r/robinhobb • • Nov 19 '24

Spoilers All I read all the Fitz books and I am mad Spoiler

5 Upvotes

I read Farseer trilogy when it came out, same with Liveship and Tawny Man. I finally read Fitz and the Fool - I had started Fool’s Assassin a while back but forgot to keep an eye out for the new books.

I’m discontent. I feel like there was a ton of fan food that betrayed how Farseers generally treat Fitz, stuff that should have belonged in fanfic (him coming out of the shadows etc).

But what I’m really mad about is I feel like for all the hurt and uncertainty readers have endured between the decades Fitz and Beloved were apart I never got a satisfying reunion. Never an easing of the hurt of the disappearance for decades. Yes, Beloved couldnt come back because he was held hostage and then lost. But nothing made it better. Their time lounging and chatting on the bed in Kelsingra was nice. But I wanted tender understanding, even if Hobb wouldn’t allow full forgiveness.

Edit- the period of time between Tawny Man and Fitz & the Fool, not between Farseer and Tawny Man

Maybe I missed it. I tore through the last trilogy in the space of a week. I’m so gutted I can’t do a reread anytime soon though.

And the Fool is intersex, I’ll die on this hill.


r/robinhobb • • Jul 09 '24

Spoilers Assassin's Quest I just finished Assassin's Quest and I'm mad Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I just need to vent. What even was this book? This book seems to be a complete contrast to Assassin's Apprentice and Royal Assassin, and not in a good way. I feel like many aspects of this book were written in a way that asked "what would this character do in this situation?" without asking "... AND what will be narratively satisfying?"

AA and RA were far shorter but a lot more happened. This story was slow and meandering, and yet hardly managed to pay off the promises of the previous books. The red ships are resolved in what amounts to an epilogue, but we get chapters and chapters of walking.

AA and RA were fantastic because they focussed on Fitz' relationships with other characters, action, and intrigue. I was instantly hooked and recommended these books to everyone. In AQ, Fitz promptly leaves his life behind and wishes to remain dead to everyone who knew him in Buck. No more interesting relationships or character interactions. The only people he wants to tell he lived are Molly and Burrich, and all he cares about is getting home to his daughter... except even this is abandoned for a contrived romance.

Characters are unrealistically stupid. Eg. Kettle tells Fitz that Regal will use The Fool to get into his mind and get information from him, specifically about Molly and the child. I'm pretty sure it's the very next chapter where then The Fool starts asking weird questions about where Molly is. Fitz tells him before The Fool falls flat on his face. Fitz walks away, annoyed that The Fool would do such a thing, and just leaves him lying there. I wanted to throw my Kindle out the window. I don't even think this is Fitz stupidity so much as Robin's trying to be clever. Also - everyone is quick to point out how Fitz is stupid, selfish etc. but if he had just killed Regal in RA none of this would have happened.

Kettle sucks and is such a waste of a character. She is introduced in chapter 15 in a 40 chapter book (41 doesn't count). It becomes clear fairly early that she's someone trained in the Skill from the past, it just takes the characters a lot longer to realise it. What we could have here is a new mentor for Fitz - in RA there was mention of finding some of the old skillmasters, and this could pay that off nicely, having Fitz grow in the Skill as well as providing some exposition and answers to unanswered questions. But Kettle keeps everything to herself until the last few chapters of the book. Yes, they play checkers, but I would be more interested in seeing Fitz learn to use the Skill, not just block the coterie.

I'm so confused by the whole side quest to go kill Regal. Once again, this is due to asking "what would the character do?" and not asking if it is narratively satisfying. Burrich and Chade give Fitz grief about learning to be a man instead of a boy, and after being a wolf for a bit he chooses to go kill Regal. Then once he encounters Will he decides to kill himself, and the only reason he goes to Verity is because he's compelled by the Skill. This... sucks. Wouldn't it be better for the character learn to be a man and make this choice himself? Fitz loves Verity and has been wanting to go and help him since the events of Royal Assassin. I understand he's traumatised but I just can't believe this character would prioritise a stupid and suicidal mission to kill Regal over everything else. This whole section does nothing for the plot except compel Fitz to go to Verity, which he could have just chosen to do. It feels like Fitz remains a child for the rest of the book.

What was even the point of Black Rolf? If there were more to this I would be interested, but it's just a side bar.

Why did we spend so many pages just walking, hunting, being injured? Like I get it but please

Ultimately I think I'm just frustrated by the lack of character progression, and in many senses what seemed like regression. Both in terms of "power level" and personal growth. In Royal Assassin Fitz began as a sickly boy, recently a victim of poison and became a man. He was a fearsome warrior, growing in the Skill, strong in the Wit, and a striking image of his father to the point that the coastal duchies sought to back him. in Assassin's Quest Fitz started as little more than a beast and had recently cheated death. And he ends as a... side character in his own story. No longer an assassin, no longer a warrior, and arguably no better a man. He grew in the Skill from his exposure to the Skill Road and Quarry, but we hardly get to see him use his power because he's constantly on guard for Will and co., who in turn had a dramatic power spike since the last book.

I was hooked on the first two books, but everything they set up was thrown out.


r/robinhobb • • Oct 17 '26

Spoilers Farseer Fitz in "Assassin's Quest" Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I had some time now to think about the trilogy after reading it and especially the final book. What has been bothering me is that I am actually a bit disappointed with Fitz (as a "person", not the way he is written).

Possibly the biggest offender is his assassination plot which had zero foresight whatsoever. I felt let down that he needed to be influenced to search for his king and instead went on a personal vendetta quest. I was actively rooting against him because he didn't seem to understand he would completely destabilise the kingdom if he were successful and possibly put an end to it.

Another thing that disappointed me was him cheating on Molly. I mean... Technically they were not together and she thought he was dead but from his perspective she was still his love and he did everything (allegedly) for her and his daughter. Yet, he cheated with the girl from the puppet theatre and was borderline cheating with Starling.

I felt that he was overall very selfish and stuck in his head. Woe is me the whole time, while other people around him were literally sacrificing every last bit of themselves to save the kingdom. I have empathy and love for Fitz, of course, not like he was dealt an easy hand but he was actively fighting everyone who loved him the whole way through (yes, I am aware he was a teen).

I also think it's selfish of him to hide his being alive. Patience and Burrich who loved his father the most, did everything in their powers to raise him and care for him. Yet, he would rather them think they failed him and that he died in one or another horrible manner. I understand Burrich might feel guilty about being with Molly but I bet that can't compare to feeling guilty about abandoning and failing Fitz.

Also - is it a plothole that they haven't heard Regal was offering a gigantic prize for Fitz's head? I am not sure how that would be possible. The other moment that felt a bit plothole-y to me was when Fitz didn't realise he was not talking to the Fool. I felt that even him being so in his own head and out of it should have realised that was most definitely not the Fool.

Anyway, not to change the topic. The ending was a bit rushed but I know there are many books left so I am not worried about that. I am sure the story will continue in an interesting way. But even as the book ended and I realised Fitz was not telling the story as an old man but as someone who is not even 30, I was again disappointed, hah. Fitz, please go outside and live your life, what are you doing?!

How do you feel about it? Again, I want to underline that I still loved the books a lot and I love Fitz as a character.


r/robinhobb • • Apr 14 '24

Spoilers All Queer-friendly podcasts and book recommendations? Spoiler

4 Upvotes

So in resources there are three podcasts to listen to: Buckkeep radio, Is Fitz Happy?, and Return the the Ream of Elderlings.

I am very very very pro-queer reading of the series and while I totally welcome other perspectives, I do not want to listen to a group of people where all of them assume only heteronormative view of Fool's and Fit'z relationship. So which ones would you recommend?

Any other podcasts/videos on that are more than welcome too ofc! I listen while crafting, so reading blogs is not really an option for me now.

Aside from than, since I felt rather cheated and queer-baited any other medieval-fantasy-queer books are also super welcome (please, I need something to fill in the gap this series left in my heart)!


r/robinhobb • • Nov 29 '24

Spoilers Assassin's Quest Fitz is a bit dull sometimes Spoiler

0 Upvotes

In book 3 and only one thing is irking me. Fitz is dumb soemtimes.3 times so far

When molly was describing the person she found I knew who it was right away brushed it off because I'm a parent so maybe that is why it is.

When kettle is describing the white prophet.

Its obvious but Fitz doesn't get it.

Just now as I was reading book 3 Fool asked where Molly was and then said he didn't remember asking that. From the moment he asked I knew what was happening but Fitz just goes and tells him and then worries about his death... It's like come on man.

Love the series. Just moments where Fitz is too dumb to see the obvious are kinda annoying me.


r/robinhobb • • Sep 30 '22

Spoilers up to Ship of Magic I defended Regal some months ago and now i will defend Kyle Spoiler

2 Upvotes

So some months ago, when i was first reading the farseer trilogy i argued, that in the first two book and part of the third, some of regal were actually reasonable and defended this obvious bad guy of the series, i think that i was somewhat compelled with these awful character speaks highly of Hobb's talent.

Now i'm reading Ship of magic for the first time (im about three or four chapters after Ephraim death), and to be honest beyond his obvious arrogance many of his points do hold up, i dont think althea would have fully provided for her sisters family, at least not at first shes young and seems self-centered. the conversation that kyle has with his wife on her first POV chapter while they're in bed completly misses the point of althea reasoning, but his arguments are not wrong if we follow the customs and culture of this place and time.

So there it goes i do point out that im not that far into this book and my opinion of this guy that is being painted as one of the bad guys may change, and i dont think he's a good guy neither thought that of Regal, but that Robin Hobb keeps impresing me with her character work.

So how much of psycho am i?


r/robinhobb • • Jul 07 '25

Spoilers Assassin's Quest Finished Assassin’s Quest and I’m very confused Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Verity couldn’t finish the dragon without Fitz, so he gets Fitz to agree to help? Fitz agrees, so isn’t Fitz supposed to die? Like how did Fitz help at all, doesn’t seem like he lended any power to the dragon. This part is just very confusing and I don’t think it is explained very well.

And same for the Regal part. It seemed like Fitz killed him with the skill. And then nope he’s just alive and loyal? Guess that’s what he used the skill for?

Why wasn’t this explained better 😭


r/robinhobb • • Dec 19 '23

Spoilers Golden Fool I feel disappointed about Fitz in the book 'The Golden Fool' Spoiler

0 Upvotes

He seems like a crybaby, as if he were once again a little child who can't do anything by himself and walks around sulkily. For example, when the Fool tells him his prophecy that he will determine the fate of the dragons and that he himself will die, he runs to his mentor like a little child.

He gets bullied by a physically and mentally challenged person. He manages to have all his secrets revealed. He betrays and hurts the only person who has always been by his side.

And what I personally find the worst is that he wanders around without a plan, he has no idea, his intelligence comes and goes, he is used as a puppet, although he had sworn never to allow that again.

I mean, it was okay when he was young, but he is 35 years old. Let's look at the Fool. He knows what he wants, he behaves according to his age, and he's not a puppet in the hands of others, but the player himself."


r/robinhobb • • Nov 17 '21

Spoilers Farseer Why no republicans in the series? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Title. I'm deep into the Farseer trilogy and everyone is some form of monarchist not a single individual entertain the idea of merit based governing...


r/robinhobb • • May 05 '20

Spoilers All Molly-olly NSFW Spoiler

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/robinhobb • • Aug 08 '23

Spoilers Rain Wilds The Rain Wild Chronicles is a disappointing series Spoiler

11 Upvotes

I just finished these books and I have some thoughts that I am sure you are all dying to hear :D

The three trilogies that preceded RWC all had some really big moments, whether they were events or just amazing emotional sequences between characters. Some examples that immediately come to mind are when Burrich drags Galen down to the witness stones and whips his ass for abusing Fitz, or the whole sequence in Fitz's cabin when he's reunited with the Fool after so many years, or all the various scenes where Fitz's identity is revealed to Dutiful and their relationship grows... there are really so many BIG MOMENTS that are so rewarding.

The Rain Wild Chronicles are four books with nothing but medium moments. IMO they don't provide even one of the big emotional payoffs that were the hallmark of the previous three trilogies. And speaking of trilogies, RWC should have been three books.

The love triangle between Alise, Sedric, and Hess was rehashed over and over and over.. and it was only made worse by the four book format as each book inevitably recaps the plot in the initial chapters.

And what an enormous missed opportunity... remember in Tawny Man when Selden and his delegation from the Rain Wilds showed up at Buckkeep Castle and dazzled everyone with Elderling gifts, then proposed that the Six Duchies partner with Bingtown and Tintaglia to crush Calced? RWC would have been much better if this plot had been enacted in the second half of the story rather than the endless relationship drama that filled these four books.

Anyway, still looking forward to Fitz and the Fool :)


r/robinhobb • • Jan 10 '23

Spoilers Assassin's Quest Rereading Assassin's Quest and I have to vent about Molly Spoiler

16 Upvotes

I'm in the middle of rereading AQ and I still find it frustrating how self-centered Molly is. In chapter 13 - Blue Lake, Burrich finds the forged corpse with Fitz's pin and thinks that Fitz has died. This is snippets of the scene:

Without turning around, [Molly] said in a low tight voice, “I was worried. You said you’d be back yesterday.”
“I know. I’m sorry. I should have been, but . . .” Burrich’s voice was hoarse. There was no spirit in it.
“But you stayed in town and got drunk,” Molly filled in coldly.
“I . . . yes. I got drunk.” He shut the door and came into the room
“Don’t come in here when you’re drunk,” Molly told him flatly.
“I know that’s how you feel. I was drunk yesterday. I had a bit, earlier today, but I’m not drunk. Not now. Now I’m just . . . tired. Very tired.” He leaned forward and put his head in his hands.
“You can’t even sit up straight.” I could hear the anger rising in Molly’s voice. “You don’t even know when you’re drunk.” Burrich looked up at her wearily. [...] Molly felt a pang of guilt. He was still cold, and the shed where he slept at night was drafty and damp. But he’d brought it on himself. He knew how she felt about drunkards[...]
“Can I see the baby for a moment?” Burrich asked softly. He had paused at the door. I saw something in his eyes, something Molly did not know him well enough to recognize, and it cut me to the bone. He grieved.
“She’s right there, on the bed. I just got her to sleep,” Molly pointed out briskly.
“Can I hold her . . . just for a minute?”
“No. You’re drunk and you’re cold. If you touch her, she’ll wake up. You know that. Why do you want to do that?”
Something in Burrich’s face crumpled. His voice was hoarse as he said, “Because Fitz is dead, and she’s all I have left of him or his father. And sometimes . . .” He lifted a wind-roughened hand to rub his face. “Sometimes it seems as if it’s all my fault.” His voice went very soft on those words. “I should never have let them take him from me. When he was a boy. When they first wanted to move him up to the keep, if I’d put him on a horse behind me and gone to Chivalry, maybe they’d both still be alive. I thought of that. I nearly did it. He didn’t want to leave me, you know, and I made him. I nearly took him back to Chivalry instead. But I didn’t. I let them have him, and they used him.”
I felt the trembling that ran suddenly through Molly. Tears stung suddenly at her own eyes. She defended herself with anger. “Damn you, he’s been dead for months. Don’t try to get around me with drunkard’s tears.”

Rereading this just makes me angry because in this entire exchange, Molly refuses to have any empathy for Burrich who has spent months helping her survive. With Molly, it's always about her own needs - what her thoughts and feelings are, never anyone else's. She doesn't even consider how Burrich could be mourning for Fitz. Never considers what Nettle means to Burrich. Doesn't even let him look at Nettle. Then makes him sleep in the shed. I mean the self-centeredness is pretty consistent with her character all throughout Royal Assassin too... I just really can't stand her.


r/robinhobb • • Feb 06 '23

Spoilers Assassin's Apprentice fancasting the assassin apprentice chapters 1-2 Spoiler

0 Upvotes

hey so i just started the book assassin's apprentice and so far it's good. anyway spoiler warning. sorry if the names got wrong i have a translation

fitz: jackson robert scott

burrich: david harbour

verity: donal logue

regal: tom hiddelston or the actor of joffery

molly: *no one so far*

karry: karan brar

so far say what is your casting and i will add new in new posts when i continue on

may the wit be with you ( i didn't found any cool quote from the book yet to end the post)


r/robinhobb • • Apr 15 '21

Admin Post Memes and other low-effort posts will be removed

13 Upvotes

I've been hesitant to put an outright ban on memes and other low effort posts here because it's been a fairly inactive sub and these posts were relatively infrequent. But over the past few weeks I've noticed them starting to dominate the subreddit, so I'm going to start removing them.

Memes and other low-effort posts, in subreddits where they are allowed, tend to drown out the more substantive content. I absolutely don't want that to happen here. This subreddit is about quality over quantity and I want to keep it that way.

I know this is going to be a controversial position and some people will probably be upset by it, but I feel it's necessary for the health of the community. If we want to continue to have a subreddit that is dominated by interesting, substantive discussions then this is necessary step to take.

If you have something cute or funny to share with the group, please start a discussion about it rather than post it as a meme. You can even include images if you want. But the post has to have substance and contribute something of interest to the subreddit, and hopefully lead to discussion and interaction.


r/robinhobb • • Nov 21 '24

Spoilers All Connected Universe Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Probably an unpopular opinion, but I kind of wish that Liveships and the Fitz books were two entirely separate series. I think both series are masterfully done, but can get overshadowed/distracted by the counterpart series. (Every friend I have who reads Liveships the first time wishes they were reading Fitz for the first half of the book at least…) And I think people would maybe enjoy Rainwildes more if there weren’t the Fitz books to compare it to. (Being in between them)

I get that the Easter eggs and characters coming together for part of the last trilogy is kind of cool, but I still think it could have been left out. (I’m not the biggest fan of that final trilogy anyway) A few little changes here and there could make both series stand completely on their own.


r/robinhobb • • Jul 30 '18

Spoilers All The train-sized elephant in the room

2 Upvotes

So are we to assume that Thomas and Friends exist in the ROTE universe at some point in the future - making the logical assumption that Thomas etc. are Livetrains?

And is the Isle of Sodor beyond the Outislands, or further south?

So many questions...


r/robinhobb • • Aug 12 '26

No Spoilers I met Robin Hobb and her attitude made me never want to read her books

0 Upvotes

A few years ago she was at a convention I was at. I went to several panels she was on and the whole time she just had this air that she was better than everyone else. She would make faces whenever anyone asked a question. She'd roll her eyes at the fellow authors on the panel and contradict them. She spoke in a condescending tone. Afterwards at the signing I saw someone approach her and she was so snarky with them. I've always been interested in her work since I hear so many great things about it but whenever I see her name all I can picture is her derisive little frown and that condescending scoff she'd make. Maybe it was an off day?

Does anyone have any good experiences with her? Should I try and push past and read her books anyways?


r/robinhobb • • Jan 25 '23

Spoilers Rain Wilds Unpopular Opinion: Liveship Trilogy is bad and you can skip it Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I just finished Rain Wilds and, on the advice of this sub, I'm generally happy I didn't skip any books. I consider myself a big RH fan now, and my judgment is just on the relative quality of the books up to and including Rain Wilds.

That said, looking back now, Liveship was the most unsatisfying and uninteresting slog in the whole series so far.

I thought maybe I felt this way because it was such an abrupt shift from Farseers, and I just needed to get into the groove of a new group of characters, new context. But having now read and enjoyed Rain Wilds, I personally believe that Liveships is just worse

  1. Maybe I just don't like perspective books? Nah, Rain Wilds handled the perspective shifts quite well. The vast majority of the action happens within the same travelling party, and so each perspective complements the other. Selden's bits are the exception, and are weaker for it. In contrast, Liveships is constantly jumping around the continents playing catch-up. It has too many threads for its own good.

  2. Maybe I just don't like non-human perspectives? Nah, I thought the RW dragons were extremely well developed, full of character and humor and drive. The serpents in Liveships are just... boring. There's a novelty to the serpent perspective that wears off very quickly, and they accomplish and add almost nothing but lore-fluff for most of the books.

  3. Maybe I just have F+F bias? Maybe! I do think RW is weaker than Farseer and Tawny. However, I still felt like RW could stand on its own legs - it reads very much like a YA adventure a la Hunger Games or Golden Compass. In my opinion, Liveships neither stands on its own legs as a pirate adventure, nor does it meaningfully build off Farseer nor setup Tawny Man. For this reason, I think it is entirely skippable for a casual reader.

  4. Maybe I just don't like Althea/Kennit/Wintrow/Paragon/[insert character here]? Maybe! Malta was basically the only character whose arc I was invested in - everybody else felt more like NPCs than leading figures. Althea and Brashen are mostly disposable characters who accomplish basically nothing with Paragon that Amber and Kennit don't undo or overshadow. And that would fine if their romance was interesting, but it wasn't. Wintrow is almost interesting - he's Fitz-like in the way he is swept up in his own destiny, but a less charismatic version.

  5. Maybe I just want more Big World Stuff to happen? Maybe. I was very satisfied with Farseer even though not much Big World Stuff actually happens. Farseer is a successful slice-of-life adventure centred on a small number of characters, and a casual reader could read only that trilogy and walk away happy. RW is successful, expanding the characters AND the amount of Big World Stuff that happens. Liverships just isn't successful - too many people, not enough happens, not enough consequences, incomplete or unsatisfactory arcs.

Anyway, I'm not here to poo-poo anybody's favourite books, or even to have my mind changed. But I am open to a discussion, and to maybe be one lone voice against the sub's popular opinion that Liveships is unskippable.


r/robinhobb • • Oct 10 '18

Chapter Length

0 Upvotes

Is it just me or are these chapter lengths way too long. Each chapter could be cut in three and be perfectly fine.

Chapters are meant to be a good stopping place and each one is meant to have it's own little mini plot so to speak, not five! It drives me crazy and making it take forever to get through a book.

My Kindle says it takes an hour to read a chapter on average, sometimes more sometimes less. It's a good story nonetheless.


r/robinhobb • • Aug 18 '20

Spoilers Tawny Man Just finished the Tawny Man trilogy. I hated the short sighted politics and stupid decisions, even though I enjoyed reading the book Spoiler

8 Upvotes

TLDR: Marrying Dutiful to Elliania is about the worst decision that can be made.

Now, I won't say that I'm a big fan of the series, but I just finished reading The Tawny Man trilogy and I grew increasingly irritated with how the characters can be so short-sighted. But, not being super into the lore, I recognize that there is the chance that my opinion is based on things that aren't true and I would ask you to correct me, if that's the case. Nevertheless, I'll write my post from my POV, that some characters make terrible decisions.

We already knew that Fitz is not bright at all from the first trilogy, and it surprised me that he was a little bit better (just a little) in the second one. However, two other characters stepped up incredibly on the not being too smart scale, Chade and Kettricken. Their political knowledge is incredibly limited. They make a lot of terrible decisions, and they mostly envolve the arranged marriage between Dutiful and Elliania. I'll try to list all of them, but my first big question is: What is the big advantage of marrying the heir to the throne to someone in The Outslands? It seems like an incredible waste. First off, compared to the six duchies, they are TINY. Super tiny, to the point that even being able to terrorize the entire mainland is a bit suspicious. But vikings were a thing at some point in our time, so I'll let it slide, even though the six duchies would be more than able to hold them off with just 4 battleships if it weren't for the Cotery working against them. Nevertheless, after the war in the first trilogy, it's said that the passage of the stone dragons forged many of its citizens. And not only that, but it is known to the people ruling the six duchies that they are not an unified nation, but rather a collection of families that don't see themselves as one. And not only that, but if not for the six duchies, they are basically cut off from the rest of the known world and would have to go all the way to the Chalced states to do any type of trade. And what do the Six Duchies have to gain? Peace with a super weak nation that is not hostile towards them? Nothing else, really. So, to summarize. Kettricken and Chade want the only heir to the throne to marry the heir of a part of a tiny nation that they defeated just 15 years ago, that was left devastated as a result, and that depends on the six duchies for anything more than the bare necessities. It gets even worse when in the end of the trilogy they treat the two parties as being in equal footing. I guess that you want to accommodate to make the Outislanders happy, but the way that they (both the people of the six duchies, but mostly the outislanders) treat the marriage as something more than a favor to the Outslands baffles me. They had the audacity to suggest that it should be Dutiful to go to the Outslands, instead of Elliania moving. How can you be so oblivious to the way your world works?! But anyway, I want to talk about Kettricken and Chade, I just got a bit exalted there. Let's get on with the complaining.

I won't even mention that much the way that Chade handled the information that Fitz gave him about Elliania and Peotre. It was incredibly (INCREDIBLY I say) obvious that they were up to something, but with the amount of times stuff like this happens in the series, it's not something extraordinary. How can the two most important (and supposedly very intelligent and wise) people in the nation be proud and seriously considering the fact that Dutiful accepted the so ridiculous it's unbelievable challenge of Elliania to CUT THE HEAD OF A DRAGON IN A FAR AWAY LAND?? First off, why does Dutiful have to prove himself? I get that she was mad, but as we established, it's her and her "kingdom" that has everything to lose. Besides, we have Bingtown on the opposite side of the spectrum imploring them not to kill the dragon but rather help them in the war with the Chalced States. And why in the world can't they see that this is the much more advantageous alliance? They can even try to confirm the claims that they have a dragon to help them in their war, but since the Chalced States are constantly battling with Shoars, it would be an opportunity to annex it to the rest of the Ducies. Hell, even geographically, they have the mountain kingdom north, shoars to the east, farrow to the northeast and Bingtown with a dragon to the west. They are completely surrounded!! And plus, it would open up the trade with Bingtown even more, since they would be practically saving them, and the Six Ducies would become the Seven Ducies plus an incredibly grateful and resourceful ally. And on top of that, the Outslands would be devastated in regards to trade if they ever were to retaliate because of the broken marriage. There is no one for them to trade with! They would be at the Seven + One Ducies mercy, so they might as well become another Ducie! Now, the books talk about how a conquered people will never accept the rule etc. etc., but I call bullcrap, even if we forget that the Chalced States are the hub of enslaved people, and won't even go there.

Hopefully, I've convinced you that the six ducies have nothing to gain in marrying their heir to (a part of) the outslands and that it would be much better to help bingtown instead. Now, onto the spies of Chade. He just sent one. One. To scout the place where the dragon supposedly is. And then when the people go to the Outslands, Chade has the audacity to be surprised and annoyed that there isn't a consensus amongst the outslanders in regards to killing the dragon. Come on... you do all of this to gain a terrible alliance with a bunch of crappy warring families and then most of them will hate and try to kill you if you kill their beloved dragon. Honestly, what a joke. Chade is an absolute joke as an advisor and master of spies.

Now, a complaint against the way that Robin Hobb tells her story is that it is not at all organic. I, like all of you, quite enjoy most of the characters, and feel genuinely happy when they succeed and sad when they don't, but the way the world works is just to move the plot forward. What do I mean? Well, since I noticed this I couldn't unnotice it, so I'll hide it.

Every time something bad happens to a character when they're out adventuring (even if it's forgetting something back at home), it's for the express purpose of creating an artificial plot point. When you start noticing it, it gets increasingly frustrating. Character A mentions he forgot to bring item B. 10 or 15 pages later, the gang is in a dire situation and they get worse off than they were. And Fitz thinks to himself "Damn, if only A had brought B...". And then you start to realize that if these little things don't happen, entire plot points just disappear out of thin air. It seems as if Hobb wants something to happen and then tries to think of an excuse in order to enable it, and it is noticeably artificial, a lot of the times. It also happens with characters withholding information. It seems that they do it for the sole purpose of creating conflict, especially Fitz. "Oh, I don't feel like saying this important thing to this person right now, even though I can. We have plenty of time!... Oh, it turns out that there was no time, I should have told them right there :'( "

To finish, I know I may seem very negative, but I enjoyed the hell out of reading these books, I've been reading them non stop. They're super frustrating for me, for sure, but still very enjoyable. One thing to note is that I read them in portuguese, so one of the strongest points of the series (Hobb's writing style) may be lost to me, I don't know. Besides, I had to look up the names of the places and characters in english, so some may be wrong, I apologize.

I think I felt the need to write this post because it's the first time that I enjoy reading about a series so much that leaves me so annoyed.

As english is not my first language, I would appreciate it if you could correct any errors you encounter.

EDIT: I have only read the first and second Fitz trilogies


r/robinhobb • • Feb 19 '22

Spoilers Ship of Magic Question for Robin Hobb fans (ship of magic) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Just finished the Ship of Magic… did anyone else struggle with the total lack of agency from all of the female character?


r/robinhobb • • Jan 18 '22

Spoilers All Assassin's Fate rewrite (spoiler) Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Disclaimer:

Robin Hobb is the best and my favourite. I'm no writer. I'm just grieving the ending and this headcannon helps me cope.

Two retcons:

  1. The Skill:

    • Skill users can join the Skill Current when they die (eg. Chade and Shrew)

    • It's difficult and dangerous seek them in Skill Current UNLESS their beings are tethered to the physical world via memory stone (eg. How Fitz's able to call to Verity from his stone dragon)

    • Memory stone acts as portal between physical world and skill current (eg. Without it, you can send only your mind into the skill current. With memory stone, you can send your body as well.)

  2. Bee took Fool's memory stone carving of Fitz/Fool/Nighteyes with her when kidnapped from Withywoods

The rewrite:

Chapter 27: Feather to Blade

  • Starting mid chapter like the original book: Bee fights like cornered wolves, stunning Vindeliar, killing Symphe and Dwalia

  • At the same time, Fitz, Fool, Sparks, Lant and Per spy into the Clerres castle via the waste shoot. They narrowly escape drowning and is now unable to turn back due to rising tide

  • Bee descends the dungeon where she meets the party

Reunion

  • As the party ascend from the dungeon, they're intercepted by Vindeliar. He has consumed the rest of the serpent spittle and Skill-summoned the remaining Four and armed guards

  • Deathly battle ensues as Bee barely contains Vindeliar's powerful skilling

  • Vindeliar, Coultrie and Fellowdy are killed in the battle. Capra escapes with her guards

  • Bee loses consciousness from the intense skilling

  • Fitz commands the party to escape with Bee while he buys them time. The party reluctantly takes Bee away

Wolf-Father

  • Fitz desperately fights as he takes mortal wounds. Dying, Fitz skills out to Bee who no longer has her walls up. Fitz says his goodbye and speaks of his love and regret for her.

  • "Fitz?" asked the Fool as he realise Bee was skilling. The Fool joins their skilling with his silvered finger. They shared their senses. Fitz takes comfort from seeing the party boarding the Paragon.

  • Bee and the Fool sense Fitz's pain; he was dying. They sense his consciousness fading, tattering away into the skill current then Fitz was gone.

Ship of Dragons

  • Bee and the Fool are snapped back onto the Paragon who is now aflame and under attack much like the book.

  • Joined in grieve and anger, Bee and the Fool see the true path emanating from this moment: the Destroyer

  • the Fool gives Silver to Paragon who turns into two Dragons

  • Unable to destroy the towers themselves (due to their size) one of the dragons takes Bee on their back to the castle where she promised destructions

  • In horror, the rest of the party watches Bee fly away from their row boats and floating debris

The Destroyer

  • Bee returns to Clerres castle. In fury, Bee begins searching for Capra and burning the library heedless of her own safety

  • Bee finds and attacks Capra

  • Before her finishing blow, the Fool's cube tumbles out of Bee's clothing. Bee grabs the cube. Her bloodied fingers land on Fitz's carving. With the Skill and Wit boiling and her blood soaking into the memory stone, Bee rediscovers her link with Fitz.

  • Fitz counsels Bee against taking revenge. He recalls to his daughter his attempts at Regal's life. "Use your strength to survive" he suggests. Nighteyes echoes this with "No more of the killing that brings no meat."

  • Together they draw Bee into the memory stone and away from the burning building.

Voyage

  • Back with the Fool, Spark, Lant and Per, events unfold similar to the book. They see dragons bring destructions to Clerres. They grieve for Fitz and Bee. They board the Vivacia to Bing Town then Trehaug, then Tarman to Kelsingra.

Skill

  • Bee is lost for a time in the skill current... But Fitz (with Nighteyes, Verity, Chade and Shrew) finds her.

  • Some character moments here and closure for Chade

  • They envelope Bee fondly and guide her and her body through the skill current to Verity-as-Dragon

  • Bee returns to Buckkeep

Happy ending!

  • Fitz's still immortalised in the Skill with his predecessors and Nighteyes

  • If you must, the Fool could stay back and die in Clerres with Fitz and be together in the Skill Current

  • I hope this gives Fitz an arc of sort. Something like:

    • Book 1: Ordinary world = Fitz stopped being an assassin to be a husband, holder and father. Call to adventure = raid on Withywoods and taking of Bee.

    • Book 2: Fitz believes the lie that he cannot be a father, only an assassin.

    • Book 3: Fitz self-actualises and choose protecting Bee over vengeance and murder.

  • Another retcon I might add is the Fool being terrified and guilt-ridden rather than vengeful following his "escape". Something to reduce the conflict between him and Fitz.

  • Suggestions and different perspective on the original ending also very welcomed


r/robinhobb • • Feb 11 '17

A thought on the Skill

2 Upvotes

So, last night i did my first DMT trip.

It was craaazy, and amazing, but the thing i remember most abut it was how similiar it was to how Hobb explains the skill. Like, EERILY similar. There is so many discussions about the skill throughout the book where the link to my own experience and that I've read about others whilst on DMT.

The feeling of loss of self, the larger being met by Fitz in his travels through the stone portals, struggling to come back to reality, words not being enought to describe ANYTHING, everything points to one fact:

Robin Hobb loved DMT


r/robinhobb • • 27d ago Mindblown

Spoilers Tawny Man I just finished Tawny Man! Here are my top gripes Spoiler

25 Upvotes

I should start by saying that I actually loved this trilogy, although Liveship Traders probably ranks slightly above it in my mind. The books were very enjoyable and I can't wait to continue with the series.

That said, here are the things I didn't like. Every time I came across one of these I thought "I wish I could vent about this", but didn't dare venture into any of the Tawny Man threads on here in case I spoiled myself.

1. Burrich returning

This is the biggest one. I mean seriously, he just fucking shows up on Aslevjal because his son is there and he wants him home? Not just the Outislands generally, but fucking Aslevjal? Putting aside the fact his arrival necessarily exposes a whole bunch of stuff everyone has worked hard to conceal for more than a decade, my impression of getting to Aslevjal and then crossing a god damn glacier is that it was very difficult and almost impossible without local guidance. Isn't that why we needed to endure Thick whining and throwing up for 1,000 pages, and read through many descriptions of how dangerous the ice was? But nope, he just materializes out of nowhere and everyone accepts his lame explanation of "oh the son I don't even like has been quiet for a while, thought I better somehow teleport to this tortured stone rock somehow".

Obviously it was necessary because Hobb needed to kill the dragon and then him (I have my own thoughts about how dirty he was done here, but I get it), but having him conduct this long, perilous journey at precisely the right time just came across to me as a clumsy plot device up there with 'a wizard did it'.

2. The Pale Woman

I think this character could have been done so much better. As a villain she 'worked', but she was so one-dimensional. She could have been some kind of fleshed-out, balanced counter to the Fool but she wasn't. E.g. she could have argued fervently about why the dragons must be stopped, or something like that - basically, give her a bit of rationality? This could have led to some seriously interactions between her and Fitz after her capture, but we only got the smallest glimpse of this when they had their weird almost-sex dinner.

Instead, we basically got "hey did u know Regal was bad because he hurt ppl? well WATCH THIS!!! its regal x 1000!!!!!! omg" and her sole motivation seemed to be to stick it to the Fool, and/or destroy the Farseer lineage. For such a major character (and for all the character development we enjoyed for the Fool) I left the book feeling like so much more could have been done with her.

Also why tf didn't Fitz burn her body at the end? "Ah yes that is the last we will see of her, when I flush her down this mysterious shaft". I have not read beyond the Tawny Man but I would almost be willing to put money on seeing her or her life-force again.

3. Skill Pillars

The pillars themselves are fine, but the use of them at the end was such a cop-out. Getting rid of Fitz for a month by itself seemed a bit bizarre, but to then use it to quietly tie up:

A. telling Nettle about her true father, and

B. the departure of the Fool,

... was a big miss. It felt like Hobb got to the end and then realized her publisher only gave her a certain page limit, and she really needed to use those pages for Fitz and Molly to shag in a field.

4. Molly

Speaking of that, I did not like the reconciliation here. The "happily ever after" (or at least "content ever after") the book concluded with seems so opposite to the misery porn I had become accustomed to from Hobb. Putting that to one side though, Molly is a woman who spent 16 years with Burrich and raised several children with him. She certainly has the agency to move on whenever she wishes, but the book well and truly rushed this to the level it simply wasn't believable. We basically see her and Fitz have an uncomfortable conversation, they exchange a handful of letters, and next minute they're getting down amongst the blackberries.

I'm a bit of a heathen here though, and to be honest I've never understood Fitz's fixation on his first love. Starling was way better for him, come at me.

5. Cousins

The chapter titled Cousins made me want to throw a brick through a window. To jog your memory, this is where Dutiful learns about Nettle, and then he/Chade spend the entire chapter tag-teaming Fitz about how stupid and shit his idea to protect her was. That by itself was infuriating, but the fact Fitz just sat there and took it, and came around to their point of view, was a hard read. There were really really good reasons for hiding Nettle, and Chade was well and truly aware of these. A more satisfying end to this chapter would have been Fitz saying "well fuck you Chade" and laying him out. Whenever I get through these books I may write that fanfiction as a form of catharsis.

6. Skill healing generally

I'm glad this didn't work on Burrich, because I swear to god they overused the shit out of this plot device.

7. Book titles

I think the death of the Fool would have felt much deeper to me, if I didn't know there was an entire trilogy of books called 'Fitz and the Fool'. Once he died I sighed and wondered how many chapters it would be until his inevitable resurrection. Yes, I know this isn't a problem with the book itself, and is a problem that wouldn't have existed when it was first written. Maybe it's my fault for looking ahead at what books were next.

Notable mention: Hap. Poor guy, his story got thrown into the sea once Nettle came along.

Again, I think these were excellent books! But I needed to get those things off my chest.