TLDR: Marrying Dutiful to Elliania is about the worst decision that can be made.
Now, I won't say that I'm a big fan of the series, but I just finished reading The Tawny Man trilogy and I grew increasingly irritated with how the characters can be so short-sighted. But, not being super into the lore, I recognize that there is the chance that my opinion is based on things that aren't true and I would ask you to correct me, if that's the case. Nevertheless, I'll write my post from my POV, that some characters make terrible decisions.
We already knew that Fitz is not bright at all from the first trilogy, and it surprised me that he was a little bit better (just a little) in the second one. However, two other characters stepped up incredibly on the not being too smart scale, Chade and Kettricken. Their political knowledge is incredibly limited. They make a lot of terrible decisions, and they mostly envolve the arranged marriage between Dutiful and Elliania. I'll try to list all of them, but my first big question is: What is the big advantage of marrying the heir to the throne to someone in The Outslands? It seems like an incredible waste. First off, compared to the six duchies, they are TINY. Super tiny, to the point that even being able to terrorize the entire mainland is a bit suspicious. But vikings were a thing at some point in our time, so I'll let it slide, even though the six duchies would be more than able to hold them off with just 4 battleships if it weren't for the Cotery working against them. Nevertheless, after the war in the first trilogy, it's said that the passage of the stone dragons forged many of its citizens. And not only that, but it is known to the people ruling the six duchies that they are not an unified nation, but rather a collection of families that don't see themselves as one. And not only that, but if not for the six duchies, they are basically cut off from the rest of the known world and would have to go all the way to the Chalced states to do any type of trade. And what do the Six Duchies have to gain? Peace with a super weak nation that is not hostile towards them? Nothing else, really. So, to summarize. Kettricken and Chade want the only heir to the throne to marry the heir of a part of a tiny nation that they defeated just 15 years ago, that was left devastated as a result, and that depends on the six duchies for anything more than the bare necessities. It gets even worse when in the end of the trilogy they treat the two parties as being in equal footing. I guess that you want to accommodate to make the Outislanders happy, but the way that they (both the people of the six duchies, but mostly the outislanders) treat the marriage as something more than a favor to the Outslands baffles me. They had the audacity to suggest that it should be Dutiful to go to the Outslands, instead of Elliania moving. How can you be so oblivious to the way your world works?! But anyway, I want to talk about Kettricken and Chade, I just got a bit exalted there. Let's get on with the complaining.
I won't even mention that much the way that Chade handled the information that Fitz gave him about Elliania and Peotre. It was incredibly (INCREDIBLY I say) obvious that they were up to something, but with the amount of times stuff like this happens in the series, it's not something extraordinary. How can the two most important (and supposedly very intelligent and wise) people in the nation be proud and seriously considering the fact that Dutiful accepted the so ridiculous it's unbelievable challenge of Elliania to CUT THE HEAD OF A DRAGON IN A FAR AWAY LAND?? First off, why does Dutiful have to prove himself? I get that she was mad, but as we established, it's her and her "kingdom" that has everything to lose. Besides, we have Bingtown on the opposite side of the spectrum imploring them not to kill the dragon but rather help them in the war with the Chalced States. And why in the world can't they see that this is the much more advantageous alliance? They can even try to confirm the claims that they have a dragon to help them in their war, but since the Chalced States are constantly battling with Shoars, it would be an opportunity to annex it to the rest of the Ducies. Hell, even geographically, they have the mountain kingdom north, shoars to the east, farrow to the northeast and Bingtown with a dragon to the west. They are completely surrounded!! And plus, it would open up the trade with Bingtown even more, since they would be practically saving them, and the Six Ducies would become the Seven Ducies plus an incredibly grateful and resourceful ally. And on top of that, the Outslands would be devastated in regards to trade if they ever were to retaliate because of the broken marriage. There is no one for them to trade with! They would be at the Seven + One Ducies mercy, so they might as well become another Ducie! Now, the books talk about how a conquered people will never accept the rule etc. etc., but I call bullcrap, even if we forget that the Chalced States are the hub of enslaved people, and won't even go there.
Hopefully, I've convinced you that the six ducies have nothing to gain in marrying their heir to (a part of) the outslands and that it would be much better to help bingtown instead. Now, onto the spies of Chade. He just sent one. One. To scout the place where the dragon supposedly is. And then when the people go to the Outslands, Chade has the audacity to be surprised and annoyed that there isn't a consensus amongst the outslanders in regards to killing the dragon. Come on... you do all of this to gain a terrible alliance with a bunch of crappy warring families and then most of them will hate and try to kill you if you kill their beloved dragon. Honestly, what a joke. Chade is an absolute joke as an advisor and master of spies.
Now, a complaint against the way that Robin Hobb tells her story is that it is not at all organic. I, like all of you, quite enjoy most of the characters, and feel genuinely happy when they succeed and sad when they don't, but the way the world works is just to move the plot forward. What do I mean? Well, since I noticed this I couldn't unnotice it, so I'll hide it.
Every time something bad happens to a character when they're out adventuring (even if it's forgetting something back at home), it's for the express purpose of creating an artificial plot point. When you start noticing it, it gets increasingly frustrating. Character A mentions he forgot to bring item B. 10 or 15 pages later, the gang is in a dire situation and they get worse off than they were. And Fitz thinks to himself "Damn, if only A had brought B...". And then you start to realize that if these little things don't happen, entire plot points just disappear out of thin air. It seems as if Hobb wants something to happen and then tries to think of an excuse in order to enable it, and it is noticeably artificial, a lot of the times. It also happens with characters withholding information. It seems that they do it for the sole purpose of creating conflict, especially Fitz. "Oh, I don't feel like saying this important thing to this person right now, even though I can. We have plenty of time!... Oh, it turns out that there was no time, I should have told them right there :'( "
To finish, I know I may seem very negative, but I enjoyed the hell out of reading these books, I've been reading them non stop. They're super frustrating for me, for sure, but still very enjoyable. One thing to note is that I read them in portuguese, so one of the strongest points of the series (Hobb's writing style) may be lost to me, I don't know. Besides, I had to look up the names of the places and characters in english, so some may be wrong, I apologize.
I think I felt the need to write this post because it's the first time that I enjoy reading about a series so much that leaves me so annoyed.
As english is not my first language, I would appreciate it if you could correct any errors you encounter.
EDIT: I have only read the first and second Fitz trilogies