I (M) recently moved into a 3 bedroom / 2 bathroom apartment with two of my friends, who are a couple. We're now having a pretty big argument over who should get the master bedroom, and I'm genuinely not sure if I'm being an asshole here.
Here's the situation:
My two friends were struggling to find an apartment they could afford, so we were looking at places together over Discord. I suggested that I move in with them because having a third person would make the rent cheaper for everyone. Eventually we found this apartment, and it was basically PERFECT. Great location, ridiculously cheap for what it is, and honestly one of those situations where you feel like you got insanely lucky.
It's a 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom apartment.
From the beginning, there was one thing we all knew: they needed two bedrooms (1 office, 1 bedroom), and I needed one. We'd also split the rent equally 3 ways. $3250-> 1083 x 3. The bedrooms are actually pretty similar in size. The two non-master bedrooms are exactly the same size. The master is only about 6 inches wider, BUT it has a private bathroom and TWO WINDOWS instead of one.
When we were looking at apartments over Discord, before we'd even toured this place, I casually said something like:
"You guys can have the master since you're a couple."
This is where the whole disagreement starts.
It wasn't some formal agreement or anything, it was just me acknowledging that they were a couple and assuming they'd probably want it. The next day, we toured the apartment, and I absolutely loved it. It was such a good deal that I knew I wanted to live there. THE SAME DAY, over dinner, I brought up that I actually might want the master bedroom. This is where our memories of the situation differ. I don't remember it being, "No, absolutely not, the master is ours." I remember it more as basically a disagreement where we'd think about it. Obviously, we signed the lease anyway because the apartment was such a good deal. And this is another reason I'm confused. We continued talking about the master bedroom even after signing the lease, which is part of why I thought the issue wasn't completely settled.
Eventually, we compromised: they would keep the master bedroom, but I could put my work desk in their office while still having the second bedroom as my bedroom. I was okay with that compromise because I work from home and I wasn't sure I could comfortably fit both my bed and my work desk in the smaller bedroom. It would technically fit, but it would be extremely cramped.
Then, on move-in day, they told me that putting my desk in their office wasn't actually going to work because there wouldn't be enough space. So now I'm back to having the smaller bedroom AND having nowhere else to put my work desk.
At that point, I told them that I wanted to revisit the master bedroom.
My reasoning is that we're all paying an equal third of the rent, but they're getting two bedrooms between the two of them while I'm getting one. If we're dividing the bedrooms between us, I feel like giving me the master is a reasonable way to compensate for the fact that they are getting twice as much bedroom space overall. I also work from home, so my bedroom is going to function as both my bedroom and my office. Because the desk can't go in their office like we originally agreed, I'm going to be spending a huge amount of my time in my bedroom. The master also has significantly better natural light, which matters to me because I have a lot of plants. The other bedrooms only have one window, while the master has two.
Their argument is basically:
They're a couple and need the extra room.
The master has its own bathroom, and my female friend says she wants the privacy of having her own bathroom.
I told them they could have the master before we even toured the apartment.
I understand that I originally said they could have it. That's the part that makes me question whether I'm actually in the wrong.
But from my perspective, I made that comment casually before we had even seen the apartment, and I didn't realize that it would be treated as a permanent agreement. Once we actually saw the apartment and started discussing how we'd divide the rooms, I thought the master was still something we could negotiate.
I also feel like the situation has materially changed because the compromise we came up with; me putting my desk in their office, turned out not to be possible.
I'm not trying to screw them over or take something from them just because I changed my mind. I'm trying to figure out what is actually fair now that I'm realizing I'll be spending basically all of my time in my one bedroom because I need to both sleep and work there.
Idk, this is just very stressful tbh, do you think we should compromise on something or I'm the asshole and should just give it up and let them take the master?