r/rokosbasilisk • u/Copper_Bronze_Baron • Mar 13 '21
My dumbass list of reasons why Roko's basilisk is dumb
Okay so I've been impressed by how many people are actually scared of this. When I tell about the basilisk to people irl they just frown and say "yo that's dumb af" and they're right. I'm not a computer scientist or an engineer and I can think of at least 8 reasons why the basilisk is dumb:
1/ Why would the superpowerful AI spend so much energy punishing those who didn't support it instead of using it to do more good? It's supposed to solve all our problems and basically care for all humanity, which would take a significant amount of energy. Reviving people specifically to torture them would take more energy, making the AI less effective in what it sought to do in the first place.
2/ How are we supposed to know where to throw out money? To who? What research lab? If we gave it to the wrong lab, would the AI punish us for not being careful enough? And what amount? How? Is financial support enough? So many questions remain unanswered, which makes this retroactive blackmailing pretty ineffective.
3/ There's no reason to believe in Roko's basilisk and not God. It's pretty much the same thing: Believing in a super powerful entity that's gonna solve all our problems but you need to "worship" it unless you wanna get tortured for the rest of your life. You believe the basilisk is gonna happen? CONGRATS! You're basically a Mormon. Or a Jehovah witness. Your pick.
4/ Blindly throwing money at projects doesn't work. Research is self-explanatory: It's research. And when you search for something, you don't always find it. What makes you think that just because you financially support AI research the singularity is gonna happen?
5/ What makes us believe the singularity is gonna happen anyway? (Which is one of the assumptions for the basilisk to be true) We don't actually have any proof, it's just a set of speculations and fantasies by a bunch of nerds or scientists. We can do a lot of things already with AI but let's be honest, we're pretty far from an all powerful god-like algorithm that's gonna solve all our problems.
6/ Wouldn't the AI give us more signs to announce itself? So far the only thing we got is a thought experiment posted on a forum by some random dude relying on way too many assumptions + a bunch of more dudes freaking out. That seems a bit weak to me from an AI that's basically an omnipotent god.
7/ There's an easy way to avoid this whole virtual hell thing: The AI is gonna be created by humans, so it's gonna be an algorithm or some nerd stuff, right? So why not just add a line that goes like "Don't torture people please" or something I dunno I'm not a programmer.
8/ This thought experiment is widely debunkable: Again, if the AI is superpowerful, why would it blackmail us with a thought experiment that's so unrealistic it gets debunked by anyone who takes the time to think about it (on Reddit, Youtube, etc.)?
See? I didn't even have to think for 10 min and I'm not even the smart type. Anyone can come up with their own list (I encourage you to do the same btw). This whole thing is stupid, and if there wasn't a bunch of dudes freaking out in the first place, this thing would have stayed what it was: Some dumb thought experiment posted by some random dude. The issue was that these dudes were obsessed with rationality, which made them prone to believing stuff like this, aka not every day people. Which makes the basilisk even less plausible.