To preface, I understand the games industry and that another Rocksmith in the same format as 2014 probably wouldn't be made today. Having Rocksmith+ is better than nothing, but its far from ideal. Publishers want long term profits and if not enough people buy the DLC then they need another way of ensuring long term profits (subscription service). I'm happy that something is being released, but not like this. Maybe Rocksmith 2014 was an anomaly and product of its time, but the fact is we're getting a lot less value for our money compared to the $30 RS 2014.
The Subscription Model:
$15/month or $100/year is a lot more than I payed for RS 2014. Since I started playing RS 2014 7 years ago that would be roughly $1260 (at $15/month) or $700 (at $100/year).
I'm sure some people (DLC whales) will save money this way but not me. In the 7 years I've been using RS 2014 I did not spent $640 on DLC. If the library really is outstanding (high value, licensed songs by top tier artists) then I could see the value of a monthly charge. But from the looks of it this 'game' is heavily leaning towards the educational tool aspect...
Education Tool:
I personally have little to no interest in this. Therefore I'm paying for a lot of content that I don't want in the form of education and even more in the form of songs I don't care for. I'm sure any player can get some value from educational resources, but there are other means of doing this and personally I've been playing long enough (15 years) not to need to buy new ones. If the lessons were packaged with the game as a one time purchase, that's fine. But not when its something I'm paying for every month and won't be using.
Song Library:
Paying a monthly subscription versus buying the DLC I want means I'm paying for content I don't want, simple as. I know that emphasis was placed on 'expanding your horizons' and the value of playing different genres, but lets be real. Ubisoft is doing this because it will bring in a more diverse crowd, and I understand that from a business standpoint but the fact remains I'm spending more per month than I ever would have on DLC for songs that I don't want. You wanna have the Backstreet Boys and T-Pain on there? Go for it, just don't force me to buy it in order to get the songs I actually want.
Always Online:
As in if I don't have internet service I can't use it. As in if the game servers are down I can't access what I'm paying for. Single player games that don't necessitate an online connection (like Hitman 3) do this and although 90% of the time it works fine, there have been days I've been unable to play because their servers were down. I don't plan my schedule around when online services are online, I plan it around when I have free time. There is no excuse for this other than piracy protection at the expense of the customer, in spite of whatever quality of life improvements there may be.
And of course the other big issue with always online is the game could disappear some day should Ubisoft no longer find it profitable to maintain the servers. Leaving all those people who put $100s of dollars into their subscription with nothing to show for. I don't expect this to happen and would assume Ubisoft would allow offline play before then, but its still a possibility.
Platform Support/ Profiles:
If you are charging a monthly fee then I should be able to use my subscription on any platform I wish. Especially given this is a progression based account that you tailor around your tastes and interests, it makes no sense to be forced to sign up for multiple subscriptions just to play it on different platforms. With RS 2014 it made sense you would need to buy the game on different platforms because it was disc based media and for the most part a one shot deal.
Unlike in RS2014 where you could make different profiles for different users, you now must buy a subscription per user. Why not at least make it so only 1 user per subscription can play at a time? This just inconveniences people who don't want to pay multiple times per month into sharing accounts, and therefore makes the progression/ educational aspect useless for those users.
The Ideal Solution:
Remedies to the above issues and/ or make the game a one time purchase with the base content and then charge for a premium service where you get more content down the road. It still doesn't solve the issue of paying for content you don't want, but I think its a fair compromise. Even better would be a tiered system where you can either choose to just get the new songs (maybe $7.50/month) or new songs + educational content for $15/month.
I'd even rather the Rainbow Six Siege route where you sell the game bare bones and charge for season passes, skins, RS coin etc. Rocksmith probably doesn't have that kind of reach yet, but it would still be better than a monthly subscription.