r/roofkoreans • • Jun 16 '20

We need to talk about Latasha Harlin.

0 Upvotes

Hello everybody.

I know many of you have joined this community and learned about the Roof Koreans in the wake of the riots over the death of George Floyd. I also know quite a few of you learned about Roof Koreans in a video posted by Count Dankula. That is fine- Asian American history is something that ought to be taught. The problem is, I see many people who mistakenly see Roof Koreans as some kind of "Ideal American" - or to put it bluntly, a "Model Minority." The type of immigrant who doesn't hesitate to exercise their 2nd Amendment rights to defend their livelihoods and property. The truth is much more complex and much uglier than that.

A disclaimer- I am not claiming that the Roof Koreans are pure evil, either- they, and the predominantly black looters during the LA Riots, are both victims of the white supremacy in the United States that pervades the echelons of power, from local law enforcement to the presidency, to this day. However, as an Asian American I would be remiss to not point out the events and tensions that led to the creation of the Roof Koreans. That would be historically irresponsible, and I assume most of you are interested in the phenomenon of Roof Koreans because of the historical parallels found today.

To start, it has often been said that the Korean community and Black community in LA were at odds with each other. Why was that? The answer is simple: the model minority myth. What is the model minority myth?
According to Wikipedia, "A model minority is a minority demographic (whether based on ethnicity, race or religion) whose members are perceived to achieve a higher degree of socioeconomic success than the population average, thus serving as a reference group to outgroups." In other words, it's a minority group that has "achieved." Pre-1900s, this "model minority" definition applied to European Jewish people, who at that time mostly worked in the financial sector as moneylenders. Jewish moneylenders attained much wealth from moneylending due to the fact that Judaism did not ban usury. Today, this "Model Minority" epithet usually applied to Asian Americans. Why is this an epithet? A few reasons.
One: The "Model Minority" myth relies on the assumption that said minorities have become successful enough to "become American," or achieve the "American Dream." In other words, the model minorities are now equal in status to the majority group. Time and time again, however, this assumption is proven incorrect- the COVID-19 pandemic being a very recent instance. Asian Americans, in the view of America as a whole, went from being "Model Minorities" to being the ones singled out in disease tests and privy to racist insults and actions [as seen here]( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_incidents_of_xenophobia_and_racism_related_to_the_COVID-19_pandemic ). Going back to the Jewish example given earlier, Jews in Europe were routinely subject to pogroms and attacks, and face rampant anti-Semitism to this day. In the best of times, the Model Minority myth gives a proximity to whiteness, but not to true white privilege. In the worst of times, that proximity dissipates, and the minority is left to fight on its own. This will be important to remember later.
Two: The "Model Minority" myth isn't entirely accurate. Yes, on average, Asian Americans earn more money than the national average. However, "Asian American" is a very broad term- it refers to both the Hmong immigrant working as a maid and the Chinese immigrant working on software in a cushy white-collar job. It refers to both the Filipino seasonal farm laborer and the upper middle-class Indian doctor. In fact, [among all Americans, those near the top of the income ladder had 8.7 times as much income as those near the bottom in 2016.]( https://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2018/07/12/income-inequality-in-the-u-s-is-rising-most-rapidly-among-asians/ )
Thirdly, Asian Americans have been commonly used as a cudgel against Black and Latinx Americans. The existence of a model minority implies that, through hard work and education, an entire minority group can rise up without much government assistance and achieve success, despite the fact that [Black and Latinx people are denied mortgages twice as often as white and Asian people]( https://www.forbes.com/sites/alyyale/2018/05/07/mortgage-loan-denials-more-common-with-minorities-new-report-shows/#3dbd7741509a ). Many Asian immigrants also often come into the country already college educated as opposed to Latinxs from previous waves of immigration that did not have [college degrees.]( https://www.voanews.com/student-union/data-show-asians-not-latinos-are-typical-us-immigrants-now )
In conclusion, Asians and Asian Americans have had advantages over Black and Latinx Americans that, while not making them fully on-par with White Americans in terms of social and political status, afforded them some power- power they could then flex on Black and Latinx people. Asians, especially Koreans who immigrated to the US in the aftermath of the Korean War, were granted some privileges by society such as a higher chance of business loans being accepted and a general perception by America of being the "Good Model Minority." These business loans were used to create businesses- but where to find land that can be used for businesses for cheap? Ethnic enclaves such as Koreatown- and black neighborhoods.

One such business was Soon Ja Du's liquor store. Soon Ja Du was an immigrant from South Korea, the proprietor of Empire Liquor on Figueroa Street, and the owner of a revolver that she kept behind the counter, modified such that she would not have to put as much pressure on the trigger to fire it. On March 16th, 1991, 15-year-old Latasha Harlin came into the store to buy a bottle of orange juice. Accounts differ on what happened- according to Du, Harlins attempted to steal the $1.79 bottle of juice by sticking it in her backpack and walking away. According to two eyewitnesses at the store, Du called Harlins a "bitch" and accused her of attempting to steal. Whatever the case may be, the [footage]( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kiw6Q9-lfXc ) doesn't lie (CW: Shooting). In case you don't want to watch the admittedly heartbreaking footage, Du initiates the encounter by grabbing Harlins by the jacket and pulling her in. Harlins breaks free by punching Du twice in the face. Harlins then attempts to reclaim her purse on the counter, which Du responds to by throwing a stool at her. Finally, Harlins seems to return the bottle of juice to Du and turns around- at which point Du shoots her in the back of the head, killing her. At the trial, the jury recommended Du be punished with the maximum penalty of a voluntary manslaughter charge- 16 years in prison.
Du was punished with 5 years probation, 400 hours of community service and a $400 fine.

This shooting took place 13 days after the beating of Rodney King. While it did not directly spark the LA Riots, the killing of Latasha Harlin worsened tensions between the Black and Korean communities, with Koreans complaining about Black people shoplifting and Black people claiming racial abuse and humiliation from Koreans. Thus the tinder had been set. When the LA Riots sparked when three of the four officers charged for the beating of Rodney King were acquitted, the killing of Harlins was still fresh in the minds of the LA Black community. Looting and destruction occurred- so the police, always ready to protect and serve... moved to protect white, wealthy neighborhoods and left Koreatown defenseless. Now that the white neighborhoods were protected, the brunt of the looting occurred in the police-less Koreatown. Korean business owners were forced to take up arms- but in their haste to defend their businesses, Edward Jae Song Lee, the son of Korean business owners, was shot by friendly fire.

The Koreans had succeeded somewhat in the defense of their businesses- no thanks to the LAPD, and no thanks to their already strained relationship with the black community, tired of white people and white-adjacent minorities getting away with their crimes with little more than a slap on the wrist. The episode of the Roof Koreans is NOT something to be venerated - it is an ugly scar that continues to inform Asian-Black relations in America and a stark reminder that the Model Minority myth, in times of crisis, will not offer the protection that white privilege entails. The Roof Koreans saga is a cautionary tale of the foibles of the Model Minority myth- the division it sows among minorities, and the ultimate impotence it has in truly making a minority "American" in its fullest sense- American enough to be protected by the vanguards of white supremacy inherent in the US.

Again, this is not a judgement or a condemnation of any of you readers. Just remember- next time Roof Koreans are invoked in these politically turbulent times, do not treat them or elevate them as lone-wolf heroes weathering a storm of rioters; but as unwitting victims in the machinations of white supremacy in America, as those whose desire to rise above oppression towards minorities ironically came at the cost of becoming minor oppressors themselves, with nothing to show for it.


r/roofkoreans • • Jun 10 '20

Regarding Roof Koreans as Koreans.

220 Upvotes

When i joined this subreddit it was about a group of asian minorities who defended themselves when no one else would. In a way, for me at least, it was a way to celebrate my asian heritage and say "hey, koreans can be badass too". I live a little over an hour away from ktown and visit it regularly, what happened there is very real for me. I feel like the recent influx of individuals becoming aware of what happened to Koreans during the LA riots after what has been going on in the news lately have hi-jacked this subreddit, and now a place that was about Koreans has been stripped of that, in a way that is similar to cultural appropriation. Koreans are not about gun rights or shooting people, you have to realize Koreans have been underdogs for a very long time. We are a small country that has been separated in half by proxy wars, nestled in between two larger counties, who have historically expressed (or actually carried out) intent to invade our country and abolish our culture/ethnicity. We are about surviving and fighting for everything thats ours. Asians have been oppressed and discriminated against throughout US history. From Chinese immigrants who were segregated against and paid slave-like wages during the 1800s and early 1900s, to Japanese and Koreans who were uprooted and sent to camps during WWII. To modern day descrimination on a systemic level, whether its from covid 19, or just from being asian. These times are very sensitive for people of asian descent.

I would ask you guys who come here to be respectful of the fact that Roof Koreans are a sub-minority, and this place is to celebrate them and what they did, not strip away their identity from what they did. I think its okay to make posts about other groups defending their property with the 2nd amendment, the issue i have is when people start to make statements or make posts that strip away the Korean part of Roof Korean.


r/roofkoreans • • Aug 28 '20

Roof Koreans 2020

Thumbnail
youtu.be
113 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • Nov 11 '20

Need your opinions fellow Asian Americans.

69 Upvotes

So for some context, I’m Korean/Cantonese American. My Halmeoni if from South Korean, and my MaMa is from Guangzho (I believe? My Chinese history is worse than my Korean). So I’m not just some random white guy ranting about this. This questions is more targeted to Asian Americans. But what is your opinion on white people using the term roof Korean? Or really glorifying them. I have seen some opinions where white people use the term roof Koreans as a way to justify their own actions. And i do get annoyed seeing white people even impersonating Asian (pissed about Asian plastic surgery Jesus). But what is your opinion on Caucasians using roof Koreans. People like Donut Operator is an example, I’m not saying that he’s racist, but he is an example of a white person glorifying Asian Americans. And then you have the whole “model minority“ myth where Asians are always smart and hardworking but that’s not related.


r/roofkoreans • • Jul 31 '23

Rate my rooftop Korean cosplay

13 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • Jul 22 '23

Rheinmetall roofkoeraed Russia: it will defend its plant in Ukraine. “they plan to protect it from attacks with air defence systems of their own manufacture.”

Thumbnail
pravda.com.ua
9 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • Aug 07 '20

Roof caucasians?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
81 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • May 31 '20

The wrong way of defending your business.

Thumbnail
star-telegram.com
24 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • Jun 28 '23

Not rooftop koreans; These are Italian Farmsite defenders: when some little countryside Italian farms went under attack by communist, sindicalist, rioters and looter they accepted task of defending the landlords and their private properties all over italy.

22 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • May 19 '22

Heard something interesting about the rifles used in Rodney King riots?!

47 Upvotes

I was having a discussion with my pastor about the 1992 LA riots and he said at that time he found it hard to believe that so many Koreans would have these huge rifles in that time.

Then he said actually the FBI was pretty suspicious about it as well because they apparently wrote up a report about the Koreans’ rifles and it turns out most were toys. Handguns real tho.

So, is this true?


r/roofkoreans • • Jun 30 '20

What /r/roofkoreans feels like ever since white supremacists Trumpers have inundated the sub

Thumbnail
youtube.com
58 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • Apr 17 '19

I feel like this man would fit right in with the roof koreans

Post image
181 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • Sep 18 '20

roofkoreans - Instagram Hashtag

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • Mar 04 '21

Do y’all feel like KTown wouldn’t have been targeted as it was if Soon Ja Du had been appropriately punished?

Post image
145 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • Jun 01 '20

The tools of free citizens

Post image
98 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • Jul 15 '21

Stepdad got this beauty had to pose like this

Thumbnail
gallery
207 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • Apr 02 '24

Does anyone know of any Books, or Movies on Roof Koreans? Thank you in advance.

6 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • Jun 11 '20

It’s like the second coming of Jesus, but better

502 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • Jan 02 '24

Connecting with Roof Koreans

8 Upvotes

I’m a writer interested in doing a piece for a widely circulated print magazine about the people involved with this part of history. I would like to get in contact with anyone who has first hand memories. Any help would be appreciated!


r/roofkoreans • • Jun 10 '20

Rooftop Korean is talking about Justice, Peace, Georege Floyd

Thumbnail
youtube.com
159 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • Aug 14 '21

Did I do this right??

Post image
211 Upvotes

r/roofkoreans • • Nov 21 '18

666th sub

9 Upvotes

Ma I finally made it