r/scifi • u/[deleted] • Mar 02 '11
r/scifi • u/TotalD78 • Jul 14 '12
A Reboot Of Firefly? Joss And The Science Channel Say “Yes!”
r/scifi • u/thefirstwhistlepig • Apr 30 '26
General Orson Scott Card Seems Xenophobic
I’m listening to the audiobook of Shadow Puppets and I’m struck with the intense irony of how much Card comes across as being quite xenophobic in his anti-Chinese rhetoric. Yes, it’s all in the future, but I don’t think it’s a stretch to read his snide comments as a pointed critique of current Chinese culture, governance, and politics. In describing Han Tzu’s difficulties navigating the Chinese military chain of command, Card might have some fair points about certain structures being ineffective, hidebound, overly bureaucratic and too concerned with etiquette, but it hits me as being overblown and very anti-Communist.
I find his work to be deeply mixed bag, generally speaking. Some of it is brilliant and compelling, and some of it feels very labored and like he’s lost the thread in getting up on his political soapbox about politics, gender, comparisons of cultures, and so on.
It’s sad because I think Speaker for the Dead (in particular) is such a good parable about how fear of “the other” warps our perception of reality, but then there are these places where it feels like he needs to drink some of his own medicine on that front and look beyond the Western-centric viewpoint.
r/scifi • u/artistandattorney • Jul 24 '26
Recommendations I got suckered into reading Dungeon Crawler Carl - Does it get better?
My son went to Barnes & Noble and asked for a recommendation for a new book for my birthday. He told them I was currently reading the Unincorporated Man series (good series) and he asked for something similar. The person he spoke with said I would probably like Dungeon Crawler Carl (DCC). Evidently this person had no idea what hard science fiction was or had never read a book before. I don't like video games and I don't play D&D. DCC is just a combo of D&D and video games. I'm reading the book anyway because my kid got it for me. Does this get any better at all? It is just awful.
r/scifi • u/TheRubyEmperor • May 10 '24
The Expanse. I don’t get it.
I see posts here praising both the show and the books so I thought I would give the show a try. I feel like I’m missing something. I don’t really like any of the characters all that much. Holden is annoying, miller is annoying, Amos is interesting, a few others are also kinda interesting but that’s about it. Earth vs moon vs belt is kinda interesting I guess. Protomolecule is kinda cool so far. Maybe this is just a matter of preference not aligning but it feels like I’m being pranked or something. I’m at season 2 episode 9 am I just not far enough into the story or is it simply not to my taste?
r/scifi • u/ArtisanTacoBandit • Mar 22 '15
How is this not all over Reddit right now! It's Firefly!
r/scifi • u/Alarming_Cry6406 • Dec 14 '24
Dune: Prophecy Review. This is why I'm starting to like series made from movies.
r/scifi • u/grapp • May 22 '13
if you Google "startrek 2" all the visible hits you get are now for Into Darkness instead of wrath of Khan, anybody depressed by that?
r/scifi • u/aonro • Apr 17 '24
Do people really not rate Interstellar that much?
I was watching a video of Neil Degrease Tyson rank his favourite sci-fi movies in a tier list, and he put Interstellar in the same bracket as Gravity. I cant believe this, these two movies are completely different calibres of movie.
Personally I would give it a 10/10.
What are the issues people have with interstellar? Is it the science stuff being wrong? The tesseract bit at the end? The lapses of judgement by the characters?
Please let me know your thoughts!
Edit: seems as if I have gathered quite the crowd here 😂
r/scifi • u/Ed9306 • Sep 18 '23
Gays in space
I love this trope. Growing up a sci fi fan and never seeing that was a bit of a boomer. A bit, cause I never saw sci fi as a romantic-friendly genre nor expected to see that there.
Now, in my 20s I found out I love seeing gays in space. It started with Mass Effect 3, of course, but now we are getting GIS in Foundation, and For All Mankind.
What do you think? Do you know of any books, comics, series with gays in space?
r/scifi • u/MacGrath1994 • May 11 '25
When I shared my “Top 16 Best Movies of 2000” ranking, I received mostly dislikes. One of the comments made fun of me placing TITAN A. E. in the list and here’s my reply on why it’s an underrated cult classic.
r/scifi • u/BowserTattoo • Oct 30 '24
What are your favorite military scifi with leftist politics?
I'm a big fan of The Expanse and DS9, and while I like Honor Harrington and Heinlein, their politics get old for me very fast. I'd love a book recommendation that has Halo style combat but Ursula LeGuin style political philosophy.
Edit: not sure how this post got ratioed with almost 90 comments lol, but thank you so much for your carefully considered recommendations!! Looks like I'm checing out The Culture series first, and some other great ideas next : )
r/scifi • u/KazamaSmokers • Jul 26 '13
"Oblivion" DVD release hits stores. I thought it was a decent flick.
r/scifi • u/Sufficient_Ebb_5694 • Mar 14 '25
I'm bored with the Show DARK.
I got like 5 episodes in and its not holding my attention like I assumed it would based on many people saying it's their favorite show of all time. Do I need to just keep going or is it not for me?
r/scifi • u/Murder_Drone_ • Nov 25 '23
Prometheus is added on Netflix, just rewatched it... its amazing.
This movie gets so much hate for no reason. People say "The characters are dumb" and there are plot holes but idc. People also were disappointed in the direction it took the franchise but idc. I love the alien movies and i love this one. High scifi, androids, humanoid aliens, alien plauge infections, mutations, cryosleep, flamethrowers. I mean this movie kicks ass. The plot is also super unique and even if it fails, really tried to go into a new direction.
r/scifi • u/DavidThi303 • Feb 22 '26
Films I think Interstellar was an awful movie
Before you pile on the hate, please hear me out.
Early in the movie they shoe the documentary footage clearly in the future interviewing people from the time of troubles. They repeat that several times. Ok, good plot device. Except...
They were complaining about the dust, the limited food choices, how difficult life was. If billions, or even millions had died - that would be the main topic in those documentaries. So 15 minutes in you know - the human race survives. All of it. Life is hard for a while but everyone makes it through.
So there's no worries of will they make it, just curiosity as to how. That makes for a boring story.
Second, they show the first launch of the shuttle with the main rockets falling off as it gets the shuttle into orbit. And the shuttle then takes a long trip to another star - and if you slingshot around the sun, that's doable. And then land on a planet. All good to that point.
But then the shuttle takes off from that planet. No main rocket. No boosters. If they were needed to get off earth, they would be needed on subsequent planets.
So totally inconsistent science.
Ok, now that you've read the above, let me have it (although you know I'm right 😊).
TV Tell me I'm not the only one who finds the Orville really mid
It's not that funny, it's not that good at political or social commentary, and waaay too many of the episodes are about the planet of the week being obviously wrong in some way that lets the audience feel better about themselves (at least we let women exist!), and the solutions offered don't seem to fully grasp the reasons why the problems existed in the first place (just turn off your television!)
I've watched the show all the way through Identity parts 1 and 2, which is the thing that most people say is the big turning point, but like so many of the episodes, the twist is so predictable if you've seen even a single episode of Doctor Who.
Should I keep going or should I cut my losses?
r/scifi • u/delitomatoes • Oct 14 '23
The praise for Foundation Season 2 seems insane to me
This has got to be one of the worst shows on TV now, barring the Star Wars TV shows (except for Andor lol)
Too many stories and plots make it unfocused, instead of following one group at a time, they decided to do the Gaal/Hari story which is couched in a dumb mystery box. The Hober story which only comes in in episode 3 and Empire, which is probably the most consistent 'political drama' for a tv show.
Is the show not being discussed? Which means that only Apple TV fans are watching it through and reviewing it?
The writing is wildly inconsistent, there is no sense that people belong in different cultures or personality, a lot of modern day cursing, similar to how nu-Trek and Witcher uses 'Fuck' a lot despite it being millennia in the future, people separated by literal light years and in the case of Gaal, by 100 year cryosleep.
There is so much unnecessary action, which I guess makes it watchable for casual audiences, but puts me to sleep as just another generic 5 min action scene
The set and costume designs also not great, things are dressed up to look cool rather than functional, which in the scheme of things describes the philosophy of the entire show.
I would describe watching the show as just scenes happening one after another with no sense of purpose
r/scifi • u/thestopsign • Jul 23 '26
General LTTP: The Expanse (books) - I am a little disappointed
Tried to avoid any direct plot spoilers, but general warning for the first two books.
I am now two books into The Expanse and have honestly been a little disappointed in the series so far considering the near universal praise for the series. I am a big fan of classical space epics and science fiction (Dune, Foundation, etc) and was kind of expecting that coming in, it was pretty evident early on that would not be the case so I re-adjusted my expectations.
The first two books are very much grounded character focused dramas that take place in a science fiction setting. For Leviathan Wakes, this meant being confined almost entirely to the POVs of Holden and Miller. They are essentially rogue agents acting on the very outskirts of the political sphere and have little insight into the grander machinations of the plot, which means we are stuck with a ground level view of the situation. This puts the focus really on their own individual arcs and frankly I really never found either of them to be that compelling to follow. I think some people like this type of fog-of-war approach to stories but it kind of drained my interest in the setting.
Caliban’s War opens things up a little more and we are given four POVs. From the four, I did find myself really enjoying Avasarala and to a lesser extent Bobbie, but still found Holden and Prax to be a little flat. I became more fond of the Rocinante crew so that was a positive, we got a bit more of the Firefly vibe that was missing from the first book. That said, this whole book kind of feels like a side story. We get a bit more insight into how the UN works from Avasarala and Mars from Bobbie but they still feel a bit unknowable, the villain plot feels VERY thin, and we get just an incremental amount of development on the protomolecule.
Part of what I love from the sci-fi genre is big, sweeping philosophical questions and searching for fundamental human truths like we get from Le Guin or Herbert or Asimov and there is a little of that in The Expanse but I haven’t felt it on an artistic or personal level yet. It all feels a little perfunctory which kind of sums up my thoughts on The Expanse. It just is fine to me, nothing special but not particularly bad. Are there any others out there that feel that way or am I an outlier?
r/scifi • u/cat_with_problems • Nov 16 '25
Recommendations looking for good sci-fi that's NOT like Hyperion
One click. Unknown number of posts crying out in silence. All gone. Redact made it stupid easy to clean up my entire history on Reddit and get my info pulled from data broker sites too.
profit cows weather fall exultant reminiscent upbeat swim melodic cagey
r/scifi • u/Aluhut • Jul 21 '25
Amazon's Blade Runner Show Is Exciting, But Apple TV+'s Upcoming Cyberpunk Series Could Change Sci-Fi TV Forever
r/scifi • u/nopester24 • 5d ago
Print Snowcrash is 1000X better than Neuromancer
Yeah, i said it. Don't get me wrong, Neuromancer is good... but Snowcrash is BETTER in almost every way.
The characters are better, the story plot itself is better, the pacing is MUCH better. The intrigue, the tech, the world of the story, the threat, the language. It's all better in Snowcrash!
The ONLY thing Nueromancer has an edge on is world building. Theres much more detail and richer language. but man... Neuromancer is so B O R I N G.
This is where Snowcrash excels. It's not quite as deep as Neuromancer but you know what? it doesnt have to be. it's deep enough and fun and exciting.
i think that's a big issue with sci-fi these days, t gets too caught up in itself and forgets that it's still supposed to be an ENTERTAINING STORY.
EDIT: Neuromancer gets a lot of street cred for starting the Cyberpunk Genre, and rightfully so. But just because Neromancer did it first, doesn't mean it did it BEST. I think it's been surpassed and people need to admit that.
EDIT 2: Based on the comments i think it's only fair to clarify my original claim. Sayingf "it's better" is very subjective, so i'll be more specific. Snowcrash is a MUCH more entertaining and palatable story than Neuromancer. Neuromancer may have started the genre but Snowcrash made it entertaining.
r/scifi • u/frycook • Dec 17 '10