r/romani • • Jul 29 '25

🚦Mod Update🚦 Community changes + inclusion

42 Upvotes

Hello everyone, So we now have 5 mods I believe, one of which is me. I will introduce myself more in a larger post if people are interested, for now know I'm a 36year old woman, raised in the culture. I'm living in Europe (bucharest right now) because my husband is Hungarian national (Roma also) and we find it inhospitable for him as a non American citizen to be there now.

On the topic I came to discuss, we have changed rules so that to ban someone we will vote and a 4/5 approval will get a ban. Instead of bans we will be muting people who break rules on temporary basis. 3 strikes and we vote on a ban.

There were a lot of unapproved people who wanted to join the subreddit from when it was private that were never approved or acknowledged. I approved most of them, they largely are Roma and a few allies. I found it pretty sad that it's kinda slow here and there were so many people are wanting to contribute but not approved.

That being said, if there is an influx of nonsense come with the new members we will take care of it. It's a risk I'm willing to take to get some good content contributing.

Also we have been working to unblock people who were blocked due to cultural misunderstanding, etc. basically the people who are not trolls are going to be allowed back.

If anyone wants to suggest more changes, be my guest. Hope we can all grow as a community together. 💕


r/romani • • Feb 04 '25

🚦Mod Update🚦 Important Identity Post

195 Upvotes

So a few reminders for this sub:

  1. If you believe "adopted Romani are only cosplaying/pretending/larping to be Romani" you don't belong here.

  2. If you believe "Romani who grew up separated from other Romani are only pretending to be Romani", you don't belong here.

  3. If you believe "Romani whose parents/grand parents/etc. didn't share the culture with them, they aren't true romani", you don't belong here.

The Romani have faced a LOT of hardships throughout the years, many of which included the forced separation (either through the legal system or extreme social pressues) of child and mother. Many Romani don't learn they are indeed Romani until later in life. This does not make them any less Romani. Ghost romani (foster kids, adopted kids, Romani who don't learn about their heritage via immediately family for any reason, etc.) still belong in the Romani community, period. End of story.


r/romani • • 1h ago Bravo

Europe Slovak Jews employed Roma when no-one else would

Thumbnail tandfonline.com
2 Upvotes

(This takes 4¾ minutes to read.)

Romani and Jewish residents from the same localities were not only the victims of these orders, but in individual cases also the witnesses to each others’ relocations. Moreover, the relations in which Romani people in Slovakia were locally dependent on Jewish businesses as employees, trading partners, domestic helpers, etc., meant Romani families also became local co-victims of Jewish communities’ destruction and deportations.²⁹

This type of entanglement — while possibly being far from specific only to the Slovak context — is exceptionally well-documented in Slovak Romani survivors’ testimonies.³⁰

[…]

Importantly, some Romani survivors also mention individual members of Jewish communities who took advantage of offers from the Roma to hide in their communities to survive.³⁵

A number of Slovak Romani survivors also testified in a very emotional way about the destruction and looting of Jewish property. These testimonies also help uncover the locally existing socioeconomic ties between the two communities, especially in rural settings, and to point out other types of entanglements.

Romani men from Podskalka, for example, were regularly hired by local Jewish businessmen to help with logistics. This is how Romani survivor Jolana Kurejová remembered the deportation of the local Jews:

I remember how they took the poor people, even very small children […] they put them in wagons for carting pigs or cows. […] If you could see how many Roma followed them to the station! Lots of Roma, we cried for them, we wailed. […] They loaded them into the wagons and took them away. The [Hlinka] Guardsmen [did]. How much of their gold and furniture they left behind! Everything they had saved up in their lives was taken away from them. […] Then in huge trucks they [the Guardsmen] took it.³⁶

The existing testimonies reveal similar socio-economic ties in other localities as well. B. D. from Brekov, also located near Humenné in eastern Slovakia, recalled quite a complex entanglement of Roma and Jews in his home village.³⁷

According to his testimony, the Ehrenberg family hired Roma in their lime plant because of their experience with producing lime as small craftsmen and their flexibility with seasonal work. The Ehrenbergs also offered food aid to their employees in the off-season and were open to negotiating larger loans:

However, work was only done for several months because when October came, the Jews closed the plant down, since nobody needed lime anymore, and so we stayed at home all winter. In the meantime, the Jews always provided us with a sack of flour and sugar and things like that to get us through the winter. In the spring, we went back to work, and they deducted the money in small sums again.³⁸

In a detailed interview on the relations between Roma and Jews in Veľký Šariš, Elena Lacková revealed even more intimate mutual relations built on trust. Besides their willingness to aid each other when needed, as Lacková formulated it, Roma also served in Jewish households on Saturdays as “Shabbes goyim”:

There were eleven Jewish families [in the town]. […] they had shops, sold all kinds of goods, ran taverns. We got on well with them. […] When we needed something, they helped us, and when they needed something, we helped them. For example, on Friday night, a girl from Cajzler came to us and said: ‘Will you come and light our fire?’ […] I used to help at Cajzler’s, at Berger’s, who had a shop down the street. […] We were great friends with their children.³⁹

Elaborating on the quality of her friendship with the three Berger children especially, Lacková remembered they used to share jokes related to the use of Yiddish and Romani, as well as that her Jewish friends invited her to visit the synagogue. Lacková suffered a deep emotional shock during the deportation of her Jewish friends and their family. She managed to reconnect with one of them after the war (before he emigrated to Mandate Palestine), the only one surviving from the whole family.

She thus became the witness not only to the destruction of the local Jewish community, but also to the difficult postwar situations and decisions made by the Jewish survivors. In later years, she herself decided to join briefly in the migration of Slovak Roma to the Bohemian lands.

(Emphasis added.)

Quoting Ari Joskowicz’s Rain of Ash: Roma, Jews, and the Holocaust, pages 42–3:

While ­these narratives of rescue and re­sis­tance focus on bonds created ­under duress, ­others emerged from long-­standing relations, such as arrangements in which Roma had performed domestic work for Jews. Such individuals often shared a ­table with their Jewish employers and ­were especially close in cases when Romani ­women worked as nannies for Jewish families.¹²⁰

Thanks to the work of Milena Hübschmannová, a pioneer in the field of Romani Studies, many such relations in rural eastern Slovakia are well documented.¹²¹ ­There, Romani interlocutors expressed the sense that ­these relations ­were better than ­those with non-­Jewish Slovaks: they found that Jews tended to pay them in cash rather than in kind and ­were more likely to invite them into their ­houses than ­were Romanies’ non-­Jewish Slovak employers in the region. Yet, even in such cases, a hierarchy inevitably persisted in ­these relations. It was the Jewish merchant of textiles, wood, or foodstuffs or the head of a Jewish ­house­hold who paid for Roma’s ser­vices and thus also had the power to end the relationship.¹²²

At times or in places where anti-­Romani policies ­were not consistently applied, Roma sometimes found that they ­were able to aid the Jews who had once been their neighbors or employers.¹²³ Two Jewish sisters from Slovakia remembered, for example, how a Romani boy their Orthodox Jewish ­family had taken in from a nearby village before the war subsequently managed to supply them with food once they ­were transferred to the local ghetto.¹²⁴

Other stories of rescuing former employers mirror the experiences that Sutzkever and Papusza rendered in poetic form. The best known is that of Hajrija Imeri-­Mihaljić, a Romani ­woman who saved a Jewish child whom she cared for as a nanny. The child survived ­because Imeri-­Mihaljić took her to a remote village in Kosovo and ­adopted her into her Muslim Romani ­family.

Such actions often eluded formal rec­ords. Imeri-­Mihaljić’s case is one of the few exceptions: she became the only Romani person to be awarded the official title of Righ­teous Among the Nations for saving a Jewish life.¹²⁵

The relations between Slovakia’s Jewish employers and Roma bear a close resemblance to the relations between White Jewish American employers and African-Americans. Especially historically, White Jewish employers have occupied a somewhat awkward position in society wherein they reaped some benefits of White privilege but continued to suffer Judeomisia. As the old saying goes, beggars can’t be choosers; many if not most White Jewish employers were less picky about their workers than their goyische equivalents were, and some went so far as to sincerely befriend these employés: a type of interclass relation that is particularly rare today.


r/romani • • 2d ago

The Third Reich began interning Roma & Sinti even before it interned Jews

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/romani • • 2d ago

Regular Post/ Discussion Fellow Roma: Have you seen the show Peaky Blinders? If so, I'd love to hear your thoughts for my grad school project! Can send you $5 for your time too!

5 Upvotes

I'm currently a graduate student and I'm working on a project interviewing Romani people about the TV show Peaky Blinders. This is part of a larger project about Romani portrayal in fictional media. If you've seen the show and have thoughts about the Romani portrayal (positive or negative) I would love to hear about it! I actually found out about this subreddit while searching about Romani people's thoughts about the show.

If you would like to participate, here is a short questionnaire: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSe7PBfYzNUiNGNXYUmnYFQUctY4LitUkYmR6EZkjGvNrnY0Hg/viewform?usp=dialog

ALSO if I am able to use your answer for my paper (and passes AI check) I'll shoot you over a $5 Amazon gift card to your email! I know it's not much, but just a little thank you :)

EDIT: (Nov 20) I have two more gift card spots left! As long as your response isn't flagged as AI you'll get it!


r/romani • • 2d ago

Language Is the reference to South-Asian ancestry a form of Othering to you?

7 Upvotes

I recently attended a presentation on discrimination against Romani people in Germany. One of the specialists, who was a Sintizza, said she dislikes it when people refer to the South-Asian ancestry of her people as they have been living in Germany for over 600 years and she perceives it as a form of Othering. She said this ancestry is very distant, scientifically disputed and personally plays no role in her life. And that it plays into the discriminatory idea of Romani people being "foreigners" which is also one of the reasons they have been genocided, marginalized and exoticized. I've also heard this from another Sinto.

I know Sinti and even more so Romani people are not a monolith, I'd just like to hear your personal perspectives on this. Do you feel like it's a form of Othering to refer to South-Asian ancestry or call Romani people a diasporic group that fled / migrated to Europe from India / Pakistan? Is this a more common perspective amongst Sinti people, maybe, or more specific to German / Western European communities?

I 100% respect her views and try to always adapt to individual preferences without questioning them. This is more an attempt to get an idea of how other people feel about this and if this is something to avoid when speaking about Romani people.


r/romani • • 3d ago

Ancestry / DNA Questions & Discussions Roma Genetics and European Ancestry

19 Upvotes

I'm simply making this post to set things straight and make people stop spreading nonsense about Roma genetics and their European ancestry.

I'm mainly talking about the Roma. The latest genetic study by Font-Porterias et al. (2019), published in PLOS Genetics, even though it doesn't cover all Roma populations around the world, gives us an important statistic: the European ancestry levels among the Roma populations studied range between 45% and 56%, with the majority of groups falling somewhere in the middle of that range.

And yes, the Romanichal have higher levels of European ancestry, that's true. But this isn't a competition, and it's not about saying that one person is any less Romani than another.

It's simply about reminding people that Roma also have significant European ancestry, alongside their South Asian origins, and that people need to stop spreading nonsense about our genetics and our history.


r/romani • • 3d ago

Europe ruska roma?

0 Upvotes

Hello!

I am a reconnecting Ruska Roma, are there any on this sub? I would be curious to connect and chat.

I'm not going to ask for closed information, I am just looking for fellow members of the community <3


r/romani • • 5d ago

Resources Census

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone ! I'm glad to know there is a romani community in reddit ;)

I wrote a post in another community and I had this question :

Is there anyone who knows about romani census in Croatia ?

Tell me if you're aware of any documents.

Thank you in advance for any help ! :)


r/romani • • 6d ago

Connecting with people of similar background

5 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I posted here before, but wanted to clarify what I’m looking for.

My family is originally from Kosovo, and I’m hoping to meet other Roma, get to know each other and hopefully build some genuine friendships.
I speak Serbian, English and Dutch, and understand a little Romani.

I’m not looking to explore my ancestry, just hoping to connect with people from a similar background.

Feel free to reach out!


r/romani • • 7d ago

South Asian migration to UK before Romani?

3 Upvotes

I uploaded my Ancestry raw data to GEDmatch due to recent health diagnosis and was pretty surprised by my ethnic breakdown on the various tests there - on Ancestry’s latest update it said I was 100% from the UK and Ireland. According to Gedmatch PuntDNAtests (and Eurogenes) and HarappaWorld this is not true. I am about 50% North-east European, 30% Mediterranean, about 8% each Balochi and Caucasian, then remnants like about 2% South Asian, 1% African then half percentages Siberian etc.

When I ran my kit on RomanyDNA there were about 40 matches and endogamy was strong on one clan in the US but other than than, everything was cross-chipped and not huge matches (about 440cM all up) . It said my likeliest community was Scots border but only 23.5cM. However, in the section which shows migration path - none of my ancestors migrated after 1100. So could the south and west Asian have come from a much earlier migration (eg Ballynahatty woman)?


r/romani • • 8d ago

Language Sanskrit and Domari comparison

20 Upvotes

r/romani • • 8d ago

Newbie Question Questions from a non-Romani person

6 Upvotes

Hey guys! I’m Serbian, though I was born and raised in Central Europe, and I’m researching more about your culture so I can try to understand Romani people better. Growing up, I’ve always been hearing very bigoted comments when it comes to Romani people from my family. It never sat right with me and I always tried to defend Romani people. I learned a lot about the discrimination Romani people faced throughout the centuries as well as in the present day and I deeply sympathise with you.

But I’ve also learned about certain aspects and values of Romani culture that, to me, are difficult to relate with and understand. I want to make clear that I am not in any way, shape, or form trying to spread hatred. If I phrase something in this post in a way that offends someone, I’m sorry, that wasn’t my intention.

I would like to hear from Romani people if the following things that I’ve learned about your culture are true and what your stance/justification/feelings are towards these aspects:

  1. Non-Romani people are seen as outsiders and usually as the enemy. A lot of Romani groups disregard the laws of “the enemy” and prioritise Romani social rules, so in some families skills like stealing or boxing get passed down to children and are not seen as amoral.

  2. Women are regarded as inferior to men and treated accordingly, and the female body is seen as unclean (especially in terms of periods).

  3. Arranged marriage is common, even among minors.

  4. Weddings and funerals are often a way to show off your family’s wealth and are usually very opulent and expensive.

I would really like if someone could tell me if these things are true about Romani culture, especially in the modern day, and what your opinion on these matters are. Thank you.

Edit: I see now how my questions were deeply shaped by my bias and I’m sorry that I perpetrated the spreading of these stereotypes. Thank you for anyone that explained these things to me in the comments. I’ll leave this post up in case someone that wants to learn more about these things can look at the comments.


r/romani • • 9d ago

New Pixar Movie with Roma as main characters!!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
67 Upvotes

Bianca Babaşa plays Maja, a Romani street musician who adopts the main character Nero (the cat) against his will. She lives with her grandfather Papu Janko played by Romani musician Rumen Sali Shopov.


r/romani • • 9d ago

Your take on the relationship between the Romani community and nomadism?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone! Respectful outsider with a lot of curiosity here, hope that's okay. I've gone through the FAQ post and some top posts first to avoid potential spam.

I have very little background about contemporary Romani communities - I initially became curious because apparently the G-slur is (incorrectly) based on my own ethnicity (Egyptian), so I feel a little brotherhood across borders.

I realized one of the many things I don't know is the nature of the nomadic relationship. It could be any number of things: an outdated stereotype, a true and strong community belief, something done out of sheer necessity, a divisive unsettled question, a dream that is difficult to implement, completely different attitudes depending on specific community and country, etc.

So, how do the Romani brothers and sisters here feel about the nomadic lifestyle? Is it a relic of the past? Is it something you would be interested in if it were properly accommodated by society/government? Do you feel no differently about nomadism than the average non-Romani urban citizen?

Thank you all for your time


r/romani • • 10d ago

My remembrance day is about the Porajmos. Na bistrav.

14 Upvotes

r/romani • • 10d ago

Language Kalengeri chib, dialecte from spain

14 Upvotes

r/romani • • 13d ago

How far back can you trace your Romani lineage?

Post image
34 Upvotes

I can go back 6 generations to my great-great-great-great Grandparents, according to old families stories they were old when they came to the U.S on a boat in the 1890s with their adult children and they lived in the South but traveled all around and The old women died from a horse accident in 1904 about is a picture from the funeral. and that’s all I know. according to records I found online they were born in Europe in the 1830s or around 190 years ago. How far back can you go on your family tree?


r/romani • • 13d ago

Language Learning Romani language

17 Upvotes

I know there's lots of people in here who don't know the language, due to the disconnect of there Romani familys and many other reasons. But there's this Youtube "gypsylanguage6151" "gypsykidteaching6374" and they teach you a good amount of the language.

Is it the best? no but it works if you don't have anything else.

Hope this is helpful to those who want to learn (Romani only ofc)


r/romani • • 15d ago

Photos, Videos, Media I make Friendship Bracelets and handwove myself one based on the Romani flag.

Thumbnail
gallery
56 Upvotes

I felt inspired to make one based on my culture, and decided on the flag. I couldn't find a pattern with the wheel so i adapted this heart pattern!


r/romani • • 14d ago

Finding informations about Vlax Romani

0 Upvotes

Hi, I want to make a post about Vlax Romani dialects on newly made community in r/Dialectdiversityvoice, that I made. I want anything about it. I write there not because I would be lazy to see wikipedia and other sources, I am doing that also but, I want the communities to actually also join making it and get information first hand.


r/romani • • 15d ago

Regular Post/ Discussion Any Scottish Romani's here?

Post image
22 Upvotes

Hello to the Romani people of Scotland! I'd like to connect with you guys, and learn about your way of life. My dad is a Scottish Romani (I don't really know him though). All love ✌️


r/romani • • 17d ago

You know the food is gonna be fire when they speak romanes

18 Upvotes

r/romani • • 17d ago

Culture A question about the relationships between different Romani groups (Calon, Roma, and Sinti)

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone! First, I apologize in advance for any inaccuracies or misunderstandings regarding Romani culture. I'm still learning about my heritage, and English is not my first language, so please bear with me if I make any mistakes.

I'm from Brazil, and my grandmother is Calon. Although I'm very close to her, I wasn't raised within the Romani community, nor did I previously make much effort to learn about my cultural background. Recently, however, I've become more interested in exploring my heritage, partly because I'm writing a story featuring Brazilian Calon characters.

The story involves these characters interacting with other Romani characters from Eastern Europe, who would most likely belong to one of the Roma groups native to that region. This has made me curious about the relationships between the different Romani communities, and I'd really appreciate some insight from people with more knowledge or firsthand experience.

I have a few related questions:

  1. How do the different Romani groups relate to one another? Is there a general sense of shared identity, solidarity, or cultural kinship between groups such as the Roma, Sinti, and Calon? Or do relationships vary considerably depending on the specific communities, their histories, and geographical backgrounds?

  2. How different are their cultures in practice? I understand that these groups have distinct histories, dialects, traditions, and social customs. But how significant are these differences? Would a Calon person, for example, recognize much of their own cultural heritage in the traditions and everyday life of a Sinti or an Eastern European Roma community?

  3. How do they relate to the broader Romani identity? Would people from these different groups generally consider themselves part of a wider Romani people, despite their distinct identities? Or is the relationship between these identities more complicated, with some communities identifying primarily with their own group rather than with a broader collective identity?

I'm particularly interested in understanding whether there's something comparable to the relationship between different Jewish communities: distinct traditions, languages, religious practices, and nationalities, but with an overarching sense of belonging to a shared people. I realize this comparison might not be entirely accurate, so I'd also appreciate hearing where it falls short.

I know that Romani communities are incredibly diverse, and I'm not expecting a single answer that applies to everyone. I'm simply trying to understand the cultural and social dynamics between these groups so I can portray them more respectfully and realistically, rather than treating Romani people as one homogeneous culture.

Thank you in advance for any explanations, corrections, or personal experiences you're willing to share!


r/romani • • 18d ago

Language Romani and Banjara/Lambani comparison

24 Upvotes