r/samharris • • Mar 16 '25

I understand this sub has the politics of r/politics but I will try anyway -- Yes, Mahmoud Khalil deserves to be deported. Mahmoud Khalil does in fact support terrorism

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/samharris • • May 16 '24

Greta Thunberg is to be admired

11 Upvotes

Sam doesn't give her nearly enough credit. When he talks about her, he seems to focus on her seeming somewhat mentally unhealthy, and possibly having Asperger's. She has been publicly open about having both. But having Asperger's is not bad - in this case, it's arguably good - and her mental health status is a result of her knowing about climate risks, and also does not make her wrong.

He also seems not to be aware of how much support she has among climate scientists, and that her knowledge of the science is, for a layperson, over six sigma. DWW had to inform him that her point is for people to listen to scientists, and that scientists have been saying what she is saying.

It's hard to think of a "regular person" (non politician or celebrity, or even including celebrities) who have been bolder on the world stage than Greta. She has accurately accused world leaders of greenwashing and doublespeak almost to their face (maybe even to their face), and has refused to tone down her language even after being invited to speak, because she knows they're trying to use her to improve their own image and won't play along. So, she has not backed down or given in or sidled up or toned it down, but continued to, in the most direct and literal way, speak truth to power. I cannot think of anyone in recent history who has done that in a way that comes even close to the way in which she has done it, man, woman, black, white, rich, poor, old, young- anyone. To do what she's done at such a young age is nothing short of spectacular. If that doesn't warrant huge props, what does? If she doesn't deserve respect for being an unrelenting, truth-telling critic of power and exposer of corruption, who does?

Now, I know that recently Greta has come out against Israel, and I don't agree with her politics. But, that should not overshadow the absolutely amazing positive change she has brought to the world through her climate speeches. While it's yet to be seen what will happen in that arena and we won't be able to run the counterfactual, it could turn out that she has saved the world from a spectacular disaster.

The only thing I can think of is that maybe he doesn't quite grasp the magnitude of the climate threat.


r/samharris • • Jun 12 '25

Making Sense Podcast Holy shit, Sam's business partner is annoying

0 Upvotes

I know it's been said before, but I just wanted to come here to say that I personally find Jaron galling, and want him to go away. I understand that he claims he's playing devil's advocate, but in this most recent episode, it doesn't feel like someone that gets it is offering an opposing opinion, it feels like he's just someone that is missing the point.

He asks about TRT and gets a lackluster response from Sam because it isn't something Sam seems to care about, but instead of dropping it he's insisting they bring on an expert to talk about TRT and Sam is just like, ". . . sure . . ." and that was worthy of an eye roll, but all the Jordan Peterson stuff was physically hard to listen to because I was cringing so hard.

He's insistent that Sam brings this agenda to Jordan's podcast, and even after Sam explains why he doesn't want to do that Jaron just keeps suggesting ways that Sam needs to bring these topics up anyway.

But the cherry on top was the, "I'll always respect Jordan because I saw men cry to him that he saved their lives," that almost made me turn the podcast off 🤮 Jordan Peterson's idiotic pseudo intellectualism might yield good results for some people from time to time, but that is not at all the same thing as having a message that is good for people to hear. Like Sam said, prison might be good for some people, but there are definitely better options out there.

I think Jaron lurks on here, and I'm not trying to hurt his feelings, but I felt Sam and his people should know that I've been a listener for years, and these episodes are turning me off. Maybe start your own podcast if you want to talk about TRT? I'm trying to learn about nuclear proliferation, philosophy, epidemiology, etc. and have Sam explain it to me in a way that I can understand. I don't need to make sense of the phenomenon of middle aged men with low T or to listen to you dick ride dipshits that use big words and speak quickly while actually saying nothing of value to dupe vulnerable morons.


r/samharris • • Nov 05 '25

The Left needs more candidates like Mamdani 😊 Do Sam Harris fans agree?

0 Upvotes

r/samharris • • Jul 22 '25

Philosophy Unpopular opinion: Despite his pro-Trump stances, I like Douglas Murray

0 Upvotes

Despite his pro-Trump stances, I like Douglas Murray..I was first introduced to him in one of Sam's videos and Sam brings him to his channel a lot. I don't like Murray's Pro-Trump stances but I think he's basically right about Islam and the problems in Europe, and he had the balls to speak out against Trump's appeasement policy toward Russia. He is a social conservative which I don't like, but I think it's a shame there aren't more people in the world of political philosophy with a similar view to his


r/samharris • • Dec 09 '23

Sam’s crackpot radar is broken.

0 Upvotes

Sam’s inability to spot kooks is stunning. He has at some point publicly supported, defended, and/or aligned aligned himself with many obviously problematic personalities. This list includes Brett Weinstein, Joe Rogan, Eric Weinstein, Dave Rubin, Sam Bankman-Fried, and more. Why? What explains his massive blind spot?


r/samharris • • Dec 20 '23

Other Sam Harris on Piers Morgan "Gazans are not radicalized by legitimate grievances, but purely by Jihadist extremism."

15 Upvotes

WARNING: Title is NOT a direct quote, its a summary of what he said, get off my azz. If you disagree, then you are arguing in bad faith. He said what he said, its 90% similar.

Trump did not explicitly order people to storm the capitol, but he still get charged for it, why dont you go bark at the court? lol

https://youtu.be/nF6GKYZzS_Q?si=T6civXza3iIfG1lc&t=567

I agree with most of what he said in this video, until this particular point.

Does Sam REALLY believe this? That no Gazans are radicalized by legitimate grievances, especially after the bombing and deaths of family members by the IDF? Decades of harsh occupation policy?

Really? 100% caused by Jihadist mindset and not due to any legitimate grievances? Really Sam? Gazans are just crazy?

I respect Sam for his work on Free will, Religion, Atheism, rationality, etc. But this is HUGELY ignorant and dismissive of him.

He has increasingly more biases, ignorance and blind spots over the years and he keeps digging in, disregarding any valid criticisms. Sam used to be sensitive to valid criticisms and frequently make the necessary adjustment to be correct, but now it feels like he just doesnt care anymore. lol

People have mixed motivations, sure religion can be part of it, may even be most of it, but to say they have no legitimate grievances and only acting on Jihadism, is blatantly untrue.

Do better, Sam.


r/samharris • • Nov 05 '24

Elon musk is a subhuman scumbag and here's a few reasons why

7 Upvotes

This won't come as news to any of you, but I started writing this for someone I know who still reveres Elon and it ended up turning into a whole dossier so I thought I would post it here.

First of all, I can't fathom that Sam was ever 'friends' with him.

He was clearly a self serving money grubbing megalomaniac from the day he was born with a silver spoon up his ass.

Claiming he was born to fairly modest means which seems to contradict the photo of him posing with his fathers Rollys-Royce... a father who admitted that he bankrolled Elon with the profit from his emerald mine scam, and who by many accounts supported Apartheid. He was reportedly bullied relentlessly in school and for good reason- on one occasion he was hospitalized after being thrown down a flight of stairs after he mocked a schoolmate who's father had committed suicide.

He entered the US on a student visa and worked illegally when founding Zip2, which is so well documented he hasn't even tried to deny it. He could still technically have his citizenship revoked (but won't obviously).

Across his career he has at various points taken credit for his colleagues ideas and hard work, and exploited any opportunity to stab them in the back - most notoriously Tesla's original founders Martin Eberhard and Marc Tarpenning.

It is evident that he never actually gave the faintest fuck about the planet, and his promoting of renewables and electric vehicles was purely profit driven.

The 2018 Thai cave rescue is where the fault lines became fissures and he fell from grace in many people's eyes - a grace he should never have been allowed to attain in the first place - as he brashly and fatuously asserted that everyone should step aside and allow him to build a miniature submarine to rescue the trapped children. Upon having his fragile ego bruised he then had the nerve to label one of the rescuers as a pedophile for no apparent reason.

Ever since, Elon musk be the center of attention has become an increasingly petulant, painfully humorless embarrassment across social media, desperate to overcompensate for his childhood bullying and exclusion, by inserting himself into celebrity circles and pop culture drama. He has referred to P Diddy as a good friend, and there's some evidence he was no stranger to Epstein, so you know he knows how to be the lowlife of the party. The only person who seems to find Elon funny is Elon. He presumably screams his own name when he orgasms and gets high on his own supply of flatulence.

This wasn't the first or last time he proposed a ridiculous unfeasible technology. There was of course the time he sabotaged plans for a Californian high speed rail by promising a hyperloop system which he had no intention or ability to build - as it turns out he is ideologically opposed to public transport... which couldn't possibly have to do with his selling of private vehicles, or perhaps it reflects his hatred of mother nature given that public transport leaves a much lighter footprint than electric vehicles at least with their current batteries.

The sordid scumbag claimed to stand for freedom and liberty during the covid lockdowns, but the most cursory level of research and critical thinking will reveal that what cared about was that his factories remained open so production didn't slow... he has consistently waged war against labor unions, imposed deplorable working conditions on employees and transgressed safe labor laws, leading TESLA to attain the unenviable position of having the worst safety record in the industry across consecutive years, and is renowned for being an impulsive, tyrannical leader.

He has compulsively lied about TESLA's capabilities, claiming the vehicles to attain full self driving status by 2018, whilst the reality is that they have yet to achieve this in a safe and reliable manner - a flagrant and dangerous lie leveraged to build hype and boost stock prices. He refused to equip TESLA's with LiDARs purely due to cost, and in doing so has compromised the safety of drivers as their cameras are simply inferior sensor technology.

He also lied about sending ventilators to an under resourced hospital. How low can you go? If billionaires are in a moral limbo contest - as they appear to be - Musk put in one hell of a performance during covid.

Some say he bought Twitter on a whim whilst coked up because he was sick of being restricted when attempting to manipulate crypto and NFTs but most likely he knew the value of owning a major platform of public discourse and influence.

Of course he claimed that his intention was to champion free speech and create a forum for unfettered discourse... then proceeds to immediately silence any who parody him whilst signal boosting those with likeminded views, including unequivocal racism, misogyny, antisemitism and pro fascism, whilst pedalling baseless right wing conspiracies. He rebrands it as X, hence tweets have become Xcrements. X marks despot.

He has pushed disinformation about OpenAI and can't hide his resentment that he isn't at the forefront of the AI revolution, especially after he was declined full control over the company some years prior to the release of GPT.

He is a deadbeat dad of 12 children with 3 partners (including Grimes in a bizarre saga) many of whom are ridiculously names, most of whom hate him, one of whom is a trans woman, who he he believes is infected by the woke mind virus and has said is effectively dead to him. She has accused him of being abusive, absent and kidnapping his children to withhold them from seeing his ex wife.

Despite appearing to support LGBT community in younger years - at least as PR for TESLAs diversity and inclusivity achievements where everyone is invited to be exploited - he has become an emboldened transphobe and won't pass up any opportunity to ridicule the community.

He was once a Tony Stark wannabe tech savior genius, and has completed his devolution into Emperor Palpatine wannabe, brazenly advocating for bigots, warmongering, and puppeteering in the most obvious ways.

His grift drift to conservatives came as no surprise, and there is strategic reason behind his Trump cum guzzling, and now god bothering.

Here was a man who should be considered the antichrist by republicans; an atheist tech bro promoting renewable energy, disrupting traditional industries, automating jobs, implanting mind control chips, in personal correspondence with Putin an enemy of the west, who worked illegally as a South African immigrant. He should be their public enemy number 1.

Thankfully, most republicans have such thick skulls (and thin skin) that all he needed to to do garner their support was attend a few Trump rallies donning a cowboy hat and jumping in the air like a fawning school girl, then claim to have found Jesus. When the axe enters the forest they rest assured that it means well because the handle is one of them... they deserve to be cut down, but they're going to drag the rest of us down with them. Space Karen illegally and unconstitutionally bribed voters to support Trump upon realizing that his propaganda network wasn't influential enough - watch as he faces no consequences.

He likely endorses many of Trumps fascistic, bigoted views, but he also wants lowered taxes (or completely abolished taxes according to Trumps recent lose vowel movements) and knows that many leftists will continue to buy electric vehicles regardless of his antics, and it is the right that he needed to win the favor of.

Of course had any of these braindead conservatives - excuse the tautology - actually read the bible, they would know that Jesus (who likely never actually existed and if he did was a maniacal cult leader) demanded his followers to abandon their families and worldly possessions, and remarked that it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God' Luke 18:25... and Matthew 19:24. But they're too busy flicking past such passages forbidding extramarital affairs, and gluttony, and tattoos and piercings, and shaving of one's beard, and stoning to death disobedient children, and the time God actually advocating for abortion, to the passages that condemn homosexuality and sanction the removal of women's bodily autonomy. If they had ever read the constitution they would realize how unconstitutional Trump and co really are, but it's obvious they only cite these sources when it suits their cause, although many of them are probably unable to comprehend it in any case.

Apart from being degenerates, a primary reason so many public figures such as Joe Rogaine wind up pandering to the right is the realization that they capitalize upon a large audience of credulous fools who are happy to throw money toward anyone who validates their vile views - no integrity or critical thinking necessary. It doesn't matter if it makes no sense or contradicts what you said a few weeks ago. Tell them what they want to hear and they will keep tuning in. It's the easiest money.

Anyhow, Phony stark has never hatched an original idea that hasn't become a trainwreck; from X to Cybertruck - that he has been considered a genius and become the wealthiest man in the world is an indictment on people's stupidity and corruption, not a testament to his brilliance. He's like the evil twin of King Midas, King detritus - everything he touches turns to shit. Figures like Agent orange the bloated fat bastard lying rapist wannabe dictator were known to be self seeking scum from the beginning, but Musk managed to convince the world otherwise for the longest time, which makes it all the more egregious.

To give the devil his due however, some of the technology he promotes is objectively useful, and has caused people to think in the right direction. Space X is at the forefront of some major progress in space travel (thankfully Elon has essentially zero input), TESLA at least served to generate enthusiasm for electric vehicles, Neuralink is promising and a much needed technology, and I have used Starlink in a remote part of Canada which otherwise would have been without any reception - at least his technologies are future focused, even if his politics are seeking to return humanity to the dark ages.

To be continued.


r/samharris • • Sep 29 '25

Has anybody become even more of a Sam fan because of his stance on Israel and refusal to speak to people with opposing views on the matter?

0 Upvotes

It’s very clear from this sub that Sam has lost a lot of fans because of his unwavering support of Israel even as it’s being condemned by pretty much every humanitarian organisation on the planet.

He is also is often criticised for not having the courage to debate his views on what is the big moral question of the age( at least in the west) with any voices that go against his beliefs. Which at this stage is a lot of significant media figures.

All these criticisms are fair but I am assuming there must also be some people that have become fans of Sam( or had their fandom solidified even further) precisely because of his views on Israel and selectiveness in who he does and doesn’t talk to on the matter.


r/samharris • • Feb 07 '25

Is Reddit now trying to suppress anti-Trump discourse?

1 Upvotes

I've noticed as of the last week or so that the trending posts are always sport or pop culture where a month or two back they were largely political

Not only does sport mean nothing while we're in the throes of a fascistic takeover but the posts don’t even have as many upvotes as those calling out the ills of the trump administration, yet I only see those further down the feed

I know Reddit already silenced a few anti-musk sub's recently

With other social media controlled by the broligarchs this place was one of the last forums of free expression and discourse despite all of it's over moderation and hive mind bullshit, and the world would be poorer if it were to fall to these heartless thugs

Not related to Sam but I think it's discussion is well warranted


r/samharris • • Oct 14 '23

I’m truly dejected by the amount of direct/indirect anti-Israel posts/comments all over reddit.

113 Upvotes

The level of ignorance/stupidity/hate on display is disgusting. I’m disappointed in our species and I’m beginning to think we are fated to destroy each other.

I hope it’s AI/bots exaggerating the issue but that would be a depressing reality as well.


r/samharris • • Nov 09 '23

Cuture Wars With all due respect, is this the Sam Harris Subreddit or the Israel-Palestine attack on Octo 7th Subreddit?

0 Upvotes

The Israel-Hamas conflicted started far before any of us were born and will continue after all of us die. What is the point of these "discussions" when the majority of it is upvoting any Israeli talking point, accusing anyone arguing in favor of Palestinians as lacking good faith just because you don't like their views, and accusing any criticism of Israel as being propaganda?

Israel and Palestine are both in a religious war. You're all acting like a bunch of Christian Zionists (it's a political affiliation, look it up if you're too lazy to understand the term) arguing in favor of your holy land interpretation. These people are going to be murdering each other long after any of us are dead over the same religious cruelty and stupidity that has existed in that region for a millennia. What is the point of arguing with people whom you automatically believe lack a "good faith" position on a forum and what the hell does most of this have to do with Sam Harris's views? Most of these discussions are spliced videos, fearmongering accusations of protestors being stupid, and so on. No actual surveys of statistical research showing Palestinian views, no real discussion just hurling the most idiotic accusations and claiming anyone who disagrees with them is automatically a dishonest actor.

This is all really pathetic. Israel is a tiny country. If you all really cared about human rights and believed in the moral landscape, where's the talks of Sudan's civil war or Tibet considering more lives are likely lost in those conflicts? It's just discussion over a tiny country's politics that get blown up in importance due to the religious significance of all three Abrahamic faiths and most responses are uncritical support of the Islamic and Christian sides. The uncriticial japes about it obviously being religiously influenced while categorically refusing to accept that the very basis of Israel is a religious one, their right-wing group led by Netanyahu has an anti-democratic bent, and supports pushing Palestinians out of their homes to put Israeli settlers into them under the legal fact of the "Right of Return" never gets any scrutiny when I bring it up from any of these topics and conversations. Nor the fact the second largest group of Palestinians are Christian Communists who have also conducted suicide bombings in the past against Israel. Obviously, I do not support terrorist organizations like Hamas and Islamic Jihad or any other terrorist group for that matter. That should go without saying, yet conversations now have devolved to the point any pro-Palestinian user is being hounded with demands of condemning Hamas, when they didn't even claim to support them in the first place. None of these conversations have been civil, you're all just shouting at each other, and my own experience the last time I made a topic this month was receiving ad hominem attacks, so much for "A place to discuss Sam Harris and to have difficult conversations with civility."; it should be changed to "A place where Pro-Israelis shout at anything and everything pro-Palestinian with accusations of lacking good faith arguments or promoting videos fearmongering Palestinians, even when specified videos have nothing to do with Sam Harris content at all."

You've all disappointed me. I suppose I shouldn't be surprised fellow atheists could fall so easily into the same religious zealotry as Christian right-wing groups in the US. Arguing "intentions matter" is nonsense because countries usually lie about their intentions. If the so-called moral landscape matters, why is there not more focus on conflicts that have greater loss of human life? If you're all not the equivalent of religious zealots, why the uncritical support for a side that has made it clear with their Nation-State Laws that they've attempted to pass that they clearly don't have enlightenment values as their intended outcome for their country?

But most importantly, why the continued antagonistic arguments about Israel-Palestine instead of focusing on... topics relevant to Sam Harris . . . in a Sam Harris subreddit?


r/samharris • • Nov 20 '24

Cuture Wars Sam's former debate opponent Cenk Uygur sends out the MAGA Bat Signal

0 Upvotes

edit: Holy shit, has this subreddit been overrun by bad actors. Cenk is directly asking to be part of Trump's cabinet. https://cdn.bsky.app/img/feed_thumbnail/plain/did:plc:oloqvkuiie22qabj5m6xg4th/bafkreig4vo2tqffiefzgjsayaffks4mcezlb5ur4n4hr3y54cpuyswghpi@jpeg

He wants to be in charge of the Pentagon. He's praising the open-mindedness of Republicans over Democrats. He's suggesting that Matt Gaetz is not under fire because of his alleged sex crimes, but for the "good bills he proposed." His signaling is abundantly clear in the original tweet I quoted. But to even suggest that he is propagandizing for Republicans is, according to this subreddit's most upvoted comment, the dumbest thing he's ever heard. Amazing:

How detached from reality are you that you think Cenk is right wing propaganda?

That's the dumbest sentence I've ever read. I demand an apology for everyone's eyes that had to read it.

When did this sub be so completely blind and defensive about obvious grifting, and fall in love with these sort of righteously shallow and delusional commenters that offer nothing but insults that don't track with reality? How are so many people blind to what rightwing grift looks like after the examples of Sam's friends and all the Roganverse people: Dave Rubin, Tim Pool, Bret Weinstein, Glenn Greenwald, Elon Musk, Tulsi Gabbard, Ayan Hirsi Ali, Rogan himself, Jimmy Dore...how can anyone miss the pattern? My god.

Original comments on original tweet:

https://x.com/cenkuygur/status/1858896978618511748

When I became a Democrat, it was the more tolerant party. Republicans were run by religious nut jobs and corporate robots. Now, the Democrats are in a lot of ways the less tolerant party.

The least tolerant part is actually the establishment wing of the party that says anyone opposing their anointed leaders is committing heresy. If you try to give constructive criticism of the party to improve it, they drive you from the party while screaming, “He’s not a real Democrat!!”

They hate populists. They have become the corporate robots I couldn’t stand. They hate their base. They insult our intelligence by pretending that the donors are not in charge. They think we should be controlled and learn how to follow orders. And they have no idea how elitist they sound.

I don't think anyone needs to even think about where this guy is headed. It's boiler plate rightwing propaganda. He'll do the "guy on the left criticizing the left" shtick for a while, play the victim, then use the "left has moved so far left that now I'm considered right" move, or something like "the right are now the real populists."

Needless to say, the MAGA cabinet that is about to enter office is the most deranged, vengeful, intolerant pack of corporate cronies the country has ever seen. Could Cenk be any more full of shit? He says it's the democrats that insult its base's intelligence while Trump is in the midst of unveiling his ridiculous clown show cabinet of quacks, reality TV stars, sex traffickers, and otherwise unqualified idiots for the sole purpose of trolling his opposition.

I guess it pays to suck up to the rising oligarchy.


r/samharris • • Nov 07 '23

Harris's recent podcast illustrates his severe ideological limitations on Israel/Gaza

5 Upvotes

As it seemed very few people were addressing the specifics of the actual podcast in the official thread I wanted to highlight the important bits here. The important bits being either claims without receipts, or the substantial moments in which his guest, Graeme Wood, is basically contradicting him, but in a polite way.

  1. Harris claims Israel goes to "painful lengths" to prevent civilian causalities. He cites two things here, the dropping of pamphlets and phone calls. I don't know in what world this would be considered "painful lengths" when civilian causalities are at the worst point they've ever been in many decades and the only resources Israel is currently expending is paper, electricity, and bombs. This strategy fundamentally makes no sense in regards to eliminating Hamas to begin with. How is warning a building it will be bombed because it has Hamas, not going to make Hamas leave the building while they force civilians to stay? How is this an effective strategy to begin with? If the goal is to simply destroy infrastructure, one would have to essentially level the entire city of Gaza to achieve anything of substance, so what exactly is the point of this bombing strategy knowing full well the warnings will ensure Hamas also have time to leave? In a perverse way, the warnings essentially delegitimize the entire purpose of the bombings to begin with. "Painful lengths" would be, to me, using ground forces while create refugee corridors as Harris himself brings up as a possible strategy he heard. Allowing for an increase in Israeli soldier deaths in order to preserve more civilian lives would actually be "painful lengths" - as should be obvious when many pro-Israeli commentors don't want to send soldiers in for this exact reason, and prefer just bombing everything into the ground.

  2. Harris essentially frames the entire conflict and its causes within his wheelhouse of Jihadism. The guest countered this in two ways: Graeme talks about how there were many Hamas just stealing stuff here and there, like taking kids bikes/helmets, etc, and to claim everyone is doing everything in the name of Jihadism is just flatly unknowable. While there are of course many motivated by Jihadism, there are assuredly many that are just pure opportunists. Hamas is an ideological mess compared to other Jihadist groups. They don't have religious requirements, unlike Isis, and are just as happy to recruit angry nationalists or looters/sadists. I don't think one can deny that the environment of Gaza over the past many decades, significantly in part because Israel literally helped cultivate and fund the state of that environment including Hamas (https://theintercept.com/2018/02/19/hamas-israel-palestine-conflict/), is significantly more likely to breed violent behavior, yet Harris would lay this all at the feet of Jihadism disproportionally affecting "otherwise regular" people. Let's be clear, growing up in Gaza is about as unregular as one can get in terms of living a fulfilling life by pretty much any mental health or physical health metric you can think of. Further, the population in general does not think Hamas was given any sort of "mandate" by God to rule their land, so actions or conflicts are unable to be presented as some unquestionable sacred act of Jihad. In fact the majority of the Gazan population would prefer to be ruled by the Palestinian authority. All these points are just to say, framing this entire thing within Jihadism is intentionally, and absurdly, flatting the complexity needed to understand this conflict to any reasonable extent.

  3. Harris claims the barbarity of the attacks should immediately put anyone who is rational on Israel's side concerning who the "bad guy" is, and that student groups, etc, who are seemingly taking the side of Hamas are ethically deranged. However the guest points out that Hamas has attempted to deny the more barbaric attacks, implying Hamas does not want to publicly position itself as a "anything goes to irradiate the Jews" organization. In addition to this, Israel has had a miserable track record of its own in regards to the propaganda machine. Israel uses the same exact "collateral damage" argument for snipers killing children and medical workers and journalists. Snipers. Not big bombs, snipers. (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-47399541 , https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2018/04/israel-arms-embargo-needed-as-military-unlawfully-kills-and-maims-gaza-protesters/ , https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shireen_Abu_Akleh). So students, who assuredly don't know much about this conflict, are essentially having to choose between two forms of propogandists, and choosing the one that has less resources and power. A bad choice, but one that Israel has largely brought upon itself by refusing to own up to literally any wrongdoing unless multiple international entities waste their own resources investigating it themselves to such an extent that Israel has no choice but to own up to it (see Shireen Abu Akleh).

  4. The biggest disagreement came between the two over the phone call. It was obvious that Harris was thinking the phone call would be a slam-dunk argument for how Jihadism grips entire families, and that the whole family is celebrating their son killing Jews. However Graeme has almost the totally opposite opinion. Harris clarifies he knows no Arabic but that it sounded like the family was praising the son because they said some phrases about God. Graeme claims these are in actuality generic phrases due to shock - essentially it would be like a person saying "Oh my God!" and then someone else drawing the conclusion that they must be literally praising God and deeply Christian. Graeme thinks the family is all in shock, not happy, not in fact praising their son, and saying general things about wishing their son was safe at home as they know he's likely going to die. At one point the son talks to a brother about how they are all fulfilling Gods will, and the responses back to him are a continual "What are you talking about?" "What are you saying?" etc. While I also don't know Arabic, I'm significantly more likely to trust Graeme's interpretation of this call as he is an actual journalist. Israel, of course, has framed this phone call in the way Harris reads it. Once again, and example of pick your propoganda.

The bottom line is that Sam is presenting a clearly one-sided view of this entire situation, and is subsequently doing his listeners, and this sub, no favors. He is flattening this incredibly complex subject, and history, into a "Jihad bad, Israel good" narrative, which has the catch on effect of also implying "bombing good, civilian casualty neutral" - which as I made clear above, is quite a perverse ethical claim.

Edit: For those reading this post late and getting depressed it's sitting at 0, the upvote rate is 48%, which I'm pretty happy about even if I won't win internet points.


r/samharris • • Oct 13 '23

The more I learn about the history of Israel the more it becomes clear the Jews are in the right

242 Upvotes

It all started with the defeat of the Ottoman Empire and the British Mandate. At this point, the British owned that land - full stop. Arabs lost the right to that land when they let the Ottoman Empire conquer it. When the Allies defeated the Ottoman Empire that land becomes theirs by right.

Then during the Mandate, Jewish settlers began experiencing racism and violence by Arabs simply for immigrating (which they had every right to do). So the UN comes up with the Partition Plan - which Arabs hated so much they launch a war against Israel and they are then defeated resulting in them losing even more land to the Jews, again you lose a war you don't deserve that land anymore.

Then again in 1967 Arab countries launch a war against Israel and again are defeated, this time Israel gains control of West Bank, Gaza Strip, Sinai Peninsula, and Golan Heights.

You can start to see a trend here.

In 1973 a cowardly surprise attack by Egypt and Syria into Israel who is able to repel them and sue for peace.

Then in the 1990s the Oslo accords, which was an attempt to make peace with the PLO (an organization who literally wanted to eliminate Israel from existence) and establish a two state solution.

Then in 2005 Israel withdrew from Gaza. Instead of the Palestinians taking this opportunity to rejoice and start building a life for themselves, they elected Hamas to run them. That's right, they elected a terrorist group. So of course the mission continues to be "destroy Israel" and not "build a life for ourselves"

Fast forward to today, and we see the largest terrorist attack on Israel and where from? Yup, Gaza - which is exactly the thing they feared leaving occupation in Gaza. So why the fuck would Israel ever consider leaving the West Bank?

When you look at the big picture it becomes so clear. Some Arab nations (especially Palestinians) are not interested in peace. They are only interested in continuing their racist and hate-filled objectives of destroying a nation that has every right to exist.

Palestinians and Arabs nations either need a deep cultural reformation or deal with occupation, because they've tried many times to whip Israel off the face of the Earth.

edit: I expected people to not know the difference between a rightful war and ownership of land. As usual reddit fashion, some people cannot separate concepts, so I'll help.

Engaging in war IS NOT the same as controlling land after you conquer. All of you commenting about "might is right" don't get that concept I guess.

Lastly since, some people think that simply living on the land gives you the fundamental right to the land in perpetuity why are you allowing anyone other than Native Americans to make laws, and control the public land and economy in states like Kansas? At least have an internally consistent countercounter if you are going to criticize a claim.

edit 2:

Unfortunately the more activity this post gets the more it get recommended to children and Leftists outside this sub, who are disgustingly pro-Hamas.


r/samharris • • Oct 10 '24

Episode 386 was refreshing

3 Upvotes

“I imagine that something like 90% of Jews in Israel if they can wave a magic wand they would just leave in peace with their peaceful neighbors” . This summarizes my frustrations with Sam regarding his views on the Middle East conflict. He assumes that overwhelming majority of Israelis desire peaceful coexistence with Palestinians. What I liked in the conversation is Yuval challenging that assumption. Yuval is saying what many respectable anti Zionist like Ilan Pappe, Rashid Khalidi , Gideon Levy,etc have been saying about Israel. (Thankfully, Yuval won’t be accused of antisemitism for this.) The conversation highlighted that Sam seems to lack a full understanding of the situation on the ground and may be driven by emotion or perhaps an overemphasis on Jihad.

Yuval’s explanation of the attitudes of many Israelis, particularly the leadership, echoed Ta-Nehisi Coates’ assessments. Sam needs to realize that today’s Israel is not the Israel of the 1990s. It’s now a country led by extremists, with some leaders who wouldn’t mind seeing the whole Middle East burning.

I won’t go into Sam’s views on ethnic cleansing—it’s clear to anyone who is objective who is morally confused.

This was one of the best and refreshing episodes this past year. However, I suspect in the coming weeks, Sam will invite voices like Douglas Murray, Bari Weiss, or Hughes 🦝 to reaffirm his biases.


r/samharris • • Dec 25 '23

Israel is the only country not allowed to win wars

40 Upvotes

So, yesterday I went to bed, watching one of Netflix's WW2 Documentary.

In July 1943, the Allies decided to bomb Hamburg.

Hamburg was one of the largest cities in Germany. The population of Hamburg, Germany, was estimated to be around 1.2 million people. It involved thousands of tons of explosives and incendiaries, including a mix of explosive bombs and incendiary devices designed to create firestorms.

Death Toll: 35,000 to 40,000 civilians were killed in the bombing of Hamburg.

Then, at Feb 1945, they decided to bomb Dresden.

Dresden was the capital of the German state of Saxony and was known for its cultural and architectural significance. At the time of the Allied bombing, the population in Dresden have been as high as 1.2 million.

In two days, between February 13 and February 15, 1945, just months before the end of the war in Europe, the Allies dropped around 3,900 tons of explosives and incendiaries were dropped on the city.

Death Toll: 25,000 to 35,000 civilians were killed in the bombing of Dresden.

This is just the WW2, I'm not talking about the on-going (!) war between Saudia-Yemen, which the death tolls is close to 1M Civilians, and still counting. Not to talk about the Syrian war, where hundred of thousands of Civilians were butchered, The Iraq civil war, Libya, Afghanistan, etc, which in all of these, the civilians death toll is huge.

Israel is now fighting Hamas, which is a monstrous ISIS like terror organization. *Responding* to the most devastating Massacre in the history, since Israel established. If we take the death toll Hamas is publishing, it's 20k. The IDF assessments which are very credible, and I think it's a minimum assessments, because many Terrorists are dead in a destroyed tunnels underground, is 8-9K Hamas terrorists.

All in All, we're talking about 10-12K Civilians death in Gaza, which is the most complicated, hostile Urban Warfare area in the entire globe!

Conclusion: Israel is the only country not allowed to win wars.


r/samharris • • Mar 12 '19

For every 'Chapo Super User' there is at least 1 White Indentitaran/Nationalist on r/samharris

4 Upvotes

Go ahead, challenge me on this. If you don't want to post names publically I can list them for you on PM.

And yes I'm talking about White identity/Ethno-nat types I'm not even including the sizable JBP, Trump and Tim Pool fanbase here (although there is some overlap).

The Constant talk of this immortal brigade is derailing this sub more than Dave Rubin posts. Ive seen too many bad right wing arguements be justified with 'what has happened to this sub?' or 'Super User Downvote Brigade'. Its possible that maybe, just maybe the argument wasn't all that good to begin with.

Also we have to be careful to keep an eye on the overton window.

A progressive Social Democrat with Hard-on for AOC probably isnt very much in line with Sam Harris' barely Center left 'concerned liberal' outlook.

But they are still miles closer to sam than a jew hating, ethno-nationalist incel who considers Alex Jones a silenced hero.

The market place of ideas is measured in degrees. An interesting and productive conversation can happen between a progressive, a social democrat, and probably even a fiscally conservative libertarian about the best way to advance our economy and ensure the well being of all citizens.

A conversation with any of the above 3 with a neo nazi about why we aren't going to 'secure a white homeland' for 200th time is going to be far less productive.

This sub is good because we have wide range of ideas on here, but it doesn't mean the entire range of ideas are good.


r/samharris • • Sep 07 '26

Sam is so out of touch with the regular young person who’s against American capitalism

0 Upvotes

I was gonna write a long post about all the reasons why. But I just find Sam to be completely out of touch with someone that would support some further left wing ideas. Not everyone who has sympathy with these ideas is fully on board with every proposal of the DSA either. I’m just talking about some of the more energizing movements on the left right now. People like Sam just seem to jot it down like all these people are all in for every single policy on the DSA website. Feels so bad faith in my opinion.

EDIT: Seems like people have some reading comprehension issues. MY POINT IS THAT PEOPLE WHO LIKE MAMDANI ARE NOT IN FAVOR OF EVERY POLICY ON THE DSA WEBSITE. I’m not anti capitalism. I’m a centrist who’s generally in favor of capitalism. I’m very much against what American capitalism and the current administration is doing. My main point is that there’s lots of people energized to vote for democrats and if enough of these people are energized to get out and vote Trump and the Republicans won’t have power anymore. Sam seems to think if we have 15 house members, a mayor and one senator who are in the DSA we’ll start to become communists. And Sam’s main focus seems to be ideas around Israel, and whatever you think about that issue, it’s not going to be a winning issue in 2026 or 2028. I know it’s not Sam’s job to try and elect democrats, but at this point if you listened to his podcast you might be more inclined to vote for someone like Marco Rubio or JD Vance in 2028 over someone like Ossoff, Newsom or Buttigieg


r/samharris • • Feb 28 '21

The Woke Left's Nonsense Claim About Opposition to Political Correctness Being A Straight White Guy Phenomenon

0 Upvotes

Discussions about political correctness rather invariably generate more heat than light and the odds are this will be no exception but I want to get this off my chest. Have you noticed that anytime you get into a debate with a woke person about what you see as the problematic features of political correctness and wokeness, they say something like 'Yes we know to straight white guys, wokeness is the worst thing ever and it's going to bring down civilization. This is what happens when calls for equality sound like oppression to the dominant group.'

Why is this nonsense? Because overwhelmingly surveys show that across categories of age, gender, and race, there is profound and widespread opposition to political correctness. I'll link to it below but this quote comes from a 2018 piece in The Atlantic by Yascha Mounk: "Among the general population, a full 80 percent believe that 'political correctness is a problem in our country.' Even young people are uncomfortable with it, including 74 percent ages 24 to 29, and 79 percent under age 24. On this particular issue, the woke are in a clear minority across all ages." https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2018/10/large-majorities-dislike-political-correctness/572581/

As the 80 percent number suggests, race is not a great factor in predicting opposition to political correctness. Indeed, the number of blacks who thought PC/woke culture was a problem was 75 percent, a modest five percentage points below the nation as a whole. And some of that is surely attributable to opposition to idiots on the Right (yes I said idiots on the Right because there are many and being anti-PC does not= being right-wing) who say if you argue for criminal justice reform to ensure greater racial justice you are 'woke.'

So next time some woke scold tells you you're only objecting to their arguments because you're a bad bad evil white cisgender straight guy, cite the survey data!


r/samharris • • Apr 20 '23

Why is this sub obsessed with trans issues?

12 Upvotes

I really don't get it. What business is it of your what gender people want to live as? Even if some people regret transition and transition back? Why does this sub think this is such and important issue that it comes up nearly every day in one form or another?

Even if you think kids are somehow victims of a conspiracy of doctors who wish them harm (I don't think there's any evidence of this), how many kids are actually being harmed in the worst case scenario? Even if you imagine the worst case scenario, aren't way more kids seriously harmed by a number of other issues, like gun violence, swimming pool deaths, malnutrition, poverty, etc. etc. etc.?

For a subreddit that follows Sam Harris, who himself advocates for effective altruism... I would think that restricting trans healthcare would be near the very bottom of things to concern yourself with if you want to make the world a better place, even if you assumed that nearly everyone taking hormone blockers or getting gender reassignment surgery was being harmed. It's still a very small number of people, yeah?

Can someone please explain the obsession?


r/samharris • • Sep 24 '24

Can Israel do any wrong in the eyes of Sam Harris?

Thumbnail
washingtonpost.com
0 Upvotes

One of the best ways to know if you are ideologically captured is to ask, "is my belief falsifiable?" It seems like Harris is trapped in a mindset of Israel as a righteous enemy of jihad that can do no wrong. What would shake him from this belief?


r/samharris • • May 29 '25

Free Speech Can we filter out the poors from this sub, maybe a “POORS” flair?

0 Upvotes

It seems like an awful lot of poors are complaining about the whole switcheroo on free subs.

I mean, I had a free sub for like 3-4 years until I was like “ya know, maybe I should play something.” And was surprised to see there was a 50% off option for Waking Up. So the past 2(? Maybe 3) years I’ve been paying that. Waking Up is way more worth it vs Making Sense tbh. I was curious about Making Sense, though, and was granted a free account like back in late Feb or March?

It’s one thing to be upset about the pricing. It’s another to start off a thread about it and then continue to list all the reasons why Sam is just sooooo different and unbearable now. It’s ok to be poor, and to say poor things like “I get much more value out of my Netflix (the thing keeping me poor) than I do from Sam Harris. Oh, plus he loves Israel.” Spare me the bullshit.

Anyways, any mention of the new subscription model should be flagged with “POTENTIAL POOR” so we know what’s really grinding OP’s gears.


r/samharris • • Oct 11 '23

Ethics Victims of the hardest hit town of the Hamas attack watching IDF bombings in Gaza - 2014

Post image
0 Upvotes

I know most users here only look the other way when generalizations are made about Muslims and Palestinians in order to excuse, justify or simply shrug off their suffering.

There are multiple examples of Israeli towns having community “hilltop cinema” gatherings to watch their military bomb a city of 2 million, almost half of whom are under 18 years old.

When people here explain WHY Hamas committed this attack, they’re not excusing it or celebrating it, they’re explaining how those people were radicalized, how Israel and the West reacting in the same way they always do changes nothing and why it’ll all happen again and again.

And frankly, I’m pretty sick of seeing lazy arguments that the purposeful murder of 40 kids is a crime against humanity but the “unintentional” murder of 300 kids is just the cost of doing business.

It is factually and intellectually dishonest to claim there Israeli military doesn’t know that there’s a near certainty of civilian casualties every time they level a building and they do it anyway.


r/samharris • • Feb 25 '20

Bernie Sanders looks electable in surveys - but it could be a mirage | Vox

Thumbnail
vox.com
9 Upvotes