About 10,000 years ago, a Neolithic culture in the southern Levant known as the Natufians became some of the first nomadic hunter-gatherers to transition towards agriculture. But even before this monumental lifestyle shift, members of the prehistoric community were already crafting symbolic figures from clay. What’s more, archaeologists say more than 150 recently discovered artifacts dating back 11,500 to 15,000 years ago are likely the earliest examples of their kind ever found in the Middle East. Their findings, published today in the journal PLOS One, suggest that even children sometimes had a role in creating these miniatures.
I'm Dean Ammons, author of The Little Girl Who Gave the World Fire: Information Influence and Provenance Framework.
The question is whether a learned capability can persist while the evidence needed to identify its original contributor no longer survives for a particular observer.
The paper separates source admission, causal influence, retained information, recoverable disclosure, historical attribution, allocated contribution and legal entitlement. Those are different targets: success at one does not establish the others.
It gives finite constructions in which a teaching event remains causally consequential across copies while origin information becomes unidentifiable. Independent rediscovery changes the counterfactual, so the framework also distinguishes historical priority from present marginal contribution.
Four mathematical architectures follow: response provenance, feedback admission and containment, generational inheritance tracing, and counterfactual contribution with separately governed payments.
The controlled experiment adapts 256 output coordinates of a pretrained 14-million-parameter transformer over eight randomized synthetic source-assignment blocks. Mean next-token accuracy is 96.09% with source-derived feedback versus 57.81% under matched independent replacement. Evaluation uses new wordings of the same trained keys.
Teacher scores transfer the task behavior to fresh students. With the numerical inputs fixed, making external provenance records available or withholding them leaves the learned student weights identical. That equality is by construction; it does not show a model forgetting an identity it once learned.
The experiment does not establish unseen-key generalization, a deployed-service leakage rate, or reconstruction of an unknown training history. The architectures are mathematical specifications, not claims of deployed attribution products.
What minimum provenance would need to survive a teacher-to-student transfer for an originating contribution to remain identifiable without disclosing confidential source content?
Dean Ammons — Paper III
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24223543
Author disclosure: I wrote the paper. AI-assisted tools supported its preparation and this post's drafting.
Only 76 southern resident killer whales remain, and one of the threats they face is noise from ships passing through their habitat in the Pacific Northwest.
The whales rely on sound to communicate, navigate and hunt salmon, but underwater noise from vessels can interfere with these activities.
Now researchers are testing an AI-powered buoy in the Haro Strait, between the US and Canada. It uses underwater microphones to detect killer whale calls, with the goal of warning nearby ships so they can slow down and reduce noise.
It's a sad day, but at least they caught the decline long enough ago that we aready have breeding populations at the Oregon Zoo so the genes won't be lost.