r/rpg_gamers • • Dec 31 '23

Discussion Fallout 3 was Bethesda's last good game, and Skyrim was their last decent game

2 Upvotes

Ever since Skyrim, Beth has stripped mechanics and RPG systems out their games until the games barely classify as "RPG" anymore. I saw one comment on YouTube saying, "Bethesda isn't a game developer anymore, they are a game factory" which I think sums it up all to well. They lost passion and only care for the money. It's strictly a business now. What happened to the art?


r/rpg_gamers • • Mar 07 '25

Discussion Avowed is fantastic!

60 Upvotes

I recently did a review on Avowed and it is really dissappinting how stupid the discussion around the game has been.

It is a phenomenal rpg that has some of the best first person rpg combat around. It is incredibly fast and fluid.

The movement and parkour system is also incredible. It is so smooth! It really allows for some great vertical exploration.

I really reccomend you give it a shot! Especially since it is on gamepass.


r/rpg_gamers • • Aug 20 '25

Discussion getting tired of the gaslighting when we bring up how AAA rpg are dying-ish

0 Upvotes

What sparked this was the launch announcement for Vampire the Masquerade bloodline 2, which you know, is based on a TTRPG and is a sequel to a known cult classic RPG and from the people who got to get their hands on it, as to be expected, it's another franchise that ends up going the Action Stealth Adventure ""rpg"" route where the rpg aspect are extremely dumbed down and the real focus is the action, combat, platforming and stealth.

We've seen this happen with fallout, elder scrolls, dragon age, etc... but whenever we bring up how most games who claim to be rpgs in todays AAA sphere are merely action games with a bit of rpg flavor, so many gamers will try to gaslight you into believing that they're still "very much rpgs".

Not saying that there are no rpgs today, we got kingdom come deliverance, BG3 and other great titles, but if we look at the franchises who used to be great rpgs and where they often end up now, it really does feel like rpgs as a term is getting stretched very thin.

What are your thoughts on this?


r/rpg_gamers • • Nov 26 '24

if I enjoyed both BG3 and DA Veilguard what other games do you guys recommend ? (PS5 Only) thanks also no judgement lol

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/rpg_gamers • • Apr 07 '25

Appreciation The Most Impressive Open-World RPG

Post image
0 Upvotes

Been playing this non-stop for over a month since I got it on sale, and I have to say: to have an open world like this incredible! Keep in mind Witcher 3 predates the likes of Breath of the Wild & Red Dead Redemption 2, but it was THIS good?! Seriously, there buildings with levels and items you interact with. NPCs with all sorts of behavior. Monsters that roam the land. Regions with a unique feel. And side quest with lore and/or a story behind them! The fact that this released a decade ago is frickin insane! Universal acclaim & mega commercial success well-earned!


r/rpg_gamers • • Jun 09 '25

Obsidian seems to be have been left behind by new emerging Studios

16 Upvotes

Was really hyped for Outer Worlds 2 even after Avowed seemed like a let down ( was expecting more from Obisidian ... but the grapevine circulating that it was supposed to be multiplayer project which was later converted into a Single player game...) ..

Untill i saw the trailers for Owlcats's latest Expanse game and Inxile's Clockwork tower ... OuterWorlds 2's trailer seemed polished but did not get me hyped or invested in the story.. made me feel like getting and playing it on Game pass instead of buying it . ( Owlcat and Inxile may fumble ..)

Obsidian seems to be turning into a sweatshop of making AA games with stories and characters which are forgettable ... they churning out 3 games in a year ... Hope they have a story team being fostered instead of developers doing same part-time ...

EDIT ... new and newer studios(Owlcat being the oldest .. Expedition 33.. released game and The Blood of Dawnwalker and Expanse game trailers ) .....

and peers (like Inxile .)


r/rpg_gamers • • Jan 24 '24

Discussion Ok. Disco Elysium. "Best RPG of all time ". I try it and its just a game with a wall of text every moment with discombobulated Thesaurus and Dictionary fueled rants.

0 Upvotes

Maybe I was expecting a more traditional RPG. but its just a wall after wall after wall of text and after 5 lines i am like. I want to play a game to relax. If I wanted to read more than play i'd rather read a good book. Anyone else feel this way. I am really surprised looking at other RPGs this is rated this high


r/rpg_gamers • • Jul 22 '26

News Hound13's big flagship Anime-styled singleplayer/co-op RPG successor to Dragon Nest, 'DragonSword: Awakening', delayed indefinitely in final hour before launch

Thumbnail
store.steampowered.com
0 Upvotes

Hello.
This is Producer JYJ from Hound13.

To everyone who has taken an interest in <DragonSword : Awakening> and waited so patiently — from the bottom of our hearts, thank you.

<DragonSword : Awakening> was originally planned to launch at July 23, 07:00 (KST) / July 22, 15:00 (PT).

However, the app review currently in progress on Steam has not yet been completed, and we are unable to release the game at the scheduled time.

In our eagerness to bring the game to you as soon as possible, we did not sufficiently account for Steam's review timeline — and as a result, we have failed to keep our promise to you.

We know that no words can be enough.
To everyone who has waited so long, we sincerely apologize for not being able to release the game on the promised schedule.

We have completed our response to all items requested by Steam, and are currently awaiting the final review result.
We will do everything in our power to release the game as soon as the review is complete.

We will inform you again as soon as the new launch schedule is confirmed.

Once again, we deeply apologize to everyone who has been waiting.
We will give our best right up to the final moment to deliver an experience worthy of the time you have given us.

Thank you.

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Kind of crazy that there would even be a countdown clock at all if this necessary check wasn't yet passed...? IDK, but the community seems to be reeling and theorizing as to what the heck happened here...will this affect the reception of the game long term?


r/rpg_gamers • • Mar 13 '25

Discussion Both RPGs come on out the SAME day next week. Which one are you getting?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/rpg_gamers • • Nov 29 '25

Discussion My Problem With The Outer Worlds.

0 Upvotes

I never played a Fallout game, a TES game, a Bethesda game or an Oblivion game in my life. Not because I wasnt intrigued by them I just dont play many games. So, anyway just saying that to let you know this is a fresh experience for me and I was under no false expectations. Though, I did watch gameplay videos of them so I am aware how they feel similiar to The Outer Worlds. Also, I read some old threads here about Oblivion and the game and I have seen some users sidelining some criticisms by labeling them as attacks due to mismatching politics and such. I have no problems with LGBTI representation in video games, I am pro-gay marriage I think everyone has the right to live their lifes as they see fit as long as they dont interfere with others. Kind of wild I had to make that statement for stating an opinion on a video game.

Gameplay.

Combat is very very boring. It isnt just generic, it is straight out not fun. I think the biggest reason behind that is because enemies are bullet sponges. This is a terrible thing in a video game that breaks the immersion and seriously hinders and restricts unique approaches, tactical gameplay. I know there is an advantage to stealth but it is like a slight bonus rather than an alternative playing style. Your first hit deals some more damage. Enemies also feel very uninspired and generic. Marauders, raiders seriously? They also have these typical ''insane gone mad'' lore behind them. Like couldnt you name these bandits in a more unique way, couldnt you give them some better lines, dialogues between them that delved into their reasons behind leaving city life behind?

Gunplay is also a disappointment that contributes to this boringness. Why still wild west kind of guns? Seriously who was it that first thought it is cool to have sci-fi wild west guns in space? Revolvers seriously?

This tinkering upgrade system is utter laziness too. Tinker it, it levels up, it is now a better gun... Like how much can ''tinkering'' make a factory made standard weapon better? How the hell does that work?

Now I have seen some comments here saying it is an rpg game so it doesnt have to have a very good combat system. Is it though? Of course it is but does the rpg aspect of the game successfully compensate for lack of a good combat? No, it doesnt! Rpg in this game is so mild that probably the next Far Cry if the trend continues will catch up! Far Cry already has health bars, companions, skill trees, weapon upgrades, different cartridges, looting, different armors with different perks... What was that? These dont constitute an rpg game? Well, Obsidian feels like you are wrong!

Persuation, Lying, Lockpicking, Hacking... these are just some additional tools in your arsenal to progress in this linear game. They allow you to loot stuff, stuff that you can loot elsewhere not unique stuff I mind you. At best, they allow you some very mild shortcuts.

About skills yeah... attributes refer to skills that overlap in such a way that they are almost pointless. Overall it is all designed in a way that it is almost impossible to create a unique build. The only meaningful difference you can create seemed to me that either creating a companion heavy character or not and a melee heavy character or not. You can almost always lie and persuade your way through the game no matter how you built your character and that feels inconsequential too.

Story.

I had great hopes for the story. I was intrigued by the Rich Sanchez type character at the intro. Corporation dystopia was also an interesting universe idea. Is it executed well though? Unfortunately not. It is the same gimmick all over the game. Corporation brainwashed people. People in this game also all are represented to suffer from low iq. Everyone is very gullible. Also, the motivation that was set for the entire game wasnt really motivating to be honest. You even forget about it after first ten minutes. It was something about saving people stuck in cryogenic sleep? People you have never met, people you basically dont care. It can only be a motivation for a side mission seriously. Why would I care for people I never met?

About companions, they arent empty shells or badly written generic people dont get me wrong but they dont feel like the type of people who would take up arms and fight alongside you against alien wildlife or bandits to be honest.

Parvati is a girl who aspires to be an engineer. Has an engineer lady as her idol whom she also falls in love to. What does she do to chase her aspirations? Kill thugs for her in gunfights. Same for the Vicar Max, a man of some sort of religion and he says he is good in combat?

The universe screams at your face at every opportunity it doesnt take itself seriously.


r/rpg_gamers • • Oct 28 '24

Discussion Dragon Age: The Veilguard - 83% of Critics Recommend (OpenCritic)

Thumbnail
opencritic.com
18 Upvotes

r/rpg_gamers • • May 21 '24 Heart of Silver

I've noticed that you usually can't romance black female characters in RPGs.

0 Upvotes

Usually, you'll have Black female characters, and they'll usually be very graceful/competent. Pallegina from Pillars of Eternity, Vivienne from Dragon Age: Inquisition, and Selah from Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteousness come to mind. However, you cannot romance them. It's unclear why Pallegina can't be romanced; maybe she's out of your league? Vivian is betrothed to Duke Bastien. And Selah is a lesbian; obviously there's nothing wrong with that, but you can't even romance her if your character is a woman, because she has someone already.

No matter the in-game reason, Black female characters are specially written to not be romanced and it's a strange pattern. "Who cares?" you ask. All the people who would want to romance women like Pallegina, Seelah and Vivienne, and ask "why can't I?"

Obviously, some White female characters can't be romanced either. But it seems like none of the Black female characters can be romanced, while some White female characters are too easy. Whenever there is a Black female character, you just can't, either for story reasons or...no reason at all. And it's a strange pattern: graceful, competent women that for some reason are just out of your league. You don't have to have every character like you, but why is it never Black female characters?

You can romance Black male characters, like Sosiel in Pathfinder: WoTR, but you have to be a man/male, because that's his preference. Come to think of it...

I wish I knew why there's a pattern like that. Are devs scared or feel awkward to have romances with Black females/women? Do they lack imagination or the empathy/perspective to realize that a Black woman is still a woman, while being flirted and romanced, like any woman? Are they intimidated by the idea of this in real life?

It's hard to think that programmers, who are intelligent, would have a oversight like this and just not think about it. But I also don't think it's anything malicious. Has anyone else noticed this?

*Aphra from Greedfall is the only exception to this pattern that I've found.


r/rpg_gamers • • Jun 14 '24

I feel that RPG audiences changed a lot after seeing reactions for DA:V

0 Upvotes

I visited the Dragon Age subreddit to see how people felt.

Things to consider: I'm an avid Origins fan (certain that's never coming back), lost all my faith in Bioware, and I'm old by gaming standards lol.

I was surprised by how many people did not care about the gameplay at all! Many users saying they only wanted the game for the lore and story.

I know I should not judge everyone by my own standards, but don't we also play RPGs to interact with complex systems, try character builds, party compositions, and all those things?

If you only care about the story why don't you go watch a series or read a book? I'm certain they will have much better writing.

I don't know, perhaps I'm not the target audience anymore, and that's ok. But seeing Dragon Age being turned into Arkham Knight really messed me up.

To note, I also enjoy RPGs like Disco Elysium, but they don't focus on combat by design. Excellent roleplaying though.


r/rpg_gamers • • Nov 03 '24 Heart Eyes

Honest review of Veilguard someone who has played every dragon age game

360 Upvotes

7.9.

Now to start of the dialogue gets a lot better later down the line. The first big area is dedicated to basically a catch up exposition dump. But I think once it picks up it’s pretty good story wise. About the HR in the room comment… it’s not really throughout the writing? Like there’s like 3 scenes so far where I kinda felt it was iffy but honestly that’s not a game thing. That’s a BioWare thing(looking at you krem)

Combat is fucking awesome. It gets way better as you unlock skills, and you can chain abilities together to deal more damage.

The art style 100%looks better in motion and it’s really easy to get used to. I don’t get the idea that this is the worst looking game. Origins came out when re5 came out. This is by far the best looking game.

Companions are pretty cool. Like a solid round of a dragon age party.

Rook is definitely gonna divide some people. I personally like him but I admit I really wish I could be a proper asshole sometimes. The whole idea of role playing is gonna skew some people. As someone who’s played cyberpunk and bg3 I’m fine with the options.

Honestly if you liked inquisition a lot you’ll like this game. I honestly prefer 2 to 1 because a lot more of the writing in origins does not hold up compared to 2, they make a big deal if your wardens a female, a lot of cheat SA scenes to get across its dark, and the whole ritual thing is a lot more immature than people remember. But it definitely is still peak DA. I lm really pissed though that anyone on YouTube who has a good opinion on the game is just getting bombarded with no this fucking sucks your opinion is wrong you’re not allowed to think it’s good(like Luke Stephen’s and Jake Baldino) the games nowhere near an abomination. I swear the dragon age fandoms like the fallout fandom sometimes never can agree on something😭


r/rpg_gamers • • Mar 24 '26

Review After 100 hours in Cyberpunk 2077, I don’t understand the hype

0 Upvotes

Cyberpunk 2077 is often described as a masterpiece, especially after all the updates it received over time. Many fans present it as one of the most immersive RPG experiences out there. After 100 hours, finishing both the main story and the DLC, I honestly don’t understand that perspective.

I went into the game with high expectations, hoping for a deep narrative and meaningful choices like in other great RPGs (for example Baldur’s Gate 3 or Mass Effect). But the more I played, the more I felt something was missing. From a technical standpoint, I have almost nothing to complain about. The gameplay is fun, the graphics are incredible, the city design is unique and the build system is interesting.
But when it comes to the “soul” of the game, that’s where it falls apart for me (spoiler alert).

Dialogue & Choices
The game gives you a lot of dialogue options, but in most cases they don’t actually matter. They change a line or two in the moment, but rarely have any long-term consequences.
Relationships don’t really evolve based on your behavior and there’s very little sense of building something over time with the characters.
In many cases, everything comes down to one or two key choices at the end of a questline, rather than a real progression shaped by your decisions (you can even enable the command console and see that relationships are basically handled as a boolean variable, true or false).

Romance
Romances felt very limited and underdeveloped for the same reason.
There are only a few options, some of them locked behind gender (I played as male V and Panam was basically the only option that felt somewhat relevant), and the outcome depends on 1/2 dialogue choices during the final missions, rather than an actual relationship arc.
And after successfully completing the romance? I could just invite her to my apartment over and over again, only to go through the exact same 3 dialogue lines every time.
There’s not even any progression in conversations based on what happens to V during the story, which makes everything feel static and artificial.

Story
This is subjective, but I found the story engaging at the beginning, especially during Evelyn’s arc.
After that, it became quite repetitive: you chase a possible solution, it turns out to be a dead end and the cycle repeats until the end.

Ending (biggest disappointment)
This was the part that disappointed me the most.
I completed all the side content and even finished the DLC before the final mission because I expected an ending that would reflect everything MY V had done.
Instead, you’re given 3 final choices that completely exclude each other.
For example, I chose to go with Panam and that basically removed the involvement of other important characters like Johnny or Takemura.
Everything I had done throughout the game felt reduced to a few messages during the credits, often not even consistent with the relationships I had built.

Final Thoughts
Is Cyberpunk 2077 a masterpiece RPG? In my opinion, not even close.
It’s a good game, with strong gameplay and presentation, but it lacks depth where it matters most for an RPG.


r/rpg_gamers • • May 03 '25

Recommendation request Are there any critical reviews of Avowed that aren't "anti-woke" rants?

0 Upvotes

I'm looking for videos/video essays that go in depth on the genuine strengths and weaknesses of the game that aren't just insecure maga bros ranting about the color palette being too gay or that being able to have your character be a woman is trying to force them to become trans or whatever.

Every video I've found is either that, or just a constant shower of praise with no critical thought or structure.

Anybody have any suggestions?


r/rpg_gamers • • Nov 21 '23

Discussion Crafting in RPGs is a boring waste of time - Change my mind.

1 Upvotes

I can't really imagine Conan the Barbarian or Mad Max or The Man With No Name taking time off from their exciting adventures to go harvest junk in the forests or wasteland or great plains and then build their stuff in some workshop. I don't want to follow Merlin or Gandalf while they go to the marsh to gather toad sweat and hag's mucus to concoct their spells.

I play RPGs in order to be an adventurer and do heroic deeds and fight monsters or mutants or outlaws, not to engage in tedious manual labor as a tradesman. Whenever I play RPGs, I usually ignore crafting altogether.

Crafting in RPGs is a boring fad whose time has passed.


r/rpg_gamers • • Aug 05 '25

Discussion Dragon Age 2 reception at release?

3 Upvotes

As a DA2 virgin I finally got around to playing after doing another run through of origins. Holy shit, this game is really fucking bad. Like legit one of the worst sequels and games I've ever played. A dialogue wheel that makes fallout 4 look like citizen kane, voiced protag has 0 emotion, can't change companion armor, the dumbest combat loop in video game history. Go into room, kill 8 guys, immediately 12 more spawn from the ceiling, rinse and repeat 8 times until the waves stop spawning then repeat 4 times per every room. Ya it has some really cool lore and writing to keep you interested but damn this game is one of the worst I've played in a long long time.


r/rpg_gamers • • Sep 26 '24

I believe that Baldur's Gate and Baldur's Gate 2 are still some of the greatest videogames ever made, even after the release of Baldur's Gate 3.

46 Upvotes

Hello guys. I am 22, and I have got an unpopular opinion to voice. One that's going to get me downvoted to oblivion and beyond.

I have seen that Baldur's Gate 3 has caused quite a ruckus as of late. People have lost their midnds over this game. I know that people love Baldur's Gate 3 and want to promote it as hard as possible.

However, I have to come out with an unpopular opinion. In my view, Baldur's Gate 1 and 2 are still some of the best games ever made. And I am going to die on that hill.

I mean, how great and immense are these games? Let's take a look at it.

First off, we have Baldur's Gate 1. And that is honestly such a good game. You start the game in a castle called Candlekeep, governed by monks. You are an orphan being raised by a man called Gorion. You have not much clue of your real parenthood, and of the great wide world.

One day, Gorion wakes you up and tells you that you need to leave Candlekeep immediately. Soon afterwards he is killed in an ambush. Having been left to your own devices, you are forced to venture forth and to uncover the truth behind the iron shortage crisis plaguing the Sword Coast.

Baldur's Gate is an absolutely incredible game. The scope of the game's design is absolutely stunning for 1998. There is absolutely no way to overappreciate the brilliance of this game.

However, the best was yet to come. 2 years after Baldur's Gate, Bioware made Baldur's Gate 2. A rare example of a sequel vastly superior to its predecessor. A game that continues to stun me after all those years.

Baldur's Gate 2 took the formula of the first game and improved on it in every way. First of all, we've got much more fleshed out companions, with mode dialogue, more interactions, and more voice acting. The world is much larger and has more things to do. Last but not least, the improvements to the loot system, the higher level DND gameplay, and the memorable villain make it a truly worthy successor.

In my opinion, these games are some of the best and most monumental ever made. The saga of the Bhaalspawn has a permanent place in the Gaming Hall of Fame, right alongside Kratos and the others.

To this day, there has hardly been an RPG game (besides maybe Planescape Torment, Dragon Age Origins, Disco Elysium, and Divinity Original Sin 2) to have risen to the heoghts of the original Baldur's Gate games. They remain the pinnacle of the cRPG experience.

In my opinion, the release of Baldur's Gate 3 hardly changes that.

What do you think about? What is your opinion on this? Would you disagree with me?


r/rpg_gamers • • May 07 '25

Discussion Starfield and FF16 are easily in the top 3 most boring rpgs I’ve ever played. What are yours?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/rpg_gamers • • Nov 27 '24

Discussion I did not have a good time with Planescape Torment

7 Upvotes

Recently bought PST Enhanced Edition on GOG as it went on sale. I think everyone agrees that the game has aged a LOT and the combat wasn't great even for the time period.

But besides struggling with the combat, the setting kinda got old to me in a matter of hours. It was interesting at first, but it quickly faded away as it became a matter of aesthetics, one which I'm not very fond of. The dialogue was very interesting, though, and the "death" mechanic was indeed unique compared to any games I had seen before.

I gotta say though, quests were VERY basic. They were all a matter of "go there, do this thing, grab this MacGuffin and come back" and a lot of the times, there were MORE quests like that when you came back, and then suddenly the guy was like "you know, now you've done enough, I'll give you exactly what you want!"

However, the main selling point of this game on the internet is the story. "The best story in a videogame ever", "The best book you'll ever play" and "Entirely original to its medium" are some of the things you'll often see said about PST. And it might have been true, but unfortunately, the game's themes like culpability and what it means to be human have been explored to death in other medium like Frankenstein and Blade Runner, so even that, while interesting, wasn't anything new or unique to me.

Also, the way the story is presented is... kinda weird. Like, you gotta find out about your past. So you go to this guy who pinky promises you he knows about you and can tell you a lot of important stuff, as long as you do some things for him first. At first, my reaction was "well, this dude's obviously bullshitting me" but then I did as requested and... he did give me a lot of pertinent info. So onto the next guy and the exact same thing happens. I think there were 4 NPCs in the first half of the game that were offputting, only to be direct and give me a ton of info. Expectation subversed I guess?

But I do think most of this is on me. My expectations going in were exceedingly high (especially regarding the story) and if I hadn't consumed a ton of media with the themes from the game, the overall experience would've probably been better. It's not a bad game by any metric, but combining its dated gameplay, the (personally) unappealing setting and themes I'm accustomed to, unfortunately PST wasn't as enjoyable as I wanted it to be.

For the people who played and enjoyed the game (which I expect is the majority) what did you like the most? How did your experience differ from mine? Let's talk :)


r/rpg_gamers • • Feb 01 '24

Games with queer romance options?

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I recently played AC Odyssey and liked it a lot! I’m looking for similar games/vibes where I can have queer romance options. Some of the ones that I already know:

Ac Valhalla, Dragon Age: Inquisition, Mass Effect

I’d appreciate if the vibe isn’t dark or moody like Valhalla or Elden Ring


r/rpg_gamers • • Feb 15 '25

Discussion Am I in the minority of RPG gamers?

0 Upvotes

Maybe I pay too much attention to other ppl’s opinions (or could be overreacting) but these days, bc video games all cost $60+, I have to rely on reviews to decide if they’re worth purchasing.

And I feel I’m struggling with 2 things:

  1. My genre doesn’t match up with what most other people enjoy. Unfortunately seeing bashing posts on the internet especially from someone with more credibility just sucks

  2. Critiques might have started as constructive feedback on aspects of the game that underdelivered, then it just went to the extreme end; games are either 1/10 or 9/10. No in and between. I agree with a lot of the critiques, but to hyperbolize things as a massive letdown when you have a huge fan base just feels idk really harsh.

For 1, I’m just not that into dark grimy env for every game and I like magical fantasy more. It’s hard not to check out some of the previews prior to these games releases without seeing ppl blasting them to shreds. Everybody on the internet seems to be into only dark fantasy and action and souls. I feel like I have to mute a post that I don’t agree with on YouTube or Reddit every day so they don’t jump on my feed.

For 2, The slate of games currently being talked down by the major streamers like SkillUp are also unfortunately games I enjoy casually. Specifically, games like dragon age veilguard and more recently Avowed. By talked down, I meant shred to bits and pieces. I’ll also hear from my friends who said because one major streamer said something, they’ll not check things out further on their own. Im tired of defending my preference when my friends talk down about them.


r/rpg_gamers • • Oct 05 '21

Discussion I think many people miss the definition of an RPG

1 Upvotes

I think alot of people would define an RPG as a game with the all the following 3 traits to some degree:

- Levelling up and stats

- Character actions and abilities unique to certain choices

- Exploration and quests

But I think a game can have all these things and not be an RPG, and I think, personally, there's a better definition we could use. Would we call destiny 2 an RPG? No, it follows all these traits, but deep down must people can realise it's not an RPG just by touching it. Would open world Call of Duty be an RPG? No, it would also have exploration and missions, levelling up, and specific perks and weapons exclusive to certain characters, but we all know open-world CoD would not be called an RPG deep down. Now, is Skyrim an RPG? Well quite obviously yes. So what's the difference when all these games have these 3 traits we use to define an RPG, but only one is in fact an RPG?

I think to examine this we have to ask the question "why do RPGs often have these 3 elements?" and how are the reasons destiny 2 has these elements different. I believe the reason RPGs often contain these elements is - they contribute to you roleplaying, the reason destiny 2 has it is to create fun meta and reward system that keeps you playing.

If we go through each of the aspects, character choices don't make something an RPG inherently, but they define your character in your mind and therefore make roleplay easier. Exploration doesn't make something an RPG, but it allows you to get in the head of a character reacting in a free form nature to what they discover. Levelling up doesn't make something an RPG inherently, but they let you define who your character is (let's say I've made a rogue; if I put my newly-levelled stat points into strength, I know I'm roleplaying a thug, if I put those points into charisma, I know I'm playing a silver-tounged assasin). Picking your class does much the same thing, arguably more effectively. I'm not just making up the idea of this either, I find the first copies of DnD had these mechanics for this reason.

This isn't to say all RPGs focus on roleplaying equally, some games are bad RPGs and their other parts are good (see fallout 3), whereas in some RPGs I roleplay a ton more (skyrim personally, D&D, fallout new vegas, and most crpgs). Nor am I saying if u don't roleplay you're playing an RPG wrong, this is just what I think the best definition for an RPG is, because I think if you don't enjoy roleplaying in an RPG you can get the same enjoyment from a game in a different genre which also has these elements (god of war 4 and monster hunter would be a good way to test this).

I think what we've been doing is defining an RPG not by what makes an RPG an RPG (roleplaying with an idea of who your character is), but instead by the mechanics that are common in RPGs because those mechanics let the game be a better RPG. This would be like defining something as ice cream if it has chocolate sauce and a cornet. The chocolate sauce (levelling, character choices, exploration) definately makes it a better ice cream (RPG), but it isn't what defines it (better RPG =/= better game).

A common response to this is "doesn't that mean an oldschool JRPG isn't an RPG?" and I have to say, I haven't played many. I tried to start chrono trigger and switched over to something else, and enjoyed secret of mana but didn't have the time for it when I was playing. The same is true of many modern JRPGs like the final fantasy VII remake. Perhaps this definition works better for "how do we define a western RPG?" But I'll leave others to debate that in the comments.

My definition of roleplay: acting as how you imagine your version of a character would act. E:G approaching the guard for a stealthy backstab as a lvl 20 thief in skyrim.