r/rotp • • Jun 04 '26

HOLY HECK THAT WAS UNFUN

0 Upvotes

Love MOO1 favorite game
I knew about ROTP for awhile, do not like a lot of the changes. (Why does the guardian have 10k hp? You will literally never crack that in time for orion to matter. Am i crazy or does every race share a tech tree? etc.)
Like the UI improvements, the base AI was....ludicrously unchallenging, and boringly so. (they never seemed to research techs except the cheapest?) Dropped it.

Heard of fusion mod, gave it a chance. Saw the transport automatic which made xilni's AI sound fair.
The way the game went to war was just....brutally unfun. The AI didn't care about ships at all, entire wars for a huge chunk of the game were just...throwing transports at eachother.
Once one empire went to war at me every other empire i had met went "wait, your at war" so now i'm spending like 50 turns slowly eating through the darlocks while the alkari and mrrshan flip flop one of my planets every 2 turns.

I guess that makes "only research the cheapest techs" the correct strategy, perma ground war from day 3 makes anything besides your expansion tech impossible to get an edge with.

AS IT TURNS OUT, THE GOVERNOR DID NOT SAVE ME FROM ENDLESS TRANSPORT MICRO.


r/rotp • • Dec 25 '20

Is it really second beta?

2 Upvotes

As an experienced MOO player I can only tell it's another alpha version. Very long way to go.

UI

  • It tries to improve on MOO interface but it fails. It's painfully slow but maybe it's because I use Atom x8500 CPU. ROTP is memory hungry, maybe there's a memory leak? In one game on tiny galaxy it forced me to restart as it got close to using 1,35 GB.

  • Ship design screen is weird. Hard to tell what is clickable, what I'm able to change. It can be even harder for those who never played MOO.

  • Diplomacy is OK but what happened to single graph with all races? Why multiple screen instead of one with everything? Maybe it's tweaked to work well in huge galaxies with massive number of opponents but still....

  • Tech screen is awful. Really hard to look what tech are discovered. Please give us as much info as possible without clicking or scrolling.

  • Research screen - detailed info is good, but once again we are forced to scroll when there are more choices available. Again and again, please give as as much info as possible on a single screen.

  • ground battle screen - no info on casualties, no instant info on techs gained after planet is captured.

  • ship battle - Missile bases number is not seen without mouse over. Same about hit points.

  • GNN, new colony screens etc. I know in MOO it was exactly the same but why in 2020 use another enforced full screen animations and pictures to give a simple info to the player?

galaxy

  • It lacks interesting things like two-three stars very close together, or stars that are very far away. Every galaxy in ROTP feels the same. That was something that gave MOO lot of replay value. It would be nice to have a game where good fuel techs would be required to win. In both ROTP & MOO most of the time 5 parsecs is all you need.

art - graphics & music

  • I know there's a lot of hype on Petar's graphics but I don't find his graphics good looking at all. Some pics are OK. Some are ugly: ground battle warriors, asteroids in ship battles, animations. Take it with a pinch of salt as I come from roguelike background. Don't need good graphics, don't need graphics at all.

  • Music is very generic like the same you would find in other 4X games and boring as well. Wasn't able to look deeper into race specific music. Does it give you goose bumps? Does it feel like listening to the national anthem? That is something I would be looking to. Otherwise it's better to turn it off.

bugs

  • As i already mentioned game forced me to quit due to memory problems. After restart there was something wrong. There were no GNN news, no new tech discoveries etc. Still I saw there was a SuperNovae

  • In another game I had GNN news - my home planet Meklon became fertile. Was it good? No, because planet didn't increase in size.

  • In next game I have completed research of Soil Enrichment and clicked +50% button. Didn't work, had to micromanage every single star system. At least this time Meklon increased it's original size.

  • Sometimes I had to micromanage ECO slider. Maybe it was after improved eco tech discovery. Not sure.

  • Sometimes in auto-battle I saw my own ship standing still and not moving towards enemy ship. Had to take over and destroy enemy.

  • Random events frequency is too high in tiny galaxy. Space Ameba etc. destroying stars in huge galaxy is not an issue but in tiny it can become a problem.

other

  • I know some people here like detailed descriptions. Well, I don't. I don't understand why ROTP uses detailed names of races like in recent MOO reboot version. I prefer good old single word names.

  • No violet stars, Irradiated planets etc. I would keep old way here.


r/rotp • • Apr 27 '22

Thanks to everyone for such an enjoyable game! - I'm leaving reddit for discord...

4 Upvotes

Later all - I'm leaving reddit, my other communities have moved on to discord.

I've defeated XilmiAI on Hardest on 1.03 base game (Prod = 200%) with some modification, no tech trading, and lots of reloads. Not sure I could do it again after the further improvements; but maybe on the more reasonable Prod = 145% in the mod.

Thanks Ray, thanks Xilmi, thanks Modnar and all those who contributed to this!


r/rotp • • Jan 14 '22

Video (HILARIOUS VIDEO) Darlok emperor attempts diplomatic negotiation, only to be saved by his green assistant, barely avoiding a war - Please like this video (YouTube suggests it to ROTP fans like you and it really makes a difference) and hit subscribe for more ROTP stuff! I appreciate it.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
6 Upvotes

r/rotp • • Aug 26 '25

Windows XP 32 bit

3 Upvotes

Is there a way to play RotR on Windows XP (32 bit)? The "Windows XP" search in the thread showed nothing. The "standard" requirement is 64-bit OS, but this is very strange for a remake of a DOS (!) game.


r/rotp • • Jun 20 '26

Crushing the new AI from first try on hardest mode, on my favourite galaxy settings

3 Upvotes

After a long hiatus during which time I survived fighting non-humans in real life, I managed to get back to ROTP.

This time, I downloaded the latest version.

First, many many thanks to the development team, this game is getting better and better. I love it so much, in 2025, I had a vague plan for a proposal, a new chapter, written in C++ for performance reasons. "Revival of the Precursors", with some very interesting original ideas IMHO, and truly huge galaxy sizes.

Sorry for digression.

Galaxy settings: very poor planets, huge distances between stars, 9 planets in the home planet cluster, 3000+ star systems, research rate the slowest, colony only allowed if you have the actual ecology researched, no Terraforming allowed on hostile, hardest game level ("deadly").

The problem: only two species were capable to exit their local cluster in time.

How I did it: I was lucky to have one small artifacts planet nearby my local cluster. I used treasury reserves from other planets and kept allocating money to the artifacts planet boosting my research into propulsion and ecology. (*1)

All the AIs researched the right things, so kudos for that!

The most dangerous enemy, the Jack Trades having Rich home world(!), had maybe 200 systems when I met them. They tried interesting strategies, but it still felt like they have no real planning. They shouldn't have even declared war, since my stats were much higher already.

Now it's a played game I think. I have 1000+ star systems, and I managed to research Atmospheric Terraforming.

(*1) How to enable the AI and users to use this technique: allow for a new feature. Every planet, whether research center or shipyard, to have "automatic allocation from treasury", obviously limited by how much money there is in treasury. For example, I want to select a shipyard planet near the border to receive annually 300 BC from treasury. Can be random priority. This will allow AI to do the same thing.

Thanks again for this amazing game! Let me know if I should upload screenshots or saved games.

EDIT: forgot to mention one more setting: very small available space on spaceships. Makes the game extremely interesting.


r/rotp • • Sep 19 '20

New here but somethings bugging me...

3 Upvotes

New here but the thing that's bugging me is this, Wargaming owns the MOO IP now and already redid the first MOO game (but gutted a few races out to sell as DLC) and this is a 1:1 copy of the original just with better graphics and some tweaks/fixes right? So the next thing to mention is does the person/team doing this even have permission from Wargaming?

If they do then this is fine but if not? Well lets just say Wargaming has threatened people with legal action for just a bloody joke or in the case of SirFoch, DMCA'd his vid on a particular tank because they didn't like his review of it and that he called them out on just how BS *cough* the Chrysler K *cough* in terms of its frontal armor and lack of weakspots...


r/rotp • • Dec 31 '23

Meme AI-Created Fan Art

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

r/rotp • • Dec 14 '21

Java Vulnerability

5 Upvotes

Not that I know enough to know whether this matters vis a vis RTOP, but since it's fairly important java related news, figured I'd post it.

https://www.infosecurity-magazine.com/news/experts-log4j-bug-could-be


r/rotp • • May 14 '26

Disagree auto result

2 Upvotes

Auto resolve is good, save time of boring battles, but sometimes make bad things, unnecessary losses or flee from winable battles.

Then you can load back and replay manually but it is bad when you did more long battles and you should replay all of them because one bad auto result.

The solution could be if you can refuse the auto result and rather still fight it manually. Just a second "enter battle" button after auto resolve if you not accept the auto result.


r/rotp • • Jul 25 '22

Meme Keep setting them up and I will knock em down!

2 Upvotes

I should be sponsored...

HAHA! This was a perfect opportunity... You can't get a setup this good.

https://twitter.com/BromioDev/status/1551594816038772736


r/rotp • • Jan 02 '21

In my opinion the new sabotage animations are too compressed

2 Upvotes

The showcases of the new cityscapes for the various races on this subreddit looked absolutely amazing, which makes it an even bigger shame that what we see in-game is a pixelated mess.

And now it’s not some code that is the problem like it was with some other racial artwork, the actual images for the animations are the problem here. I think they are way too compressed and end up looking terrible.

What do other members of the community think?


r/rotp • • Jun 06 '25

Question about Ground Combat

2 Upvotes

I'm trying to understand how ground combat works under the hood. This quote from the ROTP manual helps, but I still have some uncertainty.

Ground combat is resolved automatically. Each faction takes turns rolling a d100 to see if they kill an enemy colonist. This continues until there's only one faction surviving. The odds of a successful hit are based on your ground troops' equipment, including armor from the Construction category and handheld firearms from the Weapons category. Ursinathis add +25 to their ground combat rolls.

Which of these happens each turn:

  1. Each side rolls d100 + its bonus. The side with the greater roll kills one opponent and suffers no loss. On every turn one troop dies.

  2. One side rolls a d100 + its bonus. If the roll is greater than a benchmark value, one opponent is killed. Then the other side rolls the same way. These two sequential rolls together are one turn. On some turns zero troops are killed, on some one troop is killed, and on some two troops are killed.

  3. Something else

Thank you!


r/rotp • • Jan 20 '22

First Impressions from a long time MOOer

13 Upvotes

I'm a long time MOOer but I can't recommend MOO1 to new players because DOSBOX and Gog's $10 is beyond what most people are willing, so I am very glad to see ROTP.

My first impression with ROTP's were mostly positive. I like the music, the art, the dialog writing, and the clean interface. Most of all I like it being faithful to MOO1's gameplay which is practically perfect. Too many sequels or clones ruin it by messing with it and thinking piling on their own "improvements" better.

What I didn't like: Major dislike: The space combat screen is very confusing. Couldn't tell what ship to move. Had to guess by interpreting the ugly blue squares. The interface is confusing here. To fire you need to left click on the target and press 1 or 2. So confusing my brother kept losing space battles because he didn't realize he wasn't even firing! Not intuitive at all. The white line grid ruins the aesthetics. Lets down the rest of the game.

Minor dislikes: Spaceship designs art is ugly. Even MOO1 was better. Also landing animation needs a proper walk cycle and flag plant. It's just two extra sprites! The one sprite animation doesn't do the beautiful landscapes justice. The game also froze for 20 seconds 10 minutes in then resumed. Not sure what that was.

I know this is an early version and look forward to future ROTP releases. MOOers everywhere thank you Ray!


r/rotp • • Dec 19 '21

How ray responds to someone who likes something he doesn't.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/rotp • • Nov 05 '20

Master of Orion

6 Upvotes

You are the best! Love you games, but please restore original Moo1 UI. Its Very clear and intuitive, or give this option ingame, especially "colonies" and "tech" screen. Thank you for near perfect remake best sci-fi 4X strategy. Martin :)


r/rotp • • Jan 18 '22

Announcement (Live stream announcement) To err is human - Remnants of the Precursors - A free Master of Orion 1 remake - #4XGaming #4X #turnbased #MasterOfOrion #SpaceStrategy

Thumbnail
twitch.tv
10 Upvotes

r/rotp • • Feb 02 '26

Ideas

7 Upvotes

Just found this game and it is great like the good old Master of Orion. I hope it is still developing because there are some issues. Here are some ideas wich would make the game much greater.

  1. Easier trade management.

The most annoying part is checking every turn every race for trade offers. So much clicks and screens. Would be good a button in the diplomacy screen to improve a trade relation. Would be better a button to improve every possible trade relations. The best would be an optional automatic trade relations improvement.

2. Auto resolve should not flee from winner battles.

I went with huge fighters and bombers against some missile bases. It was a sure win manually, but the auto resolve fled, it was unpleasant.

3. AI should not be cooperative during extermination.

I started to exterminate a race without war declaration, destroyed its colonies one after the other, and it did not declared war, even we improved trade and exchanged technologies during the extermination. It was useful just ruined the roleplay.

It would be nice to play this game without these issues.


r/rotp • • Nov 21 '25

Bye, bye Stellaris

8 Upvotes

Hi!

Is there any way to disable the possibility of researching colonization of barren, inferno, toxic, etc. planets? (Perhaps by disabling the possibility of researching modules for colonizing these planets, similar to cloning - never/never in the game options). I play on very large maps above 700, but with a maximum of 8-9 opponents.

PS. Great game!! The AI is impressive!


r/rotp • • Mar 26 '21

Adhere to MOO1 originalism, or explore bold new gameplay?

4 Upvotes

ROTP is (currently!) best explained as, and plays just like, a recreation of MOO1. It is not entirely faithful; the graphics are much improved (bordering on 'completely different'), a bunch of shortcuts have been added, the map has shaded areas, space monster math has been changed (I think?), a bunch of quality of life / automating boring clickwork has been added, but mostly it tries to steer close to the original. The gameplay is effectively the same.

MOO1 also has a few optional modifications on the original available to use: There's far more options when generating the map, and a bunch of game-specific tweaks such as slowing down research. Thing is, these are optional, so if you want a close-to-original-MOO1 experience, you can mostly get that. They do modify the gameplay, but by being a smorgasboard of optional modifications, it isn't a streamlined amazing experience.

But, what if ROTP was a reimagination of MOO1? A game that should be familiar to MOO1 players but which does not play the same and isn't really intended to. Perhaps it takes some notes from MOO2 and has a much wider palette of space monsters to contend with, some of which are just idling at a juicy planet. Perhaps a simple act of rebalancing the race bonuses to make it less of a 'psilons GOOD, mrrshan BAD' situation; in light of the fact that the combat-bonus-oriented races are generally considered 'bad', could be worthwhile. Perhaps add more races, adjust certain techs to work differently, introduce completely new techs, add other win conditions, add more 'environmental' effects, such as speed boosting lanes, natural warp gates, or BC-granting planet-less starsystems that you need to claim by having a fleet stationed there - a thing to skirmish about without it being an all-out war.

But, right now it feels silly to propose any significant tweaks to the core gameplay itself: Even if e.g. messing with race bonuses or adding some juicy planets protected by monsters (which in its own way would help the race bonus situation out a little bit, as that effectively makes combat-oriented better) is universally agreed upon as an improvement, now you're messing with the MOO1 formula, and I'm not sure that is the (current) 'point' of ROTP.

So how do the contributors feel about this? Would there one day be room to have 2 options when you launch a new game: MOO1-esque play, or with the reimagined rule set? Perhaps not quite as drastic as what civ4 did (with a re-built and somewhat re-imagined colonization available to play backed by the same engine), but in that vein: Similar game with similar looks, but quite different gameplay. Or should the game just stick close to the roots and leave any serious tweaking of gameplay to mods? Or make tentative steps in abandoning the less well tuned parts of the MOO1 rules without bothering to try to continue to support 'original' gameplay?

I'm not talking about going ham on the alternate options screen. I'm thinking more about a single option that gives you a streamlined game experience. A combination of a bunch of the tweak options with broader changes, designed to make sense and work well together to make a different (and hopefully better, more fun) game.

Disclaimer: I'm a java programmer but I'm not sure if I have sufficient time to contribute much, and this post does sound a tad bit like I want to direct development - which certainly isn't the intent. Thanks to Ray and all the other contributors for this fantastic project.


r/rotp • • Aug 09 '24

I had an unarmed colony tank for me against the hybrid AI, this surely is a bug, I shouldn't have won this fight. The AI never attacked my armed ship.

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/rotp • • Apr 24 '26

Subjective Question: What Systems/Player ratio do you enjoy most?

4 Upvotes

MOO1 was around 8 systems/player. E.g. Medium was 48 systems for player and five opponents: 48/(1+5)=8. The first option that comes up in ROTP is around 12.5 (Small; 50 systems for player and 3 opponents: 50/(1+3)=12.5. What ratio do you guys enjoy most? I know we can easily change it.


r/rotp • • Feb 03 '26

Small ships are useless?

9 Upvotes

In this game all ship classes available from the beginning. In space fleet games usually the bigger is better. Big ships can defeat weak fleets without any losses, invulnerable for small arms, and so on.

Here I can start building fleets with huge ships and I dont see reason to use small, medium, or even large ships. But Im new and yet dont know the depths of mechanics.

Pro players have good arguments to use smaller classes?


r/rotp • • Jul 14 '22

Download Broken

5 Upvotes

I've been trying to download this game for most of a week and can't. Both the .jar and the .zip "fail" almost immediately. I've tried dozens of times, on different days and different times of day, always the same: download failed.

Is there a functioning alternate site to download the game files?

EDIT: The is a repeatable but unexplained issue on my PC only. Was able to download from a different computer. Thanks for the help!