r/saltierthancrait • • Apr 10 '24

Encrusted Rant I still hate that Rogue One acts like the Death Star weakness was a "plot hole"

86 Upvotes

It was not a "plot hole" that the Death Star had a direct line between the exhaust shaft and the reactor. It was a design flaw. An oversight. A manifestation of the Empire's arrogance. Thematically, it works.

Furthermore, it requires a full-on suicide run against the most powerful weapon the galaxy has ever seen, guarded by turrets, TIE fighters and a hell of a trench to navigate.

Even if you get through all of that, it's basically impossible to land a missile shot. It's an incredibly tiny target that must be hit precisely under the most extreme conditions. The only person able to do it was the space wizard in training who used space magic to do it.

Could they have just put a grate or something on it to block that kind of attempt? Sure. Yeah. But it's just a fun space adventure. It's basically high fantasy where a boy rescues a princess from a tower and shoots a dragon in the heart. Is it a "plot hole" that the dragon wasn't wearing chain mail?

So the idea that they had to build an entire movie explaining that *pushes up glasses* well, actually, it wasn't a plot hole, because you see, Galen Erso, who designed the Death Star but was never mentioned before and will never be mentioned again, intentionally designed a flaw... It's so dumb!

Could they not have done the same premise only not had Galen Erso be the secret messiah who never gets honored because it's an obvious retcon? Could the motivation not have been the Rebels saying "holy shit that looks invincible, we have to get the plans to study it no matter the cost, there has to be a weakness somewhere"? Can you not imagine Cassian Andor saying that in the same tone he discussed finding a weakness in the prison? If anybody could sell the idea that the exhaust weakness was a result of the Empire's arrogance, it's fucking Cassian Andor.

God. All my friends still love this movie and I just fucking hate it. Yeah, yeah, the Vader scene is cool, but it sucks ass that to get there, you've gotta sit through bad characterization, stupid retconning, and Vader making dumbass puns.

/rant

EDIT: I was wrong about Galen making the vent, people pointed out that he designed the chain reaction that gets set off when you blow up the reactor. Fair enough. It's been years since I've seen the movie and misremembered. I still think the movie feels unnecessary to me and I still don't like the idea that we're just adding this turncoat saboteur character who never gets mentioned ever again, but I'm happy to eat crow on that one and say yeah I'm wrong there.


r/saltierthancrait • • Feb 05 '24

Encrusted Rant Rogue One is the most overrated movie in the franchise

0 Upvotes

I remember when it came out, the common sentiment was that the movie was kinda meh with some cool scenes at the end, but kind of a boring story with uninteresting characters.

Now, I see this movie get endlessly circle jerked with comments with hundreds or thousands of upvotes saying it’s the best SV movie since Empire (the disrespect to ROTJ is so tiresome) and some even saying it’s the best Star Wars movie period.

Maybe this is unpopular but I’d rather watch any of the main 6 movies than Rogue One (just ff the Anakin + Padme scenes in AotC). And the prequels aren’t masterpieces but even the biggest prequel fans won’t claim they are, unlike the rogue one fans.

I just don’t get what people like about Rogue One. Sure, it’s better than the garbage sequels but so is everything in Star Wars lol. Andor is actually top quality and it’s everything people claim Rogue One is. Maybe people get them mixed up but it’s shocking how many people think Rogue One is some masterpiece.

EDIT: To make it clear, Rogue One is leagues better than the sequels, but the sequels aren't overrated since they are just bad and most people consider them to be bad except for a few ardent defenders.


r/saltierthancrait • • Aug 30 '23

Encrusted Rant Can we agree the Prequels as a whole weren’t necessarily great?

52 Upvotes

Don’t get me wrong, I very much enjoyed the prequels for what they are and generally they did told a great overall story but execution wise the Phantom Menace & Attack of the Clones just aren’t phenomenal. I struggle to even rewatch AotC because of how awful a lot of the scenes are. TPM is definitely more bearable but Jar Jar & Padme brings it down. Revenge of the Sith corrects a lot of the problems I have however there’s still some bad bits left in though those are very few and far between.

Am I wrong for thinking these films aren’t necessarily great as a whole?


r/saltierthancrait • • May 30 '22

Granular Discussion Why are the two most prominent female characters in recent canon so badly written?

0 Upvotes

Rey and Ahsoka are both awful characters, yet they have dominated the canon stories in terms of screen time and importance for years now.

Why is Disney so awful at creating a well written, sympathetic female lead. These two are both boring, unoriginal characters. One's a complete Mary Sue, while the other is a slightly lesser Mary Sue but a total creator's pet. It's clear the fanbase is sick and tired of both of them.

I'm sad for all the little girls growing up with this franchise. They have no recent female role model to look up to.


r/saltierthancrait • • Feb 02 '22

Encrusted Rant Mando season 2 was TERRIBLE Imo

15 Upvotes

It was basically a collection of backdoor pilots to other shows like: Book of Boba, Ashoka, Luke's jedi Academy etc....

I loved Mando bc it was a show about the background characters of Star Wars, now Mando meets literally every Star Wars character out there. AAGHHHH I hated it...

Sorry I had to get this off my chest


r/saltierthancrait • • Sep 12 '23

Encrusted Rant I think I'm bitter at Disney for causing the Prequels and TCW to be positively viewed

0 Upvotes

I have an impression in my mind, of what Star Wars and the fanbase was like before the Disney purchase. There was a sort of "good Star Wars": mainly the Original Trilogy, with a solid chunk of Expanded Universe material. And then there was George Lucas messing up his franchise... special edition vandalism, the Prequel films, an eyerolling cartoon project that decided Anakin had a teen padawan. The best Star Wars material was coming from projects that George Lucas was kind enough to avoid.

There was also a cosmic sense that... well, someday, George Lucas was going to stop touching Star Wars and messing it up. And when that day came? The assumption was that we would continue getting superior, non-George Star Wars. Things like the silly Prequels and cartoonification would fade away.

That's why there was a sense of anticipation and wonder, when Disney first bought Star Wars. That's probably why The Force Awakens was able to start with, "This will begin to make things right," to approving nods of so many audience members.

It still astounds me that Disney Star Wars was able to go from that high - the release of The Force Awakens - and just crash it into the ground so much more disastrously than anyone could have possibl imagined.

So complete has this disaster been, that the spirit of post-Prequel George Lucas has risen to heights that it never enjoyed before. Because Rey and Finn and Poe and Kylo were so empty, it's now Ahsoka who is becoming the face of Star Wars.

And here we are now. Disney+ doesn't even have the original releases of the Original Trilogy available. The "Filoniverse" of cartoon clones and helicopter sabers is the metric of whether something feels like Star Wars. Watching it all unfold has been like watching two Kaiju monsters - the terrible PrequelGeorge Monster vs. the abominal SequelDisney Monster - swing at each other. And yeah, I guess it's pretty great to see the SequelDisney Monster collapse. I guess.

George Lucas should send an elaborate fruit basket to Kathleen Kennedy. Because he chose her to run his company; she was his last great gift to us. And she has done a tremendous job creating a reality where, for the first time ever, George's late-career travesties are receiving a modicum of respect by comparison.

Onward, Filoni. Onward, Ahsoka. Onward, Hayden Christensen and roger roger and Darth Maul's upper torso and world between worlds and space whale Thrawn vs. Space Aladdin and everything with them.

EDIT: There's another facet. Congratulations to all of you who loved the Prequels and loved TCW, and loved George's contributions in those last years and love his apprentice Filoni. You should also send an elaborate fruit basket to Kathleen Kennedy. Because a decade ago, the things you loved were considered the worst parts of Star Wars. But now, thanks to Disney's disaster, those things are the best hope Star Wars has. You've won.

EDIT 2: Thanks for hearing me out again and responding to me, guys. Believe it or not, this is extremely cathartic.


r/saltierthancrait • • Jan 16 '25

Granular Discussion Say something good Dave filoni did for Star Wars?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/saltierthancrait • • Oct 22 '24

Granular Discussion Does anyone else dislike the homeless clone trooper inclusion?

Post image
511 Upvotes

To me it makes no sense. I get it’s a parallel with vets in our world but the dudes a literal clone of the best bounty hunter in the galaxy. The bad batch from what I understand are turncloak clones and seem to do fine, other clones became instructors in the army. But this guy couldn’t become a Mercenary? A bounty hunter? Some private security job? A bouncer?

Why would he even wear his clone armour anymore?


r/saltierthancrait • • Jan 13 '23

Granular Discussion I still just don´t care about Andor

11 Upvotes

So, when I heard about the show for the first time, I really wasn´t too excited about it due to the main character. Andor was completely fine in Rogue One, but nothing special and he didn´t survive the movie. I just haven´t had a lot of interest in seing him again and thought he wasn´t a good pick for an own show.

Before it aired, I expected less than nothing. A boring, forgettable production at best, but probably just more disrespectful garbage from Disney. However, I was curious for reviews and found out a lot of people seemed to like it. The show continued to get praised with more and more episodes released. I´ve seen it being called the best Star Wars in a long time and still keep coming across positive opinions. So the general perception seems to be more than good enough to give it a try.

At least in theory, but I feel no urge at all to watch it up to this day. Looking back, the Obi Wan series was just more than I could take. It was a cheap, completely unnecessary and disgustingly bad mess that ruined yet another legacy character - it killed off the last bit of actual hope and good will I still had for new Star Wars projects without me quite realizing it at the time. At least right now, Andor is just too little too late.

Do you feel the same or similar? Did u give the show a try despite being sceptical? And if you´ve watched it, did you like it or did you regret your decision?


r/saltierthancrait • • Aug 12 '22

Granular Discussion "The Mandalorian" is not good.

283 Upvotes

It's also not bad. It's mediocre. That said, I really don't understand how this show is so popular. I suspect (I'm sure) that half of the people who like this series like it mainly because of the "cute alien" (I still don't understand how he can be 70, since Yoda has already trained students at 100), and the other half just like the mandalorian armor and fight scenes. Really, this show has nothing to offer. You can watch season one first episodes and season two last episodes and you wouldn't lose anything except fanservice.

And you know, there would be nothing wrong with that, if it weren't for a show called "The Mandalorian" which should seem to be about the Mandalorians. Karen Traviss in the "Republic Commando" novels so wonderfully showed their culture, history and language that it was begging to be shown on the TV. Meanwhile we got some Mandalorians in TCW which were shit, some in Rebels which were also not good and now in the series where the only thing we got was "This is the way" (because who needs Vode An) and that you can't take off a helmet... unless yoy're in another clan, then you can.

I don't know what hurts me more, the fact that we got a simple, unnecessary tv series that could be something wonderful if someone had read the source material at least once, or that many people consider this series to be an absolute masterpiece.

What do you think about it?


r/saltierthancrait • • May 02 '24

Granular Discussion Is Obiwan worth watching?

0 Upvotes

Should I consider this show canon?

I didn’t watch it yet, but now it’s available in Blu-ray and wondering if I should get it or not. I plan to buy Andor because I loved Rogue One.

So far I love the Prequel, Solo, Rogue One and the Original trilogy, so for me it’s what’s canon in term of movies. I started watching Mando and love it so far.

I heard bad things about The Book of Boba Fett and Ahsoka too.

I’m a bit lost about what’s should be forgotten and what’s worth watching.

Thank you!

Edit: It’s the best things I’ve found:

https://youtu.be/JfovZj-rmck?si=QDF-lNeVZ4mw1twD

https://youtu.be/m4CMNHefNrU?si=Js0mPoSeEU3Anl6C


r/saltierthancrait • • Dec 30 '21

Encrusted Rant Let's be honest...Book of Boba is a subpar YouTube Fan Film

26 Upvotes

I could absolutely spend hours dissecting a lot of what’s wrong with the new rush of Star Wars content (games/comics/books/etc), and how it absolutely lacks the vibe and genuine creativity/quality that captivated us with the Original Trilogy and 90’s LucasArts Games but that’s for a different post/video series. Let’s focus on this dud that just dropped…

Book of Boba, or “How I Created A Show To Appease Action Figure Fantasies” was even worse than the “uh oh” vibes I got from the trailer. I have to admit the panic and claustrophobia of being trapped in the Sarlacc and escaping was actually an awesome scene, but after that it was all downhill.

This show, as well as many episodes of The Mandalorian reeks of “shitty YouTube fan film”. Some amateur cinematography, the superhero poses, and the new era of Disney snark where EVERY scene has to have some witty one-liner or self-deprecating remark has been wearing me down since The Last Jedi. To be fair, it’s becoming an industry standard for every action-oriented movie/tv show/video game, which I’ve coined as “Avengerization”; constant punchlines, NEVER a moment to let a scene breathe, and tense moments continually cut with “omg, can you BELIEVE that happened”-esque retorts. It completely tosses out meaningful cinematography and story-building to insert as many “these characters are cool/moody/funny, right guys?” scenes as possible. Barf.

The flashback sequence is of course going to span multiple episodes, and will predictably tell us how Boba had become a respected member of the nomad Tusken Raiders, earning their clothes and weapons (as evident from his appearance in Mando Season 2), and it’s a tired “Pheonix from the Ashes” trope. It’s also jarring and bizarre seeing this mysterious character that we assumed holding complete lethality and reserve sitting on a throne as the new Tatooine Don Corleone while his “I’m dangerous, can’t you tell by my smirk?” sidekick rattles off a smartass comment about each person that enters the scene. Oh, and by the way…our mysterious Bounty Hunter that we spent decades enamored with his allure of intrigue, costume (more on that in a bit), and assumed motives has his helmet off for large portions of his day-to-day life. Cool.

Can we also take a second to acknowledge how dogshit his new costume is compared to the masterfully crafted works of the original helmet and armor meticulously painted by Joe Johnston? I’m not going to pile onto how Temuera is a bit…bigger than how the original Boba actors were built (lithe and clocking in between 5’11”-6’0”), but the tailoring and arrangements are clunky and he looks like a cased sausage trying to move around his over-sized gauntlets and padded Samurai flightsuit, or whatever that is. It looks like a bizarro Halloween costume you’d purchase off of Amazon and cross your fingers that it looks SOMEWHAT like the product photo (spoiler: it’s worse). To be fair…it’s leagues better than the “re-armored” version we see when he repaints everything to a hazy, clean version at the end of Mando Season 2. If you would have told me the costume designers grabbed all of that from the rack of a Party City, I wouldn’t be surprised in the least.

I absolutely think they missed the mark with just about everything that made Boba Fett a true fan favorite. There’s some prequel/in-between stuff that sure, I’m not a fan of (a clone, really?) but it didn’t completely botch the essence of who we saw in the Original Trilogy. His movements were methodical, his dialogue was to the point and efficient (we can all thank the original voice actors Jason Wingreen for that), and his minimal screen time lent us to believe this was a character that was far more mature/interesting than the person we just saw in Episode 1.


r/saltierthancrait • • May 30 '22

Encrusted Rant Anyone else have the problem with Obi-Wan Kenobi character consistency in the new show?

20 Upvotes

Kenobi 10 years after RotS: "All is lost, we have lost, im doom and gloom tragic character who clearly had a lot of mental problems".

Kenobi 8 more years after that: "Hello there, Luke, its me, smiling nice old man, who is always calm, wise, collected, with the hint on long time trauma, but overall completely adequate and functioning person".

To me its not realistic for Kenobi to:

  1. Not being able to get over the past in 10 years

  2. Not being able to get over the past in 10 years, but be perfectly fine in 18 years

I can clearly fill the gap between ROTS Obi-Wan and ANH Obi-Wan given his personality and circumstance. Its more or less perfect transition. Kenobi is very stoic and optimistic character, 20 years are enough for him to become the one who he was in ANH.

Disney+ Kenobi fits badly in the overall picture. He is broken 10 years after ROTS (which shouldnt be a thing imo at all), and i can hardly imagine the smooth transition between him in Kenobi and him in ANH.


r/saltierthancrait • • Oct 04 '23

Encrusted Rant Ashoka was decent but flawed Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Yes it has a lot of flaws I am sure have been listed off like crazy by this point. Do I even need to bring them up? (Like Marrok not really be explained, Thrawn lacks his genius besides being basically competent, New Republic are clowns, lack lightsaber dismemberment and bits of stupid logic etc) But it’s not the raging crap fest people on this sub make it out to be. (Kenobi and Book of Boba Fett say hello)

Even the dumbest things in it pale in comparison to dumb things Kenobi ( Bale’s message detailing Luke’s home address, bounty hunters tripping, Leia super speed, Reva’s plan, trench coat scene, no lightsaber duel against inquisitors etc)

I could go in. Point is, it’s average, but enjoyable. Decent fights, plenty of lightsaber duels, Baylan and Shin have potential and don’t just die abruptly. Thrawn at least reads as more competent than most villains in the series( yes he makes mistakes)

Hell even Ezra was well done. Sabine is not the best in this but acting from everyone is solid.

And I have to stress how focused the plot feels compared to Mandolorian season 3.

So in brief, 7 out of 10. Maybe 8 but that’s debatable. Not a complete shit fest. Could be better but it’s above most recent Star Wars shows ( besides Andor)

Downvote or upvote away


r/saltierthancrait • • Mar 26 '23

Granular Discussion Anyone else not like Ahmed Best's character? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Mandalorian Season 3 Spoilers:

Many things can simultaneous be true which is the case here. I like redemption arcs (both in movies and IRL). I'm happy for Ahmed Best that this is a redemption moment for what I still believe was a terrible character in Jar-Jar. It's possible to dislike Jar-Jar while also acknowledging it was not the fault of the voice actor and he did not deserve hatred.

I also have no issue with them making him a Jedi. If they gave him signature cool characteristics, I see no reason why this character couldn't be a Jedi. My problem comes with how they staged his whole entrance.

It felt forced. It felt clear as day their intention was to surprise people by leaning into the fact he voiced Jar-Jar. That's a type of wall break that made it feel fan-fiction like and cheesy and definitely not a moment that belongs in such a serious-toned scene of Order 66 and Grogu's origins.

I earnest don't care too much. Star Wars as a whole feels oversaturated to me, I'm certainly not angry about anything, I just didn't really like it.


r/saltierthancrait • • Jul 20 '23

Encrusted Rant Star killer is nearly as bad as Rey

23 Upvotes

Ok before you come at me with pitch forks, hear me out: Yes, Starkiller at least had a better explanation for his powers since he was brutally and abusively trained by Vader from a very young age ( like 4 ish or 5) to young adult hood. Rey has no decent explanation for instantly knowing of force powers and wielding them ( she downloaded Kylo’s skills on Skype call?) But his fears are even more ridiculous. Wiping out battalions of armed men is common for Jedi and Sith but taking out Jedi masters, pulling a capital ship out of the sky, and defeating ( destroying more like) Vader and fighting the emperor to a stand still on his own? That’s ridiculous , especially considering Vader’s feats in legends. So both are overpowered ( in spite of explanations ) but Starkiller doing all this stuff, even being able to both kill vader and palpatine on his own is ridiculous

Edit: I know video game mechanics don’t always translate to canon but many of his feats still stand in the comic or novel versions. The other reason I bring this up is because I saw people on other Star Wars subs citing Rey has overpowered but Starkiller has well written


r/saltierthancrait • • Feb 03 '24

Encrusted Rant I was rewatching the Clone Wars and I realized that the show’s flaws are more egregious than what I once thought.

175 Upvotes

Let me know if you agree or disagree on any of these points. I would love your feedback/counterpoints. I am open to changing my mind. Some of these are less common so I thought it would be interesting to post them.

There are many problems with it, but here are those on top of my head:

— Disjointed storytelling. Most arc are independent of each other or weakly linked

— Lack of nuance and where it is present it’s kinda blunted.

— Many arc have no impact. Example: clone funding arc with Padme. It was badly written, but even then, there is no impact after of defeating the bill. It would seem that with lower funding on clones will have huge impact on the war, political balance, public perception of Padme etc. One could write a lot into this, something, anything. But there is nothing. Abysmal. And this negligence happens almost all the time. Mortis arc too.

— Le Force Dudes (Mortis arc) and the idiotic contradictory balance of the force. Lucas should have fired his entire team here (Alas)

— Ahsoka. She is a cool idea really, Obiwan feeding Anakin his own medicine, but oh well we all know what happened. Also she doesn’t “grow” as a character, more rewritten every time Filoni needed to.

— Absolutely atrocious, ugly like plague Jedi terror bombing and the order kicking Ahsoka out. This is morbidly stupid. Filoni needed Jedi order to be bad so he shits out this cancer of an arc.

— War is not explained. War is not really depicted. It’s just random battles. There is no explanation or over all picture of the wars. Very disappointing. On screen the good guys win, but off screen the bad guys loose.

— General Grievous. I pity him so much. He didn’t deserve this. I don’t know why the writers hate him.

—Darth Maul resurrection. Damn you, Lucas!

— Witches magic voodoo crap. Wtf?

— Political system not explained. To be fair, they did dig into it, but lack in both depth and breadth. Very disappointing.

That is everyone I could remember so far. Throw me your points

Edit: a lot of things that people criticize Disney for today, was first done here by Finoli. Character assassinantions, chasing the ends, Mary Sue, bs retcons, squandered EU/legends. In retrospect, TCW was a harbinger of doom for Star Wars.


r/saltierthancrait • • Jun 20 '23

Encrusted Rant Dave Filoni and the Bad Batch Series ruined clones and stained their reputation in Star Wars

28 Upvotes

Dave Filoni has single handedly destroyed the concept and purpose in the Star Wars universe. The clones ultimate creation was to give palpatine a army to create a new empire and destroy the jedi. In Revenge of the Sith the clones do this and ultimately succeed in creating a pathway for the empire and eventually turn into stormtroopers. Dave Filonis inhibitor chip has already tried and degraded Revenge of the Sith and make it seem like the clones were only forced somehow to kill the jedi, but to no avail this change is too late as the movie was created way before the chip was a thing and the movie will always embody pre chip clones in when they are truly in their prime.

With the bad batch now we see the chip going at it again making it seems like clones are goody goodies who can't do no wrong. On top of this Filoni is destroying the reason why clones were ever created by George Lucas....to become stormtroopers. In bad batch the empire is throwing them away before they can ever become stormtroopers. Yes the clones were eventually phased out, but in this series it's happening absolutely too soon and for no reason. Well the actual reason is so Filoni can keep clones as good guys forever. It's even ruined RoTS clones such as Cody, which further attempts to degrade RoTS.

The bad batch has degraded clones so much and the effect of this degrades Order 66 in Revenge of the Sith. The emotional weight will be degraded if clones like Cody reunite with the jedi they tried to kill, in this case Kenobi. Unfortunately the bad batch has made to start to dislike clones more and more now because they are pointless now and are essentially just fodder. Thankfully Revenge of the Sith still exists and cannot be changed where the clones are in their prime. Lets see what Filoni does next to try and degrade the clones and the film Revenge of the Sith.


r/saltierthancrait • • Apr 20 '21

Granular Discussion Now, I like Mando quite a bit, but does anyone else feel this show is beating the crap out of it?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/saltierthancrait • • Jan 18 '22

Granular Discussion I genuinely don't see what the problem is with TBOBF.

13 Upvotes

Most of the time I agree with your rants about the direction Star Wars has been taking, but I think this time you are jumping the shark a bit with this show. I'm not saying it is an amazing show, but it's also really not that bad. Yes, I agree the bounty hunter wookie scene could have been a bit better, but all I've seen recently were complaints of insignificant stuff and posts with titles like "Boba Fett's character has been destroyed" or "Star Wars is now officially dead". Chill, there are only 3 episodes and all I have seen so far is how Boba's interaction with the Tusken Raiders made him change as a person.


r/saltierthancrait • • Jun 05 '25

Granular Discussion I’m glad Andor is over.

8 Upvotes

Some time last year, I wrote a post about why and how I was done with Star Wars, with the exception of Andor S2, and now that it’s done, I can finally seal that blast door and move on.

That said, and this is probably a hot take, but I’m glad Andor S2 left me feeling unfulfilled. I know a lot of people are raving about it, but it was just sort of a big nothing for me. It had some great isolated moments, but it also started or continued a lot of open plots that it just didn’t bother to close. I wasn’t expecting a Star Wars-caliber battle at the end, but I also didn’t want the last episode to basically just be people sitting around talking, gathering at Yavin all to…not ever show up ever again.

Obviously, before anyone jumps the blaster, Cassian’s plot couldn’t have any sort of cap because Rogue One is his finale, and I think they set that up well, but my bigger issue is all these other characters that seem to be set up for what comes next and…there just is no “next” for them. With Gilroy gone, I wouldn’t accept anyone else’s follow-up for these characters, so they just basically stop existing, narratively speaking.

I still believe killing Karn when and how they did was a mistake. Not because I have any sympathy for the guy (although I do think gunning him down the second he starts a redemption path is fucked), but because I wanted to see what he was going to do. There were so many characters in this show and season where I wanted to see what was going to happen to them and it turned out nothing was. Wilmon had a whole one scene dedicated to his fuel addiction before that just never came up again. Saw, a character I admittedly do not care for, was wasted being in this show. Why was he even there?

I could go on about the “nothing”, but it’s all basically the same issue: all set-up and no pay off. I’m fine with intentional loose ends, that’s life after all, but in trying to distance itself from the usual “everyone’s related and everything’s connected” issue with Star Wars, this show seems to have gone out of its way to answer nothing, not even its season 1 episode 1 scene 1 question that incited these entire two prequel seasons and movie finale: where is Cassian’s sister, and why is he looking for her?

I admire Gilroy’s commitment to his 5-season story, but not that he committed to it so hard that it distilled the final product into basically being a Cliffnotes adaption of a show that never existed. And I guess that’s fine because that makes being done that much easier. I didn’t leave me wanting more (in the traditional sense) so there’s no withdrawal. And I’ll always have Battlefront II (2005).

Welp, with that most midwestern send-off I wish the rest of you well, may the Force stay with you, and ever remain salty.


r/saltierthancrait • • Jul 25 '18

encrusted rant Rant: There is nothing honorable, inspiring, heroic, or "Jedi" about the war crime of perfidy

15 Upvotes

TLJ fans have lauded Luke's projection trick as being some brilliant, noble act that stayed true to the Jedi way and saved lives without the use of violence.

I strongly disagree. It only worked at all because it was criminal in a different way.

Perfidy is recognized as a war crime, for good reason. It exploits the trust and mercy of a victorious opponent, by feigning surrender or good-faith negotiations, in order to gain a military advantage. It leads to unnecessary deaths in war because it discourages victors from taking their opponents alive, because the surrender could be ruse that forces them to pay the ultimate price.

Heroes, to inspire us, must be above such treachery. What makes the good guys good is that they're willing to give up such tactical advantages because it means fighting honorably.

The good guys commit perfidy twice in TLJ

  1. Poe's prank call. He insists he has an "urgent communique" from Leia in the middle of battle. Of course, he has no such communique, he just wants to waste the FO commanders' time, and thus exploits their trust that the Resistance wants to engage in good-faith negotiation -- trust (and mercy!) that was horribly misplaced, in costing them a dreadnought.

  2. When Luke appears at the end. He makes all the gestures of inviting Kylo to a duel in lieu of battle, while having no intention of engaging in a duel at all. He exploits Kylo's trust that Luke is an honorable Jedi and so his challenges must be legit.

So wait, all deception in war is wrong?

No. Ruses of war are a legit tactic. Perfidy differs in specifically asking for the other party to trust your attempt at good faith negotiation, and then betray it.

What about the Jedi mind trick?

The Jedi mind trick does not ask the victim to consciously trust the Jedi, and then betray them. Rather, it bypasses their ability to think rationally at all, no different from conking them on the head so they become disoriented and unable to fight. It does not punish someone for choosing to trust the Jedi.

The Jedi were above this in the Prequels

Mace Windu was given a chance to surrender at the end of AotC. He refuses, even knowing that the Jedi could eke out a few more kills by pretending to surrender and then lashing out at the last second.


The praise for Luke and Poe for their perfidy is confused. They debased the Resistance cause by using those tactics, and turned it into an uninspiring, less-worthy cause than the one we saw in TFA, which held that "Everyone, even Stormtroopers, deserve a name".


r/saltierthancrait • • Apr 25 '25

Granular Discussion Is the prequel trilogy considered good now?

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I grew up a big star wars fan in the prequel era. My first content was The Clone Wars It was followed by the PT OT then legends books and comics.

I remember growing up it was the consensus that the PT sucks, but it seems since the sequels, sentiment has changed and its more common for people to list it as good.

I feel like before Ep 7 good star wars was 3456 (honestly not sold on 3) then for a bit after it was 34567 then after RJ’s mess of episode 8 and JJs even bigger mess of episode 9, somehow i see people calling episode one good? Is this like a rare opinion or commonplace?

Since I’m sure it will come up, my ranking is 5,4,6,8,3,7,2,1

I have Ep 8 as interchangeable with 3. I kinda like the idea of Luke not being the yoda character I like the benecio del toro character. I think it’s easily the SW movie with the best cinematography, art direction and best attempt at a theme. Luke’s ending was perfect in my opinion even though the flashback was dumb. I love the fact that he used a deep connection with the force to avoid actual violence as we are kinda told a true Jedi would want to. Otherwise though rose sucks, holdo maneuver sucks, finn is wasted (rose and that planet suck though) to me the holdo stuff and rose and the gambling planet suck but more stuff sucks in Ep3.

George Lucas dialogue sucks as usual, palpatine’s plan is kind of silly. Anakin’s character change from episode 3 to 2. I guess I might be more critical of episode 3 because of its promise to be a satisfying answer to the questions: who was Vader and how did the empire come into existence? I might be biased since I saw Anakin in the clone wars first where he is so much more compelling.

I would say that both movies kind of suck for reasons regarding the basis of their trilogies. PT all should have been during the clone wars, we did NOT need a child Anakin. ST sucks partly because of all of the copying and the fear of doing anything new in the first movie and then whiplash in the next you guys surely know the drill with that.

note: I complement ep8 a lot and hate on ep3 only because I assume the folks here like ep3 already and dislike ep8 already.

Thanks and looking forward to your thoughts!

Edit: wow guys I guess that is the consensus these days lol. thanks that is pretty interesting.


r/saltierthancrait • • May 31 '26

Peppered Positivity Challenge: Say something nice about every Disney era piece of media that you dislike.

7 Upvotes

From the sequels to The Book of Boba to The Acolyte and beyond. I am curious to see how easy or hard this is for some people. It could be anything from a specific scene to a character design to the special effects.