a little note with some nice words from my ss but no dice.

So anyways, that was my vent about life and ss and basically I'm an entitled little kid who wishes they got to celebrate christmas and give and get nice things (and have a tree and set up lights... ok I wish I got to do everything christmas related but we get to do NONE of it) and have good family dynamics like everyone else. Sorry for wasting your time.

I can't solve the family dynamics part, but perhaps I should do more exchanges next year. Hmmm

*Disclaimer: am not actually a kid, am 18+ which makes me even more pathetic but at least not a ss rule breaker. Dw folks my giftee got tons of effort put into their stuff.


r/scrooges • • Feb 29 '16

I signed up for the snack exchange, and all I got was dried fruit...

1 Upvotes

Using a throwaway account since I actually do enjoy SS and the community as a whole.

This may sound whiney, but my sister had signed up and got her gift. She ended up with nice things such as chocolate, girl scout cookies, and other things.

I got sent three bags of dried fruit, never even once asking for it on my wishlist or even putting it as a thing.

"sweet, salty, and sour" were fine. I did put down potato chips I like and candy bars, etc.

I never ever ONCE put down dried fruit or anything at all. I did post I never tried a lot of it ages ago on Reddit on my main account, but that was a one off discussion.

Really, it was overall just a shitty gift to me and I expected more than being sent dried fruit. I think next time I'll put 'no dried fruit' or something to be clear.

I do know the santa did spent good money on it, but I was just disappointed.


r/scrooges • • Dec 20 '20

This subreddit doesn't fill me with confidence...

1 Upvotes

This is my first year participating, I sent my giftee a well thought out gift based on their interests...I'm going to get banned aren't I?


r/scrooges • • Oct 15 '10

Hey, I fucked up

13 Upvotes

I was really excited for the first secret santa. I had signed up for two people thinking that I'd be able to support that, but I was a little too optimistic about what I could reasonably do, and it all kinda fell apart. I'm sorry theleaderisgood and colonelmustard (I think that's who I was supposed to gift to - my laptop I'd saved the info on broke and never came back from the service folks). Life just wasn't co-operating with me, and between a paycheck getting lost for a week and some other circumstances, I wasn't able to carry out the commitment I'd signed myself into.

Anyway, I didn't mean to no-show when it came time to gift, but I hope that you two aren't too discouraged. If there was some way for me to confirm that those two were the ones I was supposed to gift, I'd be more than happy to try to do something, now. Though my salary's still pretty pitiful, I'm doing a good bit better than I was in December, and I really would like to do a little something for you two.


r/scrooges • • Jun 06 '14

Thank you scrooge for sending me a gift...

4 Upvotes

... 20 days after the deadline, when I told redditgifts that I havent received anything. And not even considering what gift to send, but just cheaply sent the first gift you could find. Giftee knows... because he got the receipt with the ordering date and the date which you last checked his profile.

Sorry, have to express some love for the anonymous redditor that managed to "buy" his package 10 days after the deadline, after making me wait in pure agony for a gift that was supposed to get "lost" in the mail. It "magically" arrived exactly 10 days after he bought it, which was exactly 10 days after the shipping deadline. Guess when I clicked the "no gift" button? Yep, 10 days after the shipping deadline, when he confirmed shipping his imaginary gift.

I put the gift online for all to see, on request I can send a nice picture of the invoice to redditgifts. Scrooge is lucky he did send me something, but he did it in a real scroogy fashion.

EDIT: I found him! I found him! I am confident its this guy, since its linked to a website which is linked to some pictures which in return is linked to a profile on redditgifts which shows the same face with glasses on one of his pictures, and he is from the same region as my SS... I am not going to put any personal information here, but when I look at his history, I feel ashamed. Literally ashamed. He got sacked and let me feel the pleasure of getting sacked too. And that for someone with 79 exchanges on his name! Sorry dude, but that red finger on your profile is not gonna help you now. Great god of the internet, please tell me what I should do?


r/scrooges • • Jan 30 '11

Hey Phrea, Please Confirm or No More RedditGifts For You!‏

2 Upvotes

Ok...

Maybe edit that title of that standard mail a little bit? It's a bit strong.

I did this for my original giftee and I did this for my rematch giftee.

To top it all off, I did this.

As you can see, I did my best.


r/scrooges • • Feb 19 '21

I've figured out Scrooge mc Duck's wealth

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

r/scrooges • • Dec 24 '19

Bad gift? [Update]

4 Upvotes

I got another card from my Santa today with a 10,- gift card for the book store. I didn’t expect this and feel bad about telling Santa that the present wasn’t what I expected. I’ll reply with a card after Christmas. ❤️


r/scrooges • • Oct 03 '16

Deleting your account, the task fron hell.

3 Upvotes

So I've tried to delete my gift account. I've expressed to the admins I'm super angry I spent money on being an elf to get shafted by both the original and rematcher. I wanted to be deleted off the site (because you can't do this yourself ....) And my money back since I just purchased 3 months of elf status for this exchange and it's horrible.

I.am now I'm this horrible cycle of having to contact support at Reddit while the mods send me messages reminding me to.go fuck myself basically. It's not guaranteed you'll get a gift. It's certainly not guaranteed you'll get a gift as an elf. No one has to send you a message it's not required and your rematcher pulled your info (4 weeks ago....) And we don't require a timeline for them to send you things so you can't even delete while this is active. So just wait. The tone in the other emails is even more short and snippy. Like how dare I question the Reddit gifts gods and how dare I expect something on time or a message at least letting me know you exist. How dare I expect that the service you push on everyone all the time as being a "better experience" and allows you to be paired with a "a better gifter" actually result in a gift especially because I paid for it.

So now my account is still active. I'll never get a nice response from Reddit gifts (legit Opus is a dick ) so I'm creating a new Reddit account and deleting all information from gifts and pretending that horrible social experiment that cost me far to much never happened.

Fuck.reddit gifts, don't do it. It's a scam of epic proportions. Just created a gift exchange at your office, school, or try the other regulated services online or honestly save your money and subscribe to a monthly box like Loot Crate or something. This is a giant waste, if not right off the bat than your 2nd, or 3rd and once it starts sucking it doesn't stop and no one supports or cares about it.


r/scrooges • • Dec 21 '17

So... signing up for PLUS or PLUS PLUS doesn't guarantee a non-scrooge santa?

6 Upvotes

I'm concerned since picking out these options guarantees a match from someone who has already participated before. Thinking, a 1 (bad) rating doesn't really guarantee the mod's atleast reviewing or validating the quality of them being in site.

Sorry, a bit salty since I got a pink umbrella which costs cheap. I put too much options and dislikes in my description and genuinely salty how they came up with this.


r/scrooges • • Jul 31 '17

May I just say, thank god for this subreddit!

6 Upvotes

I was so ticked off with the behaviour of my giftees and santas I thought I would burst if I couldn't find somewhere to vent.

In the pen and stationery campaign, one fucker Santa sent me a 50c ink cartridge. 'Oh', he says, 'the pen that goes with it is coming'. Well it never came and when I asked for the tracking number, he suddenly goes dead. See it here:

https://www.redditgifts.com/gallery/gift/last-my-pen-stationery-gift-has-arrived/

Ok, now the funny thing is, I get the same guy as a giftee in the T-shirt exchange. He says he likes Elon Musk so I get him the Musk's autobiography and a SpaceX T-shirt to go with it. Both from Amazon.

Thank god I kept the postal receipt and provided proof of shipping because, of course, he sends no thanks - postage to Mexico is not cheap, no post is made in the gallery, I get emails from the Redditgifts admin and then finally amazon informs me that my gifts have been exchanged for cash credit.

Nice.


r/scrooges • • Sep 26 '13

I'm anything but a teachers pet...

1 Upvotes

....overly introspective & self condemning person...who's looking through all the school supplies the other gifters sent to their teachers & feeling like an a**hole who misunderstood the rules. I could have easily have sent a box of crayons, tissues & hand sanitizer...but nooooo, stupid me had to honor her spirit...and do all sorts of personalized stuff like hand craft a reddit "plaque" and card with a donation to "my" teachers public library. A gift certificate to a teaching website & lifesavers for the class (they work) Ugh, next time I'll buy stupid shit & ship it sans personalized chicken soup for her soul...


r/scrooges • • Jan 02 '18

Disappointed

1 Upvotes

My SS was in constant contact with me. Overly excited about the gift exchange and sent her gift the day she was assigned to me. That being said I don't think there was much time or thought put into the gift itself. It left me feeling slightly insulted as well. All the tags and prices were left on everything. https://www.redditgifts.com/gallery/gift/nice-224/ Still I sent her a nice note thanking her for the gift. I appreciated she participated this year because as I see here that is half the battle. I don't know what I was expecting this being my first year doing this but I won't be doing it again next year. Also I gave my SS a drone he could film with since he is an aspiring film maker and the company screwed up so he ended up getting two for the price of one. lol!


r/scrooges • • Dec 16 '16

Kind of disappointed..

1 Upvotes

[deleted]


r/scrooges • • Dec 22 '19

Bad gift?

7 Upvotes

Hey everyone. I got my “present” yesterday and it’s total crap and I wanted to throw it straight into the bin. I wrote a bad review and sent my Secret Santa a message. Santa replied that it was his first time participating and he didn’t have enough time. I looks like it’s a teenager that participated and didn’t have time and/or money to spend on it. I put a lot of effort into the questionnaire and hoped that I get something cool, nothing expensive but something thoughtful that I could enjoy.

Is there anything else I can do additionally? Should I write the support team a message? Or just leave it with the bad review?

It’s my first exchange and I hoped it all would work out...


r/scrooges • • Dec 09 '10

My SS is just keeping me waiting.....

0 Upvotes

Since Nov. 27th it says they have shipped my gift. Since then no additional info has been given, only Air Mail with no tracking number, and no message from them. Am i being trolled, am i just not patient enough, what do you guys think? (This is my first SS btw)


r/scrooges • • Nov 13 '16

Falsehoods

Thumbnail
imgflip.com
2 Upvotes

r/scrooges • • Dec 09 '10

Official number of scrooges?

3 Upvotes

I know there's still time for people to ship their gifts and I'm still hoping on it. But are there any official statistics on the number of people who registered and the number of people who have and have not yet sent out something? Will this kind of information be released or just kept hidden? I'm sure I'm not the only one interested in this. Thanks.


r/scrooges • • Sep 21 '16

SO glad I found a place to vent! Incoming swear filled rant about this scam!!!!!

3 Upvotes

Honestly think i'm done with this whole thing. I had a SS send me a fucking .99 keychain from Taiwan that took 2 months to reach me, had nothing to do with any of the "fantasy"/"Sci-fi" things I listed in my exchange facts. I sent my giftee a wonderful HP gift set, with wands and pens and books. I was so fucking mad. When I posted it and told the Mods that I found the listening for the 0.99 keychain from the website that sent me the gift they got mad at ME. How dare I "shame" my giftee.... are you fucking kidding me... I had packaging proof it was form the website I sent them the link to. But I got yelled at and not remachted. Against my better judgement I signed up again and had Elf status because I also regifted for the exchange I got shafted on AND during an elf status exchange my santa just never sent me anything AND my re-matcher just never bothered.... SO thanks Reddit Gift exchange i've sent over $100 worth of stuff in 3 exchanges and I get yelled at my mods and dick all. This is just way too much scam and very little pay off. I think that less than 10% of exchange participants post in the gallery so we are seeing a very biased view of how the exchanges are actually going!


r/scrooges • • Dec 23 '19

Very Annoyed, As Usual

14 Upvotes

So of the 10 exchanges I have done, I have gotten some really poor gifts half the time and been shafted once (no rematch). I have gotten a set of wall sticker designed for a four year old (even though I specified no wall decorations), a comic book from a series I don't read even though I, also, specifically said to not send me volumes of any series to err on the side of caution, the list goes on.

This one takes the cake though. I was sent a $20 gift card for amazon. How impersonal can you be . . .? But oh, it doesn't matter. It's the giving anyway. I spent $80 on my giftee and bought them things related directly to their interests. I even stalked their reddit profile and found out we were fans of the same video game and sent them some merch from that fandom.

They posted their reaction to the gift and they didn't even thank me, just a list of "I got this and this." I messaged them if everything was okay with their gifts and they said "you didn't buy me anything on my wish list."

Everything on their wish list was $150+


r/scrooges • • Dec 23 '14

Gift shipment; "Amazon". Actual gift; T shirt

4 Upvotes

SS got me a shirt that has no relation to my likes or dislikes. Strange that it was shipped the same day that redditgifts offered a 50% sale on the same shirt. SS knows they were being cheap, and according to their profile, they're a 12 y/o.