I never played a Fallout game, a TES game, a Bethesda game or an Oblivion game in my life. Not because I wasnt intrigued by them I just dont play many games. So, anyway just saying that to let you know this is a fresh experience for me and I was under no false expectations. Though, I did watch gameplay videos of them so I am aware how they feel similiar to The Outer Worlds. Also, I read some old threads here about Oblivion and the game and I have seen some users sidelining some criticisms by labeling them as attacks due to mismatching politics and such. I have no problems with LGBTI representation in video games, I am pro-gay marriage I think everyone has the right to live their lifes as they see fit as long as they dont interfere with others. Kind of wild I had to make that statement for stating an opinion on a video game.
Gameplay.
Combat is very very boring. It isnt just generic, it is straight out not fun. I think the biggest reason behind that is because enemies are bullet sponges. This is a terrible thing in a video game that breaks the immersion and seriously hinders and restricts unique approaches, tactical gameplay. I know there is an advantage to stealth but it is like a slight bonus rather than an alternative playing style. Your first hit deals some more damage. Enemies also feel very uninspired and generic. Marauders, raiders seriously? They also have these typical ''insane gone mad'' lore behind them. Like couldnt you name these bandits in a more unique way, couldnt you give them some better lines, dialogues between them that delved into their reasons behind leaving city life behind?
Gunplay is also a disappointment that contributes to this boringness. Why still wild west kind of guns? Seriously who was it that first thought it is cool to have sci-fi wild west guns in space? Revolvers seriously?
This tinkering upgrade system is utter laziness too. Tinker it, it levels up, it is now a better gun... Like how much can ''tinkering'' make a factory made standard weapon better? How the hell does that work?
Now I have seen some comments here saying it is an rpg game so it doesnt have to have a very good combat system. Is it though? Of course it is but does the rpg aspect of the game successfully compensate for lack of a good combat? No, it doesnt! Rpg in this game is so mild that probably the next Far Cry if the trend continues will catch up! Far Cry already has health bars, companions, skill trees, weapon upgrades, different cartridges, looting, different armors with different perks... What was that? These dont constitute an rpg game? Well, Obsidian feels like you are wrong!
Persuation, Lying, Lockpicking, Hacking... these are just some additional tools in your arsenal to progress in this linear game. They allow you to loot stuff, stuff that you can loot elsewhere not unique stuff I mind you. At best, they allow you some very mild shortcuts.
About skills yeah... attributes refer to skills that overlap in such a way that they are almost pointless. Overall it is all designed in a way that it is almost impossible to create a unique build. The only meaningful difference you can create seemed to me that either creating a companion heavy character or not and a melee heavy character or not. You can almost always lie and persuade your way through the game no matter how you built your character and that feels inconsequential too.
Story.
I had great hopes for the story. I was intrigued by the Rich Sanchez type character at the intro. Corporation dystopia was also an interesting universe idea. Is it executed well though? Unfortunately not. It is the same gimmick all over the game. Corporation brainwashed people. People in this game also all are represented to suffer from low iq. Everyone is very gullible. Also, the motivation that was set for the entire game wasnt really motivating to be honest. You even forget about it after first ten minutes. It was something about saving people stuck in cryogenic sleep? People you have never met, people you basically dont care. It can only be a motivation for a side mission seriously. Why would I care for people I never met?
About companions, they arent empty shells or badly written generic people dont get me wrong but they dont feel like the type of people who would take up arms and fight alongside you against alien wildlife or bandits to be honest.
Parvati is a girl who aspires to be an engineer. Has an engineer lady as her idol whom she also falls in love to. What does she do to chase her aspirations? Kill thugs for her in gunfights. Same for the Vicar Max, a man of some sort of religion and he says he is good in combat?
The universe screams at your face at every opportunity it doesnt take itself seriously.