r/rhino • • 2d ago

Help Needed Surface intersection error

Been trying to get the profiles on the sides of the green object to also be on the top surface, but keeps giving me a surface intersection error. Been trying boolean intersection, as well as the trim and split tools, and I keep getting the error unless I move it off where I need it to be. Still somewhat new to Rhino, so any suggestions are appreciated.

1 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

1

u/Bobson1729 2d ago

This happens to me all the time, usually occurs when you have a short difference between control points. Best way I've found is to:

  1. put the object into two different layers

  2. explode the one you are cutting.

  3. extract and join the cutting surface.

  4. Merge all coplanar faces.

  5. trim

  6. join and merge all coplanar faces again

  7. clean up

1

u/Alex_Lascu 1d ago

The nudge trick above works, and here is why: the error shows up when faces of the two objects lie exactly on top of each other, or meet tangent. Rhino then finds an intersection that is a whole patch instead of a clean curve, and gives up. Moving one object by 0.02 mm breaks that overlap.

The downside is that the 0.02 mm stays in your model. You get sliver faces and tiny steps that come back later, in fillets, in drawings, and especially if the part ever goes to CAM.

A cleaner way is to make the overlap deliberate instead of accidental:

  1. Make the green cutter clearly bigger than it needs to be in every direction where it doesn't matter. Let it stick out past the top and the sides of the blue body by a few millimetres, so no face of one sits flush on a face of the other.

  2. Run the Boolean again. With the faces crossing properly, it usually goes through first time.

To see where the trouble is before you fix it, run Intersect on the two objects. Where you get clean curves, things are fine. Where you get nothing, or a messy patch, those are the coincident faces.

Two quick checks while you're there: SelBadObjects to make sure neither solid is broken, and Units to see that the absolute tolerance is around 0.001 for a model in millimetres. If what you actually want is just the profile outline drawn on the top face, skip Booleans: Project the profile curves onto that face and Split it with them.

1

u/EstablishmentDizzy94 1d ago

Try nudging it a very small amount in x or y. Like .02mm