r/rust • • Mar 15 '23

Zed – A high-performance, multiplayer code editor written in Rust. Now in public beta

https://zed.dev/blog/beta
215 Upvotes

238 comments sorted by

776

u/Thing1_Thing2_Thing Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23
  • Closed source

  • MacOS only

  • Forced telemetry (EDIT: Not true, it was forced before beta, opt-out now)

Bold to post it in /r/rust lol.

462

u/cauthon Mar 15 '23

The license is... interesting

INVESTIGATIONS, MONITORING, & NO OBLIGATION TO PRE-SCREEN CONTENT. Zed may, but is not obligated to, investigate, monitor, pre-screen, remove, refuse, or review the Service and/or Content, including Your Content and User Content, at any time. By entering into the Agreement, you hereby provide your irrevocable consent to such monitoring. You acknowledge and agree that you have no expectation of privacy concerning the transmission of Your Content, including without limitation chat, text, or voice communications. In the event that Zed pre-screens, refuses or removes any Content, you acknowledge that Zed will do so for Zed’s benefit, not yours.

360

u/Razican Mar 15 '23

I think this is illegal in Europe with GDPR, just saying. Any consent must be revocable, and we must even be able to request all the data they have from us.

124

u/cat_napped1 Mar 15 '23

this contract would also likely be found unconscionable in the US and basically worthless

32

u/generalbaguette Mar 16 '23

What you say might be right in practice. But as a legal nitpick: be very careful about the difference between contract and license in common law.

11

u/NotTooDistantFuture Mar 16 '23

They would lose the protections afforded by the DMCA and could be held directly accountable for hosting illegal content.

37

u/TheTrueBlueTJ Mar 15 '23

That and it must be crystal clear how the data is going to be used. They are explicitly saying you have no expectation of privacy.

3

u/fekkksn Mar 16 '23

And request to have it deleted too

166

u/elcapitanoooo Mar 15 '23

wtf is this? like why ruin a product with a license like this?

75

u/rnmkrmn Mar 15 '23

That's the product.

84

u/devraj7 Mar 15 '23

The fact that the Zed team reviewed this license and approved this kind of verbiage is deeply, deeply concerning to me.

It's one thing when a single person wants to be overly aggressive in collecting analytics and claiming ownership of user produced content, but this is another level of stupidity.

And the whole team seems okay with it.

106

u/Whaison1 Mar 15 '23

irrevocable consent

Is that even legal??

I'm no expert, but I think if you have customers from the EU they must be able to revoke it. But maybe the law has some constraints

54

u/tobimai Mar 15 '23

Nope. Under GPDR you are allowed to revoke you conset at any time and all data must be deleted

4

u/ssokolow Mar 26 '23

From what I remember, the GDPR even has things to say about if they've used your data to train things like collaborative filtering systems or machine learning models.

It's... not amused... by "Oh, we're technologically incapable of complying" tricks.

65

u/QualitySoftwareGuy Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23

Wow, that's a hard pass from me. Will stick to my current IDEs.

15

u/arjjov Mar 16 '23 edited Mar 16 '23

Interesting? Do you mean straight up garbage?

This shit is pretty much also a spyware

9

u/AWDDude Mar 16 '23

This reads like they are preparing to harvest your data for machine learning.

1

u/nathansobo Mar 15 '23

Hey, I commented separately, but you're right that we didn't do a good job with the EULA. We'll fix it. Also: telemetry is not forced, but it is closed source for the time being.

78

u/Hnnnnnn Mar 15 '23

The bad impression is irrevokable! Like the consent sometimes, apparently.

34

u/-main Mar 16 '23

Will you fix the internal processes that generated and approved it? Or only this specific document, in the specific places where the internet called you on it?

33

u/nathansobo Mar 16 '23

The internal process was me being a bit overwhelmed with the launch and not being experienced working with lawyers who are paranoid by default. So I'm finding a lawyer I work better with. I have a meeting with a new lawyer today to help. Doubt you believe it, but I'm just a guy trying to build something useful with paranoid lawyers that demanded we ship with a EULA, was in a hurry, and fucked up.

3

u/freepensforall Mar 16 '23

it is closed source for the time being.

That's disappointing. Care to share why?

3

u/coderman93 Mar 16 '23

Care to share why you feel that developers should have to give away their intellectual property and hard work for free?

9

u/freepensforall Mar 16 '23

Care to share why you feel that developers should have to give away their intellectual property and hard work for free?

I never said that and I don't feel that way either.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ehloitsizzy Mar 27 '23

Since the person you addressed seemingly felt too cornered by your passive-aggressive question I'll give it to you straight: Because that's the best way the world runs. That's not an opinion, that's a simple fact. Human work is best done as collaboration, not as competition. Intellectual property is a cancerous thought of capitalist ideologues that in it's current form hurts more than it helps.

Simple as that :)

→ More replies (3)

1

u/PandaParado Mar 16 '23

They probably don’t want someone like Microsoft to embrace, extend, extinguish them. Like what happened to atom.

5

u/flashmozzg Mar 16 '23

Yeah, MS did such a great job at extinguishing VS code, nobody even uses it anymore, wait...

8

u/PandaParado Mar 16 '23

Um… what? MS owns VS Code. That’s the point. They extended Atom to create VS Code, then Atom died. The Zed devs are the original Atom team.

12

u/flashmozzg Mar 16 '23

It died because it was a worse product, not because VS Code has extended it. There was no standard to extend to begin with (if anything, MS has created the standard with LSP which lead to lots of advancements in tooling which lots of editors enjoy now). Well that, and also because MS bought GitHub so there was no sense in continuing to invest in it when it's just an all-around inferior product. The fact that Zed devs decided to start a new on a different SW stack instead of trying to carry on with Atom just shows that it was a dead end (there was nothing it could realistically offer to complete with VS Code). So MS did kill Atom but it wasn't due to EEE strategy. Just regular competition.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/JumpingJack79 Dec 05 '23

FWIW, this was apparently accidental (written by clueless lawyers and poorly reviewed by a busy founder). The ownership claim was meant to refer to content posted on their web site (which makes sense) and not the work done with the editor. The license has since been fixed and no longer contains preposterous claims of ownership.

76

u/dread_deimos Mar 15 '23

Saved me a click!

1

u/TRAFICANTE_DE_PUDUES Mar 16 '23

Nice! What are u planning to do with it now?

2

u/dread_deimos Mar 16 '23

I have a piggy bank for saved clicks.

1

u/TRAFICANTE_DE_PUDUES Mar 16 '23

Can you save dicks in it?

2

u/dread_deimos Mar 16 '23

Only the smallest ones.

3

u/TRAFICANTE_DE_PUDUES Mar 16 '23

Plenty of room for mine then!

26

u/eshansingh Mar 15 '23

Wow, it's truly astonishing how tone-deaf the replies from the OP in this thread are.

18

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

The moment I saw MacOS only I was like well dead on arrival, but did not realized the rest which is even worse.

82

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23

The real bold move is using light theme for the editors' screenshots on the landing page

10

u/wischichr Mar 16 '23

I heard the rustacean station podcast episode about zed recently and it started really good and I thought the idea was great and every 10 minutes they "dropped" something like "closed sources", "mac only", "communication via centralized server", etc. definitely not for me at that point.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23

It’s planned to be (partially) open source. Personally, I don’t really care about the editor itself but I’d like to take a look at their UI framework.

12

u/JoshTriplett rust · lang · libs · cargo Mar 16 '23

It’s planned to be (partially) open source.

What does "partially open source" mean? Which bits wouldn't be, and how hard will they be to remove so that the remainder can be relied on?

5

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

From my understanding, the GUI and the local editor would be open source, but many of the syncing and collaboration bits wouldn’t be.

2

u/dozniak Mar 16 '23

So just take any gui framework for rust and you’re done. No need to drag more baggage.

6

u/coderman93 Mar 16 '23

There are currently 0 good UI frameworks for Rust.

2

u/d86leader Mar 17 '23

There are currently at least 4 good gui frameworks for rust, and imo we need less single-purpose solutions like a library written specifically for a text editor. Still would be nice to have, to learn from their experience and decisions.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

Same, but they've said it's going to be GPL, which IMO makes any UI framework worthless. A UI framework is not a product you can sell, meaning making it GPL doesn't protect some future business selling the framework, but it certainly *will* drive off anybody who thinks they might possibly want to sell an app they write in the future. Why learn and contribute to a framework I will have to abandon as soon as I finally reach a point in my own work that it's worth selling?

7

u/ConsciousLiterature Mar 16 '23

I am sure they would be happy to sell you a licence if you want to make a product.

Or you can write your own I guess.

19

u/Trader-One Mar 15 '23

telemetry can be turned off.

at least this is what is in documentation.

74

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23

Exactly. The documentation isn't legally binding so they can say whatever the fuck they want.
The license is legally binding and unfortunately it's absolutely trash.
And since it's closed source how do we know that turning off the telemetry really turns it off?
I wouldn't be surprised if someone uses Wireshark and finds that it's a blatant lie.

The license makes this the definition of spyware. This software is not to be trusted.

6

u/Da-Blue-Guy Mar 16 '23

oof, lmao now i feel like making something like this out of spite

17

u/Recatek gecs Mar 16 '23

You could contribute to Lapce?

5

u/Da-Blue-Guy Mar 16 '23

:O oh my god thank you

6

u/coderman93 Mar 16 '23

Ugh, I hate what Open Source has become. There is nothing wrong with closed source. Developers deserve to make money for what they develop. Why does everyone feel they are entitled to free software? There is now an expectation that developers just give there work away for free that doesn’t exist in any other industry.

3

u/mattsowa Mar 16 '23

lol it's not (just) about the money.

3

u/Krantz98 Mar 17 '23

Probably nothing wrong with closed source, yes. But definitely wrong if you claim it to be “eventually open source” and take no action in the meantime: you cannot eat the cake and have it, just advertise yourself as closed source OR publish the source code.

-61

u/maxbrunsfeld Mar 15 '23

You can disable telemetry immediately on the welcome screen, or alternatively, pop open the telemetry log screen at any time to see what's being sent. Right now, we're just finding out what file extensions people open the most, to see what languages we need support for.

The editor will be cross-platform and open-source, but we're not there yet.

58

u/elpix Mar 15 '23

Why is project progress required to make it open source?

6

u/maxbrunsfeld Mar 15 '23

Well, they claim they're going to. In the meantime we should treat them like any commercial company and not give them extra credit on the basis of a promise they haven't actually delivered on yet. Especially when their current license seems to have much more draconian terms than most.

Because we need to separate out the collaboration-related code that we'll need want to keep closed source (in the near term) so that we can build a business around it.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/legendaryexistence Mar 15 '23

can you elaborate more about the license? Clearly, it's a blocker for a lot of people and might have an impact on the product itself.

50

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23

According to maxbrunsfeld on hackernews

Thanks for pointing this out. Our whole terms-of-service is just standard boilerplate provided by our lawyers, but this part doesn't really apply to Zed. Obviously, there's no "content moderation" for project code that you collaborate on with Zed.

We'll look into adjusting this to make it clearer that we don't do anything remotely concerning or invasive.

But even this can be chalked up to hearsay as it doesn't matter what they say about the licensing, the only thing that matters is what the license says. So this changes nothing until the actual problem at hand is fixed.

As ibejoeb says here

Not only is it non-obvious, it's explicitly stated that you can do what you want with any content that you are exposed to, which is all of it, because you've granted yourself the ability to surveil everything. And not only what the "Application" or "Tool" sees, but by any means available to you by the "Service."

So obviously until changes are actually made, it will remain to be a ridiculous invasion of privacy.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

23

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23

Are you aware that the name "Zed" is already taken? https://github.com/zedapp/zed

8

u/Krantz98 Mar 16 '23

The previous Warp app was also advertised “to be cross-platform and open-source”, so now we get two Futures to poll, do we? Ever growing cake floating in the air, but you never get a bite. Promise without a due time is cheap; planned open source without a timetable is even worse then closed source.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

18

u/molepersonadvocate Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23

I want to like this, but one thing I don't understand is why every modern editor goes with the design of having tabs grouped within splits. The inverse (splits grouped within tabs, ala Vim) makes it so much easier to organize your workspace when working across multiple files, and is pretty much a required feature for me at this point. These things aren't even mutually exclusive necessarily, but it seems like everyone goes with the first design exclusively these days.

9

u/maxbrunsfeld Mar 15 '23

Co-founder of Zed here. I agree with this. We have talked about support alternative buffer-organization paradigms. A lot of folks want to be able to simply remove the tabs, and have the list of open buffers managed explicitly via a separate list.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

[deleted]

2

u/molepersonadvocate Mar 17 '23

Every editor has its own terminology, but Vim “splits” == Vim “windows” == VSCode “editor groups” basically

105

u/rapsey Mar 15 '23

Seems to have less features than lapce. Which is also rust based and fast.

51

u/Recatek gecs Mar 16 '23

Fewer features, closed source, invasive telemetry, questionable license...

5

u/BRA1L0R Mar 16 '23

And open source.....

97

u/Speykious inox2d · cve-rs Mar 15 '23

I'm more excited for their GPU-accelerated GUI framework than for the editor. The editor looks amazing and probably feels that way too in regards to performance, but I'm still skeptical of these kinds of projects that start closed source. The separation between the commercial collaboration-related features and the FOSS core of the editor should've been made from the get go so that anyone could try and contribute to the core of the editor. Also really a shame they had to build it for MacOS first.

Suffice to say, it looks promising but we're really not starting on good vibes...

22

u/nicoburns Mar 16 '23

I would be excited for the GUI framework if it was cross platform and already open source (or with a clear timeline on open sourcing). As it is, I could name at least five rust-based GPU-accelerated GUI frameworks that are more promising.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/nicoburns Mar 16 '23

Something like: Slint, Iced, Xilem, Dioxus/Freya, Vizia

29

u/guerres Mar 15 '23

At least for the macOS-only start, I get it. If you've never worked on a cross-platform desktop app at scale, the manual QA testing matrix can get unmanageable really quickly. Like, of course you should try to cover as much as you can with robust automated cross-platform testing, but there's still no automated substitute for trying to reproduce a bug from a bug report and develop an understanding of the problem. And having to do that for 3 platforms out of the gate with a tiny team... yeah, that's a lot, enough to potentially distract from product work in those critical early days.

I'd be more disappointed in a cross-platform beta that was just, wildly unstable in different ways on all 3 because they had to split their attention. But, if it turned out to be Mac-only for life, and not just for the early part of the beta, that would be pretty disappointing.

27

u/Speykious inox2d · cve-rs Mar 15 '23

You're not wrong. But the thing with Rust is that it's much easier to create cross-platform apps. I still wonder why they chose to use Metal over WGPU...

11

u/raheel_sawaali Mar 15 '23

Isn’t wgpu backed by Metal on macOS?

21

u/Speykious inox2d · cve-rs Mar 15 '23

Precisely. While also supporting Vulkan on Windows and Linux, DirectX12 on Windows and GLES3 on Linux. That's why I'm curious why they used Metal directly.

8

u/asmx85 Mar 15 '23

I would imagine they started when wgpu wasn't available and/or unstable/unusable?

3

u/Speykious inox2d · cve-rs Mar 15 '23

I don't know. Fair enough if that's the case I guess...

3

u/guerres Mar 15 '23

Huh, that is a really good question. I hope they consider just using wgpu instead of their own handrolled Metal shaders.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23

Maybe they wanted more control? From my understanding they wanted something very low level while wgpu is sorta high level, it even provides a safe API. Maybe blade or wgpu-Hal would be suitable options for them

1

u/Keavon Graphite Mar 16 '23

I recall reading on their site (last time I visited it a few weeks ago) that they began before WGPU was much of anything.

3

u/protestor Mar 15 '23

What is the GUI framework?

8

u/Speykious inox2d · cve-rs Mar 15 '23

It's called GPUI. But it's not open source yet, and MacOS-only using Metal.

3

u/vasametropolis Mar 16 '23

This is.. an interesting choice. Is that temporary or will it always be macOS only? Seems like Swift would have been better if that was the case.

1

u/Speykious inox2d · cve-rs Mar 16 '23

Temporary, since they plan to support Windows and Linux. I mean they won't necessarily remove all the Metal code idk, but they'll have to implement the renderer with other graphics APIs.

0

u/dylantb95 Mar 15 '23

Pretty sure they’re going to make core editor open source. faq section - scroll to open source

25

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23

Our intention is to open-source the core of Zed while omitting any code related to features we aim to monetize.

The exact timing of when these pieces will be open to the public isn't clear to us at this point, but we will share updates as they emerge.

&

We'd like to be as open as possible while maintaining the ability to run a profitable business. This probably means some kind of "open core" model, where the editor is available under the GPL but other parts of our system remain proprietary. The timeline and exact strategy are still uncertain at this stage.

So Microsoft VSCode but with even worse licensing.

17

u/nicoburns Mar 15 '23

Well, they claim they're going to. In the meantime we should treat them like any commercial company and not give them extra credit on the basis of a promise they haven't actually delivered on yet. Especially when their current license seems to have much more draconian terms than most.

4

u/Speykious inox2d · cve-rs Mar 15 '23

I know. I didn't say "they are closed source", I said they were starting closed source and that I still find it odd. I've been told previously that the reason the core is not already open source is because they "haven't made the separation yet", which is why I mention it.

2

u/dylantb95 Mar 15 '23

Ah, apologies, I must’ve misread. Yeah it is really odd. I guess we’ll see if anything changes after the beta.

118

u/cameronm1024 Mar 15 '23

No matter how cool the product, I don't think I could bring myself to use a closed-source editor.

As for frame rates, you wouldn't believe the FPS I get with neovim :p it even keeps up with a 360hz display

21

u/not_user_telken Mar 15 '23

I see you are a man of culture as well

19

u/Zalack Mar 16 '23

Aren't Jetbrains' editors closed source?

I really like open source mentally as well, but I'm not sure I like the idea of demanding that other people open source their projects.

I get not using closed source projects, but since comments get really nasty whenever someone announces a closed source program (not yours, just a bunch of other comments I've seen).

13

u/KingofGamesYami Mar 16 '23

Aren't Jetbrains' editors closed source?

Some are. The community editions are open source, but may include closed source plugins. Additionally, the paid versions will include closed source plugins.

To quote Jetbrains own documentation:

The IntelliJ Platform is Open Source, under the Apache License, and hosted on GitHub.

...

The IntelliJ Platform underlies many JetBrains IDEs. IntelliJ IDEA Ultimate is a superset of the IntelliJ IDEA Community Edition but includes closed source plugins (see this feature comparison).

9

u/cameronm1024 Mar 16 '23

I believe they are. To be clear, I'm not demanding anything is licensed in a particular way. If you put your time into some software, it's up to you who gets to use it and under what conditions.

I don't have a blanket policy around open source software. I use chrome, slack, hell, even Reddit. But for me personally, a is so core and fundamental that it's essentially a requirement that it's open source. A few scenarios that pop into my head are:

  • a feature that I use is now paid-for

  • I get given "recommendations for services I might be interested in" (i.e. ads)

  • the developer stops maintaining it and the project dies

  • private source code is leaked because it was accidentally included in "telemetry"

Not saying any of these are especially likely, but I want my editor to be something I can trust. And I find it hard to trust closed source code

2

u/Administrative_chaos Mar 16 '23

You probably use a comparable terminal as well in that case ;) because that's what does the actual drawing.

2

u/imhayeon Mar 16 '23

BTW: it keeps up with 240hz display and I’m pretty sure it’ll easily get 360fps

26

u/AceofSpades5757 Mar 15 '23

This looked cool for about 5 minutes. Now I'm just deeply disappointed...

112

u/Recatek gecs Mar 15 '23

This is cool but I feel like I'm drowning in choice when it comes to code editors. I want an ecosystem of more complete IDEs.

21

u/TheJodiety Mar 15 '23

would love something like emacs but more of an ide, code completion and easy to use graphical debugging by default.

71

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23

You say that you want emacs without need to know how to configure emacs.

77

u/Arshiaa001 Mar 15 '23

Is that so odd, wanting a tool that works for you out of the box instead of having to spend a month learning to set something up?

8

u/ummonadi Mar 15 '23

Amen! I've wanted to use vim for years, but never do because of how hard it is to configure the right way compared to vscode.

8

u/Thing342 Mar 16 '23

Helix editor hits the sweet spot for me.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/x_JustAThrowaway69_x Mar 15 '23

You could try LunarVim (its what I use). Its Neovim with a whole bunch of plugins and sensible defaults while still being easy to customize.

4

u/ansible Mar 15 '23

Link for the lazy: https://www.lunarvim.org/

I've gotten ... eh, halfway? ... through configuring NeoVIM for Rust code editing using the LSP. Right now it does a whole bunch of annoying things. Like when it finds an error, it shifts everything over two columns to place a marker on the line where the error is. I find that so jarring. Warnings appear after the code on the line where the error is, but the warnings are verbose, and run off the right side without showing me anything actually useful. I suppose if they automatically wrapped and shifted everything else down that I would dislike that even worse.

At any rate, maybe I'll give LunarVIM a try. I can live with dedicating some screen space to status, error messages and whatnot, but dynamically shifting things around is a big pet peeve of mine.

4

u/Administrative_chaos Mar 16 '23

Try :set signcolumn=yes to mitigate that shifting behaviour. Though it just permanently shifts things and you might not like that :P

And you can do :lua vim.lsp.buf.hover() to show the diagnostic in a floating window. People usually bind that to K, since by default K (:h K) uses the keywordprg option (:h 'keywordprg') to look up the keyword under the cursor and that's like analogous to looking up the diagnostic under the line.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Arshiaa001 Mar 15 '23

Use VS code with the VIM plugin!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Ghosty141 Mar 15 '23

Then why use emacs in the first place? I mean DOOM/Spacemacs comes close.

3

u/pascalkuthe Mar 16 '23

You guys might be interested in helix. We had this exact vision that we don't want to spent a month configuring our editor while still having acess to a powerful modal and lightweight edito. My personal config is 10 times long.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Zagerer Mar 15 '23

I mean, you still need to learn the hotkeys and things that the new ide offers you

23

u/Arshiaa001 Mar 15 '23

That's faaaaaar less time consuming that learning an entire language and setting everything up bit by bit.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/po8 Mar 15 '23

Have been using emacs continuously since 1985. At this point, it has become basically unconfigurable by mortals. I have tried to get Rust Analyzer running with it three times in the last couple of years, and given up after many hours each time. I have written substantial amounts of emacs lisp in the past and still can't configure the damn thing.

Am going to give another try at getting used to vscode. We'll see.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Recatek gecs Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23

Agreed. A few tool/editor combos give visual debugging already but support is still pretty basic in some places. Also no Rust IDE experience to my knowledge currently gives you Visual Studio-like build configuration selection in a way that affects code highlighting (e.g. select the "server" build config from the pulldown and all #[cfg(not(server))] blocks gray out).

3

u/mihirtoga97 Mar 15 '23

Intellij Rust kind of does visual debugging and has the feature selection thing with the Cargo.toml gutter icons right?

2

u/Recatek gecs Mar 15 '23

That's only for features, and can't be easily associated with full build configs. You can't, for example, specify a custom compilation conditional as part of a build config in a pulldown menu and have it control code highlighting and inline hints the way you can in, say, Visual Studio.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23

[deleted]

1

u/Recatek gecs Mar 15 '23

Yeah, I think all the ingredients are there, but it would be nice to have a pulldown menu like Visual Studio to change those configs.

6

u/EdorianDark Mar 15 '23

What are you missing with VS-Code? I used Visual Studio for a long time and i am not missing anything now in VS-Code.

31

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23
  • Performance. It's not unusably slow but go and try Lapce (or I guess Zed) and you will see what we are missing.

  • Performance management of extensions. Extensions very often get stuck indexing all files in a large project or whatever. The c++ one is particularly bad. Unfortunately it's difficult to diagnose due to the use of very long command lines with no identifying information, and the built in Process Viewer doesn't work at all. It's bad enough that people have resorted to this.

  • Some useful refactoring features like moving items to a different file are impossible (at least via the LSP).

  • Various useful extensions are closed source (SSH, C++, Python).

I really like VSCode but better is definitely possible.

9

u/Recatek gecs Mar 15 '23

To add to the other list:

  • Build configurations that let you control compiler flags and #[cfg] toggles (not just for features, but also custom conditionals) that are reflected in code highlighting/inline hinting rather than just building/running.

  • In-editor profiling tools -- Visual Studio does a very good job here for C# and C++.

  • A better debugging experience in general, especially on Windows. The code-lldb debugger doesn't handle PDB files well and often won't visualize even fairly basic data structures. There also isn't good support for things like memory breakpoints (CLion provides this, but doesn't provide other things).

  • Viewing disassembly with custom filters. There's cargo-show-asm but that's not integrated into any IDE yet. CLion has some support for this while debugging but not outside of it.

4

u/physics515 Mar 15 '23

This has promise since it's from the guys who build Atom. So they have experience building very popular/useful IDEs.

20

u/Puzzleheaded-Cold-45 Mar 16 '23 edited Mar 16 '23

License to Your Content. Subject to any applicable account settings that you select, you grant Zed a fully paid, royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable, worldwide, royalty-free, non-exclusive and fully sublicensable right (including any moral rights) and license to use, license, distribute, reproduce, modify, adapt, publicly perform, and publicly display Your Content (in whole or in part) for the purposes of operating and providing the Service to you and to our other Registered Users. Please remember that other Registered Users may search for, see, use, modify and reproduce any of Your Content that you submit to any “public” area of the Service or . You warrant that the holder of any worldwide intellectual property right, including moral rights, in Your Content, has completely and effectively waived all such rights and validly and irrevocably granted to you the right to grant the license stated above. You agree that you, not Zed, are responsible for all of Your Content that you Make Available on or in the Service.

As another commenter said: that's a hard pass for me.

69

u/Grisemine Mar 15 '23

Mays I suggest instead Lapce (https://lapce.dev) :

  • open source, written in Rust

  • Mac, Windows and Linux

  • work well with most of languages

  • integrated terminal

  • dozens of themes, plugins & utilities

29

u/oaeben Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23

Warning, this app is in heavy development and far from ready, it's more like an early pre-alpha version

Also a lot of the official plugins weren't updated in a very long time and don't even work (like... javascript)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

used it and ran into a lot of bugs... as an at best intermediate user who didn't touch any of the more advanced features. Can't imagine how stressful it must be for power users.

the bugs I ran into was it refusing to save (I think they fixed that a few versions later) and the terminal breaking every other restart, plus the terminal let you scroll between builds meaning errors between each attempt would flow between each other.

Its good, its fast, but for now I'll just sit beside the outlet and use clion

3

u/sparky8251 Mar 16 '23

early pre-alpha version

It says "Pre-alpha Stage" above the download button, so not far off lol

10

u/pascalkuthe Mar 16 '23

helix is actually much more mature and sees much more development activity. Its currently a TUI mot a GUI but it's actually much more approachable than other TUI editors (we have many people that migrate from VSCode) and does not require a complex setup (everything is configured out of the box). Especially with the next release coming up this month there will be many long awaited features added (like softwrap, snippets, inlay type hints and much more).

2

u/ispinfx Mar 16 '23

While having a lot of features, Lapce is buggy...

1

u/Grisemine Mar 16 '23

I use it extensively, still have to find a bug ;)

1

u/chintakoro Mar 16 '23

is the vim modal approach baked in or configurable? i kinda like how zed has keybindings for vscode or vim (or…) as configurable.

1

u/Grisemine Mar 16 '23

"Vim users, we've got you covered! Built-in support for a Vim like editing experience, without a plugin."

1

u/chintakoro Mar 16 '23

i was looking for the opposite of that :D was hoping to be able to turn off any vim like experience. (vi/vim is great but i never developed the muscle memory for it)

2

u/Grisemine Mar 16 '23

Dont use the mode, I just quoted. Works like a "normal" fast and clean advanced editor with a terminal (that keeps memory of commands between sessions ;))

1

u/yusufmalikul Nov 13 '23

Lapce is good.

but when in idle state I get a bad experience, it starts to suck my battery like vscode.

12

u/Adhalianna Mar 15 '23

I have recently listened to the Rustacean Station episode about Zed and my first impression was that there was some unnecessary duplication of effort with lapce being already out there. I was surprised that nobody on the episode seemed to know that there's another IDE written in Rust. I wonder how different will their plugin APIs be and if porting plugins from one to another will be difficult. They are both using WASM for plugins.

6

u/thoomfish Mar 15 '23

Zed's main gimmick (and the part they plan to keep closed source and make money on) is the collaborative editing bits which require specific internal data structures to work. I'd bet that's not trivial to bolt on to an existing project.

11

u/UpsetCake8010 Mar 15 '23

The description of multiplayer for code editor is funny. The first thing that comes to my mind is calling some friend to do a co-op and tackle down this hard boss.

Jokes aside, I've used only once or twice the vscode live share feature. I don't think that it would be like a killer feature for an editor. But I have to agree once you need it, it's nice to have it!

5

u/GuybrushThreepwo0d Mar 15 '23

I mean it's not like it's ground breaking. You van technically already do this with vim, ssh and tmux. Though admittedly that has a higher technical barrier to entry

9

u/guerres Mar 15 '23

u/maxbrunsfeld Correct me if I'm wrong, but from reading the rendering blog post it seems like Zed's GUI framework (GPUI) is currently pretty tightly coupled to Metal on macOS. Since the plan is to open source GPUI eventually, would one of the prereqs for open sourcing be to add support for other graphics APIs like Vulkan / DirectX / WebGPU?

I'm just wondering because otherwise downstream consumers would only be able to build Mac apps with it, even if nothing else about their apps is doing anything particularly platform-specific.

17

u/thoomfish Mar 15 '23

It's impressively fast, but I need direnv support before I can actually use it for anything, for my Nix shell development environments.

1

u/Earthqwake Mar 16 '23

My direnv activated right away when the terminal opened. What integration are you expecting?

2

u/thoomfish Mar 16 '23

I need it to be able to see the $PATH and other environment variables setup by direnv when looking for things like LSP servers, which I do not have installed system-wide, only in a nix shell.

39

u/darth_chewbacca Mar 15 '23

Good interview with one of the creators

https://rustacean-station.org/episode/antonio-scandurra/

Unfortunately it's MacOS only at the moment.

95

u/Ketomatic Mar 15 '23

Unfortunately it's MacOS only at the moment.

Oh that's... extremely disappointing.

14

u/Puncake4Breakfast Mar 15 '23

Unfortunately it's MacOS only at the moment.

Oof thats disappointing

2

u/not_user_telken Mar 15 '23

Ugh, those filthy peasants

1

u/devraj7 Mar 15 '23

Definitely interesting to listen to, but the fact that Antonio was saying "Like" all the time was very distracting to me.

14

u/dorianim Mar 15 '23

Any plans of open sourcing this?

2

u/JustAGuyWhoLikesMath Mar 27 '23

Yes, this will be fully open source and cross platform. Most of the devs use osx atm so they are beta testing closed sources on mac

14

u/woodalchi96 Mar 15 '23

Crap. Only Mac.

13

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23

Let's just improve helix shall we? Plug-ins? Copilot?

9

u/Earthqwake Mar 16 '23

I'm so stoked about the future of helix! Next release will have LSP type inlay hints and soft wrap mode among other great features.

A wgpu based gui with a lisp or wasm plugin system would be so lovely on top!

I'm glad the team is focused now on polishing what they have and building out the batteries included features.

1

u/drpika12 Mar 16 '23

where did you find the info regarding the next release?

3

u/Earthqwake Mar 16 '23

I've just been watching and testing incoming PRs

2

u/dragonelite Mar 18 '23

I do the same every week or every other week just look at the PR and what has been merged. I'm still missing some features but helix is improving fast maybe next year I might use it for all my coding.

6

u/sainishwanth Mar 16 '23

Was just trying out "warp" terminal yesterday and was immediately put off by the mandatory login (on a terminal???) And telemetry.

Not another one these again...Are these from the same company by any chance? Similar domain names, keep using the term "multiplayer", telemetry, rust based, similar UI since both use the metal API..

61

u/nathansobo Mar 15 '23

Hey, Zed founder here. I can see why people are upset about the license, and we will work to improve it. The terms people are referring to were meant to refer to the server side interactions, and I think that was lost in communication with the lawyers. I should have taken more care when reviewing the terms they put together, but I was in a rush and wasn't careful. This is on me, and I'll work to fix it. Thanks for the feedback.

To be clear, we have no expectation of monitoring anything that goes on in the client without your explicit consent. But I realize the language of our agreement needs to be updated and clarified to enforce that.

Apologies.

19

u/bik1230 Mar 16 '23

Any plans to let lawyers read the actual license text? Because it's clearly invalid more or less everywhere, and basically begging for fines in the EU. And if your lawyers were on board with that license, please find better lawyers.

12

u/Erfeyah Mar 15 '23

The project certainly looks very interesting. But it will be quite tricky to convince people to invest in a new editor if there is any uncertainty about its current or future licensing..

3

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '23

For those reading the Zed founders response, check out my comment here as to why you should still be skeptical.

11

u/InflateMyProstate Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23

Your co-owner was on the Rustacean Station podcast the other day! I enjoyed the podcast and it sounded very interesting, but Zed’s license is absolutely ludicrous and downright malicious. Clown behavior, I’d be embarrassed to have my name tied to this. I will be sharing with others to avoid this project at all costs. Hopefully this can be a learning opportunity for others.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

assuming the license gets changed, i'm excited for this since atom was very innovative UI wise relative to vscode.

15

u/stusmall Mar 15 '23

A bunch of my coworkers use it and love it. I haven't had a chance to try it yet, since I'm majority Linux, but sounds like they are building a great product.

3

u/redditSno Mar 16 '23

No thank you. Nvim for life. Might as well use VSCode.

4

u/YetAnotherRando Mar 15 '23

I've tried it and it's pretty snazzy, but the lack of full Vim support is a major issue to me.

6

u/Zakis88 Mar 15 '23

Have been using this quite a bit recently and it's definitely impressive in terms of speed. Hopefully when it becomes more feature complete it can become my daily driver.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

Nah, just written in Rust won't make us lick this thing if it's closed source...

2

u/ummonadi Mar 16 '23

Feature request is the ability to record your streams so others can play, pause, and then interact with the code in different ways, like run the code or copy/paste the code as it is at a certain timestamp.

Audio recording sync would be needed, but not video.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '23

i tried zed out today and really enjoyed it! Looking forward to the future of this project

4

u/shuuterup Mar 16 '23

How is this still not downvoted to oblivion?!

3

u/HyperReal_eState_Agt Mar 16 '23

What’s with the obsession with telemetry? Selling data analytics or something?

2

u/-n26 Mar 16 '23

I have been using it for almost a year now as my main editor (in closed beta), and I have used all the editors. Why I like it:
- Faster than VSCode (the input latency and slow UI drives me crazy)
- Better (and out-of-the-box) LSP integration than Sublime Text
- It has a GUI (TUIs like neovim, helix, amp, etc. don't work for me)
- Overall more polished compared to Lapce (in its current state)

In a nutshell: fast editor that works out of the box (unless of course you are not on macOS, or write in a language that it does not support).

It rescued me out of VSCode fatigue and put a lot of joy back into coding for me. It does not have all the features I'd like my editor to have, but it just works and is fast which I value more than what is still missing.

I'll still keep an eye out for CodeEdit though (due to its macOS native UI; don't really care whether my editor is written in Rust as long as it has a decent UI and ist fast).

1

u/Whatakey Mar 15 '23

"Currently, Zed only supports macOS. Support for other platforms is planned, but it is not being prioritized in the short term."

For the short term as a windows user, I'll not test and give you feedback, Linux users too!

1

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

Give me a Linux build and I will try it out

1

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

When you say "transcends Electron" is it still browser-based?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

OK, I don't get why you're talking about Electron on the site then.

1

u/hatsagorts Mar 16 '23

I love the speed of releasing new libs/frameworks/software in recent years

1

u/banjo001 Mar 20 '23

How did you integrate Alacritty into Zed? I am trying to integrate a terminal into my app.

1

u/cthutu Jun 06 '23

Forget this - closed source, macosx only, really dodgy illegal license. Look to supporting Lapce and its plugins.

1

u/Muqito Mar 15 '23

Much anticipated. Sent an invite to a friend of mine. He likes it; I haven't been able to test it out myself yet due to not having a mac.

1

u/s1n7ax Mar 15 '23

I just want a text editor with Neovim like APIs to extend the capabilities through plugins. It's sad that Helix did not have it planned from the beginning.

1

u/tobimai Mar 15 '23

So VScode LiveShare

0

u/gibriyagi Mar 15 '23

It would be interesting to see a very well baked in Github co-pilot / ChatGPT support for the multiplayer part.

Like playing against/with computer in a computer game when there is no one else around.

1

u/mtndewforbreakfast Mar 16 '23

And for some other prospective users that would be a death knell.

0

u/MS_GundamWings Mar 15 '23

Decent reason to dust off the old macbook and give this a shot.

0

u/kroos_47 Mar 15 '23

Would love to try it out! 🤩

-1

u/LoganDark Mar 16 '23

Oof, you changed it to only 10.15 and up... there goes my personal machine which shall never be updated past 10.14 for reasons.

2

u/ryanmcgrath Mar 16 '23

The license is shit on this, but expecting any software to support a now unsupported OS will increasingly be swimming against the tide.

Hell you’re not even getting security updates anymore.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/GermanCoatHanger Mar 15 '23

Why is this better than VS code with live share?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

I think this focus on CRDTs and multiple simultaneous editors is a red herring. The example use-cases they use to sell it all sound great, but IMO would be *better* with a virtual-conch that only allows one editor at a time, or using micro-diffs to proffer suggested edits.

0

u/haevaristo Mar 16 '23

Why would anyone code in multiplayer !? Wtf is wrong with screen share to review code together ?! It just sounds a solution in search for a problem...

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23

I don't own a mac and I don't plan to buy one :wq

-2

u/Environmental-Rip826 Mar 16 '23

Take your botnet and shove it up your ass, OP