r/saltierthancrait • u/[deleted] • Apr 10 '24
Encrusted Rant I still hate that Rogue One acts like the Death Star weakness was a "plot hole"
It was not a "plot hole" that the Death Star had a direct line between the exhaust shaft and the reactor. It was a design flaw. An oversight. A manifestation of the Empire's arrogance. Thematically, it works.
Furthermore, it requires a full-on suicide run against the most powerful weapon the galaxy has ever seen, guarded by turrets, TIE fighters and a hell of a trench to navigate.
Even if you get through all of that, it's basically impossible to land a missile shot. It's an incredibly tiny target that must be hit precisely under the most extreme conditions. The only person able to do it was the space wizard in training who used space magic to do it.
Could they have just put a grate or something on it to block that kind of attempt? Sure. Yeah. But it's just a fun space adventure. It's basically high fantasy where a boy rescues a princess from a tower and shoots a dragon in the heart. Is it a "plot hole" that the dragon wasn't wearing chain mail?
So the idea that they had to build an entire movie explaining that *pushes up glasses* well, actually, it wasn't a plot hole, because you see, Galen Erso, who designed the Death Star but was never mentioned before and will never be mentioned again, intentionally designed a flaw... It's so dumb!
Could they not have done the same premise only not had Galen Erso be the secret messiah who never gets honored because it's an obvious retcon? Could the motivation not have been the Rebels saying "holy shit that looks invincible, we have to get the plans to study it no matter the cost, there has to be a weakness somewhere"? Can you not imagine Cassian Andor saying that in the same tone he discussed finding a weakness in the prison? If anybody could sell the idea that the exhaust weakness was a result of the Empire's arrogance, it's fucking Cassian Andor.
God. All my friends still love this movie and I just fucking hate it. Yeah, yeah, the Vader scene is cool, but it sucks ass that to get there, you've gotta sit through bad characterization, stupid retconning, and Vader making dumbass puns.
/rant
EDIT: I was wrong about Galen making the vent, people pointed out that he designed the chain reaction that gets set off when you blow up the reactor. Fair enough. It's been years since I've seen the movie and misremembered. I still think the movie feels unnecessary to me and I still don't like the idea that we're just adding this turncoat saboteur character who never gets mentioned ever again, but I'm happy to eat crow on that one and say yeah I'm wrong there.
