r/scishow • • Aug 23 '24

Bad Science in SciShow’s HRT Video NSFW

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Apr 21 '24

Suggestions Science communicators like SciShow and Neil deGrasse Tyson should rephrase the statement 'As always, more research is needed' as 'As always, more research funding is needed'. The former does not clearly convey or address the "need". NSFW

1 Upvotes

One can always find curious individuals/teams to design and perform research studies. The problem is executive dysfunction and funding.

This applies particularly well to psychiatry and neurology. I think these fields have been stagnant since the beginning of the century.

"A breakthrough treatment for xxx could be around-the-corner" - These claims never materialized in the realm of mental health.


r/scishow • • Aug 10 '24

New presentation format (colors and camera) NSFW

1 Upvotes

Anyone else feel that the new presentation style with the vibrant colors and constant camera changes is jarring? I feel like the show as of late is trying its best to catch my attention, but I find it confrontational and exhausting. I'm here for a chill science news experience, not a constant visual assault. I don't need that to pay attention.


r/scishow • • Nov 11 '22

Why they all talk the same NSFW

4 Upvotes

Has anyone else noticed that all of the sci show hosts talk like hank green? Do they take speaking classes to sound like him?

I’ve noticed it on pretty much every video I’ve watched that they put the same emphasis on words and use the same intonation and rhythm hank green does.

Do they do it on purpose or is it just because they are fans and like how he talks? Idk

Plz help me figure this out these questions wake me up in the middle of the night in a cold sweat.


r/scishow • • Jun 16 '15

How to Break the Internet NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Jul 29 '14

News [News] HIV, Circumcision & The Fight Against AIDS NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Oct 23 '20

Suggestions Japan approves first human-animal embryo experiments NSFW

Thumbnail
nature.com
4 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Oct 13 '16

Leaked Email Reveals Former Astronaut Wanted To Meet With Obama Official About Alien Life NSFW

Thumbnail
huffingtonpost.com
0 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Jul 16 '14

QQs: [QQs:] Why Do We Blush? NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Jul 22 '14

Dose [Dose] Dam Fun Facts About Beavers NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Jul 24 '14

QQs: [QQs:] Why Do Birds Have White And Dark Meat? (And Do We?) NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Jul 22 '14

Dose [Dose] Understanding Trypophobia: The Fear of Holes NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Jul 20 '14

Quiz Show [SciShow Quiz Show] Dr. Lindsey Doe NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Dec 18 '25

Mind Blown NSFW

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Oct 13 '16

The Science of Dank Memes was filled with errors NSFW

5 Upvotes

SciShow is fairly reliable. When they talk about topics, they do a decent amount of research and present verified and vetted claims with a clear understanding of the topics.

The Science of Dank Memes was entirely the opposite. It felt like one of the many unreliable pop-science YouTube videos. (SciShow itself is pop-science but they are generally reliable.)


Because I have nothing better to do with my life and this is the internet...

1:15 "genes competing with others for survival" resulted in the life we see around ourselves. This is Richard Dawkins theory, not the prevailing understanding of evolution. Darwinian evolution does not necessarily focus on competition, and neither does the reality of evolution -- cooperation is often selected for.

1:27 "Those instructions [genes] tell your sell how to create proteins." Genes are also used to create functional RNA which acts as an enzyme on its own; we are finding that this is a huge part of genetics and cellular function.

1:58 "Evolution is driven by the natural selection of genes." This is by Richard Dawkins ideas and, again, not the prevailing understanding.

2:01 "Genes that help you survive and procreate will get passed on and genes that hurt you will die off, or at least become less common." This is demonstrably false. Ignoring semantic errors, there are genes which hurt humans that are continually passed on (e.g. for Tay Sachs'). They go on to talk about cooperation and deal with that end of this, though.

2:30 "One thing that really doesn't make sense is the ridiculous size of our brains." This is a long portion of the video that's just wrong in many ways. Here is the framework of why.

Evolution is not driven by "survival of the fittest;" Darwin never used the term. It was coined by racists, for racist use. Darwin called the driving force "natural selection." It's even in the title of his book. Natural selection refers to the selection of traits that are passed on by their ability to contribute to an adaptation to the environment and desirability in reproductive mate selection. This is what drives evolution.

2:35 "Genetically speaking, music and art and YouTube are probably pointless." Music and art help you increase desirability in reproductive mate selection. Additionally, they can help express and relieve emotions, pass on stories and tales, and train people to think abstractly and symbolically. This stabilizes our mental states, helps reinforce actions and plans, and enables future-based thinking, respectively, along with a lot more. YouTube, along with the others in modern day to some extent, helps you make a living or instruct others, which both help you reproduce. A better informed society is one that's better to live in.

2:38 "My capacity to wonder about my place in the universe is not helping me to make babies." Sure it is. Our curiosity drives us to do incredible things, and that's what this wonder really is. It drives us to develop new technologies that have led to things like computers, phones, rockets, tacked ships, and more.

2:44 "And the fact that I've been able to remember how to do the Macarena since 1993 isn't going to be what helps keep me alive." But it could help you select a mate. If they have similar or dissimilar interests based on the music and dance you like, you can assess some genetic compatibility. Beside that, dances are commonly and obviously used as reproductive selectors across the animal kingdom.

2:51 "Our brains could probably be way smaller and we could be way less intelligent without it being any harder for us to spread our genes at all. In fact, a smaller brain could probably help us spread our genes." This is by far the most egregious statement ever said on SciShow and blatantly contradicts a lot of the philosophy Hank Green has expressed in other videos and media. Even worse, it contradicts memetic theory as described later in the video, which is the whole point of the video.

Neanderthals had a lower brain/body mass ratio than humans did. They were better physically adapted to the cold of northern Europe than humans were. Yet we survived. Our symbolic culture, allowing us to think deeply about the future and how to survive for it, along with our superior tools and our capacity to throw, allowed us to survive better in the cold than this cold-adapted species. Our superior intelligence beat out superior physical capabilities.

Memetic theory works alongside that example of humans adapting better than neanderthals using cultural adaptation, which is quick. Why they would say something so flatly wrong that disagrees with established scientific consensus and a controversial concept they are discussing is beyond me.


That's just under two minutes of the video, and nearly every statement said was wrong for some reason. This was a terrible, sloppy video compared to the normal standards of SciShow.

Some of what they said was from the viewpoint and framework of Memetic theory (I use theory for lack of a better word; it's an unproven hypothesis with validity). That's an okay thing to do when that is the point of the video as long as you clearly establish that is what you are doing. The statements they said were given as though they were just the consensus. Most of their videos do just discuss the consensus, so using that framework without being clear is misleading anyway.

Even worse, many of the statements had no place in the general consensus of the community or memetic theory. They were just wrong.

This sort of thing from a reliable source without any clear distinction is embarrassing and can grossly mislead a lot of people.


r/scishow • • Jul 26 '24

Hank please, don't do the soyjak face. NSFW

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Dec 31 '21

Great Minds Making Reactions Go Faster Since the 1700s | Great Minds: Elizabeth Fulhame NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Dec 08 '19

Compilation Plants Are Way Cooler Than We Give Them Credit For NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Dec 04 '19

Compilation The Coolest Birds on Earth | A SciShow Compilation NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Apr 29 '18

[News] Your Asthma and Allergies Aren't Causing Mental Illness NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/scishow • • May 13 '19

Dose The Bee-Pocalypse is...Fake NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Aug 18 '18

News [News] A Zombie Gene Keeps Elephants from Getting Cancer NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Oct 03 '18

List Show [List Show] 5 Bizarre Aircraft That Pushed the Boundaries of Engineering NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Jun 22 '18

[Quiz Show] Supersonic Giggles and Bat Cigars NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/scishow • • Oct 06 '18

Dose [Dose] The Biggest Volcanic Eruption in Human History NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes