r/ryewhiskey • • Jul 30 '25

Review Sagamore 9yr

Post image
55 Upvotes

Sagamore -9yr Rye. Picked by the Kitsap Whiskey Society, it was the first nine year pick outside of MD, though there are more out there now. Nose is all caramel and burnt sugars, palette is full of rye spice. 8/10. Glad to see this Reddit back up and running.


r/ryewhiskey • • Jul 29 '25

Announcement — Welcome Back

53 Upvotes

Hello all,

For a year or two, this subreddit was closed to new submissions. While rye whiskey has continued to grow in popularity, with new rye whiskeys popping up all over the place, this subreddit remained stagnant and there was no updates to its content.

I decided to ask to become moderator to open up the subreddit again and yesterday I was approved. I'm going to do my best to get this subreddit up and running again, while respecting the existing whiskey subreddits that are still present. I have a lot of rye whiskeys sitting around my house and my goal is to post new reviews every few days while the community (hopefully) gets off the ground.

I'll try to have a post describing our content policy and subreddit rules in a day or two.

Until then, the main rules are:

Fous on rye whiskey

There are plenty of other subreddits that focus on all kinds of whiskey. The content here should center on whiskeys where the key component is rye.

Be kind to each other

That means both remaining polite in conversation as well as refraining from any forms of hate speech. Ideally the focus will always be on rye whiskey and only rye whiskey, so this won't even be an issue, but if someone expresses intolerance for some reason those comments or posts will be removed.

No selling, buying, trades or pricing offers/requests

The secondary market is a nightmare, we want no part of it, and it is also likely to be a violation of Rule 7 of Reddit's Content Policy:

Rule 7

Keep it legal, and avoid posting illegal content or soliciting or facilitating illegal or prohibited transactions.


r/ryewhiskey • • Feb 02 '21

Gift from the wife after helping her through a rough surgery.

Post image
46 Upvotes

r/ryewhiskey • • Aug 16 '25

Celebrating 16th anniversary with a Rittenhouse Rye Old Fashioned

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/ryewhiskey • • Aug 14 '25

Alberta Premium Cask Strength Rye - 66%

Post image
37 Upvotes

This whiskey (or rather, the bottle that immediately preceded it) was named the whiskey of the year in some influential whiskey "bible" in 2020. At the time I was just starting my whiskey journey in earnest.

I think this was the first cask strength whiskey I had ever purchased.

It's a really fantastic whiskey. I think one of the reasons I like it is because I'm not particularly into oaky or well-aged whiskeys. I don't mind them on the younger side.

So although others have apparently criticized this whiskey for tasting too rough or too young, it tastes just perfect to me. But on to the tasting notes.

This whiskey has been open for years and has likely oxidized a bit but it still smells fantastic.

The first thing I noticed when I first opened it, which is still discernible now, is the umeboshi plums. These are sour plums used in Japanese with a fragrant, sharp-sour earthiness. There is also the familiar rye spice. Dill (although mild) and cinnamon. At one point I got a whiff of chocolate ice cream which was surprising.

On to the taste. This is much less hot than you'd expect for the proof. It is hot but for something 132 this is definitely drinkable.

It starts out very sweet and concentrated. Sugary, dried fruit and concentrated stone fruit flavors (maybe plum wine?). Saltiness as well as the umami I seem to get from the higher proof ryes.

The alcohol is thick and syrupy and absolutely coats your tongue and back of the throat and numbs your lips.

This is a sipping whiskey and I do mean tiny sips. I took a smaller gulp for scientific purposes and found it overwhelming. That is where the proof really hits you. On larger sips you start tasting cask influence, charred oaky flavor.

On the finish, it is mostly burn. But still pleasant and warm.

I'm not one to have my whiskey with ice but this might be a good candidate. Also probably good if you're the sort to add a few drops of water.


r/ryewhiskey • • Nov 01 '25

Wild Turkey Rare Breed Rye

Post image
34 Upvotes

Solid high proof rye. Plenty of rye spice. Really sweet on the palate and nice oakiness.


r/ryewhiskey • • Oct 06 '25

Old Overholt

Post image
34 Upvotes

I purchased this bottle based on a review from r/ryewhiskey. I’m loving this. To the Redditor that posts the detailed reviews, thank you and Cheers!


r/ryewhiskey • • Mar 22 '26

Picked up a nicer bottle of the Rye I tried, new to this side of whiskey

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

While I’m definitely more into bourbon than rye, this was a very worthwhile purchase (and perhaps irresponsibly my first ever full bottle of rye). For how strong it is, it is much smoother than some other ryes I’ve tried. I kind of get that mint flavor note I see people mention. But otherwise it’s spicy and oaky. Adds a nice flavor to my collection.


r/ryewhiskey • • Oct 19 '25

Rye kinda night!!!

Post image
33 Upvotes

Gotta see what is what


r/ryewhiskey • • May 15 '23

Let’s see……I love single barrel whiskies, I love non-chill filtered, and of course I love rye. Check, check, & check. Cheers! 👍🏼🥃🌴

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

r/ryewhiskey • • Aug 24 '21

No better way to end the day!

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/ryewhiskey • • Jul 30 '25

Review JDSBBPR - ‘Nana’s First Rye’

Post image
32 Upvotes

Jack Daniel’s SiB BP Rye (7yr) Nana’s Kitchen, Tucson AZ Barrelhouse 1-06, 7th Fl (BBQ/Slop Hill) Picked at 136pf, Bottled at 137pf

Nose: chocolate, honey, rye Palette: honey, cherry, rye spice, cinnamon Finish: long, cinnamon and rye.

Probably the best JDSBBPR I’ve tried (I haven’t had any Coy), let this sit long enough and you get a nice maple syrup on the nose. I blinded this at the restaurant against an EHT BP Rye and picked this without thinking twice.

9/10


r/ryewhiskey • • Aug 22 '26

Haystack Needle!

Post image
31 Upvotes

First time seeing this in the wild in NY! Paid $127. I’m excited to try it.


r/ryewhiskey • • May 13 '23

This is such a good rye. My open bottle is 54.7%…these will be even nicer at 56.5%. Cheers 👍🏼🥃🌴

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/ryewhiskey • • Jul 23 '22

Cutting rye for whiskey

31 Upvotes

r/ryewhiskey • • Oct 23 '25

Review Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Rye (Barrel Proof)

Post image
30 Upvotes

A lot of people have good things to say about this bottle. I definitely don't like regular Jack Daniel's, let's see how I feel about this. As you may tell from the photo, I've had a few drams from this bottle. It's definitely not on my regular rotation though.

Here's one thing I can say for it: at 134.3 proof (67.15% alcohol) it's way smoother than you'd expect. I've nosed weaker whiskeys that gave off nothing but harsh ethanol.

This whiskey starts with a strong overpowering sweetness with sometimes hints of and sometimes screams of banana. Vanilla but maybe the artificial kind they put in cheaper ice creams? Brown sugar and toffee and at the end definitely some prominent rye spice including dillseed but sweetness throughout.

I'm actually enjoying this more than I usually do, so far.

Swirling vigorously wakes up more spice and maybe some salty brine? Really I have no idea what's wrong with my nose but I swear I'm getting some ocean there.

All really promising. Time for a taste.

The heat is definitely there but again very smooth with the heat at least 10-20 proof less than you'd expect. It starts out very gently then sort of expands out on the tongue with a lot of warmth and some sharpness. Oakiness. Spice. Plums (actually plum wine if you've ever had that). Raisins. Loads of sweetness but also bitterness.

There's some savory here too. Lately I've been getting umami flavors from my higher proof ryes and this is no exception.

Usually with stronger whiskeys your mouth gets more used to it the more you drink. Here it feels like the opposite. As time goes on in the burning gets more intense.

Although adding water to scotch is fairly common, it's not as common for American whiskeys but I think this is one where I've heard it's recommended. I don't have water handy so I'll just drink it as it is.

Overall a pretty decent rye whiskey but the banana is a bit distracting and although I appreciate a strong whiskey now and again this might be just above my threshold.

The similarly high proofed 66% Albert Premium Cask is, in my opinion, a little smoother and more interesting although I believe it is now considerably more expensive.

But honestly I'd probably enjoy the more reasonably proofed Rare Breed Rye at just 56%.


r/ryewhiskey • • Mar 16 '26

Cocktails Sacrilecious

Post image
29 Upvotes

Surprisingly, root beer makes an excellent mixer for rye whiskey. I usually use a nicer root beer and a cheaper whiskey but I used what was near.

1 part Rare Breed Rye with two parts Mug root beer. Root beer really brings out all the botanical notes in the whiskey. Meanwhile the whiskey amplifies the flavors of the root beer.

The only downside is that Rare Breed is already so sweet that it makes the root beer almost too sweet. So maybe a less sweet, spicier rye like Michter's or Willet would be better?


r/ryewhiskey • • Aug 02 '25

Review Old Overholt 10 year cask strength

Post image
29 Upvotes

A Overholt Distillery "Aged in escalator warehouse V" 2023 bottling, 10 years old. Paid $99

This is cask strength, unfiltered, 121 proof.

This is very obviously a cousin to the Old Overholt 114 I've reviewed previously. It's basically exactly what you'd expect if you took the 114 and made it older and stronger.

Dried fruit is more pronounced on the nose, with apricot and raisins. The dill is less.

On the palate the barrel influence is much clearer, with more wood and char than its younger counterpart. The sweetness is more immediate but the punch of the alcohol and spice follows almost immediately. More dried fruit, darker raisins and maybe figs.

Similar to the 114, after the initial flavors there is an umami taste that lingers. A little bitterness on the finish.

I really enjoy the Overholt line, this is not a steal at $99 but it's not too much either. I love the appearance of the bottle but it doesn't affect the value of the whiskey one way or the other, it's just a plus. I bet it would make a fantastic infinity bottle once empty or low.

I'm not sure if this bottle is available everywhere or just in Pennsylvania. What's interesting is that this year they have the "same" rye whiskey but this year it's 11 years old. Seems like they must be hitting the same batch of whiskey that was all barreled at the same time. No idea whether next year's batch will be 12 years old or not.

If you are a fan of aged rye whiskey, this is definitely worth snapping up. Personally, I will probably stick with younger whiskeys. My sweet spot, I think, is in the 4-6 year range.


r/ryewhiskey • • Feb 09 '22

Tonight’s Flavor!🇺🇸🦅🥃

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/ryewhiskey • • Jul 27 '26

I should have purchased the second bottle.

Post image
28 Upvotes

I was on a waiting list for this Elijah Craig barrel proof rye 115 proof, for months.
I’m still somewhat new to rye whiskey and have been discovering that I do enjoy an older age (within my budget) rye. Another thing is that I was not really enjoying higher than 100 proof. When I got the call for this bottle I had the option to buy two, I only got one at $75 and now, (sigh) I wish I purchased the second.
I’m not great at reviews.
So in my novice experience. I usually make old fashioned drinks with my rye and I wanted to share that the two old fashioned drinks I prepared with this were absolutely delicious. I wanted to try to give a novice experience by sipping after a breather of 10 minutes in a glencairin.
Nose: high alcohol, caramel, sour citrus orange bitter and earthy wood.
Palate : definitely an alcohol burn that develops to a sourish clove dill orange cayenne browned buttery flavors.
Finish: after the alcohol burn there is an earthy ferment orange black tea sour cinnamon.
I do like this and will get back on a waitlist to by the second bottle.
Through following r/ryewhiskey I have found and tested quite a few recommended ryes. This has helped me develop my tastes and preferences so far. Since this bottle was hard to acquire in my location I thought I would share my experience.
Sharzor rating: 7 (this means nothing to anyone but me and my two rye whiskey drinking friends)


r/ryewhiskey • • Sep 25 '22

Sagamore Double Oak

Post image
28 Upvotes

Don’t sleep on the beautiful Rye as a mixer. Don’t get me wrong I love it straight but wow what a mixer!


r/ryewhiskey • • Nov 25 '25

Balcones Texas Rye Cask Strength

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

This is a barrel pick from McScrooge’s Wine and Spirits in Knoxville, TN. If you’re ever in the area, I highly recommend you stop by. They have an amazing selection and have lots of bottle open for sampling. I was able to try this and their True Blue Cask Strength pick as well- this whiskey blew me away. At only $59.99, it was a must buy.

Aged 67 months in new American oak

64.4% ABV/128.8 Proof

Nose: Rich earth, chocolate, raisin, cardamom, and plum. With some time, flamed orange peel comes forward.

Palate: Dark, jammy fruits. Plum, earth, sweet oak, a dark, sweet orange note, and more cardamom.

Finish: long and funky. Dark chocolate, plum, well worn leather, and dark Virginia pipe tobacco.

t8ke: 8/10

This is phenomenal. It really reminds me a lot of the Jack Daniels Barrel Proof ryes I’ve had, but with more funky craft whiskey character. It also reminds me a lot of Whiskey Acres BiB rye, which is estate grown and super funky/crafty as well. Plum and roasted cardamom are the two things that really stick out, with some sweet blood orange coming forward with a little time to open up. Can’t wait to pair this with some cigars. Cheers!


r/ryewhiskey • • Sep 07 '25

Review Stellum Rye (Cask Strength Blended Rye Whiskey)

Post image
27 Upvotes

Stopped by the liquor store on a Chinese food pickup run and saw this bottle and decided to buy it. It was around $27, nearly $30 with tax.

That's a pretty good price for cask strength whiskey. Although there's no age statement it says it's a blend of straight rye whiskeys and with no age statement that means they are at least 4 years old, I think.

It states "Distilled in Indiana, Kentucky and Tennessee". More than likely that means a 95/5 whiskey from MGP, a 51% rye from Kentucky, and some indeterminate rye from Tennessee, most likely Tennessee style (filtered).

I really like high proof ryes as well as high rye whiskeys so I'm anticipating good things about this whiskey.

The nose: surprisingly very little ethanol for the proof. If you stick your nose all the way into the glass you'll get some, but this smells lower proof than it is. First smells very little dill for a rye. A little bit of rye spice. Lots of sweetness, some dried orange peel. After letting it rest, sweet iced tea, cinnamon, vanilla ice cream.

The palate: sweet at the start and the sweetness lingers while spice and heat spread out. Lots of savory flavors emerge: white pepper, clean umami, something vegetal, and a very mild brininess. More umami and spice on the finish.

The distiller's own tasting notes which are pretty good, suggested adding a splash of water, so I did (around 12 drops). The nose gets a little more familiar, more dill as well as licorice and rye spices. The taste is sweeter and a little flatter but still very good and very sweet with orange. Honestly, with a dash of bitters it would nearly taste like an old fashioned without the sugar cube or orange peel. With a finish that tastes like, for lack of a better description, angry brown sugar.

Even with the water this is a very strong whiskey. Although this drinks way smoother than 116 proof, it's still probably a whiskey that would hold up better in a cocktail.

Overall recommendation: buy, especially for under $30.


r/ryewhiskey • • Sep 19 '25

Jack Daniels Bonded Rye

Post image
26 Upvotes

Jack Daniels Bonded Rye

100 proof

Mashbill: 70 Rye, 18 Corn, 12 Barley

This is an interesting one. I'm not a fan of your standard Jack No 7. But this is different. This is much much better. Right off the bat, it has some great spice. Which is surprising since it's only 70% rye. It's far more spicy than some lower rye Rye Whiskeys that I've tried. But it's a good kind of spice. On the back end, it's smooth without a lot of alcohol burn (despite it being 100 proof) and with a sweet aftertaste. It has a complex flavor that keeps me coming back for sip after sip.

Perhaps most notably for me personally is that this is the first Whiskey I've found that I prefer neat. Typically I drink everything on the rocks. But this is far better neat and chilled.

For $35, this isn't a hateful purchase. I still think Bulleit Rye is the best bang for your buck. But this is very close behind.

Overall, it's a solid 8/10


r/ryewhiskey • • Mar 04 '22

First try of Bulliet 95 Rye...it’s a smooth, enjoyable pour!

Post image
26 Upvotes