The Public Prosecutor's Office of Rio appealed the Justice's decision to acquit Paulo Roberto Silva e Souza, leader of Santo Daime and founder of the Céu do Mar Church, in São Conrado, accused of the crimes of sexual rape and psychological abuse by his former assistant, Jessica Nascimento de Sousa. In a 17-page document sent by prosecutor Flávia Abido Alves to the TJ, to which O GLOBO had access, the MP refutes the thesis of "extramarital consensual romance", highlights excerpts from testimonies in court in which the religious leader admits to knowing the devotion of the follower and questions contradictory versions presented by a defense witness who lives in a house ceded by the accused's church.'Violated, exploited, humiliated'
'People think it's wrong, but we're healing': see the lines of the religious leader, according to a former churchgoer of Santo Daime de São Conrado
Another testimony shed out by the MP was that of "spiritual therapy". TO GLOBO, women reported that Paulo Roberto promised to cure them and made attacks that corresponded to deviations of spiritual conduct. One of the victims, the American Maria even turned to a council in Toronto, Canada, to talk about the therapy to which Paulo Roberto referred. She says that she had "back and hips caressed" and that the leader asked "if she wanted more". Months later, she received an email from the accused apologizing and citing "shadows" that haunted him. In the appeal, the MP resumes Paulo Roberto's testimony in court and indicates that he softened in words how the acts took plan:
- In his judicial interrogation, the appellant confirmed the practice, although he tried to soften it with semantic juggling, calling it "experience" instead of "therapy", and claiming that the touches on the breasts would have been "scraping". Even more serious, he confessed that, when carrying out this physical attack, he was full awareness of the "absolute respect and devotion" that the victim had for him, using the pretext to circumvent the moral vigilance of the offended - wrote Flávia Abido Alves in excerpts to which O GLOBO had access.
The appeal appeal details what it classifies as a scientific and mystical method that would have led Jessica to submit to the religious leader and his then boss. According to the Prosecutor's Office at the 11th Criminal Court of the Capital, the defendant would have manipulated psychic vulnerability, the employment relationship and the religious fear of fidelity to obtain continuous sexual advantage, configuring the crimes of sexual rape through fraud and psychological violence against women.
In the document, the prosecutor's office also highlighted the contradictory in the speech of a witness of Paulo Roberto who lives in favor in a house ceded by the church of the religious leader. The MP emphasizes the change of version in the woman's testimonies and indicates that there may be dependence on the accused and co-optation.
The criminal appeal now awaits the formal summons of the religious's defense lawyers for the presentation of the counter-reasons and, after compliance with this procedural stage in the first instance, the case will be referred to the TJ-RJ. In one of its Criminal Chambers, it will go to the final trial of the merits by a college of judges.
Considered by some followers a "rigid and severe godfather", Paulo Roberto aroused fascination and devotion for welcoming and advising those who presented anguish or other difficulties. The psychologist by training is a native of the capital of Rio de Janeiro and, from his youth, was developing his own method. In Daime, over the last decades, he has captivated the faithful from Brazil and the world, among men and women in search of his "blessing". The international respect and recognition he obtained at the head of the brotherhood is also due to his active participation in the legalization of the Ayahuasca drink and in the use of tea for religious ceremonies in Brazil. Outside Brazil, Paulo Roberto became a "churches multiplier" taking the doctrine and its hymns to the United States, visited frequently by the Daymist, as well as Canada and Mexico. He usually says in the sessions that Japan and the Middle East also have followers of the doctrine.
According to the investigations, Jéssica Sousa joined the Céu do Mar Church, in São Conrado, in mid-2015, in search of support for a depression. The church is the first urban aspect of Santo Daime; the first temple was created in the Amazon. In the early years as a church attender in Rio, Jéssica was not close to Paulo Roberto, whom she saw as a "sacred figure" and to whom she owed spiritual obedience. The scenario changed from April 2020, when she began to act as his secretary, accumulating a double relationship of labor and religious subordination.
The prosecution points out that the beginning of abusive conduct occurred on April 13, 2022. Using intimate information provided by the victim in a moment of venting, one of them that of having suffered sexual abuse in childhood, at the age of 11, the religious would have proposed a supposed "bioenergetic therapy" to "unlock traumas". In her testimony to the Justice, transcribed in the appeal, Jessica narrated the internal conflict caused by the initial attack that occurred in the accused's office, reporting that, at that time, she really wanted it to work because it would be very bad to distrust him, thinking that the situation would end soon and that she would not let it happen again, but admitted to having made a mistake and asked to stop when the accused reached her breast.
As the MPRJ points out, paralysis and the lack of energetic physical evidence, elements used by the first instance sentence to justify the acquittal, resulted precisely from the "reverent fear" and the fear of destabilizing the religious community that centralized its social and economic life.
One of the central points supported by the prosecutor's office to determine the reform of the judicial decision also concerns the use of drugs and hallucinogenic substances without any relation to the traditional rituals of Santo Daime.
The prosecution states that Paulo Roberto provided and administered illicit drugs such as LSD, referred to by the parties as "Lucy", and "Pérol", a highly concentrated extract of marijuana for about 97% THC. Psychoactive substances were presented to the victim as therapeutic "awareness expanders" necessary for the spiritual healing process to advance. The Public Prosecutor's Office points out that physical doping served to mitigate the victim's psychological resistance and facilitate abuses, which extended from May 2022 to July 2023.
In telephone reports cautioned in the process and transcribed in the reasons for the appeal, Jessica confronts the defendant about the alleged therapy, stating that that day was to heal from a trauma. Then she says she was more traumatized. Then, Paulo Roberto replied that he discovered "blockades" and therefore proposed an "experience" so that it could come to the fore and be worked on. The Public Prosecutor's Office maintains that the consents received in this interval point to fraud, since the defendant transformed the natural fear of abuse into "spiritual failures" or "attacks of hidden forces" for which the victim himself should apologize.
The MPRJ document also refutes the defense's allegations about letters and affective notes located in the secretary's diary. The promoter maintains that the behavior reflects the psychotherapeutic characteristics known as Trauma-Coerced Attachment.
According to the expert literature above, in the face of cyclical abuses perpetrated by figures of extreme authority and on which their financial and spiritual survival depend, the victim's mind temporarily adheres to utopian idealizations designed by the aggressor as an unconscious defense mechanism. Witnesses of their own defense enrolled in the criminal process, including prominent members of the Daymist congregation, confirmed in justice that traditional healing work and the rituals of doctrine do not involve, under any circumstances, physical touches in intimate areas, bioenergetic massages or the use of external synthetic substances.To demonstrate that the case examined does not constitute an isolated episode, but reflects a sequential predatory behavior, the Public Prosecutor's Office's appeal transcribes judicial testimonies of two other women who report dynamics of identified approaches that occurred in previous decades. In the sentence, Judge Renata Travassos considered the testimonies of the other women "legally irrelevant" for this process.
One of the witnesses was Isabela Maria Augusto de Lima, one of the co-founders of the church in Rio de Janeiro. The prosecutor's office stressed that she declared under the screen of the contradictory to have been the target of the exact same strategy forty years earlier, a discovery in which the defendant found her for her apartment under the pretext of carrying out a "spiritual discharge" and "realignment of energies", coming to groping her shoulders, breasts and genitals. The second rescued report is from 2008, coming from the American witness Maria who psychological expenses, attempted isolation and the same pretext of bioenergetic treatments after trying to escape from the spiritual leader.
Flávia Abido Alves, when recovering testimonies from witnesses in court and including even that of a defense witness, classified Paulo Roberto's practices as "sexual predation" conduct.
- The criminal investigation not only emptied this thesis (of consensual love relationship) but imploded it completely, revealing the total lack of credibility of said witness and revealing a pattern of serial sexual predation perpetrated by the defendant for decades - wrote the prosecutor, in an excerpt to which O GLOBO had access.
For Judge Renata Travassos, the reports emerged in order to corroborate the accusatory thesis, but did not add about the specific relationship between Jéssica and Paulo Roberto, which was the only object of the trial.