r/scifiwriting • • Sep 01 '20

HELP! Would a 4th dimensional being or higher be capable of interacting with creatures of a lower dimension than itself?

679 Upvotes

I'd assume they could interact with 3D creatures with ease, much like how we interact with 2D drawings. However, I've read scientific articles that state that 2D creatures couldn't see or comprehend 3D beings, so I imagine a similar situation would occur with 3D creatures and 4D creatures.


r/scifiwriting • • Feb 05 '25

DISCUSSION We didn't get robots wrong, we got them totally backward

643 Upvotes

In SF people basically made robots by making neurodivergent humans, which is a problem in and of itself, but it also gave us a huge body of science fiction that has robots completely the opposite of how they actually turned out to be.

Because in SF mostly they made robots and sentient computers by taking humans and then subtracting emotional intelligence.

So you get Commander Data, who is brilliant at math, has perfect recall, but also doesn't understand sarcasm, doesn't get subtext, doesn't understand humor, and so on.

But then we built real AI.

And it turns out that all of that is the exact opposite of how real AI works.

Real AI is GREAT at subtext and humor and sarcasm and emotion and all that. And real AI is also absolutely terrible at the stuff we assumed it would be good at.

Logic? Yeah right, our AI today is no good at logic. Perfect recall? Hardly, it often hallucinates, gets facts wrong, and doesn't remember things properly.

Far from being basically a super intelligent but autistic human, it's more like a really ditzy arts major who can spot subtext a mile away but can't solve simple logic problems.

And if you tried to write an AI like that into any SF you'd run into the problem that it would seem totally out of place and odd.

I will note that as people get experience with robots our expectations change and SF also changes.

In the last season of Mandelorian they ran into some repurposed battle droids and one panicked and ran. It ran smoothly, naturally, it vaulted over things easily, and this all seemed perfectly fine because a modern audience is used to seeing the bots from Boston Dynamics moving fluidly. Even 20 years ago an audience would have rejected the idea of a droid with smooth fluid organic looking movement, the idea of robots as moving stiffly and jerkily was ingrained in pop culture.

So maybe, as people get more used to dealing with GPT, having AI that's bad at logic but good at emotion will seem more natural.


r/scifiwriting • • May 01 '20

TOOLS&ADVICE I can't emphasize how valuable of a resource Isaac Arthur's YouTube channel is for aspiring authors

592 Upvotes

Most users are probably already aware of Isaac Arthur's Youtube channel. For those that don't, it's a (huge) compendium of 15-20 minute videos on a staggeringly wide variety of space and astronomy related concepts. Farming black holes, tidal locked planets, first contact, colonizing Proxima Centauri, O'Neill cylinder, ringworlds, types of interstellar spaceships - you name it, Isaac probably has a video on it. They're informative, enlightening and honestly, truly mind-boggling at times. I've gotten so many ideas just from watching his videos and the best part is that everything he talks about can be applied in a hard sf setting - there is a scientific basis for even the most out-there concepts.

Even if you don'tr write, they're still worth watching simply because of the insanely epic ideas they deal with.


r/scifiwriting • • Aug 19 '25

DISCUSSION My dystopia is no longer a dystopia.

543 Upvotes

A few years ago, I started writing a first contact novel. One of the elements of the story is that the world is becoming more dystopian and fascist. I struggled with some of the characters, who I believed were too unrealistic. I decided that I needed to ramp up their fascistic traits to clarify their ideology without making them mustache-twirling villains.

I just reread my work, and many of the elements that I wrote with the idea that "this could never happen in the real world" are now normal parts of the American Zeitgeist. In the context of current American Politics, my draft is bland at best and boring at worst.

I got a kick out of this revelation.

Anyone else finding that their work is being undermined by reality?

Edit/Update:

First off, I’m really enjoying this conversation. Thanks for that.

I want to clarify that the material I’m talking about is about twenty years old. It was meant to be overtly absurd. The interesting part for me is that ideas I wrote back then, which I considered completely unrealistic, wouldn’t even make low-tier headlines today. Today, these concepts would be bland at best. Dismissed out of hand at worst.

What’s funny is that one commenter took my thoughts about imaginary scenarios two decades old as a direct attack on Trump and then insulted me directly. I never mentioned Trump, but I was overjoyed that my mention of fascism evoked in them a thought of Trump. It feels like they are proving my point about what was formerly absurd now being the norm. My made-up story (at least in concept) is no longer just a narrative; it's a vector for political attack. George Orwell would be delighted by this. Or terrified... Probably terrified.


r/scifiwriting • • Feb 17 '20

Your setting is fine. Ask us what we think about your characters, their motivations, their flaws. Your characters make or break your story, not your setting.

444 Upvotes

r/scifiwriting • • May 17 '25

DISCUSSION Why do people on spaceships rarely wear environmental suits, even depressurized? Especially during combat. This would increase their survivability a lot. Not every hull breach they fall into would be a death sentence on its own.

413 Upvotes

Something that I noticed while expanding my Bohandi is that, in science - fiction, especially like Star Trek or Star Wars, people often do not wear spacesuits when inside their spaceships. Especially in spaceships bigger than one - person fighters. Even during combat. Many times, people died because a hull breach occurred. If they had spacesuits on during combat, depressurized, it would improve their chances of survival greatly. They could be automated to seal off and pressurize when outside pressure drops. It would not be that hard and would give the person a chance at survival. 

Do you think I have a point? Why is it not used, if so?


r/scifiwriting • • Oct 22 '25

DISCUSSION Is there a way to make Aliens losing to us in some way believable?

410 Upvotes

Basically the title. It is such a classic storyline, alien invasion, we get scrappy and find some guerilla way to beat them.

But realistically, in a scenario where humanity is still bound to their home planet, is there any plausible way to have us win a conflict with an interstellar race? Surely the requirements to facilitate organic travel of this nature will render anything we can throw at them useless right?

I genuinely can't for the life of me think of a scenario that sees us win here, that doesn't involve human plot armor.


r/scifiwriting • • Dec 09 '25

DISCUSSION I have an Idea for causality protecting FTL with a cool/dark twist.

363 Upvotes

I have been a little obsessed lately with FTL that protects causality. After a lot of thought I think I came up with something novel and kinda creepy.

Instead of describing how this drive works (it doesn't, it’s fictional). I want to give a fictional timeline of how it could be developed and what the implications are.

FTL year 0 - The Cable:

- Scientists create a one-meter “exotic particle cable” that can transmit photons seemingly instantly. 

- It has low band width and there’s a tiny but measurable error rate. But it is sending information FTL.

FTL year 1 - Scaling Up: 

- The cable is lengthened to a kilometer.

- Entire atoms are transmitted.

- A few atoms go missing or appear extra, but the process is 99.99999% effective.

FTL year 3 - FTL communication:

- Packets of atoms carrying data can now be transmitted reliably enough for communication systems.

FTL year 5 - The Stock Market:

- FTL cables are used for high-speed stock trading.

- But there’s a strange error: The stock prices sent by FTL cable don’t exactly match the light-speed versions.

- It isn't noise, noise can be accounted for. It is just that some of the stock prices are wrong by a few tenths of a cent.
- The cable is still useful, just not 100% reliable.

FTL year 6 - Anomalies:

- Scientists construct a cable stretching half way around the world to examine the anomalies.

- They find that highly chaotic systems like weather are especially prone to this FTL corruption.

FTL year 10 - Moving the cable through itself:

- Researchers realize they can send the cable through itself with some engineering.

- This phenomenon simply looks like the cable suddenly teleporting one cable length away.

- It still has the same momentum (stopped relative to earth), it did not travel through space, it just popped out of existence than back in, five feet to the left.

FTL year 15 - The First FTL Probe: 

- After exhaustive engineering challenges a space probe is combined with the self teleporting cable. 

- By rapidly sending the cable/space probe through itself it exceeds light speed by several orders of magnitude.

FTL year 16 - FTL Mars Probe:  

- The probe is sent to mars, weather data is collected from martian weather stations.

- The probe reverses and returns to earth and relays the weather data before the actual signals arrive from mars.

- The data is detectably different. Wind speeds from the probe read 3.75 knots, the later light speed transmission reads 3.74 knots.

FTL year 25 - A Human rated ship:

- The first human rated FTL ship sets off to explore the solar system. 

- They make it to Neptune in minutes and record a video.

- They send the video with a radio signal, then race home beating the signal by several hours.

- The two videos are almost identical, very slight changes in the voices, the camera pans a few pixels more in one video than the other. The RGB values are slightly off pixel to pixel.

- It is spooky but it's just more FTL corruption artifacts.

FTL year 30 - Alpha Centauri:

- The first interstellar ship is built. 

- The cable drive is thousands of miles long to boost speed. 

- It makes it to Alpha Centauri in under a month.

- The crew pops champagne, records a video, beams the video back to earth with a high powered laser then races home. 

- Four and a half years later they compare the footage. 

- They are not the same. In the light speed footage the captain struggles with the cork, one of the crew mates makes a joke, everyone laughs. 

- In the video from the ship, no such incident occurs and the crew have no memory of it.

FTL year 50 - Colonization:

- First colonization attempt on an earth-like planet 10 light years away. 

- The ship drops off the colonists, they hold an election and elect Bob, narrowly winning over Alice. 

- The ship returns to earth a year later, leaving the colony happy and healthy.

FTL year 51 - Checkup:

- A second ship is sent to check on the colony.

- It finds the colony perished, and the logs say it happened almost a year ago. 

- They return home with the bad news.

FTL year 52 - Conflict: 

- The reports are conflicting.

- In one the colony died almost immediately.

- But in the other, they left them all alive after a year of success. 

- A third expedition is sent.

- They find that the colony is fine and thriving under Alice’s leadership.

FTL year 54 - Checking again: 

- This strange turn of events leads to yet another mission, this one reports a thriving colony under Bob’s leadership.

FTL year 55-60 - Stabilization:

- The colony appears to be fine in all further expeditions.

- Alice is the leader in all subsequent reports.

- The light speed transmission finally arrives indicates that they successfully colonized, Alice was elected and they have been thriving for 10 years.

So what happened?

- What happened to the Bob who won the election and was stressed about his new responsibilities?

- What happened to the dead colonists who wrote video diaries to their loved ones?

- Who are these colonists now?

- Who are the crew who reported the dead colony?

- Where did all these people really come from?

The thing is they are not really traveling faster than light, they are slipping out of reality and back into somewhere close. But there are infinite realities and as they skip more and more they drift more and more. The further you go away the more the drift. 

This means that the crew that left is never the one that returns.

That's why you get conflicting reports, and these reports start to culminate probabilistically. At first the colony was alive or dead depending on the report, but as more missions were sent the probability that they were dead diminished, and the details like the election started to fill in. No info was sent faster than light, only a probability.

I think this adds some really cool story potential. Like an empire trying to rule by probability. Ships coming back with conflicting casualty reports and all kinds of weird things that need to be adjusted for.

People might skip back and forth looking for lost loved ones.

Ships that skip to far might return to a dead earth.

TLDR; You are not traveling faster than light. You are ceasing to exist then reappearing in another reality a few feet to the left. This has some serious and creepy side effects.

PS. I tried to make a better time line but it hasn't gotten much traction. you can read it here but, no worries if you don't want to. It just proves its hard to write.


r/scifiwriting • • Jan 21 '24

DISCUSSION It's just me or does sci fi have became more depressing over the years?

342 Upvotes

I don't feel the same amount of joy and wonder in science fiction anymore, I'm just seeing series after series of the same bland, gray colored, depressig vision of the future and humanity

There are no more daring space adventurers that go to a planet, befriend the local aliens and then fight the big bad shooting their laser guns at them, no, just a corporate hellscape were humans have to live with their worst face.

  • Oh, I wanna be a space adventurer!

No! Space it's mostly empty and devoit of life.

  • I want to ride on my spaceship and explore the galaxy!

No! Spaceships are an expensive piece of equipement, they are the propiety of goverments and corporations, also, faster than light travel it's impossible so each vogaye it's going to last a life time.

  • I can't wait to befriend those aliens!

No! Aliens are strange and unknowable, so far appart from us that any contact besides the ocasional scientiffic curiosity it's meaningless.

  • Can I shoot the big bad with my laser gun?

NO! Lasers are ineffective weapons that use too much energy, use a boring looking gun, besides, the big bad has people more qualiffiec than you under his command, you have no chance to defeat him and even if you do he's the president/the head of an important corporation, so you would be a criminal!

No wonder why everyone wants to be a space pirate or live under a simulation.


r/scifiwriting • • Feb 27 '25

DISCUSSION Why is it a bad idea to take off your helmet on confirmed breathable planets?

325 Upvotes

Specifically I'm referring to the (trope?) of characters in sci-fi media running some quick atmospheric composition check on the alien planet they're on and then taking off their helmets as it's safe to breathe. I've seen so many people eyeroll at these moments as if it's something blatantly obvious and I have my own ideas as to why it's still a good idea to keep your helmet on (easy prevention against alien infections or unexpected poisonous gases). I just want to know concretely why it's a bad idea.


r/scifiwriting • • Jan 04 '21

MISCELLENOUS Hit 10,000 words on my first novel today, feeling good :)

312 Upvotes

I’m 15, going on 16, and this is primarily just to keep me writing regularly, but I’m making progress and having a lot of fun with it. My MC needs to be fleshed out more, but I plan to write a character paper about him soon to give myself more to work with, but all around I’m quite happy with my everything so far. Just happy to hit that first little milestone

Edit: 13,000 :)


r/scifiwriting • • Jan 10 '22

TOOLS&ADVICE The Ultimate Science Fiction Resource Guide

310 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm looking to consolidate an internet's worth of Sci-Fi resources into a wiki for r/scificoncepts or at the very least in this post. If you have a resource that you use often, then pop a link into the comments along with a brief description of what it is and what you use it for.

  • You cannot have a list of best resources without mentioning Science and Futurism with Isaac Arthur and Atomic Rockets. I could honestly write pages about how influential they both are. I'm sure 90% of all your research can be done with these two alone. If you haven't checked them out then I highly recommend it, but I feel like I'm preaching to the choir on this one.

  • Tough SF is a great blog site that has the Atomic Rockets seal of approval (High Praise). It's a great source for hard scifi concepts.

  • Whilst it's not been updated in 5 years, the RocketPunk Manifesto is another great blog that contains amazing hard scifi ideas

  • I've never been one to reinvent the wheel, so here's the Orion's Arm Resource List. It's genuinely an amazing source and I'll probably have some of their links in this post just from how useful they are. It includes a lot of calculators for things like travel times, orbits and gravity. Whilst I think Orion's arm is a great resource, you can tell it's been around a while when half their external links need to use the wayback machine and the other half takes you to websites with a nostalgic 90's design.

  • Orion's Arm Planetary Classifications, This post wasn't in their main resource page but it's a google sheet that goes into extreme detail for how to classify planets. (Not an objective way of doing so but a well thought out one)

  • The Extrasolar Planets Encyclopedia Is the best source for current extrasolar planet discoveries and is updated regularly.

  • Another great encyclopedia is The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction. This site has entries on different science fiction themes, technologies, authours and critics, all of which are beyond useful when researching.

  • Don't know how I stumbled on this site by Courtney Seligmann. It's an astronomy site and has 1000 pages and 18000 images. I mostly use it because it has the best maps of the moon that I've ever found but the rest of the site is a goldmine too. You could spend hours learning about astronomy thanks to this site.

  • An Atlas of the Universe has star maps ranging from 12.5 lightyears to 14 billion lightyears. Although I personally think it's second best to these series of space maps in Atomic Rockets

  • For a more interactive map star map, you can view Nasa's 3d map of stars with exoplanets

  • When I first started out, I used the Future Timeline website as a guideline for my own worldbuilding project. It's a massively helpful resource that tries to predict what will happen in the 21st century and beyond.

  • A sort of sister site is the Mars Colonisation Timeline. As with all predictions, I see this site as a guideline for the colonisation of Mars rather than what will happen

  • If you don't have time to read, watch or play every bit of media out there then I highly reccomend checking out wiki's.

    • Warhammer 40k Lexicanum or the fandom wiki alternative

    • Star Wars' Wookiepedia

    • Star Trek's Memory Alpha and the non-canonical Memory Beta

    • The Halo Wiki

    • The list could go on ad infinitum but the point is that any piece of media with a devout following will have a wiki page attributed to it. The completeness does vary, so it might be worth actually reading, watching or playing the things that interest you.

  • TV tropes as a whole is great for identifying tropes within your work and other media. However, this page on tropes in space has been more than helpful for most things scifi. From these linksyou can find examples of these

These sites are the ones that I use on a semi-regular basis and are the ones that have inspired elements of my novels and worldbuilding.

If there are any sites, Google Sheets, calculators, maps, pictures, resources, anything that you use then please share it. It would be great to have a comprehensive list of the best resources the internet has to offer.


r/scifiwriting • • Aug 25 '26

DISCUSSION So The Martian wouldn't work because perchlorates in Martian regolith would kill Watney's plants and Watney himself.

305 Upvotes

Early in the 2000s, astronomers discovered that Martian soil actually contained a lot of very toxic perchlorates. Weir didn't address the perchlorates problem in The Martian because it wasn't a big deal when he started writing, but now we know Martian soil contains between .5% and 1% perchlorates. Very poisonous to life. How can we Macgyver our way out of this? Here's my solution.

Perchlorates are highly water soluble, so he can just rinse it out of the soil. Problem: he'll need a lot of water and more than he can get out of his hydrazine. So how do we get the perchlorates out of the water so he can reuse it? You could try to precipitate it. Most perchlorates are highy soluble, but potassium perchlorate is very insoluble. He has large amounts of potassium. It's in his urine and it could be in pyrotechnic igniters and in CO2 scrubbers (not the big ones in the hab 'cause they are ISS type LIOH scrubbers). There's also a fuckload of potassium in Martian regolith.

He could simply get the potassium in his perchlorate solution, put it outside until it gets colder, and decant the water, and just throwing away a small amount of wet potassium precipitate.

Unfortunately, the numbers are against him. He would need around 88kg of potassium to leach out 250kg of perchlorates out of the Martian soil (based on 30 tons of soil to cover 160m2 of hab space with a 25cm layer of poop-enriched soil for growing potatoes) and he doesn't have nearly enough. He would need to pee a hundred time the usual volume to get enough urine. He might have a few pyrotechnic igniters but we're talking grams of potassium not kilos. Same goes for the scrubbers, a few keys max. Martian soil has nearly unlimited potassium but it's very dispersed. He would need to set up a primitive mining and extracting operation to get enough. Meaning a dead Watney long before he'd see any usable soil.

Luckily, there's one additional solution! Instead of getting the perchlorates out of the water, get the water out of the perchlorates. A hybrid low pressure (Martian atmosphere) and heat distillation operation would allow him to reuse the water (limiting the amount of water he would need) without needing heaps of potassium. Problem solved.

So while it would change the timeline, it would still be doable.

"But what about the dust storm?"

Yeah yeah, shut up.


r/scifiwriting • • Sep 26 '25

DISCUSSION How would you cool a massive super computer in space?

304 Upvotes

In my story, there is a fleet of massive ships heading through space with a population of about 50,000. While the ships are a democracy and the leaders are human, they are technically guided by a hyper-advanced computer system. It does not make laws or control people (outside of a critical emergency), but it is responsible for everything from avoiding collisions, to powering a child’s night light. It makes probably millions of micro, and macro, decisions daily.

Where I run into a problem, is that a computer this large and complex would require massive amounts of energy, and overheat very quickly. Most computers like this use water to cool down but on a ship like this, water is very valuable. It probably wouldn’t work to have thousands of gallons dedicated to keeping the computer from frying itself.

I considered having it be occasionally exposed to the vacuum of space via depressurized pipelines, but that would cause a loss of energy on a ship that should function as an isolated system as much as possible.

I also considered fans, but that might not be enough at this scale, and wouldn’t be fast enough in an emergency (not to mention making things worse in a fire).

Does anyone have ideas for how to cool down a massive computer in this situation?


r/scifiwriting • • Feb 03 '25

DISCUSSION Sea creatures on another planet are not suitable for human nutrition - looking for a simple explanation why not

293 Upvotes

There is a group of scientists doing research on another planet which may well be human habitable. Most of the life is concentrated in the oceans. The variety of fish-analogues and other aquatic creatures is huge. Unfortunately, they cannot be used for human food.

I need a simple, scientifically solid explanation why not (the real reason is that storywise it should not be too easy to settle on another planet ;) To make it more complicated, there is a family of creatures that are biologically distant enough from the rest to make them edible by humans. Thus chirality of amino acids would not explain why it would be frustrating to go fishing.

EDIT*: thank you all for so many suggestions! It has been truly inspiring to read them. I hope that if someone else has been wondering about similar things they have gained new insight, too.*

What amazes me is how lazy people are: dozens of people never bothered to finish my original post which was seven rows long. In the end I say that the chirality of amino acids would NOT be an explanation here. I lost the count when I was trying to see how many suggested just that. They had just read the first few lines and rushed to write their suggestion like an attention-seeking kid in school "Me! Me! Me! I have the answer!" :) :) :)


r/scifiwriting • • Mar 05 '25

DISCUSSION How to explain why aliens (or humans) won’t just throw ships/rocks at FTL (or very high sublight speeds) toward their enemy planets in science fiction?

285 Upvotes

How to explain why aliens (or humans) won’t just throw ships/rocks at FTL (or very high sublight speeds) toward their enemy planets in science fiction? What kind of defenses/physical properties would be good to justify the necessity of fighting battles for orbital superiority before invasion or planetary bombardment?

I read a lot of times that there is one tactic that would make a lot of normal space battles and planetary invasions useless. That is, to strap an engine to a rock and take a ship and empty it and send it at full speed toward the planet. If you don’t need this planet intact, this will cause much more damage than most bombardments and all, and is much harder to stop. But, if the plot needs that to be impossible but I don’t want to just say that it didnl;t happen, how can I justify aliens, or humans against aliens, not using this tactic? I am especially talking about not doing such things from a distance. Throwing rocks at a planet once you have orbital superiority is another matter and something that can still be allowed. In particular, why would humans and Bohandi not do it against each other, but that’s just a detail and I mean for every scenario (this is just one I am myself considering right now, at this moment). 

Edit: This is specially for defensive wars (humans in this position). Attackers may want to preserve planets they are attacking, but why would defenders simply not do this to the attackers (especially for their planets which location is known for them, since humans do know locations of some Bohandi planets, including all close to Earth, although not their homeworld).

Edit 2: Also, what if (as is in this particular scenario) invaders already have an outpost in the system's Kuiper belt (as did Bohandi on Pluto in this scenario), so rocks/ships at subligh speed would not take years.

Edi 4: Also, while using it against inhabitated planet may be wastefting the planet, what about using it against planets/dwarf planets/asteroids that only have a military installation and nothing more? For example, why would the humans not use this tactic against the Bohandi Pluto base (this is important)?


r/scifiwriting • • Aug 12 '21

DISCUSSION Is there a market/demand for low-stakes, slice of life sci fi?

284 Upvotes

I've been working on a sf story that follows a group of colonists setting up a new home on a distant habitable planet far from Earth. At first, I was going to make it a high stakes space horror kind of thing where they discover some weird Lovecraftian entity that lured them to the planet and their existence turns into a brutal fight for survival.

But as I kept writing, and setting up the atmosphere and focusing on the colonists' day to day lives, I kept thinking...hey, I actually really like this. It's almost comforting to weave this little story about regular people in extraordinary circumstances. So I'm wondering - is there any demand for just this kind of story? Essentially, kind of a melancholy, wistful slice of life narrative about these people, millions and millions of miles away from home, trying to set up a new life for themselves. Dealing with loneliness, homesickness and a spectrum of human emotions, all lost among the vast abyss of the universe. But they find friendship and strength in each other and the hope of a better future for themselves and that keeps them going. My plan is to follow characters over multiple generations (over multiple books maybe) as they turn this fledgling frontier world into a true civilization.

SO yeah really not any serious kind of stakes at all - just regular people living life, with a dose of nostalgic sadness laced with optimism.

Is this something that would potentially have readers within the genre?


r/scifiwriting • • Sep 10 '25

DISCUSSION Do point defense cannons matter if the fragments of the missile they shoot down are still coming towards their target?

280 Upvotes

In naval warfare, a hard kill is when the ciws phalanx guns shoot a missile and explode its warhead, blowing up the missile entirely. A soft kill is when the guns destroy the missiles propulsion system and it falls harmlessly into the sea. A soft kill in space would still leave a large piece of metal traveling thousands of kilometers faster than the target ship heading right towards it. A hard kill might turn most of the missile into plasma, leaving a few fragments left over to pepper the ship.

My question is, how much damage could the left over fragments do?

So unless the ship is in maneuvers, or simply reaching high G accelerations that would turn its crew into goo, I’m not sure that it would be able to dodge the debris

I was watching the expanse and incoming missiles were being shot down within a hundred feet of the Rocinante. Now I know those ships have thick armor, but in space, missiles are traveling much much faster than on Earth.


r/scifiwriting • • Jul 08 '20

MISCELLENOUS I just finished the first draft of my novel after four years of writing and the feeling is surreal

272 Upvotes

I just needed to share this with somebody. After years of writing and a two-year hiatus, I have finally finished the first draft of my sci-fi novel, currently sitting at 44 chapters and 150,000 words. I know I'll have to somehow cut about 50,000 of those words in order for it to be publishable, but hey, it's something! Man, writing that last paragraph felt out of this world - like you're done with it and all fed up, but also don't want to let it go. Anyway, that's all. I'll now proceed to let it sit for a month or so and ready for the first round of editing.


r/scifiwriting • • Mar 19 '20

TOOLS&ADVICE My experience on having my sci-fi debut edited by a Big Five publisher

270 Upvotes

Hey, everyone. I posted this a little while back in r/fantasy, and given the response there I thought some of you would be likewise interested in one writer's editing journey.

My debut space opera noir novel, Stormblood got picked up last year by Gollancz as the first of a trilogy. And, like any other Trad published book, it goes through the rounds of editing. I'd already edited the book thoroughly, with myself, beta readers, my agent. When it ended up in the hands of my editor Gillian Redfearn (who also edits Alastair Reynolds, Joe Abercrombie and Richard K. Morgan) I thought there wouldn't be too much more work to do.

I was very, very wrong.

There's a lot in this industry that isn't always transparent but should be. Many of you may be interested in working with a Big Five editor yourselves one day, so I wanted to provide some insight into the guts and gears of the editing process, the various hoops and cycles a book goes through, and what my personal experience has been in crunching the revisions.

I believe it’s very underestimated how extensive the editing process is when it comes to traditional publishing. We’re not talking about cleaning up typos, chopping away gratuitous sentences and chapters, or even tweaking character arcs. No, we’re talking about digging down into the root canals of the narrative, the bones of what gives a book its identity. Fleshing out the ambiance, the structure, the voice, the style, and using this understanding in context to influence how you approach edits.

It sounds like a mouthful, but it’s necessary to see your work from a different light. And it’s necessary to take that mental stance when editing. It’s so easy to get caught up in the minute, in one chapter, that you don’t take the necessary steps back and look at the book as a whole. That scene has great dialogue, but is it disrupting the pacing? That’s an interesting turn of events, but could it be entirely rewritten to be better? The tricky thing is, it’s not about what’s objectively better. It’s about whether it’s better for your book, your style, your voice. If I wanted to have my book have breakneck pacing from cover to cover, we’d be taking a completely different approach.

So that’s what we did for the first round of edits. In taking a step back and looking at the naked scaffolding of the structure, we realised there needed to be some changes early in the book, in terms of character motivation, relationships and backstory. Which changes the way the entire book, and the main character, comes across. Not in a major way, but significantly enough. And that’s where playing word jenga comes in: because the wrong sentence in the wrong place can get your entire book to come crashing down around your head.

None of this was forced upon me, though. All editorial was a conversation from start to finish. My editor didn't tell me to make structural changes or rewire entire characters: she made suggestions and encouragements to consider the benefits of doing it, and what the end result would be. I'm the one who made the decision. It was never out of my hands.

After we agreed to make the change, my editor worked on the first half of the book to reflect this. This meant tweaking characters, shuffling certain flashback scenes. At this point, I don’t touch anything on a sentence-level, any of the prose. This is all big-picture stuff.

I applied the changes, and sent it back to my editor. My editor then re-edited the first-half of the book again, because she’s a pro, and edited the second half in as a consequence of the changes we made in the first half. Because, if she didn’t, we’d be seeing two very different stories. This is what I meant at the start, about looking at the bare bones of your book.

So I edited the second half again. Tightening characters, adding and removing world-building, checking for continuity, and in some cases, completely re-writing scenes, or the internal mechanics of a scene. This means I change what the characters go about doing in order to complete their goals, whether they accomplish them, what the consequences are. Big-picture stuff that ripples out. As an example, one battle sequence was very run and gun. We retooled it to be about tactics and team co-operation. Another scene had a character try to get information from someone, blowing his cover pretty soon and searching the guy’s place. Instead, I had him remain undercover almost the entire time, slowly up the dread and tension the two characters play verbal cat and mouse, until one breaks.

It’s a hell of a headache, and it’s not easy to take scenes that have written a certain way, been in place, for years, and strip them out and completely retool them, but it’s necessary. And it almost always means a better book.

Then comes my next pass. I make most use of my editor’s comments in this round. Plugging logic gaps, tightening sentences, adding or deleting sentences, making sure all the dialogue is consistent with the characters, chopping away the ugly word clay, fixing up the location of the scene (and moving it, if need be) making adjustments that impact the scene, but nothing else. This is where the book is more or less falling into place. It’s probably the part I enjoy the most, putting the meat on the bone so the plot, story, characters and descriptions read smoothly and consistently.

The next round is where I am now. Fixing up sentence-level structure, word-choice, prose, and descriptions. My editor’s mighty red pen has left it’s mark on every single page, so there’s no getting away from it. It’s tempting to call it purely cosmetics, but my work is first-person, very voice-driven, and the state of the main character absolutely impacts the prose. I don’t care too much about flowery word-choice or elegant descriptions, but I absolutely care about each word sounding like it could come from the protagonist’s mouth. So I make sure my sentences are running smoothly, so a heedlessly complicated word or turn of phrase doesn’t turn into a jolting speed-bump. I ensure the sentences and paragraphs have a nice rhythm and balance to them. I deliberately purge any “flowery” prose, any words that detract from the tone I’m trying to strike, any poorly-timed metaphors. So words like “illuminate” and “sparkle” or any of their relations are chopped out. I’m trying to write sharp, razor-edged prose with a good dose of sarcasm and cynicism when needed. So specific word-choice, and how the words are conveyed, matter.

And then, of course, when all’s said and done, there’s copy edits. So there’s a lot of hours and a lot of work poured into editing a book, both by the editor and author. But here’s the thing about print: it lasts forever. So if a sentence, paragraph, chapter, or even character, is lacking, it’ll be lacking forever. And it’s my debut, and you know what they say about getting one chance to make a first impression. . .

Either way, I hope this was insightful or helpful to you all.


r/scifiwriting • • Oct 10 '25

DISCUSSION Does an empire having a 1000 planets but still wanting more make sense?

251 Upvotes

I was wondering about why a nation with that much territory would want more. Maybe it`s a Putin situation where it invades another because they wanted to join a nation as strong as the invader. Maybe it has a need for resources not available in their planets. Thoughts?


r/scifiwriting • • Jun 20 '21

TOOLS&ADVICE A Technology Checklist for Worldbuilders

250 Upvotes

I have been bouncing back and forth between story, characters, and setting. And I finally decided to focus just on the more technological aspects of my setting, to make sure it feels consistent with each other.

I've been organizing my stuff under a few different headings, and thought it might help you too. I tried to order it from the "bottom-up", but it might be more useful in reverse, as you start from one of the more specialized topics and then fill in the details that serve your concept. (For me, I started heavily from space and politics, and am still working my way backwards.)

GENERAL

  1. ENERGY (Fuels, Generators, Batteries, Distribution)

  2. MATERIALS (Mining, Synthesis, Application; Harder, Lighter, Stronger, Smarter, Larger, Smaller, Warmer)

  3. WORK (Farming, Labor, Robotics, Management, Equipment)

  4. TRANSPORT (Local, Regional, Global; Personal vs Many; Supply Chains, Logistics, Waste)

  5. IMAGING (Farther, Smaller, Clearer, Projections, Holograms, Surveillance, Heat, Biometrics)

  6. BIOTECHNOLOGY (Birth, Sexuality, Disease, Mental Health, Surgery, Drugs, Prosthetics, Genetics, Death)

  7. INFORMATION (Communication, News, Cyberspace, Intellectual Property, Interfaces, Computing, Artificial Intelligence, Simulation)

  8. HABITATS (Urban vs Rural, Home, Work, Commerce, Governance; Frontiers of Space/Oceans/Subterranea)

SPECIALIZED

  1. ECONOMICS (Public vs Private Ownership, Economic Systems, Class, Currency)

  2. POLITICS (Local/National/Global Governance, Voting Systems, Succession Systems, Rights, Equality, Unity)

  3. CULTURE (Art, Music, Games, Literature, Sport, Storytelling, Events, Holidays, Myths, Cyberspace)

  4. ROBOTICS (Vehicles, Exoskeletons, Labor, Data, Warfare)

  5. TRANSHUMANISM (Cybernetics, Robotics, Clones, Genetic Engineering, Artificial Life, Longevity, Mind Transfer)

  6. WARFARE (Soldiers, Smart Weapons, Energy Weapons, Energy Shields, Biochemical Weapons, Stealth, Cryptography, Cyberwarfare, Long Range, Mass Destruction)

  7. SPACE (Detection, Propulsion, Satellites, Speed of Light, Gravity, Asteroid Mining, Terraforming, Defense)

  8. ALIEN LIFE (Detection, Defense, Language, Diplomacy, Uplifting, Hive Minds, Superorganisms)

  9. PARAPSYCHOLOGY (Telepathy, Mind Control, Telekinesis, Pre/Post-Cognition)

  10. ALTERNATE DIMENSIONS (Detection, Travel, Time Travel, Simulated Reality)

I'm interested to see how your world fits in with these headings. Going to post something here myself as an example.


r/scifiwriting • • Jun 24 '21

MISCELLENEOUS The only reason that Earth hasn’t been colonized by crusading aliens are the legends of terrible monsters that roam the planet’s surface. All attempts to colonize the planet have ended in terrible, bloody tragedies. Earth has since been crossed off on their maps. We know those creatures as Dinosaurs

247 Upvotes

r/scifiwriting • • Sep 14 '25

HELP! What believable reason could people still be used in warfare instead of robots?

231 Upvotes

Basically, in a world with advanced robotics and human-equivalent AI, why would human beings still have a presence on the battlefield?

I mean in an actual combat situation too, not just directing drones from a command bunker or ship.

EDIT: Probably should've included it, as it is a pretty important point: the society in question is near-post-scarcity, and the human-equivalent AIs exist in computer brains slightly smaller than a human brain, allowing robots the same mental capabilities as a human.


r/scifiwriting • • Jun 06 '21

TOOLS&ADVICE Something potentially helpful for military sci-fi writers

231 Upvotes

I wrote my first military sci-fi novel when I was in High School. It's a steaming pile of crap and I ended up tossing it, but that's beside the point.

One of the things I usually got caught up on, was thinking of new technologies to introduce into the universe. Many people tend to overlook how fast even modern technology is advancing, yet at the same token forget that much of what we use today are nothing more than upgrades and advancements to existing projects.

My resource for finding inspiration for many things I included in my story was actually the DARPA website itself.

An example (and one that's likely buried since it was years ago) could be the use of Magnesium Nanocomposite for body armor. I expanded upon it to include it as the standard armor system of my universe as a lighter and more resistant material.

https://www.darpa.mil/our-research

Here's a link for you guys. Hope it helps inspire you!