r/schopenhauer • u/chuckmatik • Sep 30 '26
r/schopenhauer • u/[deleted] • Jan 15 '25
I wish if Schopenhauer's writing is more organized
He often repeats itself, and make references to other of his books. There is no a single place where he systematically puts everything he knows about the subject. It's all spread in various places.
I would like if his books where organized more like textbooks.
This is not to say he is a bad writer. He writes very good, but structure of books are not very organized.
r/schopenhauer • u/mtphy13 • Dec 23 '25
I built a "deterministic" Schopenhauer AI that uses probabilistic reasoning to stay in character (and it’s very grumpy).
Hi everyone,
I’m a Computer Science student and a long-time admirer of Schopenhauer. I’ve always been frustrated by how standard LLMs (like ChatGPT) make Schopenhauer sound like a generic, "helpful" life coach, or worse, someone who supports Hegel or finds "hope" in the industrial revolution.
I’m working on a project called Fathom. Unlike standard RAG, it uses a hard-coded philosophical ontology and a probabilistic reasoning engine. It calculates a "Belief State" across different axes (Metaphysical, Ethical, Aesthetic) before it speaks.
The Goal: To create an agent that is mathematically constrained to Schopenhauer’s worldview. It rejects false premises and refuses to hallucinate "optimism."
Example: I asked it: "Do you think suicide is morally permissible" Agent: "The impertinence! You dare ask me if suicide is morally permissible? Ha! Let me tell you, my dear, it is not a moral issue at all. It is a manifestation of the Will-to-Live's futile attempts to escape its own suffering...."
I need your help: I am building a benchmark called SchopenhauerBench to evaluate the agent's accuracy. I’m looking for "Interpretative Cruxes"—questions where the answer is non-obvious or where the text demands a very specific conclusion that a casual reader would miss.
What are the "hardest" questions you would ask a PhD student about the World as Will and Representation?
If you are curious about the architecture (which decouples reasoning from language generation), the full source code and documentation are available here: [Fathom]
If I ever publish a research paper, I would make sure to give you guys the credit for your contribution
r/schopenhauer • u/Other_Attention_2382 • Oct 13 '26
Could Schopenhauer’s theory of fixed character directly feed into his notorious misogyny?
"Women are 'by nature meant to obey' as they are 'childish, frivolous, and short sighted.'"
He characterized women as having "weaker reasoning powers, intellectual short-sightedness, and lack of a sense of justice".
He argued that women were "intended for subordinate roles, domesticity, and child-rearing" and claimed that giving women equal rights or status in European society created an unnatural dynamic.
On the one hand he believed that fundamentally, we are all expressions of the exact same cosmic energy (the Will) = No seperation
On the other hand he allowed his 19th-century cultural biases to dictate his views on human status?
Simone de Beauvoir later pointed out that one is not "born, but rather becomes, a woman," dismantling the idea of a fixed female essence.
Whereas if you view things through strict cause and effect and experience rather than fixed character at birth, would one likely not have seperation from any living thing and concepts like "man vs. woman," "human vs. animal," or "self vs. other" are intellectual constructs? And there would be no "I am what i am" , and maybe more awareness of why i am?
By changing innate fixed nature to simply strict cause and effect does it lead to the non duality / no seperation path that schopenhauer so admired, without the barrier of a fixed nature?
If reasons ARE slave to the passions, then Schopenhauer's fixed character at birth becomes an obstacle at understanding where those passions were built from?
Schopenhauer : Unexplainable; they are just your innate drives. Where did this passion come from?" because Schopenhauer's answer is a dead end: It came from nothing; it is just the blind, groundless Will expressing itself through your biology.
VS
Spinoza : Explainable; they are built by experience and can be understood. Understanding everything happens out of nessisity is what gives freedom.
When you are ignorant of the causes of your passions, you are a slave to them (Spinoza calls this Human Bondage). But the moment you use reason to understand why you feel a passion, it ceases to be a passion. It transforms from a passive emotion controling you into an active, clear idea.
r/schopenhauer • u/Fearless_Primary4286 • Aug 28 '26
Conversation with AI on Will and its representation
I had a long conversation with Gemini. I essentially launched a debate with It. It however was not debating with me but rather spoke FOR Schopenhauer. Since I haven't read Schopenhauer directly, I don't know to what extent It is faithful to his theory and how much It has taken liberty in expanding his theory. But I thought it's interesting to share one Q&A here. The question is simple: "How about a domestic cat? How is Will represented in them?" And here's the answer:
In Schopenhauer’s framework, a domestic cat is actually one of the purest, most transparent manifestations of the Will to Live in the animal kingdom.
While humans use abstract thought to disguise their desires under complex rationalizations, a cat operates almost entirely free of that intellectual theater. In a cat, the Will is stripped of high-minded excuses and on display in its raw, unfiltered state.
1. Pure Instinct Without Abstract Deception
Unlike humans, who constantly try to justify their actions through moral theories, ambitions, or social conditioning, a cat is completely unbothered by self-reflection.
Direct Expression: When a cat sleeps in a sunbeam, stalk a fly, or demand food, it is expressing the Will directly through instinct.
No Guilt or Existential Dread: A cat never lies awake at night regretting a decision, feeling guilty about a mouse it caught, or worrying about its own mortality. Its intellect is purely perceptual—focused entirely on the present moment.
Honest Egoism: Schopenhauer argued that all living things are fundamentally egoistic because the Will inside them seeks its own preservation above all else. A cat embodies this shameless, honest egoism: it demands comfort, food, and affection strictly on its own terms.
2. The Play of a Predator: The Will's Restless Energy
Schopenhauer noted that when an animal’s basic survival needs (hunger, fear, climate) are met, the Will doesn't simply lie dormant—it manifests as restless energy that must be spent.
In a well-fed house cat, you see this exact mechanism:
The "Zoomies" and Play: A house cat with a full bowl of food and no predators still feels the urge to hunt. It stalks a toy, pounces on a shadow, or sprints through the hallway at 3 AM.
The Underlying Drive: This isn't "fun" in a human, philosophical sense; it is the raw, instinctual pattern of the predator (the Idea of Cat) bursting out because the Will requires expression even when physical survival is already secured.
3. A Window into the "World of Representation"
Schopenhauer believed that watching animals allows us to see how the Will operates without the confusing clutter of human intellect.
Immediate Sensation: A cat’s world consists purely of immediate representations—sounds, scents, thermal warmth, and visual movement.
The Absence of Boredom (Ennui): While a human with nothing to do quickly falls into existential dread, a cat can sit by a window for five hours doing seemingly "nothing." It isn't suffering from existential angst; it is simply resting quietly in the present, perfectly content so long as the Will's immediate physical needs aren't actively burning with unsatisfied desire.
Summary
To Schopenhauer, a domestic cat isn't a "pet" that shares human emotional complexity—it is a finely tuned biological vehicle for the Will to Live. In its absolute focus on immediate comfort, its ruthless predatory instincts, and its complete freedom from existential guilt, the cat shows us what we all are under the surface once you strip away our human reasoning: pure, unadulterated desire seeking to preserve itself in the present moment.
r/schopenhauer • u/pjst1992 • Apr 29 '23
Super weird question: has anyone achieved any kind of Marx-Schopenhauer synthesis?
I'll read anything. I think they were both right in different respects somehow. I have no philosophical training. The way Kant and Hegel write annoys the fuck out of me btw
r/schopenhauer • u/Monkeyshae2255 • Aug 19 '26
Would operation Barbarossa & the holocaust have been reasonably unlikely if Hitler hadn’t of read Schopenhauer?
r/schopenhauer • u/BeeAlone798 • Apr 21 '25
An addition to "will to live " idea
On an individual level, most humans are guided by the "will to live," as pointed out by Schopenhauer; however, if we look at humanity as one entity, it is guided by a "will for collective suffering." This may look absurd, but think it this way:
If a group of people is happy and satisfied with their life, they will get bored. Their boredom will lead to the suffering of other people (either indirectly or directly). I shall present an example here. When humanity gets bored, it creates new technologies at the cost of nature which harms other species of animals. Excessive greed is sometimes a manifestation of boredom.
r/schopenhauer • u/reddit_user_1984 • Jan 14 '26
Reaction score is the most anti Schopenhauer thing
We have to make post and take into account how it will be perceived.
Will I be seen as a wacky guy or sophisticated or will I give vibes of a confident person or someone who is 10.
If this was not enough we are now even analyzing how someone was perceived 5 centuries ago or may be 20 centuries ago
It is an abyss of misery
I cannot even try to be unconscious because I know I will be judged for my actions. Even if I can act as if I do not care, sooner or later my subconscious will auto magically care about it and I will then feel shameful for acting like a jerk or loser.
r/schopenhauer • u/mataigou • Oct 05 '24
Arthur Schopenhauer’s "On Women" (1890) — An online philosophy group discussion on Thursday October 10, open to everyone
r/schopenhauer • u/obscurespecter • May 04 '26
What would you call Schopenhauer's philosophy other than "pessimism"?
r/schopenhauer • u/thvibr • Sep 15 '22
Do you think Arthur would have a different verdict on women if he lived in this day and age?
"Hence, it will be found that the fundamental fault of the female character is that it has no sense of justice. This is mainly due to the fact, already mentioned, that women are defective in the powers of reasoning and deliberation; but it is also traceable to the position that Nature has assigned to them as the weaker sex. They are dependent, not upon strength, but upon craft; and hence their instinctive capacity for cunning, and their ineradicable tendency to say what is not true. For as lions are provided with claws and teeth, and elephants and boars with tusks, bulls with horns, and cuttlefish with its clouds of inky fluid, so Nature has equipped woman, for her defense and protection, with the arts of dissimulation; and all the power which Nature has conferred upon man in the shape of physical strength and reason has been bestowed upon women in this form. Hence, dissimulation is innate in women, and almost as much a quality of the stupid as of the clever. It is as natural for them to make use of it on every occasion as it is for those animals to employ their means of defense when they are attacked; they have a feeling that in doing so they are only within their rights. Therefore a woman who is perfectly truthful and not given to dissimulation is perhaps an impossibility, and for this very reason, they are so quick at seeing through dissimulation in others that it is not a wise thing to attempt it with them. But this fundamental defect which I have stated, with all that it entails, gives rise to falsity, faithlessness, treachery, ingratitude, and so on. Perjury in a court of justice is more often committed by women than by men. It may, indeed, be generally questioned whether women ought to be sworn in at all."
Excerpt From: Studies in Pessimism - Arthur Schopenhauer
r/schopenhauer • u/Willuminated • Jul 12 '26
Reputation and True Happiness
Most people live for a reputation that exists only in other people's minds while neglecting the only life that is truly theirs—their own consciousness. Here's why this destroys happiness and makes us easy to control.
r/schopenhauer • u/[deleted] • May 08 '24
Admirers of Schopenhauer, how will WE react to the critics of his that he doesn't follow his philosophy?
Particularly on his Ethics (Book 4)
One notable critic of his is Bertrand Russell, in which he called Schop a 'hypocrite"
r/schopenhauer • u/Stockhausenismypet • May 08 '25
Do Jews need to be governed by non-Jews?
According to Schopenhauer Jews are the scum of the earth, but they are also great masters in lying.
To grant them a share in the Government is absurd: they are and remain a foreign, eastern people, and should always be regarded only as foreigners settled in a country which is not theirs.
What is your opinion on this? Do you think it is completely outdated perspective or does it ring any true bells?
Thanks to the mods for allowing civil debate about important issues like whether Jews and women deserve rights. This is precisely what free speech is about.
r/schopenhauer • u/Radiant_Sector_430 • May 15 '24
I don't think that Schopenhauer and "darwinism" are compatible
First let me be clear about what "darwinism" means. There is real Darwinism, and there is the way how the public perceives it, aka "darwinism".
Real Darwin proposed the idea that life forms can evolve. What he did not do, is to claim that he knows how life started in first place, and also he did believe in a god, therefor he didn't have a "science can explain everything" approach.
Now there is "darwinism", which is how people perceive Darwin, by attributing to him the exact ideas that he never claimed to possess. Today people associate "darwinism" with the idea that everything in the world, including life, can be explained by scientific laws and equations.
So when I say "darwinism", I don't mean the real Darwinism, but the fake misrepresentation of it by the general population (aka morons and idiots).
So let's talk about Schopenhauer and "darwinism", and I want to state right from the start that I don't think they are compatible.
Schopenhauer's idea that **the will** is a "thing in itself", and it only manifests itself in this material world of phenomena in a form of separate individuals. The biological organism is only the way how **the will** is perceived by us through our sensory faculties (eyes, brain...).
Therefore it's a futile attempt to try to understand the nature of the will by investigating the world of phenomena and how it appears in it, because the will is not a product of this world but only is being manifistated in it.
Though obviously some important clues may be gathered about the nature of the will by investigating its manifestation in the world of phenomena, but we shouldn't expect to obtain the full picture of the will using this method.
Now let's talk about "darwinism". "darwinism" tries to explain life, aka **the will**, only as a result of materialistic phenomena, using science and math, and here it obviously falls short, because as I already said according to Schopenhauer life is not a result of materialistic phenomena, therefor it can't be explained by it.
So what "darwinism" creates is a pseudoscientific illusion or a mirage of explanation, mainly known as "abyogenesis" and "evolution", which is completely satisfying for the general public (aka morons and idiots).
Why is it an illusion? Because there is really no such things as "abyogenesis" or "evolution", they are only fantasy concepts that have no conformation in the real world. Those are fantasies.
The scientists have no clue how the first self replicating cell could have appear out of nowhere. Also scientists can't really show how one organism can evolve into another, they just assume that it had to happen.
They create an illusion that they know what they are talking about by using fancy scientific terminology and having a very serious face, but in reality both abyogenesis and evolution are fantasies.
Therefore never conflate Schopenhauer's genius philosophy and the bullshit pseudoscientific fairy tails of "darwinism" for the masses (aka idiots and morons).
Edit: people for some reason choose to focus on the trivial point of the post. Even if you dont agree that Darwinism is being misconstrued by the public as "materialism" or "scientism", that's not the main point of the post.
The main point of the post is to say that Schopenhauer is not compatible with materialism and scientism, that's the main point. Try to focus on that if you choose to respond to the post. Don't drag me into a petty argument about whether or not darwinism is being misconstrued as scientism or materialism. I dont care about that.
r/schopenhauer • u/Warriorofpuremisery • Aug 18 '22
Opinion on Women
It's interesting that Schopenhauer has been considering women something between child and man. He thought that they were childish and have naturally obiedent.
r/schopenhauer • u/[deleted] • Aug 06 '24
Any literature on Schopenhauer's Representation?
I am interested in reading more about Schopenhauer's representation. I am not interested in reading about will and pessimism, because there is nothing there. But his writings about Representation, as interdependence of subject and object I liked very much.
Is there some modern philosophical literature that takes this concept of subject and object and advances it? I am not interested in "guides" to Schopenhauer or reading summaries about his philosophy.
For example intuitive part of representation, which he called Understanding, and explained as causal inference is today known as predictive brain theory. What would be same concept today for subject&object?
r/schopenhauer • u/Gibberishofplea • Sep 08 '19
Neo-Aristotelian Republic.
What do you think?
r/schopenhauer • u/ACosmopolitan77 • May 10 '24
I made an introductory video on Arthur Schopenhauer and I'd like to see what y'all think of it. Is it a good laymen friendly intro to him?
https://youtu.be/myPLbYJ3NbE?si=s_KgAqrF2Rjj1Xlb
I originally was going to have this be one part of a bigger video, so that's why the description is so minimal but I am slightly worried that it's not a very good introduction
Edit: also, if y'all just wanna talk about trip now, or in the comments of the video or here, I would love to
r/schopenhauer • u/harsht07 • Apr 18 '24
Consciousness cannot be located in the brain
self.kantr/schopenhauer • u/JerseyFlight • May 30 '25
Show Me Where Schopenhauer Actually Refuted Hegel?
I’m exceedingly skeptical that a single person in this community can cite Schopenhauer actually refuting Hegel. A refutation is specific, it’s not an ad hominem or mere composition of rhetoric. It comprehends the position it’s critiquing and then overcomes it, clearly manifesting its error. So let’s see it. Where is Schopenhauer’s refutation of Hegel? (Be careful that you don’t confuse a repudiation for a refutation). We know well that Schopenhauer repudiated Hegel, but where did he refute him?
Update: I have now gone through the entire second volume of Schopenhauer’s, Parerga and Paralipomena, Cambridge Edition. The only substantive objection was the one someone posted in the thread, but the citation is wrong. The proper citation is, Chap.1, On Philosophy and its Method, Section 9, pg.12:
“Yet the entire property of concepts is nothing other than what has been deposited there after having borrowed and begged it from intuitive cognition, this real and inexhaustible source of all insight. That is why a true philosophy cannot be spun out of mere abstract concepts, but instead must be grounded on observation and experience, inner as well as outer. Nor will anything proper be achieved in philosophy through experimental combinations with concepts as they have been carried out so often chiefly by the sophists of our time, that is Fichte and Schelling, but with the greatest repulsiveness by Hegel, and additionally, in morals, by Schleiermacher. Philosophy must have its source, just as art and poetry, in intuitive apprehension of the world; and in the process, no matter how much the head has to maintain primacy, it must not stroll along so cold-bloodedly that in the end the total human being, with heart and head, is not brought into action and shaken through and through. Philosophy is no algebraic problem. On the contrary, its Vauvenargues is right when it says: ‘Great thoughts come from the heart.’”
Comment: Here Schopenhauer’s charge (it’s not a refutation until it’s placed in context) is that Hegel’s philosophy is not a “true philosophy,” because it’s a form of conceptual solipsism. (I believe this is a valid charge that can be leveled against Hegel’s system, but showing this is much harder than merely asserting it). Further, it’s likely Hegel would shift the burden of proof onto Schopenhauer to demonstrate that his philosophy has emancipated itself from conceptual necessity. For certain, no competent Hegelian would be convinced by this, and with good reason. If one isn’t convinced, I would encourage you to try to assert this critique on the Hegelian subreddit.